Judaism vs Christianity on Sin: Rabbi Tovia Singer Explains Why We Differ 

Hi Eric, that must be so hard, to live apart from Jewish community. Here’s why you know you are right; does it make sense to have to pray through a third person to communicate with G-d who loves you as his child and is your best friend? Do they realize that praying to statues and paintings is idol worship? And who is Jesus to the Jews? He is our cousin. We are all cousins. Jesus would be so sad at how many have died “in his name”. He would not want it that way. He was a good Jew, just reminding us to stay on the path, as Elijah, Isaiah, and Moses did. Now and then we need a reminder, apparently.

As another fellow Midwesterner, I know what you mean.

As a history major btw I can ensure you that this feeling you have is why Jewish enclaves have formed. It's not the only reason but it's a reason.

I believe you know in your heart what is true. Don’t let what others say sway you. Find your tribe. They are out there!

I just block them because they are extremely rude. They do not understand that Judaism & Christianity are two completely different religions.

Thank you!

Check out Islam. Muhammad was a true prophet. You should investigate it for your own sake.

Peace and love

Islam is the the religion of Gentiles. if you want to be Jewish but also accept Jesus Islam is the way. The foretold Noahide Religion.

All the best to you in your quest. I'll just leave you with one thought that I hope you are aware of. Although the religions of the world firmly believe that the only way to heaven is their way, Judaism is totally not like that. If you are not a muslim to the muslims or a christian to the christians you are going straight to hell according to them. It doesn't matter who you are or how righteous you are. In judaism we know that as long as you are a good person you have a share in heaven just like any good jew. You don't have to be a jew at all. As long as you keep the Noachide laws which are all basic moral laws that any good person intrinsically knows deep down already, you are good to go. Just believe in one God and be a good person. Then you will accomplish in this world and do the one thing we are put on this planet to do, grow. Good luck to you.

@@erasethehate5616 no

@Iyas kelu actually watched hundreds of his videos. He couldn't be more honest and make Jews everywhere who have different opinions on everything so happy with literally 99.9% of all videos. And books are lrettu cheap. He definitely isn't getting rich. You are just another angry christian with no way to defend yourself so lashing out and using aggression. Would ne nice to you nut you just seek to discredit the ine guy helping the mist people here. If you don't likexhis videos stop coming to his channel and watching them

@Iyas kelu nothing he has taught is false and I didn't have to trust him. More like usually many opinions even within rabbis from orthodox Judaism yet he manages to not be wrong about literally anything. You see yourself he almost always is referencing text nd it almost always being tanach. He is right hebteaches truth Jesus and christianity and the Nt are 100% false though we knew that before Rabbi Singer Abd you have argued with me plenty before too. You have never been right when doing so. Ever. You just waste people's time. I couldn't be any more sincere when I tell you that your rekogion Is false and a real joke.

Eli, HaShem will not punish anyone for being a different religion. We are all His children and we will all meet in heaven. Shalom.

We can only know as much as we can at anytime in our lives. Hashem considers the heart. The majority have been literate maybe 150-175 yrs. and now internet. As an Education major, intelligent people are afflicted with reading disorders so they don't. I'm lucky.

@@debrapaulino918 so they don’t… do what? I don’t understand. Btw early Hebrew was found on a cave wall on the exodus route, in an uninhabited area. The Jewish people were reading Torah widely by 200 BCE.

He will, Hashem will punish them for their idolatry. It is very sad, but we can do nothing but save ourselves and our loved ones who are still alive today.

Don’t worry God is not a prejudiced Jew Christian or Muslim and Hindu God doesn’t care about puny man made religions that were written by humans in the name of god every one except fools know that god is not a respecter of religions races individuals planets star systems universes aliens Rather HE knows everyone and their intentions each will be judged by how clean your conscience is when you die Unclean conscience no religion or religious practice can save you So ask who of your relatives has a clean conscience never mind man made religions

Some are mixed up about good and why we have a written Scripture to tell us. How long before we would probably go back to human sacrifices to gods? Look what ecumenism has already done. Eliminate Torah and anything is possible.

Jared we are only made in the image of God , Art is one of his many gifts some paint , sculpt ,write,sport excel , design buildings in honour of God before people could read the listened and looked at pictures drawn on walls they became elaborate 3 dimensional to focus ones mind . Dont confuse a statue painting or scroll with idolatry

What are you talking about Allah is the same God as of children of israel if you want proof watch rabbi Tovia video about it.peace

@@287_shaikhmustafa7 Muhammad is a false prophet and a sinful man using G-d to fulfill his selfish heinous desires and lusts.

Adom Olam check it out on youtube

No. Why would it. G-d has great reason for it to take place in his plan. In fact tou would agree of yoi knew the reason and coupd understand it. You don't think G-d has excuses for everything he does? Because personally of trust G-d. Your average christian missionary wannabe no. But G-d yes.

No just on improving. Sinless is not aword we would ever use and wouldn't be a helpful word. Weirdo christian. If tou want to be sinless don't bother Jews proselytising eve4. You are wanting their nation wiped out and it is no less evil than a terrorist wanting their nation wiped out. Youxate that bad right now. No need to think aboit sinless anytime soon

Joshua this very platform is surrounded by sinfull advertising half Naked people its like the Garden of eden .but so called Teachers dont mind to line the pocket with it , i cant cast a stone nor should you

Protestant Messianic disregard the final sacrifice of their risen lord. Mainstreamers think Messianic is returning to the law which the NT says is over and in the first place was only for Jews. Job 4:14 states "who can draw what is pure from what is not pure. No one."

?? He says he is at war with himself doing what his higher self says not to do. "Woe is me."... He also advocates celibacy and castration. Borderline Personality Disorder in that guy.

May I suggest moving into the left side of the Bible instead of dwelling on Rome.

Seems the Bible can always say two things, so God is in fact the author of confusion i guess.

@@jaclynrichmond1049 Actually for the same reason he spoke in parables, its not for everyone to figure out. Only those who study to show themselves approved and establish the word of truth by 2 or 3 witnesses line upon line precept upon precept. Rightly dividing the word of truth from lies inserted by lying scribes to deceive people. Jer 8.8. Most never find the truth because they are too lazy to search for it. Where your heart is there your treasure will be also.

Meh…though yes Rome also incorporated many of its own paganistic influences, it wasn’t Rome per se. There is so so much wrong with Christianity…and Always was. Infact, the entire thing was always false, fabricated, corrupted or misunderstood.

Actually they were told and the consequence was stated. They didn't understand death. Her gratefulness for help that brought forth a son can be understood as the birthing event being uncomfortably traumatic. This is an instance in which pashat is needed. There can be many opinions but only one pashat.

@@debrapaulino918 Where did God command Eve not to eat the fruit? And how would they know what death was?

@@journeyintothebible Genesis 3:3

Jay Nunez , Abe! That's what We call 8 Revelation's !!!

I was having the same issue, but if you listen with headphones you can hear him.

@@edcrfvtgbyhnujmikolpqazwsx oh yeah funny it actually works hehe Thanks a lot buddy God bless

What's your point?

@@autifmalik8742 That she doesn't know ... but doesn't know it ... believing instead the lie that her source for her statement is valid as taught by her leaders.

It is taught by Paul also and in the gospels. "Where O death is your sting.". "I am the resurrection and the life."

“Defeat death” 😂. Ok let me know how that works out.

Church patriarch to his Council of Bishops in 235 AD stated Jews always believed it was themselves. Rashi didn't change it as missionaries claim.

Laura he gas so so many isaiah 53 videos. Just search and choose one

Darkness is not the inverse of logic but a part of it. Whether in nature or in the human mind, it all has purpose. Since you're persuaded at this time by the logic you possess, Romans 8:28 tells you it all works together for good to them who love G-d. At this time you see it as loving JC. A bud opens to it's maturity then returns to the darkness of the soil. Hashem loves you and is watching over the budding of your conscious awareness as the husbandman of your soul. Shalom dear soul much loved.

When you know G-d you will worship G-d all day long. A little book for you: The Kuzari by Yehuda Halevi. Don't pass this one by. Amazon.

Am I wrong about you believing the NT? I won't put you down. Your comment was fine.

Mkst aren't for sin or atonement at all for givingnthanksnandnotherbstuffm onky 2 are yoi able to bring for just some of your lowest grade sins. If your poor theyxvsn even be flour and pil and such called a meal offering and havexnoxmeat or blood. Dint ever get your information in tanachxor Jews from the Nat. That is the worst place to go. Rhatxbookcis full of jew hate and misinformation

Chaya Bat-Tzvi Very interesting. I think it originated (or was at least popularized) with Lutheranism, but I may be mistaken there. What do they teach as what constitutes it? Is it as arbitrary and all-encompassing as in fundamentalism? :)

Wow a completely unsubstantiated statement. Whatva waste of everyone's time

Depends. Everything eill be taken into account. If someone grew up in idolatry and never knew better that will be fairly taken into account

No

@@debrapaulino918 So, until that new covenant is instituted you are living under a covenant that God has disregarded.

@Steven Thyng no you really screwed up bad and thanks to us Jews (you may know us pharisees ;)) knowing pir own jewish texts youxdidnt get a a ay eothxit and madeissionaroes look incompetent, deceptive and pathetic. 1. You quoted wrong. Is not chapter 38 verses verses 31-32. It is all in chapter 31. I will take over eloping you with ot and yoir question now though. Hints it hel0s Jews against Christian missionaries this chapter. Doesn't hinder. 2. You mention you use the Septuagint. Dumb move. This is jeremiah. Never had jewish scholars translating for the Septuagint any part of jeremiah anytime. Had only non Jews do it and edit and reedit it constantly all the way till 300CE. All a product of the church. You heard 70 or 72 Jews. They only translated 5 books of moses and that was lost in a fire but this is jeremiah. About to write ixamxly9ng. Lol no righteous anger for you. Yry rraf any introduction you like to any seotuagint and wnjoy having all i sais aboit the septuagint cobfirmed there. Now lucky for you I read the hebrew side before going to the English side. I am so helpful like that. But if you can't read the original hebrew just get a translation that just went from hebrew to English once. Use some common sense dude. Unless you prefer corrupted texts to try to deceive people and no christian missionary wannabewould ever do that, of course not 3. Let's Get to the text. The 2 verses you quotes don't at all say anything like for they abode not in my covenant and i disregarded them". Isn't that amazing that those particular words are falsely put into the vers 3 from looking at the words there is no motivation. Here. I will quote for you the text same one most would use here and answer your original question. 4. That sentence was "not like the covenant that I formed with th3ir forefathers on the day I took them by the hand to take them out of the land of Egypt, that they broke my covenant, although I was a lord over them, says the Lord' PRETTU DANG IMPPRTANT TRYONG TO SNEAK IN SO I DISREGARDED THEM. Not just those words aren't there. He never disregarded us. Eterbal covenant means eterbal. Now next 2 verses answers your question if it has happened yet. 32 " for this is the covenant I will form with the house of Israel after those days, says the L-rd; I will place my law in their midst and I will inscribe it upon their hearts, and I will be their G-d and they shall be my people. 33 "and no longer shall one teach his neighbour or one his brother saying 'know the L-rd' for they shall all know me from their smallest to their greatest, says the L-rd, for I will forgive their iniquity and their sin I will no longer remember" Well thus is so good for us jews/phatisees .- We fixed your accidental mistake we were not disregarded. Phew - the new covenant has G-d being our G-d and us his people. Woohoo that is same as before. Yay - hasn't happened yet as still jabe to teach yoimur neigjnoir and brother and not everyone knows G-d - but woohoo this future time whenever it is pirbsins are getting forgiven andxnot even remembered You were really dumb trying to use jeremiah 31 against us. You know verse 34 tells you that yes our covenant with G-d is eternal as long as there is a sun and a moon - verse 35 telps you it involves all the laws from before. Which makes sense as G-d wouldn't break old eternal covenants. He doesn't lie for he is notba man thatxwould chanhe his mind. Verse 36 really rubs it in how G-d will never reject israelm you can't win. All this time when people tried wiling us out. They should of teadbthis and saved having to fail in their efforts. They could of done something else. Haha this is an unbelievably awesome set or verses for jews especially when facing deceptive christian missionaries. Socks so hard to be you is what I would say to them l. Ypu of coirse made a purely accidental mistake........haha

You have a false translationnfrom your septuagint. Which makes sense as the 70 jewishbscholats only translated the 5 books of moses not jeremiah. And that was lost in a fire. And the septuagint was edited and redited for years 600 You also wrongly wrote chaoter 38. Is jeremiah 31 where your mistranslated quote is from. Is not at all 'and I disregarded them.' That says 'and I was lord over them'. What dishonest christian editors ofbthe septuagint. They wish the L-rd disregarded us. But as the next verse says again covenant with israel. They can't change that eternal covenants are eternal. That no matter how much in tanach we sin and are punished G-d keeps his promises. Eterbal promises to our forefathers. Eternal laws. Eter am promises to us in torah that he will never forsake us. Told all over tanach we will always have a remnant preserved, restored and head of nations in the end. That includes in jeremiah and here even in jeremiah 31. Try Steven to nkt get the chapter wrong with yoirbreferemces and to cherry pick mistranslations from septuagint. We go to original hebrew rather than a christian corrupted translation and can see exactly what lies they have fed you christians. Thank G-d we read hebrew, in my case since early primary school hebrew with no English in my bible textbook so as to never be fooled

@@sdthyng no. Hebrew doesn't say that. Only your church father corrupted translation says that nd dreams and desperately wishes it says that

Great. What about jesus and NT. If ant still thencyoixjabe the number 1 jew hate book so teyxagain when you get there

Jesus totally just shat on Jews multiple times. Hate him from this post alone. He should not be followed by anyone

@@saul2491 So hate is the way forward then? How's that working out for you? He healed thousands upon thousands of Israelites of terrible illness and pointed many towards salvation from a course towards eternal death Israelites. He gave love for hate.

@@justinfair5216 I don't even believe he existed or did any pd that bit the fi nest part is you christians won't listen We keep telling you that miracles are not mentioned for the messiah in tanach. And that anyone doing miracles does not help at all to qualify them as our messiah or as a prophet or as not a false prophet. Why doctou w aste oir time letting us know that you claim yoir character did different miracle tell us something that is relevant if you are going to force a conversation about a religion and false prophet we wouldn't otherwise think of

@@saul2491 Is hate a constructive ethic or behaviour? Let's start there. You believe in God then? By the way, your spelling is difficult to negotiate my brother.

@@justinfair5216 we are specific allowed to mock idol worshipers actually as per jewish law. That we get from the tanach. We would rather die than join you. Literally.

Nothing about Islam. This is a jewish rabbi who is a counter christian missionary. If you get muslims to target Jews for conversion as priority over others like evangelicals then maybe he will easily show your religion false too. And it would be superb easy yourbrelogionxmales sakenmiwtke as christianity. Dares tocsayxjuda8wm was true but you are a later revelation. It is vetted for you that he never focused on islam that way. Wouldbalsoxve able to show on top mess with christianity in the middle for you.

Still a false religion but way way better and more credible than christianity

Jesus is the messiah.