Judgment at Nuremberg (1961) - We Were Doing Our Duty Scene (9/11) | Movieclips

Подписаться 62 млн

Просмотров 65 тыс.

50% 1

Judgment at Nuremberg movie clips: j.mp/2jxRgUv
BUY THE MOVIE: j.mp/2jX8TJo
Don't miss the HOTTEST NEW TRAILERS: bit.ly/1u2y6pr
CLIP DESCRIPTION:
E. Hahn & F. Hofstetter defend themselves claiming to have upheld the law as it was written.
FILM DESCRIPTION:
After the end of World War II, the world gradually became aware of the full extent of the war crimes perpetrated by the Third Reich. In 1948, a series of trials were held in Nuremberg, Germany, by an international tribunal, headed by American legal and military officials, with the intent of bringing to justice those guilty of crimes against humanity. However, by that time most of the major figures of the Nazi regime were either dead or long missing, and in the resulting legal proceedings American judges often found themselves confronting the question of how much responsibility someone held who had "just followed orders." Judgment at Nuremberg is a dramatized version of the proceedings at one of these trials, in which Judge Dan Haywood (Spencer Tracy) is overseeing the trials of four German judges -- most notably Dr. Ernst Janning (Burt Lancaster) and Emil Hahn (Werner Klemperer) -- accused of knowingly sentencing innocent men to death in collusion with the Nazis. Representing the defense is attorney Hans Rolfe (Maximilian Schell), while prosecuting the accused is U.S. Col. Tad Lawson (Richard Widmark). As the trial goes on, both the visiting Americans and their reluctant German hosts often find themselves facing the legacy of the war, and how both of their nations have been irrevocably changed by it. Judgment at Nuremberg also features notable supporting performances by Marlene Dietrich, Judy Garland, and Montgomery Clift. Originally written and produced as a play for television, the screen version of Judgment at Nuremberg was nominated for 11 Academy Awards, with Maximilian Schell and Abby Mann taking home Oscars for (respectively) Best Actor and Best Adapted Screenplay.
CREDITS:
TM & © MGM (1961)
Cast: Martin Brandt, Werner Klemperer, Spencer Tracy
Director: Stanley Kramer
Producers: Stanley Kramer, Philip Langner
Screenwriters: Montgomery Clift, Abby Mann
WHO ARE WE?
The MOVIECLIPS channel is the largest collection of licensed movie clips on the web. Here you will find unforgettable moments, scenes and lines from all your favorite films. Made by movie fans, for movie fans.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MOVIE CHANNELS:
MOVIECLIPS: bit.ly/1u2yaWd
ComingSoon: bit.ly/1DVpgtR
Indie & Film Festivals: bit.ly/1wbkfYg
Hero Central: bit.ly/1AMUZwv
Extras: bit.ly/1u431fr
Classic Trailers: bit.ly/1u43jDe
Pop-Up Trailers: bit.ly/1z7EtZR
Movie News: bit.ly/1C3Ncd2
Movie Games: bit.ly/1ygDV13
Fandango: bit.ly/1Bl79ye
Fandango FrontRunners: bit.ly/1CggQfC
HIT US UP:
Facebook: on. 1y8M8ax
Twitter: bit.ly/1ghOWmt
Pinterest: bit.ly/14wL9De
Tumblr: bit.ly/1vUwhH7

Опубликовано:

10 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 165

@krisninoorpatrianti8262 4 года назад

I thought thomas was in nuremberg trial

@bigbluebuttonman1137 4 года назад

Yeah, where's Thomas? We can't let him off the hook...

@nujabeslistener 3 года назад

A woman of culture I see

@bobcat24 3 года назад

Me too.

@thelastroman7791 Год назад

What did I do?

@thelastroman7791 Год назад

@@bigbluebuttonman1137You’ll never catch me. Lolz

@mattpeckham667 Год назад

Its jarring to see Werner Klemperer in this role, since we are so used to him as a comedic actor. But he was excellent here, and knowing his history i would imagine this role meant a great deal to him.

@tommyl3207 Год назад

He was talented. Comedy and drama excellent at both. He probably could have played a scary psycho and then also Col. Klink lol.

@MarkHarrison733 2 месяца назад

It was such terrible casting.

@TheOrangex88 3 года назад

“Only doing our duty” I was gonna say “I think a better excuse would’ve been ‘If I didn’t do it then I would’ve been shot’” but after reflecting a bit it just hit me...they have no remorse for what they have done and even in the face of their demise they still have the Gull to say “I’m not sorry”

@coolbeans8647 3 года назад

I was conducting myself in the justified and proper manner, and I still now see it as correct. Was what the first guy said. The second guy said - it was not my place to judge it right or wrong, I was to follow the law as it was written. The first guy was full on guilty if there was a fault with his actions he will stand by it. The second guy says if there was a fault, he was not tasked to determine that.

@applesandgrapesfordinner4626 3 года назад

Thing is though, you wouldn't even be shot for disobeying an 'illegal' order unless under extreme coercion. At best, you would've been rerouted to another unit. Most of the war crimes were a choice

@TheKonga88 3 года назад

Why should they say sorry for something they wholely believed in? Saying sorry means absolutely nothing anyway.. So many tards do things nowadays and when they are caught, all they have to do is make a public apology and all is forgiven by even bigger tards.. And no, I'm not sorry for writing this and I hope it offends you!

@isaiahvaldez3330 3 года назад

@@TheKonga88 too bad...... I didn't get offended

@howardtennenhouse7849 Год назад

There is no record of any German being shot for refusing orders.Germans followed orders whether they were morally right or wrong.Most Germans ignored willingly evidence of the destruction of the Jewish population.They could care less that their neighbours disappeared and happily took over their homes and businesses.

@TakeTheRide 4 года назад

To disregard your own moral conscience for any reason, is unconscionable.

@TakeTheRide 3 года назад

I stand with my statement.

@TakeTheRide 3 года назад

@Chris Webster I'm not sure how you live your life. I will say, personally, I stick with my moral compass everyday. That's what makes me who I am. Some people have no moral compass. Their magnetic needle seems to swing any direction, at any time, when it furthers their underhanded agendas.

@bobcat24 3 года назад

He had orders. He didn’t have a choice…

@richstein5101 3 года назад

Well said!

@blazzinga595 3 года назад

Man stfu with your bullshit morality. Goddamn acting like you'll be any different if u were in their shoes. You're just a drone following today's morals.

@luckymakhwe5300 2 года назад

I dont like the first guy the most. But I respect that he didnt lie.

@zerosparky9510 4 года назад

Only doing our duty. Heard that one all the time

@ShaquilleOatz 3 года назад

it was actually the first time they heard that until the Japanese and Turkish

@toptenguy1 3 года назад

Calgary kids getting arrested for playing hockey outdoors.

@WorldWar2freak94 3 года назад

“We must follow orders.”

@tuxedobandito7062 3 года назад

@@toptenguy1 OMG you know about that!!

@Diana-sb4yl 3 года назад

There's few of us will question the " only following orders" I'm one of them n lost many jobs etc I will never be ashamed for standing up for justice n truth ,freedom march 2021 think of agenda 2030 .

@toxicgoat341 Год назад

They all said this the only guy who didn't was albert speer and swindled his way out of the hangman's noose

@MarkHarrison733 2 месяца назад

Speer lied about everything.

@cloudstone123 Год назад

I find it an interesting argument. Lets say the law changes that requires all dogs be terminated without exception. The reasons aren't incredibly important. The law passes. Someone challenges the law in court. Since it is a law that passed through the legislative process, what is the judge empowered to do under the country's constitution to do find in the challenger's favor? They can only act within the confines of it. Judges are not part of the legislative branch. I wish people were more informed these days about existing laws and those being proposed and really think about the implications of it. That way the voters can apply the correct political pressure on the legislative branch to either make sure the laws are good before they even get so far as making it to the judicial level.

@AULIGAofBLEED 3 года назад

Apparently this is an ok excuse nowadays

@tompegorinno5141 3 года назад

Because it is.

@ilokivi Год назад

It appears not to be, as being a judge and knowing the law does not excuse anyone from having a moral compass and applying it to any situation in which they are involved.

@AULIGAofBLEED Год назад

@@ilokivi not true. you are confusing what is legal and what is moral. We have many instances of unjust laws that are legal. Past and present. How many drone operators are killing innocent families over another countries sovereign airspace. The guilt is the same, The only difference is power.

@jamesoffutt2801 Год назад

No it is not an excuse you are to a fault, pitying wicked men who followed orders of a wicked man, needed to be sentenced and put away. You take away this law, and you put sheer lunacy and chaos in all of the judicial services of the world. Cosby Epstein Weinstein Spacey and Kelly as well as many others in the media industry, political industry, and so forth, should we tried this same way. Not just live and let die, but take them all and treat them equally.

@victorsuarez3546 Год назад

I lost my job by "following the orders" they told me "I should have known better". And off I went.

@jessiejames7492 5 лет назад

thats colonel klink! :)

@farqitol 3 года назад

Interesting to note that Werner Klemperer (Klink) was Jewish. As was John Banner (Sgt Schultz) and Robert Clary (Cpl Le Beau). Clary was in Buchenwald and had a tattoo on his left forearm.

@jessiejames7492 3 года назад

@@farqitol i watched that interveiw

@sifeij 4 года назад

that's how humanity got enslaved - just follow orders, not exercising one's own consciousness, morality is down to the toilet as a whole, can anyone sees it?

@danyalchowdhury2833 4 года назад

If a German soldier refused to follow orders in the camps he would have likely been killed too, and they would have just found another soldier to do the job

@sifeij 4 года назад

@@danyalchowdhury2833 exactly my point - stop being a soldier because soldier means SoulDier, and order-followers are worst human being ever, because they agreed not to use their own moral standards once they swore in, they want someone else to tell them what to do and want someone else to take responsibilities for what they have done. They are the ones who keep the evil system in place. Without soldiers or police (order-followers), the system would not be put in place. Order-followers are the ones who "sold" their soul for a living (getting paid), are dogs to their masters. That's exactly what their masters call them - the dogs that wear dog tags. They kill and exercising violence toward their own kind, act just like house-slave.

@danyalchowdhury2833 4 года назад

@@sifeij isn't everybody always accepting orders. You don't have to follow the law or societal norms but you do it anyways.

@sifeij 4 года назад

@@danyalchowdhury2833 now you know why we are in the mess we are in today...the root cause, lol

@danyalchowdhury2833 4 года назад

Sophie so are you saying that anarchy is the way? Because that’s what not following rules and order and laws is.

@andrewallen9993 Год назад

Defendant "We stood for German civilization and culture" Narrator "Indeed they did, and showed what German civilization and culture was to the whole world.

@bellaadamowicz8380 Год назад

Yes, and now German culture for most people is associated with Auschwitz

@MarkHarrison733 2 месяца назад

@@bellaadamowicz8380 Franco told the real truth about that in 1945.

@MrSportsadam 4 года назад

Didn’t know that was colonel kink makes me wonder where was Schulz at if he was on here

@Admin-Kuni-6172 Год назад

he's an NCO, so it's unlikely he's getting dragged to Nuremberg, most likely he's back to Hammelburg to his family and his toy factory (if it's still there). no, the people who'd be there beside Klink would be Burkhalter (though, it's unlikely he'll be on Klink's side, considering the many troubles he made)no, his only hope of freedom (or at least a reduction in sentence) is Hogan, or the Allied Command themselves, making the judges think that Klink is a double-agent and all his crimes were done to keep his cover

@zacharypayne4080 3 года назад

How do i find this movie?

@somebodytoknow7408 12 дней назад

Try and you will find

@dislike2092 4 года назад

WERE JUST FOLLOWING ORDERS

@fasces_stronksticks2939 3 года назад

based falangist

@tompegorinno5141 3 года назад

And we would do it again!

@tomchevalier5491 3 года назад

Where was pool to explain to them

@bobcat24 3 года назад

*He was just following orders… that’s all.*

@piplee1439 3 года назад

I smell deleted comments ents ents

@dr_IkjyotSinghKohli Год назад

This is the same excuse that factions of The Indian Army use till today to justify attack on the Golden Temple in 1984.

@BRuane-pw6xq 4 года назад

Republicans did not want FDR to confront Hitler and did not want to prosecute these mass murderers. Sounds like Trumpers.

@isaiahkayode6526 4 года назад

Sounds like something a brainwsh idiot like you would say boot licking to the party of slaves

@henryreed4697 Год назад

@@isaiahkayode6526what on earth are you talking about?

@henryreed4697 Год назад

Isolationism was very common in the states back in the day.

@reaper2579 3 года назад

Good soldiers follow orders

@markbenjamin1703 3 года назад

Good people put morality above authority

@srrlIdl Год назад

'Good' soldiers don't commit war crimes

@tylerwilson3172 Год назад

So do dogs. I hold humans to a higher standard.

@Arcaryon Год назад

"W*r is when you k*ll so many of the other side that they can't fight anymore." - Ratko Do you understand what a soldier is? At the core? Beyond all the notions of honor or loyalty and all the other pretty words people use to hide the true nature of this kind of profession? A tool. A conscious weapon that only serves ONE true purpose. To destroy. Good soldiers are not good men because truly good men can not become good soldiers. Most good soldiers are not evil either. Because good soldiers - just follow orders. They don’t k*ll unless they are told to do so. They don’t enjoy the core of their work. But they do it regardless.

@protalukoriginal4560 Год назад

Furry > invalid opinion

@piplee1439 3 года назад

Hoo ha a a a

@Sam_Green____4114 Год назад

They were right though !! They were only doing their duty towards their country according to the law at the time !!

@henryreed4697 Год назад

And their laws were designed for genocide. Sometimes the law is wrong.

@MarkHarrison733 2 месяца назад

@@henryreed4697 The Allies caused genocide.

@toptenguy1 3 года назад

Ok i'll do it. wHo Is WaTcHiNg tHiS iN 2o2o?

@vladpewt5896 Год назад

The Japanese refused to submit to such nonsense. Germany is now being thrown to the wolves against the interests of the People. Japan is still 98% Japanese and staying that way!

@tylerwilson3172 Год назад

You should look up the Tokyo Trials and how many war criminals the US hung. Japan wasn't in a position at the end of the war to refuse anything.

@Big_Bag_of_Pus Год назад

Cocaine is a hell of a drug. You should stop smoking crack.

@MarkHarrison733 2 месяца назад

@@tylerwilson3172 It was a kangaroo court.

@chrisd2051 3 года назад

I'm not saying they're right but unless you've been in a position where you can utter the phrase "I was only following orders" you can't throw stones at the men and women who were only following orders.

@genyashinazugawa7674 3 года назад

oh yes we can.

@andrewmckenzie292 2 года назад

So a civilian commander-in-chief cannot prosecute a military member then?

@teamtinyturtle9103 2 года назад

Once given the order, you can say *"NO!"* If the order is wrong, it is your duty as a human being to say *"NO!"* no matter the consequences. The whole mess in Canada caused by their corrupt government made me look this up. Good stuff.

@sucram1018 2 года назад

Wrong! Hitler's men could've took him out but chose not to because they were just as crazy.

@ganndeber1621 Год назад

horseshit

@andrewmckenzie292 2 года назад

Police enforcing vaccine mandates: We are doing our duty

@mortalclown3812 2 года назад

Probably don't believe in seatbelts either.

@SquareRoot_ 2 года назад

You see, we had the chance to nerf the police. Ironically, Republicans defend the very entity that strips away their personal rights. What I hate more is statistically speaking, when I get older, I'll become a Republican.

@RamdomRando 2 года назад

You can't compare that to the holocaust. Police forcing idiots to get vaccines to avoid spreading a desease because some people are so absolutely delusional that they think they are entitled to say "no I don't care if someone else who is inmuno-compromised gets sick and dies, I am not going to die so I won't allow being told what to do because I don't care about other people" is the same as literal murder and dehuminization of a specific group of people practicing a faith.

@billyhargrove1405 Год назад

No police are doing that clown

@TheLuigiex50 Год назад

That's not the same they were killing people. Were they killing people?. No the disease was. Different they.

@johnbrown2163 5 лет назад

They should have been all released. If war is over then it over. These POW's.

@ranatangboo1185 5 лет назад

John Brown I'm sure you would not say that if your family was slaughtered by these men who were behind these atrocities that's why they are on trial

@johnbrown2163 5 лет назад

@@ranatangboo1185 They still POW's and surrendered. What about their families? They just following orders and if war over why hold a trial where most SS considered HQ?? Allies did it to flex. Don't make it right. Same as Nukes... Those involved should be held accountable after the war. Many citizens turned to dust.

@romulan227 4 года назад

John Brown The fact that you yourself are using the "just following orders" defense in response to a trial that established that the "just following orders" defense is no defense at all against charges of crimes against humanity shows that you don't know anything about Nuremberg or its significance.

@johnbrown2163 4 года назад

@@romulan227 They tortured and killed POW. What do I need to know? Same as Guantanamo Bay. Those POW and they still beaten and tortured daily.

@friendly-nemesis4754 4 года назад

@@johnbrown2163 I have a question that may (in the answering) keep us from talking past one another, so I hope you will answer it: What do the words 'Just Deserts' mean to you?