Can we take a minute to appreciate that he made an acrostic that starts with Windrunners, proceeds through the overlapping powers -- in order! -- and makes memorable sense? No easy feat! Well done, sir!
Always good to get a breakdown of the orders. The real question though is which one would you wish to join? I don't know why but the notion of the stonewards always appealed to me. Probably because their Herald is quite possibly the single most noble being in the whole damn cosmere so if the order bears any resemblance to him at all..... just damn son.
The Stonewards were said to most match the nature and temperament of their Herald, so it sounds like a good match. I'm honestly most drawn toward the Truthwatchers, both because I like the surges they can bind, and the "outcast" feeling we've gotten with Renarin is really relatable to me.
If they weren't led by Nale, whose interpretation of justice is a little... skewed... Skybreakers, without a doubt. You'd basically be a cop that can fly, yeet people into space, and disintegrate things.
Either Willshapers, for their surges (don’t have any idea on their ideals, but they are probably not that restrictive), or Edgedancers, because I kind of like their ideals. Some of the other orders I thought about have ideals I’m not comfortable with (Elesecallers and Windrunners).
Elsecaller/ Truthwatcher here according to the official quiz. I got them in the reverse order, but identify with them in the way I wrote them previously.
I wish i could put it words how much i enjoyed this video. It was amazing, i see you more confident in the way you talk, and it really makes it a pleasure to watch. I died when i heard the last windrunner oath. Thank you for your work!
Great video! Nice to see another of these. What I was left wanting was some of the oaths of the other orders apart from the Windrunners, but maybe it's not worth an entire video since there are a lot we don't yet know, maybe when the next book comes out there'll be more content for that.
Yeah, we haven't seen many oaths of the other orders. The only ones I didn't include that we've seen are the Bondsmiths, but I thought those might be a bit too spoilery than I wanted. Oh, and the Skybreakers. Oops.
Ooh, that's a good question! I think most would probably pull the lever, because that would technically be the greater good. Except maybe the Skybreakers.
They'd pull the lever, go to the single person about to be hit, summon their blade and then free them because they're storming magic warrior wizards in outer space.
When shallan draws the image of yalb and the other sailors on a beach, and someone destroying a statue, I'd she displaying the tie between truthwatch and lightweaver?
There could be some crossover, but the Words of Radiance also talks about how the lightweavers would bring comfort to their fellow orders, perhaps by doing similar things. It's an interesting thought.
Of course if there's anything you haven't read by Sanderson, that would be my first recommendation. Is there a book of his you haven't gotten to, Cosmere or not?
Hold up, I’m kinda new to the Cosmere, but I remember meeting someone in the interludes of Words Of Radiance, his name has two consonants and he is a cobbler and he was talking about “we are all the same” and all that stuff. Then Nale killed him. But I don’t know, I’m still new. Because there was also another mention of a cobbler taking care of street kids in Edgedancer. Maybe they are the same, maybe they are different, I don’t know.
@@TheCosmerenaut Wait, he was gonna be a Truthwatcher? How do you know these things? I honestly thought he might be a Bondsmith because of the way he was saying, “we are one” but I must be wrong.
Yup. The description of his spren - like a shimmer of light through a crystal - is a Truthwatcher spren. It's also been confirmed by Brandon: wob.coppermind.net/events/35/#e2507
@@henrywayne5724 him saying we are one is related to the iri religion. The iriali aren't normal rosharans , thier ancestors migrated from someplace other than Ashyn and btw the religious tale he tells is very reminescent of the shattering of adonalsium . So the iriali could be very interesting in future books. We might get to see them in the book with lift's flashbacks and they are supposed to be important in the space age of the cosmere. Check out thier entry on the coppermind
Haha, we did it totally independently! I actually just had to go check your profile because I wasn't sure what you were talking about. When I was prepping my script for this video, I thought of the phrase "coocoo for crempuffs" and knew I had to put it in.
Minor Spoilers for some Shallan backstory (I think from Words of Radiance). Aluminium can be soulcast. I don't know if it was a mistake by Brandon, but it's clearly stated at one point that Shallan's Aluminium necklace is worth a lot, but nowhere near as much if it wasn't soul-cast. When her brother was being taken for his gambling debts and she gives the debtor her necklace in exchange for her brother.
Hi can you talk a bit more about bondsmiths? For example Dalinar could start understanding people taking in a different language after speaking with them. Also the 2 abilities don't really explain how he was able to unite the realms. Even Stormfather was goofed up by this one.
I think that goes beyond his Order. He said he is “Unity”, like Odium, Honor and Cultivation. Maybe he’s becoming one of them. Just a feeling. And also when Dalinar said he is Unity, Odium replied “That’s impossible, we killed you”. I think there was a Unity before and he was killed by Odium and other accomplices.
Dalinar as a Bondsmith is about to manipulate the surge of Connection, which is one of the fundamental forces of the entire Cosmere. Worldhoppers like Hoid use a similar method to speak local languages, though others actually take the time to learn.
Aluminum can not be affected by any type of investiture which makes it one of the only thing in the cosmere that can survive nightblood. Things can be soul cast into aluminium but aluminum can not be transformed into any other essence
RoW SPOILERS ahead! So, the corrupted Sibling spren was able to negatively affect the radiants, probably through their spirit web. Could overwriting your spirit web using soul forgery prevent this effect, or since the stuff is still there, just overwritten temporarily, would it not work?
I don't think it's so much influence of the spiritweb as a whole, but manipulation of Connection - which we've already seen Bondsmiths do. It's likely any Forgery would have a similar negative effect on the Nahel Bond.
Hey, awesome video, man. You summed up all the orders pretty well. On another note, do you have any recommendations for books similar to B. Sanderson's Stormlight Archive? I have read all of the Cosmere.
Thanks! If you haven't read his other books, like the Reckoners trilogy, the Alcatraz series, or Legion, they're definitely worth it. I've started going through the Wheel of Time in order to get to Sanderson's ending, so that's a good choice too.
@@TheCosmerenaut Yeah, I might check out his other works. I've already started reading WoT since I've heard that Sanderson took inspiration from it and that it's generally similar to Stormlight. I'm loving it so far, but some asshole spoiled me some things about the story, so I will see how that turns out. I've also heard good things about Malazan. Have you ever tried it?
@@TheCosmerenaut I see. I've recently finished Dresden Files book 1 recently. I thought it was okay, but I've heard it gets better after book 3 or so. Stormlight 4 is still quite far away, but at least there are other books to keep us occupied in the meantime :)
I've noticed that you do not pronounce any of the J names with a hard J, more of like a yah. That's the exact opposite of how I pronounce that stuff. Jasnah is a hard J like a Jeremy or closer to a Jasmine (I mean, Jasnah is so close to Jasmine after all...). Same with Jah Kaved. I dunno what is right, but that's how I do it.
That's how I was originally pronouncing them when I first started Stormlight, but both Brandon and the audiobooks pronounce all the J names with a Y sound. I assume it's a linguistic thing on Roshar, like how in spanish J is pronounced more like an H.
Most of it is based off information found in the books. Some of the bits about what certain heralds are up to currently has been either taken from, or at least confirmed by WoBs. I pulled most of it from the Coppermind, so all the references can be seen on each herald's page there.
I found it interesting, just see you cutting the video all the time but not doing it while remembering the lists...That was kind of out of place, In any case here is my like and keep up with the good work
I knew the orders and the surges, but couldn't always pair them up correctly without checking. I figured if it helped me, other people might find it useful too.
I'm almost finished graphic audio oathbringer, and I have to say - it does feel long.. the others didn't really but maybe that was because they were more interesting as all this (Radiants and Roshar) was new to us in the first 2 books
Which order would I like to be in? None of them, considering the fact you have to be traumatized in order to get in and, I'm sorry, but the prospect of going through a horrifying experience only to be conscripted into an army to stave off the end times is not a job prospect I find appealing.
I don't think the trauma is important. I mean, we know that in order to bond a spren, you need to have cracks in your spiritweb, so of course some sort of "traumatic" experience is necessary, but I would argue that life itself is traumatic enough. We get beaten and broken down enough just going through our own everyday existence, that all of us, even those who, from the outside, seem to have had it easy, likely have those cracks. But being broken isn't the most important; it's what you do afterward. Do you pick yourself up, fill those cracks with something stronger, and keep doing the best you can even in the face of the end of the world? Or do you roll over and get swept up in the highstorm of life? That's the most intriguing concept in the Stormlight Archive to me; the difference between a perceived noble who falls, like Amaram, and a character you initially hate but who rises, like Gaz. It truly has to be "Life before death, strength before weakness, journey before destination." For all of us. Sorry for the wall of text.
@@TheCosmerenaut Well, I'm just going off of what I've heard WoB mention that all Knights Radiant had to be broken emotionally in order to bond. Which was why Adolin hasn't bonded with any spren, because he's fairly content with his life and doesn't really have anything he feels particularly bad about, unlike the other Knights we've seen so far.
@@TheCosmerenaut Apparently that's been misunderstood by the radiants of the past. As there is one well adjusted character (Lopen I believe) who is well on the radiant path. Bascially the idea is that you have to be "open" what exactly THAT means is another RAFO
