Is a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine possible? | Start Here

Просмотров 695 тыс.

% 13 146

The Israel-Gaza war has got many people talking again about the need for a two-state solution. It’s often presented as the only option to bring lasting peace between Israelis and Palestinians. But what is the two-state solution? Is it actually possible? And why are some people talking about a “one-state solution” instead? #AJStartHere with Sandra Gathmann explains.
Chapters:
01:00 - What is a two-state solution?
02:34 - The Balfour Declaration and its implications
03:05 - The British proposal to partition historic Palestine in 1937
03:30 - The proposed UN partition plan in 1947
04:05 - What happened in the 1948 war
04:40 - The Green Line and the 1967 war
05:55 - How Yasser Arafat recognised Israel in 1988
06:30 - The Oslo Accords and how they didn’t promise a Palestinian state
09:05 - Israeli and Palestinian opposition to the peace process
11:20 - The Second Intifada
12:00 - Attempts to keep the peace process going after Oslo
12:40 - Major obstacles to the peace process - settlements
13:39 - Major obstacles to the peace process - Israeli politics
14:09 - Major obstacles to the peace process - Palestinian politics
16:35 - Why October 7th has got people talking again about the two-state solution.
18:53 - Is all the talking about a two-state solution part of the problem?
19:18 - Why some people argue for a one-state solution
This episode features:
Diana Buttu - Palestinian lawyer & analyst; legal advisor to the PLO negotiating team 2000-2005.
Nathan Brown - Professor of political science, George Washington University
Gideon Levy - Israeli journalist & author
Mouin Rabbani - Co-editor, Jadaliyya
Rami Khouri - Distinguished fellow, American University of Beirut
#Palestine #Israel #Gaza #GazaWar #OccupiedWestBank #OccupiedEastJerusalem #PalestinianState #TwoStateSolution #PalestinianAuthority
You can find all Start Here episodes here: bit.ly/3o0BEIW
Subscribe Al Jazeera so you don’t miss future episodes: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow Sandra Gathmann on Instagram and X: @SandraGathmann
And let us know in the comments if there’s a topic you find confusing and would like Start Here to cover ⤵️

Опубликовано:

26 мар 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 3,9 тыс.

@aljazeeraenglish 10 дней назад

You can find the full Start Here playlist with all our episodes here 👇 ru-vid.com/group/PLzGHKb8i9vTxodrArxXFPziklf0iqFdC5

@bretedwards2899 Месяц назад

In 1948, Jordan took control of the West Bank and Egypt took control of the Gaza Strip, leaving the Palestinians with no land in which to declare a nation (and the Palestinians did not declare any desire to form a state when occupied by these nations). The other Arab countries were more than happy to expand their nations at the expense of an independent Palestine. BTW, except for Jordan no Palestinian refugees have been given citizenship status in other Arab countries (for over 75 years). These actions imply that the other Arab nations have no real loyalty to Palestine and use it as a political ploy only for internal political reasons.

@user-ey5om1td2q Месяц назад

TRUTH

@fatheranthony4pope Месяц назад

There lack of being given citizenship is because those countries believe that they should have the right to return to the land the Israelis stole in 1948

@user-cy4wj5ds2o Месяц назад

Why should arab countries take the palestinians in? Palestina is their country.

@starman1994 Месяц назад

@@user-cy4wj5ds2o Call the land by its real name, Judaea.

@user-ey5om1td2q Месяц назад

@@user-cy4wj5ds2o - Yeah? so how come they said nothing in 1948? From 1948 to 1967 the Palestinians did not establish a state when Jordan and Egypt ruled over Judea and Samaria and Gaza. they never said a word like occupation. know why? Because it was an Arab conquest of a Muslim country. It was only when the Jews occupied the place in the war of existence that the Arabs got angry and started creating blood plots that Jews get up in the morning and look for people to murder them, just like that, like Dracula. The Palestinians never established a state here and when they were offered 80 percent (1947) they said no. The Jews prayed to Jerusalem for thousands of years, built Solomon's temple there 2500 years before Muhammad was born and Zion (Zionisem came from zion) - the ancient name of Jerusalem is mentioned 150 times in the Torah as the place God chose for his people, Israel. Maybe read about it, a little general knowledge won't hurt you. Also read about the attack on Petah Tikva and Al Husseini, you don't have enough knowledge

@sonosofisms Месяц назад

There are several important facts left unsaid in this summary. Let’s consider two. Firstly, the British Mandate for Palestine (1920-48) consisted of land on both sides of the Jordan:: west (“Jews allowed”) and east (“Jews excluded”). The eastern half was three times as large, and allegedly of higher quality land for agriculture. Secondly, in 2005 Israel disengaged from Gaza. Within two years HAMAS was in power, and has de facto been the responsible authority there until now. Neither of these two important facts are discussed in the al-Jazeera report.

@EitanTs 29 дней назад

Wait until they figure out what Hamas did to the PLO once they got into power.

@8dksjd00kssj1 28 дней назад

Ofcourse not😂 what if they something that could hurt Hamaz

@yang8244 28 дней назад

Of course not...

@Kevin-yj4mi 28 дней назад

@@yang8244 bro what did you expect it's al jazeera

@thinkhector 12 дней назад

Because they are not important. It's all distraction and rhetoric to avoid the inevitable truth, that a lasting peace can only be accomplished by a 1 State Solution. Everything else is just whining, complaining, and foot dragging.

@Aleksssssssss Месяц назад

Hopefully someday Israelis and Palestinians will be able to live in peace and tranquility. Pray for peace

@musicandphonetic Месяц назад

and Jesus back when it happen

@andyroo9381 Месяц назад

There will NEVER be peace in the Middle East.

@Apollorion Месяц назад

But don't forget: _nothing fails like prayer._

@Hegemon1984 29 дней назад

thanks stan

@kornykorhorn 29 дней назад

I have Palestinian friends who love living in Israel currently.

@nathanabbou4206 Месяц назад

During the Naqba, you forget to tell that at the same time, 800.000 Jewish people who were established into Arab countries such as Algeria Irak Tunisia Egypt Marocco Syria and Jordan had to flee the threat of persecution. They left their homes too, and lost everything they had to move essentially to Israel. So that compensates. Do they have the right of return ?

@johnb8009 Месяц назад

Sure, they have the right to return. Much of the persecution was in response to the persecution of the Palestinians by the Zionist movement.

@user-mm3ie1dm1l Месяц назад

Yess you said......these idiots want to make their land free of other religions and make western countries influx with...olaa Uber..

@user-mm3ie1dm1l Месяц назад

Let's take an example Saudi. , UAE , Qatar their own citizens don't have the right to convert to any other religion

@user-mm3ie1dm1l Месяц назад

Actually Saudi Arabia is a very big country but. They will never accept these Palestinians into their country

@nathanabbou4206 Месяц назад

@@user-mm3ie1dm1l and also Egypt ! But it’s crazy because it’s the same people ! There is no difference between Arabs from Egypt and from Gaza, same language same genes same culture same religion same history except the past 70 years..

@aljazeeraenglish Месяц назад

Here are some more Start Here episodes linked to Israel and Palestine ⤵ Al Aqsa explained ➡ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Lb3v8M8dzic.htmlsi=nvS8R550mR3qxDKQ The fight for East Jerusalem ➡ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-b5RoQdlseMs.htmlsi=YNW2grTpytJ2DDYr The US-Israel relationship explained ➡ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oQJt8dwvs78.htmlsi=T4MoweNfmXpHw8-J And you can find the full Start Here playlist with all our episodes here ⤵ ru-vid.com/group/PLzGHKb8i9vTxodrArxXFPziklf0iqFdC5

@vinm300 Месяц назад

Al Jazeera never mentions :- a) 1922 Ottoman empire collapsed b) Israel's security : Golan Heights & Jordan heights c) 1947 Israel declare a state, but Palestine wait till 1988 : why ? Because in 1948 the Mufti looked to Damascus In 1967 the PLO looked to Cairo Arab League Nasser Al Jazeera paints a very, very biased picture.

@Alchemist340 Месяц назад

UAE good Dubai gone???...go Dubai...

@michaelaminov3505 Месяц назад

من أين جاء الله؟ هل خلق الله نفسه؟ 🇮🇱 ‎.الله غير موجود❌ ‎الله شخصية خيالية عاشت إسرائيل حبيبه انتي في قلبي إسرائيل❤ ❤️انا احب اسرائيل 🇮🇱 أُورُشَلِيم عاصمة إسرائيل الابدية ❌لا يوجد دولة اسمها فلسطين في التاريخ⛔ الله غير موجود. ‎ @@Wilson5768

@D-E-S_8559 Месяц назад

UNRECOGNIZE those who do not recognize others... UNRECOGNIZE those who do not recognize the law.... Such an act is not difficult, complex or complicated ....

@davidboi4025 Месяц назад

🇺🇸🇮🇱🦅💪

@francescobanco Месяц назад

The video ignores an important point. While the term “Palestine” is used today to describe what became Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip, at the time of the British Mandate, Palestine also included what is now Jordan. In 1922 Britain detached 78% of Palestine to become the Arab/Palestinian state of Trans-Jordan (now Jordan), and the League of Nations declared that the remaining portion should become a Jewish state (only later did Britain and then the UN decide to further divide the remaining portion into two parts). So it’s not very accurate to state that Israel had 78% of Palestine in 1948. In reality it had 15%. It also seems a little suspect that the video qualifies the count of 1,200 killed Israelis after October 7 with, “That’s according to the Israeli authorities” but does not qualify the count of killed Palestinians as being supplied by Gaza's Ministry of Health. Nor does it mention that that number does not differentiate between civilians and combatants. I’m not disputing either number, but it does indicate some level of bias.

@AhmedAhmed-ki1sd 28 дней назад

So today n now howmuch zionnazzi izraeli occupying d land of palestine n all !?still 15 %%%...wot qbout palestine!?hwmuch d they remainin land on their hands !??...

@ftftyffghfvghfcht6701 27 дней назад

because the palestinian count has been verified by other organisations. anyway its about the future. too much obsessing for both of them on the past. 90/10 split is not fair and wont be accepted. its been 100 years. just split it in half, but israel would never accept that

@tclanjtopsom4846 27 дней назад

Palestine was an area not a state, just like Africa. Just because someone takes the name of the area they live in doesn't mean it's theirs. The the archaeological record shows Jewish occupation in the majority of Israel.

@doraemon402 26 дней назад

As if that justified the partition, people migrating there and kicking people out of their homes

@tani123 23 дня назад

There is currently no Palestinian organization that does not support terrorism that receives the support of more than 30 percent of the Palestinians. For this reason, a two-state solution, at least for now, is simply irrelevant.

@davidpinkus355 26 дней назад

My understanding directly from Dennis Ross, is that Arafat rejected the best deal he was ever going to get. 97% of the green line territory, plus 3% compensating land in Israel, capital in East Jerusalem, etc. Arafat responded with an Intifada. Israel electing right-wingers was a response to this. The electorate had voted for peace-makers until the process failed. For there to be any hope, the Israeli public needs to believe there is a partner for peace; which they don’t. Israel could evacuate many of the settlements; I don’t think that’s the sticking point some believe. It’s the fact, especially after Oct 7th, that the populations don’t trust each other at best, and hate each other at worst. And until there is a functioning government in the West Bank and Gaza, there really isn’t anybody even to talk to. Honestly the best solution may be for Egypt to administer Gaza and Jordan to administer parts of the West Bank for a generation or two until a generation can be brought up who believes in peaceful co-existence.

@zephsmith3499 25 дней назад

Alas, Jordan and Egypt have zero interest in taking on that project. Jordan has a bad history with the Palestinians trying to overthrow their government, and is glad to have a border between them and the West Bank. Egypt feels similarly about Gaza - with Hamas being strongly connected to the Muslim Brotherhood which is fighting the Egyptian government. To administer the territories, they would need to militarily occupy them, and fight the same struggles that Israel is fighting - but with a less robust economy to support their forces. I do understand your point tho - it would be a possible solution im some areas, if only it would work in these other areas, which it unfortunately does not.

@adah4163 24 дня назад

Nobody wants the Palestinians because they are untrustworthy and a problem in every way.They teach hatred in schools and praise terrorists as martyrs.

@tani123 23 дня назад

@zephsmith3499 23 дня назад

@@tani123 I take your point. And I am curious - which Palestinian organization has even 30% support while not supporting terrorism?

@shinyshinythings 23 дня назад

After the destruction wrought on Gaza, it will be hard to find Palestinians who believe in peaceful coexistence after ten generations, let alone two.

@davidlanders2853 Месяц назад

The Cherokee nation could tell you a bit a bout a "two state "solution

@tani123 23 дня назад

@davidlanders2853 23 дня назад

@@tani123 And who is responsible for the lack of governance in the occupied territories? Over the history of the state of Israel they have made every effort to undermine any development of an effective Palestinian governance. Much like we have done to our First Nations people here in the US. We have our own kind of "settlers" here.

@dailylearning1706 Месяц назад

She kept saying there was a war multiple times without stating who started the war. If you declare war on a country and the country fights back and wins, including extra land, the land belongs to them. That is simple to understand. Also, Hamas did not automatically end up controlling Gaza. There was a civil war, and Hamas sent the Abas party/faction out of Gaza with guns. You are so economical with the truth.

@Abraham-xi9ep Месяц назад

Ah, zionist revisionism, you hasbara trolls are delusional.

@B-... 29 дней назад

I have no opinion on most of what you said, but the United Nations explicitly states that you cannot conquer land by war. Even if you're defending. Hitler sort of illustrated the problems with that. Just wanted to correct you on that point. In no legal way does the land belong to Israel unless we throw out the rules-based order we've spent 70 years building. The rest of this is a mess, but that part is absolutely crystal clear, without a doubt. And almost the entire world including Israel's allies agree with that statement.

@jaybee9269 28 дней назад

People have stood on conquered land and said, “This is mine,” literally throughout all human history.

@vishnusunilkumarsasikala674 28 дней назад

This is aljassira what else you expect? Qatar sponsor hamas

@carrie33888 28 дней назад

Right. Typical Al Jazeera news, carefully crafting a narrative that avoids inconvenient truths. She never mentions who attacked first, just that a war somehow mysteriously began. I wonder why… also she totally leaves out the persecution of Jews in the Middle East/North African diaspora and their claim to their indigenous homeland - even though they comprise the majority of Israelis, she only mentions migration of European Jews to Israel. Further she gives in depth explanations featuring these other talking heads defending Palestinian violence against Israelis - but when it comes to the reverse, she just essentially blames Israeli nationalism without going into detail.

@ishaan2947 Месяц назад

If al jazeera is making a documentary on historic census of who lived on the land, they should make a similar one for kashmir too

@arielcombalicer8118 Месяц назад

No. They are pushing for two states which is GAZA and WESTBANK from the river to the sea.

@saul3332 28 дней назад

@@arielcombalicer8118 That is everything.

@cloud-devops2741 27 дней назад

Then They will be exposed. I am not taking any side here but clearly they are trying to show Israel on the wrong side. Now we can understand if they do a documentary on kashmir which side they will take

@mishar8889 27 дней назад

And Pakistan

@prangonweb93 27 дней назад

And for Balochistan

@chrisalex001 24 дня назад

I get that Israel's response to Palestine is exessive, and that perhaps the Arab nations and the West should do more to further a two state solution. The truth is that Israelis are not going anywhere and Palestinians are not either. I think this video's title was strategically used to bait watchers into watching it. It does bother me everytime they claim Israel has not accepted a two state solution simply because reasons. Israel does not want that constant threat of being attacked. Look at what happened with the PLO, it is useless now. Hamas has gained control of Palestine until the recent war. Israelis understand that Palestine is not truly ready to become a state, not if it has no real peaceful leadership. At this point, I get that it is hard to start fresh with all the massacres that have taken place. The problem is that Israel is not going anywhere, and Palestinians deserve a better life. Perhaps a buffer de-militarized zone is required, something in between Israel and Palestine. Perhaps Israelis should move out of the occupied territories as a sign of respect. There is much room for improvement. Israelis should admit that they don't think highly of Palestinians at all, and that retaliations are often brutal to say the least. Palestinians should also realize that Israel is not stupid enough to grant a two state solution to a place run by unlawfull people to say the least. There is a lot of lying and bs on both sides, including this news media and the cute host.

@thinkhector 6 часов назад

You missed the most obvious solution to all the problems you mentioned: the ONE State Solution. The two state solution has always, to be blunt, been a garbage solution.(For one, a larger Palestinian State would still be a theat to Israel.) There are many benefits to a one state solution. It includes making Israel safer because their neighbors wouldn't attack with such a large Arab population. You simply have to get past the idea that it is irrelevant whether the land known now as Israel is majority Palestinian or majority Jewish in the future. We don't care about ethno-states. Just like South Africa wasn't divided, neither should the land and people of Israel/Palestine. One nation, two peoples.

@Marss13z Месяц назад

Haven't the political entities of the PA and hamass repeatedly rejected, for whatever reasons, proposed two-state solutions? The only rational choice is peaceful coexistence but that option seems to be consistently rejected by the Palestinian authorities. What to do?

@hamoda3191 Месяц назад

Ignorant, PLO recognised Israel

@Marss13z Месяц назад

@@hamoda3191 PLO isn't the PA. They're still calling Israel the "entity".

@thinkhector 12 дней назад

The United States can impose a 1 State Solution with both parties weighing in on the details. Nobody cares weather South Africa would be ruled by white or black South Africans. The only concern is ending the Apartheid system. Whatever becomes of the land and the people in the future is irrelevant. And really just an excuse to delay the 1 State Solution.

@RoyalBlue292 Месяц назад

Everytime i hear, let's talk about two state solution. I'm like let's "talk what rights did Britain have to give away someone else's country to European atheists, they don't want in their own countries"!

@Entertainment690 Месяц назад

absolutely right.

@shehannanayakkara4162 Месяц назад

@@user-uv9tl4jt8w Never. Even before the Ottoman Turks, it was ruled by the Mamluks (non-Arab former slaves), then the Ayyubids (Kurdish), then the Crusaders. The land hasn't even been ruled by Arabs for a millennium, let alone a Palestinian state.

@blablablaclaclacla9895 Месяц назад

Palestine people lived there for past 2000 years. Go to school to read some history @@user-uv9tl4jt8w

@Entertainment690 Месяц назад

@@user-uv9tl4jt8w that denial has shown how Israeli bots brought up Israeli Jews argument. At this point, I'm curious why the German kicked these people out. Oh wait, or the European Jews are such selfish against the Germans so that they had to do something about it. Feel free to call out the anti-Semitic anytime you can't think of anything creative. None is going to work nowadays.

@blablablaclaclacla9895 Месяц назад

@@shehannanayakkara4162your own version of story😅😅😅😅

@Manushg4 Месяц назад

Can you see that huge black triangle next to gaza in the partition plan of Palestine? Its called the Negev desert and it is qlmost impossible to live in. The Palestinians didnt want it. That is why the Israel got "more" land than Palestine in the initial partian plan.

@seerOfNatur 27 дней назад

She didn't mention that Palestinians fled because Arab leaders commanded to leave, not because Israelis would expel them. Arabs who staid are living in Israel now and are Israeli citizens.

@acmulhern 5 дней назад

Your information is wrong. Where did you learn that?

@seerOfNatur 5 дней назад

@@acmulhern Let's agree to disagree. Certainly not on Zionism conspiracy propaganda made started by Soviet and Arab propaganda. There are many official sources: "The existence of these refugees is a direct result of the Arab States' opposition to the partition plan and the reconstitution of the State of Israel. The Arab states adopted this policy unanimously and the responsibility of its results, therefore is theirs; ...The flight of Arabs from the territory allotted by the UN for the Jewish state began immediately after the General Assembly decision at the end of November 1947. This wave of emigration, which lasted several weeks, comprised some thirty thousand people, chiefly well-to-do-families." - Emil Ghoury, secretary of the Arab High Council, Lebanese daily Al-Telegraph, 6 Sept 1948

@seerOfNatur 5 дней назад

@@acmulhern Let's agree to disagree. Certainly not from Zionist conspiracy propaganda spread by the early Soviet Union and arabs. Plenty of information on that in newspapers from newspapers around 1948. I can't post links on youtube. Start by looking for an answer on Quora, not some hysterical media. Look for "Is it true that in 1948 Arab leaders urged Arabs to leave Israel, and not to return until they defeated Israel (which never happened), whereas the Jews urged many of the Arabs to stay (and those who did have done well in Israel)?"

@think-about-it-777 27 дней назад

This is the most polite but overly elaborate way to say: "A look at this FUBAR map partitioning forcing people who hate each other to live next to each other and then let's act surprised when they can't be peaceful"

@zoltankaparthy9095 Месяц назад

This was a two state solution at one time. But the Arab states did not like it and invaded Israel. And they kept doing this. The Arab states do not seem to want a two state solution. The seem to want to have a one state solution: no Israel. It has been this for 75 years now. When will the Arab states stop blaming Israel and start to look at their end of the deal?

@Yogmusa319-liq1 Месяц назад

Correct , but I need to add that there was a Jewish state thousands of years ago. It is the only Jewish state in the world.

@entertainment-mj1rv Месяц назад

watch the video. They might have rejected initially (which they had the right to, if I invade your home and offer to split it 57% and 43% you would reject it) but in the end they did agree to it per the 1967 border, but Israel wants all.

@jaydiddly1106 28 дней назад

@@entertainment-mj1rv There was no invasion. The split was mostly based on the concentration of the people: Israel with the mostly Jewish communities, the rest Arab. Of course the non-biased commentator forgot to mention that the 57% of the land was mostly in the southern part of what is now Israel, which is a desert. The Arab portion contained most of the arable land in the divided region.

@entertainment-mj1rv 28 дней назад

@@jaydiddly1106 it was illegal occupation. The land was few percent jews but over a couple of decades European jews with the help of british overtook the land. Changing the demographics. Remember the British had to right to give someone elses inhabited land to someone else. But unforetunately the british have a tendency to do this everywhere, Asia, Africa, South America etc...

@elsabishop7669 27 дней назад

The problem seem to be, who controls Jerusalem. What has Islam to do with Jerusalem other than they once conquered the land.

@aljazeeraenglish Месяц назад

🏆Start Here has been nominated for two Webby Awards, which honour the best of the internet. If you enjoy this series, please vote for us via the links below. It only takes a minute and we appreciate every vote! 🙏 vote.webbyawards.com/PublicVoting#/2024/social/social-content-series/news-politics vote.webbyawards.com/PublicVoting#/2024/video/video-series-channels/news-politics From Sandra & the Start Here team

@Porter90 Месяц назад

Palestine will be free... Free from Hamas and palestinians. From the River to the Sea Israel is all that will be. 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 Mauslemz lost the war. Right now gazans are running, crying and praying to their prophet and his 6yo wife. Will he save them? Nope. Justice for Aisha (she was 6).

@user-bg9zq9eo4h 28 дней назад

Does this really matter right now?

@tclanjtopsom4846 27 дней назад

It's great to see the vast majority people see this for the rubbish it is, you can fool some of the people some of the time but you can't fool them all. This video is so biased it's laughable and the cherry picked "facts" are anything but. I advise you to watch the Dr Phil episode on the Palestinians that has the hamas leaders son admitting some home truths. You sound fresh from a western university, don't worry you grow out of it.😂

@CosmosChill7649 21 день назад

The juice do not want to give Palestines equal rights, including voting in the land they occupy. Nor do they want them to live seperately. And the Palestinians do not want to live as slaves in an apartheid state Thats why juice see ethnic cleansing as the way out

@zeitgeist5134 14 дней назад

@@Porter90 Oh, my dear. Can you hear yourself? "Palestine will be free...from Palestinians." Examine your conscience. Look with clear eyes at your statement...because, it sure does sound like the Final Solution. You don't want to say anything that sounds like that. Deep down inside, at your core, you're better than that. Question yourself. Go deep. Somehow, you have allowed yourself to be tainted by a hatred equal to that of the..... Don't let yourself hate. You're doing yourself harm. Do not try to rationalize it, explain it away. That would only do you further harm. You're poisoning yourself. Don't.

@caialan9491 Месяц назад

You are absolutely right. Follow Singapore way of government. One state, one parliament represented by both parties. One nation one people united to focus on trade and national development for all people.

@mellowInventor Месяц назад

Seriously! It is one of the most strategically situated areas in the World, it could be a powerhouse if the two sides didn't war. However, even if every Palestinian laid down arms, Israelis would not lay down theirs: they keep theirs to turn on themselves if they view it necessary, it is a barbaric practice by humans today 😢

@jaybee9269 28 дней назад

Gazans (and Jihadi Palestinians generally) don’t seem to have a constructive bone in their national body. So that will never work.

@hamsareew1547 Месяц назад

Imagine taking 78% yet wanted to negotiate the remaining 22%...Is Israel ok?

@cocofluff Месяц назад

I agree. After the 60's war, Israel should have claimed all of the land as Israel and encapsulated all Palestinians as Israel permanent residents under equal laws for all. They would have been able to better police terrorists, control what Palestinian kids are being taught, and this dual society of inequality would not have existed.

@Seyiwale6127 Месяц назад

America doing .

@adarshverma2014 Месяц назад

@@cocofluff But palestinians are more in numbers. That would mean they can elect their own leader by voting. That would cease the very existence of jewish state.

@sh25098 Месяц назад

Palestinians owend 8% of the land in 48. That is why the un was generous with them and offered them 50% of the land. Only that Palestinians said no and now have nothing.

@samchris3793 Месяц назад

@@cocofluffexcept It stops being a Jews only country and they become a minority in their own country. Not going to fly with Israelis at al

@asifkhan4822 Месяц назад

A 2 State Solution has always just been a talking point for Western Politicians.

@user-wm5rt9pw5l Месяц назад

Excellent, there will be a 0 state solution for the Palestinians

@DarkCreed86 Месяц назад

@@user-wm5rt9pw5lExactly. There's no other way round it. The jews are not just going to pack up and leave. Two states is the only way to fix this.

@chidefes4903 Месяц назад

so then whoever wins wins

@ArtisanVibe Месяц назад

Our politicians know that this is a predominately Christian nation. That's why Trump is playing with Bibles. They know they can't split Israel. It's not going to sit well in America.

@eds1942 Месяц назад

No, they idea was that if there was going to be lasting peace, that the two people that live there would and should work it out for themselves. And that is part of the reason as to why it has become cliché. Because if a nation or group of people can be liked unto a person, than both persons here can’t act like adults and one of those has the backing of the US which feels religious compelled to back them.

@jeremywilson2875 Месяц назад

In 1977, PLO leader Zuheir Mohsen said "The Palestinian people does not exist ... there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians, and Lebanese. We are all part of one people, the Arab nation [...] Just for political reasons we carefully underwrite our Palestinian identity. Because it is of national interest for the Arabs to advocate the existence of Palestinians to balance Zionism. The existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons". They came up with the "Palestinian" identity in the 1960s in order to justify why Arabs receiving some 99.3% (Peel Commission) or 98.1% (UN Partition) of the lands of the British and French mandates was not enough, and that Jews shouldn't get anything despite being in the majority in the lands designated in both plans.

@italo8995 Месяц назад

Do you have any source for this information?

@daskalospapas1883 Месяц назад

In 1776, leader George Washington said "The american people does not exist ... there is no difference between Germans, English, Italians, and Irish. We are all part of one people, the European nation [...] Just for political reasons we carefully underwrite our american identity. Because it is of national interest for the europeans to advocate the existence of america to balance british imperialism. The existence of a separate american identity exists only for tactical reasons". They came up with the "american" identity in the 1700s in order to justify why Europeans receiving some 99.3% or 98.1% of the lands of the British and French mandates was not enough, and that british shouldn't get anything despite being in the majority in the lands designated in both plans

@icysaracen3054 Месяц назад

Europeans are all part of one body are they not? Hence we have a European Union????

@Apollorion Месяц назад

@@icysaracen3054As Darwin has already said: all humans belong to one and the same race. So Europeans are, no matter whether theist or not, whether Russian or not, whether poor or not, whether Chinese or not, whether African or not, whether Indian or not... , part of one body, e.g. the celestial body which we call in English, the Solar System.

@Boulderman Месяц назад

@@daskalospapas1883 As a United States citizen I think you need to study American history better. My own ancestors fought in the American revolution, and it was to gain our independence from England and become a free and independent nation. France helped us do that. We always thought of ourselves as American's and not Europeans. Our ancestors are from all over the world and not just Europe. America is the melting pot of the world. Maybe you are just joking.

@antonboludo8886 Месяц назад

This is never going to end.

@vozdemando1111 Месяц назад

I heard the Almighty cursed this land.

@cinspectorblyatrussauttp4354 Месяц назад

What a foolish mistake it was not to accept the initial partition. What an even more foolish mistake to then try to invade Israel immediately after the rejection of the partition.

@PaylessCars-jw6df Месяц назад

Wasn’t as simple! The war was going into happen anyway Israel had already prepared it military backed by powerful allies.

@user-xx2hj7xb6b Месяц назад

Yeah, the Arabs made a big boo boo in rejecting the UN partition where they would have ended up with more land then they did after the 1948 war. That said, I doubt it would have resulted in a lasting peace.

@zuleimarobinson7964 Месяц назад

Thats pointless Israel had zero intention of respecting any partionand had Plan D the entire time they had every intention of removing Arabs from Palestine they smuggled weapons in for years. The west never intervened because it benefited them politically to have European Settlers there its a strategic position.

@mohammadalhashmi6080 Месяц назад

dont talk about politics if you dont know anything about it

@cinspectorblyatrussauttp4354 Месяц назад

@@mohammadalhashmi6080 Show me how these actions were not foolish. By the immediate consequences, I think it is clear - all this video did was make me feel bad for the Palestinians because their leadership even since 1948 (and their exploitation by other countries) has been awful.

@MultiCconway Месяц назад

How does one negotiate with a party that says you must go away (completely, do not exist anymore)?

@brokenrecord3095 29 дней назад

Isn't that kinda both sides in this dispute?

@kornykorhorn 29 дней назад

No, because Palestinians live peacefully in Israel. I know many Palestinians, who love living in Israel currently. However, Israelis cannot live peacefully in Palestinian areas. Let’s not forget this.

@MultiCconway 29 дней назад

@@kornykorhorn it is interesting how Palestinians can live in Israeli areas peacefully . . . BUT no Israeli can safely live in any Palestinian area safely. That fact kind of says it all.

@aniketprasad3128 28 дней назад

@@MultiCconway yeah cuz Palestinians only have 22% to live and out of that also, a lot is housed by Israelis

@MultiCconway 27 дней назад

@@brokenrecord3095 Not when one side can trace its claim to the land all the way back to Ancient Times before the birth of Christ. Volumes of archeological evidence proves it every day.

@ghoraxe9000 28 дней назад

How about a 3 state solution... The 3rd is a in-between buffer zone where both can enter and cooperate .. this would provide a bigger barrier too

@jonathana2695 25 дней назад

Out of curiosity. If it was to turn out to be a one state solution, would you rather it be controlled by Israel/Democracy or Palestinians? If those were the only two options.

@solimar1554 Месяц назад

Wouldn't it be nice if all people could stop the hyperbole and focus on negotiating a secure agreement. Hopefully, the Arabs of Gaza will choose to be more like the UAE than Syria. Only then will these people be truly free.

@hamoda3191 Месяц назад

Israelis should stop elect far right wing

@nathanabbou4206 Месяц назад

When you present the partition map from the UN with 56% to the Jews, you forget to tell that the Negev desert lies for 90% in the Jewish part. So that the inhabitable land would then be largely in the Muslim part. Your numbers 56/43 are misleading.

@hbt739 Месяц назад

I mean the hole thing is cleverly crafted propaganda with them no saying who started the wars, the terror attacks between the wars and so on. It shows palestine in a good light and israel in a bad one. The best example would be the beginning were they establish the history and jump over the fact that the jews were there first with kind david and instead only speak about the arabic histotical claim or the jumping of the first intifada strted by palestines or not cleary saying at any point that the palestines used sucide bomber against israel during the second antifafa

@zuleimarobinson7964 Месяц назад

For 11 percent of the population say maybe 25% in 48 whats the problem? They got the area they inhabitanteD at the time we dont live in biblical Times they should never of been given anything. The reason Israel won even in 48 was weapons & funding ftom the USA & UK. Jews were welcome in Palestine the problemwas they wanted the land entirely as well as other areas of the mid east.

@amaannanji3113 Месяц назад

You forgot that the population of Palestine was double of that of israel

@nathanabbou4206 Месяц назад

@@amaannanji3113 population of Palestine = Jews + Arabs + Christians. You mean Arabs ? Yes they were 2 times more than the Jews in 1940, but infinite time less in 50 BC, when, in Palestine, there were only Jews and Arabs didn’t exist yet… ;)

@hamoda3191 Месяц назад

@@nathanabbou4206 What a peace of ignorance that shows you're Israeli Palestine was only jewish ? That only means you mothfs came from a land on Iran and Iraq borders and imposed your religion on Canaanites but guess what you're ignrant that didn't happen

@bretedwards2899 Месяц назад

To have an agreement there usually needs to be a trust that both sides will honor that agreement, until this happens do not expect an agreement to occur.

@epicchocolate1866 16 дней назад

There really isn’t two sides. No one is really advocating for Palestine legitimately, HAMAS operates in gaza but there’s no unified voice, that has actual influence in West Bank or gaza, and until countries like the US recognize Palestinian sovereignty, there will only ever be extremists and radicals, and no legitimate governance

@samaracontigo2023 Месяц назад

I would like to know if it is possible to geographically split the land exactly in the middle so both ethnic groups can have access to the sea and an international airport for economic development and live in peace. Thank you for your attention.

@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад

if Israel insists only a one state solution can work , then they must grant equal rights to all in this one state regardless of culture or creed, at present do Palestinians get to vote in the knesset ? they are subject to its laws

@silvia-vm7fe Месяц назад

No, it isn't possible . The Arabs showed on October 7th what they want to do to the Jews . The only 1 state is in Jordan where they have to go .

@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад

@@silvia-vm7fe can we agree on this , a section of the Palestinian community of millions , a few thousand , commited the acts of oct 7th , however the backlash is putting millions of lives at risk , escalation isnt good , what needs to happen is equality and fairness , this will of course require concessions but it is the way forward

@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад

@@silvia-vm7fe it is humans that create borders mainly but sometimes it is also geography , both people have the same desire , a land that stretches from the river to the sea they can share it fairly but they must be treat equally

@thegame7557 Месяц назад

@@tomfinney3416when there was an agreement with Arafat there was an attempt to have open borders. Events forced construction of high walls and fences. Can both sides operate without violence

@tomfinney3416 Месяц назад

@@thegame7557 yes i think so , its the lack of ability to vote in who is govt be it israeli for palestine or palestinian for israeli , could they have one govt where each are accorded equal rights in who governs israels knesset has diverse factions mostly over zionism ie pro or anti , they pass laws that affect every moment of not only israeli citizens but palestinians too i only know a bit of each language , two words , same meaning merhaba , shalom

@louistan7560 Месяц назад

If the State of Israel could be created out from nothing, what's the difficulty with formalising Palestinian ownership over their own lands and recognized by the UN?

@ch.3569 Месяц назад

It ignores realities on the ground and displaces some 700k people and no one is even sure who would rule it and ensure security. Also by "right of return" The Palestinians in Jordan, Egypt and Lebanon want into Israel proper thats always been a big sticking point Israel refuses and the Palestinians demand.

@cocofluff Месяц назад

Palestinians lost that right after two wars and countless terrorist attacks. You win the war, you take the land. That's how war works. You don't hand over the land to the losers. There is no return to those old UN lines. Too much has happened since then.

@hahdakdahkdhalsla Месяц назад

Israel is already exist for 2,000 years!.

@accomplice7 Месяц назад

pretty sure we got jordan for that

@tl-ih8uk Месяц назад

The Palestinians never said yes to that. Israelis tried a bunch of times.

@pteechka1 26 дней назад

It's all well and good for the US, the UN, the Arabic League, or anyone else to call for a permanent cease fire and/or two states, but realistically, there simply isn't enough support for either idea on the part of Israelis and Palestinians, no matter who mediates, no matter who encourages, no matter what is proposed.

@philipv2500 Месяц назад

It's called Israel, the name before the Romans renamed it Palestina. And it’s written in the Bible, the book explicitly named in the Qur'an.

@thevillaaston7811 28 дней назад

And that helps how?..

@azahel542 27 дней назад

The name of the land was Judea though

@cestlextase 21 день назад

bash a book so loud you cant hear the 20,000 kids murdered

@MyVanir 8 дней назад

@@azahel542 Judea was one of the two jewish kingdoms in the region, the other being Israel, which used to also include Judea. Both were client states of Babylonia, until Israel revolted and was basically destroyed, their population exiled across the empire. The reason the land was called Judea is that that was the name of the kingdom that survived. So yeah, it was the name before the romans made up palestina - there was just another name between and both are still jewish names.

@yeryuzusessizgokyuzumavi9299 Месяц назад

We want a free Palestine. You can't disturb them in their homes

@LordOfSweden Месяц назад

You mean like arabs do in Europe?

@PapiiAloye Месяц назад

Do you people really no the land that Empire of Roman rename to be Palestine? Israel,Jordan and part of Syria. So tell me

@bakhtsherali2894 Месяц назад

@@PapiiAloyeyou begged for shelters, palestine gave you, and in reeturn you ingrate have done something which is unprecedented. You are complete inhuman and ingrates.

@PapiiAloye Месяц назад

@@Chaim_Stern which is your land? The kingdom of Israel or Judah? His king David,Saul and Solomon Palestinian or Hebrew? Making them Jewish

@jamese5936 Месяц назад

You realise the only realistic free palestine is Gaza + West Bank only right?

@MendeMaria-ej8bf Месяц назад

Please remove the background noise. It's disturbing.

@robinhood4640 Месяц назад

The disturbing part is someone thinks it's a good idea.

@MendeMaria-ej8bf Месяц назад

@@robinhood4640 Yes, but that's why we feed back. ☺

@kajonyjony1683 Месяц назад

How articulately represent and so nicely you are. thanks for clear this matter

@MxGrr 25 дней назад

Excellent video. Almost 100yrs if history condensed and explained in a clear and simple way. Now, there’s nothing simple about this problem, which in essence comes down to human trauma, and carries a tone of historical emotions. To Israelies and Palestinians, it’s time to leave the past behind and move into the future. Both sides will have to give up something in exchange for peace. The question for their leaders is precisely that. Do you want peace, or prefer the warring status quo.

@Popman04 Месяц назад

How did the British came in control of that land far from Europe, what about the history of the people who were living there before the British's arrival and renaming of that land...

@nickb- Месяц назад

Palestine was controlled by the Ottoman Empire (Turkey) for hundreds of years but they were on the losing side in WWI. The League of Nations asked Britain to temporarily run the Palestine region while they worked out a strategy for permanent government and borders. This was called Mandated Palestine because the Brits were given a "mandate" to run the area.

@Popman04 Месяц назад

Alright, I get when the British jumped in the story, thanks ...Can we rewind further back please, periods of 1st -2nd dominant empires of the world, we can even keep progressing up to the dominance of the Roman's empire to have a better undestanding of the regional conflicts&Claims

@xmarksthespot6699 Месяц назад

that's what you called, spoils of jihad

@komenaja311 Месяц назад

before that there is no United Nation, who win the war, have everything, the roman occupied Israel and took the land from the jews, Ottoman took the land of israel from the roman, and the British won the ww1 agaist ottoman, and gave back the land to Jews! that simple! Two state solution proposed because there are many arabs people been there since ottoman rule that area! the Arab nations against that! you can see wars after that up until now

@sith24773 Месяц назад

Because POWER equals control. Period

@allison210 29 дней назад

Mostly a good video. I was watching for bias and didn't see much, except for a couple instances. At 18:33, it's clear that the Israeli ambassador was cut off in the middle of her sentence and the subtitles indicated it was the end of a sentence, creating a misleading effect. It sounded like she was going to say "no unless" but I'm not sure. I also noticed at 16:39 that the figures for death tolls on Oct 7 and in Gaza were presented as "according to Israeli officials", but not as "according to Hamas officials." Finally, I noticed that though the Nakba and the Palestinians who were displaced during it were discussed, there was no discussion of the approximately equal number of Jews who were displaced from nearby Muslim-majority countries and who had to flee to Israel as refugees during the same time period. I think this is an important piece of information to include. But overall I found the video informative.

@eric2500 25 дней назад

Maybe awkward and impossible and really difficult to put into practice but it is has not been tried,and if the plans for it are somewhat less than honest, that does not mean an honest attempt would be a failure. Honestly if it were up to me I would draw a line that no one would like and force people to go to one side or the other. Then I would have an army enforce it - for at least one hundred years.

@capricrescent Месяц назад

What is the use of a state if the leaders are corrupt and do not bring prosperity, security etc...

@ibrahimhamza5571 Месяц назад

Ur right if can’t establish justice in Jerusalem the holy land Than u don’t deserve to rule it

@capricrescent Месяц назад

@@ibrahimhamza5571 which one is better ruler Palestinians or Israel? For 75 years, Palestinians just did destruction, not giving any positive results to their people. 75 years for Israel make them one of the advanced nations in the world.

@toddb9313 Месяц назад

I have never understood this 2 state solution question. The 2 states and their borders are given in UN Resolution 181, to try and steal land from Palestine because you have occupied it for 50 years is a WAR CRIME.

@987ujhpl Месяц назад

The arabs did not accept the 1947 partition

@norman4588 Месяц назад

It was under Ottoman Empire then to British Empire after they defeated the Ottoman in World War 1.

@user-sq3qk5zy5s Месяц назад

Strange - I fear you may be confusing conquered land and stolen land - every time Israel conquered land it was when Arabs attacked 1st - and lost on repeated occasion - heck, Israel could've conquered a heck of a lot more - and didn't. Have a problem w conquered land? Then you'd have a problem w just about every country.

@phillipaclemons7261 Месяц назад

Israel won wars only with the weapons and funding from the most powerful country on the planet

@user-wm5rt9pw5l Месяц назад

This resolution was an attempt to establish boundaries by law so that they would not be drawn in blood. The reason for this resolution is the abandonment of these territories by Britain. You are either ignorant or a vegetable.

@miguelllano4459 Месяц назад

For Aljazeerah the two state solution contemplates one State in the Land - Palestine and the other in the Sea - Israel. Very durable peace!

@maxmillianwiegel1643 Месяц назад

I would like to point out for the original partition plan: a large degree of the land allocated to Israel is desert. As in, unsuitable for actual development. Perhaps that should have been mentioned.

@probreed Месяц назад

Putting tribes of people who don’t want to live together together is not a solution. Take a look at Africa, as an African we have civil wars and tribalisms . One tribe governing and making laws that will affect others. Two state solution a necessity

@jdcarling Месяц назад

if you dont lke israel go to Jordan, lebanon, egypt, syria, iraq, yemen, saudi, etc....

@saravidal5861 Месяц назад

hmm 2m Arabs in Israel out of a population of 7m

@unreal4good367 29 дней назад

@@jdcarling and if you don't like Israel then go to america and all the western countries that israel has on a leash

@kymmillbank8889 14 дней назад

So, who started these wars? What happened to start them? What is the history in Gaza? Was there a war between Hamas and the PLA? What happened during that? You missed a lot out.

@leejackson3268 13 дней назад

she left out every part of the story where the arabs attacked first

@juliangarciaquigua8617 26 дней назад

this presenter has like an ethical aura and power , I do not know how to describe it, reaaly beautiful.

@gregpaul7395 Месяц назад

Interesting video, but why do you keep misquoting the figures. In actual fact 77% of the British Mandate Palestine was given to the Hashemite dynasty to rule over and Israel were offered a portion of the remaining 23% only.

@kam70111 Месяц назад

In one state, everyone is equal. What is a two-state? Are you making it into the Maldives Islands? Dual citizens should go back.

@asewrweerwer9833 Месяц назад

Two-state is two states. Like Germany and France. The number two comes after the number one. It is bigger than the number one. It represents two of number one. Double of number one. Monkey understands?

@silvia-vm7fe Месяц назад

Nope , not possible and never will be

@bushranizam4722 Месяц назад

Those who have dual citizenship ..they shd go back to where they came from

@DarkCreed86 Месяц назад

Problem is. The jews have shown they can't respect other religions. There's plenty of footage of them spitting on Christians. Put everyone under their rule and it would end poorly for the minorities.

@michaelw2288 Месяц назад

Like India and Pakistan after partition in 1947.

@margauxlaurenpelijates3112 Месяц назад

May God Bless humanity, and give PEACE to All!... Separate each country ....Have an assurance for Peace without underground tunnels, avoid harming each other..After all they are real brothers!

@juligrlee556 27 дней назад

The US has lived somewhat successfully with several nations within it. For example the nations of Finland, Sweden, Germany, Poland, Ireland, many numbers of First Nations, the African diaspora and more. Of course there also is the Confederate States and the Northern States and the one time Texas Nation and the nations of territories of the Pacific, of Alaska, of SW former Mexican lands etc. People from different nations can live together if their constitution requires equalities of the peoples.

@user-sf2nv4sp1k Месяц назад

It was not a war of independence it was a war of occupation of Palestine, before it was occupied the British colonial empire. It was a war of independence when Romania (1877-1878), the Greeks, the Serbs and the Bulgarians had fought against the Ottoman (Turkish) Empire.

@arpitcheema2501 Месяц назад

If someone is fighting for Their existence then it is war of independence

@jdcarling Месяц назад

the failed ottoman empire murderously colonized israels land for centuries along with the mamluks, caliphate and romans, they are all gone and faded. Israel is back home.

@MyVanir 8 дней назад

Except that most of the land in the region was already owned, as in bought with money, by jews. Before the mandate was ever dreamed up by the same fucktards that jews wanted to escape, rich jews from europe were basically buying up every bog, swamp and sandbar they could. And after they bought them, they gave the land to jewish settlement, who then dried up the swamps and transformed trash lands, that their arab owners never even tried to fix, into ones that are actually worth living in. At which point the arabs started attacking and trying (and sometimes succeeding) to massacre any settlement they could in concerted attacks every now and then. And that's beside the fact that some jewish cities were under a state of non-stop siege, pretty much.

@gabrieljosefmerrun3088 Месяц назад

Joseph Borrell the high representative of the Europe union for foreign affairs and security: "Anyone who wants to avoid the creation of a Palestinian state must support Hamas and transfer money to Hamas. This is what we are doing this is apart of our strategy. To finance Hamas so there will never be a Palestinian state." Do you know who said that? NETANYAHU in the Knesset, mars 2019.

@burnbeetlejuice9232 Месяц назад

Evil devious satanaziyahuu

@user-mq9ln7hm3q 26 дней назад

I would love to understand, maybe someone can explain to me - every nation, if it is a nation, aspires to exist in its own sovereign state. The Palestinian resistance arose around this in the first place, as you said... so wouldn't giving up a Palestinian state alongside an Israeli state actually be to silence the Palestinian nation? (In my opinion, both nations have equal rights that deserve a state, because otherwise the solution is genocide) And if there is only one country - how can it be a democracy? In Gaza, we saw that democracy does not work for the Palestinians and there is a reign of terror (I have family there so I know that for sure) in Israel too, there have been demonstrations about democracy for a year, because there is no democracy when there is an occupation and large parts of the Israelis understand that... but at least there is an infrastructure Democratic and it is possible to demonstrate that it is very different from Gaza... so what is the proposal actually? To turn Israel into a non-democratic state that subjugates the Palestinian nation? I would appreciate a respectful explanation. If it matters, I'm half Israeli and half Palestinian, so I understand both sides and can't see a solution.

@davidreichert9392 27 дней назад

Simple fact: not being able to live side by side with other people who are culturally different (somewhat) to you is just plain stupid. Now looking forward to hearing different people saying that only the Israelis or Palestinians are guilty of this, as though such stupidity doesn't exist on the other side.

@oisinm332 Месяц назад

Two people the same captial city, that is insane. I do not see how that could work. Even the idea of the two state solution is a bit to much of a pipe dream.

@buddygrimfield7954 Месяц назад

I cannot help but to wonder when people decry even so much as the possibility of a 2 state solution, whether they actually want for it to happen. Or do they simply see it as an unattainable outcome.

@oisinm332 Месяц назад

@@buddygrimfield7954 A large part I'd imagine is both sides thinking, why should they compromise. Many just want the other group gone.

@buddygrimfield7954 Месяц назад

Or perhaps some combination of both. I mean, peoples of opposing ideals have lived in the same place all throughout the entirety of human history. It is only the greed and religious/ethnic entitlement of the few which seems to get in the way. Other than that, most people do want to basically just live in peace. Or at least the very least reach some level of basic stability.

@oisinm332 Месяц назад

@@buddygrimfield7954 Exactly

@samuhlm2 Месяц назад

Palestinians need to gtfo and be taken in by a Muslim country. Sorry its been 75 yrs, theyve continued to insist on violence so theyve lost their opportunity.

@country-matters0.4 Месяц назад

Yes this is possible but only if America does not interfere in it.

@norman4588 Месяц назад

Wrong Statement. It's possible but only Israel Far-right Extremist Government does not Interfere.

@uchiha6284 Месяц назад

Lol, you stupid or what. Palestine rejected the two state and 5 Arab countries attack Israel.

@MikeNEVILLE-xf4bc 26 дней назад

Good luck with that ! They interfere in everyone's business..much like china and russia.

@thomassherwood5061 7 дней назад

Obviously it's completely different, but the Good Friday agreement specifically says that they're not trying to answer the Northern Ireland question, they just want the answer to come politically not violently

@g.b.alejandro6268 29 дней назад

It's possible... only the UN and Netanyahu are both stubborn up to this point.

@wilirobinhood Месяц назад

I think it's pretty clear that neither side wants peace. Its unfortunate that so many non-combatants are caught in the middle of a situation that has no solution

@nickb- Месяц назад

For many years I think Israel genuinely wanted peace and tried to achieve it. They even unilaterally withdrew all citizens from Gaza. Now attitudes have changed and both sides have given up on the idea of peace.

@SlickSimulacrum Месяц назад

Nice twoside-ism. You are an imbecile.

@Chris-qo4rt Месяц назад

Israel wanted peace, they have been constantly attacked by people who want to see them dead

@Yogmusa319-liq1 Месяц назад

No, this is not correct, Israel is the ancestral home of the Jews. it is their only homeland. the Israelis always wanted peace and offered it to the Palestinians with Land, but the Palestinians want more and more and more it, and they are never happy. So this sounds like more of a one state solution to me. The Palestinians only want to have that Land they don’t wanna give it to Jews. This is evident throughout the whole of the history. The voices that are being drowned out, here are the Shah of Iran Who understood the Palestinian situation very very well. He called them bullies . Arafat based his war on Israel, on the success of the FLN in Algeria against the French the FLN demonised the French and created an international condemnation against the French and eventually the French left full stop in every country that Islam is taken over they behaved in the same way. Israel is no different The fact is Israel is the only Middle Eastern democracy. It looks after its Arab and Muslim and Christian inhabitants. There’s no other country that does that in the Middle East.

@GTA5Player1 22 дня назад

One side is represented by a literal terrorist organization, and the other side is a nationalist government that thrives on projecting strength. Yeah, tough to see a way out of that one.

@moonpluto Месяц назад

The whole two state solution idea was just arab lebensraum and dar al islam. Jordan, Syria, Egypt and Lebanon are the palestinian states. There is no difference between arabs in any of these countries and the palestinians. Genetically, culturally, religiously, culinarily, linguistically. They are one people as Zuheir Mohsen said in 1977. The word palestine doesn't exist in arabic. There is no p sound. The whole thing is immoral and illegitimate and the world's sublimated antisemitism. Conscious and unconscious.

@besimple4592 Месяц назад

F sound , hasbara

@B-... 29 дней назад

Create a state based on a religion.... Blames every critique of that state on anti-semitism. This is pure nonsense in it's purest form. Conflating Israel with jews as you do is the actual anti-semitic argument because it boils an entire religion down to the actions of one tiny political nation state. That's extremely prejudiced and you don't even seem to realize it.

@MyVanir 8 дней назад

@@besimple4592 Except that the romans, who invented the term, used P, not F.

@j.f.7509 29 дней назад

The British plan of 1939 (the White Paper) called for a one-state where 'Arabs' and 'Jews' shared a government. It could be a federal government with much autonomy on both sides, and there would be the need for a 'Truth and Reconciliation Commission' as the one in South Africa. It's either something like that or a regional war that could go out of control...

@warrinbang1191 26 дней назад

"My soul hath long dwelt with him that haterh peace. I am for peace: but when I speak they are for war " Psalm 120:5-6.

@kroubian Месяц назад

Lots of people in Israel thought it was possible and worked towards that end. Unfortunately the Oct 7 event closed that possibility for the near and possibly far future.

@maxixe3143 Месяц назад

I think you meant to say "the war crimes committed by the IOF in the wake of Oct 7". If Israelis really wanted a single state, they wouldn't have denied basic human dignity to the population of Gaza and the West Bank. I am not condoning the atrocities committed on Oct 7, but to pretend they happened in a vacuum and that Israel didn't create the circumstances which led to it is irresponsible and ignorant.

@ScratchyYard Месяц назад

@@maxixe3143*IDF

@avarania Месяц назад

@@maxixe3143💯💯

@KanstantsinChernik Месяц назад

Yeah, there were two states until Oct 7

@Flexinciple Месяц назад

⁠@@maxixe3143Think for a moment: if you really wanted that Palestinian State did oct 7 advance your cause or set it back tremendously? Also remember that Israel and the Israeli society is the more powerful of the two sides in every way possible (economy and military). So you would need them or a significant majority of them to come to the table for that free Palestinian state.

@ARABICDHOTSTORY Месяц назад

I totally agree the regime must change to make it safe for everyone ,but I think if that happened the the regime that is in RIGHT now will be finished and that what they are afraid of LIKE IT HAPPEN IN South Africa the majority will always win.

@thegame7557 Месяц назад

I don't think the south African example applies in this case. That would be true if Izrael did not have any Arab population. Attempts by Izrael to annex the territory for all of it to become one state have been met with resistance. If Palestinians want they can allow Izrael to annex all the territory and then they will demand to be treated like izraelis

@ARABICDHOTSTORY Месяц назад

@@thegame7557 there is apartheid and discremination that even the palestinain that live inside the green line are facing so do not tell me this is defrent its an accupation the majority are ARAB palestinian there is also a refuge in libanon and jorden and syria so this regime is dreaming of a state that has no future in the Middle East no mather how much they have killed or going to kill they accupation will always be the minority population and them staying there is not possible they may think there is a chance by forcing themseves but that is not realistic my deer

@nickb- Месяц назад

Do you realise that the Jews are the majority? There are 7 million Jews in Israel and only 4 million Arabs in Gaza + West Bank.

@Gertunet3103 28 дней назад

one of the problems is, that the arabs don't want a jewish state in their Dar al Islam. They have 7 millions km² of land and they dont want to let even 30 000 km² to the jews. They prefer the jews llike dhimmis. I think, that that describes very good their mentality. About 800 000 jews had to leave the arab countries after the foundation of Israel. About 800 000 arabs had to leave theirs homes after being told by their chiefs to leave the country, so that those chiefs can push the jews to the sea. And you dont have to forget that those 800 000 arabs came mostly from the other arabs countries. Irak, Jordanie, Egypt, Syria.. You can see this, by looking at their names. They come to Israel, for they hoped to have a better live there, I imagine.

@moralisoppression2837 11 дней назад

That's why it is much safer to place the jewish people in Christian country.

@LincolnMaurice 9 дней назад

800k Jewish people did leave the neighbouring countries, but to say that they "had" to is a misunderstanding of the events at the time. The majority of Jewish migrations into Palestine, now Israel, was voluntary emigration for the purposes of consolidation, in an expectation that they had finally been successful in their divine promise. By contrast, the expulsions of Palestinian people is nowhere to be found in the Hebrew texts. In other words it was a choice to move. I'm sure not all had hostile intentions, but the establishment had hostile ramifications, which has never quelled since.

@leorenier1 23 дня назад

An excellent analysis, on which a reasonable plan can be built: a one state where the rights of everyone are protected.

@JoeGoogol Месяц назад

This has for some time seemed the most obvious take away from everything we have learned. Its utterly bizzare to me that people are still fighting over partitions that few agree upon, as opposed to focusing on human rights and style of government.

@greggbisgrove7499 Месяц назад

Someone tell me why Israel was recognised by the UN but not Palestine

@mangloreanwithabeard Месяц назад

Jews existed in Isreal even before islam came into existence 500 years after Christianity, whole Israel belongs to the jews ... No two states solutions...only Israel the Holy Land of David ✝️🇮🇱✡️🕎

@waldemarmarwalde6817 Месяц назад

Because Israel controls the area. And palestine does not.

@khalidrashad-xu8xe Месяц назад

Because the UN is an illegitimate zionist baby 😂

@KathyXie Месяц назад

Back in 1949 the UN only had 58 member, most of Africa and Asia were still colonies. Australia, New zealand, South Africa, Republic of China and most countries in the Americas voted in favour to admit Israeil, even the Soviet union, Ukrainian and Byelorussian SSR voted in favour, they have hopes Israel would become a socialist country. Only a handful of muslim majorities countries and India voted against. Palestine at the time was divide between Egypt and Jordan.

@ch.3569 Месяц назад

It's explained in the video, Israel accepted the partition and proclaimed a state in 1948. Palestine instead bet on the war and the 5 Arab states that invaded. Palestine didn't claim to be a state till Arafat while they where under Israel control.

@joeanderson8839 24 дня назад

I have watched this conflict, prayed about it, spoken out, voted for candidates who were for peace,and done everything in my power to make peace in this land happen. I am done. People don't care enough about this conflict to listen to both sides. Netanyahu has used his power for years to take more and more land from the Palestinians. And radical extremists on both sides have done everything in their power to stop every effort from succeeding. There are people on both sides that want peace. But every plan and agreement is sabotaged by people on both sides who refuse to let peace happen. All the other Arab nations have kept the Palestinians armed, and kept the radical extremists in power, at the expense of the Palestinian civilians. I don't see any of these nations helping Palestinian refugees. Nobody wants them in their country. They are being used as pawns on the stage of international theater. The fact is that nobody in Israel and Palestine are going to have peace because of the determination of those who insist on destroying the other. The United States has armed Israel to protect the Jewish people who live their. But most of us don't want Israel to continue to steal the land. Israel does not recognize the human rights of Palestinians, and Palestinians don't recognize that there are some Jews who want peace. I am so tired of it. There is nothing more to do but let them fight it out. I feel sorry for all of the people in this country who want to live in peace with each other. I don't know what will happen to these people if there is no law to protect the civil rights of every man, woman, and child regardless of their religious beliefs. There must be a government that protects the rights and property of all people. Not a government just for Jewish people, or just for Palestinians. There must be a separation between church and state. People must be protected and represented. Land must not be stolen. People must stop killing each other.

@rajiroqeeb4203 Месяц назад

You have been doing an amazing work since the way in gaza began…nice job…However…I just want to ask if you can really do any of your episode on Rwanda 1994 genocide as the country is currently mourning…. Thank you.

@essajoulani1083 Месяц назад

I believe as a Palestinian that the Jews should be very happy that the Palestinian people agree to a two state solution, as we all know that the land belongs to the Palestinian people.

@michaelaminov3505 Месяц назад

@cocofluff Месяц назад

ummm given the current situation I think it's the Palestinians who should be 'very happy' if Israel agrees to a two state solution. Which, after Oct 7th, will NEVER happen.

@bernaguvenc4029 Месяц назад

Now the power of colonialism, apartheid and occupation with its powers in the UN has been revealed and still being tried to be enforced, it's obvious that there should be only one state of Palestine whom were there under the Ottomans and jews were shipped!!! to join them. Zionism as israelies are the base, is not a concept acceptable and who'd want a neighbor as israel???? who hates, despises arabs yet surrounded by ONLY middle eastern countries??? One state of free Palestine from river to the sea is the only solution so these repeated apertheid and mass murders come to a halt!!! Isn't it why US, UK, Germany, France is trying their most to accomplish with their aid so Israel so it can stay??? Their colors are obvious and we the world people seen enough! One Palestine, free, from river to the sea✊️🇵🇸☮️🇵🇸

@50healthandwellness26 Месяц назад

@@cocofluff How about what's happening from 1948 on Palestinian land???????????

@50healthandwellness26 Месяц назад

You aren't Palestinian. Palestinnians are the ones fighting NOW, and dying for their land.

@timtrewyn453 23 дня назад

It has gotten so bad, sometimes I think all that can be done is to support people on an individual level to have a home somewhere they can make progress in life. When you see lots of money pouring into an area, it certainly looks tempting to a few to seek their fortune by keeping things stirred up. The average person seems caught between the greed on both sides.

@Bobbydyland 29 дней назад

In 1947 there was a 2 state set up. Arabs rejected the 2 state solution. In 1948, Israel was attacked by it's 5 neighboring states, and beat them back, taking ground. The fukaround and find out cycle 1. In 1973 Israel was attacked again leading to the state of affairs that we find ourselves in 2023. The fukaround and find out cycle 2. In 2023 Isreal was attacked again, leading to the current conflict. The fukaround and find out cycle 3. Hamas was voted into governmental power in Gaza, and has broad support (according to this video). What's happening to the people of Gaza is terrible but no worse that what happens to the Berliners who supported Hitlers wars in the 1930's and 40's. The fate of those people is heart breaking but is it the fault of the nation who's defending itself or the one who started the wars?

@bhj1124 Месяц назад

Two states solution is a false promise to the Palestinian people. It should be one state where everyone has equal rights and justice and the end of the apartheid system.

@cocofluff Месяц назад

The Palestinian people have NEVER wanted a two state solution. That's a western idea.

@user-wm5rt9pw5l Месяц назад

@@cocofluff Well, the Palestinians are getting closer to a "no state solution" situation.

@sh25098 Месяц назад

Israel will never agree to this. Why should they share their country?

@ibrahimhamza5571 Месяц назад

@@sh25098because they will never live in pace by occupier a whole nation and also it’s the the right think to this what justice and pace the land of Jerusalem the holy land it’s the land of pace and justice do u know that when Jerusalem was under Islamic rule Muslim and Christian and Jew lived in pace for more than thousand of years in Jerusalem if u can’t establish justice in holy land than u don’t deserve to rule it

@dannyv2468va2 Месяц назад

@@ibrahimhamza5571 Peace was because it was poor and under Turkish rule. What the Palestinians want is all the land and to kill or expel all the Jews. Nothing else will satisfy them. They are careful not to say that in English. That is because all the stupid westerners who support them will have to acknowledge that it would be the 2nd genocidal holocaust. Israel is never going to allow that.

@sueleeves2600 Месяц назад

Informative

@bobdhoffnar 26 дней назад

Great content but the sound effects and music are major distraction. The loud clicking sounds and low whooshing make it so I need to ride my volume control in order to understand the dialogue.

@nini199863 23 дня назад

1. Well actually it was 55% for the arabs and 45% for the jews, and after the arabs rejected the offer, they started the attack on the jews. Later, the arab nations joined the attack against the jews. 2. You have to mention the fact that before 48, the jews were called Palestinians too...and before this land was called palestine, its name was "judeah" and it was a jewish kingdom...

@hermionegranger__ Месяц назад

3:38 That was ridiculous!!! What would happen if the land in Ukraine were divided into 44% for Ukrainian majorities and 56% for Russian minorities?

@user-bx3hz6wl5m 28 дней назад

That's a good point. We sit here and tell Ukraine to keep fighting and not negotiate yet we tell Israel to negotiate and be ready to give up land.

@Sim882 Месяц назад

It seems obvious when you start war and lose, you lose territory Palestinians would be lucky to get anything at this point

@B-... 29 дней назад

Hasn't worked this way since WW2. Wars for conquest are against international law.

@merlemullet6723 26 дней назад

Your bias was subtle and your commentary well done. It gives rise to hope. But, as with all contentious issues, the real meaning of the terms used is critical. Dispensing with the unreality of a "two-state solution" is a good start. Pursuing a Palestinian "stake" in the Nation of Israel is a voice that can be heard. But before that can be a reality Palestinians must agree that the "stake" they pursue is not a stake through the heart of Israel. Palestinians must reject terror. That cannot happen until terror as a force for change is utterly defeated.

@9um9um9um 20 часов назад

Do really have to edit it with quick dramatic 1 sec images and dramatic music? Just inform us.

@isugeayub9707 Месяц назад

Not for Israel land

@mangloreanwithabeard Месяц назад

@Porter90 Месяц назад

Day 1: Palestinians dancing, singing, celebrating and cheering for hamas for what they called "VICTORY". Day 2 onwards: Crying like babies and seeking for help, lmao. Israel has a right to exist and has a right to defend itself. Hamas should never have started something they couldn’t finish 🇮🇱. There wouldn't be any borders or fences if gaza wasn't a terror base, and that's a fact, whether you like it or not. P.S. Mohaumad had a child lover. Justice for Aisha (she was 6).

@arso3335 Месяц назад

Neither side wants two-state solution and that is a fact and there is no point talking about it. Palestinians want state “from river to the sea” (without Jews) and the Jews are accepting the current situation with 2 million Arabs living amongst them, West Bank populated with 700 thousand Jews, and Gaza without Hamas (preferably under some Arab governance). This kind of arrangement is acceptable (not officially) to most Arab states also. But Iran stirs the pot. Therefore, when theocratic Iran regime falls, situation will calm down.

@fazoumanasanogo2660 Месяц назад

If this is true, why are there so many Israeli centers chanting death to arabs

@nochannel1q2321 27 дней назад

Israel has made at least five formal offers of a settlement with the Palestinians since Camp David which include an independent Palestinian state consisting of the Gaza Strip, 97% of the West Bank (with the 3% being offset by other territory and being Israel's only requirement of the Palestinian demands) and recognizing its capital as East Jerusalem. The Palestinians would need to recognize Israel and its right to exist, halt attacks and see 3% of West Bank land removed and the same amount of land added elsewhere for the same total. Every other term is literally just what Palestine demands. Each of the five times the Palestinian representatives have refused. They currently refuse to even be negotiating (Israel has been open to negotiations up until 10/6 and will likely be again after Hamas is eliminated as a threat).

@chickenbutt420 8 дней назад

Palestine has jews? Palestine wants illegal settlements, war crimes, and systematic discrimination and oppression to stop. They want to be able to, I don't know, have clean water, electricity, and medicine. Israel wants to flatten Gaza and build a parking lot.

@antbrown9066 Месяц назад

Thanks. Interesting history lesson. However the current situation is not one of history but of ideology - and behaviour. There is no justification from any source, for the events of October 7.

@joshhh92 8 дней назад

Ok, 1967 “Israel pushed out” … no mention of what war that was??? Sketchy doc. Didn’t Egypt begin going back on their word and the reason why the war started.

@NoNameNumberTwo 5 дней назад

My understanding is that Israel fired the first shot in the Six-Day War.

@michasosnowski5918 Месяц назад

The initial partition of the land was so stupid that it would make impossible for these two countries to live in peace. Who divides the country like a 4 color squares flag? The countries would then fight to have more or better borders. Unfortunately for the Palestinians, the Israelis had support from the USA, so they won more and more over time. Its uneven fight. The Palestinians also could agree on some settlement, but they wanted more(Arafat broke the negotiations). They stupidly hoped that they could negotiate and fight for more, ignoring Israel military power and support from the USA.

@user-qy6jm9tz2f Месяц назад

U.S. support started after 1967, so first learn history...😂

@SuperCedric35 Месяц назад

Please could you cover the hamas election. Was it a coup?

@nickb- Месяц назад

They don't run stories that might upset Hamas

@CamiloSanchez1979 27 дней назад

I feel terrible for the state of Israel but at this juncture, we must accept their actions are morally questionable. The moment that Israel and its people supported the creation of settlements, Israel crossed a line. Understandably they probably followed the path of the US in its westward expansion, but history is not only on the books. History will not be kind to Israel at this point. This does not legitimize the actions of October 2023, but we must acknowledge that for every action, there is a reaction. Thus, the US and the world must rethink its support to Israel unless its government reconsiders a serious path where Palestinians are returned land or incorporated with the same rights of an Israel citizen.

@timc1604 12 дней назад

Yes. It is possible, but everyone has to respect the other side’s right to self-determination. And right now many don’t.

@ysha7971 Месяц назад

The trouble is the borders! Jerusalem should be international with an airport where everybody could go directly. The ruling should be organised with representatives of each religion. If Palestinians can't return to their homes they should get compensation. Everything is possible if it is fair.

@BertWithoutErnie 29 дней назад

But everybody wants it all. 😂😂😂 Them pride!

@gregg2696 Месяц назад

How about we discuss a 51 state solution, 50 Muslim majority countries the size of North America, Central America and some of South America combined (22 of which are Arab majority countries, the size of the continental US), and 1 Jewish majority country in their ancestral homeland the size of New Jersey?

@khaoula_art Месяц назад

There are also Palestinian Christians. What about including christian countries to the solution? 🤡

@mohamedamer-ti9lx Месяц назад

how about a 68 state solution? 67 christian majority countries and 1 Jewish majority country ?

@gregg2696 Месяц назад

@@khaoula_art Christians? Seriously? 98% of the population in Gaza, Judea and Samaria is Muslim. And neither Jews, Christins, nor anyone else who is not Muslim is allowed to live as an equal in any of the 50 Muslim majority countries.

@BoroHoroSan Месяц назад

nuub. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 there a million chinese,indian,asean christian refugee....why would america take them? because u nuub in geopolitic.🤣🤣🤣🤣

@jdcarling Месяц назад

im pretty sure they are not the ones raping jews@@khaoula_art

@tnt1674 11 дней назад

I have to say that surprisingly this is more or less an accurate description of how the events have unfolded. I did not understand how from 500K Arab residents according to what I believe is the British records, there were 700K Arabs removed from the houses in a matter of years. But every number outside of the British records are always changing, and I get it. The reason why Palestinians never got a country has to do I believe, with their tendency to terror and violence together with the geographical location of the West Bank. Israel did not have a problem giving back Gaza. I don't believe even the settlements are an issue, they were originally set there as a defense line against Jordan. The problem is that Israel is supposed to trust the Arabs in the West Bank, that if they were to declare a country, they would not initiate an attack against Israel. Different from Gaza, such an attack will be more devastating because it is so close to Israel's nerve systems. And Israel never took that leap of faith, and the Palestinians only became more affiliated with Terror acts instead of showing any different side of them.

@Mrtassan Месяц назад

The picture at 19:37 explains so much in itself.

@9thGuy Месяц назад

Anyone with brain can now understand why isreal wanted hamas to stay in power. Their strategic is that they wanted hamas to fight with them and later they can occupy more territory by defeating them. Hamas have no chance to win this war. Isreal have air forces, navy and u.s support.

@gregoryjones7712 Месяц назад

Its on the Palestinians to switch strategy otherwise they're gonna keep getting rolled on and it ain't my fight I'm not Jewish nor Arabic I'm American And America first not Israel or the 3rd world

@Idanharat Месяц назад

We really don't want to occupy Gaza.

@user-ey5om1td2q Месяц назад

Whoever made this video should be ashamed of themselves. Either he is retarded or he deliberately distorts history. It is unbelievable how much incriminating information against the Arabs you have omitted. The Arabs attacked Jewish settlements as early as 1886 in the Arab attack on Petah Tikva, then in the Arab riots in Jaffa and in 1921 and 1929 and 1936 the Arabs boycotted Jewish trade in Palestin together with the Nazis in Germany. That is the truth about the coexistence lie of the Arabs. They lie that they lived in peace with the Jews while they murdered them and attacked them long before Zionism, which basically said we would have our own territory alongside the Arabs. If the Arabs had agreed to the peace proposals and the 1947 partition plan, today they would have 80 percent of the territory and the Jews - who said yes, would be happy with their 20 percent. Instead they prepared for war and attacked with 5 armies - what did you expect? That we die after the holocaust in silence like the Arabs planned for us in 1941 together with their leader Husseini?. Thousands of Jews were murdered in those years (1886,1921,1929 etc) and the Jewish population was deported from place to place by the Arab rioters when the Ottomans did not intervene and then the British did nothing to protect them either. That is why the Jews established organizations such as the Haganah and the Shomer. In addition, where did the Arab leader - Amin Al Husseini go? Where is his picture with Hitler? He hoped and planned to bring the holocaust to the Middle East, he sent volunteers and money to the Nazis. But apparently the truth is not important to you. Only the blood plot against Israel.

@essenceofachosen6407 Месяц назад

Hamas is merely a guerilla force, and as Scott Ritter said "A guerilla force wins if it doesn't lose". Or at least the Israeli mighty army loses it doesn't win. So far Israel is losing, regardless of how bad Hamas's situation might be.

@user-ey5om1td2q Месяц назад

@@essenceofachosen6407 - guerilla force? R U for real? IKN what is up with your brain (do you even have one?) but whoever shoot rockts at civiliens for 20 years and kill 1500 civiliens in 6 hours + kiddaping 233 civiliens including babies i call terorites. I was shot by Arabs just for - what? A war they lost 70 years ago? Because the Jews are the minority ( were back then and now - 8M vs 22M or so) they always agreed to a compromise proposal and agreed to the partition plan of 1947. The Arabs did not. I wonder why. Perhaps because their leader - Amin Al Husseini -( you adore him a know) collaborated with Hitler in 1940 and made the Arabs think that all the Jews would be gassed long before they had to live next to them. Oops in 1947 this is no longer an option! Well, invade Palestine with 5 armies and eliminate them all! Oh, it didn't happen, may God have mercy on us! What to do? We send our children to school where we will teach them that one should die trying to kill Jews and infidels - to be a martyr. Ugh, the new Nazism is Islam.

@humn_rights Месяц назад

I agree that we already have a one state and what is needed is to fix it by ending discrimination and apartheid.

@halukkilic3171 Месяц назад

Wouldn't work - ziyonsists are too jenow cidal insan.e.

@cocofluff Месяц назад

I agree, but after Oct 7th that will be impossible. There is too much hatred on both sides and they don't see each other as human now, let alone equal.

@humn_rights Месяц назад

@cocofluff true, it is hard to imagine but it is not impossible. The slavery was end, S.A. apartheid was ended. German French wars ended. And most parties to conflicts are accomodating each other. If we don't try we will never know.