John Mearsheimer: What’s Behind Biden’s Blank Check Support for Israel? | Endgame

Подписаться 815 тыс.

Просмотров 693 тыс.

50% 1

This is the second interview we did with Professor John Mearsheimer on wars and great power politics. Watch the first one here: • John Mearsheimer: Is C...
In this second interview with American political scientist and international relations scholar John Mearsheimer, we discussed the current status of the war in Ukraine and prospects for resolution, moral issues around Israeli military campaigns in Gaza, deterrence and risks of conflict in the South China Sea, and whether ideology is declining in importance when it comes to international relations.
#Endgame #GitaWirjawan #JohnMearsheimer
----------------------
About the host:
Gita Wirjawan is an Indonesian entrepreneur, educator, and currently a visiting scholar at The Shorenstein Asia-Pacific Research Center (APARC), Stanford University. Gita has also just been appointed as an Honorary Professor of Politics and International Relations in the School of Politics and International Relations, University of Nottingham, UK.
----------------------
Get “The Israel Lobby” on Periplus bookstore:
www.periplus.com/p/9780374531508
-----------------------
This episode is shot at The Keller Center in Chicago, home to the future of policy.
Learn more about the Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago: harris.uchicago.edu/admissions
-----------------------
Earn a Master of Public Policy degree and be Indonesia's future narrator. More info:
admissions@sgpp.ac.id
admissions.sgpp.ac.id
wa.me/628111522504
Visit and subscribe:
@SGPPIndonesia
-----------------------
Chapters
0:00:00 - Intro
0:01:53 - Why Ukraine is in Big Trouble
0:05:16 - Guns, Troops and Air Power
0:18:28 - Winning the Peace in Ukraine
0:23:37 - ‘The Blob’
0:29:03 - Israel Lobby
0:35:52 - What Will Iran Do?
0:37:46 - Cleansing the Palestinians
0:42:28 - Containing China
0:50:02 - Conflict in South China Sea
1:02:47 - Is Ideology Dead?
1:08:42 - Tools of Great Powers
1:13:22 - Future of Nuclear Non Proliferation
1:18:28 - Hubris-Humility Index

Опубликовано:

21 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 2,1 тыс.

@gwirjawan 2 месяца назад

When the definition of morality is ambiguous, and when violence is easily justified, what logic will you use to guide your course of action?

@gha9543 2 месяца назад

The lunar eclipse 😅

@RandyMorris-wq7tr 2 месяца назад

The reckless and unrighteous actions of your unrighteous goals.

@numbersix8919 2 месяца назад

United States foreign policy since 1897!

@AuditorInvestor 2 месяца назад

Read the Bible. Judge a tree by its fruits.

@roboldx9171 2 месяца назад

@@AuditorInvestor Despite the US claims of freedom founded on liberty. Those roots of the tree were in fact founded on the inhumanity of slavery and violence against the Africans. and the disposition of the Indigenous peoples of North America. Evil is indeed in the DNA of its founding fathers and to this day.

@JayaMadhavadas 18 дней назад

PROFESSOR JOHN MEARSHEIMER A MAN OF INTEGRITY AND TRUTH,,,GOD BLESS HIM.

@fabiengerard8142 17 дней назад

On Ukraine and Gaza, yes -- but not with it at all about China.

@Wilson24678 16 дней назад

He might be sharp from US POV, but fundamentally, his beliefs align with US imperialism. Some ppl from US former colonies might like him, cause his idea might bring the master back.

@cheponis 14 дней назад

Russian bot ----- please. Gag me.

@mizzypoo4827 13 дней назад

WARP view of INTEGRITY...?🤨 Shouldn’t INTEGRITY include an UNBIASED opinion/view of Global GEOPOLITICAL... seems JM has a blind spot/loyalty in KEEPING HEGEMONY of USA & to maintain USA IMPERIALISM regardless...to the point of starting ANOTHER WAR..(which it no longer can afford) BUT only this time, China are on a Military Technological level playing field...🙄 🙄

@dawsonmeirowitz2333 5 дней назад

Ukraine is russian project. Palestine is russian project. And Mearsheimer is a russian project

@guitib11 4 дня назад

I admire John Mearshimer opinion and analysis He is an honorable man and very intelligent and brave❤

@elwoodgroves7848 Месяц назад

Bravo for Dr. Mearsheimer for his courageous expose of the Israel lobby. His books and public statements have done much to document the power of the Israel lobby in American politics and the government of the United States. He is to be commended!

@Anthrax6989 3 дня назад

funny thing but his closest friend is nazi. Never trust a person who claims that the act of even indiscriminate bombing a genocide.

@fatwax3d 3 дня назад

I've never heard more sense come out of anybody else's mouth over all this. What a fantastic podcast. I couldn't fault him on anything he said. The world needs more brilliant minds like his. 👍

@itssanti 17 дней назад

At the beginning I was not fond of Mersheimer view, but he proved me wrong so many times, that couldn't help but to study his view with more attention and curiosity. He's been right on every single issue he talked about regarding international affairs. He's one of a kind, respects.

@cheponis 14 дней назад

Marshmellow is a moron and Russian apologist. Why to people give him the time of day?

@femiceo328 6 дней назад

Even a dead clock is 2x right a day

@Raydensheraj День назад

His Ukraine talks are outrageous garbage....but concerning the far right ultranationalist ultra-orthodox Authoritarian Israeli government he is spot on.

@martinwagner7361 День назад

@@femiceo328 Bullshit, Maersheimer has been right in ALL his predictions for Ukraine as is proven by time-stamped documents here on RU-vid over a Decade ago before even Maidan in 2014.... Nice try but no chance.... Maersheimers truth, integrity and accuracy is undeniably out for all giving any value to it.

@wangjim5839 2 месяца назад

The sad thing about wars is that those who start or instigate a war are never in or even near the battle field themselves.

@devianadkar7969 Месяц назад

Yes and those who go to war are not brave men and women fighting for their country. They are paid assasins fighting fir a few powerful individuals.

@markusmaximus629 Месяц назад

never

@benitopepolini1249 Месяц назад

Zelensky was near the front plenty of times 😂

@RennyChan Месяц назад

This is the biggest issue with modern warfare and our current politcal leaders. In the past, when there were kings and queens as leaders, they went to war and their entire families were on the front lines fighting and defending civilians. That entire equation has changed, what we have now is a system where our world leaders never have to put their lives on the line. They sit from afar and press a button and people die. There is a complete imbalance in what war entails and what is risked by those who call for war.

@thewedge8823 Месяц назад

not true. Stalin's son was captured by the Nazis.... The Nazi's tried to exchange him, but his son was too low ranking for the Nazi that Russia had captured. Imagine that!! He said no to his own son.. How's that for nepotism?

@PIANOSEEDS 16 дней назад

John Mearsheimer is the man for the moment. Finally after years of scholarship and analysis of world events, he's come into his own through podcasts and alternative media. He's great. And your conversation with him is one of the best. Thank you, Gita Wirjawan.

@cheponis 14 дней назад

ANOTHER russian bot. unbelievable

@PIANOSEEDS 14 дней назад

@@cheponis Hahahahahaha. Yep.

@kumstuke 14 дней назад

@@cheponiswhere?

@cheponis 14 дней назад

@@kumstuke There. Right there.

@kumstuke 14 дней назад

@@cheponis good camouflage, still couldn't see it

@successcollege4283 Месяц назад

감사합니다.

@gwirjawan 26 дней назад

지원해줘서 고마워 🙏

@LouisWaweru 2 месяца назад

When Witjawan says Indonesia dealt with multipolarity in a good way, he seems to completely ignore the CIA coup that installed Suharto and wiped out millions of his citizens for supporting neutrality. In fact, I don’t think I’ve ever seen him deal with this issue on the show, which makes the constant passive agreement anti-Sino remarks locate his loyalty in Washington rather than Southeast Asia. Good interview though. He got Mearsheimer to clearly illustrate the most key points on all of the issues.

@bernardiaVEVO 2 месяца назад

The smartest comment I found here. 🎉

@jillesdjon 2 месяца назад

Excellent observation 👌🏽

@richiesd1 2 месяца назад

So true

@richiesd1 2 месяца назад

Many who were educated in the west have a western bias. Prisoner of colonial mentality.

@alexmae2300 2 месяца назад

You hope someone whose life is connected to USA will be against it ?

@bheamla Месяц назад

One of the best interviews of Professor Mearsheimer. Thanks to the gentleman who is conducting the interview. He knows how to interview without any provocation and interruption.

@daseokamenis Месяц назад

Zionist🤢🤢🤢

@motivationultra01 23 дня назад

Yea he is better than Teers Mongor!😂

@aleejones7508 17 дней назад

even when his guest is full of misinformation and inaccurate research. Personally I like truth not biased inaccurate facts

@maxxter90 13 дней назад

@@aleejones7508 you must be delusional saying that from your arm couch... just read the guest's credentials..

@shelbs4life589 18 дней назад

John is so knowledgeable and is easy to listen to and understand. I could listen to him for hours.

@almapraxeda6049 Месяц назад

Dank an Sie beide aus Deutschland für diese umfassenden Analysen der Weltbeschaffenheit.

@looseshoulderssumali7311 2 месяца назад

"...be intellectually curious in the extreme..." Now that's a good thing to live by.

@niCEwan Месяц назад

Agreed

@leonardo__dicaprio Месяц назад

Who said the quote?

@marrks Месяц назад

@@leonardo__dicapriowatch the video

@MenelikAlkebulan Месяц назад

Probably that’s his advice to young people. (Just started watching )

@fjordhellas4077 2 месяца назад

Professor Mearsheimer is one of the most respected intellectuals, historians, geopoliticians in the U.S and the world! He’s among our most notable thinkers and visionaries just as Professors Noam Chomsky, Jeffery Sachs, Stephen Walt, Norman Finkelstein, Stephen F Cohen …

@user-cg1qq2er8x Месяц назад

Finkelstein is an abject fraud and moron. Chomsky is brilliant but a zealot with a personality disorder. Sachs is a lightweight. Stephen F. Cohen was a brilliant man. Mearsh. is a knock off of Cohen and not a very good one. Mearsh is only right about Ukraine.

@YourFavouriteiA Месяц назад

Named only jews like there are not american professors.

@GreyElder Месяц назад

I personally prefer Professor Sachs hands down .

@oceanlambert3325 23 дня назад

@@GreyElderabsolutely. He is all the theories ! He has a severe lacking of understanding of the history of China & the Chinese ; so typical of the academics!

@victordobin5918 21 день назад

He knows nothing regarding the situation on the ground. He would have to come from the Eastern Europe to understand and comprehend what's going on on battlefield.

@crisisbliss2462 Месяц назад

the question that has not been answered as of 36 minutes is if AIPAC has to lobby for things, how does AIPAC hold so much power over US politicians that they "fear" for their jobs if they don't capitulate to them? Who are the people that make up AIPAC?

@BigMu365 18 дней назад

it is by exploiting them video tap them with sex tapes with minors etc ... Epstein case is best example

@kairo007 17 дней назад

I think AIPAC is low key a blackmail ring; its the only explanation I can think of. Especially since the Epstien case revealed that many top officials had ties to Jeff and that Jeff also had ties to the Mossad.

@PIANOSEEDS 16 дней назад

AIPAC is the mossad by another name...also known as blackmail.

@_TheMax_ 16 дней назад

AIPAC is just a fairy tale, the real masters are behind money printing mechanism.

@user-yg6rp1ou1u 15 дней назад

Leave that question.

@justactonfact 19 дней назад

So much respect for him and his courage

@fajar_siswandaru 2 месяца назад

And one of the reasons that the United States usually obeys the rules is that we wrote the rules, and if a situation arises where we don't like the rules, we disobey the rules or rewrite them. That's the way international politics works. 1:11:00

@pr0newbie Месяц назад

It's called Rules-based order vs International Law. The US doesn't abide by international law.

@josephsilkstone7535 Месяц назад

⁠@@pr0newbieUSA don’t abide by its own domestic humanitarian law. That’s scary.

@fajar_siswandaru Месяц назад

My rule based order

@jameslum8822 Месяц назад

If you ignore the rules you wrote, then don't expect any other to adhere to it or respect you. In fact many will view you in contempt. That's what's facing US.

@m.m.502 14 дней назад

@@jameslum8822and who should hold USA in contempt? Who is powerful enough to hold USA in check and accountable for behaving like hypocrites 🤷‍♀️

@CHIPIONES 2 месяца назад

If I hear Dr. Mearsheimer I cannot stop listening. He is really a smart and an erudite man! Tks a lot fof this interesting interview 👏👏👏

@youssefelmrabet7033 2 месяца назад

the same.

@zetristan4525 2 месяца назад

He's in the catbird seat

@UB2K Месяц назад

John is worthless no life living spreading conspiracy go and touch grass

@user-cu9tp8dp1p Месяц назад

Dem möchte ich mich gerne anschließen - habe bereits 2007 ,Die Israel Lobby' gelesen und bin hoch erfreut. dass diesem Mann, die Aufmerksamkeit zuteil wird, die ihm zusteht. Wenn unsere Politiker nur einen Bruchteil der Übersicht. der Ahnung, des Wissens besäßen, die Hern Maersheimers auszeichnet, wäre schon einiges gewonnen. Mehr Maersheimer - jederzeit immer gerne. Danke für dieses Interview.

@RoEl-od9hl Месяц назад

Keep hearing John talk about how much superior Russia is, 10x more artillery, Russia Air Force vs no Air Force, manpower advantage, industrial advantage.. so why haven’t they won yet? Been hearing this for 2 years now

@gungadi1860 Месяц назад

Udah 2x Pak John Mearsheimer jadi narasumber Endgame & saya selalu suka bagaimana cara beliau menyikapi sesuatu dengan konsep realistis yang beliau gunakan. Meskipun beliau warga negara USA tapi bisa memberikan pandangan secara menyeluruh tidak hanya dari sudut pandang USA saja.

@matrixemperor36 Месяц назад

Thank you Prof. Meirsheimer. You are a great American hero and a gift to humanity.

@JhonJhoni-py6vc 2 месяца назад

Great prof. Gita..l am listening from Australia..

@hassu2149 2 месяца назад

What are your opinions on USA

@underblackflag3335 Месяц назад

@@hassu2149 USA is great

@ajtexas1100 Месяц назад

@@underblackflag3335 No it's not great at all.

@ewilson0223 Месяц назад

@@ajtexas1100great is an understatement. 😊

@eddiefu3727 2 месяца назад

Thank you Projessor Mearsheimer

@paulheydarian1281 Месяц назад

What's a projessor? 🤔😁

@BallyBoy95 Месяц назад

@@paulheydarian1281 spelling mistake

@user-cu9tp8dp1p Месяц назад

Dieses Interview sollte Pflichtlektüre für die deutsche Bundesregierung sein. Diese kann meinetwegen weiterhin der Meinung sein. dass Israel kein Apartheid Staat ist. Ich selbst bin da voll auf der Seite von Prof. Maersheimer.

@halifaxeh Месяц назад

@@user-cu9tp8dp1pIsrael is not an apartheid state?! Did you sleep through that part?

@halifaxeh Месяц назад

@@paulheydarian1281you’ve never made a spelling mistake, eh? So obnoxious.

@successcollege4283 Месяц назад

Thank you. Love & Respect from Seoul Korea

@CrowClouds 2 дня назад

God I love listening to smart people talk at length

@hAI_2024 Месяц назад

I'm glad to see this man again and listen to his intriguing opinions about global geopolitical. Thanks, John. Stay healthy always.

@bassocantante51 Месяц назад

Judge Napolitano has him on his show every week

@lebladful Месяц назад

"The Congress is Israëli Occupied territory" Pat Buchanan Bring AIPAC to justice for legalizing corruption, instead of improving people's lives,education and healthcare

@JH-pt6ih Месяц назад

@@lebladful Pat Buchanan - Trump 1.0 from the 90s.

@astfgl1265 2 месяца назад

It is such a pleasure to listen to Prof. Mearsheimer. Great conversation, thank you both!

@ruudgreat9810 Месяц назад

Thanks to .....USA elites, despite all non proliferation, Pakistan got nucleair weapons and missiles. The US is the most dangerous country in the world whch showed many times that it is impossible to hold it serious for any agreements..

@daseokamenis Месяц назад

Zionist 🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢🤢

@hswilly236 Месяц назад

salute dengan Anda Pak Gita bisa mengundang akademisi dunia tentang power politics Dr. Mearsheimer, terima kasih Pak!

@adonixp Месяц назад

I love listening to Dr Mearsheimer

@libertarianbydefault Месяц назад

I am so delighted the way Professor addressed the ludicrous "win the peace" argument of Kotkin who clearly was delusional when he rambled about it in a previous program. The exclusion of Russia and Russian interests is a recipe for war. It has been the case in 2022 and it will continue being the case until someone wakes up and gets the balls to negotiate for real.

@Mesamedusa Месяц назад

Lose/Win the war/the peace is a framework for looking at things and understanding them. It is not an argument. JM had no trouble expressing his own (grim) views within this framework, demonstrating it's validity.

@ajtexas1100 Месяц назад

Kotkin is a fraud, i don't get what people admire about him.

@dangin8811 Месяц назад

@@ajtexas1100He possesses a sort of scholarly charisma that is uncommon by academics. But youre right, he is ideologically blinkered and has various 'simpleton' moments.

@Mesamedusa Месяц назад

@@dangin8811 Could you pin such a moment?

@ajtexas1100 Месяц назад

@@dangin8811 Charisma ? I don't see it, and don't care about it when it comes to historarians. If i want to learn about the history of a country, i don't want to read again the white/western version/vision that we're told about again and again. I read local historians. How on earth can people believe the history of Russia or China written by AngloSaxon people ? Pure nonsense.

@kunfayakun10 2 месяца назад

Tiap kali buka YT, headline algoritma YT saya isinya konten pak gita, sebegitu seringnya hampir tiap hari saya menonton end game 😅. Terima kasih pak gita atas tontonan gratisnya dan sehat selalu🙏

@amiruddinmagga1505 12 дней назад

Dari sini kita paham bahwa PBB tidak akan berbicara banyak tentang genosida di gaza, hal yang menyedihkan untuk kita ketahui bersama di era sekarang. 😢😢😢

@richardhausig9493 Месяц назад

Gita does good stuff. Great guests and he asks good questions.

@harisk6733 Месяц назад

Terima kasih banyak Pak Gita sudah mengundang kembali Prof. Mearsheimer. Saya salah satu pelajar yang mengidolakan beliau karena pandangan beliau terhadap isu-isu internasional. Melihat situasi Israel-Palestina yang memanas, saya sangat menantikan pendapat beliau mengenai hal tersebut. Alhamdulillahnya, Pak Gita menghadirkan beliau di Endgame. Luar biasa!

@audrajones 2 месяца назад

Oh Mearsheimer, how wonderful you are.

@cheponis 14 дней назад

Say it, Russian bot!

@johnconstable1715 Месяц назад

His voice is being heard in Australia

@cresenciashamsoddin2942 Месяц назад

Great man with Reason and wisdom John Mearshiemer truth Matters to the whole world your voice Echo and heard by the righteous people around the world

@LeonEdwards-lt1bn 2 месяца назад

Thank you Professor Mearsheimer

@MC-1976Mei 2 месяца назад

Sometimes it's best to walk away with your losses and not lose it all.

@victordobin5918 21 день назад

Show us and walk away from you home and your community!!....

@halifaxeh Месяц назад

Great interview! Very informative! Wish I could take a whole class from Prof Mearsheimer!

@pisaukaratan 23 дня назад

Podcastnya Pak Gita itu definisi keren yang sesungguhnya : pembicaranya anti-mainstream bukan karena nyeleneh tapi karena berkelas dan level dunia. anak Muda 62 yang FOMO sama podcast nya pak Gita ga akan rugi, karena Jadi mau improve bhs inggris dan belajar mikir yg kompleks.

@yusufhidayat3149 2 месяца назад

Pak kalau boleh adakan dialog dengan Yanis Varoufakis

@kaeltkottmir Месяц назад

Ditunggu nih

@johnstack5008 2 месяца назад

I'm amazed how sharp the professor is at 76 years old.

@paulheydarian1281 Месяц назад

Thankfully not everyone ages like Joe Biden. 😅

@halifaxeh Месяц назад

That’s a rather ageist comment! Most people don’t have dementia in their 70s.

@brianbutler3318 Месяц назад

Not fair to compare really smart people with average IQ people

@lisabahouth8893 Месяц назад

Unbelievably ageist comment.

@user-kz8my6kf3w Месяц назад

Makes Biden look 139. Guy is a disgraceful. The people shoving him in front of crowds is just utter cruelty. The guys suffering and being belittled through no fault of his own. Another term. The people around him should be arrested. It’s utterly humiliating to watch him. This guy is sharp as a tack. A total pleasure to listen to.

@CharlesDogworth 24 дня назад

Best interview of John Mearsheimer ive seen. Interviewer did an outstanding job, and John really captured some important perspectives. 👍👍

@micky_d_designer4743 17 дней назад

This man is a real teacher. I wish he taught me in the university

@cheponis 14 дней назад

Why, do you like learning how a real Russian useful idiot behaves?

@discoverer7175 Месяц назад

I think this debate would be a lot fairer and unbiased toward China if Professor Jeffery Sachs and Kishore Mahbubani are also invited. Their opinions would be significantly different from Professor Mearsheimer and that of the moderator.

@echozhang4486 Месяц назад

I think one flaw in Professor Mearsheimer’s theory is that he assumes China will rise and becomes another hegemony like America even though China has been saying no we just want to rise peacefully and peacefully co-exist with other countries, including the neighboring countries.

@jameslum8822 Месяц назад

The moderator has barrowed himself in the US anthill and is naturally biased against China.

@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 14 дней назад

Fairness does not come alone by introducing opposition. It comes only when those in discussion are willing to cede to someone else for having a valid point of view. Pro-Chinese advocates do not go along with that kind of discourse. It's _all_ CCP or PLA or nothing. Whenever one critiques the CCP, those two entities call it racism. They insist that the party, the army and the people are all one entity.

@jaixzz 14 дней назад

@@gaslitworldf.melissab2897very nuch agree yours is the comment-scape today

@MY-bc3qq 11 дней назад

@@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 on the other hand you have the people who mix the nation, the party in power, and the civilians as in one entity. It happens both ways, people who are pro-china, and people who are anti-china. Prof Mearsheimer is so far the only one I find who's not taking a side in his logic.

@zhuoli2139 2 месяца назад

Amen to the hubris-humility part

@redice_1183 15 дней назад

God bless you for telling the truth

@JayaMadhavadas 18 дней назад

THIS IS BRILLIANT-THANK YOU -

@asthadwivedi6749 Месяц назад

Thankyou so much for bringing this great man again.

@tedwong7037 2 месяца назад

john mearsheimer’s point of view based on the prediction that China is going to walk through the road exactly like how America did when it became a superpower, but he kinda ignored the history path of the chinese civilization, Chinese are just not the same like the Anglos. Chinese never had those colonial mentality, if they do, SEA are full of small countries, it should be easy for a elephant like China to manipulate those small states and exploit them, but on the other hand, China has only been building up economic connections and do more business with them.

@Joaocruz30 Месяц назад

You said it ALL! greetings from Portugal!

@sholrothaegis3125 Месяц назад

you might want to take a look at the history of china how it grows then you would know that what you say might not be concurrently true...

@Joaocruz30 28 дней назад

@@sholrothaegis3125 that statement is a fair one if already known the future. We cannot accept the fact that we don't like the political values of a country but you cannot judge their future actions just by not liking them! We see their true colours by their actions and not by their words. If so then the austrian painter with a moustache was a great man...

@chenqin415 28 дней назад

This is extremely foolish and ignorant of China's history. During the cultural revolution for example, China export its marxist revolutionary teachings to many countries, provide training and arms to native armed groups (thus they are known as maoist revolutionaries), host radio stations within China itself for these maoist forces. For example, the Communist Party of Malaya which fought an insurgency against Malaysia's government has its radio station in hunan China. This only come to an end when Mao died and Deng took over. He decide that China should build economic ties instead of export marxist revolution and ordered these forces to step down. And they did. With the way China is going today, who knows if Xi will revive the cultural revolution again and build a cult of personality for himself?

@bigtuna45 Месяц назад

I have to say I love the final discussion about the Hubris-Humility index, this concept allows anyone no matter their age to be mentally agile. Also you can tell he's from New York, he pronounces the word "Idea" as "Idear", reminds me of all of my relatives that do this.

@thecommentnews7447 Месяц назад

Ketika Mas Gita mengalihkan pembahasan dari Gaza ke Tiongkok, sepertinya menarik nafas yang sangat dalam. Barangkali karena terkait jawaban Dr. Mearsheimer bahwa tidak ada jalan tengah antara Palestina dan Is****. 😢😢

@metugeekane8454 2 месяца назад

People think of Mearsheimer as an academic, but Mearsheimer is also a soldier, which makes his analyses quite intriguing.

@robhaythorne4464 Месяц назад

Mearsheimer was an Air Force Lieutenant who served five years in a Los Angeles office. He couldn't wait to shed his uniform.

@Roberto-de8xv Месяц назад

@@robhaythorne4464Your post history is smearing John as a supporter of Russia. My man the world, particularly geopolitics, is not binary. If you were going to accuse him of a bias it would be anti-Soviet/Russia if you've read any of his literature. If someone observes country X has an advantage over country Y in a war, it doesn't mean the observer is biased towards country X. *You'd probably agree China has an advantage over Tawain. Does that mean you support China for acknowledging that advantage? Of course not.

@Truthorfib Месяц назад

@@Roberto-de8xvChina has an economic advantage over the US and have stopped buying US bonds. Hence the Treasury Secretary went to China out if panic 😂

@Truthorfib Месяц назад

@@Roberto-de8xvthe US Dollar though is still a major trump card the US has. But as soon as the BRICS currency is implemented the US economy is going to implode

@MaskedUpActivities Месяц назад

@@Truthorfibare you drunk? China is an a economic pooper they lost 90% of foreign investment the Chinese economy is literally about to collapse 😂😂😂the property market has fell too

@Qiushishuo 2 месяца назад

There are three miscalculation there about China. 1. There is no trade are influenced in SCS. 2. China will respond the contain strategy from US. No one likes repression. 3. China is not US, who wants to grab all. China is fine with South east Asia for thousands of years.

@philipemerson473 Месяц назад

China is imploding all on its own.

@NoohCee Месяц назад

Agree with you totally. But please improve your English, seriously.

@putrapratama-sq8hu Месяц назад

Bullshit... There are three miscalculation there about China. (ULTIMATE BULLSHIT) 1. There is no trade are influenced in SCS. ---------------------> YES THEY ARE $5.3 trillion worth of goods transits through the South China Sea annually 2. China will respond the contain strategy from US. No one likes repression.---------------------------> GOOD LUCK FACING JAPAN AND INDIA (They Hate You) 3. China is not US, who wants to grab all. China is fine with South east Asia for thousands of years.--------------------------------> LIKE YOU STEAL FILIPINO AND VIETNAMESE ISLAND??? OR STEALING OUR FISH!!!

@ghoziakbar6410 Месяц назад

"For thousands of years" It's not like China was always this powerful for thousands of years, they have long history of collapses in every couple of centuries.

@Pelerkuda45 Месяц назад

You don't see what China Coast Guard doing on Philliphine Coast Line

@margaritadubrovina7063 Месяц назад

Appreciate the thought and insight on this matter

@cheponis 14 дней назад

What? The dude is a Russian stooge! Total idiot.

@narveenaryaputri9759 12 дней назад

This is an insight in the philosophical base Worth listening : Moral compass Realistic logic Economist logic Prosperity goal Survival goal ! That's the balance Thanks for asking that very insightful question Gita.

@Mmzk155 2 месяца назад

Ini temubual kedua dengan Prof. Mearsheimer. Syabas kepada Gita Wijawan

@reginaldpoofta5 2 месяца назад

professor Mearsheimer is the national treasure.

@PhiloSurfer 2 месяца назад

To the global majority, Prof is a national treasure. To the MIC, the US regime and the media, Prof is a traitor, and is shunned and ostracized.

@roccos2311 2 месяца назад

Don’t tell Nicholas cage

@UB2K Месяц назад

He’s absolutely worthless spreading conspiracy theories

@user-xp5id1kh4r Месяц назад

No he's not, lol. Half of his life's work was proven wrong when Russia invaded Ukraine. The only reason why his name is even known is because his theories fit the pro-Rus propagandistic narrative.

@Mesamedusa Месяц назад

@@UB2K Point to a theory and where can I here him talking about it? Be precise.

@katsukikatsunori5107 14 дней назад

It is truly an intellectually stimulating creative pleasure to attend Professor Mearsheimer's lectures. I feel that Prof. Mearsheimer is asking us the question, “Is there a solution to the problem of how to deal with the monster that is growing bigger and bigger with resentment and rage?　 I feel that Professor Mearsheimer is sounding the alarm that such a problem is materializing without our knowledge.

@iqbalamarullah8 Месяц назад

Inilah salah satu hebatnya podcastnya Pak Gita dibandingkan podcast lokal yang lain. Beliau bisa mendatangkan orang-orang hebat untuk berbagi ilmu secara free kepada kita. ❤❤❤

@wagnerbotelha6301 Месяц назад

Excellent interview. Greetings from São Paulo, Brazil.

@BindasBadshah Месяц назад

Wonderful discussion..

@edwinrenaud2002 15 дней назад

Wonderful conversation!

@Jean-rg4sp 2 месяца назад

*John Mearsheimer is easy to understand and he appears to be correct in his assessment of international relations.*

@zetristan4525 2 месяца назад

That's a bold assessment.

@Jean-rg4sp 2 месяца назад

@@zetristan4525 Thank you for noticing my comment.

@j.sarnak1391 2 месяца назад

Really how is his assessment of China's intentions any different from US foreign policy?? China has not attacked anyone in this century. They are building a defense against the Empire of lies. Think about the prosperity China has brought to other countries without forcing regime change on them.

@zetristan4525 2 месяца назад

@@j.sarnak1391 What is your (differing) assessment of how China will proceed, proactively, in the South China Sea, in the decade ahead?

@Jean-rg4sp 2 месяца назад

@@j.sarnak1391 I agree with you and I heard John Mearsheimer say the same.

@hannahlouisefitzpatrick6742 2 месяца назад

Thank-you for this wonderful conversation!

@cheponis 14 дней назад

Yes, just what we need, more Russian bots cluttering up YT

@GMATveteran Месяц назад

19:00 - Vietnam is hardly an "ardent supporter" of the US; it's simply pragmatic & realistic enough to stay equidistant between the US & PRC, so as to maintain its own independence, & play big powers off against one another for its own benefit.

@huberthumphry280 18 дней назад

even though I would agree with the "pragmatic" description and not so much "ardent supporter", you got who they are balancing seriously wrong. It isn't with the PRC which literally had its last war in 1979 as Mershimer notes, with Vietnam, plus the Paracels dispute, plus the Spratlys. Vietnam gets no military aid from China, it gets it from Russia, that is who they are balancing. It is clear that ardent supporter is an exaggeration since Vietnam has expressed neutrality in Russia's conflict in Ukraine but also refused to condemn the invasion at the UN. But Vietnam has been getting US arms deliveries, most importantly warships

@ramiramadan3578 Месяц назад

WHAT A GREAT INTELLECTUAL CONVERSATION BETWEEN 2 SCHOLARS EACH IN HIS LIFE JOURNEY ...

@dev5392 2 месяца назад

Professor is a knowledgeable man and has been telling us this for years this was all predictable

@vkerametlian3 Месяц назад

You are correct

@GaryGraham-sx4pm Месяц назад

@@vkerametlian3 the professor is a defeatist, appeasement with a belligerent adversary never ends well

@rusminnoer632 2 месяца назад

Professor Mearsheimer is the BEST. Cerdas luar biasa...

@S3LFSOVR3IGN 21 день назад

One of the BEST INTERVIEWS you can find on RU-vid. Amazing Channel and interviewer! You can tell Mr. Mearsheimer enjoyed it as much as we have... props to you. If that's the Indonesian way of speaking i wanna be Indonesian!

@pancho.carlos 6 дней назад

Deeply appreciate how you were able to ask Professor Mearsheimer his take on Stephen Kotkin's "winning the peace" argument and how he illustrated the differences between a true peace and a frozen conflict

@mcs351 2 месяца назад

"that's why the American has to be there" ... come on, the Americans are in the region Not to protect its friends or the SEA nations, it's to defend its own hegemony

@annawarner1078 Месяц назад

Meanwhile we are getting destroyed economically. Already China is number one economic power in the world. US lost this position.

@alexchristensen9712 Месяц назад

INDIA RAS A HEDGEMO Y WITH SUNAK AND our vice president

@alexchristensen9712 Месяц назад

MERESMEAR IS AN IDIOT Kennedy was assassinated by Soviet indoctrinated Oswald and Jimmy Carter served one term of Liberalism till Clinton Presidency. R'S HOLE knows no history

@ihsanrachid8763 2 месяца назад

As noted in Haaretz, Netanyahu seems to boast of his knowledge of the US by saying, "I know what America is. America is a thing you can move very easily, move it in the right direction. They won't get in their way." He also boasts of manipulating the U.S. in the ongoing peace process, as the Washington Post points out: "They asked me before the election if I'd honor [the Oslo accords]," he said. "I said I would, but ... I'm going to interpret the accords in such a way that would allow me to put an end to this galloping forward to the '67 borders. How did we do it? Nobody said what defined military zones were. Defined military zones are security zones; as far as I'm concerned, the entire Jordan Valley is a defined military zone. Go argue." America, apparently, is moved by the Israel lobby. Evidence to the contrary has yet to emerge.

@solneeman518 Месяц назад

If you move to. Gaza for a while, you will change your mind.

@irisheyes5890 19 дней назад

We even let him speak on the floor of our Congress!!

@alexgarcia7643 15 дней назад

@@solneeman518there was a christian churches with Christians in gaza, yet they continued to live there. Your point is mute.

@gaslitworldf.melissab2897 14 дней назад

It saddens me that these are the kinds of people who don't get into politics. They know too much about how things work to want to waste their time. At best, they'll serve as consultants, but never throw their hats into the running for a seat. They know it's a losing proposition.

@anonymousWombat3 Месяц назад

Mearsheimer makes a lot of good points. Great discussion

@elwoodgroves7848 Месяц назад

Thank you, Mr. Gita! An excellent interview!!!

@LP-zr4iq 2 месяца назад

so beautiful to listen to these carefully spoken words, thank you!

@acommon1 Месяц назад

Total John Mearsheimer Fan & Follower!!! Realist Rock! Thanks 🙏🏽 you having a true statesman on your show. I plan to read up on your materials too

@hasmikghazaryan9914 Месяц назад

Thank you for your great conversation!

@leboon70 Месяц назад

Terima kasih prof Gita. Narasumbernya keren

@oswarz 2 месяца назад

Would you please give an example of where China is trying to rewrite the rules?

@ChrisZ901 Месяц назад

China has been advocating international law based order instead of the (US/Western) rule based order which has been used by US and her allies to attack China. China does not want to be ruled by those laws which in the US's book is rewriting the rules

@lyq232 Месяц назад

Not yet, because they're not powerful enough to do it just yet. China would love it if they could repeal EEZ and lau absolute claim over South China Sea

@UrMediaIsFake Месяц назад

China is not trying to rewrite rules at all, it just wants to be equal and not be ruled by foreign white imperial power. Most of Asia is the same except they are too weak to resist. This is what he means by "threat", you and I would see it as threat but these global empire fanatics think they own the world and any country can't rule over is considered a "threat"

@MrSilv55 28 дней назад

You forget that China Has hypersonic missiles that can sink all the US warships.

@osamuikeda3953 2 месяца назад

Survival of the fittest doesn't necessarily come through raw strength. Offering mutually beneficial relationships can be a source of real power.

@jacobjorgenson9285 Месяц назад

That’s how China has moved 500 million people out of poverty the last 30 years without fighting a single war

@foxyr4bbit 8 дней назад

i think this is what mearsheimer gets wrong in that he views power through the individualist / liberal ideology

@RangKlos 19 дней назад

Such a complete wisdom. My admiration goes to the interviewer too.

@mouradbsiri3822 Месяц назад

John is the founder in Geopolics of a School of Thought '' Pragmatism'', based on a deep understanding of the various forces in presence with a rogourous evaluation of their main assets (Vision, Military, Economy, Energy,,..). He proved to be right on several occasions .He remains for viewers a great source of a credible Info in Geopolitics.

@anthonyfx100 2 месяца назад

Good dialogue but Gita disappoints in not pushing back on John’s well known hawkish views about China’s potential aims in East Asia, I think.

@Justin87878 2 месяца назад

Agreed! like other commenters said.

@wawanhermawan-sz7gl Месяц назад

it's not gita's style to push or challenge his guest, he always lets his guest offers their views without being confronted. for example, 42:00 gita is correct that zionism was not meant to commit genocide, but john wrongly stated that they know from the start they're going to cleanse the palestinian because they couldnt have established a jewish state among palestinians. well, zionism started in late 19th century was to find homeland for the jews, not to establish a jewish state, therefore it's possible to live side by side as long as they're not praticing apartheid as in the original zionism. first generation of aliyah among zionists in 19th century was relatively peaceful, things gotten worse only since balfour declaration and jewish businessmen (rothschild etc) who bought many lands etc. but then, gita didn't try to debate john either though i think he knows john was wrong here.

@casteretpollux Месяц назад

@@wawanhermawan-sz7glThe British army trained up genocidal Zionist forces in the 30s and they were unleashed in the 48 Nakba slaughter and eviction of a substantial part of the population. They have continued step by step since then.

@shelonnikgrumantov5061 Месяц назад

@@wawanhermawan-sz7glI’d say, the idea that Jews could live peacefully among Arabs and under the Turkish rule was either totally naive and delusional (which would be strange for such a clever nation) or disguising the real goals. If you want to have Jews settling and living en masse while surrounded by Arabs, you need to carve out a state for them - I suspect, Jews realized this from the beginning just at the initial stages did not proclaim this openly for the obvious reasons.

@fasha7747 Месяц назад

@@shelonnikgrumantov5061You don't understand Judaism. Jews back then didn't have the idea that there should be a 'Jewish state,' at least until the Messiah comes according to their beliefs. In fact, it's prohibited. Traditional Jewish belief holds that the establishment of a Jewish state is linked to the arrival of the Messiah and the Messianic age.

@hisham1269 Месяц назад

‘The reason u need a lobby … is because there’s a lot of instances where isreal’s interests conflicts with American interests and lobby wants to go to great lengths to make sure isreal’s interests prevail’ wow, quite simple but never thought of it this way.

@esp505 13 дней назад

makin uhuy aj bintang tamunya pak Gita ❤🎉

@suleimanjarara5379 2 месяца назад

Thank you gentlemen for a great interview.I appreciate your time and thoughtful talk. It was a pleasure listening to you.

@Pitonisa 2 месяца назад

Thank you both ! From Brazil.

@rajatshrma3 Месяц назад

Professor is a True Legend.

@sunshine-vd9jl Месяц назад

Title got me interested and this conversation got me subbed. I look forward to watching the rest of your videos. Best wishes for you and your channel.

@haroldoluizrodriguesfilho7779 Месяц назад

Thanks for your considerations , the World needs to pay attention in your words and thoughts

@sabinehahn9774 2 месяца назад

"the Australians gonna defend Taiwan with us"? I wouldn't hold my breath on that one - the population is certainly not keen at all on doing so or being dragged by the US into another useless war, gonna be interesting if our government, whoever it may be at the time, is going to be able to force us.

@lyq232 Месяц назад

The government can always mobilise their armed forces without the consent of their civilians. Would that then be a political suicide for said ruling government? That's a different question

@glebskakovsky9475 Месяц назад

The war with nuclear capable enemy...

@arifra2062 Месяц назад

It doesn't matter what the population think, Australia is literally the lapdog of the US.

@alfanfajri409 Месяц назад

As an academic from a western country he speaks very neutrally and in accordance with academic values, unlike their hypocritical media

@Momowowo8 16 дней назад

one of the best podcasts i have listened to. always very inspiring to listen to Prof Mearsheimer!

@LordEdwards Месяц назад

Thanks for your honesty Mr. Mearshiemer

@faisalkamandobat3125 Месяц назад

Mearsheimer selalu logis dan akurat, seorang maestro dari sekolah realis. Tapi yang lebih membuat respek adalah integritas dan keberaniannya untuk bicara berdasarkan ilmunya, bukan berdasar keinginan penguasa.

@erwinlee2842 Месяц назад

Does Indonesian know if Indonesia ever become USA competitor Indonesia is the next on USA dinner table?

@kail9777 Месяц назад

Man you gotta love Professor Mearsheimer. I agree 95% with him except for the S. China sea issue as I do believe agreements will happen between the neighbors.