Yogi gave a list of around 35 people, all rejected and replaced with his own people by Amit Shah. BJP is short of around 30 for simple majority. Numbers would’ve met if not for shahs insecurity to be pm
Shivam is living under the stone! The regional media (specially Maharashtra), the people were clearly pissed of the BJP. The mandate was clear that the BJP will have tough time going forward. Print media in India is living under the rock and have their heads in the sand. Lallantop, Samdish, etc. did a great job and connnected with the reql people of the gao-dehat. People of Gao-dehat are smart and their votes are powerful. Good job India keeping the BJP is check.
BJP lost only 1.4 percent votes overall The senior politicians in the BJP became arrogant eg none of the 30 favourite candidates of yogi adityanaath were not given ticket The whole opposition United But still the NDA has 303 seats and support so nothing is changing. At the end of the day, this is the best result BJP would have got- no defeat, a mirror to the senior management, and time to recover without any defeat.
People say South india, south india In reality out of 4 southern states One has BJP as the only opposition and strong too. Another has nda alliance with the BJP as the ruling party In Kerala BJP opened its account for the very first time In Tamilnadu BJP vote share is and has been increasing consistently around 15 to 19 percent
@@naresh2973 in up, there was around 56 percent voting around the same percent less voting as u claim BJP lost same in Rajasthan. Given that the wave was weak this time, directly implying low voter turnout, u at least have very less reason to celebrate
I don't understand why some people say this. Both Congress and BJP are political parties. Then why democracy dies when BJP wins and Democracy lives/wins when Congress wins?
Because with Congress and TMC Muslims get extra constitutional powers and the whole ecosystem is built in and out of India to cater to this section only and not the truth ... Truth is despite the anti-muslim rhetoric BJP someone use to get Hindu votes the policy and action of bjp government is completely secular... On the other hand despite all the secular rhetoric Congress and other sick party uses they all sacrifice Hindu's life for the appeasement of Muslim vote, there are numerous ex of that. Like waqf board act ,waqf property act and all other bullsh*t...
1 Because bjp was now a days started over exercising of power means trying to crush opposition. Horse trading , Ed , cbi not against them who join bjp leaving congress 2 biggest thing using Muslim word in every election basically creating polarization in the society and that is not good for social harmony of the country
Hey Shehzad. Please know that a large number of your Indian viewers are also Modi supporters because nothing gets them harder than Pakistani commentators saying how great India is. Therefore, please take the feedback with a cup of salt.
Indian Yt Media space is very vibrant across Indian languages. Noida channels bakwas hai, even my BJP supporter uncle relatives say that. Ambani ko koi bhi gaali do, but the Jio Revolution is something I'm thankful as an Indian.
" BJP lost in Maharashtra because of Caste factor" .. He is joking..his knowledge about Maharashtra politics is Zilch.. BJP lost in Maharashtra because of the mess it created by dividing Shiv Sena and NCP , which people of Maharashtra did not take lying down..
@@orangeman2456he does it also for thousands of his critiques on Twitter in the name of "abuse"....but yeah I am Pakistani and he is one of the voices here who I can agree with mostly.....
What's the big deal. Even I, a tuluva from southwest India , follow state elections of the Hindi belt; although this Pakistani probably feels more connected to Hindi guys than I do. Akhand Bharat, remember?
This is the first time, i am hearing about this guy and you're saying that he is a well-known Indian Political Analyst. OMG! Why don't you take Abhijit Iyer Mitra or Sushant Sarren like that?
@@user-rh5jp2sh4sokay ho Gaya you are happy by saying bjp it cell 😂 or agar bjp jaha sahi ho waha use sahi kahna or support karna it cell h to yaad rakhna ki hum india ke aadhe se jyada log proud bjp it cell hai tu kis kis ko bolega 😏
@user-il2xx2ug6n Well why a watch and comment on a channel called the Pakistan experience in the first place if you have such opinions... hope atleast they compensate you for your "work"..
kisko bula liya kuch pata nahi hai esko....BJP supporter got overconfident on 400 par... Jab majourity aa hi rahi hai to thoda lazy ho gaye... Next baar mein pata chal jayega.
About Manipur, it borders with Myanmar and Myanmar is suffering from a Civil War and that has resulted in the incoming of Northern Myanmar people into Manipur and that has led to this chaos in the state.
Andhbhakt: Ladakh is chinese conspiracy Andhbhakt: wrestlers protest is political conspiracy Andhbhakt: manipur isnt BJPs is fault its border issue Andhbhakt: farmers protest is khalistani
india dont need peple like dhruvv rathe who targets only single party and doesnt even speak about other parties.we need people like nitish rajput who slams every party.
Bjp did good except in UP. Bjp lost in UP because of false propaganda by Congress like 1 lakh rupees in women, constitution change and reservation removal. This Congress propaganda did not affect other states like mp, gujrat odisa Bihar asom Telangana Andhra Pradesh etc.
Why your indian guests are always left leaning ideologues? Are you afraid to engage with any other ideologues. Is it problamitic for your safety in Pakistan ❓❓❓
Although I feel shezhad is unbiased to an extent, when it comes to his Indian guests are all left leaning extremists, to balance it out he should invite someone from right or even a centrist. However I don't think that will happen, as thy say birds of feathers flock together.
It's is funny🤦🏻♂️ when he has Pakistani guests of a more Liberal/Left bend who criticize the military establishment. Some are happy. But the very same people get worked up when he invites Indians of a more liberal mindset...
20:20 Rahul Gandhi as Forest Gump. Brilliant! And no the Bharat Yatra the first one helped the next 2 were Why. The master stroke was the SP alliance and their showing in Maharashtra where Rahul barely campaigned. So he is a nice guy who is likeable but as the leader of the Congress, crap.
One of the main reasons Maulana Modi didn't get majority is that he and his party has become quite anti-Hindu. Appeased all kind of wrong communitities but want vote of Hindus.
@@junaid_2107 Jane ki zaroorat nahi. Pakistan is a temporary arrangement, will be dismantled before 2047. Mujeet, prepare to move out, there's enough time and lot of countries around the world to move to.
@@NidzShah-ps6kr Primarily muslims, but also Dalits. Additionally extreme ideologes of Dravidians in Tamil Nadu, and Khalistanis in Punjab. Each of these visible simiping attemps in public kept pushing away their supporters. If they don't learn their lessons now- which they won't- there's enough critical mass to push for a legit far right Hindu party now.
Only bjp created the image of Rahul Gandhi as weak and non serious.He was abused by everyone and he never talked without ji for the bjp leaders.Actually Rahul Gandhi is not badtameez.
The Pakistan factor in this election? Zero. Basically Modi has 2 great campaigners. RG and the ISI. This time the ISI decided not to campaign for Modi.
After listening to Shivam Vij's opinions/observations or answers I am not very sure that he has comprehensive knowledge over the subjects that are being discussed, he only seems to have half a sense, please maintain the quality of guests at the podcast, regards.
@@dhruvilkumpavat6037 True, Kerala and Odisha are also coastal states but the have not seen the kind of boom that Gujarat saw. Coast helps for exports but you also need Infra and Policy. TATA was building a plant in Bengal (coastal state) but after riots they moved to Gujarat because the Government was business friendly.
@@logiclogiclogicOn average Coastal states have a big advantage over landlocked states. Kerala has best HDI in country. Kisko chutiya bana raha hai bhakt..🤣
Oblivious of reality u are. BJP clean swept 4 states with 100% strike rate. 5 states with 98-99%. State assembly elections were also won by BJP and they formed state governments in 4 more states. There were some losses. But overall it was a great performance even after incumbency of 10years. Further, workers of BJP went complacent so there were some losses indeed
Shivam - please speak in one language. This 60% English and 40% Urdu/Hindi. And spare us the silencing of liberal media trope. The popular ones are fine. The congress simp media lacks popularity. So stop overplaying the persecution angle
Hey shehzad no hate i like ur work and i listen to ur podcast but i do want to request u to bring someone from the right for instance kushal mehra or abhijeet iyer mitra to have a political kinda debate and a healthy conversation which would be much more interesting. Please🙏
Shivam vij is getting legitimacy while the Pakistani podcaster is earning money. Vij is as relevant in India as Pakistan in world affairs. India with its Hindu majority populace will keep growing. And we will resist Hinduphobia.
He wasnt bad like Dhruv. Like he said perfectly abt evms and democracy, but I lost it when he couldnt admit In Gujarat it was the govt who brought the reforms and not just that we are coastal state
BHARATVA has won. The Indian narrative won. BHARATVA believes in inclusive democratic system of governance. While reactionary and nativist forces are on the rise all over the world, India what is BHARAT has shown the world that collective wisdom and will can lead humanity.
Correction, it was not Indian Media, it was (G/M)odi Media. There were independent analysts who had predicted this result; however, it was limited to the world outside the clamoursly calimunous (G/M)odi Media. Yours truly was one of the guys who had predicted this result and pasted it in your one of the podcasts 3 weeks ago almost.
@ThePakistanExperience It's funny to see how active the BJP IT cell is in the comment section 🤦🏻♂️. They seem to be really taken a back ... or are just desperate...
I think that journalists on RU-vid like Ravish Kumar and Ajit Anjum and influencers like Dhruv Rathee made quite an impact on public opinion in the Hindi-speaking states since, I presume, a lot of people get their news on their mobile phones and not from satellite tv, particularly in rural areas. Neither of you mentioned the Supreme Court judgement on electoral bonds shortly before the elections which took the BJP by surprise and was the first big scandal that the government could be attacked for weeks at a stretch. The conspiracy theories about the election process started when the the government passed the law that would decide how the election commissioners would be chosen. And then the partisan conduct of the election commissioners during the campaigning and initial phases of voting reinforced the suspicions. The chief election commissioner admitted at the press conference at the end of the elections that they decided not to take any action against the top two leaders of the BJP and Congress. This allowed the PM and Amit Shah to indulge in hate speech and bigotry to their hearts’ content without any consequences.
He might be neutral but he failed to point out lot of ground issues specially in states like Maharashtra where it's not caste but the mess BJP created by dividing sena congress
They won because 26 of the parties got together against the single mammoth called BJP.Not because of Bharat joro yatra. West Bengal as always rigged 😂 DMK always distancing the voters from mainstream parties via Dravidian sub culture Imagine if Rahul again started giving interviews Rahul has yet to prove himself as a hard working politicians Becoming a statesman is a far off thing for him and pinky
17:59 - what the heck was this? 😅 He blames Shehzad for the terror attack and making Modi win in 2019. And doesn't even take his words back. I thought Shivam came across as a bit cold in this podcast till this point, and this sort of reaffirms it.
I've been seeing this podcast for almost about 2 years now and it never disappoints me. I think I really want this guy as a mentor if he'll have me. Shehzad bhai, I'll send my details right away just give me a thumbs up😄😄. Fondly from South Waziristan!
40:42 Congress (INDIA) was assured of Muslim vote while BJP had to hope Hindu vote consolidates. Muslims vote non-BJP Hindu if that's the only way. Where there's a Muslim candidate that's preferred over Hindu (Barhampur, West Bengal). In other words, Hindus will rescue secularism while Muslims can play by the secularism bandwagon till a more credible option emerges.
Behrampur adhir lost because his hindu vote got transferred to bjp Tmc vote also came down at Behrampur And i dont think bjp got muslims votes from adhir
TPE always gets left leaning people from India on its podcast. I suggest that you get folks like Kushal Mehra (Charvaka podcast), Abhijit Aiyar Mitra, Ajeet Bharti etc. on your show.
Rahul gandhi didn't actually won, it was just local politics and caste card played by rahul gandhi, i mean how bad it is for our country that a person who used caste politics increased his seats. And bjp who was telling people to look beyond caste lost few seats. So it is the caste euphoria that won, rahul gandhi is still a pappu cause he hardly know anything about governance.
And bjp uses religion plus caste , 50% ministries are given to upper caste and no muslims in ministry And who does jat vs non jat in haryana , non yadav bc vs yadav in up , vokaligga and lingayat in Karnataka 😂😂
He seems so delusional. Bhai BJP spent 100 times more money on campaigns. They used all the power of government agencies and mainstream media. The opposition had to have a lot of impact to be able to beat that and stop bjp from winning the majority. They froze Congress bank account for example. Additionally, in UP alliance would have won at least 16 more seats, had BSP not cut votes. Kya journalist banega re tu😂. Pehle confirmation biases door kr bhai. Jokes apart, I actually agree with a lot of what he's saying too. Just this point that the opposition didn't make much impact is a little unfair in my opinion. p.s. I'm commenting after watching half of theinterview, maybe he talks about it after that. Couldn't stop myself
Agree with his overall analysis, although I do think he is underestimating the role of Dalits and people belonging to other backward castes from all religious backgrounds in turning the tide against Modi.. Also @53.00, if I may, I would like to address this oft-repeated false equivalence made by many progressive public voices in Pakistan when comparing both the political parties and voters of India and Pakistan respectively, thus advertently or inadvertently claiming a higher moral ground,where none exists ,by saying a) that Pakistani political parties hardly use any anti-India rhetoric in their speeches unlike their Indian counterparts b) that Pakistani voters have never brought a religious right wing party to power unlike Indians with the BJP. Lets address the first claim. Have we not heard slogans of "Modi ka jo yaar hai, gaddaar hai" in the recent past, not just from the extremely right wing PTI , but also from the so-called progressive PPP's Bilawal Bhutto against Nawaz Sharif who ironically had taken a very similar anti India stand to discredit B.B in the 90's. Even someone like Z.A Bhutto who was arguably the most popular leader in the history of West Pakistan had to use anti-India rhetoric all through the 60's to garner support and strengthen his base among Pakistani voters. All this anti India rhetoric from all the major political parties is even more surprising considering the fact that the average Pakistani voter is well aware that no elected government in Pakistan can have any say in matters of National security or foreign policy unlike their Indian counterparts. Also let's be honest, the public sentiment in Pakistan about India cannot be compared with the experience of the Indian people vis a vis Pakistan given that the Indian state does not openly run terrorist camps where proxies are trained to infiltrate the border and carry out heinous acts of terrorism, unlike the Pakistani State which has a long recorded history of using proxies right from the start with the sending of tribesmen to Kashmir (who btw went on a raping and pillaging spree there ) , and from there on graduating to create and nurture terrorist outfits like L-eT, H-uM and J-eM( who have run recruitment drives, training centers and have collected funds in the name of Kashmir jihad in broad day light all over Pakistan for decades), and then aiding and abetting these groups in carrying out terrorist attacks on Indian soil. Nor has the Indian state ever been the aggressor in all of the 3 Indo-Pak wars. And lest we forget, all the major peace overtures from the Indian side were sabotaged by the Pakistani establishment and not the other way around, either by orchestrating terror attacks or by straight up starting a conflict like Kargil. Now let's examine the veracity of the second claim. India is a secular state atleast on paper, whereas Pakistan is a Muslim state with Islam baked into the very idea of Pakistan from its very inception, where Sharia is written and embedded into the Constitution, where a non-Muslim can never hold the highest public office, where a non-Muslim can not even contest elections from an unreserved constituency. In a country like Pakistan where the state has a religion , claiming that no religious party has ever been elected to power is like saying -'Yes, fishes do live in water but they are not wet'. The political parties by the very nature of the polity in which they operate, become religious parties by default, do they not? Would be interesting to know your thoughts on this though. This was a great discussion, nonetheless! Would love to see more Indian journalists on your platform. Please try and get someone like Arfa ji from The Wire, or Faye D'Souza or Yogendra Yadav- who is a political worker and a former psephologist, for a more in-depth understanding of the election results. Cheers!
I've given up on TPE to ever call an unbiased guest from India . Initially I thought it's just coincidence or not being aware but now I know it's by design . Good luck and bye forever .
I have been following your channel for sometime now. Unfortunately, all pakistani channel include Congress related or affiliated "so called experts". Same happens on "the black hole Pakistan". Please also include people from government or govt affiliated, that way you can also have current govt thinking.
it is clear you will always invite congress follower😂shehzaad trust me you will never know the ground reality of indian politics until you invite a real informed guest
@alishaalisha1186 Well, intelligence agencies never share their real assessments irrelevant, which one ISI, RAW, CIA... but it's very telling that the GODI MEDIA got it wrong by a huuuge margin
You have contacted a person who has very little knowledge He is just speaking in English and giving a completely incorrect analysis There are so many journalists You should have done research too How can you present a program on a topic you don’t know
40:40 bhai, kuch bhi bolna hai, Gujrat Muslims are different, but most jagah pe muslims can't vote to BJP even if they want to. BJP tried wooing pasmandas, but BJP got ghanta from them.
@@junaid_2107 bhakt bula ke nikal lo, ghuspethiya to 2nd round ke baad bola tha na, Rampur wale booth pr 500+ ghar lene ke baad bhi 1 vote bhi nhi diya, wo to 2nd round mein hi tha na. even you know ki agar modi tumhare poore khandan ko crore pati bna de, tum nhi doge vote BJP ko
@@AbhineetSingh13 "Babar ki aulad", "Abba Jaan", "Aurangzeb", "Pakistani" toh 2014 se bol raha tere paw paw... Crorepati to usne sirf Adani ko banaya..🤣. Tereko jitna bhi chuna lagaya, naukri dilaye ya na dilaye, tera paisa adani ko dede, but as long as he calls me Babar ki aulaad you will still vote for him.
Shehzad , kya burger pakda hai India se? Superficial reporting and surface political thoughts without a sense of rural India is fatal for journalism . You were asking something, he was more interested in telling k main bhi UP gya tha. If this guy travelled so much then how did Yogendra Yadav get his act together and he didn’t? Shivam has articulation and Opinion page knowledge bilut he seems far from actual pulse of the nation.it started making sense after 25-30 minutes . Lastly, your man thinks that RU-vid is mainstream. He doesn’t understand that in villages TV is still big. Has there been a level playing field , INDIA alliance would have performed lot better. Aise hi nahi Modi ne 50 interview dite TV pe
