Karsaaz Accident | Karachi 

I am law student from university of law college Quetta . Apsa bhut khuch sekhna ko mil rha ha , stay blessed sir ❤

معزز کائونسل بہت خوب عمدہ انتخاب مزہ آ تا ہے آ پ کو سن کر۔۔معلوتی

MashAllah Sir ❤❤

Dear sir, all have been proved by medical examination that Natasha was drunk. And i am sure by the guidance of you they will charge Natasha with section 302 of PPC. It was a lengthy but comprehensive analysis and the idea you came up with was also great. 🙏🏻. I developed my legal understanding on this issue just by watching your video. Izhar A. Khawaja Forth semester LLB student based in Karachi.

I learn very much from your video lectures,the way u teach is appreciated 👍

MIAN ALI HAIDER WAS MY STUDENT, HE WAS A BRILLIANT STUDENT, I'M PROUD OF HIM ❤❤

Right sir. Adalat wohi kary gi jo law mein hai. Unfortunately, judges are bound to act according to law.

ur view is 100 percent correct!

Very nice Ali Bhai, good analysis and right approach.

Very much informative

🎉informative respected sir

Excellently explained.

A very fruitful discussion 👍 Much appreciated ✨ Respected Sir, i need to comment in order to clarify one thing you said in the video that the legislature should amend the punishments provided by Sections 320 and 322 PPC, and if the legislature intends they can give retrospective effect to it. My question is, "Wouldn't it be in contravention to Article 12 of the constitution which deals Protection against retrospective punishment ?

Waiting from day one finally come...

I frequently follow your page about recent decisions and appreciate your legal understanding. But if the "knowledge based " portion of s.302 appliies to this incident what about the S.320 dealing expressly with rash and negligent driving which caused the incident and was the fact-in- issue of karsaz incident .

well explained sir😊

informative

Great learned counsel.You are always amicus Curiae

Law needs to be rectified and upgraded

Very informative sir ❤️

V good sir.

Legally there is no way because laws will not evolved in our country suddenly socially boycott the culprit and those who support the culprit Now we have to stand as a society😢

very good and informative video. sir, I like when u give examples of law in western countries. Sir , I humble request to you make a video on how to improve the system? what should be the role of the nation for the improvement of Pakistan system/legislature, thank you.

Could you please mention the case laws where it is stated that if a person has a valid license, they will be charged under Section 320, and if they do not have a license, they will be charged under Section 322?

Sir, The most eminent dissection of qatl e amad but the problem here is the case of first instance for instance the lodging of FIR. How can you amend the charges in the court of first instance for say in that case how can you change it into qatl e amd.

AssalamuAlaikum Ali Sir! Firstly kudos to you for your content. Do you provide internship program for law students? Your response would be highly appreciated Sir❤

Kesa qaanoon hai ke license tha toh 10saal qed aur diyat aur agr nahi tha toh sirf diyat😂

Sir your approach is veryproffesinal but by all means you are trying to pave the way for the accused. Although a Diyat law is there to compensate but again a severe social pressure is built by the public…in Pakistan there is a wide difference between rich and poor classes so people feel themselves a deprived class…..so there should be well defined law tone made

A.o.a sir kindly guide about status of making video of anyone to record the incident or making videos of police officers kr govt officers if they are not performing their legal duty.is it allowed or not.similarly can we install cctv cameras without any regulation, is there any limitatiins or regulations?as we see alot of cctv videows on social media posted by public

Assembly ka kaam Qanoon banana he magar assembly ko aaj tak kisi ne paband nahi kia ke har bande ke pas aik Degree LLB ki bhi honi chahie. Jab onhain Qanoon ka Ilm hi nahi he to wo Qanoon Saazi kar kese sakte hain?

i think hr pakistani ko law prhna chye tb smjh aye gy sb ko wrna log yeh nhi smjhti qanun ma kya ha

If its related to legislation then dont you think Supreme Court should take up this case as this case is seeking attention of public at large.

Sir, What about if she was mentally ill? or any accused is underage? will their legal guardian would be responsible or nothing would happen in such cases?

She is innocent.Must be released .she was just driving on her Father's road😮😮

Jin judgments ka zikar kar rahe thay sir wo list to lga dia kren sath

سر قتل عمد کے لیے نیت بھی لازمی ہے یہاں نیت تو نہیں ہے اس طرح پھر کس طرح قتل عمد لگے گا۔ کیا یہ ہوسکتا ہے کہ اگر کوئی جرم کے لیے دو essential ہو ایک ہو ایک نہ ہو تو کیا وہ جرم لگے گا ؟؟؟

Mian sb manay people do not know,s who are legislators? always explain clealrly legislators are those who sit in assembly and senate by your vote. Not by the will of lawyers and judges.

Why don't you take this case as a prosecutor ???

Na koi Nasha Kiya ho jab wo normal drive Chala Raha ho jab jasay wo main road hat kar chalaye darasal jab first gatri ko hit Kiya us nay us surat me uska demagh mauf ho gya us surat me usnay bireck ki bajaye acsilatar per paon Parth gya us surat me gatri ki us surat me speed Barth gai us hi surat me ya incident hotay Gye usi surat Samnay Arif saf ki bike ah gai Yun unka accident Hogy ab ya bataye wokasa Nashay me thi ya tu ahwaz uhti ahwam ki jab k easa nahi tha bohat pareeki say dekha jaye ya khud accident nahi Kiya gya ya sabitifaqi hoha

I have thoroughly analyzed the entire CCTV footage, examining it second by second and accounting for the service lane's road width. My analysis leads me to conclude that all three parties share responsibility, with the incident initially triggered by the Corolla driver. Natasha, who was on her way to a relative’s house near her own to pick up her son, took a familiar route, as seen in the footage where she brought her V8 to a complete stop due to the Corolla approaching head-on. The Corolla driver should have shifted to the left well before reaching her, which he failed to do. Typically, in Karachi, male drivers tend to give extra space to female drivers to avoid any potential confusion, but it appears this Corolla driver had ulterior motives. He might have noticed from afar that a young alone woman was driving a V8 Land Cruiser and chose to stay close, perhaps for a closer look. In some cases, such drivers even deliberately cause minor collisions to interact with the female driver. This may explain why the Corolla driver, despite having ample space on his left, did not veer away. Conversely, Natasha, after coming to a stop to avoid the oncoming Corolla, took a slight left and attempted to navigate around a large pothole, assuming the Corolla would quickly pass. Her focus was on safely bypassing the pothole, but the Corolla neither veered left, despite having plenty of space, nor sped up; instead, it came to a halt, leading to a collision with the V8. Natasha likely decided that before the lowly stalker Corolla driver could use the accident as a pretext to engage her in conversation, she would accelerate her V8. In doing so, she must have honked at the biker ahead several times, operating under the confidence that at high speeds, the biker would eventually move aside. Unfortunately, this did not happen, and the bike collided with the V8, causing Natasha to become disoriented and panicked. Her now out-of-control V8 then collided with a Honda City and flipped over. The bikers, too, bear some responsibility for their fate. Their bike lacked rearview mirrors, as required by law, which would have allowed them to see the speeding V8 from a distance and heed the horn. Additionally, if both had been wearing helmets as mandated by law, they would likely have survived with minor injuries. The CCTV footage shows both riders being thrown into the air upon impact, landing head-first on the left side, leading to fatal head injuries. Natasha herself could have suffered severe head injuries or a neck fracture from the massive impact that caused her V8 to crash and overturn, but she was fortunately saved by the vehicle's ten airbags. Amna’s daily journey through the hazardous traffic from PECHS to Gulzar-e-Hijri without any safety measures is a tragedy in itself. Despite being part of a city that contributes trillions in taxes, there are no state-of-the-art circular railways or metro trains with a network of connecting metro buses for students like Amna to travel safely and comfortably. May God grant forgiveness to the father and daughter who lost their lives, and may Natasha’s family generously compensate the surviving family members. Natasha should be pardoned as this was an extremely unfortunate accident, one that neither Natasha nor Amna and her father could have anticipated just seconds before it occurred.

MashAllah Sir ❤❤