Тёмный

Interviews with Veterans of My Lai 

Veterans For Peace Chapter 180 - Fresno
Подписаться 275
Просмотров 80 тыс.
50% 1

Fifty years ago at the height of the American War in Vietnam, an event known as the My Lai Massacre took place in a small village. Five hundred civilians were killed by U.S. troops. The following are taken from interviews with some of the soldiers of C Co. 1/20 Inf who were there that day.

Опубликовано:

 

26 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 605   
@ariesram74
@ariesram74 2 года назад
This is the first time I am seeing these interviews. Speechless.
@peacefulone4461
@peacefulone4461 2 года назад
@ David Crimaldi... 😭 💔 same here. I, too, had never seen this. (I sent it to all the adults in my 'contacts')
@Roscoe.P.Coldchain
@Roscoe.P.Coldchain 2 года назад
How old are you David..?
@sosoo000
@sosoo000 Год назад
In the book "Kill Anything That Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam " explains this went on all the time.
@jamesdelcol3701
@jamesdelcol3701 14 дней назад
Welcome to the party. You should read three authors. Marilyn B. Young, Douglass Valentine and Alfred W. McCoy. Then you might get PTSD like me. This subject broke my soul. I have a deep sadness over it. My uncle was In the US Airforce and he served as an intelligence officer in Thailand. He married a Thai woman, my Aunt Jit. They did something in Vietnam and I want to ask him about the air missions, but I don't want to make my uncle feel uncomfortable. I think talking about this subject will become illegal. It is already in motion. They have edited the LBJ website to lock certain days out. You have to get a court write a FIOA to open 3.21.67 Guam file. You have to look at LBJ's schedule for that day. The list of names will rock you. I have all the information and I won't publish it. You'll have to read about it yourself. This is a big head start for you. Good luck studying the most interesting subject in the world. Vietnam starts in the 1930's. After WWII everything changes. Follow the money. Who was locked up in Vietnam under the Japanese during WWII? French Aristocrats, French Corsicans, an American pilot and an English pilot. The Japanese held them and they said "Vive les colonies". And they planned to take Vietnam back. The French are spent in 54' America takes over in 57'. The Vietcong and NVA kicked the Americans out. You are going to be spun by the end of this study. The CIA stayed there until 1978. Assassinating people and doing black sites.
@scottoshea9440
@scottoshea9440 2 года назад
How every single person that witnessed that massacre didn't have extreme debilitating PTSD is beyond me
@ariesram74
@ariesram74 2 года назад
Simpson committed suicide in 97. His son was killed at age 10 and his daughter died. he went to war and committed crimes against humanity for which he was exonerated. His Wikipedia says he participated in rape, mutiliation and murder at My Lai. Yeah, I'd kill myself too if I woke up one day and realized the monster I was. He believed losing his son was punishment for the murders and maybe it was.
@MalieeimaL
@MalieeimaL 2 года назад
It takes time to dawn on you. First, the nightmares then assigning personal tragedies to comic justice. it takes time.
@georgebuller1914
@georgebuller1914 2 года назад
Chances are, many (most?) of them did! But back in those days PTSD wasn't the 'get out' that it is so often these days.....
@RAsphalt
@RAsphalt 2 года назад
Look up Varnardo Simpson, the black dude in this interview. His interview in 1989 is heartbreaking
@reycesarcarino4653
@reycesarcarino4653 2 года назад
They Dehumanize the Vietnamese and didn't see them as people. That's what the Army do take away your identity
@MrFrogmanScott
@MrFrogmanScott 3 года назад
This should be required viewing for every high school history class. And then require it again in college. Also make it a requirement to watch this before you get to register to vote.
@Vivi-c7o7p
@Vivi-c7o7p 2 года назад
I agree im 13 and im watching this for entertainment but I absolutely agree with this!!!
@domwings4329
@domwings4329 2 года назад
100% except that would kill recruiting
@MrFrogmanScott
@MrFrogmanScott 2 года назад
@@domwings4329 EXACTLY! 😁
@havefunbesafe
@havefunbesafe 2 года назад
Required reading would be “the peoples history of the United States by Howard Zinn”.
@deeppurple883
@deeppurple883 2 года назад
The government and army don't tell the truth. Most of human History is a lie. Most believe their lies. Billions of humans have been deceived and lied to by other humans. I won't miss this planet when I move on.
@hambone2335
@hambone2335 Год назад
This is a good lesson for people who have not seen or lived through war. We are no better than the Nazis. The smirking on some of their faces says it all.
@playinragz8183
@playinragz8183 Год назад
You support Ukraine right? So YOU support Nazi’s. Imagine that fact !
@almaestroham
@almaestroham Год назад
Nazism never raped children , In my lai they reped 6-9 children
@ConanTheContrarian1
@ConanTheContrarian1 2 месяца назад
Sorry, but plenty of vets make up stories based on what they think they can get out of it. The makers of this propaganda piece were good at ferreting out the slime.
@grandcanyon-d4d
@grandcanyon-d4d 2 месяца назад
@@ConanTheContrarian1 this massacre was real and so many more crimes
@Goran-zc2qw
@Goran-zc2qw Месяц назад
@@ConanTheContrarian1 You retarded shit, you call this a propagenda? Bravo maniac. Just bravo.
@terrywaters6186
@terrywaters6186 Год назад
Anybody that doesn't believe the average soldier would fire on American Citizens if told to needs to watch this.
@JJ_SDWR
@JJ_SDWR 9 месяцев назад
It depends on the individual.
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
​@JJ_SDWR no it doesn't, there is a moron at the top of these comments saying " orders are orders "
@Gary-vn8qj
@Gary-vn8qj 18 дней назад
​@@JJ_SDWRand most individuals in the military are increasingly that kind of coward
@JJ_SDWR
@JJ_SDWR 17 дней назад
@@Gary-vn8qj interesting, how did you come to the conclusion that the number of servicemembers who'd kill their fellow citizens is growing? What's your source for that?
@Gary-vn8qj
@Gary-vn8qj 17 дней назад
@JJ_SDWR almost all the young military guys I was in prison with were cowards who thought their shit didn't stink. Almost 5 years in tdcj
@zs5002
@zs5002 7 месяцев назад
I can appreciate that our history teacher taught us this in high school. Not sure if it was mandatory to learn but he taught it
@SalveRegina8
@SalveRegina8 3 года назад
“There were some rapes at time” (like recalling the market carried fresh mangoes now and then)🤯
@shable1436
@shable1436 2 года назад
These ppl were monsters, and the leaders of the units, made up lies to get them to do this, I think they should have been accountable too, but the fact that only one person went to brig, only for this is insane. It reminds me of when police investigate police corruption, and find out there's nothing to see here, we've investigated ourselves and find ourselves innocent of all charges.
@edwinquiray615
@edwinquiray615 2 года назад
Pure evil.
@ethan073
@ethan073 8 месяцев назад
16:29 was one of the creepier moments. The long pause, the knowing, but not telling.
@MayankDwivedi-ob9nr
@MayankDwivedi-ob9nr 4 месяца назад
Talking so casually and laid back as if they are discussing a movie or a book. The banality of evil.
@benyaminyisrael4634
@benyaminyisrael4634 3 месяца назад
@@shable1436 Wonder what kind of lie you could tell someone to cause them to have an erection and penetrate a screaming child?
@parr40
@parr40 2 года назад
My Lai Massacre, also called Pinkville Massacre, mass killing of as many as 500+ unarmed villagers by U.S. soldiers
@Kelly14UK
@Kelly14UK 2 года назад
AKA Son Mai. I think it's a group of tiny villages, or hamlets
@1223steffen
@1223steffen Год назад
Unarmed but not innocent
@jackjohnson6230
@jackjohnson6230 Год назад
@@1223steffen could say the same about the yanks who died in 911
@desserteyes6978
@desserteyes6978 Год назад
@@1223steffen so babies arent innocent? If a country wants to be communist what are they guilty from? They are guilty of communism? Thats a reasom to rape babies and killing women and children. COWARDS PUSSIES! Couldn't handle men so they took revenge with the children. Bunch of pussies American Soldiers are. No Honor! They deserve death penalty. So much anger towards the weak! WOW! God will serve justice. America is coming down soon. Every empire ends. God's Justice will serve America sooner or later.
@TeurastajaNexus
@TeurastajaNexus Год назад
@@1223steffen Civilians were not innocent? :D
@anthonyomibeku-davies.9418
@anthonyomibeku-davies.9418 2 года назад
There is no excuse for killing unarmed civilians .
@RustyShackleford19999
@RustyShackleford19999 Год назад
Orders are orders
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
​@@RustyShackleford19999 Follower, simpleton logic
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
​@@RustyShackleford19999 You are the type that would fire on American Civilians if ordered to
@RustyShackleford19999
@RustyShackleford19999 6 месяцев назад
@@AshleySmyth1212 non White’s sure
@colincampbell4261
@colincampbell4261 5 месяцев назад
​@@RustyShackleford19999mr nasty nazi.
@arkybaldknobber8062
@arkybaldknobber8062 Год назад
Sgt. Hutto was in the bed next to me at Fort Polk Army hospital late in 1968. I was bad wounded, could not walk, had to shit in a bag. He told me all about the fight at My Lai. Pink Ville we called it back then. I also had been in the Americal Division. I never saw any thing like he described, thought maybe things like that happened, did not disbelieve him. He lad a leg injury, nor sure if it was a wound and did not stay there long. They were giving him a leave to go home and he borrowed 20 bucks from me, going to Boogolussa , LA. Maybe I spell that wrong. He said he would come back and pay me. He never did. just Like every other guy I lent money to in the Army who had to get home.
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 Год назад
How did get wounded? There was one report of someone getting wounded by shooting himself in the foot or leg? He told you the nightmare that took place?
@arkybaldknobber8062
@arkybaldknobber8062 Год назад
@@bossbonita1235 .. I'm sure Hutto did not shoot himself. When he told me about all the killing at Pink Ville , he was not upset in the least. I saw him on TV when I was back home discharged. Probably very late 1969 0r early 1970. The news was showing Lt. Calley charged with murder, the Sgt. Hutto charged with 2 counts of murder and rape.
@Thenogomogo-zo3un
@Thenogomogo-zo3un 6 месяцев назад
@@bossbonita1235 Self inflicted wound
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 6 месяцев назад
@@Thenogomogo-zo3un Wow! That’s terrible and absolutely traumatizing
@MsLaurjean
@MsLaurjean 2 месяца назад
@@bossbonita1235 yes he shot himself in the foot. My uncle was in Charlie and Co. my grandma is 98 and talks about it till this day. My uncle was court marshaled and testified against Cali. He passed away in 1991.
@dewit9288
@dewit9288 2 года назад
18:28 "They were putting responsibility on other men." OR it might just be because the knew it was wrong and they didn't want to get involved
@jacksonmarshallkramer5087
@jacksonmarshallkramer5087 Год назад
4 Hours In My Lai is the complete documentary. Remember My Lai part 1 is a FrontLine documentary. The black dudes mental decline over the years from guilt and being haunted by what he did is unbelievable. Then , his own little boy was killed in front of him just put the pedal to the metal. Check it out.
@domwings4329
@domwings4329 2 года назад
A soldiers job is not to obey orders but simply to obey lawful orders. The only reason we don’t use lawful is because it is assumed and part of military and civilian law.
@bryanpinto4051
@bryanpinto4051 Год назад
what do you do as an 18 year old kid who went thru basic training, kill training and are told if you dont kill you will be killed? After seeing the guys next to you blown up every day it gets to you. NOBODY has the right to pass judgement except the CREATOR. If there is hell to pay then let it be but unless you were there I think opinions are like a holes.
@MrFreeman0179
@MrFreeman0179 Год назад
Besides killing you have a "duty to disobey," and is empowered by the Uniform Code of Military. Nazi defendants in the Nuremberg Trials after WW II argued, to limited effect, that they were just following orders. U.S. Army Lt. William Calley used the same argument in defending himself against murder charges following the My Lai Massacre in Vietnam. He ultimately served 3 1/2 years in military prison.
@MrFreeman0179
@MrFreeman0179 Год назад
​@@bryanpinto4051 "what do you do as an 18 year old kid.." At that age you know what's morally wrong. Age doesn't excuse anything here. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1NwnnLnvQYA.html 44:10 That teenager went through basic training and still disobeyed. Their "enemies " were unarmed civilians.
@sandro19691000
@sandro19691000 Год назад
​@@MrFreeman0179, but the "sense of moral" is, I would say, "very flexible", depending on where it applies.
@adrianzilic5753
@adrianzilic5753 4 месяца назад
Law on the battlefield does not exist.
@mattwinthewoods
@mattwinthewoods 3 года назад
This video will speak through decades, if only those ears will be open to hear... I hope so.
@dmmchugh3714
@dmmchugh3714 2 года назад
What is he talking about at 15:10? The civilians were 'huddling' because the Americans herded them over there and then massacred them. And the guy at 16:30 - smiling at the rapes ? Despicable.
@dlcchannel8881
@dlcchannel8881 2 года назад
I thought the same. Pretty sure he was one of those who rape and mutilated from the way he acted
@itsofficialb
@itsofficialb 2 года назад
It didn’t seem like he was proud of it he seemed uncomfortable and embarrassed but then again I wasn’t there and i don’t know the man
@chuckf2156
@chuckf2156 Год назад
Seemed to me like he didn’t want to talk about it maybe because it bothered him, but then again who knows
@ibienlejos
@ibienlejos Год назад
@@chuckf2156 Aww, his evil crimes "bothered him"? How touching.
@ibienlejos
@ibienlejos Год назад
Exactly, psychopathic mass murderers and rapists, every single one of them.
@notjack2491
@notjack2491 2 года назад
They're all so weirdly . . . casual. I understand the attitude of that time is a bit more composed and articulated than now but this is next level.
@truthseeker2321
@truthseeker2321 2 года назад
@@cycologist7069 It is. These guys are emotionally detached, and many never recover from that. Those of us who have never seen war, will likely never understand what happens to the minds of the men who have .
@christopherallen8930
@christopherallen8930 2 года назад
It's a coping mechanism. This interview was shortly after they got home. It takes many years for the fog of war and justification to fade from soldiers hearts and minds.
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
They've become numb and conditioned to feel nothing. The only ones that seem to show even a sliver of remorse are the white dude with a beard from California and the only black vet.
@donnacaldwell3267
@donnacaldwell3267 Год назад
The guy being interviewed in the moving car seemed like he liked it.
@drewbonsall384
@drewbonsall384 Год назад
Some of those guys looked like they enjoyed it and thats sad
@noisemud
@noisemud 2 месяца назад
this is still going on by the us nothing has changed a lot enjoy it and more and more countries are just waiting for the cracks to show so they can unleash hell on americans no one is going to be in any remorse whatsoever
@uraigroves7898
@uraigroves7898 3 года назад
Interesting fact - all of these guys are dead except for the worst one - Garry Crossley of del rio texas - the guy in the car. He is 74 years old and still alive. Hopefully, the scenes of gang rapes he witnessed still torment him till the day he dies.
@davidhanson3174
@davidhanson3174 2 года назад
Garry Crossley didn't do much, all the testimonies are online and free to view, Roschevitz,Hutto, Hutson,Wright,Gruver, Smith, Conti, Torres, Delgado, Brown, Makey,Goodson Neria, Hodges etc were rapists and killers.
@uraigroves7898
@uraigroves7898 2 года назад
@@davidhanson3174 he was there and he watched little girls get gang raped murdered and did nothing to stop it. I hope he sees those images in his dreams every night and I hope there is a god that he will have to answer to.
@davidhanson3174
@davidhanson3174 2 года назад
@@uraigroves7898 Fair enough, for the record i'm not defending the man, however the only evidence i have of him is shooting a man on the arm. Bernhardt was totally innocent, infact he was discouraged and threatened to keep quiet. No evidence of Garfolo committing atrocities either, Bergtholdt and Simpson were 100% guilty of war crimes.
@uraigroves7898
@uraigroves7898 2 года назад
@@davidhanson3174 you are right - unlike most people you actually did research on this and know the facts. I spoke with simpson before he killed himself. what a wasted life. calley is still alive in florida living alone at 78 with cancer. when he dies I will have a small celebration and a toast. I await the others leaving this earth and hope I live long enough to see them all gone.
@davidhanson3174
@davidhanson3174 2 года назад
@@uraigroves7898 Gary Roschevitz who died in august 2020 was by far the worst that day, not that it was a competition. I saw a few pictures of him in the 1/20 reunion website, evil personified, i was told he was monitored by the authorities from the day he landed back in the states till the day he died the man was a monster.
@srennielsen4545
@srennielsen4545 2 года назад
Great honesty for history. If there werent any enimies when we arrived, there were - when we left..
@Kelly14UK
@Kelly14UK 2 года назад
After the massacre they were put on patrol for 2 stinking months ( wearing the one uniform ), just to get them out the way. Maybe the brass were hoping for a massacre of guys who may talk.
@NewKanyeFan
@NewKanyeFan 3 месяца назад
US Army Veteran here. *EVERY* individual in this interview is a sociopathic monster.
@michaeloliveri1907
@michaeloliveri1907 Месяц назад
I'm a Nam Era vet. I have 1 question for you and you want know the answer bc I knew a soldier who was in that village the day before the massacre.... Do you know why that village was called Pinksville by the troops? I'll wait!
@NewKanyeFan
@NewKanyeFan Месяц назад
@@michaeloliveri1907 the topographic map color coding to indicate population density in the village. Idk what your point is, or you just heard some other scuttle butt back then but the name pinkville was coined due to it's pink coloration defining population density on the maps.
@DavidThomas-qq4hf
@DavidThomas-qq4hf Месяц назад
​@michaeloliveri1907 tell us what u think the reason is
@johnwallace3990
@johnwallace3990 23 дня назад
@@michaeloliveri1907 “Nam era vet” is Army-ese for “I wasn’t in-country.”
@mikloridden8276
@mikloridden8276 18 дней назад
@@johnwallace3990 Most likely in the rear taking advantage of impoverished Asian girls back then. Reason why I don’t thank every “Nam era” vet. You never know what they did out there.
@thepimpernel6971
@thepimpernel6971 8 месяцев назад
I remember this happening and how shocked people were.
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 2 года назад
This is just PURE EVIL and so f’ing heartbreaking. I come from a military family- yes, they’ve always told us war is war and it’s a terrible place to be in- BUT you’re a human being who loves your country and fight for what’s right- NOT cold blooded murder to INNOCENT people- babies, children, elderly, and women!!!! That’s just pure EVIL!! 🤦🏻‍♀️ This is so hurtful I wish I could help every single victim in any way possible. These men have NO remorse whatsoever and actually smile and laugh when they talk about what they witnessed or wtf they did 🤦🏻‍♀️ Sickening after wtf they did, then literally talk about it as they’re back in their country with their freedom walking around living their lives as other lives of women, elderly, children, and babies were cut short due to these men and their cowardliness! Oh how nice it would’ve been if Medina’s fat ass and the other POS in charge were smashed by Hugh Thompson’s helicopter! Or blown away!! Then interview people to talk about while laughing!!!
@johntynan8161
@johntynan8161 2 года назад
Yes its first time i seen this. Paychopathic
@1223steffen
@1223steffen Год назад
The Nva did that. Patton killled woman and children and bragged about
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 Год назад
@@1223steffen Anyone guilty of it is evil scum
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 Год назад
@Robert Taylor You don’t know me- to tell someone “YOU have pure evil” That’s something a demented, evil, ignorant person would say who’s f’ing guilty of some evil s**t like these men are so F**K YOU- So many others were in the same position, and refused to do anything so EVIL, cold blooded murderer to weak, helpless, innocent people so YOU’RE WRONG! And f’d up yourself- get help!
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 Год назад
@Robert Taylor WOW! Sorry to burst your bubble- but you’re absolutely WRONG! You’re just a twisted little weirdo who posts f’d up comments thinking you know everything about everyone- clearly you Don’t! And to act as a total dumb a** accusing me of being upset cause you’re right! 🤦🏻‍♀️No, you’re not! Anyone would take offense to that twisted accusation- because it’s not normal! You’re demented and I’m certain guilty of some f’d up s**t- you’re very immature and just stupid! You know nothing 🤦🏻‍♀️ Keep telling yourself that BS- it’s just ridiculous it’s NOT universal truth- it’s very immature behavior by someone who’s completely full of your own s**t, trying to convince yourself that you’re correct- and you’re darkness is “normal” and everyone has it- NO! They don’t! You’re f’d up, ok- seek some help and open your eyes! And accusing someone you know NOTHING about, of being naive is just as stupid as your twisted mind. You’re bs is supposed to make you feel better and think it’s normal and everyone is the same way but you’re so far from the truth and out of touch with reality! It’s NOT normal- and NOT the truth! 🤷🏻‍♀️
@jesnandrew6104
@jesnandrew6104 2 года назад
The way these guys talk are so unbelievable, hypocritical, and insensitive...that they would talk about innocent people as if there nothing.
@shable1436
@shable1436 2 года назад
Nazis
@dudermcdude9245
@dudermcdude9245 6 месяцев назад
Insanity. It was Incredible that this stuff happened all through history by all armies. But, these guys were American soldiers. Really sad time. They were trained and ordered to do this.
@luvmanny2x857
@luvmanny2x857 2 года назад
The man killed a mother and a three month old baby and said”it crack me up” bro I’m in shock
@Psyxic_Crimes
@Psyxic_Crimes 2 года назад
Untill it happens to their family, then they cry for their mommas and whine about vengance. Hypocrites and scumbags.
@TheViolinKid
@TheViolinKid 2 года назад
"Crack me up" in that era meant something different than it does now. He was saying that it hurt him. During the First and Second World Wars, to "crack up" meant to lose control of your emotions and be temporarily unable to perform. He was probably trained by veterans who still used that terminology regularly.
@dmatej79
@dmatej79 2 года назад
How insane and sad ... horror.
@oldsalt7534
@oldsalt7534 2 года назад
I went to high school with one of these men. He was just an all American kid then. Varnado Simpson committed suicide.
@ibienlejos
@ibienlejos Год назад
Well, so what you are saying the "all American kid" means a potential psychopathic mass murderer and rapist. That should make you question your sick society.
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
Rest in piss
@aboveusall22
@aboveusall22 Год назад
I served in Vietnam but the area where I was there wasn't any villages or civilians only hardcore NVA so you were fighting to stay alive.
@arkybaldknobber8062
@arkybaldknobber8062 Год назад
me also...A 196th 198th LIB same time period. Killing babies though? Never saw such things.
@Darunia_s
@Darunia_s Год назад
​@@arkybaldknobber8062still happened
@juanshaftpatel7488
@juanshaftpatel7488 Год назад
but you lost the war
@juanshaftpatel7488
@juanshaftpatel7488 Год назад
@@arkybaldknobber8062 you lost the war tho
@jmhakeem3734
@jmhakeem3734 Год назад
​@@juanshaftpatel7488 , they are still 19 yo kids and have to fight without support from their family and society. They are not soldier like japan or german troops during ww2. If it like win for nothing. Stop killing and return is to be better.
@MarkWilliams-p6v
@MarkWilliams-p6v 4 месяца назад
And there leaders got off which is an utter disgrace
@katherinegates1559
@katherinegates1559 3 месяца назад
Horrible ........
@clgaminguk
@clgaminguk Год назад
First time watching these interviews and I’ve probably watched nearly and I say this with my chest NEARLY EVERY SINGLE COMBAT VIDEO THERE IS TO WATCH, from WW2 to Ukraine on RU-vid and the worst of the worst on best gore.. but These interviews right here touch a different type of nerve. To hear these guys so calmly and sometimes even happily talking about shooting innocent WOMEN and children in the back as they run away. Walking into another man’s humble abode and taking things then wonder why he’s following you shouting? To just shoot him.. I wasn’t there so I don’t know the situations and the real outcomes of these particular situations talked about in the interviews but how in ANY situation UNLESS THEY HAVE A WEAPON on them.. SHOOT ANYONE in the back? Let alone women and children.. genuinely baffles me. Can you imagine being the only one in the platoon or the battalion to talk about this to the higher ups? You’d find yourself buried alive in a foxhole or alone in a jungle wondering where everyone went.. and if that didn’t happen to you and you did make it home to have that on your mind.. just hearing the first person stories from you’re friends or comrades let alone seeing it or doing it yourself.. you wonder why so many of these guys couldn’t live with themselves and unfortunately committed suicide. When you round up the whole situation as a whole and look back all you can say is it is Fucking SAD and my condolences and my love from anyone and everyone affected by this war in whatever shape or form it comes in. Peace and blessings to all. I hope everyone has a beautiful Christmas with their friends and family. Nothing but LOVE❤
@dennisgordon7767
@dennisgordon7767 Год назад
you will never undersetand unless you were in a war i think
@PolarBearPredator
@PolarBearPredator 11 месяцев назад
There is nothing to understand. This is war. Shit happens.
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
​@@PolarBearPredatorAnd how exactly are we to learn from history to make sure it never happens again if we just chalk this up as, "Shit happens"?
@SoldierDrew
@SoldierDrew 10 месяцев назад
Had any of my men raped prisoners when I was active duty or torture civilian families I'd have gone to prison for shooting my own men. Thankfully this behavior wasn't tolerated during my generation in the Army.
@Rich6Brew
@Rich6Brew 8 месяцев назад
This is what politicians do to people.
@4eyenuocngoai847
@4eyenuocngoai847 2 года назад
They should have been locked up
@jamesheath1025
@jamesheath1025 2 года назад
The Superior Superior will judge.
@scottodonnell7121
@scottodonnell7121 16 дней назад
"What can we do to make sure this doesn't happen again?" "Get out of Vietnam." WE should never have been there in the first place.
@24barnaby
@24barnaby Месяц назад
The horror and constant grind of war will make any human being capable of anything.......anything. This fact is as old as the first battle between men.
@rayali9854
@rayali9854 3 года назад
Monsters. Some even grinning as they recall the event.
@Wolly735
@Wolly735 3 года назад
It’s most likely a coping mechanism, but it could be the person is just evil. When normal people are pushed to this, it breaks them.
@bhbxgoclran2174
@bhbxgoclran2174 2 года назад
That could be Me are you some day
@stabilis8895
@stabilis8895 2 года назад
@@bhbxgoclran2174 Never.
@foofkanon
@foofkanon 2 года назад
It seems mandatory now to thank veteran's for their service.America appears to be more militaristic and arrogant than ever The fact that they have never paid Vietnam reparations and supported the murderous Khmer rouge speaks volumes.
@axoloootlprincee2285
@axoloootlprincee2285 2 года назад
The people who killed in my lI should go to jail for life
@truthseeker2321
@truthseeker2321 2 года назад
@S The military obeys the orders of the CIVILIANS who control our government. If you have a problem with that, then take it up with those CIVILIANS.
@Darunia_s
@Darunia_s Год назад
​@@truthseeker2321civilians didn't order search and destroy operations or tried to coverup gang rapes by soldiers?
@jamesbennett5587
@jamesbennett5587 Год назад
@@truthseeker2321 the military obeys orders from the government, civilians only have illusions of control and or power. What these men did right or wrong is up to the individuals war is war you fight kill etc or you're excuted it's easy to condemn these men as well as it's easy to say that others won't do the same . It's human nature to be selfish sparing the lives of others you're at war with and the choice you're given is if you don't you will be killed is an easy choice self preservation rules all . This is the other side of humanity people always rejected.
@truthseeker2321
@truthseeker2321 Год назад
@@jamesbennett5587 Last time I checked, our senate and house and the executive and judicial branches are made up of CIVILIANS. How hard is that to understand?
@grandcanyon-d4d
@grandcanyon-d4d 4 месяца назад
these are the same people that point fingers to Russia
@fredrit323
@fredrit323 Месяц назад
I've seen interviews of soldiers involved in atrocities in the Vietnam war, and you know what? I don't think any of them have a shred of remorse for what they have done, the guy in the car is like : what's all the fuss about it ? I didn't think there would be so much publicity, these kind of things were going down all the time... Truly shocking.
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
Gary Garfolo, Michael Bernhardt, and Varnado Simpson are the three of the five interviewed that seemed like they held some remorse (Bernhardt didn't commit any war crimes at least). The other two didn't.
@francisphillips53
@francisphillips53 2 года назад
What a bunch of monsters.. again we hear. (We we’re just following orders.)
@MrFreeman0179
@MrFreeman0179 Год назад
Adolf Eichmann used that phrase "I was just following orders" as excuse
@forwardobserver6441
@forwardobserver6441 Год назад
No they are just humans stressed to the absolute max with combat duty. We all have a breaking point. Not condoning their actions- but the villagers new where mines were, where ambushes were set up etc. They were stuck between us and vc. They committed murder- it goes on everywhere. Like the vc nva executing our wounded. Will you leave the same message on their videos?
@mynameisnobody454
@mynameisnobody454 Год назад
​@forwardobserver6441 dawg they raped and pillaged for 2-4 hours killing 504 civilians... No one had enough spine to say we need to stop after the 100th death??? Why did it take mutiny from a hell bird to get the troops to stand down?
@Gufyrdhff
@Gufyrdhff 7 месяцев назад
I have to admire you, I've rarely seen anyone display moral cowardice, dressed up in whataboutism ​to this degree. @@forwardobserver6441
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
​@@forwardobserver6441 simpleton logic
@MisterBlue80
@MisterBlue80 3 года назад
The Horror......The Horror.....
@peacefulone4461
@peacefulone4461 2 года назад
💔 😭
@rfj1156
@rfj1156 3 года назад
0:36 I don't know how true this is, but this man is said to have witnessed the events however did not part take in the Massacre itself. Again I don't know if its true so dont quote me on it
@uraigroves7898
@uraigroves7898 3 года назад
you are right - he did not shoot anyone or rape anyone. the only guy who didnt here. he died at 59 in 2005.
@civil380
@civil380 2 года назад
11:58 I can't believe what I am hearing.
@moonjumper66
@moonjumper66 2 года назад
Oliver..thats when normal people turning into monsters.
@JJ-zd5uj
@JJ-zd5uj 2 года назад
Read ...Lt. Calley His Own Story
@jes31192
@jes31192 Год назад
It is very easy to criticize and condemn when you are comfortable at home... I would like to see all those people in the same circumstances... if they are so kind to what is around them.
@rseim100
@rseim100 Год назад
Valid point.
@OCCX11
@OCCX11 Год назад
They’re going to hell Jesus.
@agarlicsorbet6482
@agarlicsorbet6482 Год назад
In the long run, it would have been easier for themselves if they hadn't murdered people. Also people usually don't empathize with murderers, Cortez.
@agarlicsorbet6482
@agarlicsorbet6482 Год назад
​@@rseim100 spoken like a person whose country has never been trampled on since British
@Loverofass
@Loverofass Год назад
We can condemn when we see that they do not give a fuck that they killed innocent women and children. They may have “had to do it” to survive or whatever but to feel zero remorse is disgusting.
@jamesdelcol3701
@jamesdelcol3701 14 дней назад
This is Michael Bilton and Kevin Sim's "Four Hours In My Lai". Can't talk about it.
@ycartyahoo
@ycartyahoo 7 месяцев назад
It's so easy to be evil...
@toulantaspanormitis1862
@toulantaspanormitis1862 5 месяцев назад
Those murderers baby killers and innocent people look so proud recalling the even
@andrewjensen8189
@andrewjensen8189 2 года назад
Like 30+% of these "gentlemen" ended up homeless. Being ordered to carry out war crimes surely takes a toll on one's mind, no wonder they end up dysfunctional.
@SandfordSmythe
@SandfordSmythe 2 года назад
30% of who?
@andrewjensen8189
@andrewjensen8189 2 года назад
@@SandfordSmythe Well around 10% of all veterans end up homeless at some point, and that number only goes up with the "type" of combat you took part in. 18 year old's forced to commit genocide had a very high chance of having mental health issues and many became homeless due to it.
@SandfordSmythe
@SandfordSmythe 2 года назад
@@andrewjensen8189 The statistics become complicated on this. I've seen different reports. I'm going to do research on this.
@SPOOKSTR
@SPOOKSTR 5 дней назад
Now check out the ''Highway of Death'' story. Now that was a massacre.
@joehaliday1990
@joehaliday1990 3 года назад
Some messed up shit
@maxxamiss5386
@maxxamiss5386 3 месяца назад
And it's still happening to this day
@RealAaron317
@RealAaron317 Месяц назад
One soldier shot himself in the foot to get out shooting the villagers
@johnelamin65
@johnelamin65 7 месяцев назад
Look Varnado Simpson and watch his story about being @ My Lai.
@ARXDMOS
@ARXDMOS 10 месяцев назад
no honor. period. some people had and served with honor like the helicopter pilot. but these people, no honor. disrespected your humanity, your country, your oath... sad criminal and shameful. history is filled with men serving with honor. if you don't have the balls to disobey such orders, then you are as bad and dishonorable as the assholes that gave the order.
@douglasspende6685
@douglasspende6685 2 года назад
My Gunnery sergeant once told me, " Sgt. Spende one thing your going to find out in war is how brutal an all American boy can be"! I told him like my dad before me told his commander, I did not sign up for this"! This entire Company will be facing God I hate to be them! Burning in HELL! For all Aternity. There are rules even in war time. My dad told me he and his unit had to deliver supplies at an Army base near Chew lie. He said when they got there. American soldiers were smoking and shooting dope smoking urb. High as HELL! The base looked terrible like I one was keeping the base up to code! My dad told me he got back to his fire base and told his Captain about this Army base.
@copperridgegrow3940
@copperridgegrow3940 Год назад
Your dad sounds like a real pu$$y
@juanshaftpatel7488
@juanshaftpatel7488 Год назад
you lost the war
@arkybaldknobber8062
@arkybaldknobber8062 6 месяцев назад
@@copperridgegrow3940... some kind of clerk/truck driver
@BlickBoogie
@BlickBoogie 6 месяцев назад
I recognise the guy in the yellow shirt from Thunderbirds.
@susievarnado2142
@susievarnado2142 2 года назад
WTF about 6:45 into the video a cockroach runs across the screen. Also my name is Varnado. Sometimes I think I’m in the twilight zone.
@woodhook
@woodhook Месяц назад
How do u do this and then live with yourself?
@emaguigad
@emaguigad Год назад
Pure evil...they talk about it like it was nothing with no feelings of remorse...how can anyone in the right mind go on and live knowing you killed innocent women, children and babies...so sad
@gwl6258
@gwl6258 Год назад
Were you in nam???
@emaguigad
@emaguigad Год назад
@@gwl6258 yes
@playinragz8183
@playinragz8183 Год назад
How can you judge people when you have No Clue. Zero
@emaguigad
@emaguigad Год назад
@@playinragz8183 sounds like you have no clue...i sense you lack intelligence
@juanshaftpatel7488
@juanshaftpatel7488 Год назад
@@emaguigad you lost the war
@stevengilman-u1u
@stevengilman-u1u 4 месяца назад
what shame. i was in the marines and we would give our sea rats to the kids. i always felt sorry for them.
@anthonywall4160
@anthonywall4160 Месяц назад
Gary garfolo is my dads cousin
@drjoshuashurley3285
@drjoshuashurley3285 Месяц назад
Is he still around? If so, I would be interested in interviewing him and talking about our organization, Veterans For Peace. Thanks.
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
He seems like a decent dude, one of the three in this that held some remorse. The other two didn't.
@dropperknot
@dropperknot Год назад
Did anyone else notice the extra rat in the picture, as if there weren't enough being interviewed?
@joseflemire4284
@joseflemire4284 4 месяца назад
at 6:51 A RAT SCURRIES right behind the guy talking about the beginning of the killing...it seems as if these guys left their souls behind them in My Lai or they never developed their souls prior...in any case this is murder...God forgive them
@MU_._
@MU_._ 4 месяца назад
16:29 looking pretty guilty 😔
@345mrse
@345mrse 4 месяца назад
“Good job! Get you a case of beer for that one.”
@diamonds_and_julesxo2775
@diamonds_and_julesxo2775 Год назад
I feel when men are under fire day in day out, they see their friends get blown to bits, it turns men into something that they cannot control. We cannot judge because most of us have never been in this situation. I’m not condoning this massacre by any means, I’m just saying we will never get it.
@elias560
@elias560 6 месяцев назад
Stop justifying mass rape and killing please.
@bluemarshall6180
@bluemarshall6180 2 года назад
Just like they did in the late 1890's somewhere in south east asia. They massacred 100% civilians.
@steved9147
@steved9147 Год назад
A dramatic failure of the officers to exert control of their troops
@playinragz8183
@playinragz8183 Год назад
That statement shows your lacking knowledge of Vietnam in general.
@SalveRegina8
@SalveRegina8 3 года назад
16:44 GROSS
@jamesomalley4556
@jamesomalley4556 Год назад
Sad !
@colind.wescott845
@colind.wescott845 2 года назад
Murder
@abilshihadah2199
@abilshihadah2199 18 дней назад
read My Lai by Howard Jones
@vesaroivainen
@vesaroivainen 2 года назад
is it really you or me if you are upagainst women and children....
@JoelGalvan-w6y
@JoelGalvan-w6y 5 месяцев назад
Need interview with commanding officer, Colin Powell.
@jacksonmarshallkramer5087
@jacksonmarshallkramer5087 Год назад
The thin black dude in the blue suit is older in the other vid. It has to be seen to be believed.
@bradmuehlenbein
@bradmuehlenbein 10 месяцев назад
6:45 anybody else see the rat?
@SandfordSmythe
@SandfordSmythe 2 года назад
I can see the stressors, but this does not absolve the guilt. I think it was soft-pedaled by the Army because of the guilt of the Command leadership here. Guilt in executing the mission, and the guilt of condoning this kind of behavior all along. If it was made known down to the platoon level that this was wrong, maybe this would not have happened.
@truthseeker2321
@truthseeker2321 2 года назад
You can blame the company commander, the platoon leaders, platoon Sergeants, and every other NCO- they were the professional soldiers, and at least one platoon Sergeant that I can remember reading about, was the oldest of all of them, and had battlefield experience dating back to the Normandy invasion. They all knew that it was a war crime to wantonly kill unarmed men, women and children, and not one of them tried to prevent it. Captain Medina and his junior officers, and the NCOs under him should have been court martialed and executed for this mass murder.
@infernoreviews2529
@infernoreviews2529 Месяц назад
no matter how many conventions or laws are established. In times of war these allways go out the window. I'm pretty sure there has been some war crimes in Ukraine too or in syria.
@denamaes7009
@denamaes7009 Год назад
The American way...Lord forgive.
@1namokao
@1namokao 2 года назад
It's a method called Free Fire Zone...taking the water around the fish
@sranney1
@sranney1 4 месяца назад
WW2 we killed 100s of thousands of unarmed folks
@44SWAGNUM-MAGA5
@44SWAGNUM-MAGA5 15 дней назад
first day of dday , killed over 70K civilians from the pre shelling for the landing on the beaches
@how5851
@how5851 Год назад
Pure evil. Gland these people received a well deserved hate.
@joeybrazelton3069
@joeybrazelton3069 Год назад
12:00 "They don't care if they live or die." Excuse me, what?
@hughca1
@hughca1 Год назад
I'd like to know if he learned that from his community or unit. Maybe both?
@jmhakeem3734
@jmhakeem3734 Год назад
As a kid they are not wise enough to make difference between living in wide roads united states and villages and trails in vietnam.
@McNallyF
@McNallyF 2 года назад
Criminal.
@watersbey25
@watersbey25 Год назад
@6:50 WTF crawled over that guy being interviewed, a mouse?!!!
@torycsummers7328
@torycsummers7328 Год назад
No excuse. Yall knew right from wrong. We are the US Army. WTF were you thinking? Or better yet you all Weren't thinking! No Damn Excuse!
@markhonerbaum3920
@markhonerbaum3920 2 года назад
New American nazis, same theme revised and re-edited.Sleepless nights and night Mayers. Following orders no conscience, and its a shame, you still have this on an on.
@deejaye2647
@deejaye2647 Год назад
Kissiinger ❤ WAR
@jj7834
@jj7834 3 месяца назад
Geezuz krist man i cant believe these monsters talk so casually. I get it tho.....they will deal with padt memories in due time.....WAR SUX...
@sranney1
@sranney1 4 месяца назад
Better to not go to war
@wellitsherenow
@wellitsherenow 3 месяца назад
sounds like these men were led to a set up.
@keithharris19061
@keithharris19061 Год назад
What was that running through the video about 6 min 45 seconds in? I thought that was a rat!
@ConanTheContrarian1
@ConanTheContrarian1 3 месяца назад
When I was in, there were lots of guys, we called them bullshitters, who would make up shit just to feel special. Can't say for sure, but it would be interesting to see the interviews on the cutting room floor from this antiwar organization. I'm glad it's not on my conscience, but I'm not going to condemn it out of hand. These guys had good reason to hate the Vietnamese in their minds.
@conradsieber7883
@conradsieber7883 3 месяца назад
The crimes US troops committed at My Lai are well documented by the Army's investigation into the massacre. It documents rape, mutilation of bodies and murder of women and children...
@ConanTheContrarian1
@ConanTheContrarian1 2 месяца назад
@Randy_Richmond This is why the bias of the media can't be forgiven. Vietnam was divided into 2 polities, north and south, in 1540, not 1955. The Nguyen (south) and Tranh (north) fought 20 major wars until the French took over. Neither side wanted to reunite, they wanted to conquer the other. We were there at the INVITATION of the South Vietnamese government, who were overmatched because of the Chinese and Russian involvement.
@sosoo000
@sosoo000 Год назад
In the book "Kill Anything That Moves: The Real American War in Vietnam" explains how this happened all the time.
@playinragz8183
@playinragz8183 Год назад
That book is total BS. Lol learning about Vietnam would take research which your not ever gonna do.
@AshleySmyth1212
@AshleySmyth1212 6 месяцев назад
​@@playinragz8183 no it's not
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
Okay apologist. There was a My Lai every month in Nam. ​@@playinragz8183
@Jimtom933
@Jimtom933 Год назад
Despicable
@WSNight-
@WSNight- 2 года назад
I know this is a serious video and I appreciate it being a veteran myself of the Gulf war but that guy with the yellow shirt and sideburns looks like Elvis LoL.
@bossbonita1235
@bossbonita1235 2 года назад
😂
@lelouchvibritannia4028
@lelouchvibritannia4028 12 дней назад
I can't unsee that haha
@ycartyahoo
@ycartyahoo 7 месяцев назад
11:58 what tha fuuuu...😮😢
@nikitachirich7985
@nikitachirich7985 Год назад
that’s true but when it’s down to the wire like this and those two orders were given to “take care” of the civilians , as a right minded soldier would you say sir I’m standing down that us and unlawful order and honestly even point the weapon at the officer and have the XO or someone arrest them on the spot . I’d like to think I would do that , probably die for it .
Далее
Ron Ridenhour’s Last Talk: My Lai and Why it Matters
1:17:19
Les Dykema, Veterans Oral History Project, Vietnam War
2:25:28
Это ваши Патрики ?
00:33
Просмотров 33 тыс.
Four Hours In My Lai (7 of 7)
7:44
Просмотров 77 тыс.
George Carlin Gets Dark | Charlie Rose Interview 1996
21:48
Feb 27, 1982 Interview with Jack Hill
42:16
Просмотров 26 тыс.
The Good Guys: My Lai Massacre, Vietnam
2:12:47
Robert Price, Sergeant, US Army, Vietnam War
1:53:34
Просмотров 22 тыс.
Four Hours In My Lai (1 of 7)
9:54
Просмотров 227 тыс.
Vietnam Remembered
1:27:40
Просмотров 3,3 млн
Это ваши Патрики ?
00:33
Просмотров 33 тыс.