Josh & Brennan live for the high seas 

The fact that Brennan drops the gnarly old sea captain voice and mannerisms to go for a general Irish accent and stance implies that his sea captain was faking his ways the whole time in order to try and act more sea captainy

I love the second skit because it's clear that Josh was ready to give up and move on after Brennan's bit but he just grabs him and says "No, we're doing this. Escalate. Go for it!"

"I call him Poseimi, 'cause he was always besi' me" is a deeply underappreciated line

Brennan just wanted the whale faced woman's lore 😂😂

"oh no c'mon girl" 1:29

“Oh no, come on girl” - Sea Lover Terry Menenecker

"I fell through my bed into a liminal world, and woke up fighting God in an arena of creatures." goes so hard😂

Brennan is an absolute genius at the "re-statement of what wackiness we have just established is reality" bits. Frickin' brilliant, the both of them.

I love how the ending effectively confirms that Terry Minninicker was telling the truth this entire time

Did not see the crab coming, I thought he was gonna reveal he was Poseidon all along lmao 🤣

I love the "my fever dream is burning hotter than yours" vibes going on.

I love the look of awe on Brennan's face as Josh gets more and more unhinged as it goes on

"You, Terry Menaniker, are my favorite" 😂

this is one of my absolute favorite recurring bits on all of dropout. the way josh delivers "to allow me to fish again!!" is so impassioned and incredible, in such a silly ass context shoutout to jacob wysocki's surfer & skateboarder bits too

Brennan: "...and I got a witch to spit on the stumps and I stuck 'em back on!" Josh: "Holy fuck!"

I just noticed that Brennan lights up a cigarette in addition to his pipe in the first one (0:32). The little touches are just crazy.

In an Attenborrough voice "In the end we can see Brennan, although giving his best in this contest of creativity and wits, retreating in a playfull aknowledgment of defeat. But, as we know this fearcly creature, he will come back for more."

4:37 My first time watching this, i was really hoping he'd say "a bowling ball the size of a bowling ball" for some reason

I don't know why but, "I didn't take enough breath, I fuckin died", always cracks me up. 😂

The fishermen compare scars skit just reeks of that scene in Jaws when they are getting drunk on the boat, I half expected it to end with an anecdote about the USS Indianapolis...

1:16 I love that both Brennan and Zac have to turn away from Josh basically in sync because of that line.

"Come on, girl." Has me cackling every single time

Pretty fucking boring McKale

Brennan: "Okay, so she comes up to you and says *I'm the sea and I'm in love with you* ?" Josh: "Well, no, excuse me, I wish, am I wrong?" I am dying! XD

1. How was "braids like barnacles" not addressed 2. I was a little disappointed they didn't bring back the whale woman for the gnarly injuries prompt

The Whale Faced Woman was very Hilda Hilda.

why does joh's fisherman characters all seem like drunk or high...

This is just the "My uncle from Nintendo" of fisherman stories.

Major props to Josh in this! He knew he was gonna have to go head to head against Brennan at his own game for this bit, and absolutely nailed it!

Terry Mennenecker is the grizzled old sea daddy we didn’t know we needed.

Always here for Brennan as anything on MSN, but Josh has some great bits of descriptive oneupmanship here. "Blows me up like a roadkill cartoon full of air come back to life... whole tourist o' banana boat girls... I tell 'em what happened - no-one believes." "That's pretty fuckin' boring, McHale, coz it don't compare to the time I fell through my bed into a liminal world..." "I fought a crab in a big hat! A tiny hand with guns for fingernails! A boat that screamed! And I split, McHale!" Like the Four Yorkshiremen meets Jaws by way of Lovecraft.

This legit gave me a tension headache from smiling

brennan's reaction to the whale woman reminds me of his reaction to sniddies

Years from now this is going to be the textbook example of how to “yes, and” someone

Josh and Brennan is endgame form

poseimeemeeo

Finally the origins of *BILLLL SEACASTER, FATHER (slight pause) OF FABIAN SEACASTER CAPTAIN OF THE HANGMAN*

Who else wants to hear Josh give a great Werner Herzog impression?

"Oh no come on girl"

"Oh no come-on gurl" my favourite moment ever

If bill Cosby was a pirate

Seamen showoff sounds like a fair competition lmao

I insist to this day that that point should've gone to Josh for that, "Oh, no! C'mon, Gurllll." xDDDD I seriously DIE every time I hear it! XDDDD

Holy Fuck 😂😂😂😂😂😂

Incredible! This channel is going to soar with subscribers ❤

i came with all my sea men.

1:25 synchronicity