i go through my old garageband sessions! + newer logic sessions 

Hi i came back to this video HAHAHAH. Just to let you know that this 2:26 never be not funny to me. LOL. I love ur reaction and it's so funny😭😭😭

Ikr the vibrato and control is INSANE

this must be the top comment

that would be amazing

I AGREE

I ALSO AGREE

PREWARNING: this is very theory heavy so if you aren't in tune with theory please don't be discouraged or intimidated by this talk, everything I mentioned is perfectly learnable off the internet. So to respond to how she makes harmonies: I can't speak for her process but what she seems to like to do (or at least what she did in Apple Pie) was adding a third above her lead. In the bigger parts she goes 4 part harmony, usually the main chord (major, minor, sus, etc) is made with 3 lines then she'll add an extension as the 4th line (a 9th or 11th I think she uses in Apple Pie). She takes these lines and almost always inverts the chord so the 3 higher lines are in close harmony, and the lowest harmony line has more space, sort of acting like a bassline. In the largest sections she'll maybe add more voices or she'll move the close harmony to be further apart. She will also add other vocals lines which arent supporting the lead vocal, but instead doing a little pad or riff or whatever emblishment, and half the time the embelishments will have harmonies too. Beyond that she is doing more clever theory stuff (idk if she is knowingly doing this or is subconsiously doing it). These more advanced theory things will be paying more attention to tension and resolution. Doing actual clever chord trasitions and finding really colourful or more abstract chords, often playing with dissonance in a very jazzy way. This is really easy to hear, because you really feel it when she goes into a complex chord or resolution, you just don't always know what she's doing exactly. As she does all this she is aware what chords she's making (or just hearing them without much theoretical thought) but she is probably aware of the shape of each harmony line as well. She knows if she wants things to move on parallel or contrary, etc etc. Really the practical takeaway if you aren't experinced with harmonies is to pay attention and spend lots of time focusing on the exact chords you're making around your lead. Then focus on how each line is gonna move to make those chords. Also have a GREAT take of each line, sloppy takes will ruin her style.

LOOLL HAHHAHA

i feel this, hard

X2

honestly AHH X3

She hears it differently, she knows every single thing that changed in her voice, sound, etc It hits a lot harder to hear ourselves than to hear others, that being said, get your music out please!!!

that's exactly what i was thinking :)

Right? Never in a million years could I sound that good and music is kind of my entire passion so...

@@kailyn1389 i feel you hahaha

She could obviously sing back then too, but you could here that she hadn't found her own voice yet. It sounded like she was trying to imitate her idols. She has come a long way. :)

That's how it is when you listen back to your own music, you always hear things that no one else hears.

SAME OMG I LOVED ITT

Organization has left the chat

@@Ribo138 my moms computer has entered the chat

but oml the 'let me in' guitar hurt my ears momentarily HAHAHA