This film DESERVES an Oscar more than any other film I’ve seen in the past year. The actor who played Numa was PHENOMENAL. He deserves so many accolades for his performance. Just incredible.
You're right. And the fact that the Academy finally did not give them any Oscars it reveals the political and economic interests of the American Film Industry to protect "the exclusivity" of the US in making "the best" blockbusters.
He's hilarious! And so smart. Nando also, I listened to both of them in different interviews and I can see why they are the ones to sacrifice themselves and go on that 10 day hike.
I'm so happy Tom is giving support to J, I strongly believe The impossible had a lot of weight for him to be selected as the new Spiderman, the performance he gave in that movie was magnificent. I love seeing Enzo here in this panel ❤️ he really did a beautiful job, such a special person to have portrayed. I wish him the best in his future career. Such a gem of an actor. 👏🏻
For me the most hard thing to learn in this movie was about the Strauch cousins their kindness and strength for rationing and don’t let anybody know how they did it and keeping it all inside in their hearts in order to don’t make anyone feeling guilty 😢 breaks my heart they were just kids trying to survive 😞💔 the Strauch deserve all our respect and compassion
I read Strauch book. It's a beautiful book about his spiritual feelings over the whole thing. It not much about in great detail what happen up there, there other books with other survivors that explain things in detail. It's more about his inner thoughts about his home and the love and closeness he had with his family
I saw this film in theaters and it was one of the most visceral films I've ever seen. I appreciate it even more hearing that Roberto loves the film so much and feels its true to what they experienced.
You should watch it in the original spanish, It will give a smidge of realism since they corrected all type of spanish mannerisms in language by the real survivors and entonation and acting goes to next level. As a spanish guy I prefer to watch english films in the original voice and it's always so much more immersive!
Agreed! The screening I went to was in Spanish with english subtitles. Watching films in their original languages definitely feels more genuine. @@-u-i3419
@@alejomiranda95 cierto, aún así los supervivientes ayudaron a corregir manerismos no solo por la diferente época sino por la localidad de los chicos de manera mas exacta. No es lo mismo un cordobés que un porteño, igual pasa con Uruguay, igual que con la clase social, ya que la mayoria en el avión serían de clase ''alta'' por decirlo de alguna manera, lo dijeron ellos mismos en la entrevista, para así darle ese toque de realismo al 150%!
@@-u-i3419el cuidado que tuvieron con los detalles, y además la disposición de los sobrevivientes a cooperar y la de los actores a aprender, teniendo en cuenta que muchos de ellos no habían actuado nunca o solo habían hecho teatro, es impresionante
J.A. Bayona sharing the thought behind the scene where Numa goes back to the fuselage gave me goosebumps. He is an incredible storyteller. He deserves an Oscar for his directing. This film has a hold on me, it's been 3 days since I've watched it and I can't let it go.
I love how Bayona speaks about how this film gives the survivors the opportunity to give back to those who died. The reciprocity of the dead giving their bodies so the survivors can survive and those survivors using this film to bring the dead back to life. How beautiful. This film is truly a love story above all else. ❤️
Tom is a great interviewer! His experience as an actor and as a producer/filmmaker himself makes him a knowledgeable, empathetic conduit for info about this project.
I just spent this afternoon with him at his clinic, and he is so down to earth, grounded, humble, compassionate and witty... his sense of humor is great! One of the greatest guys you could know or meet.
I’d have loved to see Nando Parra in here. What a real life hero. And I’m obsessed with Numa, Enzo did an amazing job as him. Kudos to all. I’m never complaining about being hungry for a few hours or having to endure the cold again
@teasecremeactually, they were starving and freezing while shooting the movie. Enzo was only eating a can of tuna and a tangerine a day in order to get not only the look but the experience as well. He spoke about it in many interviews; they also shot the movie in a place where it was freezing cold and it was as close as it could be from the climate conditions in The Andes, cause they didn't use a green screen, Bayona was looking to recreate the experience. He wanted the actors to feel what the survivors felt. It was very important for him to get as close as they could to the real story to really capture the struggle and pain.
SOTW was one of the best films ive watched. It kind of had that Titanic vibe but the whole society of the snow element just got to me. Made me shed quite a few tears. Honestly, I think it goes beyond Titanic for me. Choosing Numa as the narrator was the money shot of this movie. My new number 1 film where i can watch many times SOTW. 👌🏾
Soy de Argentina. Supe de ésta historia cuando era chiquita, pero me pareció tan fuerte que no me animé a saber más sobre lo que pasó. Ahora de grande veo ésta película y realmente te deja sin palabras... Tan bien hecha, actuada.... todo 🥺 impresionante, sobretodo por el hecho de que esté en español 👏🏻
Sabes que soy una enferma cinéfila que elijo ver las pelis en idioma original, es decir el 90 % en inglés. Y escuchar el relato desde nuestra lengua materna, con el acento, tan cercano, tan natural, tan propio; me pegó una cachetada de realidad que desde que comienza la peli, la emoción me envuelve. La película es una obra maestra, el casting es maravilloso, y las interpretaciones son estupendas, y se me hace tan "necesario" recordarle a la humanidad a través de historias basadas en hechos reales, que los límites están en la mente! También soy argentina, te entiendo perfectamente, recién después de esta peli, me he atrevido a escuchar a los sobrevivientes. Seguramente me haré con el libro y lo leeré.
No solo está en español, es español uruguayo, bo! 😂🤣😂 Los actores argentinos, que son mayoría en la película, tuvieron que aprender el tono y los modismos uruguayos para sus diálogos, aunque obviamente no debió haber sido muy difícil para ellos siendo tan parecidas las formas de hablar de ambos países.
The more you watch this film, the more you realise the genius of it. Absolutely every aspect was well thought out. It became my favourite film very quickly!
@@TD.Lap.igual aunque es lindo que tenga oportunidades en su idioma, la verdad es que ahora el inglés es necesario si quieres crecer en la industria, aunque sea así como sofia vergara o derbez que tienen un acento marcado el saber inglés les abrió muchísimas oportunidades
@@cazzzzzzzzz nadie niega eso, pero ojalá trabajaran más con gente en su idioma natal, el español es hablado en tanto territorio por millones de personas, y los doblajes y subtítulos no son un problema, los actores brillan el doble cuando están expresados en su idioma y exigirles un esfuerzo tan grande solo para que los gringos no tengan que leer subtítulos es triste. como dijo bong joon ho, cuando sepan superar la barrera de 2 cm que son los subtítulos van a descubrir cosas maravillosas.
@@kyanight sisisi entiende tu punto e igual me parece ridículo que la gente (gringos) se rehusen a tratar las cosas igual por el idioma, pero yo me refería más por la industria, por que justo o no la verdad es que la industria es en inglés, y los estudios y compañías grandes te lo van a exigir, igual ojalá si empieza a trabajar en proyectos así puede siempre igual tener su idioma y cultura presente, pero pues tiene que ser una mezcla porque el inglés tiene que estar. no se si se entiende es muy temprano acá hahaha
This was an INCREDIBLE movie. Bravo everyone, thank you to Netflix for producing it. I watched it twice back to back and will watch it again. Just phenomenal!
Interesting that they brought up giving the dead a voice. One of the things I couldn't help but notice watching Alive all those years ago is they changed the names of almost all the dead in that movie.
This was exactly what I needed to see after watching the film. I had so many questions about the process that needed answering. Tom was such an excellent interviewer. Kudos to him, and to the entire cast and crew for the grueling work they did to create such a masterpiece of storytelling. Really looking forward to rewatching with all of this context in mind.
Movie of the year. Definitely in my top movies of all time. Y’all remember that feeling after finishing Titanic in the theaters? Needed to take a moment.
I was eager to watch this whole meeting and interview! Thanks for uploading it! Greetings from Uruguay 🇺🇾 Congrats to everyone involved in this production! I watch this movie almost every day.
Esse filme foi algo EXTRAORDINÁRIO. É incrível ver o reconhecumento que anda recebendo internacionalmente, extremamente merecido. Foi um trabalho impressionante de todo o elenco e produção.
I think that the most precious thing in this life is to sacrifice for others. It's something very human that's why Numa is so special and authentic. Of course the human beings have this animal part, but what make us human is our soul and our true nature is being generous and cooperative with others. It's a pity that they think that Numa should have been more animal and had to accept that. Because the point of this character is that he is the only one (as far as I know from the film) who cared about the spiritual implications that's why his behaviour is so human.
He wasn't the only one that cared about the spiritual implications of eating human flesh! For most of them that was a big dilemma and it was depicted, they had several discussions about it, moral, religious and practical implications of choosing to eat or not. Numa couldn't accept that eating was the only real option they had, as Bayona said, he had to understand his animal side that needed to be fed, but did it so late that he was incredible weak and ultimately died. Not sure why you say "the point of this character": Numa died in the movie because that's what happened to the real person, in real life, it wasn't a choice of the director or the script.
The fact that the Academy finally did not give this film any Oscars reveals the political and economic interests of the American Film Industry to protect "their exclusivity" in making "the best" blockbusters. So, the Oscars Academy did not give any award to J. Bayona's film because it threatens that exclusivity: Bayona is a Spanish director who has shot the best blockbuster of the year, with a full cast who speaks Spanish language (and not English as the production companies wanted to imposed on Bayona).
It’s nice to hear from the crew about the background of this movie. I’m glad it involved the survivors and families so closely, they’re so proud of the production. Amazing win for Uruguayan representation ❤
Esta historia me ha apasionado desde que la conocí hace 30 años, siento una enorme atracción por ella ojalá un dia pueda conocer a los sobrevivientes. Tenía miedo de ver la nueva película por que no queria perder esa profunda admiración que siento por todos los sobreviviente pero al fin la ví este fin de semana y he quedado mas atraida que nunca de la historia.
What excellent translator person, she She used the same intensity and emotion that he used in each response. Excelente interview. Vamo Arriba Enzo!!! 👏👏👏👏🙌🙌🙌🙌💫💙☀️
Que orgullosa de J. Bayona por está gran película este viaje de emociones que nos lleva a un lugar del fuselaje del avión. Soy española, de Barcelona y del barrio de Bayona ( la trinitat) . Ojalá te den el Óscar te lo mereces . ....❤❤
Muchas emociones que experiencie durante la película. Escalofríos, angustia, estrés, tristeza, y felicidad. Deberá mente quede admirada de la película y que lejos puede llegar un humano debajo de circunstancias extremas.
Watched this last now . I have not seen a movie that has held my full attention for so long. … I was even yelling at the tv saying HOLLY SHIT!!!!! OMG OMG OMG … ..I never do that … but I did it last night . I was yelling and screaming at the tv !!!!
Me doy cuenta viendo esto y con admiración de que Roberto Canessa no se ha dejado frenar por nada en la vida; habla inglés con una fluidez increíble pese a su edad 😮. Es una persona que no deja de sorprender, muy admirable y carismático. Enzo también me lo parece y me sorprende muy gratamente cada vez que le veo o le escucho, es tan joven y a la vez tiene la cabeza tan en su sitio, las ideas tan claras y es tan sumamente comedido, sabiendo estar en todo momento en el sitio que le corresponde...No sé si otro actor con otra personalidad hubiera podido encarnar a su personaje de esa forma tan personal, ni saber llevar todo lo que la fama repentina acarrea, de la manera tan acertada en que creo que lo está gestionando Enzo.
Me hace tan feliz ver a Roberto ahí, siempre que lo escucho me siento mejor, wao y Tom entrevistando es la primera vez que lo veo desde ese lado. Wao como lloré, voy viendo La Sociedad de la Nieve como 5 veces, es que me encanta, a parte de las cosas horribles que debieron pasar para sobrevivir, para mi es una historia de esperanza, amistad y fe, es que era imposible que sobrevivirán, pero lo hicieron y lucharon contra todo para poder seguir vivos y poder volver a ver a su familia, es que eran jóvenes con toda una vida por delante. Con esto ellos demostraron que nada es imposible, toca luchar y mantener la fe siempre. Por mi parte cada parte de la película me tenía siempre con las ganas de que va a pasar, se me hizo entretenida, a parte es una película basada en una historia real con personas reales que tuvieron que pasar por eso y lo representaron muy bien, uy y sobre todo la escena del choque fue impactante, muy bien hecha, para mi La Sociedad de la Nieve es un 10 👌❤ Wao es extraño ver el contraste de los 2 idiomas
Soy de Argentina y no supe de esta historia hasta que salió la película en Netflix. Me pareció tan maravillosa, la forma en que lo filmaron te hace sentir como si fueras otro más dentro del avión. Los nervios, la frustración, el miedo, la incertidumbre, la pérdida de esperanza y también la pérdida de sus compañeros. Y al final el agradecimiento y alegría al encontrar a alguien que podía salvarlos. Es una montaña rusa de emociones, muy conmovedora. Si no obtiene un Oscar voy a quejarme personalmente 🙌🏼
Roberto tendría que haber dado su perspectiva en cada pregunta. Me encanta Enzo y su actuación, pero no puedo parar de imaginar que estará pensando Roberto, que vivió en verdad esas “escenas”, sin la chance de que alguien gritara “corten” y verse a salvo del frio y del hambre.
When they were talking about how difficult and sad filming those scenes was for the actors and Roberto was just sitting there listening to them and he looked so detached .. i felt so sad for him cause he actually went through the real thing and experienced those losses...
Roberto calling Matias tiny is very cute to me. I’m so glad the actors were able to contact the survivor they played or their families for those who didn’t.
It´s really heartbroken to me when Enzo is talking about "how funny was to film the crash moment", I don´t have any doubts had to be funny), to see Roberto´s face at that moment 21:45 ... The scariest moment of his life (probably) was the funniest moment for the actors.... I´m obsessed with this human drama... Gracias Bayona por traerlo de nuevo al tapete de la vida tan rápida que vivimos ahora.
I agree with you, it was a bit tactless... But I watched both Roberto and Nando talking about the ordeal and both said that the worst was the avalanche that carried them all under the snow. Enzo's worst day was also filming that scene.
Yo creo que uno tiene ser inteligente y consciente de que obviamente es solo una película y Enzo está en lo correcto al responder eso, lógicamente el mundo real es mucho más cruel, pero repito es una película no sean exagerados con su reacción al comentario
Los sobrevivientes son muy honestos contando lo que vivieron y tienen piel gruesa. Ellos han contado su historia miles de veces. Y le pasaron el mando a estos actores que son como familia, ellos mismos lo dijeron.
I first knew about this story 52 years ago, when I read front page of the newspapers in 1972. since then I have read all the books, seen the 3 movies SURVIVE 1976, ALIVE 1993 and Society 2024. So transfixed that I even sing the song- Break it all- (the song at the airport scene) on my youtube channel. Its very real for me as I am similar age to the survivors. 💖💖🌹🌹New Subscriber here ✌✌
The latest "movies" are about rewriting the past, changing color, gender, orientation, and maybe even diet. Hats off on this one for not getting lost in trends, agenda and "the message"! All the effort are put in the right place: show the crude reality, hold nothing back.! Unsurprisingly, feels very, very respectful in such a tragedy. If 2024 starts like this, maybe is hope for great movies, with great characters that feel real. Great Interview/ chat btw!
@@_bella2345 I'm assuming you mean: "why you care so much?" the answer would be: Because I love well done movies, characters, cinematography and directing.
