If you really want to have that uncomfortable conversation on your platform you need to have an Israeli and a Palestinian person come face to face and hash out their issues towards one another and that can help society come to their own conclusions instead of being obligated and pressured to support something they might not necessarily support.
Do you have that same energy for Palestinians, or only.Israelis? Because you realize Hamas doesn't want Israel to exist at all, unlike Israel who has made various peace offers over the years for a two state solution? Not to mention Hamas openly states they want all Jews around the world to be killed. It's literally in their charter.
People were at a dance festival, and all of them were civilians. More than 200 were deliberately killed, some with unimaginable cruelty. Some of them are still held as hostages. Is it something that you find hard to be empatic with?
Wow...I spoke some "uncomfortable" truths about #ACHO and race and received a notice from RU-vid ....smh unh unh unh....I already KNEW I would strike a cord, because I was speaking FACTS..... that shit hurt so they removed my comment Point Proven. #FREEPALESTINIANS 🇵🇸 #FREEGAZA ✊🏽✊🏽✊🏽 Israelis stand with theirs and it's "admirable"....people of color stand with theirs and it's somehow " inappropriate" or misplaced....BEAT IT.....Naming racism does not equate to antisemitism Stand with your tribe!
@hawkwing3 😢oh my goodness...these two are very related!!!!! Like the amazing Dr. MARTIN LUTHER KING JR said..."when people criticize zionists, they means Jews..."
The thing that you don't understand mate. And I'm sure you're not Jewish by the sounds of your comment. Is they mean Jewe and general even us who are anti Zionists and who live outside of Israel
@@lexakellington123 are you sure that's what you want? Days ago z!onist mobs supporting the right for soldiers to s0domize Palestinian "prisoners" broke out - another great example of z!onist PR
That is an insane take TBH. Jewish people have been systematically oppressed since Roman times. There is no such people as Palestinians, they are Arabs given a new name for political purposes. Arabs who have colonized all of North Africa by force now cry genocide and it's been working well for them.
My heart hurts for the Israeli people and Jews across the world. It’s horrific what’s happening in Israel, without a doubt. But the arguments shared here (pro-Israel) are what I hear so often, and they neglect to use the full history of Israel, Palestine, and this conflict to inform the conversation. This historical context is critical to understanding the modern conflicts between the two people groups, specifically because the Zionist movement was and is incredibly harmful to the Palestinian people. I have no doubt that many (most?) Israelis and Jews throughout the world want peace with Palestine, but what does the Israeli government want? What do Israel’s allies want? The Israeli government needs major reformation and they need to stop the imprisonment of the Palestinian people. Gaza isn’t some utopia that Israel gifted to the Palestinians like this video and many stories like it claim it to be. But I’ll say it again, none of this discounts the pain, suffering, and trauma that many, many Jews the world over are experiencing. Jews need our support right now, as do Palestinians. And let’s educate ourselves on the full history of the conflict so we can have truly informed conversations about this instead of blanket support for one side or the other. Also, who is pro-Hamas?? Other than perhaps extremists, I’ve yet to see someone explicitly or implicitly supporting Hamas and their heinous acts. That part is very confusing to me.
When you see far-left laughing and saying that the "hipsters" got what they deserved while waving a Palestinian flag... pretty much says they agree with what Hamas did.
Sure, absolutely. I don’t see that being common, however. There will always be extremists, but the overwhelming majority of what we’re seeing is support for the Israelis. That isn’t the same thing as support for the Israeli government, however.
@@NessaBear90 Do you really think right-wingers/conservatives give a darn about Jews and Israel? All of those people in Charlottesville yelling, "Jews will not replace us" were conservative/Republican/Donald Trump supporters. The shooter at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh was a card carrying member of the Donald Trump/MAGA cult. Show me where someone on the far-left in america has committed a similar atrocity? The level of Jewish bigotry on the right/conservative/Repbulcian side is immensely greater than what is seen on the left.
I appreciate the support. and I’d like to recommend this short video about the history. This is a travel guide from Israel like me, but you can completely fact check everything he is saying. I’d like to add this is not a conflict about land, this is an Ideological issue. You might also like to watch Interviews with ‘son of Hamas’ not only from the past few days but from years ago. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-XNf40sBcvKk.htmlsi=xvNpKOj8VtmF8ND0
Define what it means to "stand with Hamas". Because if you mean condemning them and wanting them to be stopped while at the same time questioning the human rights violations that Israel's government is doing to innocent people, then I can get behind that. If you mean that you cannot hold the Israeli government accountable for human rights violations because of this terrorist attack, then no, that is a precisely wrong definition. Remember, you can support Palestine and Israel. Questioning these leaders and their supporters is not supporting the other side. It's calling into question their actions. Specifically THEIR actions. It has nothing to do with the other side.
I can't imagine being a Palestinian after this happened, knowing you didn't do this and the horror that was coming bc of it to your people. Israel needs to step back and deal w/the offenders not Palistine as the Palistinian people have been in a state of apartheid for 60 plus years.
@@beeamendola How would words help after a terror attack that killed 1300 people? Just look to the US response after 9/11. I obviously abhor the violence of both sides but how can you sit there and comment that "just punish the offenders and not the other people" is a realistic path or even possible AT ALL to accomplish?
Comparing this Hamas attack to the Holocaust is insulting. Its wild to me how ppl can so casually compare one of the most tragic events in human history (the holocaust) to every other events. The Hamas attack was tragic but it is not Holocaust 2.0. Also the Israeli lives lost on that one day are not more deserving of compassion and comcern than the thouaands of Palestinians that have died at the hands of the Israeli govt.
When you do this: The State of Israel was created on May 14, 1948. The United Nations passed Resolution 181, also known as the Partition Plan, on November 29, 1947. The resolution divided the British Mandate of Palestine into Arab and Jewish states. The resolution left Jerusalem under UN control. The Arab states rejected the resolution. This led to a civil war in 1947 and the first Arab-Israeli War after Israel was created. What do you expect is going to happen? You cannot walk into an area and claim it to be another land. If the United Nations came into America and took away some land to give it to another group of people what do you think is going to happen? Notice America did the same thing with the Native Americans. When you do things like this you can cause generational long conflict.
It was conquered. The land was a part of the United Kingdom. Before that it had been a part of the Ottoman Empire for 400 years. No arab sovereign states had existed in that area for 400 years.
@@babyfaec It wasn't conquered, if it was conquered then the United Kingdom could have forced them to comply. They didn't comply because they had sovereignty which they STILL have to this day. That's what you don't understand, the United Kingdom did not have the power to do what they did. When you have the power you can ENFORCE your will, and its clear as day that they could not. For example using America as an example. If the Union lost the war they would not have the authority to tell the South what to do. You are only as powerful as your ability to enforce your will.
@@ralx225b So Israel is justified in what they are doing today since they obviously have the ability to enforce their will, and have done so for decades.
@@babyfaec Everybody is justified from their point of view. What isn't justified is pretending that taking out land from a group of people and giving it to another isn't going to cause problems. If I came to your house told you to leave because I am giving it to another group of people you are not going to go quietly into the night. But here is the biggest kicker for you. Define what a Jew is. Then I'll show you that there is no way to PROVE that you are a Jew. And how this whole experiment is a farce.
Israel pulled out of Gaza in 2005. In 2006 the Palestinian people voted Hamas into power. They have been in political control ever since, and haven't allowed new elections. Why would they vote Hamas into power? Most say it was due to the widely accepted anti-american, Israeli and European sentiment. Now does Israel have crazy control on Gaza? Oh yeah, they control all the borders and the sea. They say this is to maintain control of Hamas. So do they keep a tight grip on Gaza? Yeah, sometimes brutal. But they do not, in fact, actually occupy Gaza.
What's the point in having "uncomfortable conversations" if when you ask uncomfortable questions, you don't hold your guests accountable to providing uncomfortable answers. You asked this woman "Then why do they view Israel as the oppressor?" and she responded "Exactly." and you let her. The way she tells the history of Israel and Palestine, "Israel can almost do no right". She says "We want freedom for Palestinians too. I can't say it in so many words. There were peace offerings given to the Palestinian people many times throughout history. And they kept saying no." There's no acknowledgement of the occupation of Palestinian land that the UN considers illegal. There's no acknowledgement of the actions against Palestinians that constitute genocide or ethnic cleansing. The way she talks of the history - on a complicated and disputed topic - the only interpretation of events she leaves is that Palestinians have never wanted peace even when given exactly what they were asking for, which is obviously untrue. So why did you let her communicate that impression on your platform without challenging it? Even if you're coming at this from the angle of seeking neutrality and empathetic understanding and also of not knowing what to believe and seeking more information, hearing one "expert" turn the other side of the discussion into an inexplicable monolith where her people are obviously the Good Guys who are unfairly maligned for no reason - that really ought to have made you feel like you weren't being given a fair depiction of events. And if you aren't wiling or able to identify that on a topic when it happens - especially one so raw and mired in conflicting accounts as this one is - you really ought to not bring that topic onto your platform as though some sort of nuance is going to be presented. You don't have to lead discussions on every topic if you don't know enough about them do to so responsibly.
The arabs rejected a two state solution in 37 and 47, then invaded Israel. This was before any occupation of Palestinian land that is in the UN partition plan, before any ethnic cleansing and before any genocide. Since the first Arab-Israeli war there has basically been no progress on any sort of peace plan or solution to the conflict. These days, mostly thanks to Israel and the US as the Palestinians have changed their tune since getting their shit pushed in several times over the decades.
This is not it. I don’t discredit Jewish voices and how they feel but in occupied Palestinian territory where thousands of Palestinian civilians have been slaughtered. Israel turned off Gaza’s water, electricity, and bombed churches and mosques and hospitals innocent civilians stayed in. This is completely one sided and awful conversation.
There’s A separate conversation with an author from the Palestinian side. When you get two people together, they do usually end up speaking over each other.
I had a Palestinian friend tell me that he feels bad for the Jews for this event bc all this pain they are in reminds him of the pain he feels on a daily basis. I feel for this woman but she really is over simplifying the conflict. I’d love to hear her take on what’s been happening in the West Bank.
Palestinians love to pretend like they're the victims of Israel when really they're the victims of themselves and almost everything they claim is false.
For this conversation to be nuanced, history needed to be involved. It's only by looking back that we can understand what has happened, and I think this conversation really fell short of what it could be because that history was missing. I also think it's problematic to present both sides as if the two nations hold the same power, wealth and resources. Many people are seeking to boost Palestinian voices right now because they have been silenced for so many years. Just some feedback.
Cmon Acho. I expected more fact checking if you’re gonna give them a platform to say their side. It can’t just suddenly be “look it up”, “they said no!”. WTF is this? I hope you really learn from this missed opportunity, as the damage it caused is substantial.
literally. This isn't an "uncomfortable conversation". This is an opinion with little to no facts. She also focuses alot ON HAMAS AND NOT ON THE ISRAELI GOVERMENT
Emmanuel, thank you for asking the questions and facilitating the conversation. Please put this and your new video with Noura Erakat together so that everyone has to watch both people's pain and insights. If you could blend them together or something. I understand why you've shown them separately, but I think people need to be forced to listen to people from different backgrounds and understanding. Only by hearing perspectives and thoughts, we feel uncomfortable with will we grow and develop a more tolerant, understanding and compassionate society. I stand for Peace.
This didn’t start on October7th, No one who believes in humanity agrees with what happened, but your ignorance of historical events prevents you from from facilitating at truly uncomfortable conversations without challenging her narrative!
I knew I didn't have shit in my eyes. I kept pausing the video and checking and I wasn't sure. How's she gonna sit there and say she wants a two state solution and then we're a necklace with the whole of Palestine on it as if it's her birth right to have it all? #FREEPALESTINE 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸
These two countries have been at war for multiple decades. This didn't start yesterday. I hope someone from the other side come on your show so you can interview them. The loss of lives is horrible, but some medium needs to be reached. We, as a world, can not keep up this horrific site. It pains to watch it on TV. We should be able to agree to disagree. Thanks for your show. You keep moving forward. I am so proud of you.
The medium was the two state solution which is as close to dead today as it has ever been. The arabs rejected it in 1937 and 1947 which soon resulted in the Nakba (disaster in Arabic) and the expulsion of close to a million Palestinians after the first Arab-Israeli war. A two state solution has been rejected by Israel (and the US) ever since, even as Palestinian leaders have been pushing for this since the mid 70's.
@iFantasyKlown You're right as long as a medium can not be upheld or respected, We will be in the same situation for years to come. Thanks for your reply.
Wow people don't listen. Israel offered the land to the Palestinians! HAMAS is the enemy. Why don't you listen. And please listen the slaughter that HAMAS committed. You're still not listening.
It's not 2 countries, it's one occupying another. Jews and Palestinians lived peacefully before the occupation started. Jews fled to the middle east because they were safer there than in Europe or russia.
Thanks for the interview but tbh it never got uncomfortable. It was like Emmanuel held back tough questions b/c the author got more animated and impassioned. No questions about the displacement of 800k people in '48, the occupation of West Bank, or Israel's blockade on Gaza (especially when she said Israel isn't occupying Gaza), etc. But I appreciate bringing her on and hearing her perspective.
And no discussions of Hamas being voted in during 2007. Or Israel having Muslims in their Government and not the same in Palestine. No discussion of a possible 85% of Palestinians being compliant with Hamas and NOT so innocent after all. Obviously the children are innocent and that's sad.
This lady just said that "everytime we have come to the table to talk about how much of YOUR LAND we want to give to you" is straight BS. And she really believes this too.
I watched both of these conversations. The REAL uncomfortable conversation would be Noura Erakat & Noa Tishby sitting down and listening to each other. It is not difficult to speak, it is difficult to listen.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr believing in peace is Jen O'Syde of the indigenous population until total victory as per Bibi, the Lukid's charters (the right-wing party that is in collation with Bibi) and also in all the Bibi's recording including the assassination of the 5th president who signed Oslo accords. The issue with these comments exists between the keyboard and the chair, unfortunately.
This was an excellent interview and helped me personally to change my biased on how I’m looking at a lot of things. Even facts can be used to justify biases. I didn’t want to watch this interview, but I’m glad that I did.
I understand her point but as far as them saying no to two states, what she said is not completely true, they said no because of what the Israeli government wanted the border lines to be which is a big deal. They have said over and over that their issue is with the border lines partly because they want Jerusalem as their capital and Israel said no. I believe she wants peace but how is it that I as an American know better than her what the issue is, and let me be clear before someone call me racist, I don't like either government or Hamas, who I care about is the Israeli and Palestinian people just like I hate the Iranian government but I believe the majority of the Iranian people are good and decent and only want to live in peace but because of the actions of the minority of their people and their government that just like in Israel and the Palestine/Hamas area they end up suffering.
IDK...This felt opportunistic. I think people want to hear the facts and not opposing perspectives. The atrocities are too great for the "lets hear both sides" tactic. Its upsetting.
Mr. Acho, I applaud your willingness to present this subject. However, as an American man of color, you owe to your viewers, most who will not do their own research or hold limited knowledge on this subject, information that is factual. Ms. Tishby provided information that was factually incorrect and you didn't ask meaningful follow up questions nor correct her in real time. This will cause your viewers to come away from this interview with false notions. You've allowed yourself & this platform to further propel false propaganda. Whenever I view people who approach any subject with false information, I try to make a determination on who they are. Are they crazy or stupid? Your guest is neither. However, I can't determine if she's deceitful, misinformed or willfully ignorant. Please do not allow any of your guests to provide bad information, you owe that to your viewers.
Thank you for putting a face to the issue that CIVILIANS are facing...there is a bigger context that is hard to capture but this is a start. Nothing nothing nothing at all justifies the horrific attacks that Hamas perpertrated
My issue is that Palestinians live in anger since 1947/8 the Nakba...they live under oppression...open air prison... She is biased and speak to one side of the issue...made the situation sound easy for the Palestinians. Israelis live in fear of the sporadic attacks from non Jews militants... I wish she would compare the daily life of a Palestinians vs an Israelis, a day without any rockets or attacks... This day for a Palestinians consists of daily indignities and shame by the Israeli security forces.... This Israeli and Palestinians conflict will not end until Palestinians are first treated with respect by the Israelis...then the discussions about occupation and governance can take place.... Israel should not fear Hamas or any other militants- they should fear the anger and hate which fuel the children of this generation...The fighters in this war did not born today, they are children who have grown since 1967 to hate the treatment by the Israelis... The reverse apply to the Israelis who have grown seeing the rocket attacks, the ideology that Palestinians are lower than them and Zionism. Not until the political and grassroot leaders who support this conflict are removed and those in favor an environment in which Israelis and Palestinians live as equals on the land....then there will be no peace
You are so brutally unequipped to have this conversation. To allow someone to spread misinformation at such a critical juncture is irresponsible and harmful.
Oh my God, what a beautiful woman both in spirit and character 🌟 I received generous and human help during my stay in Canada precisely from the Jewish people, my friends, my brothers. Protect this people with your lives from the persecution of demonic structures.
She’s telling the truth. Dk what you’re talking about. Israel offered peace many times (one of them was giving Gaza to Palestinians in the first place). Palestinian leadership is crooked and ruining the lives of their people.
6th Netanyahu cabinet Netanyahu's coalition partners rejected the two-state solution. In February 2023, Netanyahu said he would be willing to grant Palestinians autonomy but not sovereignty, and in any future deal Israel would maintain full security control of the West Bank.
There you are. Thank you for taking the time to put this in what I can only attempt to say is a digestible way to explain what is actually going on in Gaza. This is just so mind-blowing. We have centers, monuments dedicated to the remembrance of the Holocaust, GLOBALLY. We have them all over the world to remind us how many Jewish people, their allies, their innocent families were brutally wiped away from something WE WEREN'T EVEN THERE FOR, timewise. And it just kills me that most of the Americans around me just move along or don't invest a blink into understanding what's going on. Noa's passion is palpable and infectious, as it should be. The anger that wells up, the frustration that heaves out of her; she's been through this conversation so so so many times, and it shows. Thank you, Noa, for doing one more time. I appreciate you.
Where you at on the Indigenous Mexicans getting parts of their country taken away? Their language, their culture, their religion... it was all striped away from them. Ukraine used to be part of Russia and Russia is just taking it back.@@anti-classist
You act like other people never endured genocide and still in so many ways do. So her point about Bernie Sanders marched for civil rights with blacks once didn't register that 2 communities were under fire and murdered for seeking equality? Keep in mind Native Americans received treaties, Japanese/Asians received reparations for interment camps. Jewish were brought to a place where they can rebuild. Heck even some pacific islanders got paid for when they dropped the bomb. But the black community can't even get a anti crime hate bill? We know reparations is being ignored..What happened was horrific this past week. But we cannot rule out that even Israel isn't 100% innocent. Heck the US government isnt 100% innocent. They brought german scientists here , many of them Nazis versus sending them to trial. From my understanding there were Jewish scientists that worked side by side with these scientists and all players were hefty compensated. Dont believe me? Look up OPERATION PAPERCLIP. We need to be angry with our leaders versus one another. The accountability is lacking tremendously.
Hold on. You know what we're not going to do? Use the Holocaust as a way to justify israels 75 years long settler colonialism of the Palestinian people. We aren't going to justify the expelling of 750 000 Palestinians from their homeland in 1948 by saying bEcAuSe oF tHe Holocaust. We aren't going to use the Holocaust to justify the destroying of Palestinian homes, of Palestinian towns and villages To justify the annexing of the West Bank, the trying of children in military courts, the kidnapping of Palestinian children from their beds, the murdering of Palestinian children on their way to school, to mosque, in a graveyard, in their garden, on the way to the shop, on the roof of their house, inside their house, standing at a checkpoint, throwing a stone, riding their bike, sitting in their parents car. We aren't going to use the Holocaust as a way to justify the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from East Jerusalem and the West Bank. We aren't going to use the Holocaust to justify the genocidal call 'death to all arabs' or the call to remove Huwara in its entirety or the 16 year seige of Gaza by land, sea and air. We aren't going to use the Holocaust as a way to justify the forcible transfer of 1.1 million Palestinians from Northern Gaza, the stopping of electricity, food and water as well as life saving medical aid to 2.2 million Palestinians. We aren't going to use the Holocaust to justify the murder of 3,000 Palestinian children.
This women is a Israeli sympathizer. Go back in history and watch some old videos of the early settler I am talking about late 19th century about 1880's. Settler would routinely say to the Palestinians "one day you will be my slave". Judaism is not the same as Zionism. Zionism is a occupying political movement that pretty much wants complete control of the entire area. She is right in one respect the PA leadership which is supposed to represent the Palestinians is corrupt to the core and personally enjoy luxurious life style and have rejected offers of a seperate state. But, one reason the offers have been rejected is because Israel offers a moth eaten portion of Palestine as a separate state. Israel needs to accept the UN mandated boundaries that were proposed 70 years ago. Israeli historians have themselves accepted this fact and denounced the Zionists for their strong arm tactics.
This just makes me sick Hamas didnt exist when Palestinians were kicked out in 1948 Its pointless to argue with anything all we want is cease fire right now children are dying !
I wonder if they said no to the two state solution because those offers came after thousands of their villages were destroyed and settlers took over their land and snipers shot children holding rocks? There always was a Palestine. There is less and less of it every year. They aren't doing that to themselves.
It’s absolutely horrific and animalistic what Hamas did in Israel on Oct 7 but what Israel is doing in Gaza is genocide, it’s not my word but it’s many international communities are saying that. She wanted to show that she is neutral, but she is ignoring so much reality that it is mine boggling.
You might wanna check the population records of the Gaza strip before uttering such nonsense about genocide. It also appears as though you're going through the motions with the condemnation, and don't really have an understanding of what happened. Sometimes evil is just that... no buts are needed. No historical context of any kind is needed when one side committed the most vile, despicable and unimaginable slaughtering, raping and mutilation of men. women, children, babies and elderly! No injustice in the world could drive normative people to do such disgusting things to other beings! Every loss of life is horrible!! however, you can't compare civilian deaths during war as collateral damage (in Hamas's case, they deliberately embed themselves in civilian areas in order to maximize fatalities in Israeli counter strikes and garner global sympathy), to Nazi-like crimes against humanity done on civilians in territory that is not even disputed by the International community! This is not a war about a land. This is about a fanatical Islamist Ideology targeting the "infidels". If you think this will end with Israel think again...
@@eyaled9367 Well, again, what Hamas did is pure evil. Now, if you think collective punishment to a group of fellow human beings are OK then I can assure that there will be no peace on earth. Our lives are short, but our deeds and words are everlasting. I have done a lot of research before I made my comments. I don’t take any side, all I hope for peace on earth. At the end of the day, we are all human beings regardless color, religion, or ethnic background and we are just passing a very short time on this planet earth. As long as we divide ourselves as us versus them, we will not have peace on Earth.
@@eyaled9367oppressed people would do anything to their oppressors when they manage to escape as long as those oppressors are insisting to keep the oppression forever. That is not to justify what happened but it is what happens in the real world, apparently not in the Israeli world though. To say "we don't need to see the context" is to demonize Palestinians as animals who just want to k*ll as your government officials claim all the time.
Even your opening is biased… comparing Israeli govt to Hamas. Israel is never the offense - they have had to defend themselves against terrorists since it’s creation. Jewish people are a loving warm group of people who have always been persecuted. Harm towards any people is never right. But the history of this situation should be told to the world accurately.
Hamas is pronounced guilty & guilty & guilty here without any questioning. I personally saw Israeli soldiers destroying the abandoned Gaza settlements, but there was no questioning here of her statements ... not a single second of challenging her "facts". She wasn't challenged here at all about anything. The occupation forces destroyed the whole Gaza Airport (built & paid for by the European Union). The standing unchallenged prejudice here is deafening. This is supposed to be uncomfortable conversations ???
Love ya Acho, but you left a lot of questions unanswered from the people who are not knowledgeable. This should of been a convo been a Palestinian and Jew.
She thinks she is the victim and the Palestinians are her oppressors whereas it's the other way around. This is what Palestinians had to put up with for close to 80 years.
Noa is simply wrong about the occupation. Israel does occupy Gaza. All flights over Gaza, boats coming to Gazan shores, and vehicles driving into Gaza need permission from Israel first. Israel has before arrested international peace activists who've tried to reach Gaza by sea. Israel also doesn't recognize Gaza as a state of its own nor part of a larger Palestinian state, which means Israel doesn't have a regular border crossing between it and Gaza, it only allows people in or out if they have the Israeli military approval. Even the Egyptian border with Gaza is only open when Israel coordinates its opening with Egypt, which as we've seen in the past few weeks, when aid trucks arrived at the border carrying aid to Gaza, Israel bombed near the border because the humanitarian aid trucks arrived at the border without Israel having had coordinated with Egypt first (but they'll still tell you they don't control the Gaza-Egypt borders)
Why does Palestine say no to a two state solution? The Peel Commission gave Israel most of the coastline and the countries most fertile land including in the Jezreel Valley and Galilee (20%) while the Palestinians were given the poorest parts of the land including the Negav Desert and the Arava valley as well as the hill country of the west bank and the Gaza strip (80%) in addition the zionist formed a labor union called the histadrut that banned Palestinians from working on land they had lived and worked on for generations and expelled them from their homes on that land. Histadrut believed in exclusiveist Hebrew labor, meaning they would not employ Palestinian people, and eventually, it destroyed Palestinian encomony. For example, when the jews arrived, the palenstines had 12 thriving soap factories, and now only two remain, and they are struggling for survival. Its all talking points. Israel does not occupy Gaza they just completely control it 🙄
Just see the map of 1940s, to today, and then see if you can continue saying, "The State of Israel is not opressive". This is a one sided view point and was hoping for more in this channel
💯💯💯💯 they paint themselves as victims all the time and who is the boogie man? You can even criticize them without being shadow banned or banned outright. Imagine a people that was oppressed now becoming the oppressor. They took the land from the Palestinians and refuse to acknowledge it.
I do have to apologize where I was being more critical to the channel. Pt 2, of a Palestinian America is up. Channel did a great job on keeping the question the same.
@@Chilifer34 that's fair but you do notice the temperament of one guest versus the other? It's not even just to gain sympathy but just factor in the entitlement to a land that was gifted to them through third parties and not acknowledging that they came to that land as refugees. That is the frustrating part.
@Eddybo22 Sure noticed the differences between both speakers. And in part, think that is where the majority of my frustration was. The biggest take away from both interviews was "how has this impacted you", With one responding, "it impacted me 2 weeks ago..." vs "It impacted me 3 yrs ago...". That spoke so loudly to me.
Did this woman ask the question: Why was Israel created in the first place? After WW2 when the Nazis were defeated, why didnt the Jews stay in their respective European countries where they were born and raised? How many Jews actually know who their real enemies are?
This was such an iresponsibly conducted interview. Noa Tishby spewed colonial settler propaganda, and Emmanuel Acho just sat there and thanked her for it. Having a large platform comes with a certain set of responsibilities. This is an irresponsible use of your platform and does more harm than you realize. I've been a subscriber since day one, but it's becoming clear that this channel is more about boosting your public profile and building some level of influence rather than creating a safe and brave space for vulnerable and necessary dialogue. I'm legitimately saddened by seeing you give Noa Tishby a platform for Zionist propaganda.
She is so full of it! Israel is not in Gaza?? What planet does she live on?? Most prople are not pro Israel or pro Palestine. We are pro right against wrong. I understand the hate judes have been going through and I sympathise with them. Everyone deserves to be treated with respect and dignity as a human being. What is shocking is how Israelians in palestine treats palestinians as people who has been going through it themselves. Nomore hiding behind antisemitism, when Israel is wrong calling it out doesn’t mean you are antisemite! Stop ocupation stop imprisonement of palestinians kids, stop slaughting innocent ppl and stop the victim card anytime anyone points out your wrongdoing. Peace to both Israel and Palestine.
She is good. She practiced her expressions. Her use of words shows how bias she is. If she cares about human rights, she would care about Israel's government treatment of Palestinians
In all of world history, I dont think there is a group of people who relishes the opportunity to be a victim more. And if you dare question them about anything or attempt to hold them accountable, you get called anti******* as a shaming tactic to deter you.
