Тёмный

Islamic Feminism - Debunked (Yassmin Abdel-Magied Hitchslapped) 

Rationality Rules
Подписаться 354 тыс.
Просмотров 528 тыс.
50% 1

This is Islamic Feminism - Debunked (A response to Yassmn Abdel-Magied).
To support me on Patreon (thank you): / rationalityrules
To support me through merchandise: teespring.com/...
To support me through PayPal (thank you): www.paypal.me/...
To follow me on Facebook: / rationalityrules
To tweet with me on Twitter: / rationalityrule
And, to watch / listen to mine, Thomas Westbrook’s (Holy Koolaid) and Rachel Oates podcast: goo.gl/oFUiie
--
References:
1). Australia’s Q&A (featuring Jacqui Lambie and Yassmin Abdel-Magied): • Sharia law debated by ...
2). Zena Agha’s “How Islam made me a feminist”: • Video
3). Aabiya Baqai’s “Feminism in Islam”: • Feminism in Islam | Aa...
4). Christopher Hitchens Hitchslapping a Muslim on Q&A: • Video
5). Al Islam’s interpretation of Ch.4 V.60 of the Quran: www.alislam.or...
6). BBC World Service’s Case Study (and definition) of Sharia Law: www.bbc.co.uk/w...
7). Etymology, origin, and meaning of Sharia Law: www.crf-usa.org...
8). Saudi Arabia is a theocracy: www.state.gov/...
9). My video "Islam is a Religion of Peace - Debunked": • Islam is a Religion of...
10). My video "Criticising Islam is Islamophobia - Debunked": • Criticising Islam is I...
11). My video "9 Quranic Miracles - Debunked": • 9 Quranic Miracles - D...
12). My video "Questions No Atheist Can Answer": • Questions No Atheist C...
--
As always, thank you kindly for the view, and I hope that this video helps reveal the fact that Islam is NOT the most feminist religion.

Опубликовано:

 

9 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 7 тыс.   
@animarul6149
@animarul6149 3 года назад
As an Iranian woman, I clapped for the man who said it was an insult to Iranian women. I was wondering if that woman lives in the same universe as us.
@leilasa6118
@leilasa6118 3 года назад
As an Iranian woman I couldnt agree more.. the only reason one could make such an absurd claim and deny the suppression of women in islamic countries such as Iran is that they are somehow related or supported by the regime...she is probably the spawn of one of the regime officials who enjoys living a free life in a western country while advocating for one of the most evil ideologies in the world..the hypocrisy is unreal ...and her accent is arabic when she says Astaghferollah smh
@RyanKeane9
@RyanKeane9 3 года назад
The wonderful Christopher Hitchens.
@HarshitSharma-lb3ul
@HarshitSharma-lb3ul 3 года назад
@@RyanKeane9 Wonderful Late Hitchens. the world misses that guy dearly!
@RyanKeane9
@RyanKeane9 3 года назад
@@HarshitSharma-lb3ul we certainly do Harshit x
@padraigmcgrath3876
@padraigmcgrath3876 3 года назад
Well, let's see now.... Do you have an engineering-degree? The reason I'm asking is that Iran is full of women who didn't emigrate and who DO have engineering-degrees. 60% of Iranian university-studies are women, in line with most western countries, but the difference is that in Iran, women DON'T study flouncy pseudo-academic bollocks like "gender-studies." In Iran, both men and women actually get real degrees - maths, chemistry, physics, engineering, etc.... Proper, traditional academic disciplines. On my return from Iran, this was what had really impressed me - NOBODY there has a wishy-washy degree in "marketing" or "communications," or any other airhead pseudo-academic shite like that..... It seems to me that a society which really wanted to disempower women WOULDN'T be equipping them en masse with degrees in maths, chemistry and engineering.
@CosmicSkeptic
@CosmicSkeptic 5 лет назад
0:57: ‘What about equal rights for women?’ ‘That is completely separate from Islam!’ She’s not wrong...
@jl9062
@jl9062 5 лет назад
Lol
@aceofleaf606
@aceofleaf606 5 лет назад
Women have equal rights to each other and I believe to dogs as well. I'm certain upon reading the Quran and the hadiths there were numerous references to the cleanliness of a woman being as that of a dog. (Can't find reliable sources for this, would appreciate if anyone can confirm/deny)
@xCorvus7x
@xCorvus7x 5 лет назад
@@aceofleaf606 What?
@xCorvus7x
@xCorvus7x 5 лет назад
@@aceofleaf606 As stated above, I'm in shock. Do you have some verses to look it up?
@Flyingtart
@Flyingtart 5 лет назад
AceOfLeaf Not trying to defend Islam here but that sounds like bullshit.
@cap-lelite246
@cap-lelite246 5 лет назад
Islamic feminism ? Sounds like an oxymoron.
@belisarius6949
@belisarius6949 5 лет назад
How did you watch this fucking video. That screaming Cherry Picker girl gave me a headache.
@riadachour9864
@riadachour9864 5 лет назад
exactly.
@nicolasandre9886
@nicolasandre9886 5 лет назад
Abrahamic religions are as much feminist as oil companies are ecologists.
@phileas007
@phileas007 5 лет назад
here's how: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CQw3KSYD3ns.html
@laurenceellis6256
@laurenceellis6256 5 лет назад
Unless 'Islamic feminism' is feminism that challenges traditional or misogynistic attitudes towards Muslim women with the feminist aim of equality between the sexes & female empowerment.
@someoneortwo5290
@someoneortwo5290 3 года назад
Best defence of Islamists: “People talk about Islam without knowing anything about it” When someone reads about it and try to question: “Your interpretations are wrong”
@football_fanatic_Ethan
@football_fanatic_Ethan 3 года назад
Very true
@ErnestoRodriguez-ln5ik
@ErnestoRodriguez-ln5ik 3 года назад
Str8 up
@prolgbt_exmuslim7976
@prolgbt_exmuslim7976 3 года назад
True
@maryammussa6850
@maryammussa6850 3 года назад
Islam IS up for interpretation. Why do you think there are so many Islamic sectors and different schools of thought? There are Sunni Muslims, shia, sufi, Salafi (sector of Sunni) and more. They all have some similar and some opposing interpretation of the Quran. The Quran encourages individual reflections and there are many versus that proves this. One of which is "(this is) a blessed book which we have revealed to you (oh Mohammed), that they might reflect upon it's verse and that those of understanding would be reminded- (Quran 38:29).
@mounaimomri554
@mounaimomri554 3 года назад
@@maryammussa6850 so if anyone could possibly have his own interpretation, then way islam os based on creating a theocracy?
@PurpleRhymesWithOrange
@PurpleRhymesWithOrange 5 лет назад
Islam gave women rights before European women had any? Viking women had the right to inherit and own land around 400 CE.
@typingcat
@typingcat 5 лет назад
Viking women... Death by snu snu?
@vacri54
@vacri54 5 лет назад
And shag men other than their husbands. Lets see either the christians or the muslims be okay with that little tidbit.
@ROTAXD
@ROTAXD 5 лет назад
Ahmed Tarek and muslims love taqiya because it encourages them to lie to "infidels" and claim "we come in peace".
@adityajoshi3886
@adityajoshi3886 5 лет назад
Apparently in some very early Hindu societies, women could own property and divorce... However that right steadly eroded, just like the rights of women around the world at that time
@sliperysid
@sliperysid 5 лет назад
But your factual statement doesn't fit in with the progressive cultural narrative!! Be carefull, as soon you'll be sent for training to rid you of that wrong think!!
@rationalityrules
@rationalityrules 5 лет назад
Next up, "Nazi pacifism" :P
@Timbo5000
@Timbo5000 5 лет назад
Pfff, people talk about Nazism all the time without knowing a thing about it. Invading other countries is German culture, not Nazism. And Hitler loved dogs, how can you be against loving dogs? Some people....
@arjunmalhotra8561
@arjunmalhotra8561 5 лет назад
Hahaha! How about, "Socialist capitalism"? :P
@Timbo5000
@Timbo5000 5 лет назад
@@arjunmalhotra8561 You mean social democracies?
@nidavelliir
@nidavelliir 5 лет назад
"Jewish Nazism"
@k-techpl7222
@k-techpl7222 5 лет назад
Regis "Invading other countries is German culture" that is actually true.
@jebemtigolaz
@jebemtigolaz 3 года назад
"What about equal rights for women?" "That is separate from Islam" Thank you and goodbye everyone, we've got our answer straight away.
@alicefaitdescarabistouille924
@alicefaitdescarabistouille924 3 года назад
She is not lying though.
@jebemtigolaz
@jebemtigolaz 3 года назад
@@alicefaitdescarabistouille924 That's the point. Islam and human righst are two completely different and separate matters.
@alicefaitdescarabistouille924
@alicefaitdescarabistouille924 3 года назад
@@jebemtigolaz I can't agree more.
@rakeebahmed5153
@rakeebahmed5153 4 года назад
Yasmin-"we ain't their property " Quran, surah nisa capter3 ,verse 34- " men are in charge of women "
@jaciemokidm609
@jaciemokidm609 4 года назад
She was implying about how Islam doesn't have the western historical background of changing women's last names after marriage as a sign of property. This is fact lol. "in charge of women" means they must maintain and provide for women. They are our caregivers, which makes way more sense than feminism today. Islamic marriage incorporates rights over each other, both the man over the woman, and the woman over the man. This is simply logical.
@informationyes
@informationyes 4 года назад
@@jaciemokidm609 No it says "in charge of woman" not provide for them and as for today with feminism well if you haven't noticed woman are working and providing for themselves as well now, just that modern thing where woman also work, as for last names its simply that the kids always belong to their father in name its nothing to do with equal rights
@VogtTD
@VogtTD 4 года назад
@@jaciemokidm609 whatever hoops you have to jump through to aleviate your cognative dissonance
@BlueEyesWhiteTeddy
@BlueEyesWhiteTeddy 4 года назад
isn't it 4:34?
@void6752
@void6752 4 года назад
Jacie Mokidm no it doesn’t we are in charge of Muslim women if you want to leave the house for any reason that is non religious you must ask me yea we have to provide food clothes but I have to have sex when we ask we can beat you if you disobey us 4:34 and u can’t work or leave the house or even take part in voluntary fasts as long As we say you can’t we are allowed to shield our wives from being seen by other men so u can’t work in a gender mixed area it’s haram ur changing the religion to be accepted by atheist but this is the trusts of Islam I am Muslim these are the mans rights Over his wife
@LITrovert
@LITrovert 3 года назад
Whenever you feel delusional, remember that this lady exists.
@theace8502
@theace8502 Год назад
And the second lady, and the crowds that cheered for them. Which I absolutely don't understand how unless they had a clap sign
@pbezunartea
@pbezunartea 3 года назад
"We don't take our husband's last names 'cause we ain't their property!" Neither do Spanish, Chinese, South-Korean, Portuguese, Malaysia, Dutch, etc...
@gal_targareayn6721
@gal_targareayn6721 3 года назад
Honestly, in today's world it depends on woman...
@thelanktheist2626
@thelanktheist2626 3 года назад
@@gal_targareayn6721 Which isn’t a bad thing. Sometimes men wanna change their last name because their surname was Fuch.
@jhalakmalhotra4242
@jhalakmalhotra4242 3 года назад
She is wrong Muslim women are properties in different way is they give birth to many children to satisfy her husband's most prized possession and also Shariya .women have to live with another woman who is married to him before the new wife without divorce.Divorce is non existent in India Pakistan and Bangladesh .We Indians want Uniform Civil code but muslims oppose it .No one has come out and say they want UCC.
@user-bz3xo4kr5v
@user-bz3xo4kr5v 3 года назад
Because it’s patriarchal 💀
@maryamkidwai2543
@maryamkidwai2543 3 года назад
@@jhalakmalhotra4242 thats not Islam, thats ppl, and messed up ppl exist evrywhere in every religion, you wanna take the messed up ones and make them representatoves of the entire faith. Thats yoir problem. Those problems are pretty common in India for ppl of all faiths.🙄
@thomasf.9717
@thomasf.9717 4 года назад
"my problem is that people talk about islam without knowing anything about it" Oh, the irony...
@mdaddy775
@mdaddy775 3 года назад
Oh the accuracy.... idiots like Jacqui (the one on the panel) just denigrate an entire religion based on myths and slogans.
@thomasf.9717
@thomasf.9717 3 года назад
@Sad Sad being muslim or speaking arabic does not give you any knowledge about Islam. You need to actually put in the work and study it.
@renade7131
@renade7131 3 года назад
I’m tired of seeing this statement everywhere I go🤦‍♂️
@skmanth6194
@skmanth6194 3 года назад
@@renade7131 all the comments are same . Its shows that if we follow anything blindly then no one even nothing can changed our beleifs ,that's same happened with religion protestors.
@hazimm88
@hazimm88 3 года назад
@@thomasf.9717 "being muslim does not give you any knowledge about islam" bruhh what if they were muslim they would definitely know islam....
@wildchild574
@wildchild574 Год назад
As an ex-muslim I can proudly say islam doesn't support feminism
@LeedsUnitedJohn
@LeedsUnitedJohn 5 лет назад
If Yasmin was living in an Islamic Country she would see it differently.
@infinity-gn9xq
@infinity-gn9xq 5 лет назад
Exactly
@zapkvr
@zapkvr 5 лет назад
Correct. She's a hypocrite
@drd.n4695
@drd.n4695 5 лет назад
She won't. She will crib about the West.
@dr.medicine9723
@dr.medicine9723 5 лет назад
haha you guys. Sharia is not set in stone fiqh rullings are based on the ijtihad mujtahids make. Also we believe what God says is objectively moral since God is perfect.
@lil_weasel219
@lil_weasel219 5 лет назад
I dont think she'd see anything...she'd be long gone really....
@GreeeenT
@GreeeenT 5 лет назад
according to this lady, prophet mohammed himself didn't follow "real islam"
@derbarone
@derbarone 5 лет назад
pbuh
@torenico
@torenico 5 лет назад
dayum
@edwardmagnic8302
@edwardmagnic8302 5 лет назад
Green T don’t spread lies
@antediluvianatheist5262
@antediluvianatheist5262 5 лет назад
@@derbarone Fuck muhammad.
@twinkiesmaster69
@twinkiesmaster69 5 лет назад
@@edwardmagnic8302 don't spread lies
@cpsaleemyt
@cpsaleemyt 5 лет назад
This lady wears makeup, does'nt cover her face, speaks her mind(loudly), sits next to a man and has the audacity to talk about SHARIA. She Could Be punished under SHARIA LAW !!!
@raul7628
@raul7628 5 лет назад
Saleem Raza don't show your ignorance dick head
@raul7628
@raul7628 5 лет назад
Michael Tilley because he himself knows it is not true. There is little to debate.
@----.__
@----.__ 5 лет назад
@@raul7628 So what is the truth then? Enlighten those of us who know that mohammed is a false prophet who rapes children, and allah is nothing more than a big funky sky fairy.
@raul7628
@raul7628 5 лет назад
Be blessed in your own paradigm which suits you.
@raul7628
@raul7628 5 лет назад
Mr.Tweezy007 want some .
@sheidasha2183
@sheidasha2183 4 года назад
Thank you. I'm living in Iran and trying to get out of here. I suffer all my life for living in Islamic society under Islamic government. You exactly talked my pain and trauma. I appreciate your work. 💗 That's not easy to understand your videos for me for English is not my first language but I watch your videos several times and write down some parts to educate me better. I'm practicing how to debate and discuss reasonably and how to understand and communicate better. I guess Persian language and Iranian culture are not capable enough for philosophical debates so I have to work hard as I'm not taught in a first place. Thank you 🙂
@VeganimalLiberation
@VeganimalLiberation 3 года назад
Hope you the best!
@toanhien494
@toanhien494 3 года назад
wish you the best. I know some iraniens where I live. They also abandoned Iran because of Islamic regime. They are all well educated and good people.
@oirereomanga7936
@oirereomanga7936 3 года назад
Be strong bro
@penpithmind1941
@penpithmind1941 3 года назад
@Sad Sad Well it came from religion
@penpithmind1941
@penpithmind1941 3 года назад
@Sad Sad I agree with morocco. But also they don't have resoruces and totally dependent on tourism and Europe. So can't allow 100% conservative Islamic, or they will loose all money. There are more than 50 officially recognised Islamic countries and you're giving small dependent countries like Morocco, Tunisia as example. Look how hard it's to find a good example.
@pipsantos6278
@pipsantos6278 5 лет назад
This woman should vacation in Saudi or Iran.
@annnee6818
@annnee6818 5 лет назад
Yeah good idea.
@johnsalazar2581
@johnsalazar2581 5 лет назад
I think that Afghanistan would be better.
@marktate3431
@marktate3431 5 лет назад
She is from an even worse shit hole Sudan... I wish she would go back there
@moehoffman9830
@moehoffman9830 5 лет назад
This women must be stoned in a public place.
@katravi
@katravi 5 лет назад
HB they are not racists. Islam is NOT a race. Period.
@leadpain
@leadpain 5 лет назад
she sad "islam to me.." islam is not about you or about your point of view. im living in turkey and i can say that she know nothing about islam.
@c.m3162
@c.m3162 5 лет назад
I read this exactly when it said it on the video. I approve this comment.
@dsmgamesvlog5998
@dsmgamesvlog5998 5 лет назад
I agree bro
@leaveme3559
@leaveme3559 5 лет назад
@@theubayd9207 why did u actually left the damn religion anyway before coming back to it... What now ur OK with quran calling on beating the fuck out of the atheist and homosexuals... Or a women opinions are half as worthy as man's... Or u have every right to beat ur wife if she doesn't want to fuck.....wtf... Just convert to some Eastern religion if u need God that bad atleast they don't call for a fucking jihad against the non believers
@Conserpov
@Conserpov 5 лет назад
+Mehmet Çoksever _> I can say that she knows nothing about islam._ I bet she is simply lying.
@MrQuagmire26
@MrQuagmire26 5 лет назад
I'm not an ex-muslim, never lived in an Islamic country or know everything about Islam. But unlike many leftists, apologists and Muslims I did read enough to conclude that Islam is not all peace, love, and tolerance. People who blindly say "Islam means peace" should take a break, sit down and read and THEN come back with real evidence that backs up their claims. Islam is an ideology with 3 aspects. One religious, one legal (sharia) and one political (the caliphate). Islam is a religion of peace AND war. And before people pull out the "racist, bigot, and Islamophobe" card: No I don't hate Muslims, I'm not a racist nor do I support violence against anyone. But I disagree with certain Ideas that are not very friendly to mankind, or in this case women. People are free to criticize ideas without being threatened. Critique won't kill anyone, so extremists should at least learn not to act violently just because someone disagrees.
@terrykrow7820
@terrykrow7820 5 лет назад
I read the Quran. It perfectly states that a woman's word is worth HALF of a man's... Check it.
@michaelmagdy6647
@michaelmagdy6647 5 лет назад
They also inherit half that a man inherits. They always can justify everything because of the divine wisdom of Allah though.
@punkisinthedetails1470
@punkisinthedetails1470 4 года назад
is that like the proverbial two birds one stone or a bird (cock?) in the hand is worth two in the bush.
@vallisdaemonumofficial
@vallisdaemonumofficial 4 года назад
*🎶 I'M HALF THE MAN I USED TO BE🎶*
@imenehariri2139
@imenehariri2139 4 года назад
It does, i live in a Muslim country , let's say i need a non work certificate, in order for me to obtain it I'd need to take four women with me for them to testify with me, while i only need two men for that.
@nathanielhamilton5841
@nathanielhamilton5841 4 года назад
They got the good half so it all works out though...😂😂😂
@100percentdank
@100percentdank 4 года назад
"because we aren't property" The Quran literally calls you property
@jesan733
@jesan733 3 года назад
"The Quran literally calls you property" Well, and in the bible, among the ten commandments, wives are mentioned along with slaves in this list presumably ordered by importance: "You shall not covet your neighbor's house. You shall not covet your neighbor's wife, or his male or female servant, his ox or donkey, or anything that belongs to your neighbor."
@theishmaelitecaesar6431
@theishmaelitecaesar6431 3 года назад
Tf where does it say in the Quran that women are nothing but mere "property"?
@talahamarneh2809
@talahamarneh2809 3 года назад
Nobody said that he's a christian
@alexb9969
@alexb9969 3 года назад
@@jesan733 of course that's why the Bible will probably go next
@vinportobg
@vinportobg 3 года назад
@@jesan733 now those 10 commandments are for both sexes in Christianity, women get their rights at the 5th gathering of the churches at around 800AD i think where its states no man can force or give a woman into marriage against her will, whoever does it is not a Christian. However the Christian woman is to obey the law of the land if its otherwise. It was like that because Christianity was not a leading religion still.
@jake_runs_the_world
@jake_runs_the_world 5 лет назад
Send her to Saudi 🇸🇦 not Australia 🇦🇺
@weebnonce8327
@weebnonce8327 5 лет назад
But Britain deports to Australia
@drd.n4695
@drd.n4695 5 лет назад
She's from Sudan. As a devout Muslim, she has to drop all her makeup. Put a veil. Not talk to unknown men. That's her Izlam.
@the_polish_prince8966
@the_polish_prince8966 4 года назад
@@drd.n4695 heheh Izlam
@arnoldstallonereeves7469
@arnoldstallonereeves7469 3 года назад
Better send her to Europe 🇪🇺 Europe will be majority Islamic 🇮🇷🇦🇺🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇩🇿🇬🇷🇦🇫🇲🇷🇵🇹🇲🇻🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇹🇳🇳🇱🇲🇾🇱🇺🇲🇦🇳🇴🇪🇷🇬🇧🇵🇰🇮🇹🇸🇦🇩🇪🇪🇬🇸🇪🇦🇱🇫🇮🇹🇷🇲🇨🇱🇾🇫🇷🇸🇾🇪🇺🇪🇭🇪🇸🇧🇩🇧🇪🇦🇪 country in next 80 or even just 50 years. Not Poland🇵🇱 Czech🇨🇿 Slovakia 🇸🇰 Slovenia 🇸🇮 or Hungary 🇭🇺.
@manumit1394
@manumit1394 5 лет назад
Yasmin is not exposed to Sharia law as it is expressed in Muslim countries. She is loud and mistaken. You go Steven
@sirdiogenes2320
@sirdiogenes2320 5 лет назад
"Islamic feminism" is a bit like "Stalinist libertarianism" or "kosher pork".
@seasalt489
@seasalt489 5 лет назад
Stalin did nothing wrong
@daemon1143
@daemon1143 5 лет назад
Apart from persecution of the Kulaks, socially engineered famine, ethnic cleansing, the Great Terror, mass executions in the annexed territories, mass deportations and asset theft, you might be right. After all, he delegated a lot of the more direct crimes to his friends like the lovable Lavrentiy Beria. Still, I'm happy to let you own a share in his culpability that your support buys you.
@seasalt489
@seasalt489 5 лет назад
@@daemon1143 those are goid things lol 😂😂😂
@BurazSC2
@BurazSC2 5 лет назад
Hey, Kosher pork is awesome. Tastes like tofu.
@somegirl4631
@somegirl4631 5 лет назад
as a jew I agree. 🤦🏾‍♀️
@Der_lachende_Sachefish
@Der_lachende_Sachefish 3 года назад
Is wonderful how many rights Muslim women get granted when living in a non-Muslim country. Interesting.
@ohiodelia4899
@ohiodelia4899 3 года назад
I live in a muslim country and i have many rights granted to me. but y'all only know iran and saudi arabia which that is their culture not the religion itself
@jangohemmes352
@jangohemmes352 3 года назад
@@ohiodelia4899 How can you make the exact same point that was debunked in this video. You are also separating culture and religion even though the two are clearly inseparable in those countries
@gal_targareayn6721
@gal_targareayn6721 3 года назад
@@ohiodelia4899 I want to know about the testimony of woman in a rape case.... If you would like to enlighten us
@nawalwani3900
@nawalwani3900 2 года назад
@@ohiodelia4899 which country?
@user-uu2cj9ct3j
@user-uu2cj9ct3j Год назад
@M Soundous I'm not sure that is the exact argument this person is making. She are saying that she lives in a Muslim country that doesn't have restrictions on women's rights like in those two countries. I'd say her point is more that the OP is generalizing broadly, and to chalk it all up to religion is lacking any nuance while approaching the topic. I think its important to realize that Islam is not some hivemind or monolith where everybody approaches the religion in the same way, just like you find huge variety in Christians and how they practice.
@muruganchilayah1427
@muruganchilayah1427 5 лет назад
Being loud makes u right.. according to Yasmin
@humblesentiments1553
@humblesentiments1553 5 лет назад
All muslims think this way unfortunately. Even the moderates struggle to keep their voice down.
@banishedfromthedwarfplanet530
@banishedfromthedwarfplanet530 5 лет назад
That's also typical of black people. The louder, the righter.
@okthen.2235
@okthen.2235 4 года назад
Typical of leftists, Islamist, LGBT, fanatics all who are used to losing their arguments
@punkisinthedetails1470
@punkisinthedetails1470 4 года назад
or CROWDER
@punkisinthedetails1470
@punkisinthedetails1470 4 года назад
my opinion goes up to 11
@nightshadeavian4989
@nightshadeavian4989 5 лет назад
I have Muslim friends who happened to be female They all told me Islam doesn't really love women as much as it loves men lol
@RoastedLocust
@RoastedLocust 5 лет назад
Well, Islam permits men to have four wives, and when they get tired of having sex with them, they're permitted to have sex with their female slaves. Islam favors the penis more than anything.
@LukeVilent
@LukeVilent 5 лет назад
@@RoastedLocust And when a male is righteous and goes to haven, he is given some 72 huris to rape for eternity, while nothing is said about women.
@sweetjello_7057
@sweetjello_7057 5 лет назад
@@RoastedLocust source?
@RoastedLocust
@RoastedLocust 5 лет назад
@@sweetjello_7057 , look it up yourself, and when you find that passage, remember that "the ones you possess" actually means slaves. BTW, in one of his biographies, Mohammed had all the men and boys in another tribe killed, and being the nice guy that he was, he forced the widow of one of the men he killed to marry him in order to have sex with her that night. It's a religion invented to satisfy the worst desires of one man.
@sweetjello_7057
@sweetjello_7057 5 лет назад
@Eyre Borne Why do i have to look it up? show me the exact verse and back up your statement.
@LPempty
@LPempty 3 года назад
“We don’t take our husband’s names because we’re not their property” yes because you’re your fathers property and your father has more right over you than your husband. You’re still a man’s property according islam both to your husband and father
@pallll12r
@pallll12r 3 года назад
+ only in usa happens that thing about surname, in Italy women remain with their names
@jadenhalstead7290
@jadenhalstead7290 3 года назад
“We got equal rights way before Europeans did” Is that why women couldn’t drive in Saudi Arabia until the end of 2017?
@zd2686
@zd2686 3 года назад
Ehm Saudi Arabia’s treatment of women do not not represent the whole Muslim world. It is generalisation and not fair judgment to really think that the face of Islam equals Saudi Arabia.
@jefrreyjeffery2192
@jefrreyjeffery2192 3 года назад
In Turkey (99% muslim majority country), women got right to vote in 1930's... Long before France and Switzerland! Have a great day! Muah💋
@skmanth6194
@skmanth6194 3 года назад
@@jefrreyjeffery2192 oh man u hurt a lot . Hmm ..... Sometimes It's not easy to accept the truth because sometimes its not undigestable to our simp mind .
@skmanth6194
@skmanth6194 3 года назад
@@jefrreyjeffery2192 oh man u hurt a lot . Hmm ..... Sometimes It's not easy to accept the truth because sometimes its not undigestable to our simp mind .
@skmanth6194
@skmanth6194 3 года назад
@@jefrreyjeffery2192 oh man u hurt a lot . Hmm ..... Sometimes It's not easy to accept the truth because sometimes its not undigestable to our simp mind .
@colinwillis9096
@colinwillis9096 5 лет назад
Oh s***. Who knew the most important right for a woman was keeping her surname. F*** education, autonomy, working, not being raped, being able to wear clothing.
@ghett0_tech228
@ghett0_tech228 5 лет назад
Water and oil, islam and equal rights
@theortheo2401
@theortheo2401 5 лет назад
Best comparison ^
@irreview
@irreview 5 лет назад
Like Western liberals wars to promote democracy. Complete oxymoron
@AnonURnot
@AnonURnot 5 лет назад
irreview How So?
@gyroscope8244
@gyroscope8244 5 лет назад
You mean Islam is more denser than equal rights?
@rey_nemaattori
@rey_nemaattori 5 лет назад
Women still can't vote in Saudi-Arabia, but then again...men can't either, so that's pretty equal yeah xD
@itsonlyacommentsnowflake3346
@itsonlyacommentsnowflake3346 5 лет назад
😂
@PrasanthKumar-vg6tp
@PrasanthKumar-vg6tp 5 лет назад
Nailed it
@drd.n4695
@drd.n4695 5 лет назад
lol ...
@souljastation5463
@souljastation5463 4 года назад
@Save Earth And they have American guns to back the monarchy, so good luck to Saudi progressives.
@euanstokes2828
@euanstokes2828 4 года назад
'when I said I agree with equal rights, I meant that men shouldn't be able to vote either' - Benito Mussolini
@adrianrouse5148
@adrianrouse5148 3 года назад
Many years ago I was called out to fix a car that would not start. When I got to the house where the car was I rang the doorbell. I was told through the letter box that the car was at the rear of the property. I was asked to walk around the block to get to the car. I was busy trying to fix the car when the lady opened a litle way a window and asked if I would like a cup of tea. Ohho yes please I said. In a couple of minutes she came back with a mug of tea.but it would not go under the gap in the window. I went to lift the window and she told me that's all it will lift as her husband had locked both doors and windows while he was not home.she found a lower tea cup and I got my cup of tea.i got the car working and left. I have thought many times about that poor lady. So I laugh when I hear about muslim feminists
@pallll12r
@pallll12r 3 года назад
My god that is terrible
@stavroulathebest
@stavroulathebest 3 года назад
As an atheist i dont just dislike islam as a religion,i dislike all religions that give ground to men to have a higher power.Practising muslims might defend islam and not see the fault in the religion(first clue is the hypocrisy that covering yourself is obligatory but at the same time you cannot make people coven themselves as if that makes any sense) but i also cannkt stoo thinking that religion every where where the god is male puts more value on men and victim blames the women and it condones violence against women because religious aspects do easily become opressive culture.Msny muslims seem to forget that people(mostly men) excuse immoral and violent actions on their religion and that becomes normalised.Also both sexes become brainwashed and just normalise every bad aspect of their religion and might not ever question it.lastly lets not forget that just because you are either born as one of the two sexes that doesnt mean that your gender identity will go along your sex or you might not be straight.Any religion that is against same gender/sex relationships is not an all accepting religion and will never be.
@mylerwilson4879
@mylerwilson4879 2 года назад
Holy shit that’s just sad
@adrikkozlov
@adrikkozlov Месяц назад
As someone who experience it on daily basis from father, brother and community it's indeed sad.
@mikeh7917
@mikeh7917 5 лет назад
Yeah....cherry pick the 2 or 3 verses or hadiths that support women vs the THOUSANDS that put them down!
@CrunchyNorbert
@CrunchyNorbert 5 лет назад
you mean back when Mohammed (PBUH) was a penniless boytoy epileptic with no followers living in a pagan stronghold? Its weird how his desert god got a lot less forgiving the moment Mohammed had the power to exert power on those around him
@wade2bosh
@wade2bosh 5 лет назад
welcome to christianity interpretatins
@user-rr9gh5ko1c
@user-rr9gh5ko1c 5 лет назад
Could you please tell us just 10 from those thousands you ?
@MrJMont21
@MrJMont21 5 лет назад
ابن آدم i wonder if he could bring even 3
@pierre-pete-martin7576
@pierre-pete-martin7576 5 лет назад
My heart goes out to all those that suffer from Sharia law.
@Easy.Stocks.arabic.english
@Easy.Stocks.arabic.english Год назад
Nobody suffers from sharia law
@user-kf3is7bt2v
@user-kf3is7bt2v Год назад
@@Easy.Stocks.arabic.english yes I agree no body suffers from shariah law
@Dcm193
@Dcm193 Год назад
@@user-kf3is7bt2v women,gays,apostates,blasphemers ??
@human610
@human610 Год назад
@@Dcm193 women? No, gays and apostates and blasphemers yes and it’s a good thing
@denizbluemusic
@denizbluemusic Год назад
spoken like a true psychopath
@MrTheraystriker
@MrTheraystriker 5 лет назад
Even though I'm an atheist, i disagree.. Islam gives women rights... The right to obey their husbands ;)
@Gamepak
@Gamepak 5 лет назад
the right to go and cook my dinner and the right to stfu when i tell her to
@Korajiyo
@Korajiyo 5 лет назад
ya they let the more competent man in their life handle all their problems.
@Dannyboivt
@Dannyboivt 5 лет назад
The right to obey or get beaten. The right to be worth half as much as a man. The right to have your husband marry multiple wives. The right to cover up or get harassed or raped.
@thrownswordpommel7393
@thrownswordpommel7393 5 лет назад
The right to walk around wrapped in a black sheet.
@cauliflowerhead2735
@cauliflowerhead2735 3 года назад
I was arguing about the death penalty for apostasy with a man in my office a few months back and he did exactly what Yasmin did - he kept speaking over me, accused me of Islamophobia and not knowing the "real Islam".
@cauliflowerhead2735
@cauliflowerhead2735 3 года назад
@पार्थ आशा there is no way to be neutral about dogma that could end in death.
@Timeren2010
@Timeren2010 2 месяца назад
There is no doubt about the death penalty of apostasy in islam. Its a solid fact, anyone who says otherwise are either ignorant, or lying.
@RobertEdwinHouse9
@RobertEdwinHouse9 5 лет назад
Islamic feminism Biggest oxymoron of all time
@benner1320
@benner1320 5 лет назад
I dunno about an oxy. But she’s definitely a moron.
@MNAKHUDA96
@MNAKHUDA96 5 лет назад
Hitchslap why are so many western women converting then they obviously see something liberating within it. Use your intellect.
@RobertEdwinHouse9
@RobertEdwinHouse9 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-v0Q6DtfUynQ.html here is hitch destroying islam
@leklektan1358
@leklektan1358 5 лет назад
Why Yassmin is not living in Muslim country if it is so good. Australia should send her to live in any of the Muslim countries.
@robertanderson5796
@robertanderson5796 5 лет назад
Lek Lek Tan She wouldn’t move to an Islamic country because she would never get the welfare and handouts she gets in the west.
@sliperysid
@sliperysid 5 лет назад
@beckys2222 Because of the virtue signalling cultural Marxists! They have all the positions of power and scream their outrage all the fucking time..
@spillintea683
@spillintea683 5 лет назад
Lek Lek Tan she fled Australia after she got backlash for using Anzac Day for her political agendas
@shredo2
@shredo2 5 лет назад
she sounds like she was planing to live in a Muslim country...
@spillintea683
@spillintea683 5 лет назад
Lovász Gellért you could say western Sydney is pretty much a Muslim country 🤷🏻‍♂️
@ListlessLion
@ListlessLion 5 лет назад
equal rights isn't about how much praise a woman personally gets, it's about opportunity and so much more
@vedicdisciple2877
@vedicdisciple2877 4 года назад
It's hard to rewire a religiously hardwired brain.
@LV_427
@LV_427 5 лет назад
She doesn't even wear a proper hijab. I'd like to see her interact with actual conservative Muslim. That would be delicious to watch. Oh and if in Sharia you follow the law of the land that you're in then why would you need sharia anyway?
@justinm2697
@justinm2697 5 лет назад
Not to mention that there are now Sharia courts in Australia now. So, so much for following the law of the land.
@empuwm
@empuwm 3 года назад
Conservative Muslim? You mean hypocritical Muslims? Liberal Muslims are the only true Muslims.
@alanross2482
@alanross2482 2 года назад
You wouldn't. She's full of shit and she knows it
@Fluwore
@Fluwore 5 лет назад
I am an Iranian boy and I confirm that in Iran married women are addressed by their husbands' name except by people who are their close friends and relatives who call them by their first name. For example people call my mom by my father's name and it is and seems to be usual.
@RoRo-wq1wo
@RoRo-wq1wo 3 года назад
What does it have to do with islam? Your culture.
@josephstar1883
@josephstar1883 3 года назад
But that's culture.
@hazimm88
@hazimm88 3 года назад
So only in iran i guess
@josephstar1883
@josephstar1883 3 года назад
@@hazimm88 What do you mean?
@hazimm88
@hazimm88 3 года назад
@@josephstar1883 i mean like its iranian culture prolly cuz here in malaysia n indonesia married women are not addressed by their husband's name
@allanjazzera7630
@allanjazzera7630 5 лет назад
"I'm not going to attack you personally!". Holding back the rage.
@ElroyMF1
@ElroyMF1 5 лет назад
What's wrong with that? Being angry is ok. You can't help it, it's a normal human emotion. Attacking someone personally is something totally different. You can attack someone personally whether you are angry or not. One is an emotion, the other is a behavior. I might be angry enough to rip your head clean off your shoulders, but actually doing it is a different kettle of fish, isn't it?
@allanjazzera7630
@allanjazzera7630 5 лет назад
Well, it's all in the tone of voice. And your's is loaded too.
@ElroyMF1
@ElroyMF1 5 лет назад
@@allanjazzera7630 lol, you can hear my "tone of voice"? You're delusional. And once again my friend, feeling anger is different from actions taken because of that anger. I'm not sure why this is so hard for you to understand.
@allanjazzera7630
@allanjazzera7630 4 года назад
​@@ElroyMF1 You've misconstrued the video entirely, and my point I've made. Best we let this one go, huh?
@ElroyMF1
@ElroyMF1 4 года назад
@@allanjazzera7630 if it makes you feel better to believe that. Pity your mind is so closed
@rumble1925
@rumble1925 3 года назад
It was in the news recently that an Iranian teenage girl got 10 years in prison for using facetune and posting them to instagram. Nothing lewd, just some weird facetunes I assume were made as jokes... tell me again about womens rights (or even basic common sense) in islamic societies...
@ohiodelia4899
@ohiodelia4899 3 года назад
Omg thats literally Iranian culture like i dont understand how people only bring up saudi arabia and iran when talking about islam like there are other muslim countries too
@rumble1925
@rumble1925 3 года назад
@@ohiodelia4899 I know a lot of Persians actually. Their culture is very laid back and friendly... it only seems that things like this happen when a country is run by Islamic fundamentalists (or other religoous fruitcakes)
@ohiodelia4899
@ohiodelia4899 3 года назад
@@rumble1925 mine is and nothing like this ever happens
@rumble1925
@rumble1925 3 года назад
@@ohiodelia4899 which country?
@raikou6596
@raikou6596 5 лет назад
If you follow the law of the land then why do you want sharia ?
@ROTAXD
@ROTAXD 5 лет назад
Raikou X what the muhammedians aren't telling you is that their first goal is to make the law of the land (every land) islam.
@j_forfreedom45
@j_forfreedom45 5 лет назад
law of the land... made by men... sharia (made by 1 man) is the law of god (they say)... thats why... they believe in their imaginary friend more than their fellow men... easy.
@mu9753
@mu9753 5 лет назад
@truth and common sense warrior "STUPID BLACKS" Wow you really seem sensible, sensitive, kind and having common sense. Racist bigots like you try to defame Islam while if it were up to you, you would create a world divided upon races born out of your own personal bias.
@ahmadalshehabi1138
@ahmadalshehabi1138 5 лет назад
Why do you think she wants sharia law? Assuming that practicing anything related to islam is equal to wanting the country to practice ”sharia law”
@vervoid73
@vervoid73 5 лет назад
I clean my arse with sharia!
@greatdayn4651
@greatdayn4651 5 лет назад
You have educated me, sir. I'm still learning and your channel is helping me become more educated (not just through your videos, but it gives me points to research apart from your channel). Thank you. You are a source of good change for this world.
@gavinriley5232
@gavinriley5232 5 лет назад
Narrow toe Uzumaki If he is wrong please show where. Most of us here are here to try and understand complex issues. We all understand that this is not a perfect way to deal with these issues but it is very accessible. I disagree with him very often in terms of morality however I think he is correct here.
@stephj9378
@stephj9378 5 лет назад
Just discovered him and i'm subscribing.
@stephj9378
@stephj9378 5 лет назад
I am a Buddhist,We're known for being 'chill'.Old religions struggle to stay relevant.But if they have no power - no guidance and practices in harmony with where they are today- they are erroneous. So modern people who belong to ancient religions have to cut or 'move on'from these old ideas,so, they are in a pickle, right?
@greatdayn4651
@greatdayn4651 5 лет назад
@@edwardmagnic8302 ; No and yes. In that order. If you disagree with him (and I do on some issues), please attack the issues with your own evidence-based thoughts and concerns rather than attack either him or me personally. It is indicative of a less than educated and mature mind.
@edwardmagnic8302
@edwardmagnic8302 5 лет назад
Great Dayn English isn’t my strong point and have a hard time expressing myself.do me favour and talk to imam which is Muslim scholar which they have more knowledge than myself.
@TomH2681
@TomH2681 5 лет назад
Don't talk about feminism if you're wearing a headscarf. That's the equivalent of talking about freedom while being handcuffed.
@husnabanubucus9608
@husnabanubucus9608 4 года назад
Rubbish. I wear a head scarf of my own free will. Get ur facts right. Haters of islam
@kamilawhocares8362
@kamilawhocares8362 4 года назад
@@husnabanubucus9608 Yup, so let's get ur facts straight: Firstly, there's no such thing as free will. Secondly, I highly suggest to reconsider if wearing a head scarf is truly what you want to do and not just some sad instillment from your environment. Check this out if, of course, you're willing and have time for that. He explained it far better than I can explain here -> ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-oydsfe0wT44.html
@thomasf.9717
@thomasf.9717 4 года назад
@@husnabanubucus9608 Of your own free will? So it is not because Allah told you so?
@souljastation5463
@souljastation5463 4 года назад
@@husnabanubucus9608 It's your free will? OK, then do this experiment: carry out your life as usual but for a month *don't* wear the headscarf, let's see if you can.
@mrcrackdonald_1
@mrcrackdonald_1 4 года назад
well she could be willingly wearing it, in which case I have no problem
@revive5
@revive5 3 года назад
Whatever Sharia is is irrelevant, what should be ask here is why others like Hindus, Jews and Buddhists immigrants don't present the host country with this much of problems.
@robbiepinkerton8625
@robbiepinkerton8625 5 лет назад
I really miss Christopher Hitchens, at least he's still on RU-vid. And we have his books
@PrincipalSkinner3190
@PrincipalSkinner3190 5 лет назад
She's making her argument from her own subjective (and extremely liberal) interpretation of the Qur'an.
@ashokjadhav9904
@ashokjadhav9904 5 лет назад
She would be jailed in saudi for being loud in public, without wearing hijab. Silly girl! They lash feminists under sharia law.
@tbk2010
@tbk2010 5 лет назад
Which would be fine (welcome even), if she acknowledged that and didn't twist history to fit her views.
@ashokjadhav9904
@ashokjadhav9904 5 лет назад
@@tbk2010 Ha ha ha ...😆😆😂😂👍✅👏
@alanguages
@alanguages 5 лет назад
On point sir. One Muslim female I encountered even lied, saying Muslim women in Saudi Arabia are free to do whatever they want. Example: Go outside alone without wearing any Islamic dress to identify themselves as Muslim. What got me, is she actually thought that would convince people of her bullshit. I asked, okay provide proof of women walking around outside on their own in Saudi Arabia, not adhering to an Islamic dress code. She was not able to do it. An entire bloody country, and she had the gall to say there was no Islamic dress code for women.
@ashokjadhav9904
@ashokjadhav9904 5 лет назад
@@alanguages You are absolutely right sir! But, please note that, Islam actually encourages Muslims, to tell lies to the non muslims. The aim is to deceive unbelievers. It's acceptable behavior for them. She's doing it on purpose. It's deliberate.
@mr.d.8121
@mr.d.8121 5 лет назад
Did Jasmine learn to speak at the Kardashian school of elocution?
@punkisinthedetails1470
@punkisinthedetails1470 4 года назад
Hey Mr D. "elocution" ? That's easy for you to say.
@ybjdsw
@ybjdsw 4 года назад
It's Yasmeen not Jasmine and yes the dumb bitch went to the Kardashian school.
@oo-vh2fo
@oo-vh2fo 3 года назад
Tell me about it
@danhemming6624
@danhemming6624 3 года назад
Imagine a god so insecure that it needs praying to, 5 times a day.
@empuwm
@empuwm 3 года назад
It doesn’t need praying to. We need to pray to god.
@FatymaZAli
@FatymaZAli 3 года назад
ikr
@NewPipeFTW
@NewPipeFTW 2 года назад
My boss used to leave 5 times for its 'coffee break' and thats before its even launch time.. Its kinda nice to have your break time, work-life balance written in the religion. But if it isnt useful or even harmful we should be allowed to get rid of those traditions.
@alanross2482
@alanross2482 2 года назад
It's ridiculous and impractical
@dmx92145
@dmx92145 10 месяцев назад
@@alanross2482 Shadia: From 50 prayers a day to five BY MONA SHADIA JUNE 27, 2012 7:41 PM PT This might hurt. But once it’s over, we’ll all feel better. Jerusalem, the blessed city, the witness to heaven’s miracles, the center of faith, hope and despair, is not just important to Jews and Christians. It is significant to Muslims as well. Muslims just celebrated the anniversary of the Prophet Muhammad’s Night Journey and Ascension from Mecca to Jerusalem to heaven on June 17, which this year was the 27th day of the Islamic lunar calendar month, Rajab. You almost don’t want to believe it. I mean, how could you go from Mecca in Saudi Arabia, to Jerusalem to the seventh heaven and back to Mecca in one night? But like the miraculous crossing of the sea by Moses and the birth of Jesus to the Virgin Mary, this story was also one of the first I learned about as a child. The prophet had just lost his most beloved wife, Khadija, and his uncle, Abu Talib, who raised him and protected him, and had been enduring the cruelty and physical attacks of those who didn’t believe him when God took him on the journey of the Isra and Mi’raj. He led a prayer with the prophets of Islam, where the Dome of the Rock mosque, inside Haram al Sharif (or the Noble Sanctuary) in the Old City, now stands. Jerusalem is repeatedly referred to in the Koran as the sacred and blessed land. It is also the direction in which early Muslims used to pray. That changed later when Muslims were instructed to pray toward Mecca, the same direction we believe Abraham used to pray. After leading the prayer in Jerusalem during the Night Journey and Ascension, the prophet ascended from that point to heaven and came back with instructions for Muslims to pray five times a day. He couldn’t have gotten to heaven from anywhere else. With him at almost every step of the way was the angel Gabriel. In the first heaven, the prophet met Adam. In the second, he met Jesus and John the Baptist. In the third, he met Joseph In the fourth, he met Idris (Enoch). In the fifth, he saw Aaron. In the sixth, he saw Moses. And in the seventh, he met our patriarch, Abraham. The prophet was welcomed by Adam, Jesus, John the Baptist, Joseph, Idris, Aaron and Moses as their brother, and by Abraham as his son, and a deputy of God. (It’s right about here in the story when I get goosebumps all over.) This is where it becomes clear that our religion’s root doesn’t start with Muhammad, but begins with Adam and goes on from Abraham to Jesus and beyond. Dishonoring or disrespecting one of them is like disrespecting all of them. OK. Back to the prophet’s Night Journey and Ascension. The prophet then continued on to what’s called the Lote-Tree of the Farthest Limit, and it was then when Gabriel told him he’d have to go it alone. There, the prophet spoke directly to God. He commanded him to instruct Muslims to pray 50 times a day. That’s 50! The prophet didn’t question it. But on his way back, Moses saved the day (he’s famous for that). He told Muhammad to go back and request that the number be decreased, that the burden is too high, that he’d experienced human nature with the Children of Israel, and 50 is just too much, and it isn’t going to work. The prophet went back and the number was lowered to 45. Moses again told him to return and request that the number be decreased. The number was again lowered, but not by much, to 40. Moses continued to send him back until the daily prayer was lowered from 50 to five. At that point, Moses still wanted to send him back, but Muhammad told him he was too embarrassed to go again, and the number remained at five. I would like to officially thank Moses for intervening to lower the number of daily prayers from 50 to five. Keeping up with five is tough enough. Every single command given to Muslims came from heaven to Muhammad on earth through the angel Gabriel. But when it came to prayers, the prophet was ascended to heaven to retrieve it directly. Praying is a Muslim’s direct link to God. It’s difficult to forget about God, to lie, steal, cheat or hurt when you’re constantly going back for five times a day to connect with him, to thank him and ask for his strength. It is like food for the soul. (I hear that eating small meals several times a day is a good way to stay healthy and keep your metabolism going.) So when you see a Muslim praying, remember this story. Remember that more likely than not, that Muslim is feeding his or her soul. And now, if you’ll excuse me, I’m late for my second prayer. MONA SHADIA is a reporter for Times Community News. An Egyptian American, she was born and raised in Cairo and now lives in Orange County. Her column includes various questions and issues facing Muslims in America. Follow her on Twitter @MonaShadia.
@lordthanos190
@lordthanos190 5 лет назад
Someone rightly said: Raise your standard and then your voice...
@kiranaaisyah5281
@kiranaaisyah5281 5 лет назад
When I was a Muslim, I was pretty moderate in my view especially when it comes to women, LGBT, free speech (I didn't get offended easily by jokes about Islam, yeah it's considered moderate) etc. But now I've realised that it's actually harder to defend intellectually unless you're willing to hold this cognitive dissonance and genuinely believe this moderate interpretation, or you're willing to lie. It still boggles my mind how the so called liberal, moderate, secular, feminist Muslims justify the problematic passages within Islamic sources by reinterpreting the verses to mean something else that is more benign. So basically they are saying the traditional interpretation has been wrong for 1400 years, and Islam is actually compatible with the modern values, we just misinterpreted it for a long time. It is a hard sell, that's why the fundamentalists can sniff out these attempts and call out the moderate types as hypocrites. And I would say that they hate the liberal Muslims more than they hate atheists, gays, or just plain kafir, also vice versa. In my country, the liberal Muslims hate the fundamentalists, islamists type so much and they want to ban the fundamentalist preachers for spreading hate towards minority (even though the hate can be traced back from the the legitimate Islamic sources). It is probably the only time that I'm willing to defend the fundamentalist preachers in the name of free speech because their dawah is not calling for violence, sometimes just reiterating something from the Qur'an or hadith. And we can debunk their ideas, but not banning them. The other day, an Islamist preacher has been accused of blasphemy against Christianity by some Christians, and also supported by some liberal muslims. That Islamist preacher just made joke like this "if Jesus were the Son of God, who is the midwife"? It's not funny but if you're truly for free speech, and want an abolition of blasphemy accross the board, then it has to be consistent from both sides. That being said, for me personally, it is actually more frustrating to listen to Yasmin, Reza Aslan, Mehdi Hassan who are doing this acrobatic theology than the fundamentalist types who are being more honest about the doctrines.
@fcold9402
@fcold9402 5 лет назад
Yeah so that is kind of what I always wondered about blasphemy laws. As soon as you pass them doesn't islam have to go away? I mean it is blasphemous toward Christianity and especially Jewdisim. Christianity too is blasphemous to Jewdisim. And jewdisim is blasphemous to the various "pagan" religions. I mean if we assume the religions that came first are the first people wronged a newish religion like Islam doesn't have a chance, especially with their religious leaders inability to stay out of peoples lives and continuously insulting people of other religions.
@Hephaestikon
@Hephaestikon 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith You are an absolute idiot.
@adhomanon9384
@adhomanon9384 5 лет назад
Exactly - same with the bible. They are ancient texts from another time, and need to be done away with. We need a new religion of humanism and logic.
@adhomanon9384
@adhomanon9384 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith :obvious bait is obvious: lol
@kutu3029
@kutu3029 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith u mean liars.
@mayaz1682
@mayaz1682 5 лет назад
I have so much to say.. But I live in a country that is governed by sharia law and I could be killed for it So I'll just remain quiet
@IbrahimMehdiStudios
@IbrahimMehdiStudios 4 года назад
Shari'a 'Law' isn't invasive dictatorship.
@anandsuralkar2947
@anandsuralkar2947 4 года назад
Good decision
@kingsman428
@kingsman428 4 года назад
@@IbrahimMehdiStudios Just the religion then...
@IbrahimMehdiStudios
@IbrahimMehdiStudios 4 года назад
@@kingsman428 umm no not really. More the political agenda of the government
@kingsman428
@kingsman428 4 года назад
@@IbrahimMehdiStudios Nothing political about the word of a women being half the value of a man's. Religion per se is an *"... invasive dictatorship..."* after all, what is the Islamic punishment for apostasy?
@fromeveryting29
@fromeveryting29 3 года назад
"We got womens rights way before the europeans" she says, in a european language, on a european platform, speaking european feminist theory, in an european country. Seems to me that everything giving her that voice is... european.
@jefrreyjeffery2192
@jefrreyjeffery2192 3 года назад
I'm so sorry to inform you that Australia ain't European country :/
@fromeveryting29
@fromeveryting29 3 года назад
@@jefrreyjeffery2192 lol, true, but its culture and language is. So my point still stands. I really consider it a part of Europe, even if geographically remote. Even Eurovision song contest hosts Austraila every year.
@jefrreyjeffery2192
@jefrreyjeffery2192 3 года назад
@@fromeveryting29 Middle east used to be a knowledge hub in old times but now it's turned pretty bad :/
@fromeveryting29
@fromeveryting29 3 года назад
@@jefrreyjeffery2192 I know. I learned it a year ago in university, and was really impressed. The middle-east has been a powerhouse of intellectual development, culture and art. Much of what we call "western society" has it's ideas built on middle eastern science during the medieval period, as well as greek, egyptian and mesopotamian culture. Really sad what has happened there since then..
@jefrreyjeffery2192
@jefrreyjeffery2192 3 года назад
@@fromeveryting29 You're right. Arab Scholars like ibn rashud gave us Algebra, Algorithms, Numerical systems and the list goes on! After the 19th century, there was a rise of secularism in middle east. You can see the footages of Egypt and Iran in 1960's, they were all western looking and there were no hijabs. But US funded agencies like "muslim brotherhood" and some conservative agencies in Iran and other Arab countries. After these agencies got popular, Hijab and burkha came in middle east and middle east got destroyed! USA and Israel stopped the rise of secularism in Arab world :(
@yahyahasan2004
@yahyahasan2004 5 лет назад
Im an ex Muslim... #stay_away_from_islam trust me on that
@mr.normalguy69
@mr.normalguy69 5 лет назад
You just quoted the 'Apostate Prophet' thumbs up for you.👍👍👍
@typingcat
@typingcat 5 лет назад
The problem is, I am not going near Islam, but Islam is coming to me, and I have no where to escape. Europe is already half-conquered by Islam, and now Islam is coming to Asian countries, where I live. And all these multiculturalism and diversity propaganda make such an easy environment that Islam can take advantage of and multiply. If I reject Islam coming to my country, they will simply use easy rhetorics like 'racist' and 'islamophobia' and the radical left will take care of the rest.
@MrYogidoo
@MrYogidoo 5 лет назад
Well, before joining any religion, dwell a little on why others have left it. And if your new favourite religion threatens you with death if you leave it, at the very least consider if that is something you can risk.
@bellycurious
@bellycurious 5 лет назад
Congratulation!
@yahyahasan2004
@yahyahasan2004 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith idk are u proud that you are following a man like muhmmad ? i sure wont be if u are then u either an ignorant or have no morals
@phimsish
@phimsish 5 лет назад
Kudos for going at the untouchable Islam 👍
@zapkvr
@zapkvr 5 лет назад
It is not untouchable dummy
@Magrat_Knoblauch
@Magrat_Knoblauch 5 лет назад
@Palomitas Well, this wasn't his first take on Islam. :) But you're right, Muslim debunking videos aren't so common like Christian debunking ones.
@phimsish
@phimsish 5 лет назад
@@Magrat_Knoblauch yeah I saw that after, started watching this channel for the Jordan Peterson debunking vids tbh. I was just glad to see someone going in just as hard on Islam as they do on Christianity, it's nice
@mugoletti9730
@mugoletti9730 5 лет назад
"You're quoting out of context" say the masters of quoting out of context. The subject about the "law of the land" is just one of many examples.
@twinkiesmaster69
@twinkiesmaster69 5 лет назад
I'm not sure who are you talking to?
@mugoletti9730
@mugoletti9730 5 лет назад
@@twinkiesmaster69 - It doesn't matter who I'm talking to. The main point is that the meaning arrived somewhere.
@twinkiesmaster69
@twinkiesmaster69 5 лет назад
@@mugoletti9730 well I should rephrase that "who are you talking about?'
@ibatan2981
@ibatan2981 5 лет назад
Very wrong. It is actually the opposite. There are many good muslims (among the billions) but islam is simply EXTREMELY TERRIBLE. The good muslims are the one who are not practicing islam (or vey little of it)
@TheToffeyman
@TheToffeyman 3 года назад
Your clarity of thought and commitment to delivering accurate information is impressive, great job! As an ex Muslim it angers me to see those so called "muslim feminists" they're aiding the oppression of women who live under Islamic laws who I know for a fact are suffering at this very moment.
@user-kf3is7bt2v
@user-kf3is7bt2v Год назад
You haven’t seen the women who say that they are proud to be Muslim, you just say that because you trust an atheist who hates all religions, if I wanted to learn about Judaism for example, I wouldn’t go to someone who hates it and learn from him.
@TheToffeyman
@TheToffeyman Год назад
@@user-kf3is7bt2v no genius i say that because i witnessed it…
@user-kf3is7bt2v
@user-kf3is7bt2v Год назад
@@TheToffeyman what are they suffering from genius, I have four sisters, And they live a livable life, you haven’t seen the women that defend islam.
@Mysinismikako
@Mysinismikako Год назад
​@@user-kf3is7bt2v even if your sisters are not suffering from any oppression (which we cannot verify) that doesn't mean no one else is suffering. I can tell you for a fact that a lot of women In Islamic societies are being stripped out of their rights in the name of religion.
@user-kf3is7bt2v
@user-kf3is7bt2v Год назад
@@Mysinismikako the actions of these people are not things that Islam approves of, because it is pretty much oppression, but just because some people do these types of things doesn’t mean that their religion is the reason.
@luisfernandollinas6029
@luisfernandollinas6029 5 лет назад
You sir, and all the other atheist spokespeople, are doing the world a much needed service by fighting the good fight. Know that I speak for many when I say that you have our support, keep at it. From Colombia with reason. 🇨🇴
@JohnCena8351
@JohnCena8351 5 лет назад
0:20 I had the laugh of my life. Thank you very much for this.
@metacooler5947
@metacooler5947 5 лет назад
I can see why
@Reactordrone
@Reactordrone 5 лет назад
Listen for the laughter from the audience in the background.
@sarenareth689
@sarenareth689 5 лет назад
Nazism is THE most jew-friendly ideology in the world.
@edwardmagnic8302
@edwardmagnic8302 5 лет назад
Saren Areth 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Stay off drugs
@edwardmagnic8302
@edwardmagnic8302 5 лет назад
John Cena the irony ....the funny thing is that u haven’t done single research on Islam which I find it amusing
@jahimuddin7380
@jahimuddin7380 5 лет назад
She knows she has no facts so she just start raising her voice
@kitemanmusic
@kitemanmusic 5 лет назад
Typical muslim response. Argue over the other person.
@bibigreen6533
@bibigreen6533 5 лет назад
That's pretty much what they always do. That and play the victim.
@ifanmorgan8070
@ifanmorgan8070 4 года назад
1:12 - “I’m not going to attack you personally”. As if this is a favour.
@16048137
@16048137 5 лет назад
As a non muslim, who was raised in a an Islamic country and and a native speaker of Arabic. I don't need anyone to tell me what Islam is. I know Islam very well and understand the Islamic mentality that hates the non muslims and suppress women. My people suffered from racism, violence, and even killing. Churches were attacked and burned. Thank God I have immigrated to Western country, I see muslims here enjoy freedom of religion and worship. What people don't understand that they're multiplying like rabbots, and aim one day to rule the Western countries. I wish my kids won't see what we saw in the future, this is my nightmare. Don't rely on you government as it will do NOTHING, you people need to urgently wake and make an action and protest before it's too late, otherwise and your kids will pay the price!!! ربنا يرحمنا ويرحمكم
@rassulzamel6876
@rassulzamel6876 5 лет назад
Chocklate 06 islam is eating it’s self from inside,,I’m an ex Muslim,,Islam has to be reformed or it will died
@joeschmoe3815
@joeschmoe3815 5 лет назад
@ROBINSONREX1 in secret they have a death-wish, that's why they not only tolerate it but support it.
@TheTariqibnziyad
@TheTariqibnziyad 5 лет назад
Chocklate 06 ex-muslim from an islamic country and we are too multiplying.
@ffhetqmrgtw
@ffhetqmrgtw 5 лет назад
Thank you. Brave and thoughtful people like you give me hope. Not those libertards!
@glados9298
@glados9298 5 лет назад
@@mansur_omar they can also think locally and objectively if you didn't know btw
@GeneticallyModifiedSkeptic
@GeneticallyModifiedSkeptic 5 лет назад
Already one of my favorite RR videos
@RyanColaco
@RyanColaco 5 лет назад
Yasmin's argument was extremely poor. How can you even try and justify something to be good when the facts are in your face showing the opposite?! Good video, as usual. 👏🏾💯
@dianem6951
@dianem6951 5 лет назад
Ryan Colaço They enjoy freedom when they are living in a country that allows them the freedom to speak. I would love to see the women living in literal majority Muslim countries act like this. Then we know that they do have freedom. That’s if they don’t get stoned after being like that.
@johannsalzstreuer5006
@johannsalzstreuer5006 5 лет назад
cognitive dissonance
@engguanzhu3019
@engguanzhu3019 5 лет назад
You can never argue with a dumbass! Remember there was one guy saying islam is the only religion that put a limit to the number of wives you can take,FOUR,with arrogance. He said you guys fucked around when you are limited to one wife but we muslim stayed with four. Hahaha......allah in quran is filthy,so much so when he saw indecently dressed women,not covering their bodies.....to hell ! But he promised those who believe in him that heaven is a sex haven! What a FILTHY god!
@theflyingpotatoes2922
@theflyingpotatoes2922 5 лет назад
Why are they saying this
@gohmike6169
@gohmike6169 3 года назад
As someone from a Muslim Majority country, i can attest to what you say is true. Yasmin is lying
@Usulcardo
@Usulcardo 5 лет назад
"Islam to me is one of the most, if the most feminist religion" That is, like, licherallyyyyy, THE worst sentence I've EVER heard, like I mean, I can't even *uuuuughhhh* .
@matthewto7406
@matthewto7406 5 лет назад
I thought I misheard a few words and replayed the section a few times.
@phileas007
@phileas007 5 лет назад
they both have so very much in common: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CQw3KSYD3ns.html
@MagicMarvin33
@MagicMarvin33 5 лет назад
"We ain't their property" Isn't the definition of a woman in Islam the property of man? HAHA
@aussieginger1960
@aussieginger1960 5 лет назад
similar to Christianity, women got rights in the west despite the churches not because of them.
@jxcess3891
@jxcess3891 5 лет назад
@Rafaela Mora The koooran says women are a man's tilth which actually means women in islame are a man's property. This scumbag yasmine is a fraud.
@irreview
@irreview 5 лет назад
jxcess3891 , no chapter or verse number of the quran you cited. You are the fraud and liae
@irreview
@irreview 5 лет назад
Rafaela Mora no.quotes or citations. Do you just repeat everything you hear from right wing documentaries?
@MagicMarvin33
@MagicMarvin33 5 лет назад
@@irreview Here is a few for you enjoy: Quran 2:282 "...And bring to witness two witnesses from among your men. And if there are not two men [available], then a man and two women from those whom you accept as witnesses - so that if one of the women errs, then the other can remind her...." Sahih al-Bukhari 2658 "The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Isn't the witness of a woman equal to half of that of a man?" The women said, "Yes." He said, "This is because of the deficiency of a woman's mind." This makes it very hard for women to give evidence against being raped and in Pakistan more than half of the women who are raped are instead charged with adultery.(google it) Quran 2:223 “Your wives are a place of sowing of seed for you, so come to your place of cultivation however you wish and put forth [righteousness] for yourselves. And fear Allah and know that you will meet Him. And give good tidings to the believers.” Sunan Abi Dawud 2164 “When the muhajirun (the immigrants) came to Medina, a man married a woman of the Ansar. He began to do the same kind of action with her, but she disliked it, and said to him: We were approached on one side (i.e. lying on the back); do it so, otherwise keep away from me. This matter of theirs spread widely, and it reached the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ). So Allah, the Exalted, sent down the Qur'anic verse: "Your wives are a tilth to you, so come to your tilth however you will," i.e. from in front, from behind or lying on the back. But this verse meant the place of the delivery of the child, i.e. the vagina.” Raping your wife is fine, Mohammed said so. There is other verses calling for your wife to give you sex no matter what she is doing, using the example of cooking but I can't find them right now. There is many more verses that are horrible towards women including beating. I don’t have the time to go through them all. I am guessing you will still find a way to somehow say these are translated wrong (even though from Muslim sources used by Muslims today) or will try and tell me some long winded argument to say its ok. Maybe tell me some bad verses from the Bible? Or continue to you to berry your head in the sand and ignore it?
@TheStoneSpiral
@TheStoneSpiral 5 лет назад
I remember this, I got a co-worker who sided with Yassmn because she's brown. She derided the 'white lady' and I attempted to tell her that Yassmn was lying a great deal and went through a little bit about how she was wrong. This co-worker continues to side with people based on their skin color until she is talked into actually reasoning out what is being said. Facts are hard, I get that, but I refuse to be a racist and only take a persons word because they have a skin color I approve of. It stuns me that people still do something so shallow.
@Lilliathi
@Lilliathi 5 лет назад
Call her a racist, then hit her with facts while she's dazed.
@TheStoneSpiral
@TheStoneSpiral 5 лет назад
@Major T. Poirier Which way, my co-workers way or my way?
@Clone42
@Clone42 5 лет назад
Demographics are destiny. You must be white. Everyone but whites overwhelmingly vote based on skin color. Whites are swing voters, holding onto some meritocratic idealism. You've been successfully brainwashed into not advocating for or advancing the interests of your own race. Everyone else has no issue with it. They hate whitey and that's all that matters. Get ready for demographics and democracy to reshape the face of western civilization. Whites will still be nailing themselves to crosses, begging for forgiveness, while churches are torn down and mosques erected in their place. Enjoy.
@aceofleaf606
@aceofleaf606 5 лет назад
If you lack critical thinking skills, the ability to reason how or why a view is harmful to others, a persons decision will come down to tribalism and making the decision based on what group they closest resemble. Example, when I was homeless, a relatively trendy looking young man followed an older lady where I happened to be and tried to take her bag. I got involved and tried to stop him, the lady screamed and a group of men that just left the pub began mobbing me and the bag thief got away. With little information to work with, the men assumed the homeless man was the thief and assumed the thief was trying to help. I didn't even look that scruffy, but it mattered enough they had no doubt which was the aggressor. Tribalism at work.
@TheStoneSpiral
@TheStoneSpiral 5 лет назад
@@Clone42 I'm pale, but I'm a mutt actually.. so what 'race' of mine do you want me to champion? The Irish in me should hate the English, the Slavic from god knows exactly where since they ran away from just some of the worst shit and their home country no longer exists and they never said what part they're form, I've probably got middle eastern through the Spanish route, oh and his African bride that guy was extremely proud of.. I've got Choctaw, Cherokee and possibly Osage on top of that, god knows what else. Because all that is just the stuff my aunt was able to dig up about us on paper on one side, I got a whole other side that's just.. full of surprises I'm sure. So please, fucking tell me what 'race' I am that someone won't come along and say 'no you're not!'. The more I learn about all the places my genes are from the less I give a shit about your way of doing things. Maybe I'll just spend my time calling out all the racists I meet regardless their skin color. Sounds like a more ethical and less hypocritical use of my time. You're the type of person that is the reason we're not on Mars right now, you just stir shit without adding to the conversation. @Major T. Poirier Well.. I think it shouldn't matter. You say 'white' people do this.. but.. I know that 'white' is just a made up term from a long time ago that tries to make skin color a group that it never was, just the same that 'black' does. We use it to help in conversation but race is a meaningless term. You all can all it whatever you like. I know too much about genetics to see us as anything more different than we see breeds of dogs. They may look different but they're the same species. I'm from so many places I don't have a 'race', I identify as Choctaw, because it's the only thing I have a card to prove I am. And you do know that the whole 'content of ones character' thing was said by a black man first right? The whole idea was to go for that, but hey, tribalism is easier for humans, they're stupid like that. I get it.. so I'm just going to continue to call it out because I'm an egalitarian like that. You say naive, I say woken up to the realities of our species with an insight into our terrible nature with the understanding that education gets us around it. But to rationalize and allow that racism to keep running amok? That's reprehensible... this is why I talk sense into my racist co-worker.. because she's been convinced it's not racist until I show her. @AceOfLeaf Which is why I'm sad our school systems have been teaching less and less critical thinking skills. In a situation like that, you grab both the guys and hold them down, sort it out with the victim. Then take steps. Our mob mentality is a powerful thing, but if you're taught early, it's easy to break out of.
@vedicdisciple2877
@vedicdisciple2877 4 года назад
"Islam gives you rights." Anything that gives you rights can take it away too. Lol.
@theguyver4934
@theguyver4934 3 года назад
Are you buddhist ?
@theguyver4934
@theguyver4934 3 года назад
@Sanjay Mansure - God bless you respect from a muslim
@theguyver4934
@theguyver4934 3 года назад
@Sanjay Mansure - You being Hindu
@theguyver4934
@theguyver4934 3 года назад
@Sanjay Mansure - Because it's an enlightenment
@theguyver4934
@theguyver4934 3 года назад
@Sanjay Mansure - One question I don't mean to be rude but what's so great about the Geeta and I say that with no disrespect but I'm just curious to know
@pamelacode491
@pamelacode491 5 лет назад
"Islam gives women more rights" at about 3:21 ... The phrase "gives women [me] more rights" is for women who wake up in the morning unsure if they inherently deserve any rights (and so rights must be granted by society).
@ivismartinez2542
@ivismartinez2542 5 лет назад
Yes, You re right .She should see pictures of Iranian women and how they used to dress back in the 60's.
@IbrahimMehdiStudios
@IbrahimMehdiStudios 4 года назад
Iran is a shi'a society in a political Cold War with Saudi Arabia. Do not compare them to the true meaning of Islam
@jenster29
@jenster29 4 года назад
@@IbrahimMehdiStudios the true meaning? It seems the true meaning is lost on a lot of practicing Muslims. Until you can all decide what the actual version is, no one else is interested.
@HolyKoolaid
@HolyKoolaid 5 лет назад
If her claim that "Islam is the most feminist religion," is true, but Islam treats women like property, then maybe we should do away with all religion. 😁
@midnytemassacre
@midnytemassacre 5 лет назад
These are two words I thought I'd never hear together...
@jerrygregor
@jerrygregor 5 лет назад
You've never heard of Linda Sarsour then?
@midnytemassacre
@midnytemassacre 5 лет назад
Yeah, I have and she's in America so if you really count her your daft homie.
@jerrygregor
@jerrygregor 5 лет назад
@@midnytemassacre Why get defensive? I'm merely pointing out that she sees herself as a follower of Islam and a feminist. I neither gave an opinion or insulted you.
@midnytemassacre
@midnytemassacre 5 лет назад
@@jerrygregor I'm not. Nor did I insult you unless you stick to the belief she counts. American Feminism isn't even remotely comparable to Muslim Feminism. That whole freedom of religion and freedom of speech are as anti-Muslim nation as it gets. She's using the safety net that is America to promote feminism in a country that has zero use for it anymore.
@jerrygregor
@jerrygregor 5 лет назад
@@midnytemassacre You're like a dog barking at shadows Mykal. Chill out, stop making assumptions about my motive for commenting. You're being silly!
@tonofh
@tonofh 3 года назад
How embarrassing. It just confirms how blindly brainwashed Yasmin is . Shouting people down and lying to make a point . It was everything I thought it would be.
@ZombieProdigyUS
@ZombieProdigyUS 5 лет назад
The Qu'ran literally says women are half a man, and that men are above them.... *THIS IS LIKE CHAPTER FREAKING ONE TOO!!!!!*
@franciscomm7675
@franciscomm7675 5 лет назад
In which chapter?
@danielmia5953
@danielmia5953 5 лет назад
It's Chapter 4 tho
@ZombieProdigyUS
@ZombieProdigyUS 5 лет назад
Chapter one is 1 page long..... Sorry, that doesnt count as a chapter to me. Since youre being picky though, it's chapter two, "A woman is worth one-half a man."......
@danielmia5953
@danielmia5953 5 лет назад
@@ZombieProdigyUS Isn't that from surah 4 al-nisa (the woman)? You can't just ignore al-fatiha because you think is small, it doesn't depend on what you feel it's just what it is. Edit: Found the verse. [Quran 4:11] "Allah chargeth you concerning (the provision for) your children: to the male the equivalent of the portion of two females, and if there be women more than two, then theirs is two-thirds of the inheritance, and if there be one (only) then the half. And to each of his parents a sixth of the inheritance, if he have a son; and if he have no son and his parents are his heirs, then to his mother appertaineth the third; and if he have brethren, then to his mother appertaineth the sixth, after any legacy he may have bequeathed, or debt (hath been paid). Your parents and your children: Ye know not which of them is nearer unto you in usefulness. It is an injunction from Allah. Lo! Allah is Knower, Wise" See the 4 there? Also this is about inheritance not in general, anyway Also found the verse about men being more than women: [Quran 4:34] "Men are in charge of women, because Allah hath made the one of them to excel the other, and because they spend of their property (for the support of women). So good women are the obedient, guarding in secret that which Allah hath guarded. As for those from whom ye fear rebellion, admonish them and banish them to beds apart, and scourge them. Then if they obey you, seek not a way against them. Lo! Allah is ever High, Exalted, Great" This one is in general. Also the last 10-ish "chapters" of the Qur'an (actually called surahs) aren't even half a page long, will you rule them out too?
@ZombieProdigyUS
@ZombieProdigyUS 5 лет назад
@@danielmia5953 I wouldnt rule them out, but it was to dramatize my point. Lookup the quotes from 2:282, directly the quote says, "And get the witness of two witnesses from your men; or if there are not two men, then a man and two women of your choice from among the witnesses, so that if one of them errs the other may remind her." Another one would be 2:228, "And they have rights similar to those over them in kindness, and men are a degree above them." Chapter 4 is a good one for that though as well as you pointed out. In fact, 4:11 nails it perfectly!
@juanhunglow2220
@juanhunglow2220 5 лет назад
Islam is the most feminist religion? Seriously? Muhammad declared women to be the most harmful thing on earth: Is it possible to communicate a lower opinion of women than the one Muhammad expressed in the following hadith? It is related from Usama ibn Zayd that the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, said, "I have not left after me a trial more harmful to men than women." (Sahih Bukhari 7:62:33) This woman is completely deluded.
@MarcoServetto
@MarcoServetto 5 лет назад
well the bible is full of sentences against women too.. she is not comparing religion against secularism, but religion against other religions, and while her statement was about "all religions" I think she meant just "the big 3 monotheistic ones"... that basically all suck in the same ways...
@moeg.3735
@moeg.3735 5 лет назад
But but.. this is only metaphorical... Mohammed didn't mean it like that... You have to read it in Arabic... As a non believer you can never understand... You are blind to the wisdom of Islam because you are not a Muslim... Did I forget something?
@Kalakcha
@Kalakcha 5 лет назад
We can safely assume that the 3 big monotheistic religions are absolutely not feminist
@moeg.3735
@moeg.3735 5 лет назад
@@Kalakcha we don't have to assume that, we know it for a fact and can prove it with their own "holy books".
@ashokjadhav9904
@ashokjadhav9904 5 лет назад
@@Kalakcha But Judaism and Christianity have reformed so much. They have separated the religion from the state. Laws are independent of the religious books. Islam is unable to do that for some reason. Hence nobody mentions the other two religions. But Muslims insist on Sharia law. They have some kind of obsession with it. Nonsense!
@justalittlebitoflove6520
@justalittlebitoflove6520 5 лет назад
dude, you don't need 10 minutes to debunk this take this verse from the Qurab (4:34) Men are the protec-tors and maintainers of women *56because Allah has made one of them excel over the other, *57 and because they spend out of their possessions (to support them). Thus righteous women are obedient and guard the rights of men in their absence under Allah's protection. *58 As for women of whom you fear rebellion, admonish them, and remain apart from them in beds, and beat them. *59 Then if they obey you, do not seek ways to harm them. Allah is Exalted, Great. So feminist
@justalittlebitoflove6520
@justalittlebitoflove6520 5 лет назад
By the way, next time someone tells you "Islam respects women and there is a whole chapter called Women" Then tell them that this verse os from that chapter
@kathryngeeslin9509
@kathryngeeslin9509 5 лет назад
Right! When tribes were mixing and men used to subjugating women clashed with women used to more egalitarian ways the Prophet sided with the women-are-less crowd, not exactly strong evidence of his great love and respect for his first wife (older, wealthy merchant, powerful, can't let that happen again). I am often amazed at the Christians and Muslims who seem to believe their religion actually made women's lives freer or easier or better in any way.
@sylvestory2233
@sylvestory2233 5 лет назад
@@kathryngeeslin9509 _"the Prophet sided with the women-are-less crowd"_ How did the Prophet side with the women-are-less crowd? _"I am often amazed at the Christians and Muslims who seem to believe their religion actually made women's lives freer or easier or better in any way."_ In the case of Islam, it's widely accepted academically that the conditions and rights of women were improved by Muhammad.
@jessefletcher2365
@jessefletcher2365 5 лет назад
@@edwardmagnic8302 Then enlighten us on the research you've done. Otherwise, you just sound like Yassmin in the video, just shrugging off an argument by saying they don't know what they're talking about instead of actually countering their claim. Whether you're right or not, calling people retards on the Internet isn't going to help your case.
@edwardmagnic8302
@edwardmagnic8302 5 лет назад
Jesse Fletcher listen mate ,this guys clearly hates muslins and took an opportunity to hate on Islam plus what the point on debating with some one who is already brainwashed.
@cjalisyas
@cjalisyas 3 года назад
When one person has delusions we call it insanity, but when a lot of people have delusions we call it religion. Adults who believe in imaginary beings are stupid. THE ONLY TRUE GOD IS THE ONE WHO SHOWS HIM SELF TO EVERYONE. NOT FAITH BUT FACTS. Good people do Good things, bad people do bad things, but religion can make good people do bad things.
@empuwm
@empuwm 3 года назад
So if I wrote a book and gave it to you, but I didn’t tell you I wrote it, does that mean nobody wrote it?
@cjalisyas
@cjalisyas 3 года назад
@@ichbineinberliner8431 That's because only 7% is intelligent enough to to say that we don't understand how something happened, without just Saying that vishnu or Allah or fairies did it. And no one is a 100% good or bad but some people are more susceptible to being more of one or the other, but religion can make people blow them self up and kill and harm others.
@cjalisyas
@cjalisyas 3 года назад
@@ichbineinberliner8431 The truth in the bible. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-RB3g6mXLEKk.html
@gamemage4750
@gamemage4750 3 года назад
@@ichbineinberliner8431 fluctuations in a quantum vacuum is the current theory. Morality appears to be an evolutionary trait akin to herd/pack solidarity, as it is ultimately selfish. Moreover, on the grand existential scale, you are applying human logic (which you don’t even understand, law of causality applies to a hypothetical creator as well) to something far greater than us simple animals… why is it so bad for you to say we don’t know yet? We know so little. I’d rather keep searching then give up because some fantasy novel from 2000 years ago attributes it all to a vengeful Mesopotamian god. You do not understand the science, the history, or indeed the unbearable lightness of being human. You don’t even attempt to. Believe what you want, it makes no difference after all.
@ichbineinberliner8431
@ichbineinberliner8431 3 года назад
@@gamemage4750 actually the fluctuation of quantum mechanics does not denounce that it had a beginning so therefore it is still valid and no it does not apply to God as each thing has a cause and since God created said rule he is not included in such nor should he be as he is infinite therefore you do not understand nor want to understand what God is and who he is and I won’t force you to become Christian as you have free will to choose to or not, I strongly suggest it since if I am wrong and there is no God I lose nothing but if you are wrong and there is you lose it all and are stuck in hell for eternity for not wanting to be with God which is to be In hell as hell is eternal separation from God
@davemarx7856
@davemarx7856 5 лет назад
It'd be interesting to see her say this stuff amongst the men of Siria.
@user-ig2wg7gk4x
@user-ig2wg7gk4x 3 года назад
I find religion crazy but out of all the religions islam is the craziest
@ScienceDruid
@ScienceDruid 5 лет назад
"...people talk about Islam without knowing anything about it." I hate this rebuttal. It's so frustrating... Probably why it's used, eh? Also, putting some coherent sentences together would be nice...
@YoungGzBlitz
@YoungGzBlitz 5 лет назад
As someone who is very anti religion and especially islam it's very true
@tanjavankessel2548
@tanjavankessel2548 5 лет назад
Most muslims haven’t read the quran cover to cover, they have just learned to reproduce Arabic verses they mostly don’t understand because the majority doesn’t speak Arabic
@larsgadell5016
@larsgadell5016 5 лет назад
@@tanjavankessel2548 It is funny really how people believe in almighty Gods and that they have sent messages in book form for us to read, and still they do not read those books. If I had faith in a almighty god I would read that book every day! Always confuses me how that thing works.
@Lilliathi
@Lilliathi 5 лет назад
@@larsgadell5016 If Christians had actual faith, they would celebrate death and not be afraid of it. Granted some Muslims actually do this, but not the majority.
@twinkiesmaster69
@twinkiesmaster69 5 лет назад
Well I'm an EX-muslim And I've read the quran : it's shit
@PyroSurge101
@PyroSurge101 3 года назад
She came to speak at my school 😂 what a joke
@chinmayravindrashah
@chinmayravindrashah 5 лет назад
This nonsense is receiving widespread recognition due to the fact that curt and direct brilliant guys like Hitch aren’t there anymore. Harris is a strategy master who’d defeat his illogical opposer gradually by making him realise his follies but Hitch would be so blunt and would not waste a second to show such dumbbells their real place. Thank you for the video! 😊
@reasonablespeculation3893
@reasonablespeculation3893 5 лет назад
No one could cut down a deceiver like Hitchens. there is no longer a Male Intellectual in the Western World, who has the audacity to unflinchingly and unapologetically confront, even those in protected racial/ethnic/religious/gender categories.. The West has been neutered.
@danojc4966
@danojc4966 5 лет назад
I miss Hitch, my dictionary sits idle in the corner.
@GoDieInASearchEngine
@GoDieInASearchEngine 5 лет назад
I haven't seen a lot of Hitchens' debates, but I know he was an advocate for free speech, and that he once said we should amplify even the voices of Holocaust deniers, because we have the right to hear what they have to say. And I don't necessarily agree with that, but it's a fascinating ideal. What I saw in that video was an authority figure talking over and insulting a member of his audience, without responding to a single thing she said to him, knowing everyone else would cheer him on regardless. The woman was wrong, but what he did there wasn't brilliant, it was lazy and cowardly.
@chinmayravindrashah
@chinmayravindrashah 5 лет назад
GoDieInASearchEngine I get your point. It is true that Hitchens’ reply definitely sounds like he is outright dismissive and doesn’t want to acknowledge the lady’s position. However, Hitchens actually has talked about his position on the same thing, at great lengths, on multiple debates, along with evidence of oppressive laws in the Islamic countries. It isn’t that Hitchens has never mentioned anything before and was being assertive here. Assuming that the discussion was already going on with the free speech of women in Islamic countries, I believe that by mentioning Iran, the burden of proof shifts on the lady to prove why Iran is an example representing all the sharia following countries and what example of her qualifies as a refute to Hitchens’ stance, instead of Hitchens’ trying to prove himself. Nevertheless, it wasn’t coward or rude but maybe incomplete. I, myself, am trying to track that debate :)
@GoDieInASearchEngine
@GoDieInASearchEngine 5 лет назад
@@chinmayravindrashah I'm sure Hitchens has talked about his position, and I'll probably agree with it when I hear it. I do think the burden of proof was on her, and he rightfully put her in the position of defending her claim at first. He made the claim that in Iran she wouldn't be allowed in public without a chaperone and a niqab, and he let her respond to that, which she didn't do very well. If he didn't want to continue after that, I think he should have said "I've already talked about this at great length at [event], I encourage you to watch it. I don't want to go into it again right now." Instead, what he did was effectively punish her for disagreeing with him and with the social norm represented in the room. If they had already established that he was right, and if she insisted on standing by her position anyway, then condemning her would be all he could do. He responded as if that were the case. Since everyone in the room did think it was established that he was right, they applauded. There was nothing she could really say in her defence at that point. To be clear, I don't think it was _uniquely_ cowardly. The Left uses social norms to silence people all the time. I'm glad that my country has a diverse, gender-balanced cabinet, but when the Prime Minister (who I voted for) justified that decision by saying "Because it's 2015", he was basically saying "If you don't already agree with my position, you don't deserve to have a conversation about it". It's awful. I'm sure Hitchens' reputation is well-earned, but I maintain that this clip was not a good example of anyone being brilliant no matter what he said elsewhere.
@godisbollocks
@godisbollocks 5 лет назад
I watched that episode of Q&A live when it screened on Australian TV and was gobsmacked by that remark from Abdel-Magied. If there has ever been a more audacious lie uttered on live television, I'm not aware of it.
@zhou_sei
@zhou_sei 4 года назад
@Elizabeth Frantes who actually says that? we all know a.g. barr did it...
@enterthevoidIi
@enterthevoidIi 5 лет назад
Quran says you can beat up your wife if she's misbehaving, they can be imprisoned until they die. (Surah An-Nisa). It literally says men are in charge of women. "(Men are in charge of women by [right of] what Allah has given one over the other and what they spend [for maintenance] from their wealth. So righteous women are devoutly obedient, guarding in [the husband's] absence what Allah would have them guard. But those [wives] from whom you fear arrogance - [first] advise them; [then if they persist], forsake them in bed; and [finally], strike them. But if they obey you [once more], seek no means against them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand.)" They don't have equality when it comes to inheritance of family possession, in court one man is worth two women, it literally says that there are women that men posses, even as slaves. Quran never talks to women, it talks to men and so on. How in the world can anyone claim that Islam is feminist... What she's doing is dangerous and people who actually fall for it are those who don't know Islam well.
@leyawonder2306
@leyawonder2306 5 лет назад
Wow worst translation ever dude, it almost seems like it has nothing to do with what the Qur'an says at all Qur'an says "men are (qawwamon) over women" this doesn't mean they are in charge, it means that men are obligated to provide women with money and a good life while women are not obligated to do the same for men, a man must protect his women wether they are his sisters mother wife or daughters, they are his responsibility, and no Qur'an didn't allow a man to beat his wife, it's cleared up that a hit is a hit with a weak little branch on the hip where it doesn't hurt the wife Yes women get half of what the man gets in inheritance, but that is in the case of them being siblings because the man has to take care if all of his families finance, while the woman doesn't have to pay a penny on anyone. Yes 2 women are required to testify if there was no man, but that's because at the time of the prophet a lot of women couldn't go and testify because they for pregnant or took care of a young child, so he ordered for 2 to witness to stop the problem
@leyawonder2306
@leyawonder2306 5 лет назад
I don't think that you know Islam well, I studied Islam for over 11 years and memorize the Qur'an, I converted to Islam after I was sure I was choosing the right path
@enterthevoidIi
@enterthevoidIi 5 лет назад
Haha are you serious or are you trolling? A weak little hit? That's the worst attempt I've seen so far to justify domestic violence. Also, sorry, but you can't change the Quran the way it suits you, that's a sin and don't even make me start with Hadith. To clarify something, I'm an ex muslim, and I've been a muslim way longer than you, I'm not someone who doesn't know anything about Islam. You are being irrational even though everything is written clearly you simply refuse to believe because you wanna keep your faith or defend Islam. You can do that but not by using reasoning. So try again. Thing is, many things about women come from pressure of Umar, he affected decisions about hijab and treatment of women. That's Islam for you, think of it what you will but this shows it was written by men and it certainly is not feminist.
@enterthevoidIi
@enterthevoidIi 5 лет назад
I wonder how do you interpret the prophet saying to Muslims not to hit their wives the way they hit their slaves. What kind of mental gymnastics do you pull there? Or about that time when Umar and Mohammed took turns slapping their women jokingly. And what do you say about this? As for Ali he said “Women are plentiful, and you can easily change one for another. Ask the slave girl; she will tell you the truth.” So the Apostle called Burayra to ask her and Ali got up and gave her a violent beating, saying, ‘Tell the Apostle the truth.’” Ibn Ishaq: p 496 It was narrated that Ash'ath bin Qais said: "I was a guest (at the home) of 'Umar one night, and in the middle of the night he went and hit his wife, and I separated them. When he went to bed he said to me: 'O Ash'ath, learn from me something that I heard from the Messenger of Allah" A man should not be asked why he beats his wife, and do not go to sleep until you have prayed the Witr."' And I forgot the third thing." Sunan Ibn Majah 3:9:1986
@greasyharold2653
@greasyharold2653 5 лет назад
@@leyawonder2306 Zara, you have been brainwashed. Anybody for a non sequitur? So if one woman witnesses a crime, her testimony is inadmissible, but one man's testimony isn't? Because of pregnancy/childcare? Give me a break, talk about mental gymnastics.
@moinada4266
@moinada4266 3 года назад
I'm a Saudi myself and everything you said is true, someone had to expose her lies. thank u
@carreviewer6345
@carreviewer6345 Год назад
U an atheist? If so keep it to yourself it's suicide to be an open atheist in Saudi Arabia
@Niceonthefrenchriviera
@Niceonthefrenchriviera 5 лет назад
BUT YOU HAVE TO WATCH THIS VIDEO IN ARABIC :)
@Magrat_Knoblauch
@Magrat_Knoblauch 5 лет назад
I see what you did here. ^^
@77naaz
@77naaz 5 лет назад
Lol
@j_forfreedom45
@j_forfreedom45 5 лет назад
well put!!! nice one. hahahahaha
@Moroccanbrazilian
@Moroccanbrazilian 5 лет назад
@Don Corleone Exactly
@leyawonder2306
@leyawonder2306 5 лет назад
It's kind of stupid to judge the book upon direct translation because you know arabic is kind of about 13,000,000 words and English is 600,000 so I'd say yes we need many scholars to translate the text to silver in correctly
@michaelgum97
@michaelgum97 5 лет назад
Can she even provide evidence instead of shouting and screaming like a madwoman?
@Asterion608
@Asterion608 5 лет назад
Funny isn't? That smug apologist with the Hipster glasses does nothing but accuse everyone of what she is guilty, Talking without having any idea or evidence or what is talking about.
@thegirlinquestion
@thegirlinquestion 5 лет назад
literally all muslims go on like that. search up LBC muslim. they just shriek and get hysterical
@radar2116
@radar2116 5 лет назад
I miss Hitchens so much, you give this great man immortality. For this, you have my respect and admiration.
@leaaba2965
@leaaba2965 3 года назад
I feel a great relief when i watch these channels after a year of leaving iran i always felt that no one was hearing us , that they hear the mercs sent over by our governments for propoganda ...
@stuartthomas3994
@stuartthomas3994 5 лет назад
It’s Yasmin that had no idea about Islam . Doesn’t know what she’s talking about.
@britishpatriot7386
@britishpatriot7386 5 лет назад
@Rafaela Mora you mean feminists are the low IQ and the Left etc .
@rockysandman5489
@rockysandman5489 5 лет назад
@@britishpatriot7386 The right tend to be low IQ too, in the US...
@paulcarey1708
@paulcarey1708 5 лет назад
Maybe she does, maybe she doesn't. But Rationality Rules has exposed her as nothing more than a corrupt huckster, cherry-picking her "facts". She should consider selling used cars - she'd be good at it.
@Competitive_Antagonist
@Competitive_Antagonist 5 лет назад
She's quite hot though.
@CrunchyNorbert
@CrunchyNorbert 5 лет назад
she knows. She knows full well what she is about
@kaiserrino8774
@kaiserrino8774 5 лет назад
Probably one of the biggest oxymoron's I have ever heard in my life. She should go to Saudi Arabia and claim that lol.
@ninototo1
@ninototo1 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith Damn how did that happen to you?
@nicknyk7174
@nicknyk7174 5 лет назад
@@ninototo1 He will say anything just to be able to own many wives.
@ninototo1
@ninototo1 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith what reasons ?
@nicknyk7174
@nicknyk7174 5 лет назад
@Zack Smith I am so sorry that you're still single; even in a religion where a woman's opinion doesn't matter. But this does not change the fact, from my previous statement, that you could still own many wives. So that wasn't a lie. Although I can see how that fact could've flown right over your head since your intelligence would barely register on any test.
@breadbaconcheese
@breadbaconcheese 5 лет назад
@@nicknyk7174 savage bro
@ReasononFaith
@ReasononFaith 5 лет назад
Please correct a reference you have at 5:24 in the video. That commandment is found in a second grade Hadith; it is NOT from the Qur’an. And that is a huge difference. For context: I am an ex-Muslim and enjoy and share much of your work.
@barrythomson899
@barrythomson899 Год назад
Still so relevant. Iran 2022/2023 just one example of a female friendly Islamic country.
@reyrey.ak-47
@reyrey.ak-47 5 лет назад
Remember kids science took u to the moon and religion drove u into a building
@franciscomm7675
@franciscomm7675 5 лет назад
@Blondes in Black cars watch the videos of islam made by crash course
@franciscomm7675
@franciscomm7675 5 лет назад
@ROBINSONREX1 the fault is from the governents, not the religion. For example, the bibi affair in pakistan wouldn't be happening if not for a bunch of laws passed by a dictator in 70s and 80s.
@franciscomm7675
@franciscomm7675 5 лет назад
@ROBINSONREX1 when the european powers occupied the middle east after wwi, local populations began to associate islam with nationalism and became distrustful of western values. But its the supreme leader of iran and the saudi royal who oppose reforms the most. Watch the vox vídeo "what i learned from befriending iranians on Facebook, to get a glimpse that are many muslims who want reform.
@franciscomm7675
@franciscomm7675 5 лет назад
@ROBINSONREX1 okay fine. Just remember: don't discriminate the muslims just because some of the them did harm to you
@j_forfreedom45
@j_forfreedom45 5 лет назад
I taught it was in a crowd.. not a building??!!
@stevegrydzyn6038
@stevegrydzyn6038 5 лет назад
Look up the term "taquiya". It explains everything.
@danielled8779
@danielled8779 4 года назад
Check out Drew’s (aka Genetically Modified Skeptic) video on takkiya
@punkisinthedetails1470
@punkisinthedetails1470 4 года назад
wow wvwn how they get ships in tiny bottles that's incredible
@andreasballer369
@andreasballer369 4 года назад
It is actually a myth, no such thing in Islam, there are a lot of faults in the religion, u don't need to create them
@thevideochannel4155
@thevideochannel4155 4 года назад
When Quran itself a Taqqiya.
@sunset2.00
@sunset2.00 4 года назад
taqiyya is only halal when a nazi says are you muslim say yes i will kill or no the you go free.A muslim should say no for life.not here but lol these guys think they are nazi like so they are misunderstanding.
@1voluntaryist
@1voluntaryist 5 лет назад
These shouting matches disgust me. That moderator was overwhelmed. The bottom line: Some people (dishonestly) want to own a religion while denying some parts.
@ront2424
@ront2424 5 лет назад
Tony Jones was not overwhelmed he just let it go because it was good tv.
@gatyielwal8704
@gatyielwal8704 Год назад
I hope the woman who claimed that she can not cover her hair is witnessing the protest around the detention and subsequent killing of mahsa by the morality police triggering a nation wide protest.
@pjaworek6793
@pjaworek6793 Год назад
RIP Mahsa
Далее
No, You Can’t Be A Feminist Muslim
13:14
Просмотров 150 тыс.
Atheists Are Murderers - Debunked (Jordan Peterson)
12:38
Here's Why I'm NOT a Libertarian
10:56
Просмотров 382 тыс.
Awful Things We Believed at My Evangelical University
15:16
LGBQT GIRL SAYS HOMOSEXUALITY ISN'T HARAM
15:39
Просмотров 456 тыс.
Muslims DEBUNK Christianity... and Islam
12:43
Просмотров 110 тыс.
Talk: Peter Halstead on the Death of Shelley
5:47
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.
Candace Owens is more IGNORANT than we EVER IMAGINED!
16:23