Тёмный

Immigration is Bad For Britain | Godfrey Bloom 

OxfordUnion
Подписаться 2,1 млн
Просмотров 205 тыс.
50% 1

Godfrey Bloom gives his argument why Immigration should be limited in Britain.
SUBSCRIBE for more speakers ► is.gd/OxfordUnion
Godfrey Bloom suggest that Britain should place more control on who is let into the country. Much like Australia and Canada the policy should allow people with a certain skill set to be allowed residence in the UK.
Filmed on Thursday 23rd January 2014
MOTION: This House Believes postwar Britain has seen too much immigration.
STAY CONNECTED:
Facebook @ theoxfordunion
Twitter @ / oxfordunion
Oxford Union Website @ www.oxford-union.org/
ABOUT GODFREY BLOOM:
Godfrey William Bloom TD is a member of the United Kingdom Independence Party (UKIP) but sits as an independent Member of the European Parliament for Yorkshire and the Humber.
Bloom was elected for UKIP in 2004 and re-elected in 2009. He has received attention from the British media for making remarks considered objectionable by his party leader, and for expressing a position of climate change skepticism.
Bloom resigned his party whip from UKIP on 24 September 2013 and sits as an independent MEP.
ABOUT THE OXFORD UNION SOCIETY:
The Union is the world's most prestigious debating society, with an unparalleled reputation for bringing international guests and speakers to Oxford. It has been established for 190 years, aiming to promote debate and discussion not just in Oxford University, but across the globe.
Rights managed by Oxford Media Associates www.oxfordmediaassociates.com/
Filmed by Oxford Media Solutions www.oxfordmediasolutions.co.uk

Опубликовано:

 

30 янв 2014

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 754   
@TheVic256
@TheVic256 7 лет назад
Im not from UK but visiting the country it feels like I'm in some middle-eastern country... How does a country allow for itself to loose it's heritage and culture in such a horrible and rapid way?!?
@BeatingStandards
@BeatingStandards 6 лет назад
Amen.
@GashGalore
@GashGalore 5 лет назад
Oy...
@h7283
@h7283 3 года назад
Treacherous money grabbing M. P. s
@thomasalvarez6456
@thomasalvarez6456 2 года назад
By be called “racist”. There will not be many cultures in the future. Just a mish mash of many.
@vjab1108
@vjab1108 2 года назад
None of the British people want this mass immigration so you wonder why the Governments of the last 30 years have allowed it.
@nyctreeman
@nyctreeman 10 лет назад
Godfrey Bloom is a gem ... he says it like it really is and pulls no punches.
@JohnSmith-su3ze
@JohnSmith-su3ze 5 лет назад
I've always been very positive about immigration, but after what I've seen in the UK in recent years I've been turned off immigration for life Immigration has divided us and created so much negativity. It is a lie that we need immigrants. I'm now, for the first time in my life, totally against immigration. It's simply not worth the hassle.
@jayo3074
@jayo3074 5 лет назад
Get a life you racist
@osifrahamanov3436
@osifrahamanov3436 5 лет назад
triggered much?
@StayStrapped1
@StayStrapped1 5 лет назад
Shane Chambers nice b8 m8
@MarkRai-ko1sk
@MarkRai-ko1sk 5 лет назад
It's a little late to get cold feet over immigration. I'm just glad UKistan is gonna be gone from europe in short order.
@blakeshannon9800
@blakeshannon9800 5 лет назад
Islam, if we continue to live in fantasy, will one day rule Britain 🇬🇧. 1500 Mosques 🕌 and growing; many are in politics; and remember the men can have four wives which will increase their birth rate, making us a minority in our own homeland. Islam is at odds with our values, culture, and Christianity and they will only tolerate that till they gain power. More people need to wake up to this grave danger in our land and reduce its presence. It’s preserving our Nations and liberties. “The ultimate tragedy is not the oppression and cruelty by the bad people, but the silence over that by good people.” - Martin Luther King. “Every Race & Colour is Beautiful. It is BEHAVIOUR that is of Consequence when it comes to Vice and Virtues.” - B.B.
@matthewread7220
@matthewread7220 5 лет назад
Immigration is great for massive tycoons, but very damaging for the working class
@POLISHAMERICANLEGIONS
@POLISHAMERICANLEGIONS 4 года назад
This is a true as well. But the Polish migrants motivate working class of UK and they do open a British companies as well.
@milo2324
@milo2324 4 года назад
Yes! COSTA, STARBUCKS, and the banks who get their leaflets and brochure printed cheaply!
@cliffsousa4184
@cliffsousa4184 4 года назад
Cheap labour and no insurance you see. But some 20% of immigrants are quite good and they add new blood to the old jack. But i must say the rest of em are quite useless and don't adapt well and insist on living like they did in their old country.
@Robertsmith001
@Robertsmith001 4 года назад
@@milo2324 You missed out a lot
@tubsymcghee7169
@tubsymcghee7169 4 года назад
It's great for the working class, who appreciate Chinese and Indian cuisine and Reggae music amongst many other positives.
@aliengrey6052
@aliengrey6052 3 года назад
A great speaker. Of course what he says is true. It is quite obvious we need to control our borders it is simply a fact of decent management of any country.
@gamithawanasinghe4096
@gamithawanasinghe4096 2 года назад
Yes,but now also UK have more than 9.5 million foreigners and that's too much,Why still borders aren't close???
@Cjrdrumming
@Cjrdrumming 5 лет назад
You could see this was hard to swallow for most of the audience
@swesleyc7
@swesleyc7 4 года назад
Many (not all) universities are full of leftist professors who brainwash students. They're taught what to think, not how to think.
@milton7763
@milton7763 4 года назад
Dichotomy & Balance Thanks for the insight! Never heard this before. Certainly not expressed so eloquently
@cliffsousa4184
@cliffsousa4184 4 года назад
@@swesleyc7 what makes it interesting is that they believe it 100% from the bottom of their souls that they are the good ones and that they know what's right & that whoever has a different opinion is the bad guy.
@bitTorrenter
@bitTorrenter 4 года назад
@@swesleyc7 You shouldn't need to be taught 'how' to think. It's your brain, your life.
@swesleyc7
@swesleyc7 4 года назад
@@bitTorrenter Sorry. What I mean, as an example, is the Socratic method. It's good to be taught correlation vs causation, as another example.
@johnbell1859
@johnbell1859 Год назад
Absolutely spot on, and things are even worse now in 2023. 🤔 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿
@Sameoldfitup
@Sameoldfitup 4 года назад
The number of white British people in the capital fell by 620,000 - equivalent to the entire population of Glasgow moving out. The consequence, as revealed by the latest census, is that white Brits are now in a minority in London, making up just 45% of its residents.
@leainokuchi9650
@leainokuchi9650 Год назад
Same here in the USA. WE are now hated by our own citizens, the very people ALLOWED and welcomed to come here. NEVER is when a white civilization should allow the demography to become less than majority. When this happens, the social fiber crumbles into insanity and hatred. SEE last 5 yrs of history in EVERY continent that allowed this to happened.
@martynnash6904
@martynnash6904 4 года назад
Well said that man, and I'm delighted that this is being spoken to our University students of today.
@Anicius_
@Anicius_ 2 года назад
This was 7 years ago
@youriwander7419
@youriwander7419 2 года назад
Not anymore
@jaydunstan1618
@jaydunstan1618 Год назад
Did he know Kwarteng?
@Tobypaws2002
@Tobypaws2002 9 лет назад
It's not a problem when you have ,say , point 1 maximum of the population as immigrants. The problem has come from decades of more and MORE ! Such that chunks of cities feel like foreign countries. Alien customs and religions come in and make the original population feel uneasy. Plus the lack of integration makes even more fear and division. Especially when you get demonstrations calling for beheading of anyone who speaks out.... IT IS NOT A RACE THING, IT IS A SPACE THING. We don't hate ANYone. But our hospitality is being stretched too far...... We struggled for many centuries to make a civilised country.... Is it better now than in the 1950's? We weren't fearful then....... This is a small island, and we are vastly overcrowded. 1000per square mile in England is a disaster for the future, and no wonder we have fear : The STATED Intention is to conquer us by out-breeding us. Isn't that a charming way to be thanked for accommodating 7 million 'extras' since 1997 ?
@TheRugFace
@TheRugFace 4 года назад
I don't know that anything you've said here is true. Most British people are tolerant of immigrants. Yes the country is better now than the 1950s, only a moron would say otherwise. Current population density is 670 (per square mile) in the UK, not 1000. In 1997, the population was 58.31 million, in 2015 when you made your comment, it was 65.11 million. The total growth of the population (including all demographics) in the period you have outlined is less than your made up statistic for the number of immigrants who moved here in that period. It's easy to have a bigoted worldview when it's not supported by facts.
@milton7763
@milton7763 4 года назад
The ‘space’ argument is such a joke to me. Go live in Delhi for a year - you know, that city in that country you invaded and ruled for so many years...
@crestadude4139
@crestadude4139 4 года назад
Toby you are completely right we just seem to forget that we are a small island.
@memeoti6266
@memeoti6266 4 года назад
We all immigrated here at some point in time. That is nature's way.
@abigailslade3824
@abigailslade3824 3 года назад
Meme Oti shut up muppet
@Kareszkoma
@Kareszkoma 9 лет назад
He is right. As wrong as it sounds, he is right. Maybe it's not nice, or sounds awfull but that won't make it any less true.
@user-wy7em9fm2c
@user-wy7em9fm2c Год назад
m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QhMO5SSmiaA.html
@frankvonfrauner
@frankvonfrauner Год назад
But none of these same arguments work for Australia or Canada. Growing places need to welcome as many immigrants as they can handle. And for some reason, our politicians demand we take twice as many as we can handle.
@cliffmatthews6106
@cliffmatthews6106 5 лет назад
Very true, we have had too much immigration over the years and it’s time that some of these politicians realised this !
@rashidawad5825
@rashidawad5825 Год назад
ENGLAND ROB EVERYONE AROUND THE GLOBE SO ENGLAND SHOULD SHUT ITS MOUTH SO WE CAN SPEAK--TOO MANY IMMIGRANTS GIVE ME A BREAK.
@jaydunstan1618
@jaydunstan1618 Год назад
Like Kwasi Kwarteng and Godfrey Bloom.
@user-wy7em9fm2c
@user-wy7em9fm2c Год назад
m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QhMO5SSmiaA.html
@michaelscales5996
@michaelscales5996 3 года назад
Our tiny island is overcrowded. House prices are now out of reach for most people,our NHS even before Covid struggled to cope as do our schools and infra structure.Our roads are full to bursting as are our towns and cities. One side effect of huge immigration is that many Brits are now left in areas where they are very much in the minority in that part of the town.Consequently they experience loneliness as they are often the only English speakers in that street.Corner shops they used either shut down or change hands and sell food they don't eat but the immigrants prefer. No one seems to speak up for those stuck in such circumstances,and if you do,you are labelled a racist.Many are in the generation that fought for our freedom in WW2, and it's a disgrace they've been treated so shabbily.
@JJaqn05
@JJaqn05 2 года назад
Britain isnt a "tiny island". Its 6 times the size of Denmark, nearly twice the size of Bangladesh and is the 11th biggest country in Europe.
@michaelscales5996
@michaelscales5996 2 года назад
@@JJaqn05 The USA forty times our size,so is Australia.France is 2.3 times our size.We are a tiny overcrowded island.To say we are bigger than Denmark and Bangladesh is a strange comment.Bit like saying a sparrow is bigger than a hummingbird.
@JJaqn05
@JJaqn05 2 года назад
@@michaelscales5996 The USA is the 4th biggest country in the world. You are an idiot for trying to compare it to the UK. We are not "tiny". We are the 80th biggest country in the world out of more than 200. That cannot be tiny. And we definitely are not overcrowded. We need a bigger population and if the white people in the country cant have enough babies then we will need more immigration to increase our population.
@JJaqn05
@JJaqn05 2 года назад
@@michaelscales5996 Russia is also nearly twice the size of the US. It is 2.23 times bigger than Australia. And is 5.2 times bigger than India. That doesnt make India small
@JJaqn05
@JJaqn05 2 года назад
@@michaelscales5996 Bangladesh is nearly 2x smaller and has more than 2x the population.
@Verse_Jumper
@Verse_Jumper 4 года назад
Why must a country risk destroying itself for those who don’t care if they destroy the country?
@mikecarter5275
@mikecarter5275 5 лет назад
Large scale movement anywhere is trouble. From, Bradford to the Costa del Sol, Dubai to Paris. Rich dominating poor, and the desperate undercutting wages of ordinary working people . Slavery, indentured workers, urban working classes, just a case of exploitation and power abuse. We need true civilization.
@CraftyApe
@CraftyApe 8 лет назад
Who the fuck titled this? It's mal-formed. He says from the start that immigration in itself is neither good nor bad. The motion should be is MASS immigration bad, or free movement. Not immigration as a whole.
@storbynatt
@storbynatt 8 лет назад
+Rahul Kemp Bloom is not really a racist. He's just against the concept of a government who steals peoples money and puts it out as a carrot for people to come to the UK. Either you stop doing that, and it wouldn't be fair if you didn't stop it for everyone and reduce taxes for everyone, or you have to restrict immigration.
@rahulkemp6489
@rahulkemp6489 8 лет назад
***** im not gayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
@DuskAndHerEmbrace13
@DuskAndHerEmbrace13 7 лет назад
It's the name of the motion, you idiot.
@SternDrive
@SternDrive Год назад
This guy gets it!
@Frosty-oj6hw
@Frosty-oj6hw 9 лет назад
Having a country which is ever more socialist and taxes the native population to provide socialist benefits like free healthcare and the welfare state, and then opening borders to the entire world...it's just idiotic and will quickly become a race to the bottom. I say we let people put their money where their mouth is, if you want the borders open then let's calculate the tax increase we'll need to support unchecked immigration and lets exclusively tax those people who support it, so only they are paying for that decision, and not those people who oppose it. In the long run socialism has to go and we need to become a capitalistic country where peoples standards of living are correlated with their contributions to the market, then the people wanting to move to the UK won't be millions of poor people looking to scrounge off benefits, but free marketeers who want to provide value to everyone else and make a good living for themselves. More freedom, more liberty and more quality living for everyone who can live peacefully together with us.
@motanelustelistu
@motanelustelistu 5 лет назад
Most of the states in the world provide "free" healthcare in that you don't pay for it like at the shop,but you do pay a tax,like pension one.Helathcare without hat tax is trully idiotic. Still,you need to understand capitalism aand communism are the faces of the same coin. The economy it's not about to let it be uncontrold,unregulated and unjudged/unarbitred ,but about keeping key industries in state's control and ownership and others,free,but regulated. P.S> This CRETIN AND GENOCIDAL communists are way too psycho and dangerous to concentrate on such little important problems in comparison with the EXISTENTIAL PROBLEMS they bring and brag about thinking and putting in fact/implementing.
@109joiner
@109joiner 5 лет назад
We have the finest health service in the world. It is the envy of the world and I’m quite confident no mater what your political persuasions it will remain free . So stick that in your pipe and smoke it.
@sakhawatrahman4961
@sakhawatrahman4961 3 года назад
Frosty. In terms of Socialist-Capitalist economy, I think we’re doing fine. What I do agree with, is that we need to make immigration more strict; lower benefits for immigrants. And we also need to deport the bad immigrants. By the way, I’m a Bengali-British Muslim 2nd Generation immigrant (My parents came here in the Early 2000’s; they came here legally).
@HarpreetSingh-kj8ro
@HarpreetSingh-kj8ro Год назад
@@sakhawatrahman4961 I hope you see this. What do you think of Muslim extremists of the UK like Smile2Jannah, Ali Dawah, and Muhammad Hijab. UK really fucked up allowing these types into the UK.
@onetwo6064
@onetwo6064 5 лет назад
God bless you Godfrey
@enyape
@enyape 7 лет назад
MAY THE SPIRIT OF ENOCH POWEL WATCH OVER US.WHY DID WE NOT LISTEN???
@truecinnamon
@truecinnamon 5 лет назад
BBC
@margotmadden1119
@margotmadden1119 5 лет назад
Eddie W because he was a racist wanker
@chatoyant23
@chatoyant23 5 лет назад
@@margotmadden1119 What an insightful and unpredictable response.
@pullitlarry5296
@pullitlarry5296 5 лет назад
@@margotmadden1119 DEMOGRAPHY IS DESTINY. JUST LOOK AROUND THE WORLD.
@margotmadden1119
@margotmadden1119 5 лет назад
chatoyant23 sorry I’m not about to write an essay in the youtube comments section lol
@cyngaethlestan8859
@cyngaethlestan8859 4 года назад
We should all be thankful that the Oxford union records and uploads these speeches, I just wish they also uploaded the whole unedited debates as a single file, with results of the vote at the end. Apart from that, THANK YOU.
@user-pe1wu9zb4x
@user-pe1wu9zb4x 10 лет назад
Excellent speaker! The problem is the level of immigration has been too high for comfort. Its not that immigration itself is a problem. Dont be fooled by politicians who keep saying immigration is good so, having too much is also good.
@wouldbabyhitlerkillyou4217
@wouldbabyhitlerkillyou4217 4 года назад
Immigration has no positives whatsoever and those who say otherwise in these times of great despair are traitors to their own people/nation. Immigration is simply cultural and racial suicide to varying degrees and it forces the native population to reproduce less leading to eventual extinction...
@danielgraham5907
@danielgraham5907 4 года назад
John White do you really think messages can be sold, individuals such as Farage et al will be respected and listened to with that sort of messages? If so you are utterly deluded. Ultimately it can only be argued that freedom of movement is bad and that we should only allow useful people with much needed skills/ offer work persists for lesser skilled roles that need filling.
@zootsoot2006
@zootsoot2006 4 года назад
He's anything but a good speaker. A complete bore imo. The kind of guy who takes over every social situation he's in and sucks out all the oxygen.
@anonymoust2877
@anonymoust2877 3 года назад
@@wouldbabyhitlerkillyou4217 it does. economic benefits. "racial suicide" gtfo
@quillo2747
@quillo2747 3 года назад
@@anonymoust2877 The English are now a minority in the capital of England. Current projections show the British becoming a minority in Britain by 2060. At the youngest school age, nursery/infants, Brits are already a minority. Having a slightly higher gdp, which only benefits the wealthy, is not a good reason to lose your homeland. I would not wish ethnic replacement upon any peoples of the world. Europe can not be a home to the entire world.
@BabylonianHebrew
@BabylonianHebrew 8 лет назад
Based Godfrey! I quite like his jacket. Keep giving leftists incredible asspain, one day you will be remembered as a hero
@johnmoore9862
@johnmoore9862 5 лет назад
Babylonian Hebrew, Three years on & he is still remembered as an arsehole.
@naybobdenod
@naybobdenod 9 лет назад
Moderation is not an EU policy.
@askvlogs9604
@askvlogs9604 7 лет назад
if people are so much in migrating to uk ... i donot understand why they fought for freedom... why donot these immigrats ask uk to re conolise thier country again.. whats the point in blaming britain for ruling the world
@pavankiran4719
@pavankiran4719 4 года назад
Becoz uk is the reason for most of problems in the world
@ryanboshell6124
@ryanboshell6124 4 года назад
pavan kiran haha
3 года назад
@@pavankiran4719 Is that why you speak English so well?
@pavankiran4719
@pavankiran4719 3 года назад
@ lol..no America is the reason why world considered English as business language. The moment china dethrone America , mandarin will be the business language. No body gives a shit abt Britain
@Woltato
@Woltato 10 лет назад
I'm not racist, I've got lots of friends from Bongo Bongo Land.
@oraclex2976
@oraclex2976 3 года назад
What is happening in some European countries today is demographic colonisation.
@brahimbouh7499
@brahimbouh7499 3 года назад
We will conquer your land as you did to us in the past
@oraclex2976
@oraclex2976 3 года назад
@@brahimbouh7499 Why? You're too dumb to develop your own?
@nickohira1397
@nickohira1397 Год назад
@@brahimbouh7499 where are you from?
@user-pe1wu9zb4x
@user-pe1wu9zb4x 10 лет назад
The Rate of immigration makes all the difference. Imagine. If the rate of immigration is so high that 55% of Britain is made up of New Citizens from say China. Then, Britain would have lost its identity. If only 5% are new citizens, then these would not be able to dominate Britain identity. If 55%, native brits would have become a minority. In a democracy, majority rules. Then, the native brits would have to assimilate with the majority Chinese brits. Not the other way round. British identity would then be lost forever because these new citizens are here to stay.
@MrDanielfff777
@MrDanielfff777 4 года назад
True
@user-pe1wu9zb4x
@user-pe1wu9zb4x 3 года назад
@S. I. V. 55% was a scenario for the purpose of illustrating my point. Not a specific situation.
@user-pe1wu9zb4x
@user-pe1wu9zb4x 3 года назад
@S. I. V. I think you are misguided by Muslim or Islam. There are many good people there
@sukraatahluwalia5137
@sukraatahluwalia5137 3 года назад
Which is why the US immigration law has a strict rule, that in any year at most 7% of immigrants can come from one country and no more, for example: if the US takes in 100 immigrants, then at most 7 immigrants can come from China, all other Chinese applicants would be pushed into a backlog for the next year. The US does this so that a major chunk of immigrants to the US do not come from one country and this leads to a diverse set of immigrants, without forming a majority.
@user-pe1wu9zb4x
@user-pe1wu9zb4x 3 года назад
@@sukraatahluwalia5137 Of course. Its not easy to allow huge proportions of new citizens from a particular country like china without being noticed by the native citizens. My point is a theoretical one. In practice, this is still possible in authoritiarian countries where the people are ruled by law and fear such that they have no opposition to speak up for them as all opposition have been destroyed. Eg. China. Of course china does not need so many new citizens. Just a case in point. An asian authoritarian country can be so bastard they do not disclose the real rate of influx until its too late for the native citizens to realise a critical mass of new citizens have been allowed. New citizens typically , almost everyone of them, tend to vote for the govt that granted their citizenship. This is one way ruling parties of authoritarian states can retain power longer. This can change the fabric of the society permanently. Natives can be wiped out just like American Red Indians
@TomKilworth
@TomKilworth 8 лет назад
South Africa is civilised? News to me!
@CommieCotch
@CommieCotch 8 лет назад
+Tom K My idea of civilisation is not murder, ecological catastrophe and exploitation.
@Supermario0727
@Supermario0727 7 лет назад
+CommieCotch That's why it's only the white parts.
@berhoom2024
@berhoom2024 5 лет назад
Bring them in, but no citizenship (ever) - not for them or their children. Only residency visas which must be renewed. And after a certain term, no more renewals. Pretty much like the Gulf countries.
@lukejohn1277
@lukejohn1277 5 лет назад
So true that UK has seen too much immigration and about the immigration policy of the right skill set and nothing more
@jtk1ify
@jtk1ify 5 лет назад
i agree with Godfrey about immigration, but not about state provision of healthcare and welfare. the problem as he rightly points out is that these foundations of a civilised society which can not be expected to provide for a open door immigration policy. with regard to jobs for the youth in our country it is through his own ideology that a lack of training and investment into the children of our country has been replaced by the buying in of skills from abroad which has led to what we now see
@jimdavis8391
@jimdavis8391 10 лет назад
As the titular Yorkshireman said 'I say what I like and I like what I bloody well say'. That is being English.
@nicoc6387
@nicoc6387 5 лет назад
The title given to this video (and ditto the one with Douglas Murray) is misleading, presumably deliberately. That was not the argument. The motion was "postwar Britain has seen too much immigration". Not at all the same thing.
@abigailslade3824
@abigailslade3824 3 года назад
Nico C well these people always twist the narrative to suit them and make their opponent look bad.
@banurobymusic
@banurobymusic 9 лет назад
6:50 omg their faces
@mikanfarmer
@mikanfarmer 4 года назад
I totally agree, .........Jeezus, did we all look so frikken stupid when we were at university ? Okay, okay, .......don't answer that !
@JR-rv3xr
@JR-rv3xr 2 года назад
In 2021 the national opinion has evolved. We don't just want a stop to immigration. We need a fully supported repatriation system no matter how long you've been living here. A third, second, first generation migrant it doesn't matter. It needs to be positivly encouraged and financially backed for all none natives.
@frankvonfrauner
@frankvonfrauner Год назад
Extremists in the New World call that "The decolonization of Native North America" Unless you're willing to accept the 20 million or so Australians and Canadians of British descent who would need to be repatriated under your scheme, your argument has a serious flaw.
@JR-rv3xr
@JR-rv3xr Год назад
@@frankvonfrauner Well this was an old comment, looking back. But yes we would accept that privilege. An example of why I think like this. A woke reporter from BBC interviewing the Dalai lama, a few years ago now. Couldn't understand why he thought natives staying in their own country and reducing migration was a beneficial thing for all? At the time she tried to infere that might be racist, but clearly knew he wasn't. Why one of the kindest most wholesome thinkers of our age would hold this opposite view to her. A year after the interview the reporter wrote a piece about why she moved back to India (3d generation Indian migrant in Britain). In the end of the large piece she said she felt more at home and connected than at any time of her life. Personally I thought that was quite lovely 🙂.
@user-wf4gt9ei2u
@user-wf4gt9ei2u Год назад
Ur a freak mate get a life
@santhanaraj5863
@santhanaraj5863 Год назад
Patriots please share this everywhere!! We must save the UK!! The UK needs you!! Godfrey Bloom was right all along!!
@englishpayerofgermantaxes8186
@englishpayerofgermantaxes8186 4 года назад
I don't understand for the life of me, why any native British people think that we should have any immigration at all. A few people from neighbouring countries maybe, who don't need to become citizens, or have the rights of citizens, could live in Britain, so that free trade could be assisted. Why would we even be interested in hearing the opinions of a "fellow English person" about nationality and nation. In a proper market economy any labour shortages would automatically be compensated for by changes in relative wages. The people most interested in opening Britain or any other successful nation to mass immigration, are those who are very often immigrants themselves, who only see our countries as "economic spaces" to be consumed and abused as they think fit. 99% of British people don't benefit at all from immigration, unless you think it so important to have Indian or Chinese restaurants. Even these could be offered by entrepreneurial Brits. Throughout history only defeated peoples allowed their countries to be settled by people from other cultures. What has already happened only makes sense if you consider the politicians as stooges of foreign industrial and banking interests.
@oisindayo
@oisindayo 10 лет назад
I idolise this man.
@jimhump3575
@jimhump3575 4 года назад
NOT, HE RIGHT, AND IAM BLACK, BECAUSE MANY FORMOR COLONIAL COUNTRIES, GOT INDEOPENDANCE, BUT HET THEY ALL WANT TO COME LIVE IN WHITE COUNTRIES, HOW ABOUT THAT, I SAY BUILD YA OWN HOMELAND, PERIOD
@chrismassey1960
@chrismassey1960 6 лет назад
Can’t wait to view this, I love Godfrey Bloom. He talks sense!
@Opa_Joke
@Opa_Joke Год назад
We can't do crap about it because of the leftist politics who are usefull idiots for these corrupt governments.
@aaronwalderslade
@aaronwalderslade 4 года назад
It is unfair to allow immigration from countries so poor that living three to a room and earning 300 pounds a week is a wet dream to those people. It means ultimately that British workers would have to suffer the same conditions in order to compete. I am sick of hearing about how Polish people do the jobs we are not willing to do. Their money goes FIVE times as far in Poland. Imagine if you could work in an open door county for five times the wage. You'd also be willing to live three to a room for five years, save up, move back home and buy a house. AND YOU'D DO IT. I don't in any way blame the Poles themselves. They absolutely are doing the right thing under the circumstances, for themselves and for their families. But when this country IS your home, that option of buying a house in Poland is not available and so you cannot compete. Immigration has fucked the working classes up the arse. I'm the son of an immigrant and have a posh background. But by God I have the consideration to have the highest respect for the working class, and I have no respect for anyone who does not appreciate how hard they work.
@anonymoust2877
@anonymoust2877 3 года назад
@@EresirThe1st Africans do have respect for the culture wtf?
@govananglesey5265
@govananglesey5265 7 лет назад
Economic and on a cultural level too much can damage the pattern of a more desired higher form of society.
@ivandegrisogono3334
@ivandegrisogono3334 4 года назад
Excellent speech, valid arguments! Enoch Powells prophecy is becoming truth and everybody must know und realize the facts!
@motanelustelistu
@motanelustelistu 4 года назад
Wich is that profecy ? I THINK i heard about him,but i have no ideea from where and what he said.
@carolwood9930
@carolwood9930 Год назад
Ye you are so right about Enoch .
@carolwood9930
@carolwood9930 Год назад
Yes he was so right Parliment would not listen .
@threecatsteve
@threecatsteve 6 лет назад
Also true for the USA
@moeothman1987
@moeothman1987 2 года назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣 everybody is immigrant in the US- the country was established by immigrants ffs
@ggggg77273
@ggggg77273 Год назад
@@moeothman1987 are you brain-dead or are you just pretending to be stupid?
@peterj.f.blackwood-davis7840
@peterj.f.blackwood-davis7840 4 года назад
Allow immigration when everyone here has a job, housing,...and our health services and schools are not burgeoning with vagrants and benefit moochers arriving here from everywhere on earth with outstreached hands.!
@frowin001
@frowin001 8 лет назад
Imigration should be a purely moral matter. And in this Situation you find all answers needed for yourself.
@dianegoymer7601
@dianegoymer7601 5 лет назад
Great speech, so right!
@honeybunch6473
@honeybunch6473 Год назад
"We are just full" - and have a responsibility towards existing tax payers. 131 000 British children homeless today - a 10% increase from last year. But when will the politicians stop blocking attempts to change it?
@FarhanAmin1994
@FarhanAmin1994 2 года назад
Oh look! My favorite thing about them Oxford debates, the like:dislike ratio is gone from RU-vid. Isn’t that just stellarly awesome? 🙄
@grahamriley8124
@grahamriley8124 2 года назад
Yes, funny that!
@AnInterestedObserver
@AnInterestedObserver Год назад
How right. The thing is, we - anyone with their eyes connected to their brains, know this. Just a cursory knowledge of history shows that immigration by people from alien cultures leads to division and conflict. This is still the case.
@TH-mx5ek
@TH-mx5ek 7 лет назад
brilliant speech.
@tetraquark2402
@tetraquark2402 4 года назад
Ah just seen the date published. I doubt he would be allowed to say that now
@lemoneyesalt5513
@lemoneyesalt5513 10 месяцев назад
Too f****** right, what did you expect to happen Britain
@mallianumula
@mallianumula 4 года назад
I like one thing here is , many of them are youngsters and they are observing lot. that is really good for debates and talks.
@alexhill556
@alexhill556 9 лет назад
This title is misleading
@Maximilian0011
@Maximilian0011 8 лет назад
+Lexie Hill indeed, its is a mislead with Bloom's twist to it, where one does not know what side he stands for, it rather sound like he is backing up both sides of the issue.......
@JS62515
@JS62515 8 лет назад
Agreed. It's not that it's 'bad' it's what is sustainable and good for society as far as real growth and balance.
@heighwaysonthewing
@heighwaysonthewing 5 лет назад
Alex Hill you are so right , it should say silly old mean spirited old bastard with nothing we haven't heard 100 times before . you're right correct.
@etherealcatholic5711
@etherealcatholic5711 4 года назад
The baby boomers are dying. Once they go this type of mentality will die with them.
@nigelblaymires4668
@nigelblaymires4668 4 года назад
Send em back Enoch Powell R I P
@davidhookway514
@davidhookway514 Год назад
9 years ago! Another Few Millions Added!
@honeybunch6473
@honeybunch6473 Год назад
My God it's crazy
@totalpkg6912
@totalpkg6912 6 лет назад
This man is exceptional and my hero
@CasiodorusRex
@CasiodorusRex 5 лет назад
These people would be banned from American Universities.
@bekindandmerciful5145
@bekindandmerciful5145 10 месяцев назад
Can we send Suella/Suellas Mum and Dad and all her family back as a starting point..
@CCDR07
@CCDR07 2 года назад
Yeah, and instead of flippin arguing about this, we should be thoroughly examining how our society is fundamentally creating the reasons that compel people to immigrate! You think people want to risk losing their lives and families drowning in the North Sea because UK social welfare and quality of life is so good? How about the social-political disruption caused in the middle east due to imperialist geo-strategic positioning around oil? How about UK arms manufacturers (4th in the world, last time I checked) that profit from political instability and war in the middle east? Or farm industry multinationals turfing rural farmers off land in India, Indonesia, Africa, or South America? Or mining companies doing the same? etc. etc. And propping the whole thing up? It's us and our consumer behaviour, feeding this beast so we can waste our time and energy obtaining obtaining so much that is unecessary for our happiness, well-being, and distracts us from ourselves and a meaningful life. Where are our politicians and political will to stem these primary drivers of mass immigration in the world? Oh, wait, politician's and the ruling class's bread is buttered by these very same imperial interests... I know, let's convince people it's immigrants to blame...
@RifleEyez
@RifleEyez 3 года назад
I always find it interesting how one of the primary arguments for immigration is bringing skills into the country, yet the argument is never ''why can't we do more for our own citizens so we don't require that crutch to begin with?" Even with working class jobs the white working class British community seems one of the most neglected, and how much potential is wasted there? Feels a bit of a cop out and is essentially saying ''we give up on our own people". I work in a Hospital - so believe me, I see the absolute peak positives of immigration, and have a great working relationships with all my colleagues. Yet I know that isn't the same experience the working class have had with immigration (enclaves where you can go a whole day without interacting with a 'native' Brit/huge demographic shifts in areas over a short space of time, lower educated immigrants/more prone to extremist or outdated beliefs, less likely to want to integrate, less likely to view their host country positively, etc). Despite my own current positive experiences, I still feel the best course of action would be getting the most out of the current population (or would have been, the Rubicon has been crossed already) before allowing others in. It's like decorating your house with flashy appliances while the foundations are crumbling, and expecting it not to topple over. I genuinely believe to get the 'most' out of a country and population some degree of civic nationalism has to occur. When you import elements who treat you as a stepping stone, lack desire to embrace all the quirks and traditions, even at some expense of their own, or frankly don't really care to be here to begin with, that further damages the foundations. Has it all been worth it, considering the tensions from both sides of the fence? I wouldn't be shocked if a biological hard-coded distrust of 'the others' is still prevalent, which causes all of this wasted energy to be expelled on our current PC culture and tensions. Would countries be better off more homogenized, but working together peacefully globally? That would also have a knock on effect of eliminating brain drain, a real problem when your brightest leave, and that's not exclusive to Africa/Middle East etc - even from EU countries like Poland. We see tensions in other regions and the problems that arise (and a lack of fulfilling potential) blamed on the arbitrary drawing of borders, especially by the "imperialist West", mixing various religions, ethnic groups, tribes, etc, yet fail to see the same thing happening in our own countries as having a potential knock on effect. Agreed, it's not a 1:1 analogy, but even so.
@heli0s101
@heli0s101 2 года назад
Work permits have expiry dates, so they can be used as a temporary solution. If your health service is crippled by a lack of staff, you don't have the time to educate a whole generation and direct them towards a market gap. Bring in foreign experts to fill that gap, keep up living standards while the native generation can be trained, then let the work permits expire once there's a surplus of native workers.
@MapleSyrupPoet
@MapleSyrupPoet Год назад
Love ❤ the burgundy jacket Godfrey ...had one similar, in my life time
@ruudklasen8656
@ruudklasen8656 4 года назад
A good man 👍💪
@michaelscales5996
@michaelscales5996 3 года назад
Our tiny island is bursting at the seams,that's the problem with unchecked immigration. We are so short of decent building land we are now having to build on flood plains in order to provide more homes,how daft is that. And don't forget all the extra millions now over here obviously require food and water, and how can we provide that if we keep building over land,that ought to be used for farming and water storage ?
@richardspeed7135
@richardspeed7135 2 года назад
Well said sir
@budte
@budte 3 месяца назад
Indians first went to Uganda to build their railway. When it was finshed they stayed. Then they brought their families and relatives and did not assimilate with the native populous, but instead brought more wives and husbands for their children from India. They introduced business when the Ugandans had mostly been bartering. They worked long hours and began to take over. Idi Amin saw this and ejected them from the country. in 1968 Enoch Powell warned of the same thing, unassimilated migration and high fertility rates. Unlike Idi Amin we took in more and more of everyone and now we are a multicultural catastrophe. I would suggest this country has seen far too much immigration than Godfrey suggests going right back to Windrush.
@berniefynn6623
@berniefynn6623 2 года назад
especially from those countries that are incompatible to us.
@garsm2290
@garsm2290 10 лет назад
His wife is Polish !!!
@mr.zardoz3344
@mr.zardoz3344 5 лет назад
OMG!!!!! 04:45 THEY LOOK SOOOOOOO PISSED OFF!!!!!!
@cfchazard4669
@cfchazard4669 3 года назад
I don’t know nothing about politics but I discovered Godfrey channel at back end of last year. He opened my eyes wilder to this scamdamic very well spoken and easy to grasp tells it like it is. I like this guy true English gent.
@glennhurley7300
@glennhurley7300 4 года назад
Not me, certainly not me
@topskek9786
@topskek9786 3 года назад
Immigration from nice countries is ok lol
@motanelustelistu
@motanelustelistu 5 лет назад
You see,boefore the disasterous WW2,we had,here in my beloved Dacia (first and most important Nation,Nation State,National Identity and Purity,Culture,Civilization,Society,Writings,Alfabet etc) ,filosofie and logic clases since 8th grade. Now you might understand why from 20 MILION people not even 2000 were members or supporters of the FILTHY communist party.Because people had MIND,RATION AND LOGIC to see beyond the MADNESS the communists came up with and the LACK or any arguments against the established state of facts,let alone in support of their brain dead ideas.
@ddjay1363
@ddjay1363 7 лет назад
I do like Godfrey Bloom. He's very outspoken but also very funny.
@chetannanwoke4725
@chetannanwoke4725 5 лет назад
Is it not telling that none of the debaters opposing the motion are English?
@uchennaemenike8699
@uchennaemenike8699 Год назад
If one is not intelligent in advanced economics, mathematics, commerce & some science, history and agriculture, he or she wouldn't make much meaning of all of these!
@markashdown1314
@markashdown1314 Год назад
Rather better than expected.
@m4rios916
@m4rios916 Год назад
Immigration is useful for a country, illegal immigration is an entirely other thing
@Hello_there_obi
@Hello_there_obi 4 года назад
So many people would just dismiss him because all they think is hes just a rich, old, straight white male. Its staggering to me that the same group who sided with martin luther king in the 60s has now done a complete 180 on his words.
@seanmoran6510
@seanmoran6510 2 года назад
1914 was the true disaster I’m just waiting for the fall/crash now. The Last Phase of Empire The fight for and possible collapse of the Core State I’d also say why do so few people not talk about the negative consequences of modernity
@howdyahworkthisthing1520
@howdyahworkthisthing1520 5 лет назад
Not anymore in Canada.
@ShasOSwoll
@ShasOSwoll 5 лет назад
Star Trek turned me onto the idea of everyone living together at a very young age Reality turned me off after the first dozen deaths
@johnstonsteele9751
@johnstonsteele9751 11 месяцев назад
What about the Men in Boats 50 thousand of them,No background checks, Get Royal Marines and Royal navy to force them back to France.
@favodeferro2340
@favodeferro2340 4 года назад
Colonialism is worst!
@Replevideo
@Replevideo 6 лет назад
What twaddle. The country is not being concreted over and is not full. Our population density is 600 per square mile and similar to other European countries. The real problem is that many immigrants do not come here to work. Of a certain group. over 50% of men and 80% of women of working age are unemployed. Not only do they not contribute to society, but they also demand we change our laws to the ones in the countries they came from, so they are not here to escape oppression either.
@jimdavis8391
@jimdavis8391 10 лет назад
The argument has nothing to do with economics and everything to do with identity.
@BowlinJosh
@BowlinJosh 6 лет назад
Nonsense.
@booishoois309
@booishoois309 5 лет назад
I would say tackling youth unemployment is an economic challenge. But identity is just as important, if not more. I'm Canadian, and see the exact same symptoms happening here because like Britain, since the war we've based our economy on immigration and even our current PM has been quoted as saying Canada has not identity, and is the first post-national state. Imagine hearing that from the mouth of the leader of your country. How would you feel?
@FEAREDTHANLOVED
@FEAREDTHANLOVED 4 года назад
That lady constantly looks down and away every time the camera pans at her, weird....
@jtk1ify
@jtk1ify 4 года назад
we do not need to scrap the welfare state to control immigration. we need to control immigration by need of skills and we need a much closer link between business and education to ensure they harmonise so that we train british people to have the skills for our future. a free roaming market force economy, especially without a welfare safety net is a dangerous ideology and has existed before in our country until after the second world war when the free marketeers the likes of GBloom realised if they did not agree to a more social society they might have a society that would rebel against them,
@jonwood6900
@jonwood6900 3 года назад
So the solution is to dissolve welfare then. Any true libertarian would see that the issue should be to destroy the insensitive for those to move here to take advantage of the welfare state. This isn't just labours issue from the nineties this is a perpetual issue of trying to blend socialist and capitalist policies, we keep immigration open in order to increase growth and the consumer base, but we also give these immigrants the benefit of social welfare, it's fundamentally a contradiction of policy. Perpetual immigration wouldn't matter or be a issue to many people if it simply wasn't for the deficit that is created by having an open door policy. End the socialist experiment and the immigration problem will evaporate.
@kihuntekimossa4643
@kihuntekimossa4643 7 лет назад
Bongo Land is a proud country in Africa, in other Well known name it is called Tanzania.
@sherlockwatson5942
@sherlockwatson5942 9 лет назад
no borders, let your people go.
@petergreen2552
@petergreen2552 3 года назад
He's never been the same since they cancelled one foot in the grave
@h7283
@h7283 3 года назад
What one feet on the grave?
@shodanxx
@shodanxx 10 лет назад
So this speaker says the motion is "We've had too much immigration since the war" while the youtube title of this video is "Immigration is Bad For Britain". Make up your mind +OxfordUnion which is it ? (And while you're at it, when you have guest speaker with question period, how about you report the questions verbatim humm???)
@mastrammeena328
@mastrammeena328 2 года назад
I am Indian and I feel that immigrants should not make more than 1% of the population Don't let your culture be destroyed
@nickohira1397
@nickohira1397 Год назад
Thank you for understanding
@TheMightyTed
@TheMightyTed 10 лет назад
HAHAHA I go to that university in the Fens.
@jayturner3397
@jayturner3397 Год назад
Oct '22..we are in a mess
@ZimbaZumba
@ZimbaZumba 4 года назад
"..turned dominoes into a spectator sport", that went completely over the head over the audience. Which shows the middle class, and beyond, circles they move in.
@34Packardphaeton
@34Packardphaeton 3 года назад
... This man is correct!
@johnwoods7650
@johnwoods7650 2 года назад
What a pity Enoch Powell couldn't have addressed the Oxford Union with a more thought out argument, but he was relegated to the fringes of politics by Edward Heath and the holier than thou brigade.
Далее
EU Debate | Nigel Farage MEP | Opposition
15:46
Просмотров 883 тыс.
Immigration Is Good For Britain | Nadhim Zahawi
7:46
Debate: We Were Right to Brexit
1:27:10
Просмотров 205 тыс.
The Great European Refugees and Migrants Debate
1:23:18
The trouble with this country is the Daily Mail
1:32:58
Ben Shapiro | Cambridge Union
1:11:39
Просмотров 1,2 млн