If Star Wars games had Lore Accurate Lightsabers 

Just a fleshwound

He became an Imperial BBQ

oh get up, not even a nose bleed...

He's twice as fine.

Mans was cooked from inside out

Haunting memories of Disney's Kenobi series are returning now 😂

You pretty much just described the force unleashed 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@@Sharp47 you can withstand 2 lightsaber thrusts through your organs if you're a black female

Spot on 👍

​@@CptFrosty And Fallen Order and Survivor.

And also not having to hit them 20 times like you’re just using a blunt stick the whole time

Do you not think that the armor of the galaxy conquering empire would have the technology of saber resistance ?

@@wilsonstrong5597 Why would it? The jedi were all but extinct

​@@wilsonstrong5597not enough beskar

​@@wilsonstrong5597The only things to ever have been shown to be lightsaber resistant were beskar and the Zilo Beasts armor. Beskar is a very scarce resource and the Zilo Beasts story is still ongoing in the Bad Batch, but it will have to end with them failing to replicate the armor because it would be the biggest retcon in all of Star Wars history.

Imagine what was on that last storm troopers mind when he sees all of his unit being chopped into big chunks of burnt meat by a female Zabrak with the yellow lightsaber 😮

True, but you would probably die if you got shot once from one of those blasters too Imagine if there was a setting in this game were you killed people in one hit but you would die too if an enemy landed a direct hit

@@TheDomino12121 there's a perk on Jedi Survivor that does exactly that.

@@jahn117 oh that’s really cool!

Troopers still not using shotguns and explosives to deal with force users for some reason

Few remember...

I played that a long time ago I'm not even a star wars fan

That must be a horrifying sight indeed. Thanks for the comments. You have a favorite part from this clip?

It's worth noting that the lightsaber was never really meant to be like this. Lucas was a fan of Kurozawa and old samurai flicks, so a it was a given to include some sword fighting in star wars. But a sword is clearly to medieval for story with hyperspace and laser guns, right? Well, we'll just make the blades of the swords be lasers as well to match the aesthetic. That's the main reason lightsabers exist. To have saber battles in the story without ruining the aesthetic of the setting.

Unironically Lightsabers are weak to normal bullets sooooooooo

@@dmartin-cg4136 Normal bullets (or, slugs as they’re called in Star Wars universe) we’re almost never used at all. Nobody carried them because they were very impractical compared to blasters. And your chances of needing them to fight a Jedi were very slim because July were very rare. There was around 14,000 in the Jedi order during the events of the clone wars. That is not a lot compared to the population of a whole galaxy.

​@@dmartin-cg4136they're not weak, they're impractical at defending against bullets because they melt them and project the stage to the lightsaber user

⁠​⁠@@tite93 The issue though is that the gameplay shouldn’t really be like swinging around a traditional sword. It should be more focused on using the lightsaber as an actual lightsaber along with the force to create intriguing and unique gameplay. This is something that could be done but it seems like EA doesn’t want to put in the effort to do so, even if made for a better game.

​@@UnknownCosmos playing a game where you one shot everything doesnt seem too fun

@@him1019 bro the entire star wars gameplay is a power fantasy, you should at least be able to one shot things in clever ways

@@him1019 It depends on how it is implemented. Because the enemies should actually be trained then it should be hard to hit them. Timing would be a big part of it. If you have ever played a game like Superhot, all the enemies die in one hit, but there are a lot of them so you have to be careful because you also die in one hit. I believe a system like that could be implemented fairly well into a Star Wars game, but it just depends on if it is done correctly

@@0Blueaura how clever can swinging a fucking death laser be? Using the force doesnt change the fact that they die from being sliced in half by a lightsaber.

I still think a freaking machine gun would be more deadly

@@JonathanGarza16 yeah if theirs a hoarde of people for sure but the lightsaber is quiet and has tecnuiqe and also a force user who can fold bodies like pop cans with a flick of a wrist

@@lilchernovevo I'm not against lightsabers they're cool af, but you provably could kill most Jedi with a machine gun

@@JonathanGarza16 if you caught em off guard

Did "It's Always Sunny'" taught you nothing? Guns always win in reality.

Right!! I would love a game with realistic wounding mechanics

This is already in Jedi Survivor. It's a perk called Purity that you get in New Game Plus. It lets you one-shot everything, but you get one-shotted as well.

It exists in the second greatest game I've ever played just behind elden ring. Jedi Survivor has this option upon NG+

It exists in the second greatest game I've ever played just behind elden ring. Jedi Survivor has this option upon NG+

It exists in the second greatest game I've ever played just behind elden ring. Jedi Survivor has this option upon NG+

Down the middle...

Nah Star Wars people are ballsy af. Their friend got turned in half but they are different and will kill this Jedi.

Not always, Flight, Fight, or Fright exists, and there will always be the ones who fight even if they are scared shitless

Or at the very least to REALLY perfect your aim.

Im more concerned about the trained warriors inability to shoot a person from just a few metres away.

I loved those games and u could spawn in anything using the console commands too.

those games were my childhood, I always got so disappointed seeing newer star wars games with lightsabers and wondering myself how they couldn't even add an effect of the lightsaber just touching the wall or ground just by walking when it was possible back in 2003 or whenever those games were made

Jedi academy goated

g_saberRealisticCombat 1 if i remember correctly.

Yup g_saberrealisticcombat 1 this comment made me load jedi outcast back up

Cal Kestis has a suspiciously positive attitude for a guy who's constantly slicing dozens of people in half 🤔

Yes, I think this could be the last stage of a negotiation proces.

@@bluemonday2000 Well, that's a Jedi for you. They a soulless robots. I mean, they suppress their emotions so they dont fall to dark side. But this is actually make them more scary. All that prevent them from killing you is their code of Jedi.

Pretty sure in the lore, at least the old lore, a Jedi (as a general rule) would never be the first to fire up their lightsaber for this exact reason.

@@Demial_Sparda Did Obi Wan (actually in any movie) look like a soulless robot? Or Yoda? No, they were caring, kind, always willing to help. But yes, the Jedi code and training is supposed to control some tendencies as I imagine the ability to crush and mind control people with a mere thought can be tempting for many.

They could've, they didn't want to, tho

They didn't do it to make the game more PG.

@DrSabot-A it could have been made like sekiro. Also oldschool Jedi Academy games had dismemberment like this. But they dont make games like that anymore

Disney made Star Wars into a children's franchise that's why the games do not get as lore accurate as they should

they probably just pulled it from game files, early gameplays looked just like that, but they cut it out because of PG rating like mentioned earlier

Lightsabers shouldn't be used to stab. But George did it in the prequels so...

I was so confused when kylo ren just... survived with a little scar... after having his face cut by a lightsaber. That strike should've at least completely destroyed his jaw or something

The concept of lasers melting stuff is such an obvious thing. The fact that people who write this stuff "forget" this genuinely disturbs me

>Disney This is how lightsabers work in like all star wars games even before Disney tho?

Even Force Unleashed didn't have these kinda effects.

What a beautiful world that would be

And everyone would follow the guidelines and ratings without question right? right?

The Clone Wars. A kid's show

Bloody limbs and intestines spilled all over the floor. That's the M-rated star wars lol.

@@ConsensusX Only in the introduction shot. By lore Lightsabers burn so hot they instantly cauterize dismembered limbs.

i miss those days.. game’s multiplayer duels could be ridiculous sometimes.

Jedi Outcast and Jedi Academy are still the best Star Wars games. Parkour Wars is crap.

I forgot that it had to be manually enabled. First seeing this video I was thinking "didn't the Jedi outcast/academy games always have this? How is it a new concept?"

​@@cavscout43 g_dismember command (forget the number) so you can slice n dice through foes and see bits flop off when they fall. But the saber always scorches walls/floor if not mistaken. I think in MP sometimes people would mess with each other by standing with their sabers out looking at the floor.

@@cavscout43 I think the key sads here is.. No modern Star Wars games seem to have it. I actually got curious and re-launched Jedi Academy with the dismemberment enabled. It was a mess.

Probably why Lucus had the Jedi fighting droids in the Prequels, because it would have become a horror movie if they were fighting humans.

Beg they aim for the head

And yet a better love story than twilight

Right? It's actually quite unsettling now that I'm seeing it lol. I think it makes sense seeing a jedi cut limbs off, I'm used to that, but cutting someone down the middle is brutal. I kinda get why we don't often see Jedi characters cut the torso or head in half as often now. Seems more like a Sith thing to do

@@rileymachelle4088 Well, tbf, Obi Wan sliced Maul in half at the waistline, and I think that was the last brutal “death” we’ve seen in the Star Wars universe.. (aside from Ani turning those younglings into “kid-bobs”)

"Am I Imperial-who? Nah bro, you trippin"

@@Sharp47 lmao "Oh!... you must be talking about Cody!... nah. he lives around the block. he aint me.."

Is this a reference on that Video about a fire nation soldier resigning after seeing Toph Metal Bending.

​@@EWALK"I ain't no fortunate son."

I mean 0:49

They do that to keep the franchise mode clean, but actually is very gore. A real fight with a lightsaber would mean people divided in 5 pieces everywhere. Not just a small hole like in the movies.

​@@bazingapuzzaObi-Wan Kenobi cuts off that guy's arm in episode 4 in the Mos Eisley Cantina. It looks just like this. Go back and re-watch that scene.

Yeah of course. But when you get to see it like this it’s like on a whole new of level. I mean you get to see here how Jedi’s aint so peaceful once they have to engage combat. It’s pretty dark.

@@NinjaSushi2 I always thought it was funny how it went from that scene to bonking off armor and just everything yet also goes though walls like butter

This video makes sense of how Palpatine so easily made the population of the galaxy afraid of the Jedi.

Still waiting for a new game or at least a remastered version with multiplayer

Don't know the games but this is what I liked about the force unleashed 2

They didn't light your own pants on fire once. I call a hoax! Especially for Kylo Ren's style of completely insanely stupid crossguard.

Some people expect super realistic things from a fictional IP. Its quite hilarious and sad at the same time 🤣

@@TaurusInvicta Obviously not, but wouldn't it be cooler if the crossguard was .. better designed? You know, so that you could actually parry the oppoent's weapon from sliding across your lightsaber to your fingers, the traditional use case for crossguards.

@@TaurusInvicta Don't be silly, man. We're having a conversation over youtube comments - there's no need for this high and mighty stuff. We're talking about lightsaber designs after all! Or at least, I am. You don't need to be so concerned about me, though it is somewhat endearing.

Idgi. Exactly what did he mod vs base game?

Star Wars has never been big on realism. It's fantasy in space.

Which is why lightsabers are mostly wielded by force sensitive people. They can avoid making those mistakes.

Also, you can change the settings, like, it isn't explored as much, but you can make a saber function like a bat, just like how you can choose it's size.

Iirc they show them being used to saw bulkheads open in the movies at some point & it isn't instant Plus probably if you did poke a hole in the hull itd suck the saber & your arm through instantly; if you did enough to damage the ship your ass is going into space

​@@RedLancerMoto THATS SO HARD

Dismemberment in those games was just as rare. Also didn’t make sense cause you would cut off a guys hand and then he would die, which doesn’t make sense and isn’t lore accurate.

reminds me of Army Men, plastic figurines without any blood inside of their bodies 🤣

"Sith just hunting down people with this kind of violence" Like Vader, who hunts down the rest of the Jedi after the third episode.

Been saying we need a Star Wars horror movie for years

A haunted star destroyer wreck with a deranged sith on board. Go

I've thought about a Star Wars horror novel. Could be rad

Appreciate the kind words, man. It took a lot of time to edit it the way I wanted.

@@Sharp47 where did you get the dismemberment and luke mod from? can you link it please?

@@patcrafting read video description

@@Sharp47 IS this music from TLOU2? It kinda reminds me of the WLF theme.

​@@thescruffinator8830It is :)

100% this. Most lightsaber fights in the movies were drawn out clashes that ended with one decisive lethal blow so it does fit the lore.

This is from a game...? Have you not played them? They have a lot of the same combat as Dark Souls.

@@BollibompaHe refers that they should make a game where one blow is all that’s needed, and instead of health bars it would work with pose similar to Sekiro.

You are describing Movie Battles 2. It's a multiplayer mod for Jedi Academy that refines the lightsaber combat. Force users have BP (Block Points), you drain block points for blocking lightsaber attacks unless you perfect block. Lightsabers are an instant kill on almost all player classes. There is also proper dismemberment. Despite being super old it 100% beats the way dueling feels in any of the Battlefront games, new and old.

@@iminumst7827 MB2 used to have really good system in B19 to RC1 era days (I think that was around 2008-2010) but people complained that the fights were taking too long so they dumbed it down and made it more spam reliant. The end result was that fights became who can bounce their lightsaber inside their opponents the fastest and drain their BP. It just looks really stupid now. B19 fights looked like the actual movie fights. You actually had to aim your strikes and intercept the enemy's strikes. Almost every strike was a block swing (holding the block button while swinging) and people who spammed were either very quickly disarmed (by mblocking) or knocked down and had their BP destroyed on the ground (or beat to death with melee if the opponent was feeling particularly trollish). Hit and run was a very viable strategy. You could duck and weave, slipping in and out of range, dish out damage then step back to dodge. People even turned off their sabers while blocking to prevent BP loss (and also to flex on their opponents). The best jedi/sith players could take on 3-5 average jedi/sith players at once and absolutely wreck them.

I always wondered why they never did this in the first one they did it to animals just annoying cuz like u said they atleast could of made them say different stuff when it's down to 3 or 2 they actually do say stuff but I get what u mean I want then to feel scared but still fight if u hold them with the force they'll sit there and say it can't end like this and stuff so still pretty alright I just wish we can add lil ideas to games and they'd listen just like rdr 2 so many endless ideas that game has

@@JohnyAnderson-hk2nj Or you know, switch to full auto until their gun is empty/overheats (however blasters work). And then either run, beg for their lives, or fall to their knees in mute shock

​@@tomc.5704either let the weapons overheat, so you're constantly dodging, deflecting, and covering. Or you can start crippling them and give them their Free Cybernetics Pass. If they are spared now, they'll return with better ranged weapons, unless it's before a boss, then they get murdered by said boss for fleeing. If they get the Meat to Metal Discount, they'll come back with more difficult weapons, more aggressive tactics, limbs that need more than one hit, and a better AI. If they're killed in the beginning, the rest start to panic and AI rolls the dice

shadow of Mordor and war have a fairly similar terror mechanic if you haven't played it 👉😎 👉

Like arkham knight where the enemies just run away

In survivor you can equip a perk in new game plus that essentially one hits most enemies

also it can be balanced by having the player take a lot of damage too each time they get hit. That way its grounded to the actual lore and demands high skill. Glass cannon is balanced.

It can be something like adventure mode

This is biologically incorrect. Getting ur arm or leg cutoff, or stabs to the stomach do not make ppl die instantly

In turn you would need to get one shotted aswell. Else there is literally 0 challenge

Yeah the guy working on this is a miracle maker.

Just shows how lazy/PC friendly the devs are

​@@SexyStreetStyle what did you accomplish today?

​@@SexyStreetStyleIt's really not the dev's fault. DICE spoke about this when they made Battlefront 2. You gotta realized that Star Wars is a borrowed IP owned by Disney. DICE said Disney wouldn't let them add dismemberment or destruction to the game. You can even google the concept arts for destruction in Battlefront 2. The reason Disney gave is that they want to preserve the look and feep of the movies and don't want any destroyed buildings, nor do they want anything a kid can't play. So no, for Star Wars, the culprit will always be Disney

​@@PermanentHigh meanwhile the animated clone wars series ☠️

Yoo! It's SWTheory! Much love brother! 🫡 I can't express how awesome it is to see you here. Long time fan of your content. Hope to see ya reacting to this on your stream one day 😅

Theory you gotta react to this shit bro! 😂 We need to spread the message that people want realistic dismemberment in SW games!

Who wouldnt wanted jedi academy in new engine with modern graphic, mechanics and characters

Yes…gooood goooood….give into your angaa

You want this.... don't you?

Legendary game

That's realism, though. You suck at throwing sabers? Now you're 6 inches shorter. And it made the fights with Reborn and such way more terrifying, because one shitty stance swap or misdirected swing could be instant death.

@@IrisCorven I just ran up to them and spun, didn't even bother attacking it was so broken.

yes, g_saberrealisticombat lives rent free in my head alongside helpusobi 1

I'm more a Wampa Stompa TIEDUP Weena McCater the hopping woman kinda guy myself,@@costadinover

"Oh look my first enemy with a lightsaber, holy crap im dead" good times :D

Kyle Katarn is so badass that I hope Disney forgets about him so his character isn't ruined.

Never forget: g_saberrealisticcombat9 iykyk

Gen z making games are lazy meh. I prefer jedi knight 2 from 2002.

@@fynkozari9271No one from Gen Z is old enough to work for a company making these games

Glad to know I wasn't the only one,haha

There’s a perk for that on Jedi:Survivor in NewGame+

Still would've preferred to have it as a difficulty option available from the start, instead of some extra where you have to finish the entire game and mess around with perks. Ghost of Tsushima did it right, where it was presented as just as legitimate a way to experience the game as the normal difficulty. Instead of just some extra you get to mess around with after already experiencing the story, like how some games used to treat cheats.

@@HA-ot6uf Ghost was hard AF with that when you first start off, but then gets hella easy when you get new armor and charm perks while enemies are still subject to your hyper damage.

What game is this from?

​@@ryanb3731 no. game is gey

Thanks. When making the video at first I had idea to only include Sith characters, but then I thought including Jedi was just as necessary if I want to show the horrors that these guys can inflict if they are messed with.

Luke's arrival in the mandalorian shows you just how scary a Jedi can be.

every war is a horror movie, and we might forget sometimes, but Star Wars essentially is a story set in a horrible war told by one biased side only

Honestly they should make a game with accurate lightsabers

I dont know what it was about it, but Luke cutting the droids in half gave me chills.

A world where A New Hope's violence was maintained throughout the whole series...

Sure.its called warhammer 40k.

​@@MenderSlen579 I was just about to say this. Powerswords > lightsabers

Help me out guys, last Star Wars video game I played was n64 rogue squadron. Is this not a real game being shown here? Or is this just someone’s pet project they created with Unreal or Unity.

This is Jedi Fallen Order, but with a bunch of mods to change who you’re playing as and changing the lightsaber damage. It’s a great game, but this is definitely not what lightsaber looks like in the actual game.

In the old EU its explained that without Force training its nearly guaranteed you will chop your own arm off eventually. It even happens to some jedi trainees.

@@nathank2289 wait what jesus lol 😂I want to keep my arm’s thanks 😂

Jedi arts trying to make lightsaber fights as elegant as possible instead of a cauterized gore fest

Jedi Academy had the most satisfiying lightsaber combat ever imo but you had to get good at it because you could get 1 shot by lightsabers just like everybody else

@@a.g.m8790 Flailing was a bad plan

@@rocktalon2 yea I had many game over screens w/ my head or limbs flying off because I got lazy and tried to spam 😆

@@a.g.m8790 I was just a dumb kid who didn't know better. Now I'm a dumb adult who doesn't know better

@@rocktalon2 exactly lol I was like 7 when it came out but I didn’t play it until I really got into Star Wars years later. I remember feeling like a badass slicing through Stormtroopers then being instantly humbled when my head came off in slow motion after I tried the same tactics on a lightsaber user 😬

just play in easy mode XD

Sadly jedi academy was never advertised properly so no one ever found out about it and the developers thought it wasnt a good idea anymore because corporate investments so they trashed the realistic combat and stuck to boring ol hack and slash nonsense since 2003

It's just as annoying as Spiderman's swinging. I think Spider-Man 3 was the only one that lets you swing from a building and wrap around a street light if you didn't watch your angle.

@@21skate86what if I told you that you could have realistic and accurate combat AND good game play? Shocker I know but you can with out making lightsabers pool noodles. Also yeah take your pills Timmy.

​@RomanvonUngernSternbergnrmfvuso Would you suggest something like Sekiro's combat? In that game, you don't really hack/slash and most of the combat is centered around just clashing blades with your opponent until one of you gives in.

They sure seem to love their glowing baseball bats from Kenobi series 😅

I thought Jedi survivor has done a better job of this than the first game. If the lightsaber was this brutal it would be too violent for the hero of the game.

@@justin8517 oh I love Survivor and I think they have a well balanced dismemberment system in it, especially when you take in to account that each of the 5 stances also have unique brutal finishers exclusive to every stance. And yeah there's no way Disney would allow such realistic dismemberment system as shown in the video.

Even with a baseball bat you just need one good hit, fallen order/ survivor more like you're using a whiffleball bat.

@@JWonn well how the hell is it meant to be a game if you make everything one hit

The deal is it's not a laser but a plasma. Would like to remind you, that all stars are made of plasma.

Just another reason why TFU 2 is severely underrated.

@@justinharvey7398 Truly a shame that you can finish this Game in less then 2 hours. If i compare to the absolute Gem that was TFU 1 for PS2. Nether Xbox nor the PC Port of the The Force Unleashed are anywhere close to that.

​@@HandsomeGamerGuy PC\Xbox versions are vastly superior because of the physics engine work and uprgaded graphics and resolution.

@@thunderboltproductionsshpk A good Joke you made. Go on and play the PS2 Version. I cannot even beginn to understand how they could downgrade a Game from PS2 => Xbox/PC.

You can experience it in Viscera Cleanup Detail

They got a Droid for that

@@marcelwaddell6290 I feel bad for his vision receptors pray for this droid

Droid scream*

No blood tho😎

I guess chopping living being into pieces with a lightsaber is considered more civilized in Jedi teachings 😂

Jedi give you a chance. You shoot once, it gets deflected. You shoot twice, your own shot comes straight back at you. You survive that and keep fighting, you get cut into nicely seared chunks. Back before the Clone Wars, seeing the deflection or the reflection was probably enough to make most aggressors surrender in shock.

because its not about how brutal the weapon is. you need technique to wield a lightsaber, with blasters you can just shoot

Obi Wan could call this "civilised" as sarcasm, he was to old and wise man and he probably understood that jedi could be wrong with some things they did when he told that to Luke

Did any Jedi besides Obi-Wan ever say this though?

Deadass even the older games allowed u to control the swing direction too

@ThugOG30VIPs3rd-T Yeah, it really is wild this system wasn't improved upon. It wasn't perfect in the Jedi Knight games it was a little janky for me sometimes, but it was still really close to absolutely nailing that feeling of countering someone by swinging in a different direction.

@@vjthehandsome5659 what are you talking about it was damn Near PEFECT. Once you "master" it... takes more time than anyone should honestly invest Tinto a damn video game honestly but once you get it... MMPHHHHH

@@stephonjones4734 maybe I just need more time to master it then

Nah you're right. As awesome as the games themselves were, they were still quite clunk to handle. Don't listen to nostaliga.@@vjthehandsome5659

you can actually do this in star wars battlefront II classic. When playing as the CIS use the "hero unit bonus" on polis massa. Spawn in the hanger checkpoint that has a door leading to the outside surface and simply sprint across to the hanger on the other side, this will allow you to cap the zone at the end of the map and trap the remaining clone troopers. When you get the prompt to play as darth maul you will be able to cut down swaths of clone troopers as they are now trapped in the narrow hallways on the remaining checkpoints in the center of the map.

​@@4T3hM4kr0n Sounds like fun... how'd you figure this mechanic out?

@@thalmoragent9344 by playing galactic conquest and taking advantage of the fact that droids don't take damage when going outside into the vacuum of space because they don't breathe air.

Imagine be Anakin tearing down the younglings into pieces. He was basically a school shooter.

@@4T3hM4kr0n My favorite similar experience was general greavious on Tantive IV

Honestly. The noise the hammer would make as well just lacked any ounce of power

Captain America would be cutting people in half if he hit them by throwing his shield, that thing ain’t dull enough to bounce off flesh

@@firstnamelastname5008 It may as well have been a plastic squeaky hammer.

I was disappointed by that, too. It’s one of the most legendary weapons of all time. The way Thor hits, you’d expect enemies to be torn to pieces, smashed into gore, or flung into the heavens. That’s what comes from a game that puts Thor or equal footing with a girl who has big noodle arms.

This is the star wars that should've came out but the suited up executives were too afraid the market won't like it

Glad the video captured that feeling for you! Which part you enjoyed the most?

@@Sharp47 The whole thing man, it was bloody brilliance.

Heh. Lightsaver.

@@jackychang9148 Yep! I LOVE star war!! PEW PEW, light saver! dark vader and luke skyscraper and obi 1 cannoli and r2b2 and 3pco and tobacca. i love star trek.

@@RomeoX1000 Don't forget Master Yomama and Princess Leeway (RIP).

thank you

For this... I'd be ok with that.

but the game is rated M at least here in Australia it is

So what?

You can cut animals in half soooo

Heres the thing though its not really gory, its not like theres an explosion of blood and their internal organs spilling out when they are sliced in half so I could see it still being rated T

"super hippy code" I fking love it XD. I laughed too hard at that

Jedis: I want to kill Yes but only on tuesdays and sundays

when im playing battlefront 2 the terror i felt when i was a trooper seeing a jedi or sith running towards me

an elegant weapon for a more civilized age obi wan says...

​@@BLVCKSCORP this is outrageous it's unfair!

It would be more brutal if it wasn’t a one hit kill- like in not instantly killing them if you cut them in halve

@@darmanskirata4167 And they keep stumbling with a missing limb? Ooh what if you cut like a part of their head and their personality changes depending on which part was lobotomized?

Not really. They would just need to either put a energy shield or a decent passive defensive system, like in Jedi Academy and everything else is one shot kill for the Jedi/Sith as well. I mean, they've done this before in Jedi Academy and it was glorious. If you tripped while with your lightsaber on, you would lose something and die.

@@johnlime1469 crawling with their arms

@@darmanskirata4167 Like in No More Room In Hell.

Smells like space pork

Yeah like imagine cutting through someone's colon or bladder, like shit man I'd rather have done the job with a plastic spoon and went straight for the neck

Probably smells like barbeque

And I thought they smelled bad on the outside.

@@Joebotnik Oh, that was too good. 😁

Yes that’s what I was thinking

Read my mind

Imagine a game focusing on a Jedi during the clone wars, dismembering droids could be an interesting mechanic.

It was a cheat code not tweaking settings.

@@GaijinGamerGirl I suppose that's right. I just thought of it as changing settings, because you could alter the chance/severity through the console commands. Think it was 1-3? And it was at times risky, because other light sabers were equally dangerous to you if you altered the damage output. I got killed by a friendly when trying to help another Jedi on the final level; I bumped into his weapon while fighting a Sith and died instantly.😂

"borderline Star Wars p*rn for eyes" - I'll take that as a compliment. Thank you 😅

Is this a mod

Read video description

Star wars is for children, now. Like most things, they've been ruined by attempting to appeal to children.

@@TheVoiceOfReason Nah, that's not really it. The appeal to children has been there for a long time. I mean, I absolutely loved Star Wars as a kid. They ruined it by two things: Scrapping the entirety of the Expanded Universe lore ("Legends canon" my ass) and arrogantly believing they could do better (they couldn't), and pandering to the woke ideologues, because apparently everything needs to push political ideology today, and especially in entertainment. Marketing to children is really only a basic symptom of the franchise having grown too big, its market share and target audience too universal. Well, that and the simple fact of being bought by Disney, commerce aimed at children is basically their entire business model. Or was, at least.

Not sure it would work out so well but there's that

In reality there would be soo much mess. Human bodies are 60% water. Upon contact with lightsaber there would be steam reaction (and that steam pressure has to come out somehow) that would literally cause a bodies burst into nasty red pasta. Maybe not for hands/legs but definitely if you cut them through the belly or head down to balls vertically, like in the video. But hey - that's not how it works in Star Wars fantasy 😅, therefore it's lore accurate. Remember how when they cut Maul in half and the worst we saw is tiny little redish mist of blood? Otherwise it always cauterizes in prequels and beyond.

@@Sharp47 Yeah right, like liquid flashing to steam in a blast furnace type effect, my God, could you imagine what an even real-er depiction of the actual physics then you've already done would look like???

@@Sharp47Whilst what you described is the case, I don't think it would play out like that because the lightsabre would be passing by areas of the human body very quickly, so there wouldn't be enough heat generated in the areas of the body for long enough for that to occur.

That's not how physics work... The bodies would literally explode. There is more than enough time for that

​@@JustBuyTheWaywardsRealmsbut definitely not in terms of saber fight which was crappy af

Force Unleashed 2?

My thought watching this was "so you'd be Kyle Katarn with better screen resolution and worse animations." A stormtrooper clutching the stump where his hand used to be before curling into a ball is more lore-accurate than this. The Jedi Knight series remains the peak of the Star Wars video games; frequently imitated but never surpassed. Academy had a weak-ish story, but it was still very fun. Outcast was amazing, but it didn't give you enough time with the stronger powers that let you carve through stormtroopers like this. Force Unleashed was garbage, from plot to characters to mechanics.

​@@RyvakenUnleashed was utter garbage. It was like filoni trying to ape Knight, the sheer amount of nothing personnel kid was irritating.

@@JustBuyTheWaywardsRealms didnt that game have goofy ass Quick Time Events? lmao fuck outta here calling a game with QTE mechanics good. fucking lol, lmao even.

That would be fantastic. The flow of combat in Sekiro was mostly just these long periods of metal clanging on metal as you both parried and blocked and parried and blocked, all of it leading up that red dot moment when you could finally do real damage and kill them(or not if they had multiple lives, you know what I mean). Breaking posture in an SW game would be a perfect way of communicating the fact that to hit someone with a lightsaber's blade *is* to kill or maim them. There's no in-between. If you get a hit in, they're dead. You'd have to wear them down so you can earn the opportunity to actually use your blade on them. With weaker enemies your lightsaber could just chew through them instantly but stronger enemies would be a lot like boss fights in Sekiro where blade strikes that land are fatal but most of the combat flow is parrying and blocking. And parrying is just cool. It's the most satisfying mechanic in action games. Seeing two characters parrying one another's blows over and over is cool too. The scene at the end of Equilibrium, where Christian Bale and the bad guy are fighting hand to hand trying to get a gun shot away, springs to mind. Someone make this game.

@@thesprawl2361 Like I said in other comment, Sekiro's parry system would make more sense with lightsabers for the reasons you just listed. WIth Sekiro I cannot get my head around it. I know it's a game and From Software tried something different to a soulsborne, but fight like that in real life and you will destroy your sword in no time. Lightsabers' blades are indestructible, they don't bend, they don't chip, they don't get dull, but cutting the emmiter with another lightsaber or hit with a perfectly aimed blaster fire, will kill your glowy sword for good. Some of the traditional lightsaber forms had techniques to disarm lightsaber users or destroy their weapon. That being said, I played Sekiro a little and I'm not sold to its combat system. Ghost of Tsushima is actually better and more realistic, specially on harder difficulties.

​@@Xerxes1688sounds like you're just bad at it tbh. Also why are you looking for realism from a game with demons and ogres. Kind of weird.

@@thesprawl2361 I never understood why there can't just be a game where instead of health, you have "luck". So if you get hit by an attack and don't parry in time, your character still parries for you, but you only have a finite number of times where your character will do that for you, and once your "luck" runs out, you actually get hit and die. As i've gotten older I have a harder time getting immersed into a games where you're a bullet/sword sponge and never die.

@@AlkaVirus Realism is having to control every aspect of a character from bowel movement to breathing. What is being asked for is consistency.

me too, this is a main reason i just cant play the new games

Yeah, these games are sick. Btw if you didn’t know, this game is Jedi survivor.

@@EdemamePizza no, that's fallen order with several mods

@@luisrivas1201 that makes sense. Thanks for letting me know

I mean they basically are

jedi knight 2 had all of this, just saying.

​​​@@arkgaharandan5881 It didn't had "all of this". Infact it only had a fraction of what this project offers. People need to stop wearing their nostalgia glasses. What it had was a hitbox with predetermined spots that fall of once touched with the saber. THIS system makes it completely dynamic and physics based. Meaning that the way you gonna cut your opponent depends on the angle from which your attack comes, position of your opponent when attack animation is happening, whether the saber went through the body completely or just slashed the surface of it. I have done countless testing sessions and results are often very different. You can slice the same part in many different ways. Actual closest thing to this system is Metal Gear Rising: Revengence

@@arkgaharandan5881 lil bro got cooked

@@dupersuper6516 when he's says your wearing nostalgic glasses then explains how the games are different kinda proved it's not recent bias.

​@@Sharp47 Por favor no hablo ingles sino español pero aplaudo y fija tu propio comentario has echo evolucionar las fisicas de un juego no se cuanto tiempo te llevo pero tienes mis respetos, esto es algo que me gustaria poder implementar en Halo 2 :') Original

Nah, it's really not. The cauterization on skin and muscle, let alone internals, requires a much longer exposure than we see in almost all lightsaber wounds except for stabbings. Someone getting slashed by a lightsaber would be extremely bloody and horrific.

​@@thelordofcringe flesh (and other stuff too) literally gets cutted because of lightsaber's heat burn it to nothing

Duh

Thanks Doc

@@thelordofcringe Have you noticed that a lightsaber can penetrate a metal bulkhead with ease. At those temperatures, yes it can not only cauterize a wound.. it would also set someone on fire. The heat is intense at the stab/slice/penetration area.

Preach bro!

In Jedi Academy, there was only a cut off hand or arm by chance. However, there's the code to turn the feature on fully.

Lightsabers have always been like that in old movies and shows too. Cutting off limbs and stuff happened rarely, for whatever reason. If anything, they only seemed more deadly in the prequel trilogy. I guess because they were fighting robots (but also because they cut Maul in half lol)

I miss the old movies like Star Wars episode 1 the phantom menace... Saber fights made more sense, so much quicker, wild, made it feel like actual Jedis. int eh newer ones it looks like two knights from the medieval times fighter with a heavy sword. Slow swings, etc. Nothing beats the fights like Obi and Qui vs Darth Maul, or Anikan vs Obi in Star Wars 3.

@@Jamezy316 Anikan? Who is that character?

Oh, you mean because even if you're 'out of range', they can just snatch you with the Force and end you in an instant? Yeah...

@@zeromancer-x Well... yes. it's like - 1 hit kill everytime.

Yeah, this is why you don't fuck with a Jedi or Sith unless you're actually tough. Getting chopped to bits isn't fun.

@@chrisnichols9014 I dont think being tough will help you much against a lore accurate lightsaber... xD

@@Cangaca777 Mandalorians kill Jedi and Sith so they are pretty tough.

"Good soldiers follow orders"

Rick the door Technician my beloved

Nah fuck the magic space Nazi soldiers 😂

i love stormtroopers so much

They didnt should jefi in the back when they could and they really should've...

It definitely wasn't like the simulations.

thank you for your service

Nahh Jedis are better

@@alfredohumberto2222 hell no sith are !

@@alfredohumberto2222bro you seem to not understand the full power of the dark side of the force

Grey Jedi? With options to pick and shit

@@efreq.6465 I know they can't become a ghost and the ghost is the most powerful form able to use the force in the normal world, but without being touched

An elegant weapon for a more civilized age.

Rogue one??

@@eldararnautovic2797 Rogue One is still PG-13. What he's saying is what a lot of us have been saying for decades. We want a rated-R Star Wars masterpiece.

They cant do that, cuz Lego

Star Wars reg George Lucas, Stephen Spielberg and Cristopher Nolan

Also make a rated R film would be awesome. Storm troopers getting decapitated and sliced in half…yes plz

Aye, would make more sense that you had to be force capable in order to sense the blade and not strike yourself with it. Otherwise, one wrong move and it's your leg or your companion's half a torso... whoops! 😅

Not really more challenging, but yes challenging

That’s why up until disney took over it was nearly impossible for anyone but force sensitives to wield a lightsaber in the starwars lore.

Difficult because the “blade” has no mass. Imagine wielding a simple flashlight, but anything within three or four feet the light touches is destroyed. Not imagine the speed at which you could swing it. And how easily you could kill yourself. If the Jedi were real, they’d essentially be otherworldly just to be able to wield a massless sword.

@@obeliant5025Yes, more challenging. The ultimate challenge being that the blade has no mass.

😢 I miss those days.

@@cowel8734 days of wine and song they were

Yeah it was awesome in Return of the Jedi when Luke was cutting people in half.......oh wait

Crazy how you people delude yourselves into believing that Star Wars wasn't always trying to be kid friendly for the extra big bucks despite its violent universe before Disney came along. You guys swear Star Wars Legends was the actual face of Star Wars lol.

@lightningonlycommentsonce5824 Impressive, you managed to tap dance your way over that edge without ever once hitting on a good point. I never said that Star Wars wasn't kid friendly. It would be best described as "fun for the whole family." Though that said, if it had a target audience, it was adolescent boys, and while no one is arguing, that they should be shown a graphic disembowling scene, that audience tends to be placated with a slightly higher level of violence in their films, but that's neither hear nor there. As for Disney's hand, well, to start, they've never gotten lightsabers right. Oh sure, the VFX looks decent, but it always seemed off, and then there's the fact that there hasn't been a good live action duel since they bought the property. As for Legends, it was a mess, but it was a mess made from the dreams of those who loved the world, making it more than just some space opera from the 70s, more than a heroes epic journey, they made it a world. I don't see as there was a need to make films happening after Return of the Jedi, but if you have to, there are dozens of interpretations to draw from and I don't know of one I'd prefer less than what we got.

Lucas always intended him to be a joke character. Clone Wars 2003 portrayed him in a much better light imo

They didn't mishandle him, he just didn't have a place in the films. Go watch the clone wars miniseries, that was star wars in 2d made by ultra talented people. It was allegedly pg-13 but I remember grievous CLAPPING asscheeks in that.

​​@@necromax13that's what I mean. I watched the Tartakovsky clone wars as a kid before I watched ep III

​@@Gyro___ZeppeliGrievous' concept work was incredibly messy, he was a child in a floating chair at one point lol. They finally managed to strike gold, only to reduce him to a jobber in subsequent media.

@@Raptorman0205 *tartakovski but yeah.

the force unleashed 1 and 2, this would happen exactly so like in the video. at least in the version that was sold in germany. don`t know how it was elsewhere but i could cut throuth stormtroopers like that, at least in the versions for ps3

@Super-Godzilla99 It was the same way in the USA

@@Super-Godzilla99Force Unleashed 1 & 2 both had dismemberment physics on the versions I played (US;WII)

@@darthvaydor6716 jo i didn't know that, because many games are very different from area too area around the world.

Some righteous soul should mod The Force Unleashed into this.

Glad you noticed it! I made that shot and a little zoom-in effect at 2:07 on purpose. One of my favorite things about this dynamic dismemberment system is the fact if the saber goes completely through the body it will cut a chunk depending on the angle the attack came from, BUT if it only grazed surface with the tip of the blade like at the end of the video - it will leave a burn mark instead. The author of this system said that his vision for complete project includes partial dismemberment (not included yet). Meaning that we should also see a "hanging" limbs if they weren't cut off completely

@Sharp47 that's amazing, you gotta admire the people who love games and gamers enough to work so hard on delivering us free and high quality content. Keep highlighting these awesome people sir!

​@@NO-AH562 yep especially considering that it's just one dude is doing all of this during his spare time. Alone and for free.

This is amazing but not completely realistic. I believe for sufficiently dense/thick body parts like torsos it shouldnt cut right through with quick vertical/diagonal swipes, heat still needs time to transfer and things like armor should definitely affect the cutting ability too.

@@Henry14arsenal2007 In films or animated CW series, comics they cut through way thicker/solid stuff with ease all the time. Even in prequels they constantly cut through metal of B1 or even thicker B2 droids with a single swipe. Sometimes even through multiple metalic droids in a single one handed strike.

You ever played jedi academy? It’s exactly like you described

Jedi academy has the best and most accurate light saber combat so far there will never be another game like it definitely not from a AAA company

@@shodan2002 Yeah. I wouldn't say the sword fight in Jedi Academy is accurate to say how a real lightsaber fight would be per se (you strafe around and do wide swings, it does look a little silly), but it captures this feeling of out-maneuvering your opponent and scoring that one critical hit. People who think video games have to be hit points / bullet sponge just don't have imagination.

@@BrotherCheng AAA companies have the budget but they could never do this today at least we have indie devs that actually come up with something new despite having a smaller budget I love Kenshi it’s an amazing game never that no AAA company could do properly these days no matter how much money they have

Only studio I can think of that could make something like that is a studio under Sony

Stormtrooper: "I won't let you kill me!" You: ”You don't have a choice!" /slices him up

The stormtroopers break my heart in this game. "I'm the only one left?" "Is he gonna kill us all??"

@@justinharvey7398What really gives this game immersion is the stormtroopers feel like people and not just moving obstacles.

For it to be an actual interesting game the stormtroopers would need to be a fearsome force too, and also able to one-hit you with a single blaster bolt. Any error on each side would be fatal. This seems like lambs to the slaughter and it's power fantasy, not a game, unusually cruel too.

Exactly. Jedi Outcast with the dismemberment mod is the closest to this. Take them out with the Strong style :D

Mod? I remember it as a console command

@@Damian-rp2iv oh maybe it was yes!!! youre right.

i still remember that code after 20 years... [~] >helpusobi 1 (enables cheats) >g_SaberRealisticCombat 1

@@Damian-rp2iv oh! Well then, next time I play it...

Which shown character in the video was your favorite?

​@@Sharp47Galen Marek's/Starkiller's Dark Lord Armor. The robotic breathing just sends chills down your spine

Absolutely, even more so breaking the guard of bosses just stagger them for 2s and thats it

that's kind of how lightsaber fights work

We had something similar from Jedi Knight series from 20+ years ago but it aged like milk and plays like jank. It had cool dismemberment but nowhere near this level and it wasn't dynamic

@@Sharp47 you can do some cool stuff with mods like Movie Duels 2 for J Academy. It changes the combat so you can slow the speed to your liking and manually block etc. Then you can change the damage and dismemberment multipliers to make it a 1 hit kill game with 100% dismemberment. Still janky but made for a fun time.

@@jordanneal8979 true, I loved MB2 mod

Everyone forgets Force Unleashed 2 existed, you could literally decapitate enemies

@@rhysking3597 Yeah you can cut off some limbs or decapitate, but those were set points that were allowed to be cut as a straight line across the arm, leg or head. Also, not every enemy could actually be cut. Whereas this is fully physics based, where any point can be cut and the angle is recognized, for any unit. It just doesn’t compare.