Тёмный

Is it time to rethink democracy? | Head to Head 

Подписаться
Просмотров 270 тыс.
% 2 616

In this episode of Head to Head, Mehdi Hasan challenges the renowned economist and thinker Dambisa Moyo on why she believes liberal democracy is under siege and requires a radical overhaul.
The best-selling author first made waves with her book Dead Aid where she argued that foreign aid was preserving poverty in Africa instead of relieving it.
Now, the former Goldman Sachs banker and World Bank consultant is taking on an even bigger target: liberal democracy.
In recent years, the West has been said to be in crisis. The election of Donald Trump in the United States, the UK's Brexit vote and the rise of far-right parties across Europe have all been cited as evidence of the failures of the current political system.
In her new book, Edge of Chaos, Moyo provides her own diagnosis for the recent rise in populism and provides a radical blueprint for change.
"The notion that democracy is not a problem is mad. It's crazy".
Dambisa Moyo,
We challenge her on whether her plans to save it - by giving some voters more power than others - will end up killing democracy instead. We also ask if economic growth is more important than political freedom.
Speaking about China and its economic model, Moyo commented how "over 300 million people have been moved out of poverty in 30 years" and suggested that the West should be careful not to "point fingers" when commenting on the country's democratic record, which was on its own particular "path".
We are joined by a panel of three experts:
Jason Hickel, anthropologist at University of London and author of The Divide: A Brief Guide to Global Inequality and its Solutions.
Ann Pettifor, author of The Production of Money and one of only a handful of economists who correctly predicted the financial crisis.
Jamie Whyte, director of research at the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) and a former New Zealand politician and philosophy lecturer.
Is it time to rethink democracy? with Dambisa Moyo will be broadcast on August 3 at 20:00 GMT and will be repeated on August 4 at 12:00 GMT, August 5 at 01:00 GMT and August 6 at 06:00 GMT.
Head to Head is Al Jazeera's forum for ideas, a gladiatorial contest tackling the big issues such as faith, nationalism, democracy and foreign intervention in front of an opinionated audience at the Oxford Union.
More from Head to Head on:
RU-vid - aje.io/headtoheadYT
Facebook - AJHeadToHead
Twitter - AJHeadToHead
Website - aljazeera.com/headtohead
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: AJEnglish
- Find us on Facebook: aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/

Опубликовано:

 

3 авг 2018

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,1 тыс.   
@domingo2977
@domingo2977 4 года назад
I think these 2 fell in love when she is the first person to actually insult him while in a public tv debate.
@Iwaxberrox
@Iwaxberrox 4 года назад
Alex Leigh she came off as straight rude and irrational.. what are you on? 🤦🏽‍♂️
@MamadouFalilouSARR
@MamadouFalilouSARR 4 года назад
You cannot be more right!
@samanthataylor1761
@samanthataylor1761 3 года назад
I was thinking the same thing. She put him in his place. 😂🙃
@marylms5777
@marylms5777 3 года назад
@@Iwaxberrox ¹
@Best-bw4xr
@Best-bw4xr 3 года назад
@@samanthataylor1761 No she didn't ... she just seemed argumentative. The most unintelligent speaker I have heard brought on this show so far. In to the trash can.
@bornfacesikanyika2605
@bornfacesikanyika2605 2 года назад
I keep on listening to this debate over and over again. They is a pure flow of wisdom in this
@eden493
@eden493 2 месяца назад
the chaos, the drama of it all
@lau_dhondt
@lau_dhondt 5 лет назад
Can't think of a more compelling talkshow. Great work
@bloodhun23
@bloodhun23 6 лет назад
We don't need to rethink democracy. We just need to beat fascism again.
@skepticproof
@skepticproof 6 лет назад
i had her same views when i was young, now after 7 years in the work force i rethinked a lot of opinions, educated people are not always the solution and they tend to be opportunistic and lack empathy
@skepticproof
@skepticproof 6 лет назад
educated people were not specificaly educated on taking good decisions in votes ! hence educated people are also broke or thieves imposters and and and ..., just like everybody else passing a physics exam does not make you a good voter lol
@kimobrien.
@kimobrien. 4 года назад
@@OpiumBride What they fear most is the working class taking power from them. The Chinese Communist Party is no more communist than Norway is socialists.
@OakleyANDSittingBull
@OakleyANDSittingBull 4 года назад
​@@skepticproof, *Indeed!* They tend to be *very classist* and *ableist* and often *racist* as well.
@Iwaxberrox
@Iwaxberrox 4 года назад
True, she literally said that she empathizes on growth versus emotional reaction from common people... 🙅🏽‍♂️
@kimobrien.
@kimobrien. 4 года назад
@@Iwaxberrox Growth of profits and privilege no doubt.
@AntonyWanyama
@AntonyWanyama 5 лет назад
"...I said 'what if', what if is a question, what if is not a statement" :D
@j.j.714
@j.j.714 3 года назад
This is episode probably had the most interesting questions, awesome job!
@Glickan
@Glickan 5 лет назад
Why so few clicks?! this is like the best thing I've seen in a long time.
@danieldboyharper7414
@danieldboyharper7414 3 года назад
His hate for America makes him hard to watch. He calls America terrorists but then ignores all terrorism related to Islam.
@umerabbasi834
@umerabbasi834 3 года назад
@@danieldboyharper7414 wiki leaks
@eniktedi4399
@eniktedi4399 2 года назад
@Chuck Green of Green Drywall Solutions look, VICE worshiper, lol🤭
@s.konyine1469
@s.konyine1469 5 лет назад
this black woman is so intellectual am rwandan, i love how u silenced them about our country even though ur not rwandan even though they were not even willing to understand u
@robroy7456
@robroy7456 4 года назад
She’s so intellectual. Why?Because she can parrot what the white man taught her? She a tool of her globalist masters used to impress people like you.
@kapambwekapambwe4131
@kapambwekapambwe4131 2 года назад
Slow down son
@s.konyine1469
@s.konyine1469 2 года назад
@@robroy7456 we need to think as Africans
@s.konyine1469
@s.konyine1469 2 года назад
@@kapambwekapambwe4131 no slowing down in Rwanda 🇷🇼
@jeffreyfinch8609
@jeffreyfinch8609 6 лет назад
More of an argument than discussion. Not letting her finish, and just criticizing the author.
@kindinohubert8962
@kindinohubert8962 2 года назад
Exactly!! How can you get an answer when you don't even allow author finish answering your questions. Bad journalism.
@subditamerop8141
@subditamerop8141 2 года назад
can't believe that I watch it in 2022 (being too late). this is one of the fiercest debates ever. Dambisa is boldly unappologetic which is deservedly so.
@josew9438
@josew9438 5 лет назад
That moment Mehdi told everybody she worked at Goldman Sachs for 10 years. Her credits dropped to 0.
@Qwerty-ff1cr
@Qwerty-ff1cr 4 года назад
@Adobo Those Because during her time there she worked on debt capital markets, hedge funds coverage, and global macroeconomics. Can you seriously tell me with a straight face that she had NO clue what Goldman Sachs (GS) were doing leading up to the global financial crisis of 08? She definitly lost all of her credability after she DENIED that GS was complicit AFTER they publicly admitted their wrongdoing and dishonest behavior which they even paid a huge fine for! Even if she did have no clue, then the answer would of been "I don't know", but to deny it after there's clear evidence and an admission of guilt? That's why I believe she lost her credability!
@jaykoo
@jaykoo 5 лет назад
I never believe democracy can bring economical improvement - LKY
@savvySevellianOfficial
@savvySevellianOfficial 4 года назад
IN this case, the interviewer was acting like a _robot that was programmed to ask specific questions and required specif answers_ . This is what happens when you don't read the book of the person you are interviewing and have other people tell you to attack a guest on specific phrases that they think will keep her quiet.*He only chose sentences that he thought he would use to attack her without reading the entire chapter.*
@aleemun
@aleemun 5 лет назад
Mehdi-"You were part of GoldmanSac, which is big part of problem. Are you right person to advocate any solution?" Mayo-"I don't understand your question, You don't understand how economy works". Not surprised, in fact Banon & Scarmucci would have similar answer.
@SajjadHussain-ei4vv
@SajjadHussain-ei4vv 4 года назад
I recommend all of you to check Plato's views about democracy
@stevefromsaskatoon830
@stevefromsaskatoon830 3 года назад
Lol , indeed
@Wadafwuck
@Wadafwuck 4 года назад
I really do wish speakers had second to explain academic material. The interruption helps get your perspective more than theirs
@descendantofdragon5906
@descendantofdragon5906 6 лет назад
in last thousand years, all countries is rules by the minority, democracy is also a Utopian
@520412Will
@520412Will 3 года назад
I LOVE this woman! What a fire show!!
@ThobiasMarandu
@ThobiasMarandu 5 лет назад
If you have to explain every chapter of your book? It is Not worthy a Penny.
@thesomalibrotherhood7112
@thesomalibrotherhood7112 5 лет назад
If I have to explain every chapter of this book Means you belong in the warehouse stocking shelves.
@nebyoudaniel2975
@nebyoudaniel2975 4 года назад
By far this is the topic that cant be discussed and argued upon in 47 minutes
@muhiziallan5534
@muhiziallan5534 4 года назад
Rwanda and H.E Paul Kagame are currently doing an amazing economic work....Facts
@themomentswithnature778
@themomentswithnature778 5 лет назад
Why episodes are not consistent in every week? We love this so much that whole week we anxiously wait for it..
@sunday4159
@sunday4159 6 лет назад
This was a great discussion ✨
@mohamedberrhili794
@mohamedberrhili794 3 года назад
She was kind of rude, attacking him personally and not his views.
@John-qi9cj
@John-qi9cj 3 года назад
Thats what medhi does all the time
@mutaenockbaisi1510
@mutaenockbaisi1510 4 года назад
She's fire!
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 3 года назад
No she is terrible and immature and not a great intellect
@kapambwekapambwe4131
@kapambwekapambwe4131 2 года назад
I can tell you've never had a chat with a smart woman
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 2 года назад
@@kapambwekapambwe4131 who?
@kapambwekapambwe4131
@kapambwekapambwe4131 2 года назад
@@JaKommenterar YOU
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 2 года назад
@@kapambwekapambwe4131 Yes I have while at LSE where many fellow grad students were U.S Harvard and Yale graduates etc as well, that’s how I know she isn’t truly intelligent. Respond directly next time if you are so superior
@hksnic
@hksnic 6 лет назад
Think this guest is tougher than the previous 2 by far.. in terms of argument and resistance to Mehdis counter points
@truhoodbitch
@truhoodbitch 5 лет назад
She definitely is. She gave as good as she got...well she gave better , although I'm not agreeing with her.
@sjive830
@sjive830 5 лет назад
I couldn’t agree more, I felt like she owned Mehdis, he was punching above his weight class this time around.
@WayneLash
@WayneLash 4 года назад
Agreed. Enjoyed her hustle. He backed off in part 2.
@Iwaxberrox
@Iwaxberrox 4 года назад
No. The notion that she talked over everyone who criticized her is a sign of desperation. Which is how she come off and no one would take her seriously
@BLKPlutoh
@BLKPlutoh 6 лет назад
"In a world of fake news, even urban legend becomes fact" 😲😳we as humans are in deep trouble. Edit- this was a great episode though.
@WoodwiseJoe
@WoodwiseJoe 5 лет назад
I am always ready for a steamroller when Medhi Hasan is the presenter but he had his hands full with Dambisa Moyo. I wish they would have allowed each other to speak.
@amirkhusroohamid9705
@amirkhusroohamid9705 5 лет назад
Agreed, Mehdi was challenged right at the start - and I am positive he personally didn't read the book.
@Zaid-vs2zz
@Zaid-vs2zz 3 года назад
@@amirkhusroohamid9705 why? He backed up everything he said
@vizalieporto4267
@vizalieporto4267 6 лет назад
I admire her assertiveness for pointing out some perspectives in an emerging market. The question remains, whether this idealized growth recommendations in the economy will be worth its implied cost in an actual society.
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 3 года назад
She isn’t assertive, she is immature
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 2 года назад
@Ismael barrera You are immature as you cant even understand her lack of maturity. For you it is normal. How obsessed are you?
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 2 года назад
@Ismael barrera You’re the one with the accusations you weirdo
@greatbritian9930
@greatbritian9930 2 года назад
@@JaKommenterar In an extend, quite true.
@hopesy12u4
@hopesy12u4 6 лет назад
Socrates also warned us about some democratic elements... to stop politicians from manipulatingbthe ignorant, voters have to be better qualified to vote. How to do that, no idea.
@bwalyafrancis496
@bwalyafrancis496 6 лет назад
She is far above the audience big up. You are making a lot of sense
@JahGaz
@JahGaz 6 лет назад
Dambisa Moyo 💪🏿💪🏿
@michaelgamas2399
@michaelgamas2399 4 года назад
the host is regularly interrupting the guest response. the show became an interrogation than a good discussion of ideas.
@rccr5183
@rccr5183 3 года назад
If you look at other stuff with Mehdi Hasan you soon realize that that's what he's about, not trying to understand and trying to make the guests look stupid and getting laughed at by playing around with words making invalid points. He's not a serious journalist
@sudiXP
@sudiXP 3 года назад
Millions of students took masters entry examination this year in China. Millions of people get educated and lifted from poverty. Families priorities education and culture. I agree there are problems just like any and every country in the world. The mistakes and problems in China now will be solved and addressed in the near future. China is heading in the right direction. Sincerely Kenyan.
@samuelrobertson1567
@samuelrobertson1567 6 лет назад
Great conversation!!!
@xerxeshamburg
@xerxeshamburg 6 лет назад
I am a big fan of MH and especially this Show! I hope there will be more and more episodes. Thank you MH and AJ for this good content.
@ihl0700677525
@ihl0700677525 6 лет назад
I disagree with Dambisa, but also disappointed by Mehdi and the panelists. 1. I don't understand why Mehdi Hasan is so hostile to the guest (Dambisa), the tone and framing of his questions is clearly shows that he was biased against her. Ofc he's the type of journalist who like to ask difficult questions, which is good, but please don't frame your guest, we are here to get new knowledge and information, *not* to "prove" that your guest is wrong. 2. Ann Pettifor (the female panelist) is pretty good at dismantling Dambisa, she didn't intentionally "provoke" the author but explain her viewpoint with clarity. Yet she's unable to do discussion, she only make set of statements but did not asking questions or making inquiry. In short, she's good at explaining her own points, but she close her mind to Dambisa's view. 3. Jason Hickel is a terrible panelist, he's full of contempt toward Dambisa and couldn't even discuss or talk about something that didn't match his original viewpoint. He's the ultimate example of narrow-mindedness. This talk is *useless,* they are unable to get anything from this discussion, just a group of people forcing their own view and *accusing* (instead of discussing with) Dambisa.
@MohamedNidabdella
@MohamedNidabdella 6 лет назад
Immanuel Herman i guess m. Hassan was doing his job, a show like this is made to really challenge the guest with questions that mainstream people would ask, i think mahdi isn't the guy who would frame someone for their point of view on democracy, but he tries to see the problem as a typical person who will read mrs moyo's book and put her in that frame. By asking that framed question , he allows her to address the matter. The economist lady, has very strong arguments against mrs moyo book. You shoul've mentioned the way Mrs. moyo looks down on the host using ad hominem je each time she gets stuck (you didn't read my book - you seems very ignorant of this so i will teach you...) and uses whataboutism to defend her point of view, which is very disappointing if not pathetic. Also by the end, she talks about visiting China in tourist mode, and claiming that she knows more about china just because she went there for few days. Last, but also on china, she praises the political model of china "focused on the society" But then talks about how black people struggle to vote is a lesson of fighting for rights. Here where jason hickel had point this duality of viewing the same problem but he failed and instead looked like he didn't read her book.
@ihl0700677525
@ihl0700677525 6 лет назад
Mohamed Nidabdella I think Mehdi sour the interview by saying "just because you write it doesn't mean it's true" right in the beginning. My reaction is like: Ofc sherlock, that's why you are there. He should ask her why and get more info about her view, not to trying to disprove her. Mehdi also trying to frame her as "untrustworthy" because she was working for a big bank, which Mehdi believe as main perpetrator of 2008 housing bubble and financial crisis, therefore she's guilty by association. That's just stupid.
@MohamedNidabdella
@MohamedNidabdella 6 лет назад
Immanuel Herman Exactly, the first point is a fair criticism of Mehdi's way of "challenging" the guest and i guess he could've been more professional. But the second part is as I mentioned Mehdi putting himself in the shoes of someone interested in economy who saw a best sller and read it only to discover that the writer is a GS former employee. But what I found more interesting is the weak way Mrs. Moyo answered that, she could've done better instead of adressing the association fallacy of Mehdi, she went on an ad Hominem one. I know that you may work with/for a company without agreeing to its different strategies, but other people don't see it that way, and Mrs. moyo had the chance to dismentle that idea and unfortunately missed it.
@toshir0m1
@toshir0m1 6 лет назад
@Immanuel Herman What you describe as a flaw (in your first point) IS the very clear purpose and interest of the show. Did you see the success of past season? Mehdi was NOT less hostile to ideas he identified as false or dangerous, and that's what watchers of the show seem to actively want. You can have polite exchange of ideas ALL OVER the channels, but no no no this one ALSO must conform to the same all-too-known recipe? If you're here to take information you're at the wrong place. Get informed then come rewatch the debate, it'll be much more interesting. Some day, people will complain that John Oliver always feels the need to joke about everything during his news flash...
@rosemarysardi3051
@rosemarysardi3051 6 лет назад
Immanuel Herman I can’t agree with you more👍
@NchlsPtrck
@NchlsPtrck 6 лет назад
Two people debating only to defend rather than learn and improve.
@fahimabegum6292
@fahimabegum6292 6 лет назад
All she is doing is saying You havent read the book properly If shes saying that to everyone then maybe it wasnt written well enough it clearly didnt portray her ideas well enough
@sjive830
@sjive830 5 лет назад
Think you need to watch the interview again, she was basically pointing out that he’s ignorant in the topic of global economics, which i would have to agree with. When he referenced her book, such as chapter seven, he tries to interpret her meaning is what she is saying no sorry but you’re way off, i suspect he didnt even read the book but instead had othger people read it for him. He was over his head and she destroyed him.
@owenbeharry8478
@owenbeharry8478 4 года назад
He is criticizing her book and giving snippets and not the whole story. How do you expect her to reply.
@ambujarind1991
@ambujarind1991 6 лет назад
Mehdi, for all his flaws as an interviewer, was presenting facts in his arguments but she used ad hominem to attack him every time she did not have a response.
@LeKuDz98
@LeKuDz98 6 лет назад
Ambuj Arind she had the answers but how could she respond if everytime she tried to explain herself she got cut off?
@MohamedNidabdella
@MohamedNidabdella 6 лет назад
LeKuDz98 look at the debate again, i saw this "she gets cut off" argument in many comments, and I rewatched the first 20 minutes, she cuts mahdi on 4 occasions at least. She used ad hominem 2 times
@Sunny-we7uv
@Sunny-we7uv 6 лет назад
She attacked him because of the way he interviews. She makes him squirm in his seat so she can better explain her point. Attacking isn’t always non effective almost everyone who deals with politics will attack their opposer, it’s a way to make them kinda squirm and cause you to get an upper ground. I’ve seen ted do it, milo do it, Ben does it, literally probably any politician you know have done it. Thats not an argument to make her seem dumb, she knows what she’s talking about, just like he interrupts his guess so he can try to make them get confused and say the wrong thing.
@freethinker4liberty
@freethinker4liberty 6 лет назад
His facts are just that, his truths, they are ridiculous. It doesn't take much to double check his claim that the working class voted for Hillary or that rich people voted for Trump, those two are completely off. I'm sure that she knew that and from then on took his other "facts" with a grain of salt.
@osmanjerry3272
@osmanjerry3272 5 лет назад
You are biased. This lady is under attack from all corners. See how she answers the questions from the floors, that is more objective.
@johnsonolajide2887
@johnsonolajide2887 4 года назад
I listen to this interview once and am listening to it again, I think ( my own opinion) the presenter try to control Moyo, creat fear and manipulate the whole programme. I think this conversation suppose to be friendly and educative.
@MrDJmarkyspider
@MrDJmarkyspider 3 года назад
she was the one throwing insults...
@mastabah6861
@mastabah6861 3 года назад
You are completly right! He's great but not enough to win over this smart Woman
@cholnhomachat7626
@cholnhomachat7626 2 года назад
You have a point! Such journalists need some one who responds with arrogant responses and make them look stupid in return. I always admire the way Paul Kagame does it.
@coldwarifyful
@coldwarifyful 5 лет назад
The hands of the middle lady in panel 12:59 - 13:00 , what's going on between them? :p
@TheStrodog71
@TheStrodog71 3 года назад
Great interview!!!!
@jonhone1
@jonhone1 5 лет назад
Mehdi can’t interview people like a judge in court by expecting only a YES OR NO answer only.
@Zaid-vs2zz
@Zaid-vs2zz 3 года назад
The problem is that people often start talking and talking and in the end the question isnt answered. So he as a good host wants to get answers. There is no problem in her elaborating afterwards.
@kindinohubert8962
@kindinohubert8962 2 года назад
Exactly right. Bad interview - always interrupting when the author is trying to answer his questions.
@chrisalas879
@chrisalas879 4 года назад
Never knew about this black and beautiful strong woman I love the way she defend her self I love it she has some wisdom 👍
@machojones1146
@machojones1146 3 года назад
What wisdom? Hand even more power BACK to the people who oppress her own???
@jonasspiro6476
@jonasspiro6476 3 года назад
She seemed very loud, arrogant and ignorant.
@marlonmiller5527
@marlonmiller5527 6 лет назад
wonderful discussion
@crouchingstone
@crouchingstone 2 года назад
I think this video is one of the most energetic and aggressive head to head.
@mohammadtayyar6623
@mohammadtayyar6623 2 года назад
kinda agree with her. great debates at head to head. always impressed specially with mehdi
@gautamniroj
@gautamniroj 6 лет назад
For the first time ... I see Mehdi being countered well and little disoriented..yet another great episode. Lot to learn from.
@MohamedNidabdella
@MohamedNidabdella 6 лет назад
I beg to disagree, the guest was a bit arrogant, using ad homenim fallacy to twist the argument and make the host look ignorant, phrases like "I'm trying to teach you..." or "you seem ignorant of the subject" aren't used by people who call themselves intellectuals, and having a phd doesn't make anybody better than anyone. Let's see her argument about Clinton winning the vote of people earning 50k+ a year, she substracted two major cities and said see trump won. Anyone who is familiar with statistics would call this a p-hacking
@gautamniroj
@gautamniroj 6 лет назад
Mohamed Nidabdella I agree with you on her choice words.. but it was evident that mehdi didn't do his homework well. I am great fan of medhi and have been watching all his debate , shows and admire him. .. But on this one he was not as his best... Which is usually not the case. Thanks
@MohamedNidabdella
@MohamedNidabdella 6 лет назад
That's not a choice of words, thats hands down a fallacy that a phd holder shouldnt use, i think Mahdi did his job well, but when you have a guest that goes on a slippery slope everytime he asks her about anything even when you quote her book. I dont think there's any better job you can do to catch her. She thinks government should be hold accountable, but also that China is a great political model because, according to her, it's model focuses on "society" very hard to challenge someone with that hypocricy level.
@LeKuDz98
@LeKuDz98 6 лет назад
Mohamed Nidabdella I think you fail to understand her point with accountability of the government as she was talking about African nations who receive foreign aid.
@LeKuDz98
@LeKuDz98 6 лет назад
Mohamed Nidabdella and with China she is talking about how the model of China focuses on society that's how it' managed to get 300 million people out of poverty. She is pretty well informed I just think you fail understand the message she's trying to convey
@svenjorgenson3224
@svenjorgenson3224 6 лет назад
The only reason the U.S. stock markets continue to make new highs is because companies simply buy back their own stock
@samc269
@samc269 3 года назад
Great job Miss Dambisa.👍👍👍 I loved your views. You made Mehdi felt loss.
@TheQwertsy
@TheQwertsy 3 года назад
This lady is brilliant.
@roachmusicpublishingbarbad7555
Great interview, Ms. Moyo defended herself extremely well.
@JaKommenterar
@JaKommenterar 3 года назад
No she didn’t, she started acting like a child and disrespected the host right from the beginning. Her arguments are weak too.
@abdubura
@abdubura 2 года назад
No she didn't. She was just unnecessarily using disrespectful insults whenever he asked her a reasonable question.
@sandipkhatri6085
@sandipkhatri6085 2 года назад
U sure? 😅
@joebuck943
@joebuck943 4 года назад
Did they both drink a gallon of espresso coffee before this debate
@moseswangwa5893
@moseswangwa5893 6 лет назад
This is a good one. Once again, is democracy a prerequisite for economic freedom or is it vice versa? My research starts now.
@tazisayshi
@tazisayshi 6 лет назад
Dambisa talks about the perception of Africa, yet she worked for Goldman-Sachs, what is her experience working for an NGO focused in African aid, or dealing with any government in Africa. Corruption is a real problem here.
@Karmnu
@Karmnu 6 лет назад
Corruption is a real snake..put in place by the West to assert CONTROL!!!!!
@LeKuDz98
@LeKuDz98 6 лет назад
Dog文凯High Dambisa was also born in Zambia, pretty sure she would have witnessed corruption first hand.
@tazisayshi
@tazisayshi 6 лет назад
LeKuDz, She grew up in Zambia, yet she can't seem to understand why bureaucracy, and working in those countries is so complicated. As soon as she got her degree she got out of there and left to the United States working for the World Bank & Goldman Sachs, she has lost perspective and growing up in a country doesn't give you first hand accounts of corruption.
@garyhughes1202
@garyhughes1202 6 лет назад
Dog文凯High She worked as a consultant for the world bank as well. Yet, it doesnt matter because her thesis is centered on africa needing to develop itself rather than depending on foreign aid which, she points out, has exacerbated the problems there despite helping in terms of spurring economic growth and meaningfully reducing poverty.
@sulaak
@sulaak 6 лет назад
Why should she work in for an NGO, how many roads, dams or railways have NGO finance. African needs smart fanancial experts that can secure investment for infrastructures developments.
@puneethjoseph9585
@puneethjoseph9585 3 года назад
She is a smart woman. It's so true what she said about China
@osmanjerry3272
@osmanjerry3272 5 лет назад
Can't we agree to be different. I believe the diplomats always argue, and finally say let's differ.
@ThobiasMarandu
@ThobiasMarandu 5 лет назад
THere are no levels of democracy that is the pretext of despots. The country either has a democracy or no.
@kimobrien.
@kimobrien. 4 года назад
Some things seem to never change. Just as after the 1929 stock market crash once again the capitalist classes ideologues are questioning their own bourgeois democratic state's methods and ability to do what is necessary to keep up profit rates and maintain social control.
@curtis8559
@curtis8559 4 года назад
I believe that I may be in love.
@safiullahnaseri6768
@safiullahnaseri6768 6 лет назад
Thank you very much Mehdi for producing Head to Head. Afghanistan.
@justsayin1196
@justsayin1196 6 лет назад
Brilliant debate. Raises all sorts of issues. Decide for yourself whom you agree with, but listen.
@douglashurd4356
@douglashurd4356 4 года назад
She came prepared, put him in his place and took charge of the conversation. Also helps to be right.
@Iwaxberrox
@Iwaxberrox 4 года назад
Douglas Hurd she also ate a parrot 🦜😂🙅🏽‍♂️
@sandipkhatri6085
@sandipkhatri6085 2 года назад
U sure id***?
@EmperorScottYee
@EmperorScottYee 6 лет назад
To me, she came off as condescending and unknowledgeable. Maybe she does know what she is talking about, but her answers and the way she spoke made me think otherwise. You can be very knowledgeable and a very bad public speaker at the same time.
@sjive830
@sjive830 5 лет назад
Emperor Scott Yee perhaps you just feel threatened by a well spoken, knowledgeable woman, who could defend herself when she is misquoted, and misinterpreted. She took her punches and hit back, i loved the jabs! End of the day this debate goes to the guest not the host.
@Zaid-vs2zz
@Zaid-vs2zz 3 года назад
@@sjive830 wow really? Any critique against a woman is mansplaining and feeling threatened. The jabs only showed how desperate she is which also shows when she Talks before thinking like when she said in the age of fake News urban Legende become facts
@samtiler5735
@samtiler5735 6 лет назад
Only rich people are getting money and poor people getting things
@thegreatnormad3424
@thegreatnormad3424 6 лет назад
Maybe I failed text 😂🤣😂😂😂😂😂
@drubombom
@drubombom 5 лет назад
Why she is angry and aggressive, Don't write books if u can't explain it to ppl .
@decoloniz_afro
@decoloniz_afro 5 лет назад
DUMB
@fela1489
@fela1489 5 лет назад
I think she explains it very well when Mehdi allows her time to do so. She was very aggressive though
@roachmusicpublishingbarbad7555
Angry and aggressive ? The lady simply won't let Mehdi bully her, period. Ms. Moyo handled herself well.
@ditshego_media
@ditshego_media 5 лет назад
Your Presenter should allow his guest to answer the questions.
@ms9771
@ms9771 5 лет назад
IF she answered the qurstion not play around
@worfoz
@worfoz 5 лет назад
@@ms9771 she tries to give HER answers and he hates that, MCP muhamedan child rape fan
@eibhlinni3598
@eibhlinni3598 5 лет назад
This guy can’t bear to allow he’s guests to answer 🙄he prefers to interrupt continuously and answer himself
@jonhone1
@jonhone1 5 лет назад
I said Mehdi Hassan is the Bruce Lee in the media world and now he found his best match with Dambisa Moyo .
@asirnewazkhan4172
@asirnewazkhan4172 3 года назад
Have you seen the one with Asif Durrani, that was traumatizing
@marlonbrimmer
@marlonbrimmer 4 года назад
Very intriguing discussion
@voiceofunreason5153
@voiceofunreason5153 6 лет назад
I wish she wasn't so combative though. She is coming off as very defensive, nevertheless I enjoy listening to her views and find them interesting...
@at5286
@at5286 4 года назад
voiceOfUnreason yeah it was a bit stressful to watch her
@Iwaxberrox
@Iwaxberrox 4 года назад
She was confused..
@samliew6610
@samliew6610 4 года назад
She is really intelligent
@youngz13o
@youngz13o 4 года назад
Yea she’s got a temper but her points are on point. She’s a pistol though
@mdgulrez9141
@mdgulrez9141 5 лет назад
When I saw the title of the video I thought the debate would be with respect to the rise of right wing parties in the democratic country. And how the majority of people are taking the road to extreme right. But I guess it's too early to discuss that.
@johnmurimahistorian7689
@johnmurimahistorian7689 5 лет назад
Was of the same opinion.
@Unclejamsarmy
@Unclejamsarmy 5 лет назад
It’s important to explore ideas even if they’re unpopular or potentially dangerous. Dr Moyo is excellent at questioning conventional wisdom and looking at things in new and incisive ways and they should’ve seized on that as an opportunity rather than freak out and try to get her to condemn the parts of her book they find controversial. In part due to apathy and poor education, but moreso because of the insane complexity of modern govt, trade, intl affairs, voters are mostly WILDLY unqualified to vote. This is a serious problem and the dogmatic responses to her idea of ranking vote power are just ideological fundamentalism and emotional shock
@net81j
@net81j 6 лет назад
New ideas always sound great on paper. Whether it works or not is a different thing. We tried many "-ism"s in the past few hundred years and most of them failed.
@somefunification
@somefunification 5 лет назад
Why is she so angry though?
@Mighty_Atheismo
@Mighty_Atheismo 5 лет назад
Either because she feels like no one on the panel has read her book, or it's because she is getting publicly eviscerated like all the other people who come on this show.
@rachelgeorge6294
@rachelgeorge6294 5 лет назад
somefunification Globalism suppresses National growth and promotes exploitation of business by rich countries
@bravediomedes217
@bravediomedes217 5 лет назад
Dunning-Kruger
@adamatunkara7780
@adamatunkara7780 4 года назад
She have to
@md8590
@md8590 4 года назад
Because she is a woman
@_angelique9267
@_angelique9267 4 года назад
Brilliant! Kudos to Dambisa Moyo, a lady of vision, wisdom & knowledge, God bless! 👍👍👍🙏😇🌈✨
@JMT1985MO
@JMT1985MO 2 года назад
Wisdom? Litmus tests for voting? What are you a fascist?
@kazikamrujjaman9884
@kazikamrujjaman9884 5 лет назад
How to join like program of Mehdi Hassan.. please advise
@lukagenovese
@lukagenovese 4 года назад
just "subscribe"
@tobyli52
@tobyli52 6 лет назад
Agree that 1 man 1 vote democracy needs some basic level of knowledge to render their vote legit. Otherwise it becomes a random cast. Would be very easy to manipulate.
@ABC-tc1wx
@ABC-tc1wx 4 года назад
We need a system where every person including the elite is accountable for their actions by the Law Fully. We live in a world which is corrupted and the elite look at the working class as sheep. Too many educated people have no understanding of how the other half live.
@marissadower-morgan3313
@marissadower-morgan3313 4 года назад
the interviewer is very rude
@Zaid-vs2zz
@Zaid-vs2zz 3 года назад
How is he rude? She is the one interrupting and attacking him
@diogenes4124
@diogenes4124 6 лет назад
Why can't mehidi get it into his head, democracy is not the end result,it's one of the ways to it.Majority of the voters would not think twice before giving away their right to vote in exchange for safety and relative prosperity.
@truhoodbitch
@truhoodbitch 5 лет назад
You mean as if Obama had declared himself president for life like XI from China? Then we would know that we had an intelligent, capable, president who actually cared for the well being of the nation first and foremost. Would we then give up our vote to keep him in charge? Hmm..I'm not sure. Absolute power corrupts. If we gave up our fundamental voting right, we would live to regret it..or would we?
@peterbluesman
@peterbluesman 5 лет назад
@@truhoodbitch I think President Xi is much more well informed and capable than Obama turned out to be, just saying. To rise from the bottom to the top in the CCP is probably no mean feat. I cant say for sure but it doesnt appear from the way he conducts himself that he owes anyone else for helping him get there.
@cocohuya
@cocohuya 2 года назад
35:56 Ms Dambisa said " i think its ( ), please help me understand what was that last word she said there. plzzzzzz
@itsaykay
@itsaykay 6 лет назад
Dambisa exposes a very uncomfortable tension in development: marrying development with human freedom with property rights and sustainable development. It is probably a trade-off between these different outcomes. A look thru economic history suggests that, it seems.
@robertdmci
@robertdmci 6 лет назад
Can this guy to shut up and ask question after she has finished her argument?
@advaitanundoo3587
@advaitanundoo3587 6 лет назад
Why cant the anchor allow the speakers to finish. He cuts them off. Probably b cos he likes to hear his own voice.
@Magajiada
@Magajiada 6 лет назад
Lol, for the first time I see Mehdi Hasan put in his place. She made it clear that voters should be informed of their decision during, and Mehdi understood that's why he kept quiet.
@seasidedreams6766
@seasidedreams6766 6 лет назад
what the one with richard dawkins, he believes in flying horse
@aneesniazi7918
@aneesniazi7918 6 лет назад
A literal ancap. She's insane.
@MrFuzzKat
@MrFuzzKat 6 лет назад
Stop interrupting the guest, Medhi! I want to hear her defend her position - not you ragging on.
@MikeyJJJ
@MikeyJJJ 5 лет назад
What a trash of an interviewer and host. If Al Jazeera wishes to be taken seriously, remove this moron and hire people who know how to conduct interviews that actually draw the guests to expand and not narrow their positions. He actually had the gall "so we are in agreement then". The guest is not there to agree with you or prove that you're right to soothe your very tiny ego!
@anooptiwari7603
@anooptiwari7603 5 лет назад
Interruptions are meant to be as they should be. Mehdi has a sharp intellect and he wants a postmortem report from his audience. I think he does a good job . Asking only comfortable points is not the point of even the pragramme he is hosting.
@churbro5069
@churbro5069 5 лет назад
The problem lies in her flying off on a tangent becoming hard to understand as the man has a show to host in which his guests must follow.
@wrathofme03
@wrathofme03 6 лет назад
And yes these elections are happening in the context of a globalizing society where the definition of the nationstate is changing. It used to be that a nation was a geographic area with established borders and within it was perhaps one or two ethnicities and different dialects of the same language for the most part. Now a nation in many instances means a geographic area with borders that can have any number of cultures within it and these are changes that have happened from the outside in and not the other way around so there is of course a temporary pushback. That's how these kinds of changes always happen.
@tafadzwa6712
@tafadzwa6712 4 года назад
Very intelligent indeed
@mdtalhaansari1096
@mdtalhaansari1096 5 лет назад
The lady insults with impunity with the assumption that she knows best and others need to be educated until they agree with her. Not trustworthy.
@dreday14
@dreday14 5 лет назад
@MD Talha Ansari, have you any solution ?
@mdtalhaansari1096
@mdtalhaansari1096 5 лет назад
@@dreday14 For the current flawed democratic model? Yes. Have a set of laws that cannot be changed by a human mandate of any size or magnitude at any time. Not just that, but also have a fixed method of interpreting the laws and a minimum set of social requirements to be fulfilled before implementing the laws. Example Laws - Quran Method of interpretation - Sunnah Social conditions to be fulfilled before implementing the laws - the Prophet Muhammad's (Peace be upon him) rule and the Rashidun Caliphate Case in point - When Umar (May Allah be pleased with him) suspended the law of cutting a thief's hand when a man was caught stealing some necessities of life during a famine and the state couldn't provide for his basic needs.
@dreday14
@dreday14 5 лет назад
@@mdtalhaansari1096 Quran as your law book? Will African rastaman like me also practice your Sunnah? You want to use an over 4000 years old book as your law guide as the case is in Saudi Arabia where a woman can drive a car since 2018? Where are you from pls?
@md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037
@md.muzahidulislamsamrat8037 5 лет назад
@@dreday14 thie zio-pig and their western puppets have brought a" 5000 year old" spurious book to depopulate a native population.did u forget or just one of them?
@60-second-HACKS
@60-second-HACKS 4 года назад
We need courageous innovative thinkers like Dambisa to shake us out of our ideological blind spots. It's a pity that only one panelist (the NZ gentleman) is able to listen and discuss her ideas in a spirit of intellectual good faith.
@romlyn99
@romlyn99 4 года назад
What needs to be reformed are corporations.
@osmanjerry3272
@osmanjerry3272 5 лет назад
Taking Akin Khoo's words down below: Democracy is irrelevant in promoting growth. The late Singapore Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew said that after he built up Singapore into a prosperous city state.
@Emanon...
@Emanon... 6 лет назад
How is the air quality in Beijing again, miss Moyo?
@DredPirateRoberts
@DredPirateRoberts 4 года назад
The AJ - smells like money
@gavinisaacs2724
@gavinisaacs2724 4 года назад
Medhi , this is one brilliant woman !!!!! I fully agree with her !
@rakheebtc1071
@rakheebtc1071 5 лет назад
an unconventional way of interviewing ...Mehdi is a journalist who has got guts to ask serious questions.
@peterbluesman
@peterbluesman 5 лет назад
hes just a nuisance and comes off sounding extremely unintelligent in this particular interview.
@kshen7485
@kshen7485 2 года назад
Especially after pandemic, we have to think again if the western democracy is another extremism or ideology.