Тёмный

Keir Starmer defends ceding control of Chagos Islands amid Tory criticism | LBC analysis 

LBC
Подписаться 902 тыс.
Просмотров 6 тыс.
50% 1

Argentina has vowed to gain "full sovereignty" of the Falkland Islands after the UK gave up control of a remote archipelago in return for securing the future of a strategically important military base.
The country's foreign minister, Diana Mondino, welcomed the step taken by Sir Keir Starmer's Government on Thursday towards ending "outdated practices" after Britain returned the Chagos Islands to Mauritius.
She promised "concrete action" to ensure that the Falklands - the British-controlled archipelago that Argentina calls the Malvinas and claims as its own - are handed to Buenos Aires.
In an intervention that will fuel rising Tory criticism of the UK-Mauritius agreement and its perceived implications for other overseas territories, Ms Mondino said: "The long dispute between Britain and Mauritius came to a conclusion today, with Mauritians successfully regaining their territory of Chagos.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalp...
#MatthewWright #KeirStarmer #ChagosIslands #Labour #UK #News #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 273   
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 3 часа назад
I personally fought in 2 Para on the Falklands. I lost friends and colleagues there. I don't care if the islands become part of Argentina, "IF" It is what the islanders someday want. I didn't fight to retain territory for britain. I fought to regain the freedom of an invaded population !!!!
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 3 часа назад
Well put. You have a greater right to express an opinion than most. Respect
@shaun906
@shaun906 3 часа назад
thank you for your service, deep respect!
@GreenSaxon
@GreenSaxon 3 часа назад
Surely you'd have fought whatever the reason?
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 2 часа назад
​@GreenSaxon I would obviously have obeyed orders that was my job. But I rationalised my actions in my conscience by telling myself that (I) was there to free a captured community held captive against their will, and not for the jingoistic political aims of a politician. Also as any soldier would have told you I was there to support and fight alongside "my mates".
@joegooner3563
@joegooner3563 2 часа назад
​@@brianferguson7840the sad that ng is people will go at you for the decisions made by politicians. I thank you for your service
@w-james9277
@w-james9277 4 часа назад
The Falkland islanders voted overwhelmingly to stay British. The Chagos isles are completely different.
@Aan_allein
@Aan_allein 4 часа назад
No difference
@shanewilson2484
@shanewilson2484 3 часа назад
Yeah Chagosians did not vote for this foreign takeover by Mauritius.
@31Blaize
@31Blaize 3 часа назад
@@Aan_allein There really is. No populations were displaced from the Falklands and in an independent referendum they decided they wished to stay in the UK. Poor Chagossians were kicked off the islands they'd called home for generations and had no say in their own future - even in this latest decision. They're also banned from the largest landmass in the island system because we've leased it to the US for military purposes. Saying it's the same is nonsensical.
@lesleylamy
@lesleylamy 2 часа назад
@@shanewilson2484they were thrown out now they can go back home, google on Labour Party, the tories have been negotiating they had 11 meetings Labour just finished off ,well done. They still have airbase there for 99 years .the difference between cagos and falklands they wanted it back ,Falkland want to stay with uk,
@catherinemartin6258
@catherinemartin6258 2 часа назад
@@Aan_allein yes Tory
@JMD-er5jq
@JMD-er5jq 5 часов назад
so Labour negotiated this in 3 months, and everyone said they would never get anything done, oh wait, Cleverly started the process and then has the audacity to blamed someone else
@michaelathanasiou2030
@michaelathanasiou2030 5 часов назад
Tories wouldn't have given the Islands away without a debate in parliament, Starmer avoided this because he knows Labour supporters are THICK---LOL
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 5 часов назад
@@michaelathanasiou2030 Are you Balliol or Trinity, poppet?
@johnadamski6246
@johnadamski6246 5 часов назад
Will it effect any person in the UK ,no it won't, Just the right wing press using it as a stick to try and hit labour with .The tories started the negotiations to give it back .Nothing would have been said
@ryanseager123456789
@ryanseager123456789 5 часов назад
​@@michaelathanasiou2030except they already arranged all the deals and have been since 2022. You can't even Google something to find out if it's true.
@JimmyCRM114
@JimmyCRM114 4 часа назад
​@@michaelathanasiou2030 Reality too boring? Too many stresses and issues you've no control over? Try reality fan fiction, don't let the truth affect your opinion ever again 👍
@seagull8415
@seagull8415 3 часа назад
Find me a single Brexiteer who had even heard of the Chagos islands until this week….. i’ll wait
@Overwatch17
@Overwatch17 2 часа назад
Me. I love the British Empire and can easily name all British Overseas Territories.
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 2 часа назад
@@Overwatch17 Well done. Have a biscuit.
@keifer7813
@keifer7813 2 часа назад
​@@Overwatch17 You love subjugating people do you?
@paulchambers6537
@paulchambers6537 23 минуты назад
You for real
@Kwippy
@Kwippy 4 часа назад
Just as in America, anger and hate are the new favourite passtimes.
@XTRAIT-em4rx
@XTRAIT-em4rx 2 часа назад
The UK and US truly are the brother of arms.
@jamessteel9016
@jamessteel9016 5 часов назад
It was the Tories that negotiated the deal; why are the right getting their knickers in a twist?! Before this was announced they wouldn’t have even known where Chagos is on a map.
@BumberClarke
@BumberClarke 5 часов назад
Because right wing media feed their viewers utter tripe and have no shame whatsoever about the truth.
@j7ech402
@j7ech402 5 часов назад
But they do know what a woman is
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Grow up, sweetie.
@jeddtilley6488
@jeddtilley6488 3 часа назад
The Tory’s are pretty left wing? Traditionally the Tory’s are centre right. Now days these Tory’s are nothing but a load of far left nut cases.
@catherinemartin6258
@catherinemartin6258 2 часа назад
@@j7ech402 wow did you use all of your two brain cells to come up with that 😂
@catherinemartin6258
@catherinemartin6258 3 часа назад
James cleverly wanted the deal done 2 years ago’ it’s just hypocrisy 🤔
@joseskoks
@joseskoks 4 часа назад
Mauritius just got some of their country back! Brexiteers and the Tories should be delighted for them
@gglen6574
@gglen6574 2 часа назад
All that's left to do now is, the same for Britain.
@Brockite
@Brockite 13 минут назад
The Chagos Islands are not and have never been part of Mauritius.
@nickmannion3879
@nickmannion3879 4 часа назад
The UN International court told us in 2019 our 'possesion'was illegal so in 2022 the tories started the process. The deal was negotiated by Cleverly/Cameron and the tories are losing their minds because Lab signed it off exactly as they were going to with the exact deal? Hilarious!
@bobby9791
@bobby9791 2 часа назад
The Tories are like Trump supporters, blind to any truth or facts.
@PJH13
@PJH13 Час назад
I'm afraid you're incorrect, Cleverly did but Cameron did not negotiate the deal; he vetoed it when he came in, because he thought it was a bad idea
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 4 часа назад
You can take the empires colonies away from the english, but you can't take colonialism out of the English.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
Sad but true
@XTRAIT-em4rx
@XTRAIT-em4rx 3 часа назад
Absolutely correct
@markbutterfield5093
@markbutterfield5093 3 часа назад
As the left has no understanding of anything. Firstly the Chagos islands were never owned by Mauritius and they are 1000 miles away. It was ceded from the French in 1814 and we freed the slaves on those islands. During the height of the Cold War the US asked we lease the islands to them, which we did and sadly kicked the islanders off and sent to Mauritius. They were being badly treated in Mauritius and the islanders moved to the UK, specifically my home town. My wife was among the people that moved here. They didn’t want Mauritius to control those islands. Plus it’s strategically important in case of war with China. China has close ties to Mauritius through financial ties. China will obviously use leverage to place radar station there to spy on the base causing the base to be ineffective and thus we give territory to China who are effectively colonising Africa and Asia trapping them with financial agreements that they can’t pay back. All you people on the left are concerned is virtual signalling, identity politics whilst countries that hate us are slowly taking. Bravo. Try virtual signalling in China, you won’t live long.
@gglen6574
@gglen6574 2 часа назад
@@markbutterfield5093 y'know I didn't even know why this was controversial, until your comment. Thanks for providing some balance to this conversation.
@XTRAIT-em4rx
@XTRAIT-em4rx 2 часа назад
@@markbutterfield5093 - The Prophet speaks.
@johnxforce4
@johnxforce4 5 часов назад
It’s not a question if we care about overseas territories, we should care if the locals of said overseas territories want to remain under British control
@gherkamum
@gherkamum 42 минуты назад
Matthew Massive Mistake By Starmer.😡 UK🇬🇧 need's control of Chagos Islands for UK security…Should have been voted on.....
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 8 минут назад
Poppet, you hadn't heard of Diego Garcia until you read yesterday's Daily Mail. Toot toot.
@ryanmatheson5137
@ryanmatheson5137 3 часа назад
Im really furious about this island i didnt know about until a few days ago
@Evemeister12
@Evemeister12 5 часов назад
Waiting for the gammons to come and cry in the comments section
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
It's hilarious. They go on about sovereignty yet are against it 😂😂
@zivkovicable
@zivkovicable 3 часа назад
@@samuelstevens248 They only want it for themselves...Scream for sovereignty then cry about waiting in the longer passport queue.
@gglen6574
@gglen6574 2 часа назад
@@samuelstevens248 interesting how ironic that statement actually is. You could be on the right saying the left gave them sovereignty but don't want UK to have it. Or the left laughing at people demanding sovereignty of UK but unwilling to grant it to those of C. Interesting veiw from this fence.....
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 2 часа назад
@@gglen6574 I don't really see the left demanding sovereignty for the uk
@keifer7813
@keifer7813 2 часа назад
Gammon is a slur
@akosiamarillo
@akosiamarillo 4 часа назад
I would bet no one can even point it on the map 😅
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Really? Speak for yourself.
@catherinemartin6258
@catherinemartin6258 2 часа назад
@@robertcottam8824 ok Robert muppet
@Overwatch17
@Overwatch17 2 часа назад
@akosiamarillo It's quite easy actually. Right in the middle of the Indian Ocean
@GlennSmith-m2e
@GlennSmith-m2e 5 часов назад
It was "owned" by Britain for the convenience of our glorious Imperial Masters in Washington. I'm actually quite surprised a UK government acted with anything approaching a form of independent foreign policy.
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Correct. Except that the UK would not have acted as such without permission from The Pentagon. Best wishes.
@lesleylamy
@lesleylamy 2 часа назад
It was not owned it was taken away the people can now go home well done Labour we still have an airbase there for 99 years.
@keifer7813
@keifer7813 2 часа назад
This is what people like the ones complaining don't understand. The UK is America's b-word. Has been for a while now
@PJH13
@PJH13 Час назад
@@robertcottam8824 Except the Pentagon was reportedly opposed to the deal (behind closed doors)
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 3 минуты назад
@@PJH13 Your source, being...?
@danielhargreaves5992
@danielhargreaves5992 2 часа назад
Guest says he wants to remain under British protection, well done Starmer .
@brian8616
@brian8616 3 часа назад
Focus on your problems in your own country not stealing other people’s land and exploiting it
@CliffordSullivan-fj7jv
@CliffordSullivan-fj7jv 5 часов назад
With global warming the chagos Islands will be underwater??
@verysurvival
@verysurvival 4 часа назад
Remember the Falklands? Thatcher was ready to fight to the last drop of someone else’s blood to keep it British.
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 3 часа назад
You couldn't be more wrong !!! Until the invasion Britain had been working for 20 years to transfer the Falklands to Argentina. All students were educated in Buenos Areas, all flights went via Argentina, and for years before Britain had stopped issuing UK passports to children born on the islands. But the invasion was an unmissable political chance.
@Rexel4th
@Rexel4th 3 часа назад
The fact that you think they are comparable shows you haven't even spent 30 seconds learning about this topic.
@verysurvival
@verysurvival 2 часа назад
@@brianferguson7840can you read English?
@verysurvival
@verysurvival 2 часа назад
@@Rexel4thalso Can you read English ?
@Rexel4th
@Rexel4th 2 часа назад
@@verysurvival Yes I can, thanks for asking. The Falklands are not comparable and referencing them only obscures the reality of the Chagos Islands. This isn't about fighting for "our" territory.
@georgesgontier2425
@georgesgontier2425 2 часа назад
Seychelles has hundreds of displaced Diego Garcia residents who can not go back. Since independence from Great Britain, Seychelles is the safest country in Africa. We also have the most moral army in the world. Never shot anyone waving a white flag. Never sexually abused prisoners and never occupied anyone.
@sasserine
@sasserine Час назад
Labour haven't given Chagos to Mauritius. This was negotiated by the Tories, before they lost the election. And every single critic knows that.
@barbaracartwright2335
@barbaracartwright2335 5 часов назад
The people who live there care Mathew. You would think different if it were your jurisdiction!
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
Think they'd be happy, to be honest. Got their sovereignty back 😂
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Who lives there, Barbara?
@barbaracartwright2335
@barbaracartwright2335 10 минут назад
@@robertcottam8824 don’t people live there?
@barbaracartwright2335
@barbaracartwright2335 9 минут назад
@@robertcottam8824 Chagossian Chagos Islander · ≈3,000 (Eclipse Point Town) (2014) · 95.88% British / American; 4.12% others; (native population exiled) ... ‎Sovereignty dispute · ‎Salomon Islands · ‎Egmont Islands · ‎Peros Banhos
@alasdairgood3929
@alasdairgood3929 2 часа назад
We were held to account years ago about this given we ethically cleansed the Islands for the American airbase. Sadly, the people of the Chagos islands won't be able to go back to Diego Garcia.
@dareensooraya9615
@dareensooraya9615 Час назад
This has a massive security threat to us . I'm livid . Daily mail has covered this
@sasserine
@sasserine Час назад
The Conservatives began the handover process, when they realised people were landing on the islands, able to claim refugee status from the UK.
@thepoliticalhousethatjackbuilt
The Chagos islands were a dependency of the French administration in Mauritius, France ceded Mauritius and its dependencies to the United Kingdom. When the UK handed Mauritius independence in 1965, the Chagos islands dependency was retained by the UK to lease to the Americans. Internationally the Mauritian claim of sovereignty over the Chagos islands is recognised by the UN, except for the USA and UK (until now). International Court of Justice ruling in 2019 stated that the UK "has an obligation to bring to an end its administration of the Chagos Archipelago as rapidly as possible, and that all Member States must co-operate with the United Nations to complete the decolonization of Mauritius". Therefore as a matter of International Law, the Chagos islands are Mauritian, which the Labour government are complying with (with the support of the US) and the US will now lease the Base from Mauritius. How or whom would qualify to vote in a referendum of Chagos islanders and where would it be held? It just seem like a sensible of practical proposition.
@kieranwright2650
@kieranwright2650 2 часа назад
Yes, people of Gibraltar do care if they are British. If you have visited, you would clearly see they care about that quite a bit. I didn't realise we qualified British people on whether they have a British last name?
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
All brexit voters are getting all in a twist over an island they couldn't point out on a map 48 hours ago. Can they seriously not see their hypocrisy about sovereignty. It's hilarious 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@stuc3195
@stuc3195 4 часа назад
I voted for Brexit. I also think handing the Island back is the right thing to do. Sorry to confuse you
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
@@stuc3195 I'm never confused. How is brexit going?
@Overwatch17
@Overwatch17 2 часа назад
@samuelstevens248 Not true. As a strong supporter of the British Empire I can identify all present, former and future territories of the UK.
@sarahdickson1724
@sarahdickson1724 2 часа назад
​@samuelstevens248 ask again, when, or if, brexit actually happens 😂
@PJH13
@PJH13 Час назад
What makes you assume this has anything to do with Brexit. I was an ardent Remainer, I have also known about this island (and been able to find it on a map) for 15+ years and I think this is a terrible deal
@William-oq2uj
@William-oq2uj 3 часа назад
The key is the word indigenous, How many people who live on the Falklands are people with a heritage there. Being born in Birmingham does not give you a birth rite.
@emcarver8983
@emcarver8983 4 часа назад
They have never belonged to Mauritius.
@lesleylamy
@lesleylamy 2 часа назад
They were taken away from them They have now been given back people can now go home , well done.
@ΒασιλικήΤουρατζίδου
@@lesleylamy No. When both the Chagos Islands and Mauritius were discovered by passing Arab seafarers they had no human populations.
@ΒασιλικήΤουρατζίδου
Chagossians sound to want to stay British-are you happy with that, Mr Wright?
@ayhanenver2823
@ayhanenver2823 5 часов назад
Cyprus given back with a fight yet still have an airbase used as a staging post for lsrael
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
No 'fight' in Cyprus? Eh?
@j7ech402
@j7ech402 5 часов назад
Get The Sausage out of office!
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
Then I want back in the EU if that's how you want it to work
@paulchambers6537
@paulchambers6537 19 минут назад
​@@samuelstevens248F. The eu
@anne-Aubeeluck
@anne-Aubeeluck Час назад
It’s not Great Britain anymore it’s time we had Scotland back
@anne-Aubeeluck
@anne-Aubeeluck Час назад
This Island was taken and I am Glad it’s back in Mauritian hands My husband was at college in the 60s when they took this island and they Dropped people in Mauritius with nowhere to stay they where living in parks with nothing..they never gave them money for houses or anything I was in Mauritius this summer and people do want it back England bshould never have taken it in the first place
@johnxforce4
@johnxforce4 5 часов назад
As for the Falklands, should check your history. Argentina never had claim to the Falklands let alone have mass settlement there. British settlements and sovereignty goes back to 1774.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
Then why do we deny other land their sovereignty
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 3 часа назад
​@@samuelstevens248 What has that got to do with your question. The Falklands were British before Argentina existed.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 3 часа назад
@@brianferguson7840 after we booted the French out
@johnxforce4
@johnxforce4 2 часа назад
@@samuelstevens248 so which countries have the UK denied their sovereignty in recent years?
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 2 часа назад
@johnxforce4 Not the country, some loudpiece nationalists
@XTRAIT-em4rx
@XTRAIT-em4rx 2 часа назад
No doubt the right-wing is going to be fuming with Starmer, then come with their version of The Empire Strikes Back
@ChriswithdaK
@ChriswithdaK 3 часа назад
The son's and daughters of colonisers are clutching their pearls 😂😂😂😂😂
@sbalmer132
@sbalmer132 Час назад
Did anyone ask the people of Chagos what they wanted?
@AnonAnonAnon
@AnonAnonAnon Час назад
Falklands and Gibraltar next followed by a Scottish vote on independence, same for Northern Ireland and abolishing the Union Flag.
@just-a-working-male
@just-a-working-male Час назад
Its that gammon standard. They dont like the idea of anyone telling them what to do but like Europe.
@adriaanbertdeveldeharsenhorst
@adriaanbertdeveldeharsenhorst 4 часа назад
Give Palestina back to the Palestine people. British empire lovers
@grahamhighmore7702
@grahamhighmore7702 3 часа назад
The British (including Churchill) decided that Egypt, Palestine and Iraq all should be given independence because the empire was too big to run after WW1. The problem arose that as the British got out many exile refugees (mostly Jewish) moved in a declared their own country across a large part of Palestine. The Empire had already decided to quit but the militant Jewish refugees pushed the British into divide and quit before they left.
@shanewilson2484
@shanewilson2484 3 часа назад
Give Judea to the Jews and Samaria to the Samaritans.
@shanewilson2484
@shanewilson2484 3 часа назад
Give Tibet to the Tibetans, and Uigurstan to the Uighurs.
@shanewilson2484
@shanewilson2484 3 часа назад
Give the Russian arctic back to the arctic indigenous, and Siberia back to the Siberians.
@shanewilson2484
@shanewilson2484 3 часа назад
Give the US and Canada back to the indigenous.
@kevinbaxter7390
@kevinbaxter7390 3 часа назад
YES 👏 ESPECIALLY BEING A STRATEGIC ADVANTAGE 🇬🇧
@GloriaHoulihan
@GloriaHoulihan 43 минуты назад
Perhaps you should ask the people who defend us Matthew?
@chrisspencer6502
@chrisspencer6502 Час назад
I’m sure he can point out kimi or whoever the foreign sec was should have been aware of this, since they were in charge when the icj ruled and probably inked the agreement to return it.
@heslingplantltd9968
@heslingplantltd9968 2 часа назад
O dear do you think one day just one day !! This useless article might just do something right ?? Where ever he goes he stirs up hornets nests just lock him up it would be safer 🤬🤬🤬
@KIngMartinAaronWaite-Shelton
@KIngMartinAaronWaite-Shelton 3 часа назад
I have got one question for the whole world? Was us European colonisation was better in past then now as in 2024? Including wars, feminine etc in the world aswell as pro & cons? From 17th century world to 21st century world; Edited; fixed it What is your say? 👇
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 2 часа назад
Eh?
@bobbyd5167
@bobbyd5167 Час назад
Matthew, one of the only remaining journalists/ commentators with an honest and fair voice.
@uksubversion
@uksubversion 3 часа назад
Abolish Monarchy! End Caste System! Return to Europe!
@mikj29
@mikj29 5 часов назад
Actually the usa evicted everyone that lived and stopped them returning if they went off island years ago iv followed this island story since rhe start
@bumberClart1000
@bumberClart1000 4 часа назад
Didn’t Boris originally sign it over?
@laidbackkodiak
@laidbackkodiak 4 часа назад
I'll save you the very easy Google search. No he didn't, cleverly was sorting out a deal before they got voted out so not sure why the tories have a problem now.
@zivkovicable
@zivkovicable 4 часа назад
@@laidbackkodiak The negotiations were carried out over three separate governments.
@laidbackkodiak
@laidbackkodiak 3 часа назад
@@zivkovicable cool, still doesn't explaine why now it's a bad idea... but they were up for it before now.
@lesleylamy
@lesleylamy 2 часа назад
@@laidbackkodiakbecause they did not finish it, well done Labour for doing it, we still have the forces there for 99 years.
@bobby9791
@bobby9791 2 часа назад
@@laidbackkodiak They’re like our very own MAGA muppets. They read the right wing rags and watch GB (not) News and believe everything without looking at real facts.
@reginapontes5672
@reginapontes5672 5 часов назад
You're sadly relinquishing your own homeland so why not?
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Who is relinquishing their homeland to whom, poppet? Best wishes
@diptidinesh1886
@diptidinesh1886 4 часа назад
Right to return - the chisms caused by the empire world wide!
@robertpetre9378
@robertpetre9378 3 часа назад
James not so cleverly strikes again 😅
@Salman_Saho
@Salman_Saho 4 часа назад
Still believe you have an “empire” eh 😂
@shaun906
@shaun906 3 часа назад
no, we have done very well transitioning, compare to every other empire.
@stuc3195
@stuc3195 4 часа назад
The people who live in these territories certainly care Matthew? Which is why every British Overseas Territory should simply be put to the citizens of that territory. In the case of chagos it seems reasonable for the Givernment to hand it back to the Islanders. Although I'm unsure quite what Mauritius has to do with it. The Islands are 500km away. They're closer to Sri Lanka than Mauritus.
@zivkovicable
@zivkovicable 4 часа назад
Mauritius is 500 km away..& almost 10,000 km from the UK...London is 600 km from Glasgow.
@stuc3195
@stuc3195 3 часа назад
@@zivkovicable yes I agree
@MichaelDeacon-o4s
@MichaelDeacon-o4s 4 часа назад
Wouldn’t surprise me if he gave Falklands back just to defy magret thatcher I still feel sorry for the men that died n got severely injured during that war
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
If the uk wants sovereignty, why should we deny another countries
@zivkovicable
@zivkovicable 4 часа назад
The Falklands will return to Argentina if thats what the Falkland Islanders vote for...& thats not happening any time soon.
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 3 часа назад
I fought in 2 para on the Falklands. I lost friends but I don't care if they become part of Argentina "IF" The islanders wanted it to happen. We didn't fight to keep territory!!!!! We fought to free an invaded population.
@haveyoursaythearsenalway9500
@haveyoursaythearsenalway9500 3 часа назад
The British colonialists aren't happy. Despite the vast majority of them voting for Brexit to get their country back it seems they don't like other people getting their country back 😂
@alexandrae5346
@alexandrae5346 5 часов назад
That China view is bunk. Look at the threats at Taiwan.
@mazdaheb1823
@mazdaheb1823 3 часа назад
Publicity stunt.
@TammyOldham
@TammyOldham 4 часа назад
We are not giving it away we are giving it back which we should, Starmer as given it back with a deal that we can keep and use the military base on there for 99 years.
@GaryTaylor-gp2qc
@GaryTaylor-gp2qc 4 часа назад
its never ever belonged to mauritius , the chagos people want to stay with the uk
@emcarver8983
@emcarver8983 4 часа назад
They were never owned by Mauritius. 🐑
@lesleylamy
@lesleylamy 2 часа назад
@@GaryTaylor-gp2qcthey want to go home.
@TammyOldham
@TammyOldham 2 часа назад
We colonised it like the French did before us, and we shouldn't have it. It was wrong to go around colonising other countries, and we should give back anywhere that we still coloninise it's as simple as that! It was what our ancestors did, and it was barbaric! Are you saying we should not have given India, Hong Kong, or any of the other parts of the world we colonised back?
@GaryTaylor-gp2qc
@GaryTaylor-gp2qc 2 часа назад
@@TammyOldham if the indians wanted to stay with the uk which they didn't then yes give it back , as said mauritius never had them , the chagos people want to stay in the uk , so no its actually wrong giving them to mauritus
@mikj29
@mikj29 5 часов назад
12:35 on clock from India
@RobThomson-x8g
@RobThomson-x8g 2 часа назад
Another labour clown show
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 2 часа назад
An erudite and considered contribution. Have a biscuit.
@neilg6675
@neilg6675 4 часа назад
Most Americans can't find england on a map, doesn't mean it's not fairly important
@pianolearnermolescroft4508
@pianolearnermolescroft4508 5 часов назад
My concern is that we are now hundreds of millions in further debt as we are leasing the base now.
@amiablekangaroo9934
@amiablekangaroo9934 4 часа назад
@pianolearnermolescroft4508 We were leasing the base before this deal. We've been leasing it since it's existence..
@coppershark1973
@coppershark1973 4 часа назад
Because LABOUR need to pace themselves! They’ve kicked the poor and given up territory and accepted bribes. SLOW IT DOWN. Work for US like you promised and then do stuff that causes friction. It is basic level stuff.
@Rexel4th
@Rexel4th 3 часа назад
They've "kicked the poor" by saying only the poor should get a benefit intended for the poor. They've "given up territory" by enacting a legal agreement negotiated by the Tories. They've "accepted bribes" by being open about donations whilst the Tories and Reform hide their funding sources. You just want to moan.
@markstevens6568
@markstevens6568 4 часа назад
It is outrageous that this was (a) not in the manifesto (b) conveniently done with zero debate in Parliament and (c) done with zero discussion with the people involved (d) we’re actually giving money to them also. Given the appalling record of this government so far for deceit and non disclosure and for spending tax payers money like water, and with the clown Lammy involved to me something “ain’t right”.
@zivkovicable
@zivkovicable 4 часа назад
Except this was negotiated and agreed by the previous government...It wasn't in their manifesto either. Of course we are giving them money. Britain made them homeless.
@brianferguson7840
@brianferguson7840 4 часа назад
How many of you have gone to the chagos on holiday, or even knew they existed before yesterday??
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 3 часа назад
@@brianferguson7840 Don't be so nosy.
@emcarver8983
@emcarver8983 4 часа назад
And that is EXACTLY why he should not be in government. He has absolutely no freaking idea.
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 3 часа назад
And what are your qualifications, darling?
@shaun906
@shaun906 3 часа назад
they lost the last election, so i agree, the tories "should not be in government"
@Nickbaldeagle02
@Nickbaldeagle02 3 часа назад
No idea of what?
@pauldavies7746
@pauldavies7746 5 часов назад
This has now given political capital to Argentina and Spain over their claims to the Falklands and Gibraltar. British lives were lost defending the Falklands, so we can't just give them back.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
What happened to sovereignty! 😂
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
But neither The Falklands nor Gibraltar are under significant threat. Even if they were, they are defendable/defensible; both morally and militarily. Spain cannot 'have' Gibraltar, on either premise; Argentina has even less chance of nicking the Falklands. Suggest you research the relative strengths of the British and Argentine militaries... More specifically, check out the capabilities of a SINGLE Daring-class destroyer or just FOUR Eurofighters, based at Mount Pleasant. They are there for a reason and more than sufficient. Rest easy. Best wishes
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
@@robertcottam8824 I think it's ridiculous that we own land that is on Spains land.
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 3 часа назад
@@samuelstevens248 But Gibraltar hasn't been 'on Spain's land' (sic) since 1704, poppet. It was ceded, in perpetuity, as part of The Treaty of Utrecht.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 3 часа назад
@@robertcottam8824 is it an island?
@jona826
@jona826 5 часов назад
If you look at the map this territory is nowhere near Mauritius. It's absolutely miles away. There was no need to do this. At a time of rising international tensions ANYTHING that even remotely threatens our national security is foolish.
@amiablekangaroo9934
@amiablekangaroo9934 5 часов назад
So how far is the UK then? 6 times the distance. Just stop.
@ryanseager123456789
@ryanseager123456789 5 часов назад
How does this threaten our national security? We still retain the military base there as part of the deal.
@iaf010
@iaf010 5 часов назад
Closer than Britain isnt it? And who kidnapped and threw out the locals? That was Britain again. And where did they dump these locals ? That was Mauritius - another French former colony that was recolonised by the British for a spell.
@amiablekangaroo9934
@amiablekangaroo9934 4 часа назад
@@ryanseager123456789 Thank you! Everyone seems to think the base is going too.
@samuelstevens248
@samuelstevens248 4 часа назад
Closer than then UK. It was originally Mauritian. So get over it 😂
@russellwilliams1163
@russellwilliams1163 5 часов назад
Is Starmer benefiting from giving away his own freebies now.
@robertcottam8824
@robertcottam8824 4 часа назад
Probably not, sweetie. But it depends on whether or not you know what you mean to say. Best wishes
@russellwilliams1163
@russellwilliams1163 3 часа назад
@@robertcottam8824 You know what I meant.otherwise you would not have said probably not
@russellwilliams1163
@russellwilliams1163 3 часа назад
@@robertcottam8824 I am just asking the question that is all . I don’t know the answer
@jamesreid8523
@jamesreid8523 5 часов назад
Its a Military Base THAS WHY WE HAD IT, Now China and Russia have the upper hand in the Indo Pacific. Well done Starmer yet again showing us why he is as useful as a cat flap on a elephant house.
@CliffordSullivan-fj7jv
@CliffordSullivan-fj7jv 5 часов назад
Not true the Tories are responible for this!!!
@ryanseager123456789
@ryanseager123456789 5 часов назад
We still have the military base... That was part of the deal. We have it on a 99 year lease
@amiablekangaroo9934
@amiablekangaroo9934 4 часа назад
@@jamesreid8523 We still have the military base. Stop lying and fearmongering.
@jamesreid8523
@jamesreid8523 4 часа назад
@@CliffordSullivan-fj7jv Its a Military Base, That's what's most important!! The Tories don't come in to this!! World security is what matter!!
@conquest_icon-f4w
@conquest_icon-f4w 4 часа назад
​@jamesreid8523 so you avoided the fact that you lied that the military base was no longer under British control.
@heslingplantltd9968
@heslingplantltd9968 2 часа назад
O dear do you think one day just one day !! This useless article might just do something right ?? Where ever he goes he stirs up hornets nests just lock him up it would be safer 🤬🤬🤬
Далее
LOLLIPOP-SCHUTZ-GADGET 🍭 DAS BRAUCHST DU!
00:28
Putin damaged by Iran’s humiliation | Ben Hodges
11:36
LOLLIPOP-SCHUTZ-GADGET 🍭 DAS BRAUCHST DU!
00:28