Im completely fine if Edie feels more comfortable as a girl. If so, they slay girlie. But I have a terrible feeling that the parents are forcing this behavior onto their child.
My sister's children like to constantly put each other down. My native has internalized this, & seems to have a very low self esteem, when it comes to her looks. But she's so beautiful. But she doesn't believe it. When I lived with them for a few years, during her preteen years, I showered her with compliments on how beautiful she is... like a princess. She actually started to wear dresses again. I was cracking her shell. But after I moved out, she reverted. Now, @ 18, she posts a lot of glamour shots on social media, where she's all made up like this. But unlike Edie, my niece never smiles in any of her pix. I try to encourage her. But to no avail. My only hope for her, is that while she may not be showing any outward signs, that maybe I'm @ least planting some seeds in her mind, that may grow into future outward smiles. It makes me sad to see her looking so unhappy. Edie is beautiful in her makeup. But like my niece, I think she looks best without it. I subscribe to the opinion that if 1 wears makeup, it should highlight your natural beauty. Therefore, makeup should never be visible. It should never look like you're wearing makeup. Well... that's my opinion. Eddie is beautiful, either way.
@@Tomejatokoupil there is no evidence that her father is controlling her decision but there also is no eveidence that he isn’t. I am just not jumping to conclusions or assumptions. If there is evidence please enlighten me.
@@Tomejatokoupil that isn’t abuse. Do you even know what abuse is. Cold showers are good for you. Also it is pretty easy to tell if you don’t feel right in your body. She probably felt uncomfortable in her own body and told her parents, her parents then educated her about transgender and non-binary and other options and she chose what she felt was right for her. And also if later in life she chooses she wants to be a man again or dress differently or be non-binary she hasn’t had any surgery so it is much easier. But if she still feels comfortable in a female body that she can choose to have transitioning surgery. Just respect people’s decision with THEIR LIVES not YOURS!
being a girl isn’t just about wearing makeup and pink or having barbie’s and dresses, it’s honestly so much more that they don’t even realize. Edit 1- omg ty sm for all the likes and replies!!🫶🏻🫶🏻 Edit 2- 2.3K Likes?! I didn’t expect this to blow up💀 Edit 3- For one thank you for all the likes and agreement! For two I’d like to clarify that yes they go off of stereotypes and yes if the child in question really does want to be trans then that’s their life not mine. On the other hand though this child seems very unhappy in the videos and i think it’s a bit of a forced act! I would also like to come on here and say that I AM NOT TRANSPHOBIC!! I have a lot of family in that area and i’m completely supportive of it but only when it is wanted and not forced!❤️ Edit 4- 3.4K LIKES?! i didn’t expect this to blow up!!🩷🩷 Edit 5- Thank you all again for this likes on this! But also for the ppl who are disagreeing and the people who are bringing up things that don’t have to do with this, If you don’t like the comment scroll past it. there’s no reason for y’all to hate and reply to this. just scroll past.
@@Thespottedclaws You are delusional, a kid cannot be trans, it isn't right. They dom't know when they are kids and parents shouldn't be able to do that to kids. Now if she was an adult, I wouldn't care
Being a girl isnt about makeup and dresses and long hair and sparkles no ones hating on edie there hating on the dad. Not trying to start a war and I know that edie likes that and I support that im just saying its not all about that and yes the dad is a supporting dad for letting edie wear what he/she wants but I'm just saying that like no ones truly hating one edie including me this comment was just me stating that a girl isnt about sparkles but if that's what you like then that's fine there is nothing wrong with that. But it's not just about that and he/she won't truly feel pains of a woman but I support the dads choices of letting he/she explore there personality or there character. And if they see this comment it wasn't meant to be taken negatively and if they saw it as negative im sorry. And I'm not saying edie isnt pretty cause she is and maybe I should be worrying about there toxic boy mum but this is not her channel. But im also saying that alot of his videos are about edie and there is nothing wrong with that and im sorry for it seeming like im hating on edie and Jonathan but that was not my intention. Im sorry 👇
And also the dad is supporting his kid and letting him/her wear dresses, put on makeup and sparkles so some people need to follow the oldest rule in the book if you don’t have something nice to say don’t say it unless it’s defending you or someone else
@@Madiecakes0817no she’s just saying what is true there are some times where I want to comment something but it’s already there or I comment something and I see that someone else wrote that comment so it’s not stealing it’s just two great minds thinking alike ❤❤❤
Fr, I have NO problem with trans kids or anyone from the lgbtq+ community for that matter, I would just wait until they are at least maybe 13 because this is a very huge difference for this child to make at such a young age. (Keep in mind idk how old this kid is)
My daughter is not allowed to wear full face makeup at 13, not even at home just for fun. It would set a bad example for her, as if her first goal growing up had to be picture perfect as a woman with tons of makeup on. And also, teens or pree teens, let alone kids, mocking adults is a huge no for me
@@Bianca_Di_Angelo.i’m 14 and still don’t wear it lol! besides for like the occasional formal occasion where I put on some lip gloss and mascara, but I totally agree w you!
He just put out a video saying he now identifies as "NON BINARY" so we now know that his son is his victim of "Munchausen By Proxy" and it is time for CPS to remove the children from these mentally ill parents before it's too late!
I agree - but from today the law has been passed from allowing children to appear on here - this is disgusting!! And the mother is even worse for allowing this to happen! What else do they do to their brats??? They would do anything to pay for their 4 brats to go to private schooling - they go to Reigate private school - oh yes they show that and am contacting the Headmaster to discuss this - my grandson is going there shortly and do not wish for him to mix with a boy dressed in girls clothes with a full face of makeup. The Mother is worse for allowing this to happen - still she sleeps with a gay man - claiming to be a best friend - yea right!!
@@lydiaidylk at least they should know nothing nowadays every child says stuff like I’m trans I’m gay im lesbian and at their age I didn’t know what any of this stuff meant
God, she's just trying on something okay? Everyone hates the dad, but stop saying that. Almost every girl uses makeup so I guess they are not real Girls either?
@brodie1053 If you don't know that, then I can't tell you. If you don't see anything wrong with this, then I think perhaps you also need to be locked up.
At what point does this become exploitation? I think about all of the challenges that come with being a kid and figuring yourself out, and I cannot imagine being forced to do it in front of the whole world. I fully support the transgender community. I see nothing wrong with allowing kids to be themselves and express who they are. But it doesn’t need to be in front of millions of people. Edie’s gender identity has turned into the “brand” of your social media and your child is 9 years old. This isn’t about raising awareness or fighting stigma, it’s about profit. I hope that at some point you are able to really listen to some of the comments that you are mischaracterizing as hate or negativity and realize that they come from people who are just concerned. You know your child best, but from the outside looking in, there seems to be a dangerous disregard for your children’s privacy.
Self proclaimed 'allies' such as yourself do breath too much. The 'support', so called, isn't asked for, nor is it percieved as benefiting anyone but you as you gather for yourself social points worth nothing. The politicians demand eradication. Family demands death of association. Religion demands excommunication. While you proudly declare stealth as the only way to what?! This world props filth and sex as just another advertisement tool, but a child is admonished for trying to be free to enjoy life. I'm quite certain this child is far happier than the married, angry trolls.
So, if they apply lipstick with dangerous chemicals, their skin will immediately absorb it, and the effects might become evident in the future. Simply put, applying makeup products on the skin of your kids will make them vulnerable to toxic material
At this point we can all see that the dad needs to be in the video. It honestly hurts me to know that those parents are getting most of there income from someone that is MY age. And how they pressure her to where loads of makeup,and completely neglect there youngest son.
If you are also 7-10 years old, then you are saying this beautiful little girl can’t be who she wants to be because she is to young- and if she didn’t want to wear makeup, then she doesn’t have to, where is the proof that her parents are forcing her to do anything? And consider this- the parents are getting most of their income from this girl, she wants and likes to do RU-vid, once she is older all this *income* will most likely be in a trust fund for when she wants to go to college or wants to put it toward a career and such and such.
Yes, but sometimes trans people need to wear those things to feel themselves. In a world constantly trying to make us feel not like ourselves, sometimes dressing like our gender in a extreme and steortypical way can help us feel better.
😂😂😂😂😂 i thought mine lived in a tree right outside our classroom 😂😂😂😂 i used to ask him how it is up there, he used to seamlessly lie to me that he was happy up there 😭😭😭😭😭
Then you better get off this app and go take care of your own children. Anyone reciting this message on RU-vid is obviously not spending time on their own children, or they are pretending to know what parenting is about and childless.
What gives me hope is that one day we will get to see Eduardo’s side of the story as an adult. I hope he is able to recover from the manipulation he’s been put through. The parents will see the repercussions of this abuse one day when their son cuts them out of his life. 💔
She will talk about looking at the comment sections and feeling scared and sad due to the vicious anti-trans psycho adults, who stalked a little girls account. She will talk about how having supportive parents was what made her world not only feel less terrifying, due the stalker adults making vicious comments towards a child, but who allowed her to do things that were supportive, to be supportive…as most little girls don’t get to play dress up with expensive makeup palates (hell, I’d love to have nice makeup). She will talk about what it was like to have adults abusing her constantly. What it’s like to have online bullies that are adults, who can find her and take her…as some have threatened to do or said it would be better if a Christian family took her and forced her to be a boy. How seeing people bully her parents online was difficult as a child, because they were taking the abuse for her.
@@___LC___ Nope, my comment was 100% directed at the PARENTS. This innocent little boy has done absolutely nothing wrong. ♥️ My comment meant that I am praying for the day that Eduardo finally gets to tell HIS truth in the future. I hope he writes a book or some sort of tell-all about what it was like being manipulated into thinking he was a girl simply for like traditionally “feminine” things. How the HECK can a child decide they are transgender. That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard in my life. Let the boy wear dresses. Let the boy play with makeup. Let the boy play make believe princesses. But for the love of God, exploiting him into thinking he is a GIRL? And then using social media to pretend you’re raising awareness but actually just making major $$$ off an innocent child who’s brain is so far from being developed enough to rationalize the repercussions of all of “his” (his parents) decisions?
Heavy makeup and early sexualization (of boys, girls, trans, it does not matter) do not help children’s self image. She may be a girl at heart, that is fine, but she is still a child.
Such major emotional damage and confusion going on. I feel terrible for this little boy 😢 may God reveal the truth to him and break the deep delusion 🙏
Being a girl does NOT have to do with makeup or barbies or dresses, its way more than that. You need to teach your child to learn that being a girl is not having to include all the things that make you look like a girl, its what she want to do with herself, you cant just force "her" to be a girl just because you want her to be.. let her expierience her childhood and then she can start to think about all this. 😢😔
@@fawn_is_onlinethere was no such thing as non-binary until the last several years. You are just a person an own individual. You don’t need to pretend you don’t have anatomy consistent with male or female organs.
Yea plus it isn't cool to be a girl man, like I'm a girl and alot of boys are bullying me, especially my dad keeps saying that girls are only b00bs and butts, which this makes me think I'm trans so it isn't cool to be a girl
I’m sorry? I’m 14 turning 15 and I don’t wear makeup… putting makeup on a what- 7-8 year old?! TAHTS NOT OK . Even if they are TRANS : edit: I’m not being rude , pls stop commenting on my comment , I just think not everything is about dresses and makeup to be a woman
i do drag and im 13. its not abuse. its everyones choice, just because you dont want to do it doesnt mean she cant do it. its their decision not yours.
Don't call yourself pansexual that's literally just bi-erasure. Aka, bisexuals inventing a new label to avoid the stigma of being bisexual. Also gender fluid is a dumb concept. So you sometimes feel more masculine and other times feel more feminine? Literally everybody feels like that. You don't need a special label.
@@Bubbley4ever Okay but he didn't do his own makeup. They hired someone and told the person they hired to do adult style sexy makeup on this baby. That's why it's fucked up I guess. Same thing for toddlers in tiaras. It would be different if the child was expressing themselves; that is not what putting your child into drag or hiring a makeup artist to paint them as a sexy adult is doing however.
@@MyLovleyLife51 he turned his 7 year old son trans and (maybe) did or is planning to do irreversible damage to his sons body when their older (or has already done it)
@@brooklynn491 My little son (wich brains are not fully grown yet, like every other kid) wants to be a lion. Should i make an appointment for his surgery? Or should i wait a little until his brains are fully developed?
If your kid (eg a boy) likes makeup because it’s colourful and fun to try or playing with dolls, it doesn’t mean they’re trans. It’s a normal part of growing up. All of this is about the parents making it about themselves and wanting to seem “trendy”
Ye def not everyone maybe some people but why are saying that and deciding for everyone that they are supporting like I’m not homo but I personally would never do it my self but don’t tell people they have to support just cuz you do
IF THAT KID THINKS THAT BEING TRANS IS JUST PUTTING ON MAKE UP AND WEARING GIRL CLOTHES AND WEARING MAKE UP I SWEAR. All children deserves parents but not every parent deserves a child
No? What about all the homeless parents poor parents and have you ever imagained what a spoiled brat could be to a Homeless mom & dad well no and thats exactly why! So if u dont know anything keep ur mouth shut
at that age, I was crying because the plane was heading in the same direction I was going [edit] I don’t wanna be that person but like TYSM FOR THE LIKES ❤️❤️
@Jonathan Miller I wouldn't doubt it OR his dad will push the issue even MORE just for the clicks, views and $$$. Unfortunately the little boy will grow up and will read the comments and see these videos his dear daddy and mommy made money off of him for YEARS AND YEARS at HIS expense!! So very sad what social media has brought the truth out of many people's false personas
⚠️NOT HATE ⚠️ Honestly being a girl is much more difficult than just makeup and long hair and even our body’s or even dresses . And their is girls that dress in boys clothing but they are still considered women boys are different in many ways Again ⚠️NOT HATE ⚠️ IM JUST TELLING MY OPINION
SHE can be whatever she wants to be. her dad is doing an amazing job raising her I mean being there for her while going through that? Ik what it feels like to be trans. It’s not wrong so just stop with these transphobic comments
At that age i was climbing on the trees, pretending it’s my house and cooking with sand and stones with my friends. The sadness in that kid’s eyes … i hope you don’t give him hormones.
@@kalindamcnulty-uw4yh oh is it you gonna tell that to all the youtube family channels if she is underaged then why is her dad filming her?? So he can get more followers and likes..
