Not that we know of. There are people that feel that it is "the right thing to do", while others feel like "it's their right" to live there, but there is no organization that tells the public that it is a Jew's duty to live there.
They believe that they should claim the promised land and take the ancient sites where they claim it Holy. Such as, Bethlehem, Jerusalem, and many more. Bethlehem is the birth place of Jesus and Jerusalem was where Jesus was crucified. These both signify a great meaning to all religions which believes in Jesus. As a Christian, we believe in studying these and visiting these than capturing it since in Christianity, we're strict with the commandments and it embraces us by heart.
@@ethanbuno-an8002 Difference between you (and others that believe in Jesus) and Jews is, that Jews are indigenous to Israel, you are not. Just because you think that particular Jew is special doesn't mean you have claim to the land. If I start believing in a famous Sioux who propagates an off-shoot or sect of their believe system, can I lay claim on Dakota?
What country do you live in? I can guarantee that wherever you lived belonged to someone else 🙃 use common sense. Reflect on your self before judging others
Kareem Abumaizer Reread your comment and tell me your political affiliation wasn’t stated. You’re right, YOUR opinion NOT facts. By the way, fun fact, conservatives were the ones that made the “snowflake” term... so your attempt to insult me is irrelevant
Kareem Abumaizer Oh believe me I am a very reasonable person, it’s just hard being reasonable with liberals. Most ignorant people I have ever met, my bad that I assumed you political party, I simply did so because talking to a liberal 98% of the time is like talking to a rock. But yes I would like to have a civilized reasonable discussion with you on these issues.
At 8:25: what does the 5% refer to exactly? You mention later that Area C is 60% of the West Bank, so how could settlements be only 5% of the West Bank? Counting the city limits of settlements only will obviously reduce the 60%, but not to 5% I'd think
These comments really set back the Palestinian cause (if that is what you care about)-You link anti-Semitism to anti-Zionism and delegitimize the pro-Palestinian cause.
History, archaeology, genealogy and the Bible prove Jews originated in Judaea. They were exiled a number of times or they would have never left. They have a right to return, in the face of European/global anti semitism or not.
@@YishaiBarr As if it would be possible for those settlers to do what they do without the IDF muscle behind them. As an American I contribute more to pay for the IDF than an Israeli. www.mintpressnews.com/us-taxpayers-paid-more-to-israeli-defense-budget-than-israelis/37299/?fbclid=IwAR05zgcN6iLZjtlbyPWL-8fEIQt3AmiYEyi-ru9rdUKaLanAoJUAql9ZM_c
4 года назад
Corey Smith He will dismiss whatever you say no matter how much proof you post here. It’s what he does every day. He’s pathological liar.
@@coreysmith8489 It's an investment on the US part. Israel gave licenses of various Israeli made weapons to the US and is restricted to buying American products. No, your money is not going into this.
West Bank??????? Where can you find this place? Or where is the address of this West Bank??????? Aber Wo???? In Eretz Yisroel there’s only JUDEA and Samaria. West Bank I really believe this place can be found in ‘ LA LA LAND ‘ for sure!!!!!! Shalom Aleichem shalom
Wait? So it wasn’t Palestinians/Arabs who won the 6 Day war? But yet, there’s international law dictating what lands to belongs to who? If the Palestinians/Arabs had won the 6 day war, would the same international law dictate to them that Israelis have a right to be there? Also, it’s a actually quite humorous to read comments about Israel being funded by foreign aid when the Palestinian refugees and their descendants have received more aid from the UN than any other refugee group in world history, and continue receiving that funding today.
The Six Day War was fought against Egypt, Jordan, and Syria, wasn't it? Not against Palestinian Arabs (correct me if I'm mistaken there). But your question remains good - what if Israel had lost and the three Arab nations that fought against it had won? The answer is there wouldn't be any discussion of Israelis right to live there because there would no longer be any such thing as an Israeli. Nasser explicitly stated that his aim was to wipe Israel off the face of the map. To him, that's what winning would have looked like.
The entire opposition to Israel by Arabs and Palestinians has been- Law for thee, none for me. 😂😂😂😂😂😂 like they know each and every rule and sub rule of international law and conventions and blah blah when Israel does something but when they do something its “resistance” and “gods will” and everything else other than law.
Israel have the right to exist...if a country like Pakistan can be formed on the basis of religion and recognized by most of countries...why not Israel then... Only democracy in the middle east.... Greetings from India..
4 года назад
Forming a state on land already inhabited is immoral. Annexation ie land theft is unethical. No matter who or whatever race they are or religion they practice. It’s IMMORAL.
@ so can you say the same for Pakistan too??? Is creation of Pakistan moral and ethical.... Mention the reason too...i am waiting for your reply... let's make it a healthy debate....
@ It was inhabited by the people who founded it, the Jews. Arabs immigrated during the 20th century. Look at the Ottoman census records, there were hardly any people in the area.
4 года назад
Corey Smith I wouldn’t say it’s their right but definitely their stubborn will fomented by a supremacist attitude of deserving it as “God’s Chosen” master race.
I'm not Jewish I'm Christian, but I like how they move and operate and establish themselves...it's inspiring....I think more Christians should move like this
@Meme Memeson yeah, I am disappointed in the Israeli reaction (lack of). Must be all the Russian Jews living there. That doesn't mean you're gaining any more land for another one of Putin's palaces.... even a Crimean villa on the beach is looking less and less likely... the most you'll get is whatever toilets and women's lingerie you've already stolen from Ukraine.
@Meme Memeson you're not going to break the Alemanes with a little cold weather..... Hungarians? Maybe.... remember, half of Germany lived under the Russian thumb. They know Ruzzians are backward rapists and thieves.... I guess Hungarians have a short memory. Germans are as industrious as the Jews, their homes will be heated this winter...
I think, by the law of two states, all should be able to set themselves everywhere within the frontiers stablished by God through His messenger Moses (mentioned by the tradition and the muslim cult) or they should leave for their own place of origin because even by history, through the records of the people of His messenger that didn't lie about their deeds, the nation of Israel was invaded and slaved unfairly.
You can't colonize the land you're native to or steal the land you bought lawfully. Palestinians did just that by invading Israel and attempting genocide and ethnic cleansing on Jewish people in 1948 who have been living on the land for hundreds of years.
Yishai Barr You’re not “native” to a land because you’re 3% racially tied to a people who lived there over 2,000 years ago. That’s irrational. Some of my ancestors were Finnish. Should I demand property in Finland? *FAIL.*
@ Well, the land was bought and legally owned. Jewish people were there continuously. So your argument about genetics and history, which is false from the beginning is also irrelevant. I'm actually 90+% Jewish, judging by close relatives who have done tests who are almost 100%, so you can shut up.
It’s not based on biblical. It’s based on historical. Jews are ethnoreligious group originated in Judaea 3,500-4000 years ago. Proven by history, archaeology, genealogy and the Bible.
Not about the video, but I've seen the way you respond nicely to obvious hate comments. I just think it's a waste of time considering they'll just use it against you. I got into a useless flame war with someone just now in what I thought would be a mature debate, but they were just calling me names and stuff when they had nothing left to bring up.
4 года назад
Yishai Barr Ohhhhh booooh hoo... Go tell your daddy. “Somebody criticized my comments on RU-vid!”😭
We try to engage in conversation where possible. That's the only path to understanding each other. We don't think it's always wise to engage with obvious trolls. There isn't much "they can use against us" since we are being respectful and only responding to their concerns.
What country do you live in? I can guarantee that wherever you lived belonged to someone else 🙃 use common sense. Reflect on your self before judging others
@@kevinacosta8194 does this give me the right to come take your home, because the land you currently live on once belonged to someone else. Its all part of natural/historic order of things right, and you have to use common sense and not judge me if I do this to you :P
Muhamad Ihssan the flaw in my logic? If you can’t defend your land, then that’s your problem. If Israelis were able to over take their current land and have held it for 70+ years... my statement was that you can come take my home, but my you won’t like it
It's time to reclaim all the land belong to Israel ad God almighty had promised to your forefather as an inhertance for ever , liberate it from Muslim a very long time occupation.. His mighty right hand will help you restoring it if you acknowledge and seek his help. Give glory to and spread to the world how God love you and because of you the world is blessed too
If settlers take Bethlehem! What about Christian Palestinians !!! The land is not for a religious group it’s for all You Christians in the west are ignorant and it’s so sad to see the level of inhumanity in these comments Settlers have no right to steal land how do you expect piece while those settlers are killing Arabs and sterling the land
And [recall] when We took the covenant from the Children of Israel, [enjoining upon them], "Do not worship except Allah ; and to parents do good and to relatives, orphans, and the needy. And speak to people good [words] and establish solat (prayer) and give zakah (alms)." Then you turned away, except a few of you, and you were refusing. And [recall] when We took your covenant, [saying], "Do not shed each other's blood or evict one another from your homes." Then you acknowledged [this] while you were witnessing. Then, you are those [same ones who are] killing one another and evicting a party of your people from their homes, cooperating against them in sin and aggression. And if they come to you as captives, you ransom them, although their eviction was forbidden to you. So do you believe in part of the Scripture and disbelieve in part? Then what is the recompense for those who do that among you except disgrace in worldly life; and on the Day of Resurrection they will be sent back to the severest of punishment. And Allah is not unaware of what you do. Those are the ones who have bought the life of this world [in exchange] for the Hereafter, so the punishment will not be lightened for them, nor will they be aided. And We did certainly give Moses the Torah and followed up after him with messengers. And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary, clear proofs and supported him with the ruh-ul-Kudus (Spirit of the Holy / Angel Gabriel). But is it [not] that every time a messenger came to you, [O Children of Israel], with what your souls did not desire, you were arrogant? And a party [of messengers] you denied and another party you killed. (Al-Quran 2:83-87) If you do good, you do good for yourselves; and if you do evil, [you do it] to yourselves (Al-Quran 17:7) O Children of Israel, remember My favor which I have bestowed upon you and fulfill My covenant [upon you] that I will fulfill your covenant [from Me], and be afraid of [only] Me. And believe in what I have sent down (the Quran) confirming that which is [already] with you (the Torah), and be not the first to disbelieve in it. And do not exchange My signs for a small price, and fear [only] Me (God). (Al-Quran 2:41-42)
@@SidewaysBurnouts many Arab Christians in Israel are joining the IDF. I question the remaining that seem to side with Hamas and the PA. Must be out of fear for their lives....
The US should have left Israeli with the land and leave them alone for them to deal with the Muslim countries, not us. It's THEIR fight NOT OURS!!! We're losing some of our resources to their stupid war. Enough is enough.
@@eddyhernandez8874 I know and what good would it do if we continue to stay with them and deal with more casualty. Not to mention we should have never gave Israel a nuclear weapon if that mean we cannot break ties from them easily.
What US resources are being lost in Israel? Do you know how much the imports of US goods into Israel is today? Do you not realize that the US "aid" is credits for US military goods that pay US salaries and taxes?
6:24 Except for the fact that the settlers have made the state of Israel far less secure. Something like October 7 wouldn't have happened if the IDF hadn't focused so much on stationing their soldiers in the West Bank to man checkpoints around Israeli settlements and harass Palestinians living there. Israel would be a much more safe and secure country if the settlements had never been built and a two-state solution might have been possible.
Please tell what was done? Israel, like about 6-8 other countries was created out of former Ottoman lands. Nobody has issues about any of these other countries, some created illegally. Only Israel is ever a problem??
You do realise that there has never been a Palestinian state. I do think settlers are wrong. But there is no Palestinian state and never has been. The UN drafted it but the areas were taken over by Jordan and Egypt
Nah, they remove racist and rude comments only. Some of your misinformation can stay.
4 года назад
Yishai Barr Yeah, keep supporting censorship, you Arab-hating bigot.
4 года назад
Yishai Barr You’re the one who’s racist against Arabs. You’re just deflecting by reflecting your supremacist ideas and attitude onto others. I simply call out bigots when I see them.
Hi Mia, RU-vid automatically blocks comments that include swears and other potentially problematic comments. We only actively remove comments that contain hate speech. We haven't removed a single comment of yours (even the ones where you are acting in a very uncool way, calling people names - nice job getting around the "dipship" filter, and otherwise acting in ways that would get you banned in other places.) we actually APPROVED a comment of yours that we disagreed with and included some profanity since it was part of a discussion you were having. Unpacked Team
4 года назад
Unpacked As I’ve seen a few “disappear” we’ll have to agree to disagree. And since Unpacked’s agenda is to justify genocide... I’d say that’s pretty “uncool” in itself. I’ll be waiting for your team to cover John Pollard, the Lavon Affair and the Deir Yassin massacre. Should be a lot of fun! 🥳🎉
