Discussion on the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2019. The Bill further amends the Citizenship Act, 1955 Rajya Sabha Session 250 Rajya Sabha Winter Session 2019 #CitizenshipAmendmentBill #250RajyaSabhaSession #WinterSession2019
If congress stand-by what Mr. Sibal is saying, then let Congress demand for deportation of all the illegal migrants. Why are they not making such a demand?
Dr.Ross geller DR. Ross, I am not able to make out which Swamy you are talking about. And I agree with you that meritocracy and capabilities are utterly disregarded and sacrificed while allocating ministerial positions. However, this is a separate topic. Coming to NRC, CAA, NPR, every country in the world needs its government of the day to collect all necessary data of its citizens and residents for the purpose of policy making, internal law and order and National security and other administrative purposes. Coming to BJP being racist, as far as granting citizenship to persecuted minorities from the 3 neighboring countries, this has been the policy and demand from the time of Mahatma Gandhi post independence. And I believe no party is secular. Every party is playing politics by creating vote bank by misusing the diversity in our society into divisive forces. When national policies are formulated considering a group of people and not on the basis of well being and benefits of an individual citizen, then the policy is flawed at the inception. We are totally on a different level of understanding if you disagree to the fact that successive congress and left government allowed illegal economic immigrants from Bangladesh to settle in India and were given all necessary documents for inclusion of their names in voter’s list. Even Mamata Banerjee was opposing to this till she was not the CM. And even if you disagree to my notes stated above; please pick any country in the world (which we as Indians wish our country should be) and you will find the government of that country is the custodian of information and data pertaining to its citizens and residents. Sadly, in our country every issue is politicize to the extent that the implement introduced become impotent and ineffective ; Adhaar is a case in point. The UPA government, under Nandan Nilekani introduced Adhaar. Yet due to selfishness of common people, relentless misinformation by media houses and political compulsions it was merely made to a toothless document for identity of an Individual. To add more mockery to it, the state governments issued Adhaar to who ever they wanted to consolidate their vote banks. Adhaar, if it is implemented in a fakeproof and tamperproof degree, is an instrument which can eradicate religion, caste , creed, linguistic and regional affiliation from our polity and political dispensation. This is what the politicians do not want, not a single party. And we the citizens are too selfish to adopt Adhaar because it will require absolute transparency in terms of our sources of income, our properties & assets, bank accounts, our health and education details etc. And we for our selfish interest do not want it. We take the alibi of breach in data security and make Adhaar toothless and ineffective. We do not want to adopt any change, we do not want to be socially responsible, we do not want to be accountable for our professional responsibilities, accountable for social conducts and interaction; yet we never stop rueing on our outdated and rotten administrative system.
People like you duttaji. Who don't even read this bill and prassing a man who had passed matter in low and interbank riots. So please read the bill before say anything this is very important bill for our future.
@@jetsu3yahoo it may be the Caste system, which is leading to inbreds, India has a bleak future. prosperous lands do not pray to false gods or follow the lies of false prophets. nations ie Afghanistan which rejects Buddhism & Christianity r blighted
Exactly. Well said. Many people i see here commenting India is for hindus. India is for all religions. My ancestors fought as much for India like the other hindus. Who are these people to say me as a muslim has less right than a hindu. I love India as much as any hindu. Its my motherland as much as any hindu. My ancestors have been here for centuries here.
Those who have no idea of India can't protect the idea of India . Sibal said I am replying Those who have huge ideas of India like congress party since independence they can't protect the idea of India by practicing unbelievable and uncatchable corruptions like pc culture, collection of party fund from revenue, like helicopter and construction of roads, building etc ..This is the fact happened during this party which is having lots of idea about India and regarding the components of eradication of poverties in India
@@dvrocker he is an extremely corrupt lawyer, supporting Sahara ,UP based company, telling half truth by august speech, all this is beautiful may not be truth .
I can understand your concern. But when you create nation on religious beliefs, what people will do when their wife daughter are kidnapped raped and converted with support of State policy ? You read Indian factual history.Muslim are opressed? How population is growing 15% higher than majority? This is agenda of big International politics. People say take Rohinga ya muslim, why Muslim nation if Bangladesh and Pakistan not acceptable?
Raouf. they spreading lies and hateness each and every day..they making hindu rashtra in secular country..in Democratic countries this guys make temples and big big illegal ashram and this guys live free there its all negative to them.. but in secular country no muslim will be stay in his own country....this guys unfollowing the rules of country they creating there own rules...
@@@shareeqahmed1501 i think Secularism is the main defect of Indian Constitution, we hindu, jain, budhist, Shaikh naturally secluar in nature, we can assimilate with each other, but you people canot.
@@havegoodlife8719 you know about he say true agent of Pakistan what that he say and remember this is democracy country not autocracy all persons first of Indians firstly and lastly All are persons are independent about that problem and he is say Pakistani agent
If your idea of India is one where rats can come and scavenge food meant for the pigeons, why should I partake in your idea of India. No one has a monopoly on the idea of India not me not you. The majority has willed it and it will be done.
@@oneforallah In this parallel that you draw, you have equated humans to rats and that's part of the problem. They are no 'x' humans and no 'y' humans, we are are all one and India has been a cosmopolitan country throughout the ages. We embrace the philosophy of 'Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam' but not like this.. Not by segregating people. We reject the idea of divide and rule which as history has made us humble about it. These issues are an eyewash to the real problems plaguing the country.
@@kanavgupta9481 we love everyone but why should we give citizenship to someone who thinks us as kafirs and that's why they asked for a separate nation. We don't have any problem with parsis from Iran , no problem with Buddhist from Tibet but why only one community is getting all the hate and that's too, not only in India but In whole world. The idea of India which will allow others to exploit us by others. Why should we allow a idea above the nation? Ideas which are only good in books. Should we apply the concept of Vasudha kutubutum to hazif Saeed and Osama type people's too? We will show humanity to those who believes in humanity and will give bullets to jihadis
parvesh bisht Create lies...more lies...the community is not getting any hate outside India. There are some wars fought on political issues in countries which happen to have this religion(coincidence)…...because it's the 2nd largest community in the world... But some people are blind or only see through goggles of hatred.
Congress will lose either way. We will now protest against congress in the streets for opposing the CAA 2019 . They are shameless anti human rascals without any empathy for persecuted people of pakistan and bd. Just monsters pretending to be articulate leaders.
Mr Amit Sha ,We won’t let you wipe out our Muslims Brothers until our last breath . Because We are Indians and we believe in pluralism and inclusiveness. Because We are true Hindus and do not believe in your Hindutva idea . We wont let you divide India 🇮🇳 again
India has been divided on the basis of religion...okk..i know u r mulla but i promise to u ..not only we send the infiltrators but also people like you...
Yes India was divided on the basis of religion. One for Muslims ( Pakistan) Another for every religion ( India 🇮🇳 ❤️ ) Whatsapp univeristy doesn’t teach this
@@dragonpaili696 now india is for Hindus Sikh Jains Buddhist Parasi & Christians. We have already given more than enough land to muslim. Now no more new muslim to India. India is not aao jao Ghar tumhara. Pappu University shut up.
@@seahawkwatersports7061 sounding illiterate and being illiterate are two different words even if people are illiterate they can understand the difference between right and wrong
Jo Hindu CAA & NRC ko oppose kr re hain unhe apni Behen Betiyon ki shadi Muslims me hi krni chahiye...Aise lalchi, bewkoof or darponk hinduon ki wajah se hi aaj desh ki halat itni kharab h 😡😡😡
Top 3 Bollywood Actor (Srk, Salman, Amir) muslim, Indian cricket team ka ex captain Muslim(Azharuddin), Former President Muslim (Abdul Kalam), Many IAS-PCS r Muslim....fir b katuon ko Hindustan me rhne me darr lgta h...saale Pakistan ko apna ghar mante hain, shariyat ka kanoon...Aur kuch madarjaat lalchi Hinduon ko ye b nhi dikhta 😡😡😡
@@rohitsaxena9414 let me explain whats going on in simple words CAA itself not the issue but CAA+NRC is discriminatory. NRC:all prove again you are indian NON-MUSLIM: sir i dont have documents. Govt.:it's OK CAA will save you.U are INDIAN. MUSLIM:sir, I don't have documents. Govt.:too bad .u r not INDIAN ,get out.
@@rohitsaxena9414 aur bhai isme lalach kidr h , bewkoofi khaki h .aur darpok toh hum h nhi - pkka hindu hu. Maa-Baap ne kya sahi kya galat sab aachese sikhaya h
@@mayankm5200"Mullahs"...?!! Oh wow what a gud way of addressing someone..lol.. did i abuse any of my Hindu brothers here you punk...!?!! First off, u didnt get my point.!! Omg fascism is so much in your blood..!! Go get a life..educate yourself..!
Aiesi kanoon. Jo kanoon ko sab se pehle samman karne wale ye mantralay ki mantri log bhi thukk rahe hay. Qiyoke who achhitarha. Samajh te hay ye modi desh ko kitni barbaadi ke kagar pe le jaraha hay to Hindustani. Bhaiyo. Abi bhi waqt hay desh ko barbaad hone se bachao andolan pe uttro nahito kuchh nahi bachega mussalman Hindu. Isme kisika bhala nahi hay. Sabbarbaad ho jayega. Jago khud ki khane ki lale pade hay Hindustaan ke nagrikk ko aur dusre desho ko yaha nagrikkta ki kanoon pass Kiya ja raha hay unlogo ka khud ki Marzi thii Pakistan me rahne ki koie dhakel Kar bheja nahi thaa phir aaj Hindustaan ki nagrikkta chahiye. Kiyoo aur Jo nagrikk hay sadyo se who kaha Jaye ye hay modi is pagal netao se desh ko barbaad hone se bachao
13:44 to 14:20 .... well said "Those Who Have No Idea Of INDIA, Cannot Protect The Idea Of India" "Don't Convert This INDIAN REPUBLIC Into a Jurrasic Republic Where Their Are 2 DINOSAURS "
The last word of Mr. Kapil Sibal ( 'don't convert this indian republic to a juracik repubic with two dinosaures') should be written by a gold ink in the history of india, this speech will be memmorable for centuries and centuries
@Shaswata Chatterjee Sahi bola bhai, common people doesnt even know these kind of educated leaders exist within the party. Instead of the nepotism products, they need to promote these educated and sensitive leaders in the front
Respect to Constitution, BJP is just destroying the Constitution which is written by, dr br ambedkar.... He's one of the most intelligent person of India.😌
Well stfu mannnn.... U don't know shit about Constitution nd bills, don't blame fuking parties, it's the people who have lost their shit... If one gets a loose spot the other starts legpullin it
@@shrinivasmutalik7067 bro, no collective work sab bhag gaye they jab Constitution likhne ja raha tha, kabhi ispe study karna tab bolna half knowledge is not good
@gaming beyond then why names like c Rajgopal achari ,Dr Rajendra prasad etc..are taken if they ran away?Bro a company cannot be run by single person.Though I accept Ambedkar had more degrees which will lead to intellectual thinking,that doesn't mean he was the only one who wrote it or brought it into force. Peace
We south Indians support north east people in their fight against CAB. India isnt a dharmashala for migrants whether they are hindus, xtians or buddists really doesnt matter. If bjp is so concerned about those refugees then buy some island after selling your partys assets and ur chela bhaktas and keep thise refugees there.
Thank you. We are on the verge of death. The illegal migrants of bangladesh have already started violence on the local people of north east india. We oppose CAB, we are becoming slaves in our own land
Shri.Kapil sibal, Hon. Member of Parliament, a learneerd Advocate has presented a beautiful points of valid in accordance with natural justice. I hope this message will prevail upon intellectuals.
Yes ayese hi logoka zaruratt hay desh ko ayesi soch aiese hi aducated log koie chai walo ki nahi jago Hindustaan I yo ye bjp neta. Kisi ki nahi hay aapni tijori bharta hay aur desh ko tod raha hay dharam ke naam per ajj kitne log hay dharam se uper sochta hay. Dharam se uper socho tabhi desh ki tarrakki hogi Hindustani bhaiyo jago Hindu Muslim ek ho
Saurav Kumar,, I love your comment, Yes We need more people like him, which is more difficult in coming generation. But Lets Hope for Best. And Yeah , I also humbly request you, Correct the Grammar because Some Stupids will never understand the Emotion , and the Logic of Language, Language is used to Express the Emotion, which these Chutiyas will never get it. Well The Correct Statement is, "I am Proud on a Leader Like Kapil Sibbal Sir" 😊 Stay Happy, Allahafiz.
@@TheKyahua I used to fight people with rationality but I realised that people prefer false promises over truth. It is easier to hate than love. I was definitely not the part of May2019 verdict.
He is a man with lots of knowledge. I could listen to for the whole day. In my opinion India is falling down at an exponential rate with BJP in power. When Modi first came I thought he will rescue India from corruption. Now corruption is not in daylight anymore but Now a whole lot of new problems has emerged .
Wow!!! What a thoughtful speech by Kapil ji....""Those who have no idea of India cannot protect the Idea of India"" Fantastic 👌👌👌... Don't convert this Indian republic into a Jurassic Republic,where there are two dinosaurs... Incredible Speech👍👌👍🙏🙏🙏
@@sobhabinoy3380 Exactly that's what I told you and all other who support congress leaded by papu and this kind of funny man go to some place where this kind of people live
Stop worshipping those coward actors they haven't even raised a single finger against these things. But these are the real life heroes whom we should respect.
It's really marvelous to see such an eloquent parliamentarian and a formidable advocate bringing to the fore the underlying meaning and perspective of a key constitutional matter.
congress ko aise padhe likha logoko leader banana chahiye... na k rahul gandhi ko... pr fir india k log bolenge kapil sibal muslim hai... fir vo kitna bhi intelligent ya patriotic ho !
I m from Pakistan..this person delivering very sensible speech ...i think Indians should encourage that type of people for development of humanity Thanks
What a sharpness is in that presentation which has hited at the right spot, fearlessly. Kabil Sibal is being a senior advocate of supreme court of India he knew how to preserve the points of Indian constitution and he measures it appropriately by this manner ""converting Indian democracy to the Jurassic democracy where there are two monster dinosaurs"" Well done sir, you are a true hero.
