Тёмный

JSC interview of Advocate B R Tokota SC for the Eastern Cape High Court (Judges Matter) 

Judges Matter
Подписаться 19 тыс.
Просмотров 537 тыс.
50% 1

Judicial Service Commission October 2016 interview of Advocate B R Tokota for the Eastern Cape High Court.
Judges Matter is a South African non-profit organisation dedicated to encouraging broad-based public engagement with the important process of selecting the judges of the land. For more info: www.judgesmatte...

Опубликовано:

 

28 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 549   
@shevshenko1432
@shevshenko1432 5 лет назад
Whether you like it or not the old man is brilliant and cannot be intimidated, he is principled.
@andrewsiyomunji8260
@andrewsiyomunji8260 2 года назад
He is been there and done that and its clear he can see through Malema.
@dumisani685
@dumisani685 Год назад
Yes he is principled man no intimidation whatsoever.
@melusibuthelezi7707
@melusibuthelezi7707 3 месяца назад
💯 right and the question from Malema is unnecessary
@nokomahlachane2591
@nokomahlachane2591 5 лет назад
This is the best interview I have seen. His reasoning capacity is sharp. Malema tried to corner him but he wouldn't budge. What a wise man.
@mzukulukadezingana9426
@mzukulukadezingana9426 5 лет назад
Yhaaaa Dokota is very intelligent in this issue of taking this questions
@annetjieEnslin
@annetjieEnslin Год назад
YES HE WAS WAKE-UP. 😂
@akramebrahim1446
@akramebrahim1446 3 года назад
Never get tired of watching this gentleman. I hope he is still practicing law.
@Vusumzi23
@Vusumzi23 Год назад
He is my brother and extremely competent at it constantly.
@NtateMap
@NtateMap 7 месяцев назад
I think he is still practicing the law. I once checked judges at some Divisions in Eastern Cape...I came across a name by Tokota surname
@patricklangat681
@patricklangat681 Год назад
I am a Kenyan but I must comment on advocate Tokota. Old is gold.
@MichaelMakgoba
@MichaelMakgoba 8 лет назад
This old man is indeed good and I totally agree when you argue with facts no one can defeat you....
@JohnBradley-ys4dj
@JohnBradley-ys4dj Год назад
Do you know you can make R80,000 in 7 days
@yonelayonela2591
@yonelayonela2591 3 года назад
Even now I am still watching this interesting interview🤣 Tokota J was on fire👌
@zibalulemdeni2334
@zibalulemdeni2334 4 года назад
Commissioner Malema got his match here. ADv. Tokota, now Judge, was well prepared and he firmly directed his answers with confidence. I loved this interview. By far, it's my favorite.
@atlpoweredpete9126
@atlpoweredpete9126 6 лет назад
The ONLY Man to score one on JuJu, it did balance out as stated at the end.
@simon10500
@simon10500 Год назад
After all he must have gone through during his time as a magistrate, no wonder he was able to deal with the questions with such dignity and intelligence. When a man has his principles at the forefront of his judgement, he is immovable. I wish we had a judge like this man in my country Zimbabwe.
@onthusitsejmosie8199
@onthusitsejmosie8199 4 года назад
Well , who is watching this interview in 2020 ? The old man was completely prepared he was on fire ,black intelligence ,he mst be recommended to serve at the Supreme Court of Apeal straight away bottom and klaar
@thembafosi4608
@thembafosi4608 4 года назад
I must say this comes with experience, he didn't panic nor be under pressure. Just love the voice also
@sanelevv3285
@sanelevv3285 4 года назад
He is good bt he was a little impolite at times. Asking back questions is a no no in an interview no matter how poked u may feel.
@munyaradzinherera3383
@munyaradzinherera3383 4 года назад
He should not be interviewed for his next job, he has covered them all. He is good!
@aneleanele5878
@aneleanele5878 3 года назад
Fully agree, judges don't retire. He is still energetic to serve.
@AFRICANISER
@AFRICANISER 3 года назад
I decided to watch it again Advocate Tokota SC was prepared.
@magatephala895
@magatephala895 Год назад
Highly experienced Jurist. We continue to learn from you Judge Tokota 🙌🙌🙌
@wadenya1
@wadenya1 5 лет назад
Just brilliant, Mr Tokota. I sincerely hope that they gave you the opportunity to be the Judge. My, my, my!
@nkgaochelsia5987
@nkgaochelsia5987 5 лет назад
Well done Adv... You handle the little malema just very great... He cannot politically manipulate a legal mind neverrrrr... All the way from University of Limpopo
@lo-amijohannes9109
@lo-amijohannes9109 3 года назад
I keep coming back to this interview 2021
@katlehomosiasekolanyane8743
@katlehomosiasekolanyane8743 2 года назад
Me too
@tineshambambeva3592
@tineshambambeva3592 2 года назад
This guy is on point the way he answers questions a sharp gentlemen.Haa determined to change the system
@JohnBradley-ys4dj
@JohnBradley-ys4dj Год назад
Do you know you can make R80,000 in 7 days
@nyamekomazeka9490
@nyamekomazeka9490 4 года назад
A brilliant advocate indeed. He cannot be politically manipulated
@ZibaTV
@ZibaTV 4 года назад
Advocate B R Tokota, i always watch this video for wisdom,he's principled
@vusumuzimchunu292
@vusumuzimchunu292 4 года назад
He put this alarmist in his place
@lintlhoanemosielle3796
@lintlhoanemosielle3796 4 года назад
Adv. Tokota answered questions with great style. He's really on top of questions, relevant answers were all over his sides.
@MathematicsMadeSimple1
@MathematicsMadeSimple1 7 месяцев назад
2024 and the interview feels fresh, I like the integrity of this house.
@magatephala895
@magatephala895 Год назад
Six year later.....still watching and learning more ✍️✍️✍️
@dumisani685
@dumisani685 Год назад
The wisdom displayed by Judge Tokota is amazing. He has facts very clever 👏
@siphebawozuzile6936
@siphebawozuzile6936 5 лет назад
UMalema uqhele ukwenza alungelwe, hay kulenkonde, yincuba-buchopho yomthetho, I salute you Advocate Tokota
@jcftmkdalaxiy632
@jcftmkdalaxiy632 4 года назад
Malema is there to ensure that you have the best, objective and unbiased judge in the judiciary
@masibulelefrance2947
@masibulelefrance2947 2 года назад
Haybo Malema is there to ensure they are hiring good candidate
@CredoMaxwell
@CredoMaxwell 14 дней назад
Ngumakhwenkwetha lo 😂
@simahousemusic6500
@simahousemusic6500 8 лет назад
Well done Adv. Tokota, handled this interview very well with confidence in what you're saying. As for Malema who thinks he's the real G everywhere he goes, sit down and let those who know best do the job...
@alagiedarboe7928
@alagiedarboe7928 4 года назад
Sima HouseMusic you don’t know shitt
@nathimkhondwane8245
@nathimkhondwane8245 Год назад
Guys its 2023, i am still here I love Judge Tokota, he is everything👌🏾
@Wisparshik
@Wisparshik 6 месяцев назад
Hey it's 2024 I've just returned to rewatch this video
@ZaneleMlangeni-b5o
@ZaneleMlangeni-b5o Год назад
You are the man Mr tekoto❤
@anathimaqungo5227
@anathimaqungo5227 6 лет назад
"Maybe mhlambi" IsiXhosa kicked in. Hahahaha Judge Tokota is leadership
@minenhlekhumalo5351
@minenhlekhumalo5351 5 лет назад
Always happen to me too.
@wadenya1
@wadenya1 5 лет назад
What is mhlambi?
@phiwamchunu3796
@phiwamchunu3796 4 года назад
@@wadenya1 maybe, perhaps, probably.
@onthusitsejmosie8199
@onthusitsejmosie8199 3 года назад
Maybe
@MurimiJ
@MurimiJ Год назад
What does that mean?
@Vusumzi23
@Vusumzi23 Год назад
My brother nailed this interview, and I am yet to see any better interview than this, each time I watch it, it feels anew. He demonstrated great level of competence as he actually live it in real sense.
@bongatokota5291
@bongatokota5291 Год назад
This is best interview ever
@patrickkama2574
@patrickkama2574 5 лет назад
Big up to you adv tokota, we need people like you in this country
@ncebantweni5433
@ncebantweni5433 6 лет назад
"You cannot politically manipulate me...you can call it apartheid or whatever..." I still enjoy this interview.
@tendanirerani1331
@tendanirerani1331 6 лет назад
He killed it when he said should I have striked?
@wadenya1
@wadenya1 5 лет назад
JM was being petty. Even his next door commissioners openly displayed their discomfiture at his high handedness.
@stardust6191
@stardust6191 4 года назад
@@wadenya1 People with low self esteem normally say such things. They can only criticise.
@smd2505
@smd2505 4 года назад
I think the approach he took was "When I was in Rome, I did as Romans do" however one cannot take away the critical intellectual style of Juju's questionnaire and how he setups narrow minded and highly emotional politicians on debate platforms, the point Malema is coming from is how the post 94 youth should imply and apply their minds in current debates along the future of this country, however he should have admitted the system was a no good system, I think when he said "what I should have done" he was just hiding behind the thumb. The system needed to be challenged indeed, however Tokota was focusing or prioritizing on his articles and qualification rather than engaging and confronting the most harmful system ever imposed in our country. So for me a combination of thumbs up and down for both Juju & Tokota.
@mihlaliqoma9039
@mihlaliqoma9039 4 года назад
You're spot on
@katlehomosiasekolanyane8743
@katlehomosiasekolanyane8743 3 года назад
Great insight. But the fact remains he is a brilliant judicial officer, I like the impartiality
@mongezimtshweni176
@mongezimtshweni176 Год назад
I kept this interview on recap particularly I can't get tired of watching it
@godblessmemercy2438
@godblessmemercy2438 4 года назад
I wish Mr Tokota was my dad. His children must be lucky to have him as a father.
@inasigwabe1160
@inasigwabe1160 3 года назад
Brilliant guy tjooo
@bongatokota5291
@bongatokota5291 Год назад
Hiz a father of the village where we come from
@ugonne8456
@ugonne8456 4 года назад
I'm from Nigeria watching from Nederland i love this Malema. I skipped to reach his questions
@briankhanyile1426
@briankhanyile1426 2 года назад
My favorite interview......this candidate was well prepared. 👌👌👌👌 "look at the background and ignore the facts, that is not how I was trained " 🤣🤣
@mjnawa9228
@mjnawa9228 4 года назад
The old man is a real deal🤣 I vote for Him. He's unshakable. Law is his life
@gragkulanimhlanga6357
@gragkulanimhlanga6357 8 лет назад
lol eyo this guy dealt with Malema lol I respect him...he is boss
@aconable
@aconable 8 лет назад
ha ha ha ha eish
@wadenya1
@wadenya1 5 лет назад
He cut JM to size.
@nqobathabede5869
@nqobathabede5869 7 лет назад
Lol Dokota is so damn good, I want to be a lawyer.
@pallysithole2697
@pallysithole2697 5 лет назад
Lool hambknjn mfana wasophongolo
@siviwekulu6996
@siviwekulu6996 4 года назад
Me too 😃
@sanelemfene246
@sanelemfene246 4 года назад
I heard about him Just came to witness the unwavering stalwart of law.
@harunaabbas8367
@harunaabbas8367 4 года назад
Advocate Takota is a superb, facing hon malema in interview is like crossing a fire. I love this judge
@thembisaodendaal
@thembisaodendaal 3 года назад
This is the kind we need in this country a man of unwavering principles Dokota
@francoiscalldo2958
@francoiscalldo2958 Год назад
How can a politician without any credential, interrogate a jurist and decide capable or not😮
@oscarkasalile3966
@oscarkasalile3966 Год назад
Old is gold
@roycedelp5868
@roycedelp5868 8 лет назад
I understand what exactly Malema meant when he says all this questions. Remember the Judges who handled Marikana Report where saying things like Muthi and so on. He again likes the judge.
@bhekaninzimande4124
@bhekaninzimande4124 4 года назад
I like Adv Tokota's confidence. Yes, he did not do well in some questions from Commissioner Malema. However the last two questions were well attended to very well.
@shaibuabdallah8878
@shaibuabdallah8878 Год назад
Very disrespectful approach by Malema....But he got the right medication from Judge Tokota
@lungankinti9966
@lungankinti9966 4 года назад
The commisioners came to listen to Adv Tokota here..the guy is good..Im glad he got the job.
@vusumuzimchunu292
@vusumuzimchunu292 4 года назад
He got it crs??
@lungankinti9966
@lungankinti9966 4 года назад
@@vusumuzimchunu292 yes he is now a Judge in the Eastern Cape division.
@vusumuzimchunu292
@vusumuzimchunu292 4 года назад
@@lungankinti9966 ameeeeen
@SelloTlhako-n3x
@SelloTlhako-n3x 9 месяцев назад
Guys i also watch this Video everyday he answered Malema so well and with respect
@paulrobertson6864
@paulrobertson6864 3 года назад
This man is full OK wisdom
@lethamagatladi2680
@lethamagatladi2680 3 года назад
Adv Tokota still in 2021. Bravo!
@lukazonke7501
@lukazonke7501 Год назад
Now, imaging if candidates were asked the same questions. How would Dali mpofu handled those type of questions.
@tsheponcamane2018
@tsheponcamane2018 Год назад
I think apartheid question was one that I think got to him, he could have have said that the system was bad but he did his best to be fair,especially when his most centered argument is that the law is based on facts. Otherwise he stood his ground against one of the toughest questioner of the JSC
@zukofudumele9255
@zukofudumele9255 Год назад
𝘠𝘦𝘴 𝘺𝘩𝘰𝘰𝘰!😢
@franknkya3947
@franknkya3947 2 года назад
I love this Advocate.
@moeketsanesethojane3150
@moeketsanesethojane3150 4 года назад
i came here in 202, this judge is the best
@stefangriesel3562
@stefangriesel3562 3 года назад
Deserving candidate. Give this man a Bells.
@oscarmutoti3993
@oscarmutoti3993 2 года назад
U are the best u stand by what you believe unlike Zondo who struggled to answer questions
@qalilenasir3726
@qalilenasir3726 5 лет назад
Malama spiting fire wisdom..he looking into guy soul..wut have u done for black ppl..can u see da suffering our ppl..
@Stanley0781
@Stanley0781 3 месяца назад
My favourite, adv Tokota. No stage fright, well articulated this one. "What do you expect me to do as a Magistrate...to strike...?"
@siyanxumalo4230
@siyanxumalo4230 Год назад
Ngibuya njalo ngizoyibuka le-interview. Lo baba is brilliant and uyayazi into akhuluma ngayo. He handled uJulius ngendlela emnandi kakhulu. Malema must not think he is brighter than bonke abantu.
@sbanimagwaza7024
@sbanimagwaza7024 Год назад
My man when true judiciary officer stood firm.
@ndumzazeke2468
@ndumzazeke2468 4 года назад
Wow what an interview yerrr mr tokota ..he is brilliant
@bennedictmaine888
@bennedictmaine888 5 месяцев назад
You don’t have to use bombastic English to be factual…..thank you Judge ✊🏾
@kuschprince3216
@kuschprince3216 3 года назад
"Muti in South Africa" and Kamuti in Kenya!! Wow! Wow!
@philkazanga
@philkazanga 2 года назад
Excellent interview in recent years
@BachelorMaree-mw2ow
@BachelorMaree-mw2ow 2 месяца назад
The old man tears into mogoeng and Julius Sametime 😮
@Noname-hc5uw
@Noname-hc5uw 4 года назад
Malena fearless, always asking the tough questions. And not afraid to speak the truth.
@alfredoleza6955
@alfredoleza6955 3 года назад
Malema is asking nonsense... Law favours no1
@Noname-hc5uw
@Noname-hc5uw 3 года назад
@@alfredoleza6955 Really!? When was the last time you saw poor people making the laws? It's the rich and powerful who makes the laws, and you only hope the the rich and powerful have consideration for the poor and marginalized, when they are making the laws.
@dyondzokhosa4511
@dyondzokhosa4511 3 года назад
In ds one he was lost He will never even a single day face a man like ds
@simphiwemkhize9475
@simphiwemkhize9475 7 лет назад
Lol it one of those Judges that doesn't take nonsense.
@ULTIM01
@ULTIM01 4 года назад
It depends what you call nonsense. He admitted to tolerating nonsense by not being able to do anything about a system he considered to be imperfect. And while Julius might have asked questions that seemed offensive it was necessary to see if the old man has gathered enough experience to maintain composure if poked a little
@simphiwemkhize9475
@simphiwemkhize9475 Год назад
​@@ULTIM01 we just gonna speculate now
@Kodak718
@Kodak718 2 года назад
I wish the judge would have just answered the question as it was presented. I hate when people play with words. The question was in a scenario like that who would you pick not what should the council do in that situation.
@sindiletobayo3350
@sindiletobayo3350 2 месяца назад
I think it's you who doesn't want to understand the real issue here
@kabelodavid9590
@kabelodavid9590 8 лет назад
Tokota is key managed to wrestle Malema
@gjambaya3552
@gjambaya3552 4 года назад
The judge is unshakable.
@kamohelomaphokoane3831
@kamohelomaphokoane3831 11 месяцев назад
i am sure i have watched this interview for 7 times now...first time in 2019 when i thought i was going to be a lawyer one day. Now it is 2023 studying Education..
@siviwekulu6996
@siviwekulu6996 4 года назад
Did Advocate Tokota get the job? He's brilliant 👊🏿😃
@inasigwabe1160
@inasigwabe1160 3 года назад
Yes he was appointed in 2017
@siviwekulu6996
@siviwekulu6996 3 года назад
@@inasigwabe1160 great 😊🙌🏾
@lutwamaeric4646
@lutwamaeric4646 5 лет назад
Every time I watch this interview I like judge Tokota the more.
@phiwamchunu3796
@phiwamchunu3796 5 лет назад
me too
@vusumuzimchunu292
@vusumuzimchunu292 4 года назад
He so smart advocate tokota
@matttoddx6812
@matttoddx6812 4 года назад
Old man is intelligent...
@ramkeransusanann796
@ramkeransusanann796 3 года назад
Enjoyed this interview
@goodcomment5943
@goodcomment5943 4 года назад
Julius is a very intelligent man I love he is vocal in all aspects he is he fear no one He say always see the true
@ayandamali9479
@ayandamali9479 8 лет назад
Tokota is KEY
@tshikelosobuthongo2612
@tshikelosobuthongo2612 Год назад
I cannot stop watching this old man.
@khanyancoyini1053
@khanyancoyini1053 4 года назад
So proud!!
@AkaliciousZA
@AkaliciousZA 3 года назад
I hope advocate Tokota is a judge right now.
@raeesaasmal736
@raeesaasmal736 2 года назад
He is a Judge in the Eastern Cape Division of the High Court
@andilefede8806
@andilefede8806 4 года назад
This was experience at play!!✌🏽
@akramebrahim1446
@akramebrahim1446 4 года назад
Brilliant adv Takota!!.
@dineolekaba4600
@dineolekaba4600 5 лет назад
Well done Judge Tokota.u admirer me .
@katlholosebogodi3118
@katlholosebogodi3118 2 года назад
I think this man deserve that position ....
@chrischleopa7738
@chrischleopa7738 4 года назад
This old man is very intelligent
@tshepotshabalala3531
@tshepotshabalala3531 Год назад
Adv tokota. Is a very good man.give him that job.
@kediboneraphulu8717
@kediboneraphulu8717 Год назад
Malema got his match
@Todd.maestro1232
@Todd.maestro1232 3 года назад
This was an awesome interview judge was hired
@maynardchimaliro5593
@maynardchimaliro5593 4 года назад
Well done judge 💯 you know your job
@obakengnkadimang9209
@obakengnkadimang9209 4 года назад
he was very impressive. he should have been given the job. Zondo and the chief justice used the emotions to the advantage of the appointment of zondo
@wuokwandafm3204
@wuokwandafm3204 4 года назад
So he was not appointed the judge?? Very sad
@simphiwemkhize9475
@simphiwemkhize9475 4 года назад
They were being interviewed for two different structures, what are you talking about?
@wuokwandafm3204
@wuokwandafm3204 4 года назад
@@simphiwemkhize9475 Asking if he was given the job? M not privy to any structure thereof.
@simphiwemkhize9475
@simphiwemkhize9475 4 года назад
@@wuokwandafm3204 yes
@wuokwandafm3204
@wuokwandafm3204 4 года назад
@@simphiwemkhize9475 Thanks bro
@jabulanipeter2910
@jabulanipeter2910 Год назад
The question about muti seem to be not helping in this interview
@debby8969
@debby8969 Год назад
Love Judge Tokota❤
@tshalisebela9991
@tshalisebela9991 2 года назад
Advocate Tokoto was supposed to just answer by a simple yes when commissioner malema to was asking whether he was trained by apartheid regime government.
@yangamdlokolo7116
@yangamdlokolo7116 5 лет назад
Malema your're a small boy to this Judge....big up Tokota
@Bearded_Abdul
@Bearded_Abdul 4 года назад
You only like the law when it is working in your favour
@muedanyisinthumule699
@muedanyisinthumule699 2 года назад
The old man has been a magistrate before malema was born and you aspect Julius to win over him come on guy's
@hammondafricacd2678
@hammondafricacd2678 6 лет назад
Solid, Principled and experienced Judge! He made minced meat of Malema who seems overly scarred with hurts and pain from the apartheid era. I'm West African, not South African, but I think that people like Malema keep reopening wounds that are healing pretty well, howbeit slowly. The problems of racism and tribalism will not go away overnight or ever, but its now time for more people of colour to push on to a point of immense relevance. We live in a world where the stronger race/specie dominates. Yes, we (blacks) have been treated badly, but instead of belabouring the historical atrocities of weak minded racists, lets look forward to new black man who is looking beyond the songs of his history and driving fearlessly to conquer and dominate his world, respecting the rights and dignity of others as human beings. #jashammond #panafrican #forwardthinkingafrican
@FA-jw1sx
@FA-jw1sx 6 лет назад
Am from West Africa too, I think you can't really be educated. To say they keep reopening old wound, is very short sighted and not within your capacity as a West African person. Why don't you say that to the Jews that reminds all of the harm they suffered from Hitler and see if you won't be arrested for anti-Semitism.
@kindomofghana
@kindomofghana 5 лет назад
@@FA-jw1sx Excellent response!! I'm West African as well and I must say, for some strange reason many West Africans (not all) tend to be very ignorant and naive when it concerns the dynamics of race relations.
@lutwamaeric4646
@lutwamaeric4646 5 лет назад
I agree with you.Actually today the continent is struggling with corrupt black men eating away their own kin.For me it's a bigger problem than apartheid and slave trade,this is a problem by fellow housemates.
@moeketsanesethojane4538
@moeketsanesethojane4538 Год назад
This advocate his mental capacity is beyond these people's comprehension to such a level am quite sure they still dont understand even up until today.
@yomommasugerfoot9039
@yomommasugerfoot9039 3 года назад
I love him already.
@zwelihlemtshali9240
@zwelihlemtshali9240 5 лет назад
😂🤣😂 Ey lidala ikhehla Malema mfana. Adv Tokota would make a good judge. "My stand is like this,.... when I look at the FACTS You cannot politically manipulate me"
@dominicorero712
@dominicorero712 3 года назад
The last statement was directed to malema
@siphesihleartwell4602
@siphesihleartwell4602 11 месяцев назад
I don't believe in judgements that place 0 weight on the South African history in this context, there's a reason to consider race, but the question would be how much weight should be placed on such consideration. The Constitution its self acknowledges Historical injustices and seek to achieve transformation, why would a judge not consider race at all? Mr. Malema was asking good questions on this one. Apartheid law practioners applied the law rigidly and seldom applied their minds placing more reliance on legal rules and outcomes that such rules prescribe.
@ndarasamuels4793
@ndarasamuels4793 Год назад
This advocate is superb, made malemo something.
@kingluthernkawane3204
@kingluthernkawane3204 4 года назад
I hope he got appointed
Далее
ТАРАКАН
00:38
Просмотров 322 тыс.
Barno
00:22
Просмотров 569 тыс.
Julius Malema vs Rian Van Heerden
39:05
Просмотров 1 млн
Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng 67 minutes Leadership Talk
1:19:24
ТАРАКАН
00:38
Просмотров 322 тыс.