I Know and Still Know what you did Last Summer - Off The Shelf Reviews 

Agreed!

What would his motive have been in your version?

@@theepicbellendoftomorrow4703 It's the 21st century, motives are incidental. Maybe he just doesn't like these rich pricks.

It's a re-upload

@@JustStuey Oh... That makes sense.

​@@JustStuey was going to say gary lost weight really fast

I like it too, surprised iain hates it so much

LMFAOOOO

And Anne Heche

@@ravager48 Having read that I initially thought - “Hang on, what does Anne Heche have to do with Type O Negati--OHHH.” This tends to happen because I am very stupid.. I literally googled it just before I started this reply. I never knew she had passed, and recently too.

I think they meant Scream kicked off the horror craze that The Faculty was apart of

I think we hit a boot!

I think so. OTSR has a lot more Patreons than are reflected here. 🙂

Yep

The guy Iain was “why is he there?” that Julie and friends THOUGHT they killed. Yes.

Oof… I usually vibe with your reviews. This film isn’t for you, subjectively. I wouldn’t recommend this review as an accurate portrayal of the first movie after the first ten minutes of this video. But please Let me explain why…I want to be constructive… In my opinion (I’m 10 minutes in…) You’re doing the movie(I Know) a disservice because of your own biases. Scream exists in reality. It doesn’t exist in the universe of I Know What You Did Last Summer… so literally using them breaking the “rules” from Scream that “we learned a year earlier”… it doesn’t make sense… This movie is not the same kind of movie as Scream. They are at opposite ends, or at least on different wavelengths, from a whole product perspective. It’s hard to get to your final thoughts though because you’re comparing movies that aren’t comparable as whole products. On the sole basis of “Are teens slashed?” “Yep” “Copy that, teen slasher” Yeah, Scream is the better film… But considering both films as a whole and considering the details of the two stories and the differences in subject matter, framing, the nuances… (literally just with the first in each franchise even!) they’re not comparable. Ben Willis killed David Egan, because Susie drowned but David lived. Julie and Co. aren’t ALL awful and they *don’t* let Barry hang around anymore after that night… after the examples given to the audience of his behavior. Helen leaves him, Julie never speaks to him as a friend again, and all of them lose touch for the next year dealing with the impact of Barry’s suggestions to save Barry’s ass… I appreciate you’re trying to give a synopsis while also commenting… but again the “kinda rivals” framing is your downfall in my opinion from a deeper storyline focused whole product viewpoint. It may not be said outright but the characters’ actions and behaviors post Dock Toss prove they all fell apart because he talked them out of the right thing to do, which was call the police and report the accident… the truth is an absolute defense… and any evidence any legal person would have would be 100% circumstantial PRE Dock Toss… which is what Julie keeps trying to tell them… Barry convinces everyone to get rid of the body and won’t take no for an answer… they don’t all make a conscious decision, Barry wears the other three down, makes them murderers(as far as they know until all is revealed by the end) and they react and respond accordingly to the trauma of having to live with it… Compared to a movie that calls out horror stereotypes, while it immediately breaks them but not always, because we still have to be sucked in and enthralled by what history proves works; well done tension, and impeccable acting from the cast. You forget for a while that Sidney Prescott is just a character and Neve is in a movie… and in my opinion Sarah Jennifer Ryan and Freddie have exactly the same thing happen. Yeah at the beginning of the movie of course I’m thinking “Ok so, SMG,JLH, FPJ, and Ryan Philippe… cool, now… forget actors who are they *here*? Who are *these* people…” I stop thinking about actors and allow the story to take me. I allow the film to be and speak for itself… So yeah I feel bad but I have to wait for another time to try to finish the video. I wanted to just push through the clear bias and give you the benefit of the doubt but you’re not playing fair. You’re comparing incomparable films, and not accurately portraying one of them. They’re both massive cult classics, and personally that perception is a circle not a Venn diagram. I see them as unrelated, what does one have to do with the other from a whole product perspective…? So for those reasons at this point, I wouldn’t recommend someone watch THIS video as an accurate representation or breakdown of the first Summer movie… That said, you’re allowed your biases… still should try to fairly and accurately present the information in the film… as written and intended by the writer… the writer isn’t writing I Know while also thinking “Ok, so scream just released… I shouldn’t have these characters always follow the rules either…” Scream(or any other horror film, scene, etc etc etc) weren’t brought to the table as a guideline for something, besides the stereotypical(but well portrayed) tropes of the overall slasher genre not even just the teen sub genre… but those things are there in every movie, so the true focus is how well are those tropes dealt with and portrayed (my personal opinion expertly in both films) and how well dealt with and portrayed are the REST of the storytelling aspects handled(again expertly in my opinion, because they’re not comparable as whole products.) Just a suggested constructive criticism, and a perspective to consider… love your content normally but you’re not playing fair to this movie.

I thought both were entertaining. Very confused at his rage here

@@oldrestless Why? He doesn't like the movie and explains why he doesn't like it. What's wrong with that? Or is he supposed to like it because you happen to like it?

From what I remember he got a lot of notes on the first version of the script. Which he took and then turned into Scream, kinda as a test to see of he could, which Craven liked enough to do a big overhaul on to make it Scream. When that suddenly took off, producers came a-knocking and he gave this a spit and shine. So it isn't a rip-off, but the beta version of something that had to be altered so much to be producable that it was a completely different movie in a different subgenre by the end. Dunno if that's better or worse than a rip-off...

Love these two, but I agree with your opinion here You can’t expect a movie to be “realistic” especially given the tongue-in-cheek tone of the movie. I almost anticipate there being some over the top elements to it It’s a fun movie, aimed at a broad audience, a summertime type of flick

Nothing can ruin so pure & brilliant a film.