It’s the fact that everything that came before this scene was set ip perfectly to make you completely believe that not docking that ship will be the end of humanity, no avengers movie made me feel what this scene made me feel.
This was an experience I'll never forget. I went with a couple of my closest friends, all film and music fans. We were sat about 10 rows back. To have Chris Nolan, Michael Caine, Kip Thorne, Hans Zimmer and Brian Cox discussing the movie prior to the performance was incredible. Oh, and Stephen Hawking! And then Roger Sayer and Hans performing with the orchestra, such an epic experience. Feeling the thrum of that organ through your body as that scene played out, then when the strings come in at such volume... sheer electricity.
@@maxmustermann3476 my recollection is that this was the only time it happened, but the applause and ovation for Roger Sayers, Hans and the orchestra at the end was pretty epic.
My local IMAX brought their 70mm print out last month for 4 screenings. I went twice. Total 8 times now. So loud, so big, one of the best movie experiences.
Christopher Nolan: hey Neil what’s the most boring thing about space Neil degrasse Tyson: uh idk docking Christopher: let’s make it the most interesting Hans Zimmer: I’ll help
Everytime I listen to No Time For Caution, it feels like i was a part of something big for humankind, it just feels like I did something that makes myself proud
One of my favorite parts about this scene is you can literally see Cooper's thought process through his facial expressions. You can see the moment he recognizes that without that ship, they're dead. He notices that it's spinning in axis to the bottom docking port and that if they're going to make it out alive, he needs to dock to it.
Something a lot of movie makers need to learn as well as shows and books. So many shove everything in our faces, but as a writer myself my favorite concept is "show us, don't tell us." This movie is fantastic at conveying thoughts through expression.
this is one of the main reasons theatres shouldn’t go out of business or be put to the side because of moments like these that can’t be replicated/made at home. legendary. started tearing up a little and getting goosebumps just by the energy.
That must have been an incredible experience for those that were there. Much respect for Roger Sayer too, the guy sat there doing the hard work at the organ. Just amazing.
God, I remember being there during this. Whilst the film had its flaws, the score was just impeccable. And hearing it performed live - especially by that massive organ - it was something else. I'll never forget it.
Hanz Zimmer and Christopher Nolan are the best duo in cinema. This is the best scene ever made, when you watch for the first time you feel that pressure, you feel like you it was you!
Pretty amazing! Such presence in that sound. I bet it shook the hall. Is it just me or is the music lagging about a second compared to the movie projection? I guess it's pretty hard to sync it perfectly when performed live
+AuroraDarkStar It certainly did shake the hall! very loud during rehearsals in the afternoon. I don't remember it lagging during the performance itself... might just be me though...
What. to not sit there afterthe final scene and be left wondering who we really are and what IS the true meaning of life? So no one got to witness you still sitting in your seat 5 minutes later damn near drooling at the thought of what you had just seen? To continue asking yourself and then looking up to the sky as you drive home? Yeah.
RawBin kells well it definitely should be. First day first show. Waited for almost 3 hrs in d queue. Watched it in imax and still I hvnt forgotten the feeling it had given me back then. I simply couldn’t take this movie outta my head for weeks.
Sam Galea no its not. It means your film is going for spectical and not good storytelling. Its going for beauty but not world building. Yes it makes for some good movies, but it has a large chance of failure
@@RedDeadDepressionist virtual storytelling in its best, full of moments, but less scenes for proper story to move forth. A different storytelling. Lol, don't hate me. I like the movie too
I had the honor of watching this movie on a boat. In the Middle of the Arctic Circle; with my Dad. Watching my favorite movie with my Dad, in a cruise ship's movie theatre in one of the most remote places. Still brings tears to my eyes
I just love that Cooper cut off Tars and completely ignored him when he said to analyze the spin. He didn’t wanna hear it, he was already locked in to survival mode
When he said 'docking' i got insane chills and and major feeling of shock as if I were actually there in the cockpit, knowing how crazy docking to that would be and how high the chance of death would be. My face was literally the equivalent of Dr.Brands face here: 0:59 for the duration of the whole scene
Even though silent, it shocked the hell out of me and felt Coopers desperation for docking. Death became imminent, so it was either wait for death or die trying, which ultimately became their survival.
@@MikinessAnalog Well, if a movie is earth/human based, then yes, I agree that realism should take precedence over "artistic license". Like a silent explosion, or the harshness and unsurvivability of space. Interstellar is very much a human story, and as such it should follow "our" rules... And it does. But as many seem to forget - me included from time to time - every Star Wars movie begins with the words "A long time ago in a galaxy far far away...", so not only does it take place in the past, it takes place in an entirely different galaxy... Luke, Han, Leia etc aren't human. They're human-shaped, but not humans, and Earth is nowhere to be seen. So even while "no sound in space" would still be eligible wherever Star Wars takes place, I am more than ok with granting it all kinds of artistic license, since it takes place in another world and another time.
Mom: what are you doing? Me: trying to erase my memory about the film so I can rewatch it like new again and again Mom: its not possible Me: no, it's necessary
This scene explains why they couldn't send robots to complete the mission and why the primal instinct of survival is the greatest tool and or weapon of humanity.
lets say not yet. theoretically there is no reason why robots or AI for that matter cant get human like. however current AI is faaaar away from what is needed in such situations as you stated correctly
@@blandgreen4135 This scene and the one before show that our primal survival instinct is a double-edge weapon: Mann, in order to survive, explicitly lied about his planet so he could be rescued. His survival instinct caused the entire situation and, even in the end, he tried to lie to himself and to the Endurance's crew about it. Once the Endurance started spinning, though, it was Cooper's extremely risky move that saved the day. Cooper, especially during the Gargantua scene, became a far better man than Mann, both by docking in an extreme scenario, and by actually knowing when to let go.
A robot can be programmed with survival. It will weigh in the risks of doing it or not and choose the most likely path for survival. However survival for a robot may be different from a human, depends on how its programmed.
