Japanese dub "soundless voice" by Valshe English subs & romaji 

2019, still love this song. Valshe’s cover is a masterpiece.

I remember how I cried so hard when I was 13. Well, years later and I still do

No wonder why Rin died. She ain't got no winter clothes. *runs away*

We're in 2016 and I still cry listening to this song...

I do not speak Japanese and have to make due with various English translations. It's amazing to me how much this song can touch me. Love, anger, trust, forgiveness, grief, agony, and the willingness to die in the arms of your deceased love... For a 5 minute song it makes me think of Shakespeare's tragedies. More music should be like this! I miss the days where most songs touched me as opposed to just being catchy.

love the human touch this version adds. songs like this need that human factor to bring out the full impact

2018 anyone?

Just for those people who can't see the subs On the night everywhere is dead silent Snow falls down on my outstreched palm Snow falls and melts in a moment. What a transient fragment Snow like a light piles up without a sound You gather it and smile "What does my voice sound like now?" Even if I reply, you can't hear anything any more Tell me you're suffering, Tell me you are lonely I'm going to find you, wherever it may be... Please don't go anywhere. Please don't leave me alone. Aren't we forever the two of us as one ...? As snow piles up, You vanish away I can't do anything but hold you tight If possible, just one more time, Let me hear your voice One more time, just one more time Call out my name... Your empty eyes are out of focus, I see one drop in them In the gray world Everything is motionless, just the snow softly pours down You're getting cold, Your voice is gone We can't even melt each other as one Listen to my voice, smile to me again... Having exhausted my tears, I can't stop you melting away ... If possible, my voice, take all of it away And give it to my precious one If I'm to be left in the world all alone Without you, then like this ... With you ... I'll rot away Locked forever in a world where I cannot even say a simple "I love you" That's what my world with you is like Even if I scream, Your voice won't come back ... any more {AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA } O falling, piling snow, I beg you please don't stop falling Like I am now, rob me of everything Along with the transient life of my voice Scratch it out of existence. Everything ... ... goes white

2023, and I'm still there... :(

The thing that endeared this song to me initially, and still does to this day, is just the tone of Valshe's voice. During the verses you get a sense of both detachment and deep sadness, the second of which grows more passionate as it gets to the the chorus, where you can just FEEL the sheer hurt and broken-heartedness of the singer... and that part near the end that immitates an exclamation of pain brings it to a head before it falls back into detached despair and sorrow. I can FEEL the pain of the singer at losing a loved one and that just draws it so close to my heart and makes me tear up with every listen.

10 years have passed since the first time I heard this song XD I'm 20 now and I still find it beautiful and emotional (even though I don't listen to vocaloid anymore) :3

It is from Vocaloid, Rin and Len. Ciel does not officially have his own character song, so his fan used this song for him. Personally, I really love this song, it suits Ciel.

This was the first song that had made me cry...I listened to this song 5 years ago and it has been my favourite song since then!

omg valshe.... this is amazing. i had goosebumb..

My best friend of 11 years killed herself six days ago and this is how I feel, like an incomplete piece in this world, if you have someone dear in your life always remember to tell them how much you love them

To all you weebs that think this is Ciels' character song, you're wrong.

i just love valshes voice

Valshe's voice is so accurate to Len's! .o.

21년에도 듣습니다

You could just punch my face, it would totally feel the same thing that I'm feeling rn

2021 here 💗 Surprisingly I can sing it like 70% even I don’t know Japanese. Can’t imagine how much I listen to this song 6-7 years ago. Man it does contain memories back when I was in 8th grade!

this still hits 😔

This song... So many anime characters could have this song. But i agree with the others, it mostly suits Ciel. The only song that can actully make me cry, wow! This song is a prize winner. It deserves a golden statue. But this voice, praise holy god, they are perfect

2021, still a good friggin song

I am crying about this song at 4AM So I play project diva. IT’S SO HARD to play slow songs. I always get mad. But then I listened to the lyrics (and double checked the English lyrics since my Japanese isn’t perfect) and now I’m crying. I’m sorry for getting mad at you Len. This song is so beautiful, it makes me feel nostalgic. I love the “AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH”. :((

oh... my.... god.... i have never been riveted like that by a song before... i have heard beautiful songs, sad songs and songs to make even a soulless man such as myself cry... but never have i been paralyzed by the sheer power of emotion in a song like this.... this should be preserved for eternity.

2019 old school vocaloid gang

Wonderful... absolutely wonderful!

This song is so addicting. It's so sad, yet it understands me. (If that made sense.) - Valshe's cry was amazing heartbreaking, yet powerfully beautiful. - Her voice sounds like Len's in a way, which made me cry even more. - This song speaks to me, so I always come back for more. Valshe, your beautiful voice has struck me again. ♥♥♥

I am still here

Found this song years ago, been searching for the longest time to find it again; now I've found it. Ah, my heart. How I've missed this.

Valshe's voice😍😍😍 so beautiful

2020 and i still love it 😭😭

Valshe’s voice always makes me think of Len’s voice. ❤️ the song gives me the feelies. Let’s celebrate 11 years!

2020 and still crying

2022: 11 años desde que llevo escuchando esta canción y no importa el tiempo que pase aún me sigue tocando muy profundo. En mi época obsesiva por Vocaloid está era una de las canciones que más escuchaba. Todos los covers de Valshe son increíbles, tiene una voz que transmite muy bien los sentimientos de la canción. Espero seguir escuchándola muchos años más 19/11/2022

This song does suit Ciel Phantomhive really well.

I cry every time I listen to this song, it's just so powerful when Valshe sings it!

I used to sing this in a karaoke room back when I was a high schooler. Somehow I missed that day.

I always like to listen to this song whenever I'm depressed ;_;

I can't believe I've been watching this since 2010, made a cover, and had never liked or favorited. Well, all done now.

*lays in the snow on the ground while reaching to the sky* I miss you grandmama… Uncle Geoffery… I wish you never left. *starts to cry but keeps a straight face* ((Open RP; Anyone can join in at any time))

2020 and still in love with the vocals of this song...And I get just as emotional as 10 years ago 😂

love this song so much! I hope Valshe becomes a well known singer someday

This reminds me a lot of Ciel, however it is not his character song. It's really beautiful though

from 2009 when I first found this video to 2019. this song's been on my playlist for THAT LONG!! (i was in high school when this video was made hahaha I'm so old...)

This was absoloutly beautiful. She has one of the best voices I've ever heard. Her voice fits the song and it is one of the best songs ever. Thank you for singing this Valshe.

Knowing this song as "Ciel Phantomhive character song" and reading after chapter 129 is another type of pain.

2017 still cry w this song...

Valshe sing it so deep..

my heart clenches whenever i listen to this song

I haven't heard many of her covers but, HER VOICE OMG....it's so good it could make me cry ....

No matter how many times I've listened to this song, it always succed to make me cry... Every version that I heard have the same feeling pured in it.... *still crying*

Amo la voz de valshe!! :'3

I...I teared up so bad. Brilliant. Beautiful. Just....amazing.

This is abousultly beautiful. Between Valshe's voice, lyrics, and the video it brings tears to my eyes.

The first vocaloid song that made me cry.

People refer to it as Len's song now. I prefer to remember it as Ciel's song. But yeah... this song made me cry.

2018. Just saying. I just suddenly remembered it and decided check it out again. It's beautiful. I think that only people who remembered this song are those who found out about it when it first came out, years and years ago.

I come back to this song every day and it never fails to make me break out crying bro this song has everything on me

wtf this is rEAL LIFE LEN VOICE WTF AWESOME edit : YES I KNOW that it isn't, that was just a way to praise about how good the singer is

When I first heard of this song (I didn't know anything about Valshe) I fell in love with his (I thought that she was male) voice.... There are no words in this world that can describe my reaction when I found out that I fell for a girl's voice >.

this video is awesome!!!! its so sad. and i love the artist!!! ur art is amaiiiiiizin!!!

So beautiful and got me in tears...

It's fucking 2021 and i have a test tomorrow why am I here

*places hand over heart* right in the feels... TT^TT

No matter how many times I hear this, it still manages to make me cry and shiver... Bravo.

Omg, this is so beautiful that I can't even say in words how beautiful. Awesome fandub.

If Len was always tuned so well he would probably be my favourite male vocaloid

2019!

Really beautiful and emotional song, loved it !

This song used to bring me to sleep almost every night... So sad yet peaceful...

This time, Len didn’t die, but Rin did. I feel so sad for the two. And watching falling, falling snow before I watched this video didn’t help either. Now I’m crying. Guess I’ll just watch triple Baka or something... But NO. THE NEXT AUTOPLAYED VIDEO IS SERVANT OF EVIL. :..(

Again: we need a 💔 button

Thanks for uploading the song! >_

This song is so beautiful, i get chills every time.

I really like this song. Sad how people argue though. I don't think it's Ciel's character song. I may be wrong but eh. Yes it does sound like Ciel but it isn't. AnywAy, Ciel's character song or not, I like this song a lot.

Valshe

すごい切ない曲です・・・ 何回聴いても飽きない!

This song has the most beautiful melody I heard, even more so the meaning. Just listening to it almost made me cry.

i tried not to cry everytime i listen to this song...but i just can't...TT^TT

You sound alike like ciel phantomhive from black butler :3

I really love this song... Len's tears is really something, that can make me cry.

Bring the sad memories...

This reminded me of when greystripe lost silverstream...

DAMN IT!!!!!! I CAME TRYING TO TAKE A BREAK FROM LEN DYING!!! BUT NOW BOTH LEN AND RIN DIES?!!?!?! I CHOOSE THE WORST SONGS!!!!! BUT I JUST CAN'T STOP LISTENING TO THEM!!!!!! ;~;

Valshe sounds so wonderfully emotional here. Love her!

I love this song!!!! And valshe is soooooo good at singing it!!

2019 anyone?

eu sei q essa música n é do Ciel mas man, eu consigo imaginar certinho ele cantando pela mansão Phantomhive :')

I don't know how many times I have replayed and replayed this song. Found it a couple of days ago, and I love it. So sad, yet such a beautiful voice.

2022 , I still listen to this song

I remember someone said she deserved to die because she was wearing short shorts in the dead of winter 💀💀💀

IS THIS VALSHE SINGING??

Waaahh!!!! My MOST favourite song EVER!!! Remembers me of my past

the song gives me shivers. it's a really good song

Ciel...?o.o

Who is from 2018?

AARRGHHHHH I wanna cry!!! They sang it soooo beautifully PERFECT!!! Even the music composition and arrangement are already damned perfect!! DX

I love Valshe's dub of this song!!~~~ That's it! I fell in love with your voice!!!