jazz is never animated correctly

Подписаться 999 тыс.

Просмотров 607 тыс.

50% 1

Download transcriptions at georgecollierm... and check out the Discord!: / discord
Original video: • But not for me
Piece: But Not For Me
Performed by: Yoko Kanno?
Transcribed by: Tony Williams
faq:
Q: how are you related to jacob collier? / A: i'm not, we just have the same last name
Q: how do you transcribe? / A: i use musescore for notation and 'Transcribe!' for beat marking, slowing down etc
Q: do you have perfect pitch? / A: no
Q: where can i suggest videos? / A: / discord
Q: what music do you listen to? A: open.spotify.c...
Q: why are some videos not transcribed by you? / A: sometimes other people submit transcriptions, most are commissioned from others who can do a better job than i can. i want to make sure you see the best transcriptions possible!

Опубликовано:

12 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 327

@GeorgeCollier Год назад

unless you're in kids on the slope, then everything is animated correctly :)

@themBoots Год назад

I’d love to see a transcription for either the keys or drum part of the finale! Happy to see kids on the slope here regardless

@guidoferri8683 Год назад

But rotoscoping is ugly

@Sebastians.World_ Год назад

@@guidoferri8683 its still pretty impressive

@cosanchez124 Год назад

@@guidoferri8683 get outta here with that clown ass take

@huxlee3947 Год назад

"Soul"..?

@woakuu7764 Год назад

It took me a concerning amount of time to realize it wasn't the trumpet being transcribed

@pulsar-_-4504 Год назад

Same, i got really annoyed when i looked at it and the notes and fingering was not correlating with the transcript. and i read this comment and i was like wait what the heck

@jacobburr3570 Год назад

It took me until I found this comment bc that ish is a foreign language to me lol tried to learn at one point but I play with musicians that can't read it either. So I don't think it would help me much idk

@Chadwinw Год назад

Yeah I saw a chord and was like how tf

@akemitsusuel7583 Год назад

Same

@dogtags7019 Год назад

I thought the bass clef was the trumpet transcript lmfao

@nomannic1 Год назад

I bet the writers were thinking about Chet Baker or something, dudes got the smooth trumpet playing and vocals!

@KubaWlosczyk Год назад

The intro is taken from Chet Bakers version of But not for me in his album, "Chet Baker sings"

@wyattb954 Год назад

yea the song that he sings n plays is chet baker, "but not for me"

@4rtiphi5hal19 Год назад

i mean it is a cover of chet baker's version of the song so yeah

@b-perfection9305 Год назад

@@KubaWlosczyk Chet plays the same intro indeed, but it was not written by him. That's simply the verse of the song as written by Gershwin. But yeah it's heavily inspired by how Chet plays it of course

@elidranow Год назад

That’s where they got the key change. Chet baker does it in some recordings that way

@joramopa Год назад

I am a professional 3D animator. Animating musicians accurately is by far one of the challenging tasks. Animation is illusion, not reality. It's also very time consuming and requires a lot of effort to re-create motion in a way that's not only believable but is also pleasing. playing an instrument is an exercise in human fine motor control. To recreate that with animation, accurately, frame by frame, is months of work per shot. I have had to do a shot where I was tasked to animate a in-game emote where the character plays a guitar, the pitch was for me to animate the noodling accurately. I did, and it was a challenge that I enjoyed, but, it took a long time and many many many many revisions.

@aedinn Год назад

true true, people rly need to chill. they dont think about this, people want correct finger animations even tho 90% of the audience of the show watching dont pay attention to that. it rly doesnt matter as long as it looks like someone is playing the instrument

@Clifford_Banes Год назад

Admit it, it's hard to draw hands

@austindavis2406 Год назад

Indeed, in fact one might consider animating, as a whole, to be one of the tasks ever.

@99temporal Год назад

I mean, for said animation(the one from the video) they had an accurate recording from multiple angles of real people playing it, so they just rotoscoped it. Still very hard, although certainly more doable.

@graywarden8340 Год назад

We appreciate your work chief! 🤧

@Phantomsbreath Год назад

In which literally everything is animated correctly

@EvanLewis_ Год назад

The trumpet fingerings are so wrong my friend

@jaylenhall9450 Год назад

@@EvanLewis_ piano is in concert pitch, trumpet is in Bb. Bb on piano would be C on trumpet.

@EvanLewis_ Год назад

@@jaylenhall9450 ah I play trumpet so just used to seeing the music in Bb

@EvanLewis_ Год назад

Yeah in that case it's spot on then

@kyuuusassx Год назад

all the fingering is wrong when a F comes you can’t all your fingers up. those are only C , High C and figure the bar lines..

@YourNeighbourJack Год назад

Kids on the slope is such a hidden gem! Would 100% recommend it

@mosaicdt2 Год назад

"All these money making apps have a hidden gem."

@mendtheboy Год назад

Supported

@radiomeducks2234 Год назад

Such a nice little anime, doesn't matter if ya like the plot the music carries it

@steinblitz1506 Год назад

@@radiomeducks2234 I liked it but the drama became annoying

@yamadiver9486 Год назад

@@steinblitz1506 same here, at one point the plot turned melodramatic

@paytonkerkes Год назад

Look into the behind the scenes for kids on the slope! I have a Dvd copy and Yoko Kanno cast a young piano player and drummer to be the reference point to all the music scenes for her arrangements. The young musicians played the parts that were used on the show and the animators had correct versions to animate to . One of my favorite animes and the attention to details don't go unnoticed.

@thalb4279 Год назад

Did not know that, that’s awesome

@TJ_ax Год назад

*rotoscope

@maclaynecredere5103 Год назад

What’s the show called?

@russell5292 Год назад

@@maclaynecredere5103 kids on the slope

@IncoherentMoron Год назад

@@TJ_ax it's not rotoscoping: the artists used footage of the jazz performances as a reference to work from, not to trace over

@ZachIzBeast Год назад

Yooo did you actually go through and watch the show? It's a beautiful ride my man. They did such an incredible job. I literally just rewatched this a week ago and still loved it just as much.

@daahoud. Год назад

Bro where did you watch it I’ve been trying to find it for ages 😅

@wholesomejm Год назад

Fr where to watch

@flutemcglute Год назад

9anime

@ZachIzBeast Год назад

Okay i swear to God my comment is just getting deleted now. I've posted where i watched it 3x more and it keeps disappearing.

@martinkrauser4029 Год назад

The show is incredibly bad. Please, work on your understanding of others so you may cease to like and recommend it to fellow people for viewing.

@xupan8658 Год назад

The piano even has a correct novice feeling that overplayed a little.

@user-fw5uz4dx5x Год назад

>Performed by: Yoko Kanno? I think the piano was played by Takashi Matsunaga with his motion capture (and the drumming scenes were done by Shun Ishiwaka)

@GeorgeCollier Год назад

What about trumpet?

@user-fw5uz4dx5x Год назад

@@GeorgeCollier Shinpei Ruike, also a famous player in Japan and Yoko Kanno was the musical director.

@timofeygolev Год назад

Based on what I hear I really think the absolute most of the music played in the anime was recorded by Matsunaga, for some reason not sure about this one tho... btw he is an absolute beast everyone should check him out

@cloudtone-nyto3776 Год назад

I keep seeing this in “I can’t believe jazz was animated correctly!!!” vids, have to check it out. Great transcription!

@owendailey8683 Год назад

I would do unspeakable things for you if you transcribed the version of "Moanin'" on Organ and Drums at the end of the anime!!!!

@narulizard Год назад

that and the highschool performance. Sakamichi no Apollon

@clarinetmaster5990 Год назад

unspeakable 😳

@justcallmeJon Год назад

Yes please!!

@iannye6054 Год назад

yes, that's my favorite part of the anime.

@avi71229 Год назад

omg yessss

@liamdysoco4832 Год назад

Holy shit I’ve been looking for a transcription of this for so long

@will-ti2qs Год назад

this version has been on musescore for a while now

@HangoutswithZach Год назад

One of the best scored pieces of media ever

@avi71229 Год назад

please do more from this anime, I love this so much!

@steamedjams1633 Год назад

Sound Euphonium is another one for correctly animated instruments, I was one happy trombonist

@Birdx69420 8 месяцев назад

0:31 homie was trying so hard to not be gay🤣

@cas-sius 23 дня назад

what?

@ああ-b3t8f 17 дней назад

not funny bro

@PulseGTR Год назад

That feeling when Chet Baker is in your anime

@maggoteater2290 Год назад

Far from him

@PulseGTR Год назад

@@maggoteater2290 Oh for sure, but you have to admit the playing and singing bears some resemblance to him.

@SuzanneJen 7 месяцев назад

⁠@@PulseGTR the trumpet playing, definitely, for transcribed directly from one of his recordings of this tune. The singing, however, really is very different. But I’m sure the Japanese singer who did the voice this character must be thrilled if he ever sees this compliment☺️

@Xbox-ug1rl Год назад

IVE BEEN WAITING FOREVER FOR THIS THANK YOUUU ❤❤❤

@MarvelousMaxter Год назад

playing only half the form is so cursed

@CarlosGonzalez-oi4jb Год назад

Kids on the Slope is absolutely an S Tier anime with some of the best music and animation around.

@bintangadinugroho71 Год назад

this is literally the scene that got me into jazz and chet baker specifically lmao.

@orc_gunslinger Год назад

Anime Jazz - all the girls blush. Real Jazz - there are no girls at the club just a bunch of jazz bros vibing you for missing a 2-5-1

@brennanruiz1803 Год назад

Didn’t they literally rotoscope the music scenes for this show over the performances they used for the audio?

@faustmugen Год назад

they did

@romeo1771 Год назад

no they didn't. the animators used real performers as reference for such scenes

@makotomachiyuki Год назад

better rotoscope than innacurate

@justs_ Год назад

@@romeo1771 that’s… what rotoscoping is

@romeo1771 Год назад

@@justs_ rotoscoping is when you draw over the footage frame by frame, basically tracing the footage. using a reference means looking at the said reference irl or on your monitor/tablet/etc.. and then drawing on a different surface based on what you're observing

@lucas2698 Год назад

you doing a transcription on kids on the slope makes me very happy

@natnatnat7125 Год назад

man, bout time

@amiapsychopat Месяц назад

this is so beautiful

@WickedWilhelm Год назад

I like how this song quotes Oliver Nelson's Stolen Moments at the end.

@t3chn0kiwi1 Год назад

kids on the slope gets me tearing up every damn time

@brock8696 Год назад

The scene in the church in Kids on the slope has the drums animated perfectly

@_Aelis Год назад

Such an amazing show, through and through.

@singsong1334 Год назад

Love how the piano guy gets a crush on the singer the second he starts

@amiapsychopat Месяц назад

honestly same

@sonicflash5090 Год назад

Thank you for this I love this clip, everyone needs to listen to some Chet baker right now!!!

@trx90vito29 Год назад

When the valves *and* lips don’t line up

@reubenkimber Год назад

In what part does the valve not line up

@syxziz Год назад

brother this is transcribed in concert, and trumpet isn’t transcribed lmao

@olliezoop Год назад

The main characters in this show are really good roommates :^]

@jonathanraynard8621 Год назад

What's the show title?

@septiancahya Год назад

@@jonathanraynard8621 kids on the slope or sakamichi no appolon

@certainlysomeonehere4975 Год назад

This is actually my favourite music anime, I came across this by accident and it made it even better

@aidanmeza8922 Год назад

I wish there was the trumpet part to see if it was because I play trumpet 🥲

@romahernandez8525 8 месяцев назад

i remember trying to transcribe this when i was first learning trumpet it was super fun being able to learn this as my first peice instead of hot cross buns

@georgehiggins1320 Год назад

When ya boi comes in a major third away from the key center you CLEARLY set up...

@stevenrosalita Год назад

Man is giving free transcriptions. Thans man. Salute💪

@Barbecue_Bacon_Burger Год назад

If there was a video of sax being animated correctly that would be pretty cool. I play sax in my jazz band so that would be neat.

@cicik57 6 месяцев назад

Heyyyy, this piece is really playable!!!! so with styling and walking bass, cool!!!!

@360truths7 Год назад

His voice is lovely!

@FrankDarko420 Год назад

Looks like they cared enough to get it right that they rotoscoped a performance

@telanuevo123 Год назад

YOOOO! Do more Sakamichi No Apollon stuff!

@szniorolka7210 7 месяцев назад

Woah the double bass part is so fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥

@annchannin14 Год назад

The movie "SOUL" with john batiste played and said how impressed he was with how they got it write.

@SadButter 6 месяцев назад

This anime played a huge part in how I got into jazz. Absolute gem.

@yodelingpotato2163 Год назад

Reminds me of Harry connick jr

@lars1588 7 месяцев назад

They filmed the actual musicians live in session with lots of cameras at many different angles and then traced the animation of the videos. The extras on the Blu-Ray detailed this. It was very intentional, as well as choosing younger musicians, given that the main characters are highschoolers, so not pros. I appreciate that they went to such a length for what was a rather obscure anime.

@earlycomposer4018 Год назад

at 0:16 the note is pressed before the hand gets there xD

@dylan1kenobi Год назад

Man they took this off Crunchyroll when I was in the middle of it!

@andymcclurg9916 Год назад

As a musician, I personally don't care about correctly animated music. Animation is hard enough as it is, dammit.

@MonoHatsu Год назад

I love this anime!! Thank you

@DampRaccoon Год назад

I'm more annoyed the top of everyone's heads are cropped off

@waffleman3625 Год назад

Can't wait for you to transcribe the music from the Blue Giant movie

@triplenickelpickletickle3796 Год назад

To be fair, Anime is never animated correctly, either. Watch, I'll draw an anime nose right here ---> . .

@mercenaryforhire3453 Год назад

If you want to see well animated brass, you should check out Hibike Euphonium. Not jazz though.

@oscah_whisky 7 месяцев назад

"Than any roo-SYAN play" was so bad in so many different ways, lmaoooo!!!

@Rexus5 Год назад

Ah I remember Kids On A Slope! Complete gem of a random find!

@peaceanquiet4528 Год назад

Q: how are you related to jacob collier? / A: i'm not, we just have the same last name My last name is Holly, I get asked how I'm related to Buddy Holly. Usually I go, I'm not, his real last name is Holley with an ey not y.

@hepta5254 Год назад

Bruh that’s a nice rendition of “but not for me” reminds me of chet baker a little bit, we need more anime about jazz!!!

@123456789ore Год назад

ジャズに限らず、音楽の描写は難しい。本当に。

@rolandjohnson8482 Год назад

I’m surprised nobody’s mentioned the intro is essentially stolen from Chet Baker’s version.

@JohnsonSmithson Год назад

Don't know if you can call it stolen. But yes it's his solo.

@JuanRivera-vx5xx 9 месяцев назад

De los mejores animes que he podido encontrar.

@will-ti2qs Год назад

would there be anyway on earth that you’d transcribe the early version of But not for me from Kids On The Slope ? The piano/drum duet

@Hola-nl5um Год назад

this anime was too good, it does not get enough credit

@brainymaestro8581 Год назад

Even the trumpet fingerings in the beginning were correct

@iceborg05 Год назад

Nice Basie lick at the end

@adamrios3141 Год назад

Amazing

@Benjy52 Год назад

0:05 That’s an Abmaj7. You may need to redo this transcription.

@raven6514 6 месяцев назад

Now trascribe Hibike Euphonium the song name is Liz and The blue bird

@arleila Год назад

love it

@BlockBuster681 Месяц назад

Watch Blue Giant. It’s probably the best jazz anime out there

@Balja69 Год назад

I always freaking forget this song name. First notes are in my head but never name of this song

@BrennenL Год назад

my dumbass was trying to read the piano music as if it was the trumpet transcription 😪

@DrDarkMatter Год назад

Even if it was animated wrong, Still woudnt matter really.

@thehoodedvagabum7375 Год назад

This is totally unaccurate tho. We jazz musician don´t know any girls.

@MexicanCrusader Год назад

Speak for yourself man

@rimofantasy 9 месяцев назад

jazz is my passion 🍍

@siamangape8853 7 месяцев назад

I want to watch this show again ;-;

@NiggelTV Год назад

Gershwin O.O

@m4ssee Год назад

People who watch anime and haven't watched" Sakamichi No Apollon" need to do so immediately!

@Kastafore Год назад

Kids on the Slope is an underrated masterpiece.

@AlbertonJiggletip 5 месяцев назад

Jazz anime is just crippling me inside

@armstrong.r Год назад

Fantastic anime, highly recommend

@notgoodwithnames78 Год назад

i’ve been trying so hard to find kids on the slope, is it available to watch anywhere?

@randomperson2526 Год назад

Pirate it online

@ZachIzBeast Год назад

I found it searching "sakamichi no apollon" posted in full on some random Facebook page like a week ago, what a coincidence it showed up here lol.

@oreiller4184 Год назад

Legit thought this was Levi Ackermann in the thumbnail and got so confused

@asadplatypus3940 7 месяцев назад

this anime single handedly got me into jazz

@sninckashley9514 Год назад

This is definitely not animated correctly The bassist is just sitting there and letting the pianist take his place without seething at all 0/10

@victito8 Год назад

That is Shinichiro Watanabe for you, always a respectful soul for music

@connorthomas4826 Год назад

Everyone who loves jazz immediately thought of Chet Baker.

@d0ublewhammy Год назад

nooo hes not holding his trumpet correctly

@timothyobaob3624 Год назад

YES YES YES YES

@toprak3479 Год назад

Kids on the Slope is abbbsolutely amazing

@dallen3000 Год назад

One of my favorite animes

@galkingenadiy Год назад

can you say how anime called?

@dallen3000 Год назад

@@galkingenadiy "Kids on the Slope"

@connorlewis2517 Год назад

CHET BAKER

@FloStudios Год назад

I read trumpet sheet music in concert b flat growing up, but if I'm not mistaken he is playing a concert b flat trumpet and the transcription is in concert c.

@wholesomejm Год назад

It’s because this is a piano transcription