Jab Sahir Ludhiyanvi Ke Is Gane Par Firaq Gorakhpuri Ne Tanj Kasa | Rafi Lata Hit Song | 

जनाब ,आपकी जानकारी के लिए बता दूं कि साहिर साहब ने अपनी नज़्म किसी फ़िल्म के लिए नहीं लिखी बल्कि काफ़ी पहले लिख दी थी । वे जब भी किसी मुशायरे मे जाते थे ,श्रोता उनसे "ताजमहल" सुनाने की फ़रमाइश करते थे । आख़िरकार उन्होंने इसे 'ग़ज़ल' फ़िल्म के लिए अपनी आवाज़ रिकौर्ड करवा दिया ,ताकि उन्हें हर बार इसे सुनाना न पड़े । नज़्म काफ़ी लंबी है ।फ़िल्म में पूरी नहीं सुनवाई नहीं गई है ।

शकील साहब ने जब लीडर के गीत लिखे तो साहिर की इन्वॉल्वमेंट का सवाल पैदा नहीं होता

javez saheb aapko shayad maloom nhi ye woh thha jab shakil badayuni kuch bimar chal rhe thhe aur sangeet kaar naushad saheb leader, ram aur shayam aur sangharsh jaisi filmo mein music de rhe thhe aur film ke director se ye confirmation liya thha ke in sabhi filmo mein shakil badayuni hi geet likhenge toh phir leader mein sahir ka naam kaise agaya

Bilaa shouba firaq gohrakpuri aik baday shayer thay jinki shayeri bohat hi lajawab hai....

None can match integrity and genius of Sahir His heart protested against atrocities and unfair treatment perpetrated on weak helpless persons lnspite of being a male this humanitarian poet's pen wrote such a heart touching and forceful lines Aurat ne janam diya mardon ko mardon ne use Bazaar diya 3 Maine pee shraab tumne kya piya aadmi ka khoon Itna insaaf pasand and insaniyat se bhra hua hai koi doosra shayar sbhi mard Sahil jaise khyalat apnaye to rapes totally band ho jaayen

Wah sahab wah Firaq sb ne sahir pe ustarah saher ki jaise mor nachte Apne pair dekh ke murjha jata hai.

What a beautiful and logical response from the Late Firaq Sahib. Thanks for uploading, Dear

Muzhe to Leader ka Rafi Sumam ka duet achha laga jo Shakeel Badayuni ne likha hai, Sahir Ludhyanvi ne Apna kalaam bahot 1964 ke bahot pahle likha hai.

दोनों ही गाने फिल्म की सीचवेशन के हीसाब से शायर लोग लीखते है ,कीसी शायरकी या गीत लैखक की कमपेरीझन करना ग़लत हौगा दोनो ही गाने अच्छे है,,गायक की गायकी ओर संगीत कार संगीत रचना गीतको सफ़ल बनाती है,लीहाजा दोनों ही गीत अच्छे हैं

*The great personality of Mohammad Rafi is above Bollywood and also above Dada Saheb Palke Award.* *The voice of Mohammad Rafi is A School of Acting.* *Dilip Kumar became Dilip Kumar only due to the voice of Mohammad Rafi. Without Mohammad Rafi Dilip Kumar was/is nothing.*

kya zamana that tehzeeb aur nazkat ka jab shayar ke bhi mijaz aur usool hua karte they.dono ki ladai mey bhi tehzeeb thi aur fayda aam logo ka jinhe do master piece nazam mili

Aap ks ur kaam shuru rallhoye, ALL THE BEST

Unhone phir likkha jama pe?u mean the 3rd accepted saahir saabz view? I like the fact that Sahir ji was SO principled. Wow. Salute to him.

THANKS LOT FOR FANTASTIC MEMORABLE SONGS WE NEVER THOUGHT ABOUT THE COMPARISION.HAPPY HAPPY DAY.

Baat behad zabardast hei Firaq Gorakhpuri Sahab ki aur lajawab bhi.

پسند تو مجھے ساحر صاحب کا ہی ہے، لیکن فراق صاحب کا طنز کمال لگا۔۔۔۔

Fantastic. Shakeel is af his best,I concur ❤ with Firaq sahib.😅

❤बहुत हसीन वीडियो । हमें तो इन दोनों गीतों के सभी अहम किरदार बेहद पसंद हैं - रफी, साहिर, शकील बदायुंनी और द ग्रेट फिराक।

Criticism chalta tha aur aaj Kiya kahne.. Sahir Saheb... Namaste from PARIS.

Nice & wonderful reply from Furaq Gorakhpuri to Sahir Communist.

TINO SHAYREON KO MERA SALAM

Aap bade achche insaan hai kyonki aap har naam ke saath "ji", "saheb" bolkar aapne Bharitiya Sanskriti ko daarsaata hai. Thank you.

sahir nay yeh geet 1959 mein likha tha aur un kee biaz mein shamil hai . Yeh ghazal mein nay 1960 mein un kee aik kitab mein parhi thee aur mairi fav ghazal thee aur shakeel sahib nay Yeh gana 1968 mein likha thaa.

Both songs are great creations by two illustrious poets. My preference,however ,is Sahir Sahibs song .

Lekin taj mahl amiro se zyada garib hi ise dekhne ki tammna rakhta he ....

Film ki situation k hisaab se Shkil aur Sahir dono ne thik likha dono Shayer bahut Qabil hain

बडे लोगोंका अधिकार अंदाज मिजाज अलग होता है l लेकिन उनके प्रति आदर रखकर कहता हूँ , कि उनके उसूल बर्ताव कभी कभी समझसे परे होते हैं l

Excellent

bhai apni jagah par donon sahi the magar maine saahir saab ke kalaam se istefaada karke usi tarz par ek kalaam likha hai ( main koyi naamcheen aur mashhoor toh hoon nahin magar main apne khayaalaat ko waqtan ba waqt pesh karta hi rehta hoon) -dekhiyega pesh karta hoon us kalaam ka kuch hissa: Ghuroor e taj mahal ne bada sharmaaya hai jab ghareeb momin ne aasthana banaya hai kisi shah ne kisi ke ishq mein banwaaya hai kisi ne ishq mein kharcha apna sarmaaya hai haalaan ke main firaq gorakhpuri saab ka bhi madha raha hoon magar yeh tanz unka koyi maani nahi rakhta tha kyun ke ek mein us shahensha ne apne ishq ki numaayish ki thee aur doosre mein usne apne maalik ki ibaadat karne ke liye logon ko ek jagah faraham kee thee aur in donon mein zameen aasmaan ka farkh hai jo shayad itne bade shayar aur padhe likhe hone ke bawajood na woh samjhe ya farkh kar nahi paaye the- khair woh tha unka khayaal aur yeh hai mera khayaal. agar ab isi tarz pe bolenge toh duniya mein jitne bhi shaandaar masjidein, churches, gurdwaare aur doosri ibaadat gaahein hain aur mandirein hain kya unka hona bhi bejaa batayenge firakh gorakhpuri saab? sochiye phir boliyega.

Dono hi geet behad shandaar hain.

Shavez mian Sahir ne yeh classic nazam "Taj Mahal" kisi filmi gaane ke liye nahin likhi thi. Yeh nazam uski student life mein likhi kitab "Talkhian" mein hai. Talkhian is an absolute classic. Sahir's success in Bollywood somehow damaged his creativeness and he hardly wrote anything of this stature and we had to suffice with, "Reshmi shalwar kurta jaali ka" :)

kaisay kaisay log hamaray jee ko jalanay aa jaatay hain.

Sabir Ludhianwi Jim and Shakeel Badayuniji we’re both great lyricists. I like both of them .

राग ललित का बेहतर उपयोग।

Lider ka gaana behter h...❤

واہ فراق صاحب مرحبہ ساحر صاحب

Sir for ur knowledge.. pakeeza film chand ke upar chalo is written by shahab jafri who was a lecturer in khalsa college delhi university.his real name was s viqar ahmed jafri .But sad he was not given the credit.shahab mahrum was a very talented urdu persian teacher .well known in theatre n radio n all over India. In pakeeza he acted as the molvi too in the nikah of meena n rajkumar.

Nice❤

Tajmahal aur jama masjid do alag baatein hain ! Sahir sahab ne tajmahal par likha , ye unki choise thi ! Unpar jama masjid ka prasang thopna kya sahi tha ?! Khair uss zamane mein kya hua kya nahi hame kya pata Lekin jo bhi ho , Sahir Ludhianvi anokhe the , bakiyon se alag the , ek kamal ki shakhsiyat rakhte the , ismein koi shak nahi ❤❤❤❤❤❤

Chalo dildar chalo Chand ke par chali is the song

nice information sirji

i like shahir ludhiyanvi

Sahir sahab mujhe khoob pasand hain, personally But geetkar toh dono hi acche the

Thinking of sahir ludhyanvi correct

Bahut khub

मुझे तो साहिर का कलाम ही पसंद है।क्या ही बढ़िया तंज है और फिलासफी भी।

ان دونوں گیتوں میں شکیل صاحب کا لکھا ہوا گیت زیادہ قابل تعریف ہے ۔۔۔۔ گانے کے بول بلکل سوٹ کرتے ہیں ۔۔۔۔ واقعی تاج محل ہے ہی اتنا خوبصورت کہ پوری دنیا سے لوگ اس کو دیکھنے آتے ہیں ۔۔۔۔ اور اس شہنشاہ نے اپنی چہیتی بیوی کی یاد میں ایک ایسا خوبصورت محل بنوایا جو واقعی محبت کی نشانی اور مثال ہے ۔۔۔۔۔ ویڈیو اچھی لگی اور آپ کا شکریہ شاہ ویز بھائی ۔۔۔۔

Sahir Ludhiayani was a great poet of the Kissans-Mazdoors, Women and the poor people of society. He was not a slave of capitalism and feudalism. He believed in economic equatlity.*

Beautyfull

Great info. Thank you so much Sir..

Bahot shandar knowledge di aapne

फिराक गोरखपुरी साहब,शकील बदायूंनी साब और साहिर साब तीनों भारत के मुकुट के हीरे थे,हैं और रहेंगे

Good 👍 1:39

Retro Shavez मुझे पहली दफ़ा आपकी जानकारी पे थोड़ा श़क है । इसकी 2-3 वजूहात हैं । पहली वजह तो ये कि साहिर लुधियानवी साहिब ने ये नज़्म 1944 में ही लिख दी थी और ये उनकी शायरी की पहली किताब *तल्ख़ियां* ( 1945 )में छप चुकी थी तब उनकी उम्र सिर्फ 24 साल थी । दूसरी बात साहिर साहिब ने कभी भी नौशाद साहब के साथ काम नहीं किया नौशाद साहब के सबसे पसंदीदा गीतकार शक़ील बदायुनी ही थे । उनके बिना नौशाद साहब किसी और को गीत लिखने को नहीं कह सकते । साहिर साहिब एक खुद्दार तबीयत के मालिक थे इसीलिए फिल्म प्यासा के बाद जब एस . डी. बर्मन जी इख़त्लाफ़ात ( اختلافات ) हो गए थे उसके बाद उन्होंने इक्कठे कोई फिल्म नहीं की । यही बात ओ. पी. नैय्यर जी से हुई फिल्म नया दौर के बाद दोनों ने कभी एक साथ काम नहीं किया । तीसरी वजह आपने फ़िराक़ गोरखपुरी जी का ज़िक्र किया आपको पता होगा फ़िराक़ गोरखपुरी जी का असली नाम रघूपति सहाये था यानी वो हिन्दू थे फ़िराक़ गोरखपुरी उनका तख़ल्लस था । मुझे नहीं लगता उन्होंने साहिर लुधियानवी साहिब से जामा मस्जिद पे कुछ लिखने को कहा हो । बाकी आप बेहतर जानते हैं ।

Firaq Gorakhpuri was indeed a brilliant mind with extra ordinary sharp thinking.Communist ideology did not fit everywhere.That is not in anyway saying that Sahir was any less poet than Firak.Tho I am nobody to pass any judgement on these stalwarts of Urdu.

Best hai shavez

Nice

Saahir ki tulna me firaq 0. the

❤❤❤❤ sir aap mujhe mere walid ke yaad dilate hai

Shakil sahib was Naushad sahib’s very talented song writer, this duo produced many hit songs and ghazals, I don’t think Naushad requested Sahir to write a song about Taj Mahal.

फिल्म लीडर का रफी जी एवं लता जी शकील बदायूं जी का गीत

good video

Naushad Aur Sahir kacombintion tha hi nahi balki nausha aur shakil badayoni eksaath kaam kartey the

Very nice video thanks

2 gane bhi

Sahir ludhiyanvi

Itna’ ‘ ji ‘ aur sahab na istemal karen to accha lagega

Waiseto dono shaer bahuthi acche the. Shakil saheb ne ese filmke hisabse bahut accha likha Tha. Lekin Sahir sahebne ye nazm pahelesehi likhi thi aur na hi film keliye likhi thi.

Sahir Naushad ka geetkar tha hi nahin uska geetkar hamesha yad jyadatar Shakil badayuni hi Raha hai leader ke sare geet Shakil ke thai Bhala ek geet vo Sahir se kyon likhvata

इक शहंशाह गाने में राग "ललित" है।

Rafi singing Badauni song is better. Nazm words written by Sahir is better

Lata Ya Suman?

Shahvez Sir, AI ke aa jane ke baad ab search ka ek aur platform ban gaya hai. Aise mein aapke research ka ek aur source ho gaya hai.

One song of ghazal is rang aur nur ki barat by Rafi sahab you have not mentioned other mistake leader duet song you mentioned was Rafi suman not lata

Ghazal ka musician ravi hai

Donon gane achhe hain,keval pasand ka antar hai,kise kaunsa gana achha lagata hai, ,ye usakee pasand hai.Harek kee pasand alag alag hoti hai. Kisi ko meetha pasand hai to kisi ko nahi,jab ki shubh avasar par munh meetha karate hain lekin kai log,jinhe meetha pasand nahin hai ve use nahin lete ya keval koi bura na mane,munh meetha kar lete hain.

Firaq ki baat bhut pasand aaye,

Film leadar ka ik Shehanshah Ne Banwake Hasin Tajmahal

آپ نے تاریخ کچھ گڑ بڑ کر دی ۔ ساحر نے نظم تاج محل بہت پہلے سے لکھ رکھی تھی جو ان کی کتاب میں بھی شامل تھی ۔ شکیل صاحب ان کے مصرع اک شہنشاہ نے ۔۔۔۔۔۔سے استفادہ کیا اور باقی گیت اپنے انداز میں لکھا ۔ فلم غزل میں ساحر کی نظم بعد میں شامل کی گئی

Tajmahal ki story real hai hi nahi, real story pe movie honi chahiye thi, us movie nam Mumtaz mahal hona chahiye

, Program accha laga Sameer Kolkata

Nice ❤

Zahid sharab peene de masjid me baith kar, ya koi aisi jagah bata jahan khuda na ho

Jis film men nishad ka music hota tha usmen shakeel badayuni geet likhte they sahit se yeh geet likhne ke liye nahi kaha gaya tha Aap ghalat jankari de rahe ho

Amazing rare story of one monument & two opposing view songs. Brilliant sarcasm by suggesting lines of Jama Masjid. Great kissa,Shavez saab. Thanks🎉🎉

Tanj nahi, tanz. !

I am sorry, you are wide off the mark. Sahir wrote this poem way back in the early 1940s while in Ludhiana. It was published from Lahore in 1945 in the first collection of poems. Please check before you make grossly incorrect assertions.

Ye galat hai Unhone bahut pehle likha tha

Jabez Saab Film Leader song is the reply to Saaher Ludhyanvin and not vice versa Saaher written this song long back before Shakeel Badsyuni and this so g was I cluded in film BABAR and not Ghazal and this song is released before Leaders song Ur filmy knowledge is not upto the mark p,z correct it in ur next video after fully inquired into my remarks plz don't think otherwise

There was no such person as Firaq Gorakhpuri ... There was a great Hindu writer called Raghupati Sahay who use to write in Urdu

بھت خوب پیشکش ۔

آپ کی معلومات غلط ہے ساحر کی غزل تاج محل ۔ بہت پہلے لکھی گئی تھی جب یہ غزل ساحر نے لکھی ساحر اُس وقت پاکستان میں تھے شکیل صاحب نے گیت بعد میں لکھا

Shahir also muslim

Leader movie song was really outstanding and has become iconic.

Mind your language- likhnay say mana nahin kiya. Likhnay say inkar kiya.

Jama aur taj are old hindu mandirs , which were converted to masjid and tomb by invader. Nothing political or religious motive , it's a symbol of oppressor !

Kya uss samay koi Hindi writer nahein thhei kya

Both the sons by Shakeel Badayuni and Sahir are excellent .

This was not a good film. Was copied from North by North Wesr.

Sabhi shayar achchhe hain.lekin firaq gorakhpuri dusare galib Mirza hain.modern jamane me unka koi sani nahi hai.