No! Israel isn't retaliating. The State of Israel was established on Palestinian land by removing the native Palestinians from their homes and lands during the colonial era. How can invaders be defenders in the first place? Zionists claim that it is their right to establish a Jewish state around Jerusalem because this place was once Jewish. But wait a minute! Since when does religion start to determine where you belong? Only Palestinian Jews have the right to live there. The Jews of Israel are Europeans and Americans. They should go back to places from where they came. The Palestinians are indigenous to that land. Their ancestors were Jews; they converted to Christianity during the time of Jesus, and now they are Muslims. Everyone knows that Indonesia was once a Buddhist country. How right would it be for Buddhists from Thailand, Cambodia, and Sri Lanka to invade Indonesia and remove the native Muslim Indonesians from their lands and homes, citing the fact that Indonesia was once a Buddhist nation?
@@harmangrewal7824 it is easy to say this. You cannot understand how brutal this bloodshed is. People are getting tortured and killed, without any reason and you just say life isnt meant to be fair. Like that means in everyones life should have a deep point but this is below deep, their whole life is fcked up
Feeling sad and angry is not going prevent the children dying or help solve the problem. The difference between Israel and Hamas is Israeli government protects women and children the best way it can. Whereas Hamas uses Palestenian women and children as human shield and as fodder for social media. Israel is not like the Woke Europeans leaders who wants to build their career and look good on TV at the expense of their country and their culture.
As an Indian, I stand neither with Israeli government not the Palestinian government. I stand with the people who're living and dying in the war. I don't care who does the central government support. It's my choice.
The issue is not just about who's right or wrong, but also about the innocent lives affected by this war. Remember A Syrian Boy Said, “I Will Tell God Everything Before Dying” in 2015
I HOPE HE TELLS HOW NO MUSLIM CARED ABOUT GOD’s ISREALI CHILDREN & WONEN WHO FORCED BY HAMAS TO PARADE NAKED . ALSO WHY NO MUSLIM COUNTRY IS ASKING THE HAMAS TO RETURM 250 HOSTAGES SAFELY BACK TO ISRAEL ? GOD WILL ASK THAT BECAUSE WE ARE ALL CHILDREN OF GOD ! 📍WHY HAVE HAMAS TURNED THEIR SOLDIERS INTO DRUG ADDICTS TO NAKE THEM NOT FEEL SAD KILLING ISRAELI CHILDREN , WOMEN & ELDERLY WHY ? EVERY BODY SUFFERS…….
U mean,,, only muslims r innocent!!! Jewish people r not innocent???? Thousands of jewish people died in Israel due to war!!! Why Palestine attacked Israel after the day they got independence????? Its, Tit for tat..
What about innocent lives in iraq iran war ( millions dead) syria( millions dead) sudan( half a million dead & counting ) yemen ( half a million dead) What about kurds been killed ? Why you were silent then and vocal now when the death toll is just in thousands ?
This is not a conflict between two parties to a conflict, this is a conflict between unarmed civilians in Gaza and an Army supported by the largest military force in the world and for what! For the land of the King of the Palestinians since ancient times and review history and documents
@@nahlahossam6679 this is also israel land in ancient times, everybody tell they’re own story, the truth, they are both wrong, israel didn’t belong to anyone in ancient times, the story is that palestine had an agreement with the brits, that the brits give palestine the country, but israeli people started to come, the palestinians accepted them, but the rule was that the palestinians control the country, because it’s their country, butisrael wanted to live with each other, and the place they got wasn’t enough for everybody to come, israel were dreaming about a place for themselves, so they asked for a little part, the united nations accepted, but the palestinians didn’t, palestinians chose to risk their land, just for israel to not have a piece, because the reason palestinians let israeli people in, it’s because they felt pity for them, but they didn’t like them, so the war started, the winner will take full control of the land, after years of fighting the small but strong fighters in israel won, and banished the palestinians to gaza, and that is how israel became a country
@@Uripinkas Telling the story as if it was a fun story but the reality is not like that The reality is that the plan of the Jews from the beginning is not Palestine but to find just a homeland that can be expanded which was not the most appropriate in Palestine under the British mandate The Palestinians would not have said no in the face of the British occupation
@@Uripinkas Palestinian land was usurped and the property of others was taken unjustly and Jerusalem was recognized as the capital of Israel even though it is a right for Muslims and Christians as well and the idea of resistance was born in light of continuous rape by the Occupier and global silence
This is the best explanation and history lesson thus far that I have seen and heard. The main focus is to STOP the war. No matter who is right or wrong...killing innocent civilians is NEVER right.
Two-state solution or a one-state solution with a little twist known as "federation". Kinda like Bosnia and Herzegovina. And if you start to say that the second solution is BS, let's just say that Bosnia hasn't collapsed and Serbia clearly doesn't want Republika Srpska. They consider it the territory of a foreign state.
@@jackiechan6460 Hamas should've thought. The legitimate Palestinian government didn't attack Israel. Also you should've thought before typing such bullshit on your keyboard.
@@jackiechan6460 Lots of ignorant blockheads like you whp haven't even read a single news article about the situation or let alone watched the video you're commenting on.
@@EliasKlemedsson she literally just explained the history and the latest war, you can read about the arab wars or what it was in a textbook even, seems like you need tuning.
@NovieFox She wasn't that biased but she has missed a lot of detail. Such as zionist Jews that funded hitler so that hitler actions can justify a land kn palestine. British didn't lose control of palestine they gave it to the jews. Balfour treaty stated this in 1917, that shoes all of this was planned by British and zionists.
This is a utter propaganda by Hamas they are the people who don't hasitate to kill anyone to fulfill their agenda, and not the Jews they are totally peaceful people who are friendly with everyone and they'll never ever become a terrorist and it's the Muslim mindset that creates the terrorism
Thank you for this video, you made the conflicts clear: other videos have not described the conflict as well as you did. This is definitely a very complicated war, and I honestly hope this will get resolved soon
I came here because a classmate in my school ripped down the isreal flag and i said i felt it was wrong due to it being disrespectful to possible isreal students. I was told my a classmate to educate myself before i say anything.
You have no business in America. Get out of my country. If you get upset when I rip your flag in two then get out of my country. USA FIRST! You should only be upset when the American flag is disrespected. GOD BLESS AMERICA
Isreal stole the land from the Palestinians 💯. They are evil people. I have not finished this video but if she says anything different, she lying, manipulating. Go back to the 1900s, and BTW, jew is not a culture, 😂 😂 😂 it's a religion. Don't let them fool you, the land belongs to the Palestinians
Need some info ? Nothing started in oct 7 2023 it all started at 1948 and several years before when Israel occupied Palestine and force them to leave their homes cities or even the whole country, so some moved to Lebanon, Jordan, syria, or Egypt, and some decided to stay in Palestine but not anywhere, they have 3 options: to move to gaza, west bank or stay where they are but forced to have an Israeli passport. Anyway what is happening these days that Israel have killed about 40,000 civilians with 50% of them are kids, israel is cutting off electricity, food water and evey single source from gaza, and they even controlling the aids than could enter. Today israel bombed a refugee camp which they told the civilians to move there 4 days before , which lead to killing of 35 civilians including kids and injured much more . Rn there is only one hospital that is active in gaza for 2.2 million people, all the other hospitals are even not active because of the electricity turned off or because israel bombed it
the problem with the video is, she said, islam invaded india but Islam is a religion. Some Muslims are the ones who conquered India. However, Muslims existed before India's conquest. Islam is a belief system that the populace has accepted; aside from their respective religions, Muslims are the same people as other Hindus. However, it is absurd to draw comparisons between the situations in India Pakistan, and Israel. Jews existed before the colonial state was established, but they were not Zionists; The foreigners who were forced to reside there were known as Zionists. The foreigners who used force and weapons to settle there were known as Zionists., as opposed to the same Indians who converted to Islam after coming into touch with Muslims and the Islamic concept. When Jews come into power, they stab the Muslims who have been helpful to them. Previously, After being persecuted by Christians, Jews were the ones who sought refuge from Muslims to settle in their country. That's a long story, nonetheless. Given that Hamas is a terrorist group, IDF is likewise a terrorist organization since they utilize violence and murder to take Palestinian land and homes. This is the issue-you folks don't realize it and start on October 7th. There wouldn't be an organization like Hamas if the colonial state hadn't been established in Arab soil. For the love of God, consider yourself in Hamas' shoes before passing judgment. Reply
@@mujibultanim if there existed no Hamas, the Palestinian govt. Created by UN wouldn't use underhanded tactics. This wouldn't 've happened. Btw Hamas started the " killing innocent people" first
@@lolkail5800 are you that deaf and blind that you didn't see what idf was doing to Palestinan people and their belongings. why are you starting it from October 7th, what Hamas did it was happening with the Palestinan people after the creation of the colonial Cancer in the middle east. Hamas was a by product to idf's treatment of Palestinan people. Even more that, once Hamas was supported by IDF to control the opposition party, if you don't know that research it.
@@I_RahulPawarone day when China and Pakistan attack India and invaded... We will support pak and China... That times you will know the pain of true victim..... India are washing Israelis butt's because of their technology... Don't you felt ashamed you bull Savage indian...... Remember what white people all describe Indian as cow and they said... Dog and indian are not allowed... But Indian like you don't have dignity still supporting white people like America.. British and israel.... Shamed on you.... Whole world are supporting GAZA but only Savage indian like you are supporting Israel evil people who stealing other people land and killed millions of innocent people
Let's say if your living in your house and suddenly stranger came and took the control of your house and your trying to defend it and people from out side start to calling you as a killer/terrorist are you going to accept that your a killer/terrorist (EVERYTHING IS FUNNY UNTIL THE SAME BAD THING IS HAPPEN TO YOU!)
With that logic, every Muslim people should be removed from India because they came here hundreds of years ago and captured India. Also in America, immigrants should leave too cuz they aren't from America. Your example is just dumb
the problem with the video is, she said, islam invaded india but Islam is a religion. Some Muslims are the ones who conquered India. However, Muslims existed before India's conquest. Islam is a belief system that the populace has accepted; aside from their respective religions, Muslims are the same people as other Hindus. However, it is absurd to draw comparisons between the situations in India Pakistan, and Israel. Jews existed before the colonial state was established, but they were not Zionists; The foreigners who were forced to reside there were known as Zionists. The foreigners who used force and weapons to settle there were known as Zionists., as opposed to the same Indians who converted to Islam after coming into touch with Muslims and the Islamic concept. When Jews come into power, they stab the Muslims who have been helpful to them. Previously, After being persecuted by Christians, Jews were the ones who sought refuge from Muslims to settle in their country. That's a long story, nonetheless. Given that Hamas is a terrorist group, IDF is likewise a terrorist organization since they utilize violence and murder to take Palestinian land and homes. This is the issue-you folks don't realize it and start on October 7th. There wouldn't be an organization like Hamas if the colonial state hadn't been established in Arab soil. For the love of God, consider yourself in Hamas' shoes before passing judgment.
but yet , it has so many incorrect or unprecise information , egypt and jordan didnt "occupy" any land of palestine , they only had the control over it , because the palestinian gov wasnt initiated yet - because even the arab countries were under the ottman empire control - and even though the jews defeated arabs on the 1948 war , they were not alone , they were supported by america and the UK and so many to mention , and i just want to make sure you are standing and supporting the right side of history , does being subjected to genocide gives u the permission and the ability to displace people from their land , commit literal war crimes and genocide and wipe them off of the map ? no . free Palestine .
Actually in 11th class ncert history there is mentioned of Palestine but no israel or they were killed and there history even our book trying to hide israel history but showing Palestine only offcourse as the educational minister was muslim ans showed only mughalz so I am not surprised to see why they hide israel history
@@mujibultanimeasy to paint this as Israel being the problem when you cherry pick the information. You talk about colonialism and how that’s the cause of this issue so I’ll play along. Problem is according to your theory it proves Israel is right in this situation. The only reason why the Jews weren’t the majority population in Israel is because when the Ottoman Empire conquered the Holy Land the Arab Muslims who became Palestinians essentially expelled the Jews from the Holy land when they took over. Sounds like what your claiming the Jews are trying to do now, so why was it ok for the Jews to be conquered and expelled but when they try to come back they are seen as colonizers trying to take land from the indigenous people. GTFOH
As a human being i want peace. Every person in this world has the right to live a happy peaceful life . As an Indian let's pray for peace on both sides.
thats exactly what im saying alot of people hate other people now for them living in israel/palestine but they dont understand that in both countries there is alot of innocent people
@@montadermajed9456 I hate Hamas. Nothing justifies terrorism. However, even though it's completely understandable as to why Jewish people would want to form their own nation, why did it have to be Jerusalem? Why pick a location where people already live there? That area was obviously selected based purely on religious reasons only. Look at the amount of suffering based on a god that clearly doesn't exist and even if it did, it clearly doesn't give a fuck.
@@partapsingh2282 Who started destroying whom again? there is no peace since the land was given to the zionist, and why is this is just simply because they dont even stick to the border agreed.
Thank you for making such a complicated situation easier to understand. I have been avoiding learning about it because it was so complicated, confusing and overwhelming, but after your video I feel like I understand it a tiny bit.
Damn the power of the media can do that Everything is fake It is truly unfortunate that there are those who believe these lies The Israelis stole all those countries and killed their people and children. They were expelled not because of their religion, but because they are criminals. They are criminals because of their strange rituals. Western news channels are headed by Israeli businessmen. The economy of America and France today is based on Israeli businessmen, so we see all this exhausting falsification against the Palestinians. I did not know that the world was so unjust. Israel declared many contradictions, and yet it became the owner of the truth. The Israeli Prime Minister said on Twitter that he bombed the hospital and minutes later wiped it out and said it was the work of Hamas. It's funny, what a contradiction!! The pictures are still there but they are literally being deleted. Every article on the Internet that supports Palestine will be deleted! Every supportive RU-vid video is also deleted and the channel owner gets a strike!! They are so afraid of revealing the truth to the world!!! What a shame really. The Israeli Prime Minister described Palestinian civilians as animals. What an urban act. This is so painful that people still believe in Israel 💔
Yes, they were driven out of the land because of what was done to Jesus. This fight is about the control of the land. A quick history lesson in less than 2 mins, ‘TikToker sings for Palestine’ on youtube
In simple terms Hammas was created because of what israel had been doing to palestine for ages Only when they realized that israel isn’t stopping They took action and did that attack on October Because even before that event Israel had killed a lot of Palestinians and treated a lot badly after even taking their homes So most people think palestine started it but it’s very 1 sided It’s genocide and Israel should really stop You’re just killing more civilians and Israel people can still eat food and live a good life Palestine people don’t have a place to sleep or eat anything It’s not a “what side I should join” It’s obvious what side you should be on We need a ceasefire
00:02 The conflict between Israel and Palestine originated in Jerusalem, a holy city for multiple religions. 01:55 Jews migrated to Palestine to escape persecution, leading to conflict with Palestinians. 03:40 Israel formed in 1948 and faced war with neighboring Arab countries. 05:29 Israel captured Gaza Strip, West Bank and other territories in the 1967 war 07:19 The conflict between Israel and Palestine stems from territorial disputes and extremist groups. 09:06 Israel defends against terrorist attacks by Hamas 11:02 Israel-Palestine Conflict: Gaza under attack and tensions rise 12:51 Israel has the right to defend itself against Hamas' goal of destroying it.
Your full of Bias just like this woman both of you guys don’t like to talk about how Israel took Palestine land the only thing Palestine wanted was their own army no occupied places they’re home until Israel took control of Palestine Israel supported the Israeli settlers taking Palestinian land that’s why Palestine got mad and attacked don’t mess with someone’s property and they’re would be no conflict
I wonder, does Palestinie have the right to defend itself against Israeli occupation of their land and deprivation of their basic human rights and utilities? Evem though I believe Israel has the right to exist within the boundaries as drawn up in the UN charter of 1948.
Israelites chosen people from the creation of the universe and forever Amen Isreal name given to the son of Issac, Issac is the son of Abraham . It's not the name for Ishmael a servant's son. But they too have the favour of God due to Abraham seed but the is not Israel but Saudi Arabia
SO you mean , hamas cant defend themselves and fight israel..? its absolute shame .....hamas is not aided by any nations like that of america funding israel ...they dont have modern wepons and assault artilearies ....but still they have guts stand and fight against superpower .....even so called powerfull nations military cant dare to withstand fornite aginst them.....lol @keerthihistory
I went to many comments to write the truth to them, and this took me a long time, hopefully as much as I was tired, and my head began to hurt because I wrote a lot ،please read that story.
In 1948, Israelis arrived in Palestine as refugees. The Palestinians welcomed them well, but the Israelis wanted more. They did not care to deal well with the Palestinians. Rather, they wanted to seize the land of the Palestinians. As a natural reaction, the Palestinians did not accept it, as this is their land. Here the Israelis started killing children. They raped and killed women and the elderly, displaced 85% of the Palestinians, and controlled 78% of Palestine. This continued for 75 years, and the moment the Palestinians started defending their rights, they began to be called terrorists, even though it was Israel that occupied Palestine and was doing internationally prohibited things. Some people come and say that Israel has the right to defend itself and that it is the victim?? Now, a few hours ago, I saw that the number of Palestinian deaths had exceeded 7,703 dead and 3,595 children. They even dropped bombs equivalent to the Hiroshima bomb and internationally banned phosphorus on Gaza, and you say that Hamas are the terrorists, knowing that the Israeli prisoners captured by Hamas are receiving good treatment. They did not rape women or torture the elderly or children as the Israelis do with their captives. Rather, they made them sleep in places that were cleaned daily, bandage their wounds, and eat the same food that the Hamas group eats. . I doubt that the Israelis do this to their Palestinian prisoners. I am certain that Palestinian prisoners are subjected to the harshest types of torture there. There is no food and no clean place to sleep, and they are tortured psychologically or physically, and then you say that Hamas is the terrorist?? Knowing that a few days ago, Israel blew up an entire hospital in Gaza. Imagine waking up to find you are full of wounds. Then she takes refuge in the hospital, which is filled with people injured by bombs falling like rain, and they do not even have enough medical equipment. Suddenly you hear an explosion. Yes, the hospital containing it was bombed. Thousands of wounded and injured children who saw nothing but misery and persecution at the hands of the Zionists. They died as a result of the explosion in the hospital that they thought was their only refuge. Imagine that your mother, children, or wife are inside this hospital, and you are searching for the remains of your children among the rubble. You hear the sound of an explosion and then realize that the hospital housing your family members has exploded... This is what the Palestinians in Gaza are experiencing. Then you say that Israel has the right to defend itself and Palestine does not?? This is your concept of humanity? (If you want to confirm my words, go and watch the video of the Israeli grandmother released by the Hamas group) (Please go and search for the story from trustworthy people, whether the Palestinians themselves or the Arabs. All Arabs know the true story, but unfortunately foreigners do not know it.
@@Sky_dunes I dont think that's what she is saying... She clearly says that attacking innocent men, women and children is not the way to get back at israel's political stance. People who are trying to lead their daily lives with whatever problems they may have should not be bombed out of existence for something they are not personally liable for. I hope you treat this as a humanitarian issue and not as a jew vs muslim issue... thats not what we need to be concentrating on. I feel like we need to acknowledge that innocent civilians should not be killed during a war or terrorism... its not the right way to deal with this. :(
@@Uripinkasright and wrong is often subjective. In this case, you have two parties who both insist and believe that they are right and the other is wrong.
How terrified would you be when you get burned by phosphorus?, your children killed, bombed, starve, what would you do if you see your parents die in front of you, its bias but would you fight for your freedom or be opressed
WOW, amazing video! This conflict has really been bothering me lately as I am majoring in Social Sciences and it's something that comes up relatively often. Politics is a massive element of the course. There has been so much misinformation regarding this conflict it's been so hard to understand what is right and what is wrong. Finally, after months of researching, your video allowed me to finish my report. Before watching your video my report was sitting at 5000 words but thanks to your video, I was able to write 3000 more words! Writing this report has been the best experience I've had at university so far and I just wanted to thank you for helping me achieve this.
There is a Big flaw in this information. Please know Before palestine it was Israel's land. Israel didn't form for the first time in 1948. They were the occupiers years before palestine. That's a historic fact. Please research on your own you will find out. The video said Jews suffered persecution from Hitler and wherever they want. That's right. But one question, if they were persecuted wherever they went. Where was their homeland?? It was Israel, the homeland of the land Jews. They were scattered soon after the crucifixion of Jesus because they were attacked and lost their homeland. In 1948. The Jews came back to their homeland Israel. So all I'm saying. It was not Palestines land to begin with. Israel belongs to the Jews. REASEARCH for yourself. You'll find out this historic fact🙏🙏
@@TheMonkeyTheorists No, that's false. It originally belongs to the Cannanites. A tribe which is not in existence today. After the Cannanites, it belonged to Israel
It's crazy how the wrongdoings of several big/historical names cause this much sufferage to this many innocent lives in both places. And I side with none but the INNOCENT PEOPLE at both places, both have regular people with no power just like me, but I agree with your conclusion. Terrorism isn't a way to reclaim anything.
You're absolutely correct. So many people take the wrong stance in this and might even get triggered If I show them this video. We must also know the full picture of this complicated situation to correctly place our judgement. Its absolutely terrible that innocent civillians are getting killed amidst this war between HAMAS and the Israeli military. I pray for the innocent people and chilren that have to go through such atrocities every day and wish peace upon those who have passed
I have watched so many informative videos, news about this issue but cnt understand it completely.. but u were the best in explaining things in a common language.. thank u so much for bringing truth to us ..❤
She said it herself. “When you attack the common people, that is Terrorism”. Hamas is to be condemned for Oct. 7th. But 11,000 citizens dead, and 60 members of Hamas? That’s a 99.5% failure rate, let alone a genocide.
Okay what are the names of these 60 Hamas members even? I haven’t seen Israel release any concrete proof, everything they have released has been debunked…including the Israeli deaths on October 7th, which actually were proven to be Palestinian victims of Israel from 2014. The list of names was released and it matched almost identically to a list of Palestinian civilians they killed in the past. Israel is one step ahead of the game, they slightly changed the last names to sound more Jewish. It’s really just corrupt all around. They follow the same propaganda tactics that were done by Nazi Germany and other genocide in history. Also, how did Hamas acquire American weapons? The rockets they fired matched the same that were given by the U.S. to Israel (it’s been noted that Netanyahu actually encouraged the Hamas organization from the beginning)…all part of a bigger plan called the Zionist project. Zionism cannot be confused with Judaism, Zionism goes against it and it supports genocide of anyone who isn’t Jewish. The hostages have been released by Hamas have said they were treated well and some have even accused Israel of starting the conflict on October 7th. Netanyahu and the rest of the Knesset have publicly and repeatedly made racist comments towards the Palestinians with genocidal intent. All of this information is available if you actually look for it instead of listening to western media. 6 Zionists groups own 96% of the media, including CNN, Fox, BBC, Paramount, HBO, need I say more? Look up what ex IDF members have to say about their own country and the abuse they had to incite on Palestinians. Watch Born in Gaza on Netflix even. You know what incites violence? Colonization, oppression, family trauma….something Israel has always done since their establishment in 1948. Honest Jews do no agree with the government either, look up what they have to say. This girl won’t teach you anything, she’ll just give you a filtered history lesson.
Israel uses rockets to protect its people, Hamas uses people to protect its rockets. Palastinian die because of hamas, The murderous barbaric terrorist organization. Hamas murders his own civilian when they try to escape from combat zones. Hamas uses women and children as human shields. If you believe the numbers and lies of Hamas you are very naive.
But do you remember when gandhiji said"palestine belongs to the arabs in the same sense that England belongs to the english or france to the french".You should also mention this in your video
Even if you have your own political beliefs you can’t say Israel are at fault. It’s the same thing that happened in Afghanistan with the hospital issues. Terrorists use public spaces where innocent civilians are as their place to store weapons and fight because they know that the other side will be condemned for killing innocents when they had no choice but to try to find the terrorists. Palestine is at fault for not accepting what Israel tried to give to them. Palestines goal is to destroy Israel and if that’s not genocide I don’t know what is. I love how in this video she pointed out using an analogy that if India tried to take their historically owned land (Pakistan) then that’s wrong because Pakistan politically own it but we have a double standard that Palestine trying to take back their historically owned land (Israel) is right despite it being politically owned by Israel. As a follower of Christ I stand with the holy land of Israel 🇮🇱
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, NOT a Palestine State. 2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 3. Before The Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic State of Mamluks of Egypt, NOT a Palestine State. 4. Before the Islamic State Of Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish empire, NOT a Palestine State. 5. Before the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, NOT a Palestine State. 6. Before the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was Umyyad and Fatimid Empires, NOT a Palestine State. 7. Before the Umyyad and Fatimid Empires, there was the Byzantine Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Sassanids Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 9. Before the Sassanids Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean State, NOT a Palestine State. 12. Before the Hasmonean State, there was the Seleucid Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 13. Before the Seleucid Empire, there was the Empire Of Alexander The Great, NOT a Palestine State. 14. Before the Empire Of Alexander The Great, there was the Persian Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, NOT a Palestine State. 16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there was the Kingdoms of Isreal and Judah, NOT a Palestine State. 17. Before the Kingdoms of Isreal and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Isreal, NOT a Palestine State. 18. Before the Kingdom Of Isreal, there was the Therocracy of the Twelve Tribes of Isreal, NOT a Palestine State. 19. Before the Therocracy of the Twelve Tribes Of Isreal, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite City Kingdoms, NOT a Palestine State. In all its history THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A PALESTINE STATE but this piece of land has been under the rule of and been occupied by various rulers and kingdoms.
You struck the nail on the head. Keerthy has to learn her history well if she has to give an informed lecture. Morover israel was formed on land bought from the arabs.
Canaans are Palestinians and other arabs..Joshua the jew with his twelve tribes invaded and killed canaanites....that's why Palestinians telling they are the son of soils...all Arab countries do know this that judas are the invaders that's why they propagating Muslims as a terrorist in all media cinema etc...al qaida,isis like such terrorist groups are funded....by america and isreal even hamas also under mossad they are playing to start ww||| they failed with Ukraine that's why, how could hamas..landed on isreal freely....did isreal's air defense sleeping...judas are the Satan's cunning bastardos
It’s not original but it’s true. I’m incredibly thankful that this lady has made a messy complicated situation into an easy to understand video without any of her own political bias.
Palestinians had many chances to accept East Jerusalem as their capital. The Jewish ancestral home is there too. Arafat was offered 95% of the West Bank, and he said NO! Israel has been kicked out of dozens of countries. They got used to it. Mexico used to own all of Texas to the top of California. They got used to it and became a fine, productive country. "From the Rio Grande to the Portland, Oregon!" is not a Mexican chant, like from "the River to the Sea."
the problem with the video is, she said, islam invaded india but Islam is a religion. Some Muslims are the ones who conquered India. However, Muslims existed before India's conquest. Islam is a belief system that the populace has accepted; aside from their respective religions, Muslims are the same people as other Hindus. However, it is absurd to draw comparisons between the situations in India Pakistan, and Israel. Jews existed before the colonial state was established, but they were not Zionists; The foreigners who were forced to reside there were known as Zionists. The foreigners who used force and weapons to settle there were known as Zionists., as opposed to the same Indians who converted to Islam after coming into touch with Muslims and the Islamic concept. When Jews come into power, they stab the Muslims who have been helpful to them. Previously, After being persecuted by Christians, Jews were the ones who sought refuge from Muslims to settle in their country. That's a long story, nonetheless. Given that Hamas is a terrorist group, IDF is likewise a terrorist organization since they utilize violence and murder to take Palestinian land and homes. This is the issue-you folks don't realize it and start on October 7th. There wouldn't be an organization like Hamas if the colonial state hadn't been established in Arab soil. For the love of God, consider yourself in Hamas' shoes before passing judgment. Reply
What makes you think she didn't have any bias? Everyone who forms their own point of view on something has developed a bias. She gave her personal opinion multiple times. Also, she was selective about what she chose to cover. For example, she never mentioned that the roots of Hamas are directly within the Israeli government, who created Hamas in order to divide the people, prevent them from having a stable government, and give Israel an excuse to deny Palestinian rights and kill innocent people. None of that was included and yet those are well-documented facts. They weren't convenient to the narrative of the video, which is that Hamas is the "sole reason" for the "bitterness" between Israel and Palestine. It's funny how she spends several minutes explaining generations of conflict between Jews and Arabs and then suddenly somehow pins it all on Hamas, an organization that was created in the late 1980s and only came into power in 2006, as the "sole reason ". So... all the stuff she said before, that was just a little squabble? No bitterness before 2006? OK, got it. 😂 Maybe you agree with her bias but she certainly is biased. There's nothing wrong with being biased. But she's also just wrong, and there's something wrong with that.
Various groups of people have lived in what is now known as Palestine for thousands of years. Before the Israelites and Moses occupied the land, there were other people. The prophet Moses is credited with rescuing the Israelites from slavery in Egypt and guiding them to the promised land of Israel, according to both Jewish tradition and the Hebrew Bible. @@rajagopalan2411
u cant support both the countries, its ok that u feel sorry for the innocent people on the both sides but that only goes on to show u dont have enough knowledge to be supporting either side
I feel relived after hearing your final review because I’ve been sitting here wondering if I was wrong for seeing the right/wrong from both sides. You worded my thoughts perfectly and explained everything better than any other video I viewed trying to grasp whats going on.
There is a Big flaw in this information. Please know Before palestine it was Israel's land. Israel didn't form for the first time in 1948. They were the occupiers years before palestine. That's a historic fact. Please research on your own you will find out. The video said Jews suffered persecution from Hitler and wherever they want. That's right. But one question, if they were persecuted wherever they went. Where was their homeland?? It was Israel, the homeland of the land Jews. They were scattered soon after the crucifixion of Jesus because they were attacked and lost their homeland. In 1948. The Jews came back to their homeland Israel. So all I'm saying. It was not Palestines land to begin with. Israel belongs to the Jews. REASEARCH for yourself. You'll find out this historic fact🙏🙏
@@kylies8494 really? I think you got mixed up, it was Palestine land and they were nice enough to give some to Israel before they fought for more. And now Palestine is only trying to get their land back. Also Palestine was there first for years, (I researched) it just wasn’t an official country. And it was indeed Poland, the Jews home land, but after they got invaded many of them went to the Palestinian land.
@@HaveACrestDay Sorry to say but you're wrong. You're talking about Jews coming to Palestine and forming the State Israel in 1948. Israelis were coming back to their homeland, that's what happened in 1948. It was Israel land first. They were driven away from their homeland thousands of years ago. How do you not come accross this when you researched. Check it out for YOURSELF. I have no agenda here,except to bring the truth to light. If you don't believe me Check the Quran. It's given in the Quran that Israel land was given by Allah. Ask any Muslim. Quran has the mention of Israel country many times. Still saying that Israel never existed before 1948? How is that?
@@HaveACrestDay Israel Palestine conflict started the Very next day the Jews came and formed the State. Within one day, Israel formed a military group. They were attacked by four countries the very next day they came. But Israel out stunned the World by defeating all 4 countries. So the Jews are fighting for their homeland. It's not the Palestinians land to begin with. But still Israel gave Gaza and the West Bank as a token of peace. So I stand with justice,with Israel🇮🇱
Great brother if you want. Peace. Go to. Himalayas. And. Meditate Nava nirmanam kosam poorava. Samajam antham thatyam idhi Vidhi likitham. Orapancham. Himsa ninchi pootina portion Bida ahimsa pagatikala
Thank you for explaining this whole thing in a very easy understandable way! And thank you for your point of view too! I love how you are not bias when it comes to explaining the history, and still managed to deliver your view point in the end of the video after the explanation. You did great! I also love how you use Indian and Pakistani as a mirroring example too!
It is an occupation, and no important details were mentioned. I stopped the video and did not want to finish it because it was not fair I knew that she was biased towards the occu/pation because she did not mention that the Jews who came to the Palest/inian territ/ories from the beginning were not ordinary people, but rather they were armed, They did not come for work or tourism, but their goal was clear, the media manipulation We will not forgive your sympathy for the occu/pier, This is just further evidence that the rich do whatever they want
She’s not telling all the truth. It’s very biased. For one Jerusalem isn’t symbolic in the Bible for heaven beyond, it’s not the Jerusalem here on earth. .
@@Erenyaegerbernardintell me u know nothing about the bible without telling me you know nothing about the bible Jerusalem is a very sacred place for Christian as we believe that is Jesus’s birth place even pastors travel there to pray and bless so wdym buddy
@@tate.daulang No.. Absolutely not... They never openfired on innocent people or beheaded childrens like the Hamas terrorist did to innocent Israelis on 7 oct. How Demon are you to justify Hamas terrorist.
Damn the power of the media can do that Everything is fake It is truly unfortunate that there are those who believe these lies The Israelis stole all those countries and killed their people and children. They were expelled not because of their religion, but because they are criminals. They are criminals because of their strange rituals. Western news channels are headed by Israeli businessmen. The economy of America and France today is based on Israeli businessmen, so we see all this exhausting falsification against the Palestinians. I did not know that the world was so unjust. Israel declared many contradictions, and yet it became the owner of the truth. The Israeli Prime Minister said on Twitter that he bombed the hospital and minutes later wiped it out and said it was the work of Hamas. It's funny, what a contradiction!! The pictures are still there but they are literally being deleted. Every article on the Internet that supports Palestine will be deleted! Every supportive RU-vid video is also deleted and the channel owner gets a strike!! They are so afraid of revealing the truth to the world!!! What a shame really. The Israeli Prime Minister described Palestinian civilians as animals. What an urban act. This is so painful that people still believe in Israel 💔
We also need to know that Jews were in Palestine area before muslims because Judaism is much older than Islam But I do think innocent life should be supported , Israel please make a shelter for innocent people until the war
It's the same thing happening all over the world. You guys are going to other countries and making those as your homes. So why are you worrying about this only one incident?
Thank you for this video. I’m American and I didn’t understand what was happening. I have been trying to find videos from a lot of different perspectives. I appreciate you making this simple to understand for me 😊
Most of the time when I go into a comment section of this topic I see “free Palestine!” I support Israel because I grew up being told that’s god’s country. And then people start attacking me in the comments. If I showed this video to someone who supports Palestine, they’ll get very mad at me.
@@nourin_1 it’s hard when you’re in a religion that revolves only on that religion. I don’t want people to think I’m a fake Christian. So stuff like this.. it’s hard to choose a side
After watching more videos I feel like she missed some parts about the Israelie occupation and I feel during this she didn’t explain the reasoning enough for isreal I recommend you watch the war stories video on the topic
Israel were refugees in Palestine. As she said Isreali came from Germany because of Hitler's cruelty. It means the land is for Palestinians . And also she gave some fake information.
Well that was not Palestinians land first learn history before it became Muslim land it was jerualism land it was land of one of jew king in history not a Muslim one Muslim only took it by killing and as a refugee and force out other religions out after that jew migrated to Germany but came back to take their rights
2:32 You might have checked the meaning of Palestine in hebru. Jews were persecuted and thrown away from Jerusalem first, later jews returned to their original land in 19th century
@@hemanthkrishnan8108so according to you, Jews cannot go back their homeland?? Israel was there at least from 1000 BCE, they have the most ancient claim on the land
@@hemanthkrishnan8108 You mean, the jews who were all over the Middle East who were hunted and brutalised for not converting, completely wiped out from the entire Middle East must simply accept their fate and let the invader barbarians take everything? What do you eat for food?
@@hemanthkrishnan8108no one was thrown out they both had land to live. I mean can you imagine being attacked by 7 countrys altogether? They clearly wanted to just kill every single jew. And now Egypt wouldn't even let the refugees to enter. Quater is funding hamas. How are they gonna find peace god knows. I prey they both can live peacefully so the local people can live in peace. FYI the war is more like Islam vs jew rather than to live peacefully in their country.
Thank you for this. You made me understand this a whole lot better. I can't believe I was taking sides. Alot of people on both sides want the genocide of the other and people just go for whatever is trending and popular.
If you want more specific details not superficial information about the story from the beginning, search on RU-vid for "Palestine: The Tale of the Land" by Al Da7ee7.
It's important to empathize with both sides instead of supporting or blaming either. Jews suffered from the very beginning for no fault of theirs and neither of the Israelis or Palestinians received true support and solution from the other countries which were only concerned about division and land grabbing in between of which the 2 Country people were trapped.
It is not a land dispute. It is about the existence of a nation. It's about their belief that you can have a country, and your belief that they shouldn't exist on planet Earth.
It is a land dispute. Hamas doesn't care about Israel existing in present-day Alaska, for example. It's about Israel existing in what is and was Palestine. Mind you, apparently the Zionists were "picking" between Palestine, Uganda, and Argentina when they were thinking of settling a land, so that should tell you everything you need to know about the nature of their intentions vs. the sentiments of the Palestinians.
Thank you for this clarification! I have been trying to understand this war. Now I do and it’s similar to my native country, Haiti and the Dominican republic recently. Hopefully they won’t be no war over there.
But when your government attacks a stronger country but I feel bad for both sides but there really no good choice and feel bad for them hope they can find a ceasefire
@@average_commenter1 whatt???? israel started it years ago , it didnt start on october 7 , it started in 1940s, go and educate yourself, it is not a war anymore. its a genocide.
@@Sjsjsjsjsj798 that's not Palestine's problem, if a some people come to India and claims that they need our country so We have to get out of our own country because their population is increased, WILL YOU ALLOW IT? AND GIVE OUR COUNTRY TO THEM BECAUSE THEIR POPULATION IS INCREASED?!!!
Well said. I agree with a lot you said in this video. Im praying one day, Israel and Palestine will come together and form an agreement and maybe one day they will have peace with each other 🇵🇸🇮🇱
Your explanation is very clear and lucid. The entire history has been vividly narrated using simple words. Yes you are right. People sympathize when one is a victim, but criticize when the one fights back. That's the way, rather the brutal way of the world. It's really painful to see, but I can feel it as I have felt it many times in my own life.
Keerthi, conveniently left out the fact that Israeli government controls ALL the resources and tortures people living in Gaza. Keerthi also did NOT mention that in 2023, children living in Gaza are NOT allowed to play with crayons or eat Macaroni and cheese. Keerthi also left out that Israel has been an apartheid nation for the past 75years and is occupying and torturing common people. Israel bombs the heck out of Gaza and the people living in Gaza are NOT ALLOWED to rebuild or clean up their communities because Israel doesn't give clean water to the 2 million people and they get only 3 hours of electricity. Gaza is an open air prison and Keerthi left out all this information and is making it seem like suddenly an attack happened.
No her video is missing many facts. Some were not true. 1. UN gave Jews majority of the land even tho there population was abt 3% at that time, they offered Uganda first to settle the jews but the jews refused. Palestine was actually on list B not A. 2. Hospitals were destroyed by israel since they issued many warnings to evacuate that hospital and it was done via an official tweet as well but then deleted since humanitarians objected to it so they accused the other side to avoid consequences. This is a proven fact plz research. 3. This war was preplanned since the pm went to a UN meeting done right before saying how they will gain more land and change the map. Search it up. Palestinians are poor they dont have any rights nor fundings even in Gaza westbank israel they are not treated as humans so how can they fight a war against the supremely powerful and highly funded country with world best security and military equipments. They were provoked to retaliate to defend themselves. Aint no way that was not preplanned caz nothing can escape the security system the dome of the opposition. Literally nothing. Palestinian doesnt have high tech or anything. Check videos ull see them fighting with rocks. Their economy is trash. They are in a highly dense area with no rights, segregation amongst the two groups. They stole their land/houses, killed their people, threw white phosphorus out in the open and still are, blew hospitals/aids/cchurche/ambulances/ the border that they said to escape from/ the route they warned the ppl to evacuate from/. Theres no end to this terror. Be human open ur eyes. Anything and everything is being said to change the narrative and make them look like villains to justify this massacre this genocide so that they could take the land and US can revive its economy and the world war could start. Rn many other countries are being attacked thats how strong isnotreal is. Perform a ground operation if u think ppl are being used as human shields why dont ya? U dont bomb the entire school of a shooter is inside!! This is disgusting. Ppl are so heartless. Its not abt religion guys. Its abt power. Plz wake up. Even ur own religion will hate u for being on the wrong side. Its not abt religion tho thats just a propaganda. Plz guys why would they initiate the attack it would be suicide! If u still dont agree with me then dont bother replying. Nothing i say will convince u and there would be no point unfortunately.
You should read the Balfour agreement You should read of the atrocities the Jewish refugees did to the local Palestinian. The country was always Palestine
This is a Zionist issue. Jews and Muslims are fine together . History will provide the proof. The terrorists referred to here were first introduced by the zionists. It's in all three news.
Et ginn eng Zuel vun auslänneschen Äppel am Land wou vill Hënn an Eeër fonnt ginn, si hunn erausfonnt datt d'Positiounszäitgrafik vun der Geschwindegkeet A fir Vektor B op e konstante Begrëff ass an e gréissere Imapct vun der Manupliatioun op systematesch huet. Zäiten, D'Nofolger vun engem Kinnek, deen e Mamendéieren gär huet, deen e véier Been Organismus huet, obwuel vun engem gudde Räich, awer d'Zukunft huet d'Schlecht vun hirem eegene Goss ofgehalen, well hiren Kär net d'Zell-Enveloppe enthält well déi meescht Mamendéieren keng Zellmauer a Protoplasma hunn, also fuert also weider mam Contract of countires developmetn adn fäeg sinn ze manhe vrcotr b mat cosinus vum Wénkel seha a bauen Korruptioun manner Stroossen a Brécke amplaz déi z'ënnerstëtzen, déi e Blummen faarweg Fändel unbiased favoriséieren
So great that people like you make a fair stand unlike other so-called type of RU-vidrs who are ready to play the dirty politics on such a sensitive topic.
This was ridiculous by all standards. Talked about only crimes (that haven't been proven either) committed by Hamas and no context of the 80 yrs old oppression. Shameful when India too was once a colony of the Britishers and here too it was the Britishers who signed of the land to the zionists without consulting the indigenous Palestinians population resulting in the the exile of 80 thousand Palestinians. Razing of entire villages (read on tantura massacre and deir yassin massacre even Einstein condemned it), destruction of ecosystems maintained by the Palestinians, raping and burning of little children. Even today a white person from the US can come and easily settle in an settlement considered illegal by the un and all international laws while the 4 million Palestinian refugees live country-less seeking citizenship. Even in this genocide Israel has used white phosphorus (burns bones, illegal and a war crime under international laws, it has broken about 50 laws. Iraq was invaded for breaking two. So shut up. And this isn't a war.this is bloodthirst. They have killed 50 of their own hostages in the bombardment.
I hope that you review the latest statistics for the number of Palestinian martyrs since the beginning of the bombardment, its decline in the number of Israeli prisoners. I hope that you will review the number of martyrs since the beginning of the entry of the Jews into this Holy Land and see and know for yourself and see their actions that are not forgotten for any heavenly religion in the world
From what I understand its not a contry war more like a terrorist attack the terrorist started this tbh So i dont support Palestine nor Isreal I support the innocent people I dont understand ehy a lot of innocent people are hurt due to some terrorist like let them live in peace I hope someday the good/ innocent people from both the countries can live together happily. I feel so bad for the people from both the countries especially the children like what did they do to deserve this 😭😭 Lets all join together and pray for their well being 🙏🙏🙏 😢😢
@@user-ol3rj7gs5uso when Bhagat Singh protect his land, most indian agree with Bhagat Singh, so British have the same thinking why pity indian...so what the differences between you and animal?
Exactly my view on that whole issue, thank you for spreading some reason in the current madness of the "if you are not for us you are against us" mentality
@@Keerthihistory YES ,I AM 8TH GRADE AND TO KNOW HISTORY ,I WATCH YOUR VIDEOS BECAUSE OUR TEACHERS ARE TELLING ABOUT MUGHALS AND NOT TELLING ABOUT THE GREAT INDIAN KINGS .
@@Deva_editz21ッnot the teacher fault right!? They are just teaching you what in the book and that's their job, and even if they teach you all these there won't be enough time for your actual syllabus and you may fail or the teachers may get expelled. Btw good that you are here to know and learn, cus kids your age nowadays just praise fashion and useless stuff thinking whole world revolves around em lol.
You missed mentioning that during the year 1948, the Israeli Jews carried out ethnic cleansing and massive massacres against Muslims and Christians Palestinian, and killed thousands of Palestinians from that date until the present day. It was also pointed out that the Indian people and their historical leaders supported the Palestinians in their struggle against the Zionists, led by leader Mahtma Gandhi, leader Nehru, and leader Indira Gandhi
@@fkoff7649 imagine some one keep slapping your face for 50 times and you just slapped him back once this the same what happened , watch this movie and you can under stand (Law Abiding Citizen)
@@maanmishalmishal860 THAT IS WHY I SAID WHAT I SAID, PALESTINE MILITANTS KEEP ON ATTACKING ISRAEL MANY TIMES SO WHAT DO YOU EXPECT ISRAEL TO DO? SIT BACK AND DO NOTHING?
@@fkoff7649 oh man you misunderstood the Israeli who slapping Palestine 50 times and this was the first time Palestine slapped them , Palestinian are under brutal occupiation in Gaza since 1967 for GOD sake
Imagine you stay in ur friend place and after a while you tell ur friend to go away and if not... You start to fight them... The same happen here in Manipur also
@@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451so? Pakistan is your enemy. Palestine is not? Israel is not? China is your enemy And russia chinas friend Just because they are enemy does not mean you must hate your brother (russia) And palestine and israel is not a war, not a conflict. It’s an occupation by zionests! Like think. You hate palestine because they are with pakistan. You like russia when they are chinas friend?? And idk about kashmir but i think it’s stupid to get this land when both countries have a lot. If many indians live there they must own it. Same with pakistan i guess. Now tell me. Do you still support israel?
Thank you so much for the explanation .... I really love your voice and especially the accent ... I am really interested in south Indian temples and its history... ❤❤❤ As a north Indian its a very interesting topic for me 😊
U told so many points are correctly but few points are wrong u flipped the coin to other side stating mistakes on humas marking as terrorist.. you are telling humas is terrorist due to they attacked with 5000 rockects on israel..ok its justified ..why they attacked israel because they israeli killed so many palestine innocent people living in israel very silently from partition happened and completely destroyed palestine people from israel and for every ramzan and festival day of muslims they are attacking masjid al aqsa and all masjid present in west bank,israel and occupying them and torturing and killing innocent people from decades what are u doing at that time not a single video made on israel terrorist which these are points missing in video and intelligently hiding israel propagandas and things they done speaking in support of israel..so here actual terrorist is israel army. they israeli killed lakhs of palestine people who have their home and land in israel..add this point in this video tell israel army done this like terrorist for 50 y and humus attacked back. ur video on verdict is stating israel is correct but they are terrorist.
I actually really appreciated this video. I feel you explained everything in a fairly quick, but thorough and concise manner, and it helped me clear up my own thoughts and opinions on the issue
Good Job Keerthi..the video explains the crystal clear situation which resulted in this war.....no other you tuber explained in better way than yours....keep up and well done...!!!
As a request from the brains of UPSC aspirants thinking of a separate playlist topics of UPSC history as it is very difficult to study history you make history interestingly and easily.🙏 helps a lot of UPSC aspirants.
@@Okkitty_____research the Nakba and the past 75 years of Israels existence Haifa massacre is just one of the many many massacres Israel has done to Palestine before October 7th
Last as you said is abosolutely correct because a war declared means it seems to be a government to government not a common people, both Israeli and Palestine common people wants to recover, and government wants to conduct a war between hamas and israeli army like a video game.
