Israel's War Cabinet Collapses: What Next? 

Netanyahu acting as if asking for some kind of end game is treason when it's never a good sign for any military operation not to have one.

“An evil man will destroy his own country in order to rule over the ashes” -Sun Tzu Netanyahu is really gunning for that title, huh?

Netanjahu belongs in prison. Even before the whole palestine conflict. He is the personification of whats wrong with politicians nowadays

Replacing Gazans with Jewish immigrants is a weird way to describe unequivocal ethnic cleansing/ genocide.

No surprise that Gantz left after Benjamin refused to end the war and create a compethensive after war plan. After all Benjamin wants to drag on the war as long as possible.

I'm sorry but Gantz and Gallant look so much alike I get them confused constantly

Just as expected, Netanyahu will just continue to prolong this war as majority of Israeli supports war even if it's meant to fight Hezbollah.

For those questioning the ICC prosecutor’s decision to apply for arrest warrants against both Hamas leaders & Netanyahu When judging whether someone has breached international human rights obligations The standard is NOT the other side The standard is the LAW

Can’t say the plan because it will be condemned. Better to just make it happen before people realize what it is.

Colour me shocked the Israeli population don’t believe they’ve gone too far

Small correction: Shas and UTJ have been in coalitions for years. They're much more sectarian "take care of our constituencies" parties than "try to push a nationalist agenda" parties. There was a time, around a decade ago, when the center parties were okay to be in the same coalition as Shas and UTJ but that hasn't been the case since.

Fun Fact:A few days before october 7th,Almost all the troops located near the gaza border were relocated to the west bank.And also egypt warned israel a year-Before hand that hamas would inevitabily attack.Had israel taken warnings seriously,Oct 7th would have never happened.

O great my favourite show is on - me trying to understand wtf is going on with Israel politics

Talking about ethnic cleansing so openly is really disgusting

Well explained ! Good job Tldr keep up the work

Netanjahu should take a trip to Den Haag

To clarify, as of the writing company of this comment, the ICC Prosecutor is REQUESTING arrest warrants, it has not ISSUED warrants.

I am pretty sure Israeli will use netanyahu as scapegoat to avoid all the thing they did in Gaza

Israel has nothing to loose, as their costs are all covered by another country.

They should be called the War Crimes cabinet.

Damn, never clicked on a video so quickly.

3:28 It still didn't issue the warrant though? The prosecutor requested it. There was no ruling. I don't know how such a mistake could slip on this channel.

“Resettled” that’s the most BS word for genocide I’ve ever heard

It's "hostages" when Hamas does it. It's "prisoners" when Israel does it. They're not trading people who were charged and found guilty of crimes. Those "prisoners" are Palestinians Israel forcibly detained without cause and without charging them with any crimes.

The silence when questioned about a day after is deafening. It's like interviewing a man outside a bank with a ski mask and a duffle bag and him not replying when asked what are his intentions. The smart thing would be to intervene earlier rather than later.

Small correction: at 3:12 he talked about the "path of zealots", not the "path of fanatics." The message is still the same, this is just a minor thing.

The arrest warrant by ICC was never issued. Not yet at least

An advice: Polls count only if you pay money in Middl East, dont put too much trust on them

Very helpful and well-contextualised thank you. I think I will be supporting your print paper. Please try to use sustainable materials!

Gantz is making a play for the top job. Just another day in Israeli politics.

What would I do without TLDR, keeping me updated on things quicker than the news channels

God bless BiBi , Am Yisroel Chai from Walvis Bay , Namibia

This is what happens when you make a jailbird a head of state. Oops.

0:01 He is not the leader of the opposition. Yair Lapid is.

He wasn’t “forced into it” he chose to

Defund Israel!

Can nethanyahu get arrested?

One thing to remember: “Carthago Delende Est” did eventually become reality. Even if it’s in the name of self-defense, the consequences will certainly remain catastrophic.

No one asks what incited the Oct 7 Hamas attack. In the preceding weeks, Gvir was inciting Israeli "settler" violence against Palestinians and did a photo-op show of force by trespassing at the Al-Aqsa mosque (July 2023) and declaring it part of Israel. This was the final straw that lit the fuse. Netanyahu still enables Gvir's behavior, they are both to blame along with the rest of the warmongers in the cabinet.

Netanyahu must be tried 😢

The reason the war is still going on is because when the war ends netanyahu will lose power since he was already quite unpopular before the war

He’s not solving the issue he just made it worse by war with another

“And have ultimately advocated for Gaza to be resettled ie for the Palestinians to be replaced by Jewish immigrants” This is ENTIRELY too soft of a to describe what is literally the textbook definition of ethnic cleansing. Stop trying to be so overly-formal and just call a spade a spade. You’re not the White House press secretary you can call it genocide when it’s obviously genocide.

One thing I'll say- to me it is clear the Israeli public is tired with its current options. The ground is ripe for a new political player to rise, especially out of the anti-Bibi center right

"The majority of the Israeli public, who don't like the far right". What are you talking about? The majority of the Israeli public IS far right! Otherwise, how the hell would this government have got to power in the first place?

Isreal Netanyahu needs to step down immediately for his crimes, also if that imar Ben gavir .joins the war cab Gaza is domed.

Major mistakes in the video: - 3:30 ICC didn't issue an arrest warrant for Netanyahu, but an application for an arrest warrant. As said in the article you showed. Huge difference. It's like saying someone is guilty because they went to court. - 4:56 Biden didn't say that there is every reason to think that Netanyahu is prolonging the war far his own political self-preservation, BUT that “there is every reason for people to draw that conclusion” and NOT that he thinks that. As said in the quote you showed. Huge difference. - 4:30 The only relevant statement Netanyahu made about the deal is that he won't agree to a deal which doesn't provide political and military collapse of Hamas. Being hesitant to the current form of the deal gives zero information about not agreeing to it after changes agreed upon in negotiation. Israel made zero statements pointing to the fact that they are not willing to negotiate about the deal. Hamas made a claim that the deal is different from presented by Biden (which can't be verified to be true or not). It's not accurate to say that the deal is collapsed, considering that Qatar and Egypt said that they'll try to pressure Hamas into negotiating. - 5:38 That sounds like you are saying that Gvir advocated for compulsory resettlement, and that it's an official statement, but in reality and in the article you showed, it only mentioned the promotion of voluntary emigration (repeated several times!) and it's clearly presented as a private opinion. I'm sorry, but there is just too much poor reporting in your videos overall, and I'll have to block your channels, because I don't like to be misinformed, intentionally or not.

talk about the haredim military draft bill

I have been more or less on israels side since the start of the war. If Netanyahu gets one more term, I cant do so anymore. And this is true of a lot of people I know.

"A duplicitous American shill" -Our greatest ally

Crazy world we live in

I can only think of a quote from men in black: “a human is smart, people are stupid.”

Gantz isnt the Israeli opposition leader its Yair Lapid. and the Israeli war cabinet also included Gadi Eisenkot, a member of Gantzes party

4:59 Never thougth that I'd see biden spittin' facts.

1:25 bibi has sat in coalition many times with the haredi parties (Shas and Yahadut Hatora)

Breaking news: The new war cabinet will be staffed by politicians from the UK and USA. They were already participating actively, it will now become official.

Makes no difference to the government

4:00 if many of those "prisoners" are children under 10, people who where never trialed in court. So why are they call prisoners and not Hostages ?

It is too late for Israel.

American proposal was to just stop any further proceedings from ICJ. Israel has not agreed to any deal. Hamas is a elected government. Israel has committed acts similar to oct7 many times before. No destroyed Israeli governments in response, matter for fact there were z3ro consequences for Israel in every single instance.

Ganz is not the head of the opposition, he is barely an opposition at all, if he even exist

In my opinion this war is bad and should be ended immediately.

Gantz is not the leader of the opposition, but Yair Lapid!!!

The status in Israel is very depressing for those in the left side of politics. And unlike before theres no where to leave to as antisemitism makes living anywhere else unwelcoming as well..

You said at 4:00 "the exchange of some hostages for Palestinian prisoners". The term "prisoners" referring to Palestinians in Israeli prisons is incorrect. Those are Palestinians, in some cases children, held captive by a foreign state, often without a trial. The legal definition to their status is at worst "Hostages: held to compel a third party to act or refrain from acting in a certain way" and at best "Political Prisoners: Individuals imprisoned because of their political beliefs or activities." Most of those people are either never standing a trial (look at Bassem Tamimi as an example who was released today) OR stand trial in military court with conviction rate above 95%.

Dude is saving his behind before it's too late 😅

Gallant didn't threaten to quit

War is a quagmire without a get out plan.

Are Gantz and Gallant clones of each other?

I still think he let the oct 7th attack happen to save himself.

Why is it called israeli hostages but palestinian prisoners? Neither had a trail.

They deeply invested in Labour party in UK suggesting what the future development will look like.

5:45 The opinion that the majority of the Israeli public does not like the far right is disingeniuos since both the far right and the majority of the public have similiar if not identical opinions and advocate for the same things

They are fighting themselves more than Hamas

7:06 So basically they want more war.

This could only mean that the war could morph into a regional conflict. Gantz was right the only way to have some sort of stability is to have Gaza as a part of American, European, Muslim world joint administration. Netanyahu reject this and instead making Israel isolated on the world stage.

Pick up a new cabinet at IKEA ❤

Nice

Israel feels like a state free falling into political isolation, if not downright open authoritarianism. And the resettlement of Gaza and the invasion of South Lebanon would be nothing but the end. The fact that the majority of Israelis support it is baffling. At least when the US invaded Iraq the war was a world away from Americans, not next door... It feels as if Netanyahu wants Israel to become the next North Korea.

I am an Israeli who understands politics, and this video contains so much nonsense and lies. They continue to say that Netanyahu will not sit with the other right-wing parties until 2022 because they are "extremists," but this is a complete lie, Netanyahu sat with these parties in the coalition for almost his entire term as prime minister. What has changed is that one small right-wing party refused to sit with Netanyahu (Lieberman) because of a personal dispute, which prevented him from achieving a majority for the coalition until 2022. Left-wing parties have never sat down with Netanyahu except for one party in 2012. If this channel is a serious channel, it needs to do basic research.

Netanyahu doesn’t have a plan for Gaza after, because he has no intention of there being a Gaza, after.

4:19 why did gantz drop his ceasefire proposal for biden's?

Ethnostates just go crazy, huh?

Excellent video as always

5:34 This is the textbook definition of ethnic cleansing

Both sides committed big mistakes. Hamas attacked a festival that was hosted by various organizations that wanted peace and inclusivity between both sides since 2001. In that attack alone a big chunk of groups that would have protested later to deescalate the conflict was push out. Also the foregein victims and hostages situation eliminated some international pressure on Israel and gave them temporary freedom to later bomb Gaza. In the case of Israel, Netanjahu's approach to prefere area bombing instead of the used of more precise weapons eventually burned a lot of the international sympathy they have, although it looks like domestic support is still strong, which is the only thing he's interested in.

What does tldr mean by far right regarding Israeli politics?

What is the difference between hostages and Palestinian prisoners. Wouldn’t they both be prisoners or both be hostages? And if you think there is a difference, why?

Why didn't you talk about the return of the four abductees that happened before Gantz retired?

Land clearance for the Jared Kushner beach front condos.

What would be the ideal ceasefire plan for the gaza war in this case then.

How are these things related as host was trying to show. If you dont have rekation dont even try. 4 % thought war has gone too extreme and 62 % think we should have full scale war against Hezbollah...

Can nobody appreciate that Ben Gantz saying "If you choose the national over personal... You will find in us a partner." is the dictionary definition of fascism?

I am again amazed by the accuracy and depth of your videos! Just one point regarding the last remark: It's not that Israelis "want a war with Hizbullah". There IS in fact a war. Since the Gaza war began, Hizbullah has been regularly firing rockets and UAV's into northern Israel. It doesn't use its full capabilities and targets relatively short range. Still, over 100,000 Israelis are evacuated from their homes for 8 months with no sign of when they will be able to return. Some towns have many houses burned down. So, regardless of one's views on Gaza, there is growing frustration and anger about the indifference of the government regarding the fate of the residents of the north. Both Israel and Hizbullah have reasons to avoid a large-scale war (for Israel obviously they include the high price of a multi-front war). But people would like to see a solution for their condition. They feel abandoned by the government, like many if not most of Israelis do.

Collapsing like a house of cards built on quicksand

Most nations don't go to war as much as Israel even if they want to because of the economical cost of wars Israel is the exception because they don't pay for their wars

its time for early elections in israel, now international humanitarian law actually is endangered

naziyahu needs to be locked up

Why did this make me laugh 😂😂😂

What's next: maybe join the ICC and then ICJ as a defendant?