Тёмный

IS VOTING PERMISSIBLE? AskTheSheikh 

Ali Dawah
Подписаться 1,2 млн
Просмотров 45 тыс.
50% 1

Salam alaikum brothers & sisters. You can contribute to our day to day costs of travel and other camera and editing expenses by donating to www.gofundme.com/askthesheikh
May Allah swt Mercy & Blessings be upon you all.

Кино

Опубликовано:

 

21 май 2017

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 575   
@justincaseOne
@justincaseOne Год назад
"Those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed, they are the disbelievers themselves." (Surah Maida, Verse 44)
@AsifAnsari-hg6tm
@AsifAnsari-hg6tm Год назад
Complete the verse bro
@serk1933
@serk1933 10 месяцев назад
The scholars have made it clear kufran dunr kufr doesn't apply to democracy or secularism
@bilalshakib7162
@bilalshakib7162 8 месяцев назад
​@@AsifAnsari-hg6tmWe ordained for them in the Torah, “A life for a life, an eye for an eye, a nose for a nose, an ear for an ear, a tooth for a tooth-and for wounds equal retaliation.” But whoever waives it charitably, it will be atonement for them. And those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed are ˹truly˺ the wrongdoers. Surah Al-Ma'idah : 45 This only confirms it more
@HerrInteressiertDichNicht
@HerrInteressiertDichNicht 6 месяцев назад
​@@bilalshakib7162 So you have more knowledge than the majority of scholars?
@babychoppa463
@babychoppa463 5 месяцев назад
@@HerrInteressiertDichNichtand you skip what Allah has said?
@farhinsiddeka8345
@farhinsiddeka8345 7 лет назад
To save ya'll 20 minutes he Essentially thinks it's permissible to vote
@cassh6430
@cassh6430 7 лет назад
Lol thank you, I wanted to ask
@fastasaninja
@fastasaninja 7 лет назад
Farhin Siddeka Thank you bruh
@alphaviews4639
@alphaviews4639 7 лет назад
Thanks . But he only Thinks it permissible !?? This is why Muslims are in trouble because a simple question that the answer should be a clear YES it is permissible & obligatory for Muslims to vote is muddied by a guy that talks to much. Yes brothers & sisters it is permissible to vote & haram to not vote or try to stop someone from voting
@opocoyo
@opocoyo 7 лет назад
Farhin Siddeka JazaakumLlaahu khier!
@02amh
@02amh 7 лет назад
life saver u r
@Shammer1
@Shammer1 7 лет назад
I am confused becuase Allah says "rule by what Allah revealed"
@rasheedshehadeh7657
@rasheedshehadeh7657 5 лет назад
islamqa.info/en/answers/107166/ruling-on-democracy-and-elections-and-participating-in-that-system
@davidpanbehchi2310
@davidpanbehchi2310 4 года назад
voting is fake, elections arent even real. these allies of satan are freemasons promoting fake elections to keep people stuck in the circus loop
@Firelord2nd
@Firelord2nd 4 года назад
Saliman Latti WE CANT VOTE
@rayanomar4832
@rayanomar4832 3 года назад
do u honestly believe almighty Allah is confined to a socio-political field of the 6th centrury?
@grandshows7363
@grandshows7363 3 года назад
@Moh Kau exactly, for example by paying taxes of all sorts, you participate in the system and plans of the government.
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 7 лет назад
Haitham al-Haddaad asks: Whats wrong with voting? Allaah says: “. . . And whoever does not judge by what Allaah has revealed, such are the kaafiroon.” [5.44] Time Stamp: 13:00 - 14:00
@nightblades6239
@nightblades6239 2 года назад
Enlighten me brother does that mean we cant vote. What if voting allows for an Islamic system to be implemented
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 2 года назад
@@nightblades6239 The end does not justify the means
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman Год назад
@@nightblades6239 islamic system and democratic system they are completely different things. do not confuse the words, "vote" is not haram or kufr unlike democracy is
@nightblades6239
@nightblades6239 Год назад
@@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman Then explain to me how the khalif was elected vote dosent mean to enforce a secular system it just means you are choosing someone to represent you in parliament. I disagree with democracy but voting doesn't mean choosing a secular system.
@mintyandamr1917
@mintyandamr1917 7 лет назад
SubhanAllah it's Ramadan people the best time to make dua for ourselves and the muslims. just make dua to Allah to remove the harmful things from our path and keep us safe
@Ismail-ez7um
@Ismail-ez7um 7 лет назад
May Allah protect us miskeen who believe ruling is only for Allah
@DariusOver
@DariusOver 7 лет назад
help comes only from Allah not from those who deny his sharia
@opocoyo
@opocoyo 7 лет назад
Exactly, if only we put so much more effort into seeking Allah's help rather than the help of the rulers.
@420K
@420K 7 лет назад
Darius Over 9000 so where is sharia
@abeddoughan7192
@abeddoughan7192 2 года назад
He didnt deny thr sharia 🤦
@wata8096
@wata8096 Год назад
best comment, they have this system because they not believing in a God, so for them their system seems right, but we believe in Allah and should know that only his rules are the solution for everything.
@AlifLamMim-bf4ur
@AlifLamMim-bf4ur 6 лет назад
What Quran does this "Sheikh" read? Voting is Shirkh. Imam Sajjaj: The one who votes another legislator next to Allah is a Mushrik.
@ahmet-sivasi
@ahmet-sivasi 2 года назад
Mustafa Sabri Efendi, the last SheikhulIslam of the Ottoman Empire, tells in his work Mevkif'ul-Akl 👇 [If the state leaves the line of Islam, "Obeying the dictates of religion is not the business of the government. It is only the business of society." says, this is to separate religion from the state. In such a case, the state apostatized (abandoned religion). If the society consents to such a government, or if the government will make laws by taking the society's proxy in the parliament (that is, by voting), the society will become apostate just as the government is apostate. In this case, the following verse applies to both that government and that ummah: "Those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed, they are the disbelievers themselves." (Surah Maida, Verse 44) A political regime that accepts the principle of secularism means that it has rebelled against the rules of Islam. Therefore, first of all, this government apostatized, and then those who obeyed this administration became apostates one by one. Just as those who take part in the political administration are apostates one by one, the masses obeying this government also fall into apostasy (kufr).] (Mavkif'ul-Akıl, 4/280)
@PoeticKhalidNur
@PoeticKhalidNur 7 лет назад
Subhaan Allaah. The Messenger of Allaah didn't enter the political field of Quraysh. Rather he, sallallaahu alayhi wasallam, called to Tawheed. When the people became rectified Allaah rectified them: Allah has promised those among you who believe, and do righteous good deeds, that He will certainly grant them succession to (the present rulers) in the earth, as He granted it to those before them, and that He will grant them the authority to practise their religion, that which He has chosen for them (i.e. Islam). And He will surely give them in exchange a safe security after their fear (provided) they (believers) worship Me and do not associate anything (in worship) with Me. But whoever disbelieved after this, they are the Fasiqun (rebellious, disobedient to Allah). Surah Noor Aayah 55
@justincaseOne
@justincaseOne Год назад
جزاك الله خير اخي
@erodingaway9679
@erodingaway9679 7 лет назад
Funny how this he strongly without a doubt claimed voting is wajib, then turns around chocked up saying no evidence is needed. If it's wajib, why is it so hard to bring evidences from Qur'an and Sunnah? No, if it's wajib then there should be evidences from Qur'an and Sunnah. Making a claim in a 20 minute video with not one ayat or hadith. Don't waste our time. We're not blind followers, no matter what degree you have. ALLAH says, that the Hukm is for none but ALLAH, and ALLAH has commanded that you worship none but Him" ALLAH says, "The Command is for none but ALLAH" ALLAH says, "and He makes none share in His Decision and Rule" ALLAH says. "Or do they have partners with ALLAH, who have legislated for them a religion which ALLAH has not ordained" Yes the democratic system is already in place, and it's not as though your replacing the Shari'ah with man made laws. But STILL, by you voting you are giving so and so kafir the authority/accepting for him to rule by this kufr system, which makes you an assistant in his kufr. A system which ORIGINALLY came to rebel against the authority of ALLAH, granting man the authority to legislate whatever he sees fit. Just looking at the origins of democracy should be enough for one to conclude that voting for this system is shirk Akbar. You're taking the right of ALLAH which belongs EXCLUSIVELY to Him, and giving it to someone else, making partnership with ALLAH. Pray to other than ALLAH and we say this is shirk, Slaughter in the name other than ALLAH and we say this is shirk. Making du'a to other than ALLAH, and we say this is shirk. So why when it comes to placing partners with ALLAH in His Legislation; in a right which is exclusively His, just like the others I've mentioned, we then say it's not shirk? And I give sincere advice to Ali Dawah, it's best that you take down this video. Your giving this liar a platform to spread his kufr, convincing Muslims who might be confused about this matter to partake in shirk. A dangerous line to walk on concerning your deen.
@theasiangoat553
@theasiangoat553 6 лет назад
Eroding Away Wallahi you have spoken the truth may Allah swt bless you
@qadeerahmed5490
@qadeerahmed5490 5 лет назад
Eroding Away this is truth democracy is shirk Or secular state this is shirk
@libanartan3606
@libanartan3606 5 лет назад
Barak Allah
@libanartan3606
@libanartan3606 5 лет назад
Wicked scholar
@umarali1618
@umarali1618 5 лет назад
Shut up
@moodyniessuh4164
@moodyniessuh4164 5 лет назад
Just because times changed, doesn't mean Islam can change. Islam is for all times and all places
@bdrealest1572
@bdrealest1572 7 лет назад
Brother Ali, you as an influencer on youtube especially an muslim influencer who give dawah to others, you should know what you post before doing so, how could you not have seen the errors of this so called 'shaykh', think about this you rather be liked by people or liked by Allah swt ? It's partly your responsibility when you let this shaykh spread ignorance and falsehood on your youtube account. And don't think lightly of this but rather fear Allah swt, Repent to Him to Allah swt, and ask for guidance to Him Alone without any partners. every (young)person that will think voting in democracy is permissible while it's not, don't you think it will be part of your responsibility and actions?? May Allah swt protect us from falsehood.
@rasheedshehadeh7657
@rasheedshehadeh7657 5 лет назад
islamqa.info/en/answers/107166/ruling-on-democracy-and-elections-and-participating-in-that-system
@RoseMary-vs3io
@RoseMary-vs3io 7 лет назад
HOW MANY THINGS IS THIS SHEIK GOING TO RE-DEFINE BEFORE ALI DAWAH REALISES HE NEEDS TO SEEK KNOWLEDGE AND CHANGE HIS SHEIK? May Allah save us all Ameen.
@davidpanbehchi2310
@davidpanbehchi2310 4 года назад
you cant change a freemason, they are the allies of satan
@HamzaKhan-ys1jj
@HamzaKhan-ys1jj 7 лет назад
Wallahi this Sheikh talks totally form what he feels and doesnt even bring evidence from tge quran and sunnah. He just talks about what is better and uses analogies. Subhanallah may allah guide him
@nightblades6239
@nightblades6239 2 года назад
Brother prove to me it is haram
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 2 года назад
General principle: Everything in Ibaadah is Haraam unless there is a text to say otherwise. [Bukhaaree 2697 and Muslim 1718] ​
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 2 года назад
@@nightblades6239 Dr. Haitham Haddaad is making a claim that it is waajib therefore the burden of proof is upon the claimant (him). This is a basic principle of law/jurisprudence/fiqh
@nightblades6239
@nightblades6239 2 года назад
@@MAli99923 Ill give evidence and please brother correct me if I am wrong. Didn't the Sahbah choose the next Caliph? They would get together to decide who should be the next caliph. In the western country Islamophobia, unfortunately, is on the rise and seeping into the political system and we need to have more pro-Muslim leaders what is your opinion.
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 2 года назад
@@nightblades6239 Can you show us which sahabah got together and voted. That we can see the difference between the two. The western voting versus the one you are referring to
@pakisoulja100
@pakisoulja100 7 лет назад
Shiekh haitham may allah guide him to the haqq. He is indeed upon the methodology of the ikhwanul muslimeen who want to create a khilafah system through politics and democracy May allah guide us and save us from people like him
@nightblades6239
@nightblades6239 Год назад
brother are you a sheikh or student of knowledge. If not then please don't do this. The ulema would never outright call someone a misguided individual so I don't understand what gave you the authority.
@abdullahassaffah
@abdullahassaffah 11 месяцев назад
​@@nightblades6239he is a great scholar but there's no denying he is mistaken here
@NoNames824
@NoNames824 10 месяцев назад
Ameen
@jawadarif5676
@jawadarif5676 5 месяцев назад
Funny is the madkali and the Saudi salafi are the once that give out these fatwah so to protect there tagoot ruler
@deltrotter3371
@deltrotter3371 7 лет назад
If voting "isn't a form of 'ibaadah" then why is it "compulsory" according to Haitham??
@georgianewbury2684
@georgianewbury2684 7 лет назад
because Haitham is a delusional murtad thats why Aboo
@deltrotter3371
@deltrotter3371 7 лет назад
Easy now George...
@BP-xe7xs
@BP-xe7xs 3 года назад
He sais that it isnt a ibada in of itself that you tell us you need a daleel for ot. Rather it is an ibada when you have the right intention as same as sleeping can become an act of worship when you have the intention to gain power for serving islam.
@Abduboy13th
@Abduboy13th 7 лет назад
People are now realising Imran and his team has been saying the truth all the way through.
@SohailSizzla
@SohailSizzla 7 лет назад
I like the point mentioned around 9:00. Shaykh al Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah mentions it's mandatory to learn the Arabic language because understanding the Quran and Sunnah is mandatory, and you cannot understand the Quran and Sunnah without the Arabic language. Thus making it mandatory to learn the Arabic language.
@Ambereen098
@Ambereen098 7 лет назад
"why not?" what a great response *claps*
@kardoxcenna260
@kardoxcenna260 3 года назад
Brother watch the video before you make arrogant comments he explained very well why
@Ambereen098
@Ambereen098 3 года назад
@@kardoxcenna260 I’m a sister. Also I did watch the whole video
@ArchiveofTawheed
@ArchiveofTawheed 2 года назад
Legislation is for Allah alone. Giving the right to legislate by means of voting puts one beyond the pale of Islam.
@konyvnyelv.
@konyvnyelv. Год назад
If the people don't vote, a dictator would rule so it's still a man who rules, not Allah
@ArchiveofTawheed
@ArchiveofTawheed Год назад
@@konyvnyelv. That doesn't make giving the right to legislate to other than Allah not shirk.
@konyvnyelv.
@konyvnyelv. Год назад
@@ArchiveofTawheed Allah does not exist and even if he existed he'd have no right over us
@ArchiveofTawheed
@ArchiveofTawheed Год назад
@@konyvnyelv. I thought I was dealing with someone who at least attributes themselves to Islam. The opinion of the kuffar are as worthless as themselves.
@anxoidenamikaze1551
@anxoidenamikaze1551 3 месяца назад
@@konyvnyelv. Allah exist and he has full right on us.
@ahmedalmahdi9254
@ahmedalmahdi9254 7 лет назад
I love this sheikh lmaoo
@m0rhis528
@m0rhis528 7 лет назад
mashallah really makes sense....
@Shammer1
@Shammer1 7 лет назад
voting means we have blood of our muslim brothers and sisters
@opocoyo
@opocoyo 7 лет назад
Shaykh Haitham said voting is not an act of worship but then later said its waajib to select the best candidate for yourself. How can it be waajib if it's not even an act of worship? 17:11
@mahamedfarah4528
@mahamedfarah4528 7 лет назад
Shaykh Muhammad ibn ‘Uthaymeen (may Allaah have mercy on him) was asked about the ruling on elections, and he replied: I think that elections are obligatory; we should appoint the one who we think is good, because if the good people abstain, who will take their place? Evil people will take their place, or neutral people in whom there is neither good nor evil, but they follow everyone who makes noise. So we have no choice but to choose those who we think are fit.
@murtazaali5797
@murtazaali5797 7 лет назад
Bottom line is that voting is haram unless it's a necessity like the examples I gave above. I'm not telling anyone to vote. I myself will never vote even for a Muslim MP. Just because they are Muslim doesn't mean they will help the local Muslims in that area l myself have seen that. Unless it's a necessity like England are passing a law to ban hijabs in school and if they receive votes above a certain number they won't ban hijab in schools then out of necessity I will vote akhi. Politicts is a dirty game from hundreds of years ago and if you think politicians really help you then the millions march in London where millions turned out and soo many politicians said that don't invade Iraq and England still invaded Iraq. Bottom line is that you are made to think you are making a difference by voting
@murtazaali5797
@murtazaali5797 7 лет назад
Abū Hurayrāh al-Tunisī akhi I'm not talking about general elections akhi. I'm talking if there was a vote to ban muslim girls from wearing trousers and only skirts. then we would participate in that vote. I'm not talking about general elections.
@shahee6579
@shahee6579 3 года назад
@@murtazaali5797 brother of course voting in general is okay . Voting in government elections are the issues
@justincaseOne
@justincaseOne Год назад
He said “ voting is an obligatory “ 🤔 May Allah protect the ummah from this kinda misguiders and corrupted mind. May Allah wake us up upon the understanding of the Quran and Sunnah.
@anxoidenamikaze1551
@anxoidenamikaze1551 3 месяца назад
For example Yusuf was the prime minister of misra was it against tawhid to be the prime minister of a non muslim country ruling with rules and system that did not come from Allah ?
@justincaseOne
@justincaseOne 3 месяца назад
@@anxoidenamikaze1551 He had full authority. He did nothing against tawheed. This is actually funny and so sad at the same time. How did they fool you. Read the Surah Yousuf 56-57 verses with tafseer. You ll get what i am tryna say in sha Allah.
@shafkathussain2800
@shafkathussain2800 7 лет назад
Ikhwaani scholar - May Allāh guide him to the truth
@sherin63
@sherin63 7 лет назад
Assalamu alaikum. Will the sheikh be answering any of the viewers questions.
@muntazirbhat3109
@muntazirbhat3109 7 лет назад
i love you brother
@waseem3967
@waseem3967 7 лет назад
Well said Sheikh! Voting is important, especially for us Muslims! Vote Corbyn!
@user-ls2rb8tx7s
@user-ls2rb8tx7s 2 месяца назад
My understanding is that at best it’s the lesser of two evils, at worst it’s haram. It’s not fard to vote, so why take part in an evil? When you vote for a party, you are voting for their manifesto, which will include things which are haram ie LGBT rights, etc. Why would you put yourself in such a dangerous situation.
@Mohammed5i
@Mohammed5i 2 месяца назад
Lesser of two evils is only allowed in severe cases of daruurah (life and death situations). But the basic asl of democracy and voting is that it is clear kufr. This 'shaykh' is saying things that are very dangerous. Didnt bring any reasons as to why the evidences against voting is invalid
@nicolasmith2941
@nicolasmith2941 7 лет назад
(QUR’AN) The command to rule according to what Allaah has revealed: “And so judge between them by what Allaah has revealed . . .” [5: 49] Warning against ruling by other than what Allaah has revealed: “. . . and follow not their vain desires . . .” [5: 49] . but beware of them lest they turn you far away from some of that which Allaah has sent down to you . . .” [5:49] Forbidding seeking the ruling of jaahiliyyah, as is expressed in the rhetorical question “Do they then seek the judgement of (the Days of) Ignorance?” [5:50] The statement that nobody is better than Allaah to judge: “. . . and who is better in judgement than Allaah for a people who have firm Faith?” [5: 50] . . . And whoever does not judge by that which Allaah has revealed, such are the zaalimoon (polytheists and wrongdoers)” [5: 45]; “. . . And whoever does not judge by what Allaah has revealed (then) such (people) are the faasiqoon (rebellious or disobedient).” [5:47]. BUT ALLOWING A MAN TO RULE ABOVE ALLAH (SWT) ALLOWED?
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman Год назад
Mustafa Sabri Efendi, the last SheikhulIslam of the Ottoman Empire, tells in his work Mevkif'ul-Akl 👇 [If the state leaves the line of Islam, "Obeying the dictates of religion is not the business of the government. It is only the business of society." says, this is to separate religion from the state. In such a case, the state apostatized (abandoned religion). If the society consents to such a government, or if the government will make laws by taking the society's proxy in the parliament (that is, by voting), the society will become apostate just as the government is apostate. In this case, the following verse applies to both that government and that ummah: "Those who do not judge by what Allah has revealed, they are the disbelievers themselves." (Surah Maida, Verse 44) A political regime that accepts the principle of secularism means that it has rebelled against the rules of Islam. Therefore, first of all, this government apostatized, and then those who obeyed this administration became apostates one by one. Just as those who take part in the political administration are apostates one by one, the masses obeying this government also fall into apostasy (kufr).] (Mavkif'ul-Akıl, 4/280)
@TheRunesofmagic1
@TheRunesofmagic1 7 лет назад
i would like to know if its permissable to be a lawyer trying to enjoy justice as far as possible in the country of non-muslims?
@mohiuddin718
@mohiuddin718 6 лет назад
Mashallah bro ali, i know you were trying to make that shake look good, but Allah is the best of planners. This video exposes this guy more than the point you were trying to make. Jazakallah brother loll
@xiontion9993
@xiontion9993 2 года назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-p03VaQ_OqgM.html
@Fstarr96
@Fstarr96 7 лет назад
How can he say "Forget about the daleel, we don't read the daleel for these things" lol?? 12:33 onwards
@mustafahussain4801
@mustafahussain4801 7 лет назад
Haitham al-Haddad is in no way a scholar or shaykh. He is clearly misguiding everyone. He speaks so much from himself, and as students of knowledge are taught in the beginning, "Knowledge is what Allah said, the Messenger said and what the companions said." I don't see any knowledge here. Ali Da'wah if you're going to blind follow this man then I fear for you and him, may Allah guide him to the haqq or break his back for misguiding the youth and fighting against the clear-cut evidences from the Qur'an and Sunnah. Ameen.
@abusaleh1419
@abusaleh1419 7 лет назад
shaykh alshanqeeti r.a said regarding following kufr system and their laws. Shaykh Muhammad Alamin AlShanqeeti rahimahullah Author of famous Tafseer Adwaa albayan said: "Associating partners with Allah in his rule and associating partners with him in his worship are the same, there is absolutely no difference between them. Whosoever follows a system other than the system of Allah and legislation other than legislation of Allah and a constitution imposed by man which opposes sharia of allah is like the one who worships and prostrates to Idols and there is definitely no difference between them in any shape or form. Therefore, both the matters are the same and both are associating partners with Allah"
@smalik4854
@smalik4854 5 лет назад
JazakhAllah it is not easy to be an imam..
@habeebahtahir
@habeebahtahir 7 лет назад
Your GoFundMe page says you're no longer accepting donations
@rashedmiah1
@rashedmiah1 7 лет назад
is online currency trading Haram? I need someone to answer please.
@khayr1
@khayr1 7 лет назад
Rashed Miah yes brother check islam Q&A i myself use to do forex trading Alhamdulillah i left
@basafromnasa8980
@basafromnasa8980 5 лет назад
UK certified sheikh
@2009abuabdullah
@2009abuabdullah 7 лет назад
My argument is, if democracy means the majority have the say. And according to the Quran, the majority of people are wrongdoers. Then how can democracy be good? ﴿ لَكَانَ خَيۡرً۬ا لَّهُم‌ۚ مِّنۡهُمُ ٱلۡمُؤۡمِنُونَ وَأَڪۡثَرُهُمُ ٱلۡفَـٰسِقُونَ ﴾ (it would have been better for them; among them are some who have faith, but most of them are Fasiqun (rebellious).) Peace
@peacezorro5701
@peacezorro5701 7 лет назад
Can you please make a video on weather going to public school is permissible or not.
@kareemuddin951
@kareemuddin951 7 лет назад
Where can I ask sheikh question? Can anyone please let me know
@ahlam1770
@ahlam1770 5 лет назад
There is an international system already in place and there is a national system already in place. Voting is our way as civilians to hold our leaders accountable. It is our way of preventing leaders from abusing their power and oppressing groups.
@justincaseOne
@justincaseOne Год назад
People of Mecca had a parlement in the time of Prophet saw. They were also voting when they want to pass judgment on a matter. Did Prophet saw join them or deputize them ??? Follow the footsteps of Prophet(عليه الصلاة والسلام) not others !!!
@Ghost-re5rb
@Ghost-re5rb 7 лет назад
Autubillah.
@TH-kt5ir
@TH-kt5ir 7 лет назад
Why did he say it's almost obligatory to vote? when it can be seen as shirk
@aliyah0303
@aliyah0303 7 лет назад
Assalamu Alaykum. Hypothetically speaking...Can you vote if all candidates are corrupt?
@ghozmit1
@ghozmit1 7 лет назад
Wow this video made me 100% sure that Haitham al-Haddad is a misguided Ikhwani.
@isooo2511
@isooo2511 7 лет назад
ghozmit1 on what grounds?
@annoor5251
@annoor5251 7 лет назад
May Allah reward this Sheikh. He is full of wisdom.
@Abdullah12794
@Abdullah12794 7 лет назад
Sheikh Haitham and brother Ali love you both for the sake of Allah, keep up the good work barakallahu feekum
@georgianewbury2684
@georgianewbury2684 7 лет назад
fear Allah swt
@HerrInteressiertDichNicht
@HerrInteressiertDichNicht 6 месяцев назад
​@@georgianewbury2684?
@usualgamer4094
@usualgamer4094 7 лет назад
sheikh ALBANI said it was haram to vote
@moonchildvelius
@moonchildvelius Год назад
If you believe it's okay under any circumstances to participate in democracy then you haven't understood the concept of Tawheed, and therefore, you were never a muslim. If you understand the concept and you participate anyway, then you have left the fold of Islam.
@anxoidenamikaze1551
@anxoidenamikaze1551 3 месяца назад
If you think tawhid is to only put trust on Allah without doing anything you did not understand. Allah want you that you do action and that you put your full trust on him. He is the one he is the one who can change the matter no one else. For example Yusuf was the prime minister of misra was it against tawhid to be the prime minister of a non muslim country ruling with rules and system that did not come from Allah ?
@TheHaqqRemains
@TheHaqqRemains 3 месяца назад
100%
@protectyourthaghr
@protectyourthaghr 3 года назад
@6:20 minutes Haitham al Haddad to Ali Dawah (IS VOTING PERMISSIBLE? AskTheSheikh 22/05/2017): Voting is not a form of 'ibadah (as evidence to say that voting is permitted without needing daleel). @1:26:15 Haitham al Haddad (General Election 2017 ¦ Islam21c Big Discussion ¦ Sh Dr Haitham al-Haddad ¦ Azad Ali ¦ Dr. Salman 14/05/2017): "Voting ... for the general election is part of our 'ibadah" (to encourage people to vote).
@ayush2073
@ayush2073 7 лет назад
The fact that this is even a discussion point fk me
@alyzak.8997
@alyzak.8997 7 лет назад
I think voting is obviously permissible since the holy quran says, " Who (the believers) decide all their collective views through mutual consultation. " Hence democracy is encouraged in Islam while dictatorship is forbidden.
@simply4women
@simply4women 7 лет назад
there is a famous saying if voting made a difference they wouldnt let us do it
@fpatel7772
@fpatel7772 7 лет назад
hmm i don't agreee
@simply4women
@simply4women 7 лет назад
Mark twain said it
@konyvnyelv.
@konyvnyelv. Год назад
Then why removing right to vote is the first thing dictatorships do?
@techbetold
@techbetold Месяц назад
to not vote now, would be to remain silent and thus complacent in the genocide. we have to act and at least vote now. don’t vote for parties who support the genocide. don’t remain silent. vote for a pro palestinian party.
@Akois333
@Akois333 7 лет назад
if Allah is Al malik .sovereign...sovereignty belong to Allah... aside modern western democracy in every country around the world said state or nation is al malik taken us to the materialism and in force us to vote for what is right or wrong and majority should rule but laws is same they write it with their own hands...Allah is the law giver he is al hakam...then how can Morden state makes halal which Allah make haram...likes ...gambling.alcohol..lgbt..riba..now a days nothing is left which Allah make haram but democracy makes halal...if you voted for this state you are equally guilty...sura tawbah ayat 31...
@Umer-
@Umer- 7 лет назад
where are the sheikh Google fans
@Kurse97
@Kurse97 7 лет назад
I fear the times we live in; where a sheikh who has dedicated his life to knowledge is refuted in a point he has made by a young boy or girl with little experience in life and deen. Where is the evidence that someone with no knowledge in deen or limited knowledge can give a fatwa regarding important matters? Where was this found in the Salaf Us Saliheen?
@abdixsimplix2582
@abdixsimplix2582 5 лет назад
Voting is not permissible. Like it or reject it.
@DFandV
@DFandV 5 лет назад
Nowhere does it states its haram until proven.
@abdixsimplix2582
@abdixsimplix2582 5 лет назад
@@DFandV Voting someone who legislates law other than the law of Allah might be shirk. Here is the proof.
@abdixsimplix2582
@abdixsimplix2582 5 лет назад
@@Ecceptor I can still not to vote. If a Haram thing is not mandatory and I don't do it then I don't see the problem. Give me a VISA for KSA then if you want me to go in a Muslim country.
@abdixsimplix2582
@abdixsimplix2582 5 лет назад
@@Ecceptor Moreover I was born in a non-Muslim country, and I'm definitely not able to devise a plan for making hijra. The only country worth to make hijra in is Saudi Arabia, specifically in Makkah, others are definitely not.
@Ecceptor
@Ecceptor 5 лет назад
@@abdixsimplix2582 are you saying Saudi is closer to Islam? they are using monarchy. nothing islamic at all. there are no justice in there. you'll be a slave if you live there as non arab.
@zeekay6067
@zeekay6067 3 года назад
People who say voting is Haram generally are from well to do families with royal connections. Brilliant advice by the Sheikh. Even if the whole world is Muslim then what? Where is the system? Muslims need to learn from Western democracies how to have a system. Lowering the ego is part of faith.
@ammar6937
@ammar6937 2 года назад
The Quran says different... Your going by your own desires
@maximilobrowneyez7653
@maximilobrowneyez7653 Год назад
You are totally wrong the whole world is not Muslim stop assuming and their is only one system and it’s Allah his messenger SAW and the western culture is kuffr and misleading as the brother is telling you stop listening to satans whispers
@2009Windows7
@2009Windows7 Год назад
Learn from western democracies? Since when did we muslims take our izza from the kuffar?
@MAli99923
@MAli99923 7 лет назад
He is saying it is almost obligatory, and saying you must vote. The principle he brought forward was everything is halaal until proven otherwise. Here's a proof to show otherwise: Allaah says: “. . . And whoever does not judge by what Allaah has revealed, such are the kaafiroon.” [5.44]
@atravellerwithaquraan5365
@atravellerwithaquraan5365 7 лет назад
Ali Akhi, what if the leader voted for contributes to the killing of Muslims In other lands like Syria and Palestine even though the Muslims in the UK may get slightly better treatment other Muslim blood may potentially be on the Leaders and as a result probably the Voters hands, how it then be obligatory or Waajib to vote, how can that be good? May Allah guide us to do that which is good with him
@honeykhan9629
@honeykhan9629 7 лет назад
I'm soooo confused shall I vote or not, some people say it's fine some people say you can't. can someone give me a proper answer. after watching this video I feel as if I will vote but I don't know cause a lot of people are saying it's shirk and you shouldn't.
@fpatel7772
@fpatel7772 7 лет назад
honey Khan idk, did you watch the other vids he recommended?
@honeykhan9629
@honeykhan9629 7 лет назад
PF noo I haven't
@zohaib1618
@zohaib1618 7 лет назад
The most odd question to ask....
@holdshiftt2run308
@holdshiftt2run308 7 лет назад
Zohaib Ali how is it odd?
@fpatel7772
@fpatel7772 7 лет назад
Zohaib Ali lots of views that it is haram😞
@zohaib1618
@zohaib1618 7 лет назад
PF Those are just radical views...
@formetoknownotyou1724
@formetoknownotyou1724 5 лет назад
Parvez when you stand in front of Allah please say that him.... then we shall see how clever you are!!!
@FranklinFreshman
@FranklinFreshman 7 лет назад
you need to make where u live a better place , with a vote. if Muslim's couldn't vote then how would they elect their own leaders pool
@yusufdw123
@yusufdw123 7 лет назад
Whoever says voting is haram is dumb, IT IS NOT a form of shirk.
@mangekyoumusa
@mangekyoumusa 7 лет назад
Voting itself is not, but for man made laws, and laws other than Allah's is Shirk
@lislamenoccidentetaubled913
@lislamenoccidentetaubled913 6 лет назад
mangekyoumusa you are wrong, voting in the west is an act of worship. Democracy is a religion and elections is a ritual specific to their dine and the purpose is to choose which taghout you want and by voting you ACCEPT to obey to the taghout that will come to power ! this is shirk akbar and all those you say so are true, however sometimes they don't give proper and clear evidence.
@aliangylzalrond6439
@aliangylzalrond6439 7 лет назад
Ali Dawah is being a bit hypocritical. Why not provide fatwa of Sh. Saalih al-Fawzan? and other scholars? Dawah Man - Imran needs to make a video and refute Haitham. This man will misguide several Muslims to vote for shirk and kufr. DON'T LISTEN TO HIM!
@edinhorman959
@edinhorman959 7 лет назад
+Illyria™ Listen brothers and sisters if you simply don't believe in voting and you called it as a shirk then go live in Saudi Arabia because there's no voting there
@edinhorman959
@edinhorman959 7 лет назад
+Illyria™ yoy bitch you have music playlist in your channel!! Its haram anyway muslims don't follow this kind of people and vote for labour
@isooo2511
@isooo2511 7 лет назад
Illyria™ how long have you been practicing? your a Muslim so I expect truth
@ghozmit1
@ghozmit1 7 лет назад
Ali why do you blindly follow this person and what he says. Akhi ASK FOR EVDENCE. ASK HIM WHAT DID FAWZAN, IBN BAZ, IBN UTHAYMEEN and SULEYMAN RUHEYLI SAY ABOUT VOTING. ALI WALLAHI THIS "SHEIKH" IS NOT FOLLOWING THE SALAF.
@SM-ly5tf
@SM-ly5tf 5 лет назад
Ib Uthaymeen holds the view that its obligatory to vote
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman
@Abdurrahmanabdrrahman Год назад
Did you not see those who claimed they believed in what was sent down to you and what was sent before you? They wanted to seek judgment using evil, while they were ordered to reject it. It is the tagut who wants to lead them far astray. yusuf ali Hast thou not turned Thy vision to those who declare that they believe in the revelations that have come to thee and to those before thee? Their (real) wish is to resort together for judgment (in their disputes) to the Evil One, though they were ordered to reject him. But Satan´s wish is to lead them astray far away (from the right).
@MadelineBT
@MadelineBT 7 лет назад
This ruling would only make sense if the political system was fair, just, and truly for the people but is it not yet obvious that the political system is only in place to serve certain individuals? How does voting for someone who (perhaps) promises to treat muslims "better" than others, while continuing to pollute, wage war, and abide by unislamic laws make it halal to vote... as muslims we should not only be concerned with the wellbeing of muslims but the wellbeing of all on this earth......... by voting for a system which wages war, does this not put blood on our hands? :(
@zainabsindi3582
@zainabsindi3582 7 лет назад
many may agrue this point but voting is permissible.
@SohailSizzla
@SohailSizzla 7 лет назад
Beautiful video, may Allah bless the shaykh ameen
@holdshiftt2run308
@holdshiftt2run308 7 лет назад
SohailSecretary Not beautiful. He has lied.
@SohailSizzla
@SohailSizzla 7 лет назад
Angry, upset & ignorant.
@SohailSizzla
@SohailSizzla 7 лет назад
Abū Hurayrāh al-Tunisī may Allah guide us ameen
@naz2999
@naz2999 6 лет назад
I agree with that, it is obligatory to vote for people who are able to best represent Muslims views to protect ourselves from evil, especially if we are living as a minority in the West.
@Runnable19
@Runnable19 Год назад
Wow, the ignorance and the toxicity is amazing here. Ignoring the opinions of famous scholars such as shaiky Albani and others whilst laying over comfortable colorful pillows is really amazing. And saying about something that might be considered Kufr that it is nearly obligatory is just crazy. Indeed he does have no fear of Allah.
@freakypranks8192
@freakypranks8192 4 года назад
why you ask sheikh ,you have quran in sura al araf 54....and after this there is no ''BUT''
@yanissaradouni3619
@yanissaradouni3619 7 лет назад
I like the old intro better
@Mohammed5i
@Mohammed5i 2 месяца назад
SubhanAllah. I was waiting for mr haitham al hadad to come with rebuttals to the evidences against voting and democracy. But all I heard from him is opinions and sidetracking. Unbelieable how someone can be propped up as a shaykh and then come in public and give outrageuos fatawa. How scary is it that muslims will watch this and then vote and take part in kufr. I waited for a clear response as to why voting isnt giving one of Allah's attributes to creation...i waited for him to explain how the prophet pbuh took part in non muslims politics. I didny get anything. How sad is it that he even went a step ahead and claimed its waajib. SubhanAllah. Be careful where you get your knowledve from
@protectyourthaghr
@protectyourthaghr 3 года назад
He never gave evidence for why voting is not a form of 'ibadah (@6:20 minutes) and as for giving da'wah not leading to political change even if all the people become Muslims (@10:40 minutes), didn't da'wah to the al-Aus and al-Khazraj groups, whose people as a whole accepted Islam, directly lead to political change as they agreed to allow Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) to rule by Allah's laws, in Madinah? Our beloved prophet is a clear example of someone who lived in a society in which Allah's laws were not implemented and he refused to take part in their politics in any way, even though the compromises they offered him (e.g. you rule for one year and we will rule for one year) were far greater than what we can hope to benefit us in the West. Working within Quraysh's system would have stopped the torture, the starvation through the 3 year boycott and the need for people to emigrate. However, the early Muslims bore all that with patience and only implemented Allah's laws outside of the the kufr system.
@abdifupi2587
@abdifupi2587 6 лет назад
The sheikh should have a sitting with those with opposing view . That will e interesting
@user-ut4cm9ur1i
@user-ut4cm9ur1i 7 лет назад
Who said to live in a kufr land in the first place?
@MohammadZizou
@MohammadZizou 7 лет назад
Whoever is attacking Ali and Sheikh Haitham, I'll just say fear Allah
@MohammadZizou
@MohammadZizou 7 лет назад
I'll say it again, fear Allah!! I'm not angry, rather worried that my brothers and sisters are attacking each other and what you're saying makes me a Mushrik which will go down in your book as takfir for a brother of yours, so I'll repeat fear Allah.
@seekinglight1689
@seekinglight1689 7 лет назад
voting is not major shirk except for the one who says ruling on other than Allah's ruling is halal. As for the one who says lesser evil or makes an interpretation to vote then in this case this person has falling into haraam not in major shirk or kufr Akbar major disbelieve this is the statement of ahlu Sunna wal jama3a.
@roda6465
@roda6465 7 лет назад
I am so confused to be honest 😂 this so called "sheikh" didn't even bring any evidence to the table La hawla wala quwata illa billah absolutely lost for words. May Allah guide all of us lol I was been sarcastic when I said I was " confused" I don't hold his views on ANYTHING about THE DEEN JazakumuAllah Khairan!
@bdrealest1572
@bdrealest1572 7 лет назад
Implement the Qu'ran and the hadeeth's in your life and trust in Allah swt only, we are in the era of misguided (fake) scholars Allahu A'lem, if someone can't provide the proper dalil about the issue then rejects everything he says, because this shaykh is talking about 'common sense' 'i feel like' 'you don't want to get laughed at' etc, like really?? these are mind games to trick you into following him and his lies. Allahu A'lem. The only thing that we should obey by is that we live accordingly to the Qu'ran and the teachings of our Prophet Muhammad (saw) May Allah swt protect us against these occuring fitna's.
@bdrealest1572
@bdrealest1572 7 лет назад
Exactly this hadeeth, SubhanAllah, look at the happenings now, Every 'scholar' or non scholar who can't provide proper evidence about matters, reject it. may Allah swt protect us from these fitna's
@roda6465
@roda6465 7 лет назад
Allahuma Aameen. May Allah guide us to Siradul Mustaqim
@abusaleh1419
@abusaleh1419 7 лет назад
+UmmStrawberry read this ukhti Shaykh Muhammad Alamin AlShanqeeti rahimahullah Author of famous Tafseer Adwaa albayan said: "Associating partners with Allah in his rule and associating partners with him in his worship are the same, there is absolutely no difference between them. Whosoever follows a system other than the system of Allah and legislation other than legislation of Allah and a constitution imposed by man which opposes sharia of allah is like the one who worships and prostrates to Idols and there is definitely no difference between them in any shape or form. Therefore, both the matters are the same and both are associating partners with Allah"
@roda6465
@roda6465 7 лет назад
abu saleh JazakaAllah khair akh May Allah reward you
@gloverdragon6854
@gloverdragon6854 7 лет назад
audio is rather low, ahki
@caantroversial
@caantroversial 14 дней назад
I think the devil needs a new advocate
@kickass1691774
@kickass1691774 7 лет назад
How would you explain this ayah? 12:40 You worship not besides Him except [mere] names you have named them, you and your fathers, for which Allah has sent down no authority. Legislation is not but for Allah . He has commanded that you worship not except Him. That is the correct religion, but most of the people do not know
@jinn_1891
@jinn_1891 7 лет назад
pigs are pink, I have a pink T Shirt, is this haram or permissible? help me someone I am so worried I'm gonna go straight to the hellfire!!!!!
@moodyniessuh4164
@moodyniessuh4164 5 лет назад
You select a leader but then what about the *Islamic* SHARI'A law? What's wrong with that??
@kurdyyy6822
@kurdyyy6822 7 лет назад
All these people saying he is a kufr and clueless. Remember, this guy is a SHEIKH, he has studied Islam for so so many years. Get to the level of knowledge he has before labelling him as wrong or kufr.
@bdrealest1572
@bdrealest1572 7 лет назад
What has his study for ' so many years' have to do with him being wrong on the subject? if you try to legislate an act of kufr because you think its 'common sense'' or 'logical' its first of all haram and creating a fitna, then why should you look at how many years he has studied? even that if you have studied so many years then you would at least give some true advice reffering to the Qu'ran or the Sunnah of our Prophet (saw), wich he didn't. before following people blindly try reading and searching the truth self, Allah swt has sended down the Qu'ran not to follow others, subhanAllah. may Allah swt guide you.
@farihashafie989
@farihashafie989 6 лет назад
Kurdayeti definitely. They shouldn't be behaving like headless chicken
@vigneshrk
@vigneshrk 7 лет назад
is unmissable a real word?
@noritaken
@noritaken 6 лет назад
my goodness me, what is this "Sheikh" saying???? how is he going to answer Allah...... calling people to law other than that set by Allah is clear Shirk.
@siddharthsai8467
@siddharthsai8467 7 лет назад
In Iran elections happen, In Pakistan elections happen, in Iraq elections happen so are they Muslims or not???
@ahmadhasif979
@ahmadhasif979 7 лет назад
Is there no Islamic Party, Choose The Party that Leads Less Harm to Islam. Thats ustaz says here in Malaysia. hehe :) He also added if someOne doesnt vote and The "Bad" Party won. its a problem. So Everyone must take part to help islam. Hehe Just sharing
@nathanter7622
@nathanter7622 7 лет назад
I honestly think Ali Dawah is an atheist.. He just wouldn't admit it, because if he reveals he is an atheist, he will be jobless...Him remaining a muslim preacher is the only source of income he could get...Basically having no talent or skill, you can still make money by speaking pure rubbish, such as becoming a muslim and making dawah.
Далее
Should British Muslims vote? | Finding the Balance
24:30
Is Voting Halal or Haram/Shirk? - Ust. Abu Taymiyyah
13:57
Как вам наш дуэт?❤️
00:37
Просмотров 368 тыс.
Vote Labour? Lesser Of Two Evils?
10:04
Просмотров 19 тыс.
Is Yoga permissible in Islam? - Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem
5:41
NAS DAILY MUM MUST KNOW!!
9:04
Просмотров 81 тыс.
DOES ISLAM FAVOUR MEN? - SHE DIDN'T LIKE RESPONSE
13:15
Voting in Elections
21:45
Просмотров 30 тыс.
Voting and Democracy in Islam? - Assim al hakeem
6:28
Кто поймает рыбку?😱
0:33
Просмотров 1,5 млн