www.tiktok.com/@purple_entertain/video/7073093511234522394?is_from_webapp=1&sender_device=pc&web_id7034079506588599809 Please support our Kpop Cover group
Edit : hey bitches, its better you write or opinion than you judge my opinion! This comment personally in my opinion! I like IVE but in general Aespa is on another level. When we talk about the vocals, all members can sing very well and they have amazing stage presence. And i love how the way aespa make their own concept " oh..this is aespa"
*This is clearly a bias content, The content that was presented from Aespa clearly didn't give them justice. There are radio guestings and shows they appeared on where they showcased their vocal and dance talent but these are from general contents people can easily search on youtube. Plus, Winter should have been on the Vocal line. I'm glad people in the comments still talked about aespa more.*
@@wigsnatched9074 lol I ain’t even an Aespa stan and I know Ningning and Winter are next level vocalists compared to Yujin and Liz ( no offense to fellow Dives lol ) not to mention they came from SM
Yes they should include her in vocals and dance, because Winter besides being a great singer dances really well and I thought she was the main dancer and vocalist of the group lol
@@kennyyau9549 It can't be but if SM wanted it it would be Main Vocal and Main dancer like Seulgi is in Red Velvet, and I think Winter and Ningning are the main vocals in aespa, and Karina and Winter the visuals and main dancers lol it's perfect
As a Korean, I'll rate them both. Aespa is a group with strong vocals. Ning-Ning's Korean pronunciation was very accurate and her skills were recognized, so she pushed out many Korean vocalists and became the main vocalist. Winter is a vocal that Koreans like very much because of his good tone. Giselle speaks English very well and her rap is also recognized. Karina is a bit lacking as a main dancer, but she does a good job as a team leader and is the most popular member because of her good looks. Ive is a visual group, and it is true that their overall skills are somewhat inferior to Aespa.
I've seen K-pop girls dance, but not as captivating and satisfying as Karina. Unless you're a dancer yourself and you can judge the techniques, it's totally fine..
Aespa is just as much of a visual group if not more, IMO its no contest.. aespa is more skilled in every aspect.. being from SM helps b/c they debut some of the most talented/skilled idols
@@mahaabdul2264 its unavoidable that SM will always has the the best bcs they can choose the best out of their trainees and i believe they have alot and they trained them for years.
vocal: ive is good to but Winter and Ningning are very strong vocals for a 4-member group. Even aespa's main dancer could easily have been the lead-main in another group, and the main rapper could easily have been a lead vocalist. rap: I already knew how strong a rapper Giselle is, but after collaborating with NCT, I saw it more clearly. The songwriter is a rapper who can rap in 3 languages. dance:I think the two groups are in balance at this. visual: both groups are beautiful but I still think Karina has an unrealistic look.
both groups are talented & pretty but aespa is on a whole new level of slay like they have their own main positions but can steal the other members’ positions anytime they want to lol & theyre all really humble & respectful ahhhh
I like IVE but AESPA has better vocals, dancers and visuals. I am not saying that IVE is bad, I just think that AESPA is better in everything, it is a very complete and very strong group. ✨🛐
If you say about aespa, aespa is ANOTHER LEVEL for their generation. They just have 1 year experience from their debut, but the Achievements is so incredible. Now when they comeback, they alway fight with they sunbae in digital and phyisical album.
BIG BIG NO 😂, Giselle doesn't have a swag Voice for being a good rapper u dumb. When Giselle doing her rap, it's sounds like just talking with a louder voice , not swag or sounds like her best rapper 😂
Unquestionably AESPA. Talent, Visual, plus their attitude. They’re so kind and funny. Like the person you want to be friends coz you feel safe and warm.
VOCAL - Aespa,ningning and minjeong vocals is top tier. DANCE - Both, I like both. RAP - Rei is good but I like Giselle rapping style more VISUAL - Both, they are all beautiful in their own way.
TBH here…. IVE is still new and young for comparison aespa is officially the true leader of 4th gen and members like Karina and Winter are the first top 5 brand ranking reputation alongside Blackpink!
@@yourfuture5307 thank god someone saod it im not a dive but idk how aespa has better stage presence than ive considering the fact that yunjin, wonyoung, liz, and gaeul became viral for the strong stage presence, charisma and expressions even in syncronization and dancing i think ive is better i just give vocals and rap to aespa
@@yourfuture5307 says who? You stan a girl grouo who makes exaggerate facial expressions and always acts cute let's be for real, you call that stage presence?
@@inception6657 your comparing more weird honey. Blackpink with Aespa? How many year apart they are? Aespa and IVE in the same 4th generation. It means that you can compare them
@@cahyaninghendrivaluvi2989 Dear Ive is new to the industry than Aespa. They just debuted like two months ago.They released two tracks ( Eleven and Take it) while Aespa has more than 4 tracks and debuted in 2020. Though you have a point that they are both 4th gen but the comparison is too quick and would definitely be biased which would definitely result in unfair comparison. Don't you think?
Vocal: Aespa (sm water) Rap: Aespa. Giselle ate her rap part in 'zoo'. Btw, rei is also good. Dance: Aespa Stage presence: Aespa Visual: both, but aespa's visuals are always the topics of knetz, especially Karina- often trended in Korea. But Ive is also good, they need more time for improvement. However, hoping that starship will treat the ive members equally.
sorry I think for visual Wonyoung is always trending too, she's mostly praised despite of her very young age her visuals is mesmerising and most Korean people were said to be that they're having a plastic surgery just to have that eyes like Wonyoung. So so far for VISUAL Both Wonyoung and Karina are on my top tier list.
This is so unfair. A 1 yr old gg vs a week old gg. My reasons why aespa is a top tier group for me. 1. Their songs aren't generic 2. Their concept is unique 3. They are humble and respectful 4. All members are all-rounder 5. Their individuality is on the next level 6. A group with so much charisma 7. Their songs are all bops 8. Can harmonize 9. A group that can switch positions although they don't have fixed position 10. All are stan attractor I know that Ive has some of the things I mentioned above but not all or not as solid as aespa.
Aespa is better and excellent in every aspect ive have long way to became like aespa which they won't be but in rap there is Karina and giselle also winter not gonna lie ningning said she can rap so aespa has 4 rappers and don't let me mention vocal cuz aespa has 4 main vocalist and for dance it is winter Karina ningning and I've and there is giselle the queens said she will improve her dance so let the queen rest and for visual ningning Karina winter and giselle are visuals in conclusion AESPA is on next level so
Dont even dare comparing them, just in vocals aespa is a top tier. Just Winter is named You Youngjin's vocal daughter what more if you add Ningning the 2nd Bada no chance at all. Theyre both good ballad and rnb
Vocal-Ningning Rap-Giselle Dance-Karina Visual-Karina(I also like Wonyoung but Karina visual is on the Next Level) No hate but IVE aren't even a year old and I think some members aren't ready to debut. Love aespa
Dari segi rap, aespa : giselle another level sih. Bukan soal kecepatannya tp pelafalannya bener bener jelas persis kek sunbae nya yaitu mark. Klo pas rap pelafalannya bener bener jelas dan itu jadi ciri khas mereka sih 🤩🤩 no salty guys
The fact that both of their main rappers are just japanese keeps me loving both groups same as treasure 🥰 but let's admit it aespa is on another level and they have their own uniqueness and style as a girl group
Main vocal: aespa Lead vocal: aespa Main rapper: aespa Lead rapper: aespa Main dancer: aespa Lead dancer: aespa Visual: aespa Popularity: aespa There is no comparison, aespa always will win against ive
Vocal: Aespa. I mean Ning Ning and Winter are so good. Ive has Yujin and Liz, but they're on Karina's level, maybe a little above, but can't be compared to Winter and Ning Ning. Dance: Aespa. Rap: Aespa Visual: I've Stage presence: Aespa In IVE My Favorite is Yujin, She's the ace of Ive, and in Aespa Ning Ning, i love her voice and cute personality.
Vocally, none of Ive can support while giselle can shallow support. I mean u put Karina on Ive and She'll be Maim Vocal girlie supported A4, and Bb4 in her good times.
@@sayhaiwithchae nah stage presence is good only waekness is facial expression. Their fancams show they have great stage presence just lacking in facial expression.
Ive-their main vocalist Liz is good. Nice tone. Others are average. Yujin is perhaps slightly better than others after Liz. As for the overall-stage performance/vocal/dance, Aespa is much better. In my opinion, Ive is nice to look at and good (not bad) but definitely not top tier. Lastly..this is out of topic but in my opinion, Stayc is perhaps better than Ive vocally. Sometimes its not fair that other gg who are better did not gain much popularity as deserved. Perhaps because knet focus more on visual?
@@rose-nn3wj You're right about Winter, during Black Mamba she had great stage presence. Then during next level and savage just looked bored. I have noticed that in recent perfomances she's progressively getting better so maybe she has been seeing that people are noticing her lack of expression. Giselle is overall better and stage presence.
Not even joking but you can easily put Karina, and Giselle as main vocalist. Like they might not have the vocal range as a Winter or Ningning, but they can sing damn well. aespa is just better in all categories right now, not even a competition. What’s scary is that I don’t think aespa has reached it’s full potential yet. Don’t get me wrong IVE will be a strong group, just don’t rank them to a group that already achieved so much within a year.
![IVE VS AESPA [ VOCAL, DANCE, RAP, VISUAL & MORE'] 2021-2022](/img/logo.svg){kind=logo}
