What sold me on this personally, is the eyes - they match Revenge of the Sith, while the black series matches clone wars Smooth - RoTS Sharp - Clone Wars
I think it's beautiful. I'm very happy with it. The interior is plain, which is fine with me. Nobody sees that anyway. Some of the details aren't quite up to Black Series level, but I really like it. It's perfect for display. I definitly hope they come out with more.
The Disney one looks nicer where it counts on the outside. I thought I saw other reviews of this helmet saying it included a strap to go at the top of the head but I could be wrong.
Thanks for the review !!! IMHO Disney wins for size, looks is a tie and comfort I gotta say Black Series, cause Tony says Disney's is hard to see out of. I don't own a 187 helmet but with no padding and what looks like the battery compartment on the top, I think Disney would be uncomfortable to wear, I'm surprised they didnt put any kind of pad to cover that battery compartment. But whos gonna wear it for any length of time anyway. I don't recall ever seeing this helmet in Clone Wars or the prequels, I don't know if I'm going to buy the 187th, although I do hope they come out with other paint schemes.
Hasbro helmets are comically large. I own 2, but only looks normal on a giant. Plus the dome proportions are off. Disney helmet looks about right. Can always add a little padding inside. And, $100!
Looks sick but I’m passing on it, mainly because it would stand out compared to the plain phase 2, 332nd and Rex I have displayed. Maybe if they release other legions I’ll bite
I'll take the one from Disney. Just because of how it looks and only if I'm going to have it for display or just for the picture lol. For cosplaying, I prefer black series helmets.
Disney's is more wearable than the Hasbro one, since you don't need to have a gigantic head in order to make it a good fit. If you have small to normal head go with Disney else go with Hasbro. If you only want to put it on display buy Hasbro.