@@unknown.m.erahul gadha tweet: Lateral entry is an attack on Dalits, OBCs and Adivasis. BJP’s distorted version of Ram Rajya seeks to destroy the Constitution and snatch reservations from Bahujans.
I am from SC Category, but Reservation doesn't mean compromise on talent at such high level posts, so I am a supporter of lateral entry of field specialist rather than IAS officer with less specialisation in that field 🙏
Lateral entry was good move for country. But Brahmins made the caste system (jati and Varna) with putting themselves on top in hierarchy (first mentioned in rigveda ; 1st Mandala). Our country still paying for their evil Creation. Reservation and everything is all coz of jati and Varna. I remember reading one of famous Indian economists pointing out things which are holding back India economically ; one of them was caste system. 😌😌
Lateral Entry dekhne mein Sahi lag raha hai... Par iski kya guarantee hai ki Sarkar apne logon ko na ghusaaye? Agar yeh itna authentic tha Sarkar ko Cancel kyun karna pada Yeh Decision???
@@cinefile0075 if you really read the whole Rigveda instead of just one verse, your understanding of it would have been entirely different.😅 #find the right Guru, he or she will help you.😊
Palki, you forgot to mention that these posts are only 3 - 5 year contracts. THESE ARE NOT PERMANENT APPOINTMENTS. As such, career bureaucrats do not have to worry about their growth. Additionally, the government saves pension money on these appointments since it does not have to pay them. And with the contracts being extremely short-term, favoritism, nepotism and regime change no longer remain relevant.
@@tpsankaran6750 His extension was approved by SC and did not exceed 5 years (Oct 2018 - Sep 2023)! This also means that the courts would keep the government in check!
Two-term PM, Dr Manmohan Singh himself was a lateral entry in the government during the late Narsimha Rao's tenure. And he is also NOT a SC/ST and OBC. Seems like Mr. Rahul Gandhi is already showing signs of advanced Alzheimer's!
@@avstantra453It's same. But India is more complex and congress doing Reserve caste appeasement and freebie politics all the time. I'm telling u if congress comes to power, I'll leave india and take my brain and taxes somewhere else.
@@Dr.Kraig_RenCongress doing the right thing. Can you name 30 or even 20 people from SC and ST that’s standing in the national level? We’re a country of billions. If your Hinduism didn’t create caste system then we wouldn’t hage quota. Despite India trying to make the Indian balance the lower caste people are still struggling in the hands of upper caste. You can leave India. Bye bye dost.
@@SoorajSuseelan10001when u have caste certificates stating ur caste. How do u think caste system will be abolished? Abolish caste based reservation to end caste system.
I strongly support lateral entry in govt to bring right domain expertise. Also recruitment of 45 outsiders in a system of 7000 IAS, 6000 IPS, etc will not affect negatively any aspect of bureaucracy
1:35 it's such a demeaning comment on ST/SC groups by the opposition leaders, they are literally saying people from ST/SC groups can not become Subject matter expert/ lateral entrants.
Lateral entered personalities should prove them completely perfect, ultra faster and proof their capabilities 1000% for mother India than of UPSC after involvement. It's a serious area with great idea, but a good lateral efficiency can pour into it positive dews.
UPSC only did the recommendation…. It was DoPT, which verifies details and then sends the joining letter…. And lateral entry is now a good scope to let anybody enter the system. It’s going hyper capitalist now. I am leaving this soon to be American hell…….
May be continued equilibrium of both. Abiding by accountability is not enough. It's India where professionalism and guiding by rigid disciplines is not enough. Efficiency Level can determine the blossoming of decisions.
Efficiency, productivity is very low in almost all government institutions except banking, and defence now. It should be performance based incentive in government as well.
Such an excellent coverage on matter. It’s an excellent plan. The whole political spectrum should support. We need to support efforts of government. Nearly everything Government does goes under criticism.
India needs expertise in respective domains. Indian civil service brings common administrators, not equipped with specific domain knowledge. These Prestigious Civil Service is imported from the British which has created new Rajas in our democracy rather than diminishing efficiency. So, subject knowledge is very essential in certain fields where the I AS is failing. Therefore lateral entry is invariably a good step according to me. Even the lateral entries also under take by UPSC and subject experts on merit, I couldn’t find any wrong, in fact it invigorate the efficiency and can easily fix accountqbility.
Can you name some sector where civil servants knowledge expertise in that sector is required while he takes decisions Civil servants are generalists for expertise there are other services like indian engineering services, indian economic services, indian foreign Service if you want expertise in a certain sector there are hundreds of psu which work in specific domains why not depute from them
@@Arpit89to depute them we need lateral entry method. The power of IES and cabinet secretary is not similar. Cabinet secretary is required to make the policy. Fir this you need the knowledge of that field and the knowledge doesn't come from upsc syllabus.
Yeah instead recruit boot lickers from the private sector which we don't even know if they are capable of handling bureaucracy, and also they don't have to disclose to common people how they have been recruited!!
No exam can be assumed as equivalent to challenges faced and competence required in administrative life, no were in a democracy except few post colonial countries there is such an all important , infallible single exam which itself is not followed in a country that introduced it.@@sahanagowda9123
Reservation is slowly hollowing our system. We have dumb people becoming bureaucrats, doctors, engineers, and teachers. In the name of social justice reservation has contined for years beyond the framers of out constitution intended (10yrs). I saw the cut off for post of hindi teacher at govt school, ST 12/100 General 85/100. Now imagine the quality of teaching where this ST teacher is posted. Same goes with our reserved category doctors they r playing with our lives.
Isn't upsc all about choosing the best employees. There is nothing wrong with lateral entry. its Better to pick an individual with professional expertise than a person who study about national park and Laxmikant polity.
The shade😂. UPSC recruitment syllabus is the most outdated one ngl. Times have changed now and they are still stuck on national parks and ratta Maro system
@@Sundream_65Id say the most outdated syllabus is JEE and before you question me as you definitely will(I am going to IIT roorkee mechanical this year )
@@SoorajSuseelan10001 if everyone are equal before law, then why reservation? How can reservation and equality go hand in hand? Someone with 40% can get a job even if coming from educated and rich family just because their caste is included in reservation. Others with 90% score can't get job even if coming from poor family because they don't belong to reserved category. Which equality are you talking about?
@@SoorajSuseelan10001dude its never about caste system it about CASTE BASED DISCRIMINATION. Caste system will exist because y hold govt certificate stating ur caste. Whereas caste based discrimination is nonexistent. Have u ever faced discrimination based on ur caste. I am 100% sure no.
@@SoorajSuseelan10001 What is the use of SC-ST act? How many times you use it ? When will you learn hard work? How long will you keep taking jobs by showing caste certificate?
One of my friend moved to India from Singapore he worked in PMO and handled the best Metro system in the world while IAS officers learn on Job this guys bring experience from the best. He had no political connection and he sacrifice his career to serve for the Nation. Such individuals should be brought in
bureaucrats should only be limited to governing or administrative roles, subject matter experts/lateral entrants should be allotted the work of planning. The advantage of hiring subject matter experts for certain roles (like in planning etc) is they can be fired for not performing in their job so they'll be obliged to perform to keep their job, and the government would fire them for not performing because they will be directly appointed by the government and any government needs to show work otherwise people won't vote for them, Whereas bureaucrats don't get fired for non performance, they only get transferred to other departments or places, it doesn't matter which party forms the government the bureaucrats always remain in power.
In this context the view of the chairman of the 2nd central administrative commission about present civil service system is relevant. In the 10th report tittled Refurbishing of personnel administration scaling new heights, the chairman had said in preface page v that" That is why the civil service has to change.But not in the Incrementalist manner that barely touches the basic structure. It has to be a total change, a thorough transformation, a metamorphosis" But nothing happened and will not happen also. The above report is available in the site of dept of personnel govt of india
Reservations are based on a fair distribution of the pie. But making the pie needs domain competence. Bureaucracies nourish (incompetent) pie eaters, who contribute little, while eating a lot. (Compare ISRO vs DRDO)
If the recruitment process of UPSC does not happen with SOPs strictly implemented, probably lateral entry will dominate, also to handle certain issues people need expert Experience rather than general administrator. Lateral entry is the source for such requirements.
Bureaucracy does not want outsiders who are better than them. But Outsiders should be appointed by committee of UPSC with LoP, one from Cabinet ministers and CJI with advise of President.
Lateral entry for bringing expertise in different fields to our system is definitely a great idea. We should not bring in reservations at such senior level as it will hamper the growth of our country.
Needs a total overhaul of the bureaucratic system, and in fact every government organization. There should be no job security, the concept of permanent employment. Hence layoff of worst performing 10% should be enforced. There should be performance evaluation. There should be an agency that actively monitors corruption in such institutions. IPS and IAS should have body cams on them so that their actions can be scrutinized. Till this happens we are going to continue to suffer a corrupt system. Because of the fact that none of these measures are in place, these government jobs have become highly lucrative money making instruments. Instead people should be forced to think twice before taking up government jobs. Only then honest people, who really want to contribute towards progress will take up government positions.
Junior IAS officers really do not understand many pressing problems at ground level. The proposed lateral entry is not new to GOIs present and previous ones.Meritorious candidates with ground knowledge do contribute lot more, no denial.
Palki missed one major point - the lateral entry is 3 year contract role. They are not equivalent of IAS officer.. they are asked to leave after 5 years at max. And they are hired for specific projects or initiatives. Once that is over, govt disbands position. A telecom specialist cannot be transferred to Revenue dept. There is no comncept of transfer for this role. Lot of misinformation was spread by Congress for political mileage.
Why no exam and transpareny in selection process ? . For eg ,kal ko Ambani k company Wale kisi ko Petroleum Secretary bana dega , ,to fir Zahir hai ki iska sara decision will favour Ambani. . . . Bringing Lateral entry from corporates , , These people will just favour the corporate they are from in their respective departments . . . . Latest eg , SEBI chief and Hindenberg Report .so who will check that ?
Madhabi Puri Buch - Sebi, Pradeep Kumar Joshi - Nta are a few examples of lateral entry. To my understanding, lateral entries are the best fit when government has an hidden agenda. Punya Prasoon Vajpayee has a different say over this :- ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-MrrdAfy-H5A.htmlsi=DomGhnLlvCLPs2ig
Meanwhile the "Hidden" agenda is--India's NSE has overtaken HKSE to become World's 4th Largest Stock Market with Market Cap of $ 5.5 Trillion USD from 11th Position in 2014, BSE is currently the World's 7th Largest Stock Market from 12th in 2014 and PSUs Market cap has risen from ₹ 8 Lakh Crores to ₹ 20 Lakh Crores from 2014 to 2024 with Rising Transparency, Privatisation, Corporatisation etc Government has Digitalized India on a Scale The world has never seen which not only reduced Corruption,But increased Tax Base & Collections without raising rates,Formalised Economy etc And helped Lakhs of Startups and Entrepreneurs
Meanwhile the "Hidden" agenda is--India's NSE has overtaken HKSE to become World's 4th Largest Stock Market with Market Cap of $ 5.5 Trillion USD from 11th Position in 2014, BSE is currently the World's 7th Largest Stock Market from 12th in 2014 and PSUs Market cap has risen from ₹ 8 Lakh Crores to ₹ 20 Lakh Crores from 2014 to 2024 with Rising Transparency, Privatisation, Corporatisation etc Government has Digitalized India on a Scale The world has never seen which not only reduced Corruption,But increased Tax Base & Collections without raising rates,Formalised Economy etc And helped Lakhs of Startups and Entrepreneurs
Meanwhile the "Hidden" agenda is--India's NSE has overtaken HKSE to become World's 4th Largest Stock Market with Market Cap of $ 5.5 Trillion USD from 11th Position in 2014, BSE is currently the World's 7th Largest Stock Market from 12th in 2014 and PSUs Market cap has risen from ₹ 8 Lakh Crores to ₹ 20 Lakh Crores from 2014 to 2024 with Rising Transparency, Privatisation, Corporatisation etc Government has Digitalized India on a Scale The world has never seen which not only reduced Corruption,But increased Tax Base & Collections without raising rates,Formalised Economy etc And helped Lakhs of Startups and Entrepreneurs
Meanwhile the "Hidden" agenda is--India's NSE has overtaken HKSE to become World's 4th Largest Stock Market with Market Cap of $ 5.5 Trillion USD from 11th Position in 2014, BSE is currently the World's 7th Largest Stock Market from 12th in 2014 and PSUs Market cap has risen from ₹ 8 Lakh Crores to ₹ 20 Lakh Crores from 2014 to 2024 with Rising Transparency, Privatisation, Corporatisation etc Government has Digitalized India on a Scale The world has never seen which not only reduced Corruption,But increased Tax Base & Collections without raising rates,Formalised Economy etc And helped Lakhs of Startups and Entrepreneurs
These carrier bureaucrats dont know how comman man is affected by their decisions. They are a privileged class right from their young age. Ie. They are a collector or an under secretary from the age of 25 or 28. They have never stood in a queue since then and they dont understand the cost of compliance before signing on a circular. We need people from the industry in these committees.
Why technocrats are not appreciated in India, someone who work hard to excel in its domain, why only IAS/Civil servants should hold high post, where they have limited knowledge.. I think it’s time we change the bureaucrats system of India.. domain experts should be given importance .. reservation could be work out here aw well
I think the first requirement of any responsible position involved in decission making in running our government is they should have the necessary knowledge * skills * attitude to serve our country . If those people lack in any one of these traits, our country will suffer! Sometimes I just think the amount of resources like money , people , our government is controlling. To utilise it efficiently we need efficient & comitted people to serve our country! In my humble opinion, Atleast in those positions, we should give politics or caste based reservation the 2nd priority. We can take some examples from our defence establishments . I think they have the right training , attitude to serve our country irrespective of the political leadership on which our country has shown faith to lead our country. May be we can find some good commited people from our defence services, as well,if they have those exposure to the specific fields ! 🙏
IAS and other UPSC officers are thinking that the country is running and surviving only due to them and their talents, intelligence, brain, knowledge,, skills and expertise .
Reservation cannot help one become educated. Education is self earned. Reservation to all resources must be given to down-trodden like monthly Rs.7000 per family, subsidized electricity, vouchers for school fees etc and only in certain backward districts. Today many scheduled caste people are millionaires but still get benefits. It can be stopped and given to struggling folks from same community
Who is Raguram Rajan When he took charge in RBI??Anybody question??Even now many state Govts have NRIS and foriegn people in their financial decision making forums for huge salary what for nobody knows
Both cons are can rectified with strong norms, rules and regulations ..... Second cons are done by adjustment .... But do you think all selected IAS and IPS officers give their 50% or above efforts... no ... 40% of UPSC selected officers corrupt and doesn't give justification for there jobs ....
I welcome this idea.. it would help shitty govt bureaucrats to change perception and leave their laziness behind.. private sector employees are polishes and experienced.. they have a wider view and knowledge.. they can bring better change and efficiency into inefficient govt sector.. hopefully it is transparent and merit based.. no reservation and quota system plz..
Yesssss... There are many GEMS in private sector with amazing Track record bit we can't bring them in & gave them a proper post because law doesn't allow that. I am also ST(Gond Tribe) I FULLY support this law. This isn't Anti-Reservation but something our country really need. Besides, I don't like reservation, I prefer govt. would provide free education, scholarship and incentive rather than directly reserving seats, but that wouldn't happen Congress won't let it happen because the moment Caste-oriented politics ends Congress will never come into power because No one will buy their liberal Crap, other competitors of BJP will emerge from Central or True Right wing.
Lateral entry can be unfair to existing government employees who have worked hard to rise through the ranks. It can also lead to a lack of understanding of government processes and procedures. Additionally, outsiders may not be familiar with the complexities of government work. This can lead to poor decision-making and mistakes... 😠😡
Not only bureaucracy indias police needs outsiders, courts needs outsiders, politicians needs outsiders bcoz majority of born here are not doing their job properly
Be it UPA (INDIA) or NDA ... Transparency is big issue in all fields nowadays. This will lead a biased state. Where some people will be badly impacted or others will be benefitted. Even the recent elections were not so transparent and being questioned. Elections happened electronicaly and in phased manner so each phase results could be published. And when in the first phase result BJP was losing, ECI stopped publishing results, so no one could see whats happening and finally BJP got the win. Now we see huge difference in polling numbers. This happened because ECI is highly influenced with the BJP. Also, if we see agencies, we find that most of the agencies are headed by Govt favored people. Govt has taken up as sole responsibility to appoint the higher designations in each deptt or are major influencer. So lateral entry will also be such case where only those people will be appointed who favors the ruling party and system will start working for only few people and not for the country. This is surely going to haapen. Only the journalists can bring the change by showing - 1) the people who were appointed laterally, what was their political affiliation 2) the analysis of all the work promised and delivered by Govt and what is the current situation of that project 3) How many cases have been started and what is their current status, if the accused were penalised or projected 4) how many changes have been made to law which were not announced or not being made public 5) land distribution that has happened and are being given to big businessmen hampering the environment 6) Policies which ruined the persona of the nature and causing or will cause disaster 7) instead of praising the ruling party (NDA or UPA), media should bring the real scenario in the public 8) how the tax money is being used. what is status of all public properties, hospitals, roads, safety, education etc 9) govt teachers are not visiting the schools but are being paid. this is leading to shut down or merger or privatisation of govt schools. the poors will not be able to get education in few years 10) so many schemes are out every year but the ground reality doesn't change. 11) roads are still mostly broken, but no one is held responsible to complete. its a list of unending questions ...
Its a great initiative in nation building unfortunately marred by the idiotic vite bank pleasing tactics of the opposition, inturn bring a roadblock in national development
The question is that do private sector CEO's and skilled executives needs it ???? Salary is low even advocates of reliance has more payscale and salaries 😅
Firstpost adding a whole 1.5 minutes of footer self advertisement is irritating. You dont need that. We know the quality you deliver. You are making me touch my phone to skip it.
