Edward Said is a hero to me. I had thought he was an Egyptian historian; I found out he was a Palestinian intellectual who spoke deeply for the rights of Palestinians. He brought to the fore the horrible injustices perpetrated by Israel. I am Jewish, I have been a sympathizer and supporter of Palestinian rights for some time now. My wife of 37 years is of Palestinian ancestry. The horrible reality of Zionism has made itself clear to me the last 25 years; I never knew the truth... never knew the truth... Bless Said's memory. Harry Katz
@Esraa Tarek Thank you(it is nice to think of me as a cousin, but I'm just a European Jewish person. I do not have a trace of Middle Eastern blood in me.I have never had people in Israel, except a few years ago when some Russian refusniks in our family got a place outside Tel Aviv
What a tour de force. History, biography, Literature, music, family relations, romance, politics, journalism. They packed so much into just a 50 minute conversation.
“Criticism must think of itself as life-enhancing and constitutively opposed to every form of tyranny, domination, and abuse; its social goals are non-coercive knowledge produced in the interests of human freedom.” -Edward W. Said
amazing...blown away... americans can learn so much about the 100 year history of the arab israeli conflict with little discussion of war and total discussion of the people...outstanding interaction between interviewer and interviewee... the last 5 minutes are priceless to any positive human interaction!
I grew up speaking Arabic and with Arabic music which my parents loved. Later in life I came to classical music. What I absorbed from the songs in Arabic is a sense of melodious sadness,
I'm a long time Palestinian supporter, but I don't wanna be extremely biased against Israel and Israelis. I have recently had argument with my beloved friend who is an adamant Israel supporter and she injected into me feeling that I'm not right, that I support terrorists and so on. How to find that golden middle?
There is no middle in this case. A zionist will never be happy with you unless you completely support their genocidal aims without a slight critique of Israel. Ultimately, it is on you and your conscience.
introduce them to Edward Said . This is coming from a Jew who knows the zionist narrative well. It is extremely hard to not have empathy for him. his is an easy gateway to empathy for Palestinians
Not a great scholar but an important writer and during his heyday, the closest thing america had to a european-style cosmopolitan intellectual. maybe there just isnt a place for someone like that anymore, but i think the world is poorer without people like him around
🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:41 🌍 Edward Said's Identity and Intellectual Approach - Edward Said identifies himself as an intellectual who transcends specific fields or places. - Rejects the notion of professionalism, believes in exploring diverse fields. - Born in Palestine, lost his homeland, leading to a desire to make up for the loss by living in different countries. 03:17 🎓 Schooling and Cultural Unity in Palestine - Describes the sense of continuity in different places in Palestine where he felt truly at home. - Despite diverse characters, unity prevailed due to the commonality of being in an Islamic country and speaking Arabic. - Victoria College, an English school, reflected British imperialism, emphasizing learning about England rather than the local context. 05:21 🎶 Early Exposure to Western Music and Cultural Influences - Early rejection of Arabic music in favor of Western music due to its monophonic nature. - Limited exposure to Arabic songs, but Western music became a significant part of his life. - Influence of English education and exposure to Western records at home. 08:22 ⛪ Language, Religion, and Cultural Schizophrenia - Language as a tool of resistance during English-dominated schooling in Palestine. - The Church as an English institution, contributing to a sense of cultural division. - No schizophrenia but rather different parts of his life coexisting, with a gradual integration over time. 15:13 🇵🇸 Impact of 1948 and Loss of Continuity - 1948 marked the end of the continuum, leading to the departure from Palestine. - Family members' experiences and the impact of the formation of the State of Israel. - The sense of sadness, anger, and impotence in response to events like the Dair Yassin massacre. 19:20 📚 Early Awareness of Discrepancies in Education - Early realization of discrepancies between the idealized American history taught and the harsh realities. - Exposure to Paul Robeson's music and awareness of social issues shaped a critical perspective. - Discrepancies observed in the depiction of American intervention abroad and the treatment of indigenous populations. 21:11 📖 Genesis of Orientalism and Critical Perspective - Said's early awareness of the disparity between Western descriptions of the Orient and his lived experience. - Not an invention but a misrepresentation of the experiences of people from the Orient. - Seeds of critical thought planted during schooling, leading to the later development of the Orientalism thesis. 22:08 📚 Edward Said reflects on his early experiences, highlighting the disparities between English and non-English lives. - Non-English lives were subject to a different standard. - Despite feeling equal, Orientalism doctrine imposed a sense of difference. - Early recognition denial led to suspicion of arbitrary power. 26:12 🖋️ Edward Said discusses the origins of his philosophical attitude, influenced by Conrad, leading to the creation of "Orientalism." - Identification with Conrad's position as a stranger. - Exploration of unconventional paths in career and education. - Development of a critical perspective on power and fairness. 27:47 📖 Surprising reception and impact of "Orientalism," revealing societal issues. - Unprepared for the book's profound reception. - Touched on societal issues related to the "other" and identity. - Unintended contribution to discussions on resistance and identity politics. 30:11 🌐 Edward Said clarifies his stance on identity politics, advocating for a universalistic viewpoint. - Strong belief in universal standards. - Opposition to limiting artistic expression based on identity. - Emphasis on overcoming divisions without erasing differences. 34:00 🌍 Edward Said recounts his involvement in Palestinian issues post-1967 war, emphasizing the need for Arab voices. - Transformation into a Palestinian voice after the 1967 war. - Articulating the silent Arab perspective. - Recognizing the importance of political participation. 39:03 🤔 Edward Said reflects on his father's concern for his involvement in politics and the impact of his father's death on his political journey. - Father's worry about Zionist reactions. - No direct connection between father's death and political involvement. - Emergence as a public figure and symbol against his preference. 41:50 😡 Edward Said discusses the escalation of threats and hostility he faced, turning into a public figure. - Escalation from criticism to death threats. - Unwanted transformation into a public figure. - Loss of control over his public image and increased animosity. 42:34 🌍 Edward Said discusses difficulties communicating with American Zionists - Communication challenges with American Zionists. - Personal experience of a campaign against him, attacking his early childhood. - Highlighting the subtlety of his discourse and the acceptance of history. 43:42 🤝 Edward Said's perspective on coexistence and acknowledging suffering - Emphasizes the importance of coexistence. - Discusses the challenge of identity and the idea of having a shared place. - Advocates for acknowledging both Jewish and Palestinian suffering. 44:50 🔍 Edward Said addresses the challenges of hatred, fear, and ignorance - Identifies deep-seated attitudes of hatred, fear, and ignorance. - Recounts an experience of Arab and Israeli musicians overcoming prejudices. - Stresses the need for shared experiences to foster understanding. 47:59 📚 Edward Said on teaching Western literature in Palestine for liberation - Describes teaching Western literature in Palestine as part of liberation. - Compares teaching Western thinkers to liberate Palestinians from the imposed ghetto. - Aims to contribute to a common human experience with a universalistic approach. Made with HARPA AI
If Mr. Said was born with birth certificate, in Palestine, I think he could have applied for citizenship when Israel was born as a citizen of the land of Palestine which was renamed Israel. It is like the case of Sutter, who started first settlement in Sacramento, CA which was under Mexico that time. When Ca was bought by America, Mr. Sutter as Mexican did not apply American citizenship. So he remained a Mexican citizen. Sad to say, he was not credited for that settlement.
What reality exactly the reality that the settler colonialists coming from eastern Europe and ethnically cleansing the indigenous Palestinians Christians and muslims or the parallel reality that your delusional irrational brain live in.
@@chakir348 You are totally dismissing the truth that the Jews were exiled from this land. "Settler colonists" implies that they came from nowhere and are totally unaffiliated with the land. Nevertheless, one cannot deny that Mr Said was a very gifted orator and presented a very strong case for the Palestinian people.
Onward, Christian Soldiers 11'40" Onward, Christian soldiers, marching as to war, with the cross of Jesus going on before. Christ, the royal Master, leads against the foe; forward into battle see his banners go! Onward, Christian soldiers, marching as to war, with the cross of Jesus going on before. At the sign of triumph Satan's host doth flee; on then, Christian soldiers, on to victory! Hell's foundations quiver at the shout of praise; brothers, lift your voices, loud your anthems raise. (Refrain) Like a mighty army moves the church of God; brothers, we are treading where the saints have trod. We are not divided, all one body we, one in hope and doctrine, one in charity. (Refrain) Crowns and thrones may perish, kingdoms rise and wane, but the church of Jesus constant will remain. Gates of hell can never gainst that church prevail; we have Christ's own promise, and that cannot fail. (Refrain) Onward then, ye people, join our happy throng, blend with ours your voices in the triumph song. Glory, laud, and honor unto Christ the King, this through countless ages men and angels sing. (Refrain)
"You live most of your life in New York as an Arab in a predominantly Jewish city." Oh really? So most New Yorkers are Jewish? Really? I was interested in this interview, but the bigotry is too evident at the 1 minute mark for me to be interested continuing. New York Jews!
...and yet you took the trouble to comment on it. I bet you go through the whole interview and got angry because the Edward Said demolishes all your false facets, thx
