JOSH ALLEN OVERRATED? 😬 Mina Kimes defends Allen's command on offense | First Take 

The media is fuming because their golden boy is being called overrated. I like Josh but what makes him third best QB in the league like they want us to think? They want to criticize Lamar so badly when he's won everything except a chip because of the football MJ. "Well Lamar doesn't throw as pretty of a ball." And as much as they want to say Josh is a expert runner there's no QB currently playing that can outrun Lamar. So there you go.

Who is the last receiver to not have a career highs while playing with Allen? Fister, Beasley, smoke, Diggs and a few others , anybody that doesn't think Allen is the second best QB, if wasn't for rings and Andy Reid and kelce, stats wise allens better

That executive is absolutely RIGHT !! It ain’t no “flaw here or there” it’s everything ! He chokes each time in the postseason and in the biggest games ! Turnover machine. Did they not watch the same games that we did last season ?? 😂 Buffalo is done. They’ve had too many chances… fall short every time

Taking Lamar over josh allen

There are MAYBE 2 teams in the NFL that wouldn't take Josh Allen as their QB in a heartbeat. That's KC and the Bengals. #JA17 is a monster!

Leading the league in turnovers since you entered is worth criticism.. regardless of how good he is at the rest of being a QB, turnovers are unacceptable

He top 3 in turnovers since being drafted so how was the statement false

Everyone agrees he’s either the 2nd or 3rd best QB in the league yet he’s overrated lol

Allen is definitely overrated if you consider him a top 5 QB.

I m turning this off...WTF WE CRITICIZE DAK AND LAMAR all day...but josh is untouchable......why no melanin

2nd in turnovers. Yes he’s overrated he’s a decent qb but not elite.

I mean he is overrated

He is overrated and the fact that ESCNN has him ranked over LJ is even more laughable imo.

Kimberly Martin is the absolute worst!

Mahomes and Jackson are elite. I don't think Josh Allen even comes close to them at all. Mahomes vs Lamar is gonna be the real rivalry for many years to come along with Mahomes vs Burrow.

Mina. Stafford won a super bowl. Where is the argument. Jackson and other get hung for their style of play. Allen reminds me of brett f. But he won a superbowl. So a couple more years of the same result and it's over. Dak, burrow, herbet. And Tua. Allen's no scrub but very costly similar mistakes he keeps making.

Became the only QB in NFL History to have four straight seasons of 40+ touchdowns, if you wanna talk about overrated why don't we talk about Lamar 💀.

Joe Burrow, Josh Allan, Justin Herbert, Lamar Jackson, Brock Purdy, Dak Prescott, C .J Stroud Tua and Jalen Hurts can't all win a Superbowl in their careers. The law of average says only one or two will win at best 1 Superbowl in their career. Patrick Mohomes will win between 2 and 4 more Superbowls within 5 to 10 years from now. He will have 5 to 7 total when he's finished his career.

Omg YES finally!!! Someone other than LAMAR JACKSON getting some anonymous scrutiny!! This is amazing

He will continue to get criticism until he wins playoffs and superbowls. That is the bar. He lost to KC last season at home.

He's not overrated but when your stuck in a conference with the greatest active qb you'll always fall short because it just seems like its Mahomes era but if Allen was in the NFL he'd be dominant

I’m taking Lamar over Josh Allen every day

My favorite golfer is Greg Norman . My favorite Quarterback is Josh Allen . For exactly the same reasons . They both push the envelope . When it goes wrong , it goes off the rails . When they are on . They are the best that ever played . I know that no one will agree but Those guys are aiming for victory at all costs . There is only one gear , all in , going for it

Anonymous statement was spot on. Overrated in the sense people in the media often do not point out his flaws. “Immense talent, but he makes a lot of mistakes.” Watch the film and explain to me how that isn’t true. Yes, he’s a top five QB. But why is it frowned upon to point out the exact reasons Josh Allen is not above Joe Burrow or Patrick Mahomes.

I don't think he's overrated he's a clear top-5 QB imo he just has to go through Mahomes unfortunately

I think he’s 1B because if Josh had Mahomes defense he would have the same amount of Super Bowls.

Leading the league in turnovers since you got in the league is not a flaw here and there 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 “it’s not that he can’t read the defense it’s his confidence” brahhhhh yall are hilarious on this show just pure comedy with these takes now watch them talk crazy about Lamar 😴😴😴

OVERRATED AF!!!!

Josh Allen had 44 total TD's last season and won his division. How is he overrated? Let's not forget Buffalo before Josh Allen...rarely made the playoffs and irrelevant

He is over rated, along with Herbert, Jackson, Lawrence, Prescott, and depending on how this year goes maybe Burrow. Burrow took his team to a SB and Allen got close once but choked every other year. None of the rest have even come close to sniffing a SB and if these QB's are so great they should be able to lead their team's to a SB and win one. The media narrative is how great Allen is, how he can run and make this and that pass, again, I don't see that translate to a SB ring on a finger. Herbert & Prescott have done less than Allen but you all love to hype them up as well. Jackson has 1 playoff win and 2 MVP's. Every fan I know would rather their team & QB win one SB vs winning 5 MVP awards, they mean nothing, it's an accolade given by votes from others not by winning playoff games and what really matters SB wins. There are only two recent QB's who the media definitely hyped\hypes and are not over rated Brady & Mahommes, both have done and do more with less than any of the other QB's mentioned and they have done it consistently.

He is overrated

Josh Allen is the most talented QB in the NFL, both passing and running. No one else is even close.

He is the drexler to mahomes’s jordan

Yea at this point I see people dnt watch football at all lol

Allen would be top tier if he stopped turnovers and stop taking unnecessary damage. He’s game comes across as trying too hard at times when he’s team needs him to be more effective! He has the potential to be the greatest player in the league hands down!

You separate yourself from Lamar and Burrow because you are available. Lamar and Burrow get hurt a lot.

The Bills literally took the ball out of his hands the last 7 games and ran the ball 20+ times because he turned it over so much.

Brandon Beane is a puppet. Of course you're going to defend Josh Allen if you want to keep your job.

There’s a lot of overrated QBs now. In the past it was top tier, mid tier, then low/backup QBs. Now the talking heads want to remove the mid tier and have everyone top tier or low tier. Josh, with a lot of other current QBs are mid tier, and are talked as if they are top tier QBs, and that makes them overrated.

overrated

Josh Allen = modern day Tony romo. Can throw you into a game and can throw you right out one too

Top five QB in the NFL

Wow! He’s practically a gelding and they don’t even allow him to finish his take.

Lamar has won 2 MVPs over Josh Allen so I don’t understand why ESPN keeps talking about Josh like he’s top 3 when he’s not.

No SuperBowl doesnt make you overrated... is Dan Marino? Is Phillip Rivers? Randalll Cunningham? Mike Vick? This narrative by media that players who dont have Superbowl are trash is so stupid. How many games have we seen Allen do everything he could do to put his team in position and as a team they fail. I want Josh to try to make throws nobody can make because he can make them!! Theyre hating anonymously

Say anything about josh its ww3 its ok if he’s just ok

4 straight years of 40+ tds, only nfl player to ever do it but he’s somehow overrated? The 1 star recruit with 0 offers who accounts for 80+% of his total offenses production? Who didn’t have any run game until halfway through this last season? lol I’m convinced people just make stuff up to be edgy

I see everyone is is content dying on this josh Allen hill

All the Josh Allen criticism is coming after he had his best year ever and it is funny. And inaccurate. But the praise was premature and exaggerated

He's not overrated, but he hasn't beaten maholms when it mattered, smokin' Joe Burrow has

Lamar Jackson is overrated if Josh Allen is overrated

Allen would be the best QB in the league if he had a offense like my Eagles do....all you haters dont watch football your more like fantasy football weirdo's

That's the problem with you ESPN you act like a patriot and this is an sport, you can cover the NFL for a mellinium that doesn't give the right ok, act like pro not with the flak around your body 😂😂😂😂

I would love to know who this person is who said he is overrated

How many MVP’s does he have ? How many super bowls has he been to? Patrick/ Lamar/ Joe Burrow are better.

It’s fair

Yo quit hating on Josh real talk nobody perfect yo we all make mistakes it hard to even make the playoffs even harder to get to the Super Bowl I respect him go bills

The mustache is right !!!

Jes over rated hes basically a bret farve without a sb

Yes this man is absolutely overrated

This guy looks like he has a little sugar in the tank,,who is this guy

Well he is

I get both sides. When people compare Josh to Patrick Mahomes, yet they are two completely different tiers of players, that’s where the overrated comments make sense. Every time a person tries to put Josh on the same level as Mahomes I get frustrated. So depending on where you have him, he can very well be overrated

Josh is overrated

Kimberly & Mina Don’t talk You don’t know ball

They had to hit a …

Thank goodness the 716 here in Buffalo has a few in the national media that see what 17 does on the field. Love you Mina

Too many women on these shows.

This tool is a dope....

No super bowl for Josh Allen

Josh’s defense folds every year in the playoffs. Josh is one of the best if not they best when it really matters. Look at the #’s.

He would be the consensus best QB in the league if Mahomes and the chiefs didn’t exist.

there's a guy who was 2x NFL MVP who is overrated. josh allen literally has no accolades, how is he overrated?

3 girls and one guy talking about football. Jesus what is going on here

Trashhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Allen is Better than Mahomes it's just he's scared doing Superbowl if Josh would get to Superbowls like Mahomes and Build Comfordence he'll crush Him!

The dei showing in this video

OVERRATED.

I don’t need to say the obvious. 🥱 GO BILLS!!!!!!