K-Pop Noobs React - (BTOB) 'Killing Voice' | StayingOffTopic #killingvoice 

"We don't sell album, we sell emotions" - BTOB 💙

Finally :) To me BTOB is with EXO in the category of Vocal Kings. BTOB really serves with the vocals. I probably rewatched this killing voice like a hundred times minimum.

songs in order: Missing You Remember That (08:01 - It's because the lines aren't originally his... it's actually from a member who left the group 😅) 2nd Confession Only One For Me Beautiful Pain SOMEDAY It's Okay I'll Be Your Man Higher Blue Moon (Cinema Ver.) The Song Be Together Wind and Wish (the most recent) Finale (Our Concert)

I love how cool you were about Peniel forgetting the lyrics because it’s such an old song and he is actually covering that part for another member that left the group. Honestly though if you get to know Peniel, when he messed up I was like “Classic Peniel! That’s our Peniel!” 😂😂😂

BTOB was the reason I came to love and appreciate ballads!! "It's Okay" has been my favorite kpop song since it dropped in 2015, I teared up a bit when they started in the killing voice😭 Still feel the impact to this day just like the first time~

I discovered BTOB through this killing voice video like 3 months ago, and I already listened to all their albums and I became a big fan.

BTOB ( pronounced be-two-be ), always sing live. They are amazing. Most of their hit songs are composed by them. More than 10 years of beauful voices and ballads.

BtoB is so entirely under appreciated. Just by pure vocals and personality they are leaps and bounds above pretty much anyone out there. ❤

they promote a new album here Wind and Wish the main song is Wind and Wish, but all the songs are amazing. The names of the songs in order are 1. Missing you. 2.Remember that 3.Second confession 4.Only one for me 5.Beautiful pain 6. Someday 7. Its ok 8.I'll be your man 9. Higher 10. Blue moon (Cinema ver.) 11. The Song 12. Be together 13. Wind and Wish 🆕️ 14. Finale (our concert) songs 1, 4,5,6,8,11,12 and 13 are composed by Hyunsik (white shirt black tie) Songs 9 and 10 are composed by Minhyuk blue shirt black tie. The other songs are composed by their agency composition team. They debute in march 2012 as 7 members, the main rapper and also composer of many songs leave the group in 2020.

Legendary doesn't even cover how astonishing this Killing Voice is...👑👑👑

Glad you like BTOB! Also in case you're wondering the small text and date are the album name and release date. The larger text above it is the song title. That's how all Killing Voices are

Actual vocal Kings ! But also the biggest characters in Kpop - much loved for their personalities - try having a look at their funny moments on the red carpet 😂

Love your reaction! ❤ Best reaction out there. please check out more BTOB. They are super talented and write their own stuff. They are also the most unhinged idols in the industry... worth checking out. Ilhoonsquad has a guide to the members

Thank you for this beautiful reaction and thank you for enjoyed our BtoB, i hope you guys can reaction the whole album especially Brother Act ❤

Thankyou for reacting to btob 💙 the boy with the deep tone is (hyunsik) he is the father of btob music because he composed a lot of their songs.

The vocalists can rap, and the rappers can sing. They were 7 (7 vocals and 7 rappers). They are seniors now. Known for their specialty in ballad songs and melodic rap. These people doesnt know how to lipsing (they did it once and fail miserably), so they always sing live in every performance and yes they made mistakes and we love those, genuineness. They are know to be crackheads love to joke around and cant sit still. Many groups can sing, but BTOB not only sing, they can harmonize like no other. They have been doing this for more than 10 years, they sing and harmonize like next to breathing. If one of them suddenly randomly sings, the rest just follow and harmonize 😂

I havent heard the B TOB pronounciation in awhile 😂😂😂😂 But still, thank you for the reactions!!

I'll never stop watching people reacting to btob's killing voice while jamming out and enjoying their performance! Btob give off such chill, laid-back vibes but also they're ready to blow your socks off because that's their duality. I loooved, loooved how you hyped Peniel's rap parts (the buff guy with the grey sweater you were talking about at the beginning) and thank you cause I feel very few reactors paid him justice. As for your facial expressions, all I can say is: same here! Us melody ( our fandom name) are always amazed by their talent and how good they are even though they proved time and time again how freaking dope (to quote the song "Higher" which is in the kv lmao) they are. Do yourself a favor and dive into their music, you will never ever be disappointed with them: not only do they have vocal range for days but also have various styles/genres throughout their discography. Never a dull day with them! Thank you for reacting to their kv, but also (and most importantly) for showing how much fun you had while watching the video!!

BTOB is soulfood for the ears. Love the disbelief in your faces.

OMG thank you so much for react to them. They're so amazing... Hyunsik is the name of the guy with the deep voice and the incredible high notes haha he's the composer of BTOB. "I'll be your man" was his first composition for the group

Thank you thank you thank you, for reacting them.. BToB is the best ballads vocal idols in Korea.. Their fans called "Melody". If you heard they said repeatly melody in this video, they talked to the fans..

And this is why they're my favorites 💙 BTOB are meant to be listened to live.

They are soooo good 😢😢😢😢 top tier vocals !!

thank you very much for appreciating our boys btob! thank you for saying that they are the best.. 💕💕

Every bg that debuted in 2012 is just insane. BtoB, EXO, VIXX, B.A.P. Love from Argentina.

the i’ll be your man mv is a must watch! all their mvs are great but that one could be a great starting point

OMG!!!! I can't wait for you guys to check out more of their music!! Their MVs are either soooo touching or funny and their live stages are something that you can't miss.. I would like to recommend you to watch the MVs and then the live performances.. They always always sing live, so there are a lot of variation that they can perform for any songs of their..

Thanks for your reaction . Btob amazingly and unbelievably unique! Ballads kings.

VOCAL KIIIINGSSSIN THE HOUUUSEEEEE SHEEEESSHH!! Also, the BEST reaction I've ever seen yet!!

i don't know how many times i'm rewatching this video reaction since its uploaded... as a Melody (the fandom), i really thank you for your appreciation towards BTOB and their songs. 너무 감사합니다 앞으로도 비투비 많이 응원해주세요!

Thank you for the reaction💙. BTOB is the BEST. 🤴👑

I can't believe they did such a short part of (I'll Be Your Man), It's my favorite BTOB song and it's an old song btw but still my favorite one, you guys should check it out I'm sure you gonna like it💆🏻‍♀️🩵

thank you for your reaction😊. Was cute when all of you made the flower pose 😂. Brother act is a master piece the whole album is amazing, hear it in order is a difference experience i recomend if you gonna hear it do it in order at some point have interlude and all.

BTOB is known for their vocal voice, most of their songs were composed by the members itselff and their forte is performing live...I recommend to watch their Be together concert..

thanks for reacting to btob!! i enjoyed watching it again with you! all your reactions and comments were super fun! what stands out the most with btob is just… they make you feel happy 😊 they’re an amazing group of vocalists and rappers and i kid you not the funniest group ever, but above all that watching them just makes you feel good in the warm and fuzzy feelings kind of way ya know? 😂 i hope to see you guys react to a funny compilations vid one day hahaha (you’ll be going down the btob rabbit hole after that 😂) thanks for the reaction!!

First time hearing them. I was curious because I started to watch a Kdrama and found out the protagonist is one of the members of BTOB (the second from the left, next to the rapper). Good voices and beautiful harmonies!! Thanks for the reaction!

Such genuine reaction! I believe you would love the 'Killing Voice' of Big Mama. That one is such a delight as well.

got to know them through kingdom (where stray kids and ateez competed) and fell in love with them there! they’ve got that theatre kids vibe and the most amazing vocals that you just have to love. great video and great reactions!

Hehe... Glad you checked them (BtoB) out and liked them.

Saludos desde Venezuela, BTOB debutó en el 2012, MELODY agradecemos infinitamente las reacciones a los chicos y así más personas los conozcan. Son en el Kpop el mejor grupo vocal masculino, los amo mucho. Recomiendo ver sus mv y presentaciones en escenario.

Appreciate this so much! When it comes to superb vocals, you have to mention BTOB! What wonderful, hilarious group of talented singers! I also really recommend cnblue too! Their main vocalist Yonghwa is a beast on stage and his live is amazing!

it's B to B Born to Beat

It pronounce B-to-B stands for Born to Beat thank you for your reactions

Btob este grupo es increíble ❤ no voy a mentir no soy fan pero fue unos de los grupos que conocí sus voces y sus canciones preciosas

There are few k groups that are on vocal god tier ...BTOB are in top 5 for me...I'll be your man is absolutely ICONIC ..so much that you hear the intro and you literally stop everything to listen

Finally....btob killing voice reaction 👏👏👏👏👏

omg finally. i am so in luv with btob. they're truely amazing talented group

it was a treat watching you all guys reacting to BTOB! Most Melody have already given you the song list and some general info about them so heres some additional - and absolutely useless! - stuff: They're the oldest group still in Cube and between their two main songwriters and composers, they rarely have to get songs from outside the group. They have a literal braincell vacuum if there's more than one of them in the same place and are very loud. Keep one hand on the volume controls if you value your hearing and they're not singing. from left to right: Lee Minhyuk - 2nd eldest, the mom of the group and he owns it, the main stripper, "I rap because I like it, not because I can't sing," and is usually the one harmonizing if someone in the vocal line isn't already doing it. He's said multiple times - on tv - that he walks around his house naked. Yook Sungjae - spoiled maknae, absolute weirdo which infuriating because he's so good looking. Old man at heart - his hobbies are fishing and golf. Makes numerous *math puns* (which is, as everyone knows, the first sine of insanity). Is an actual cat. Seo Eunkwang - eldest, leader, you hear him before you see him, variety show darling and host, has a RBF so he's usually smiling, does all those super high adlibs. Has a catboy agenda on main. Lim Hyunsik - often gets mistaken for the leader and lol *dear god no* bc the group wouldn't have survived even a year. Main songwriter & composer, is doing his master's degree in practical music, and is the son of a famous folk singer. Vocal range for *days* and i think at current holds the group record for longest continuous belt (33 seconds). Lee Changsub - yes the tats are real and most Melodies lose their minds when we get to see them, famous for his voice cracks, and is puzzled by his celebrity status. Peniel Shin - CHI TOWN BOI (seriously hes born and raised in Chicago burbs so English is his native language), is just vibes and not much bothers him, hands down the raunchiest lyrics of the group - I'm still not recovered from the "how many licks does it take to make your tootsie pop" and that was on Kingdom 2 years ago ... and that's before we get to the raunchfest that is Guitar - and gets away with it because most of the time it's in English. good luck and welcome to the madness that is these stupidly talented idiots!

The buff one in the gray sweater has a podcast with other k-idol hosts called Get Real. Just dropping this here since that's how I got to know btob haha

I hope you guys check out BTOB - When I Was Your Man official mv & BTOB- It's Okay dance version mv 😁

I love this reaction!!!!! Thankyou for reacting to BTOB 💙💙 if u wanna react them again, please use their live performance because they are good on it!

Peniel forgot the lines because it was not his line originally but still slay🔥😁. They all slay🔥🔥🔥

I agree! I'm an EXO-L but I love btob too. Vocal 👑kings

So, I had heard of BtoB since I started listening to Kpop in 2017, and I knew that they were well known in the industry especially for their killer harmonies, but I never had really listened to their music until 2021 when they appeared on the battle of the bands show Kingdom: Legendary War with Ateez and Stray Kids (plus 3 other bands). I watched the show for Stray Kids and Ateez, but unexpectedly fell in love with BtoB while I was there. They were the most hilariously funny awesome people on the show, who were so kind and supportive to all the younger idol groups on the show, who also (obviously) had such amazing vocal talents. By the time Kingdom was over I was a full fledged Melody. (BTOB’s fan club name is Melody). P.S. the rapper on the end that you said is a big guy, is an American. Peniel grew up in Chicago. And sometimes doesn’t have any hair because of a medical condition. The smaller rapper on the other side is Minhyuk, and he’s the one that is super jacked.

Thanks for the reaction 💙 The small caption with the year is the album name for example Brother Act 2017. Here's the list of all the song names in English: Missing You Remember That 2nd Confession Only One For Me Beautiful Pain SOMEDAY It's Okay I'll Be Your Man,+ Higher Blue Moon (Cinema Ver.) The Song Be Together Wind and Wish Finale (Our Concert)

Thank you so much for reacting to BTOB, your reactions made my day, its a pretty hard day for me today. Hopefully to see more BTOB reactions from you guys

You guys were so cute during this reaction! Geo looked like a little boy when we was waving back at them. BTOB Vocals are off the charts!! I don’t know all the members, just the ones from Kingdom: Legendary War. But their personalities are hilarious!! You guys will absolutely love them! This was one of my favorite reactions of yours. 🫰🏼🫰🏼

26:12 That edit and reactions made me crack up!😂 21:33 perfect example of how incredible live vocals makes you just as (if not more) excited when watching a performance, as cool dance moves would do! You don't have to dance to make the audience engaged and excited! Anyway, I'm glad I found BTOB!! They are insane live! (They also have lots of choreos but it's not their main focus, live vocals are, which I personally prefer). Their songs are so good, sometimes I can't believe they produce them themselves and on top of that they are so damn funny! BTOB are one of the most famous groups in Korea and have slowly gained more and more fans internationally over the years, I'm glad you found them. They are well known for their harmonies and live vocals, as I've mentioned and for being super goofy and funny. They are also known in other parts of the entertainment industry, like Yook Sungjae, (2nd guy from left) an actor and played in Goblin etc. Lee Minhyuk (1st guy from left) is a numerous record holder in athleticism among celebrities (would've been an athlete if he didn't choose music) also a producer with lots of song under his belt. Seo Eunkwang (3rd guy, leader) the funniest dude ever and goes viral for it, is a musical actor and MC, Lee Changsub (2nd from right) is also a well known musical actor. Im Hyunsik (4th from left) producer of BTOB's hit songs. Peniel (far right) idol -podcast host on the well known Get Real is from Chicago, although he seems shy he's friends with half the industry it seems. Brother act is definitely one of their most loved albums, Missing You that was performed in the beginning is one of the longest streaming song on Koreas biggest streaming platform, Melon (only 2-3 of BTS's songs are higher). Most of these songs they performed on Killing Voice are own produced. Looking forward for more reactions of BTOB! I would love to see MV reactions of the songs you liked, and hopefully you consider to watch a live performance back to back after the MV, that way you can easily compare and take in their immense talents they have (just a suggestion). Thanks for the reaction! 🫶 (BTW, super cute baby! 🥰)

yess! :D love BTOB so glad you decided to react to them 💙 BTS, BTOB and FTIsland are my faves :) and speaking of FTIsland their main singer has a Killingvoice too Lee Hongki is his name

Thank you so much for such a wonderful reaction to BTOB's Killing Voice..they really are so good. BTOB (bee-to-bee) stands for BORN TO BEAT and is an 11 yr old self composing and producing group and known as the ballad/harmony/vocal kings of kpop. Initially had 7 members (4 vocalists and 3 rappers) but all 7 can sing, rap & play instruments. True to their motto which is "We don't sell albums, we sell emotions"..BTOB sings in a certain way that really hits you emotionally whether ballad or upbeat. Their songs have deep meanings and healing messages that anyone can relate to. Even though they are known for their beautiful ballads and amazing live stages, their upbeat songs are so cool, too. Their music goes from pop to dance, rock, jazz, funk, ballad, R&B, they have a very diverse discography and that BTOB is a genre in itself. Their songs and raps are written by the members so they feel more personal and they are a group known to put raps and choreo into their ballads and still they sound so good. Unfortunately, their main rapper was involved in an issue that made him leave the group in 2020 so they are only 6 now. The buzzcut rapper forgot some of his lines in the 2nd Confession song coz it was an old song (2013) and he's doing the rap part of the member who left the group. I gez he wasn't that familiar with it since it wasn't even his rap part..and as you said, we also appreciate that the mistake wasn't edited out. Seeing that mistake makes them more real and human. And BTOB is a very genuine and down to earth group..never slaves to that perfect idol image coz they never cared if they looked funny or weird. They are loud, crazy and chaotic and they love making their fans (fandom is called Melody coz every Beat needs a Melody to make a song) laugh with their comical ways but whenever they sing, they are dead serious with hitting those high notes. They are true artists who have a passion for making good music and performing their best for their audience. I'm so glad you have discovered them via dingo..they are not that popular globally but are BIG in SK and Asia. I'm glad you loved the songs they have performed in this video..and I can't say that these are their best coz there's so much more. With 3 full albums, 12 mini albums, special albums, solos, OST's, digital releases, Japan albums, etc..they really have A LOT of songs but all I can say is that all their songs are so good. You'll really love them all..plus they have great personalities..more reason to love them. They have released their 12th mini album 5 mos ago, same day this Killing Voice was released. Kindly check out their title track, WIND AND WISH..so good. This was their 2nd to the last song in Killing Voice. Also, you could check out the mvs of the songs they did in Killing Voice: MISSING YOU, BEAUTIFUL PAIN, REMEMBER THAT, I'LL BE YOUR MAN, 2ND CONFESSION, ONLY ONE FOR ME, IT'S OKAY, THE SONG..and these are all for starters.😊 Again, thank you so much and hoping for more BTOB reactions from you.

Watch their performances in Kingdom: Legendary War. You'll gonna love it.

Thank you very much for reacting to BTOB (prounced bee-two-bee) for Born to Beat. They are not only well known for their music but also for their humour. Their discography is such a treat filled with different genre. They are a self-composing group.

Yesss BTOB.. Vocal Kings 😍💙

Love their energy, they make me feel so happyーrelatable 💯

Btob and Mamamoo are the kings and queen of vocals in kpop

가창력 탑인 보이그룹 BTOB 짱 입니다!!! 리액션 해주셔서 감사합니다!

Please react to more BTOB and react to a guide if you really want to get to know them, it really helps.

Thank you for reacting to our BtoB. I'm so happy to see you guys love them and their songs. Have a great journey with BtoB!

ok first off…that baby coming out of nowhere…OMG…lol so cute!!!!!!! lol thanks for loving and reacting to BTOB..love when people just close their eyes and listen..shows u really appreciate!!

OMG! Thank you so much guys, I waited for this, requested and waited for this. Thank you. Love, Melody. 💙💙💙💙🫶🫶🫶🫶

loved the reaction, I would love to see more BTOB from you guys, they're great!

EXO and BTOB are the 2 best vocal boy groups in 3rd gen 💕💕

Their voices are really good. Thank you for making this reaction. I love it. And their show is really fun. They are both good vocal and funny.

Thank you for appreciating BTOB and yes they are vocal kings indeed 🩵 and yes the best episode of Killing Voice ☺️

Thanks for this reaction !!! BTOB is such a talented group 💙💙 you must react to I’ll be your man mv… masterpiece 💙💙💙

For the song I'll Be Your Man, which was around 17:35, they lowered the key for that section. So it may sound a little off but you guys should react to their live stage for that song, it is magical. Thank you for reacting to BTOB. Also please react to NCT Dream, Hongki and Yonghwa's Killing Voice videos.

I love BTOB like the way they are. They're super talented .... vocally obviously andthey are soooooooo hilarious. They're so loved.

New subscriber here! I just discovered your channel today and you guys seem so wholesome and positive! I also really like how you guys pay so much attention to both the music and the video, even noticing the member's little interactions. I'm really looking forward to more BTOB reactions, they are unfortunately still rather underrated internationally. They have amazing vocals as you can tell, but they are also one of the funniest and free-spirited idols out there! So I would love to see you react to some of their funny moments (like the reserved & quiet idols series on yt) or some guides, aside from their amazing music of course!! :D 💙

Born to Beat (B to B), the only idol group that didn’t want to be idols. Peniel ( rapper in grey sweater) is actually from Chicago. You should check out the Kingdom videos, they are amazing.

Watch BtoB's Wow MV to see their other side. Haha ❤ Plus their Christmas song acapellas. Their live harmonies are so good!

Finally!!! BTOB (pronounced: "be to be")

Thank you for your reaction, more love for BTOB 💙

I need more B to B reaction 💙

The thing is BTOB didn't choose any sort of list for songs to perform in Killing Voice. All their songs are so good so regardless of what song they choose to sing, it would still be heavenly. Thank you for reacting to BTOB guys! Looking forward for more❤

finallyyyy, another killing voice reaction. been waiting for this for so long. thank you always for this 🤍 mind to do Highlight Killing Voice as well? would appreciate it a lots 🥹❤️

thank you for reacting to BTOB and i'm really happy you enjoyed them, they're known as the "ballad kings and vocal kings" of kpop. Also can you react to iKON killing voice and Jung Yonghwa from Cnblue killing voice pls🙏💖

Thank you for reacting!!!.. My Kings of harmonies~ They were trained to be a band, then acapella group, and finally debuted as a singing&dancing group so most of them can play instruments! They are known for their live performances~ I would recommend you to check them out 💙

Thank you for liking and apreciating BTOB (pronounced Be to Be, Born to Beat), the fandom name is Melody (because every beat needs melody). Their live version is better than studio version. They can do all genre. We call it BTOB Genre, because even though they are known as the kings of ballads, their songs are actually very diverse. I'm waiting for your next BTOB reaction. If sometime you want to check full album I suggest Brother Act, Be Together, and Wind And Wish.

Oh my gosh finally!!!!

You guys just won a new subscriber cuz of this video Gosh finally BTOB is getting the recognition they deserve ❤

Loove your reaction and thank you for appreciating BTOB!! Hope this is the start to more BTOB music reaction from you all. ❤

Those are my boys! 😍

Being a fan of vocal kings and queens felt heavenly…

Thanks guys for reacting to BTOB 💙

Our talented and semi-unhinged clowns 🥹💙😂😂😂. And yes, “I’ll Be Your Man” is a QUEEN 🔥🔥

I wholeheartedly agree with BROTHER ACT (2017) being a complete MASTERPIECE. It is probably in my TOP3 best albums I've ever heard (and I've listened to a loooooooot of albums from different genres). I'm really happy you get to know more of BTOB, they're indeed incredible artists and all of them have also such unique personalities as well. Hope you get to react to more of their stuff. Great reaction!

Omg omg you know how happy I am when I get the notification 😂😂

I'll be your man the best song of btob ever.

Thanks for appreciating our BTOB, They are very talented, true artists, they never disappoint. BTOB is the genre (They makes the music and songs that they want to do) and see them enjoy in a stage is the most wonderful for a melody 💙 Yejiapsa💙

I like btob vocals.