Pft, are we still asking questions about what would have happened if Neal didn't die, up to this point? Like, try to imagine...he didn't stand a chance since day 1, alive or not. The fact that Emma told him she was hoping he was dead in 3x07 pretty much clears it up. Also...CS is TL. Of COURSE Neal didn't stand a chance.
Enchanted Keys you’re clearly a CS shipper and that’s fine, but it’s kind of rude of you to throw it in people’s faces CS were true love. That was not established when Neal died, so to act like it was a big fat ‘duh’ is kind of disrespectful. Emma told Neal that she loved him before he fell through the portal at the end of s2 so there was clearly something there. You can love someone and still have trust issues or whatever with them, and still work it out. There’s nothing wrong with people wondering what might have been and Jen’s answer was a serious cop out.
I've never said she never loved him. She did, and in the end she forgave him, but this doesn't mean she wanted to give him a second chance. He took advantage of her, sent her to jail for his crimes because he decided it was a reasonable price to pay if it meant he was never going to see his father again, moved on, never thought about waiting for her or going to her after the course was broken, treated her like shit because he didn't thought she had a right to not tell him about Henry after she got out of jail, diminished her pain and feelings, was an asshole to her the whole fucking time, etc. and you seriously think that these issues can be solved? My friend, this is the kind of relationship you need to run away from. Plus "snow robbed charming and hit him with a rock when she met him. Telling someone you wish they were dead means nothing on this show." what does it even mean? 1) Snow and Charming didn't even know each other, they weren't in a relationship, this absolutely makes no sense. 2) Of course Emma's feelings don't count in this fandom, when people don't like them, even when she speaks up. It means everything. SHe meant that. She was saying that the idea of him being dead was much better than having to deal with the pain their relationship caused her. This is serious. You don't give another chance to such a relationship. 78.media.tumblr.com/4276955ec59e1db43be77d5b3b2c3494/tumblr_n6ygxyl1qn1qcruu2o1_250.gif Jen spoke. ANd she's right. Anyway, I don't want to discuss this anymore. I have done it too many times. Ain't time for this.
@@VanessaBritneyTaylor Neal didn't have a choice but to leave her. It was always her destiney to break the curse. I do agree that Neal should of went back for her, but they way he left her, it was honestly hard to. He didn't say much at all about get back together. He just wanted to make things right hoping that she'd understand. If they were still together Emma wouldn't explore who she really was. And to be honest Hook had a worst reputation then Neal! You are saying that the way neal treated emma even if he wanted to get back with her there would be no chance because of what he did, Hook did worse! He got another chance, he change. Honestly if you are trying to prove a point you are quite failing and not making any sense. BUt whatevere its your opinion. but i also do agree with the other girl. I can see both sides of the argument
@@siiimplymyuh Lmao, Neal had two choices and he decided to send her to jail for his own crimes, which didn't have ANYTHING to do with the mission to break the curse. He was a coward who took the way out because he didn't want to face his father at the cost of ruining Emma's life. And Hook really is irrelevant in this discussion, because never did anything of the sort, so "Hook did worse" where? In your headcanon? And once Emma and Neal got to have a conversation and Emma pointed out the consequences of Neal's actions and how hurt she was, he just laughed about it and said that everyone has their share of problems, he didn't even bother to apologize. But who even cares about OUAT anymore...
i agree. emma loved neal, yes, but it was clear she did not want to give him another chance after everything. and then there's the obvious fact that cs is true love while swanfire was not. i think had neal been alive emma would've wanted him to stay for their son, but romantically emma and hook wouldve still gotten together, cause true love always finds a way.
I wish someone asked them if you could choose a fairytale character to be on the show who hasn't been on it yet who would you want? I would choose Jackfrost and there's a few other characters I'd like to be on that are connected to him in a way. I'd also love to see Narnia and The Labrynth Also thank you for the upload!
I think when they say “I agree” they’re like saying “I love you” in their own way without any one knowing what it means. ( If you guys seen The Fault in our Stars you’d know what I mean)
