The list is fake, as you have relabeled them. And prior events do not detract from the fact that the current war was caused by the events on the 7th October.
Yeah, right, not as if IDF haven't failed in providing evidence of their "hospital/tunnel" claims in the past 🙄 .. this time, the hospitals must actually have fighers in there 😅
I wonder how much of these report actually had facts.. I don't have much confidence when the BBC have had to apologise over 10 times for their misreporting of this conflict. Love how she said images by the IDF "allegedly" showed gunfire, then the next clip shown says "this was the aftermath." How does she know this was the aftermath of the IDF taking over Al shifa hospital? The Unicef guy says this is something Palestinians have never seen before with this humanitarian problem. He forgot that this "famine" word has been used for over a decade with the "blockade." Piss poor journalism from a supposedly impartial organisation. Ofcom please investigate this organisation!!
Why would the Israelis raid this hospital if there weren't Hamas fighters in it? The narrative that they're doing it because they're unkind just doesn't wash with me.
this is normal. it does not mean khamas are in there lol, american citizens own guns, so why can't gazans who live in literally war zones being raided by israel not defend themselves and the hospital?
The hospital was first raided (and many others too) on 15 November 2023 and very little evidence was produced -> see the wiki summary entitled 'Al-Shifa Hospital siege'. I am sure the doctor would love to be shown the evidence - however, since the forces of destruction and denial have so far very little inclination to provide evidence that can be independently verified, including a penchant for not allowing journalists into Gaza (after all, who wants their war crimes, crimes against humanity, ethnic cleansing, and plausibly genocide documented), the unfortunate killings of 140 plus local journalists, and a tendency to censor any negative news about the war (how many of their own soldiers were killed, wounded, how many will remain handicapped for the rest of their lives?), it is quite unlikely that the idf would invite Dr Maynard to provide evidence.
Israel bombed the third oldest church in the world (Gaza Greek Orthodox Church), civilian convoys, Rafah crossing, refugee camps etc. Israel used white phosphorus in civilian areas.
A British doctors who worked at Al Shifa said there were locations they were not supposed to go. And when he asked some colleagues why, they said "you know why".
Because she was having a laugh with her colleagues and the camera cut to her a second earlier than she expected? And that shows exactly what about the BBC?
Mr. Elder: how is it that you don't condescend to mention THE THING that would absolutely end the war: the UNCONDITIONAL RELEASE OF THE HOSTAGES BY HAMAS????????
@@nejlaalagic7165 "genocide" is what happened to jews during WW2, they were exterminated by the millions in gas chambers. after that a country was created for them to live in. hamas took power by force less than 20 years ago, and their terror started then. the blockade on gaza is with support from Egypt, it started in 2007.
Prof. Maynard: There is actual video showing two rooms IN SHIFA HOSPITAL designated for HAMAS in which weaponry was found, including grenades, explosive shells, mortars, bullets and cash money which was used for terror funds. So your statement is BLATANTLY FALSE in this regard.
Seriously? You see a report about children literally starving because a armed force is preventing anything coming in, and that's what you take away? Literally what do you get. In a month the number or dead will double from starvation. This is no different than starving in Nazi death camps. Literally even when they get food in they will need to have them eat slowly or they will literally die. What do you get.
finishing off Faiq Al Mabhouh was good to secure the safety of Israeli communities and to immunize the international humanitarian aid! thank you Israel 🇮🇱
I don't belive in any "god" - esp not the "Judao-Christian-Islamic" god. But Someone (thing) may have created the universe as we understand it. I could make a good scientific argument about everything else you said. There is not enough room to do so HERE, & I don't really CARE whatever you have to say - just spitting out simple statements only to try to upset someone. Have a good day!!
@@shannonschaerer1010 why don’t you actually tag who you’re talking to so people actually know kid. And whoever you’re replying to, you must care if you’re typing out a full paragraph. And by god I’m obviously talking about the man made god that ignorant Muslims, Christian’s, Jews etc somehow buy into. I have a bit more respect for deists, like you’re talking about, as they don’t buy into any specific god. But even then, if you think about it as much as I have you would know that the idea of a god doesn’t make any sense.
@@jamesa2482 Sorry, IDK why that reply got messed up, but at least you understood that it was meant for you. You made 3 statements, & I disagree with them. I think it's silly to believe in "God," but no one knows for SURE that life leading to us HUMANS wasn't created by some OTHER being. No one knows 100% if our "souls" or conciseness goes on after physical death. No free will. Many may agree, but many wouldn't, & I don't. I MEANT to make sure that went to you, but IDK what happened, & I hope it doesn't happen THIS time!! I have my ideas, & it would take to long to explain them HERE. It just seemed funny to me that you said those 3 things like you know 100% FORSURE! I like to keep my mind open that anything is possible. Maybe not "God" but POSSIBLY some other intelligence created our universe, INCLUDING ourselves. We DON'T KNOW!! That was the point of what I said. But yes, to believe in the "Judao-Christian-Islamic" God in this time (2024) seems RIDICULOUS to me as well!! I hope this one goes thru to you, 2482!! Peace!!
@@shannonschaerer1010 those statements I said are 100% true. Let’s go through them. And I’m not saying this because I want those statements to be true, I personally wish free will did exist, for a multiple reasons but that’s another convo. 1. Free will. Any neuroscientist whether it be Robert sopalsky or Sam Harris etc will tell you the same thing. The more you study the brain you realise we don’t have free will. This was always obvious to me, but I guess the illusion is so powerful the vast majority of people think we have it. (Just a side note, this alone disproves the Abrahamic religions/gods because surely if the bible or Quran were written by the creator or the universe, it would mention this fact, but obviously religions were created by people who couldn’t see past this illusion due to ignorance). Our actions and thoughts depend MASSIVELY on our genetics. This is obvious. An easier way of thinking about it is looking at dogs. If a pit bull is raised right, there is still a much higher chance it’ll bite you than a golden retriever. If you believe in free will you have to say that’s a coincidence, but it’s obviously because of genetics. And the other reason outside of genetics are outside factors like upbringing, any damage to the brain, prior experiences that you did not choose to have etc etc. Damn I cba to disprove god or a soul within this comment as it’ll be long as hell but if you respond then I probably will in another comment.
Under the geneva convention, All peoples living under military occupation have the lawful right to use ANY AND ALL FORCE against the occupiers . It's that simple . There's no terrorists in palestine ..... ( unless you're also gonna refer to the french resistance in occupied France during ww2 as " terrorists " I hope this clarifies the situation.
@@imanuelletbe5381 I won't... I'm only into telling people the truth . The people of palestine are EXACTLY the same as the french resistance fighters in occupied France during ww2 ANYTHING they inflict upon the occupiers is fully legal and lawful under international law and the geneva convention . And ,conversely ,anything the occupiers inflict upon the palestinians is by definition a war crime and a crime against humanity. F A C T .
Israel funded Hamas in the hope that by sustaining Hamas in Gaza it would widen the split between Gaza and the West Bank, undermine the Palestinian Authority (PA) and make the prospect of a unified Palestinian position impossible. "Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas … This is part of our strategy - to isolate the Palestinians in Gaza from the Palestinians in the West Bank.” March 2019, Netanyahu told his Likud colleagues the above. In the 1980s Israel played a significant role in the creation and promotion of Hamas as a counter to weaken Fatah/PLO. Retired IDF Brigadier General Yitzhak Segev who was the Israeli military governor of Gaza in the early 1980s confessed that the government gave him a budget to engage fringe Palestinian Islamists. Segev reportedly stated his part in financially aiding the Palestinian Islamist movement, viewing it as a "counterweight" to the secularist Palestine Liberation Organization and the Fatah party, led by Yasser Arafat (who himself referred to Hamas as "a creature of Israel.") "The Israeli government gave me a budget," Segev confessed to a New York Times reporter, "and the military government gives to the mosques." In a startling revelation, Avner Cohen, a former Israeli official who worked in religious affairs in Gaza for over twenty years, told the Wall Street Journal, "Hamas, to my great regret, is Israel's creation." Sources: Hansard Israel/Gaza Volume 833: debated on Tuesday 24 October 2023 For years, Netanyahu propped up Hamas. Now it’s blown up in our faces - The premier’s policy of treating the terror group as a partner, at the expense of Abbas and Palestinian statehood, has resulted in wounds that will take Israel years to heal from By TAL SCHNEIDER Times of Israel 8 October 2023, 3:58 pm Netanyahu: Money to Hamas part of strategy to keep Palestinians divided Jerusalem Post 12 March 2019 Warning: Benjamin Netanyahu is walking right into Hamas’s trap Jonathan Freedland They crave a rage-filled reaction from Israel’s prime minister. Wise heads should temper his response - and then be rid of him The Guardian Fri 20 Oct 2023 17.05 BST Could Israel dump Netanyahu in the middle of a war? Can Netanyahu survive Hamas’s attack on Israel? Israelis are increasingly aware of government failures that enabled Hamas’s attack, but that may not be enough to bring the Israeli prime minister down. Neve Gordon is Professor of International Law at Queen Mary University of London. Published On 11 Oct 2023 11 Oct 2023 Al Jazeera Another Concept Implodes: Israel Can’t Be Managed by a Criminal Defendant A direct line runs between the judicial overhaul and the Gaza war. Netanyahu should emulate Begin and go, but we can’t expect introspection from him. The future inquiry must invrstigate how much time the prime minister devoted to the reform - and how much listening to the military leadership Gidi Weitz Oct 9, 2023 Haaretz Israelis aren’t rallying around their prime minister. They’re rallying against him. Oct 31, 2023, 11:20am EDT Vox.com Gaza, Hamas And The Odd Role Of Netanyahu’s Likud - OpEd October 23, 2023 Eurasiareview
@@567307 your comment just shows how ignorant you are hahahahah I almost feel bad for you If you had any intellectual ability you'd know the war started years ago by the zionist agenda 🤮🤮🤮🤮
@@567307There is SO MUCH MORE to it than just THAT!! Such a limited idea. Sorry that you didn't enjoy History Class, if you HAD, you would likely have a better understanding of all that happened BEFORE Oct 7th.
@alieukamara1625 Israel has been the ancestral homeland for four thousand years. Palestine was not named after Moslems that lived in Israel. Islam was created by the prophet Mohammed and began in Mecca not Israel.
Many Muslims were part of the British army, and so directly involved with the founding of Israel. There is soon to be a monument of recognition made in london. How do you like that?
@user-mi7pv4bg8w The bbc employed Hamas as news reporters. No media in Gaza so they all report Hamas media. Doctors working in Gaza are working for Hamas health ministry and let’s not forget UNWRA and the United Nationd also working for Hamas and complicit. Terroism infiltration and psychological warfare . Brainwash the public.
Actually, a lot of Isrealis belive that Palistians are LESS than human (certainly NOT equal to THEM). It has been an idea reinforced by all Isreali governments leading to now. Illegal Jewish settlements taking land & property from Palistians has been going on for decades, & no one has ever been charged for such things, although they are "illegal"!! The state has always seen it as a way to get rid of Palistians, & so no one has ever been charged. The Isreali people that haven't done anything still turn a blind eye to the way Palistians are treated. It's not "Genocide" if the ones they kill & maim are "less" than human, seems to be the situation. Isreal is still in control of what enters Gaza, & it's not NEARLY enough to keep those HUMANS alive!! Give it 1 more month, & 1 in 10 people will have died from bombs or hunger, OR be maimed in a life changing way. A quarter million people - GONE!! That many more, wounded in BAD WAY! Horrible images of death that will NEVER go away. Lots of nations have humanitarian aid ready to go - it's Netanyahu that won't let it come IN!! Only enough to "tease" the Palistians into a false hope. This is wrong, & when it DOES end, Isreal will be on the line for what they have done. But the WORLD needs to be looked at for letting this horror continue THIS LONG!! HOMO SAPIANS - The DUMBEST Species EVER!!
Whose fault is this that there are 600,000 children in Rafah? Of the international community that supplies free food and free aid for as many people as there are. So there is a huge incentive to give birth. We should not be supplying free food or aid unless during acute disaster situations. We should not waste our taxpayers money on someone else's kids.
Former Israeli Chief of Staff Moshe Ya'alon admitted his country's responsibility for the killing of 100 people during the distribution of humanitarian aid in the northern Gaza Strip, according to statements reported by the Hebrew newspaper Maariv. The newspaper quoted Ya’alon as saying, “Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prefers to remain in power, and returning hostages is not a priority for him,” noting that “the threat to enter Rafah is a hoax. Ya’alon asked: “If we needed to enter, why did you not enter?” Why did we demobilize the reserve units? The former Israeli chief of staff confirmed that officials within the government are demanding that hostages be sacrificed in exchange for occupying the Gaza Strip, expelling the Palestinians, and settling Jews there. تاه
@@Clara-ke2wjThere is SO MUCH MORE to it than just that. I'm guessing you don't enjoy your 9th grade History Class. Give it a few more yrs, it gets more interesting (if you find such things interesting).
Sad turn for humanity....we'll never learn....even if this ends, we still have to deal with: ...China/Taiwan, Ukraine war, Haiti war famine , Sudan famine genocide, over 200 schoolchildren abducted, Ethiopia famine, N. Korea, Iran, Syria, Qatar senior Hamas living in luxury, reeducation centers in China, Russia threatens nuclear war..etc.,etc., etc.
I wonder if with this the palestinian learns they must abandon gaza forever, because the children, elder and pregnant woman dont have future in gaza strip anynore, so why to stay there, why to keep suffering in a land that just brought them death, misery, starvation , etc 💀💀🤬🇸🇩🤬
Thats a very poor argument to displace people. Should the ukrainians pack their bags and move to poland coz living in ukraine has brought them suffering and misery?
@realpolitics527 It’s not a poor argument at all because that’s exactly what was inflicted in Europe and middle eastern countries with Jewish diaspora. Russia and Poland inflicted pogroms and many other countries wiped out the Jews or expelled them long before WW11
@@567307 Disgusting. Obviously an observation of a less than mature person. Pitty. Palestinians just want to be free from Israeli oppression, subjugation, discrimination and the pure EVIL that lasts for more than 75 years which the Israelis have inflicted on these people. The long for freedom often pushes people to extreme measures. But, once you have children of your own you may understand how ignorant your remark really is. I wish you may one day experience the tragedy that has befallen these people. You certainly need it.
“Been that way for 30 years.” - U.S. Justice Department on the lack of Human Rights in Oklahoma County Jail, 2020 “Makes me feel human again after this place.” - Oklahoma City Art Museum review after life in the local shelters, 2024 “It is said that no one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.” - Nelson Mandela 🥂🥂
HEY HAVE U NOTICED HOW THE SAME THINGS THAT MAKE U LAUGH IS THE SAME THING THAT CAN MAKE U CRY&THE SOUND, SOUNDS THE SAME, THAT'S HOW GOD FEELS ABOUT THE WAR-AUROA, ASK.
