I’ve always thought Winter’s dancing is so clean and precise. Personally I like her dancing style better but I understand why Karina is the main dancer
@@cha5156 i havent seen more than 10 ppl saying this….there are way more ppl who think Karina dances better…and that is for a reason…i have even seen ppl saying ningning dances better than winter…there should be no opinion on who is better becuz Karina is objectivly better… and there is a huge gab between Karina and winter esspecially other aespa members….dancing is about tech…Karina is a better dancer than ryujin in itzy so if she was in itzy she would be 3rd best….if winter was in itzy she would compete with lia in dance…becuz yuna is a lit better than her…i have danced for 7 yrs….i am 17 and even teach…we have to be able to accept these facts first… it became really clear there dance level in STEP BACK ERA…when Karina stood out and winter was one of the worst in those performances.
@@cha5156 u see this is how it is when i chose to spill the harsh reality…i always try to sugercoat but when u non dancers try to act like this…this is what happens
@@cha5156 its not that u cant have ur subjective opinion…. Hey i can prefer lil punk music more than Kanye …but it aint going to change the fact that Kanye is objectivly better…u can have a subjective opinion but there is always for most things an objective truth
As a non dancer, Karina dance like rent due & its fun and Winter dance like this is what she's told to do, so she does it exact, no more no less.. both amazing to me tho
Karina's dance style is not kind of style for idols she has a big and powerful moves and she knows how to control her energy in the group that she will not overlap with the other members
그냥 성향임.. 카리나는 열심히 동작을 크게 쓰면서 춤을 추고 윈터는 여유롭게 적당히 추는 느낌 그래서 같이 추면 카리나가 더 잘 보이는 느낌임.. 아무래도 같은 춤을 췄을 때 카리나가 더 힘듦것임.. 좀 더 파워를 실어서 추기 때문에.. 각각의 장단점은 카리나는 같이 출 때 더 잘 보이고 춤이 다이나믹하지만 라이브 할 때 숨이 찰 수 있음.. 원터는 카리나에 비해 튀진 않겠지만 라이브시 덜 힘들고 춤추면서 보컬을 안정적으로 구사하기 쉬워짐. 윈터는 춤추면서 고음과 다른 멤버에 비해 더 많이 불러야 하기에 저렇게 적당한 춤선을 가지게 된 걸 수 도 있음
I'm so mad every time I see international aespa haters called "aespa has no stage presence" or "aespa can't dance", are you blind? why can't you see how good Karina and Winter slay every dance moves and how clean they executions all their choreography, aespa's choreo has many hard details and iconic moves, AESPA jjang 👍 AESPA DANCE LINE "KARINA WINTER" JJANG 👍
I think I'll agree they have no stage presence because they seem like robots on stage cause of their group image cause they feel as if they are "perfect" idols but they have no stage presence and on top of that they don't even sing live
stage presence thing is kinda right though because of they always have to lipsync and don't have the chance to be that active on the stage, i blame SM though. They should allow them to showcase their live vocals
I was happy to see such a video... Ignorant people were constantly criticizing Karina by commenting on the dance. I'm glad that professionals are talking about this. Unfortunately, I don't think aespa's choreography is good enough for Karina to stand out. If you look at the "Step Back" stage, you'll see that she is an amazing main dancer with powerful and detailed moves. Winter is pretty clear. I don't think the attractive thing about Winter is the way she dances, but Winter has a strange charm. Watching her fancams is so much fun. It's not because of the way you dance. You know. She's just Winter. Stop and watch her fancams for hours. You won't be bored. She is like textbook. I also want to talk about other members. After all, aespa has 4 a member. Ningning comes after Karina in stage dominance as well as being a good dancer in my opinion. Ningning is a really good dancer. I don't know how to describe her, but it is possible to say that she also has a special aura. As for Giselle. She received a lot of unnecessary criticism about her dancing. Giselle is not a bad dancer. I think she has style. She will smile at you in a sassy way and make casual gestures. She adapts the sharp movements to herself, making them a little softer but sassy. To me, the way aespa members dance is more like boy groups than SM's girl groups. They remind me of NCT and EXO.
karina definitely the main dancer for a reason she always stands out in dance practice videos and she was remarkable in step back especially considering that she’s with seasoned idols/seniors
As a dancer Karinas dance always impressed me… her moves are great, her isolation is so good, her footwork has become alot better shes so light kn her feet now and moves to the rythem better…
There’s a reason why winter’s fancam always has the most viewed in every era.That’s because of her attractive dance that makes her stands out.People are acting like she’s the worst as a lead dancer but from dancers opinion they keep giving compliments for her and says that winter is not far from karina.Haters are just overreact
Personally I'm sad she doesn't get much chances to show off her dancing despite being scouted for dancing because SM discovered her marketable vocals. We know from their title tracks that she does really well, but we also saw it from the Kick Back challenge and her BoA stage. From her dancing style, she seems like she'll do really well covering boy group songs or hip-hop songs
exactly they act like karina is light years ahead of winter same with when it comes to ning ning and winters vocal comparison. Ning ning is better but not by a huge gap.
kpop stan twt always discredit aespa's dancing yet here we have PROFESSIONAL DANCERS praising aespa's dancing skills. I hope people won't believe anything your read on social media because everyone on the internet tries to be something they are not and judge people without respect. Only trust professionals when it comes to performances because their opinions are what we can consider constructive and valid. Anyways, stan aespa and let's wait together for their comeback :)
one thing about karina is you will never see her slack off, since day 1 from black mamba to savage, her energy is consistently high. she owns the stage.
"karina goes extra miles" yep karina always the one that complete every moves every dances steps. Look at karina in DCT she's always the one doing the leg waves and popping!
Winter has less issues than Karina when dancing (hence why she does the moves cleaner and simpler) but Karina has a lot more strength in aspects such as her footwork (not perfect but quite decent still) which makes her still surpass Winter as a dancer imo.
And yet W can't do a simple body roll in step back. Karina's body control is better. Popping one shoulder here and there doesn't make you a better technical dancer. That's why krn is the main dancer
@@heysungie8679 and you should watch the got the beat performance and dance practice bridge its obvious she hasn't complete control of her body it sticks out like a sore thumb there.
not really, jaem's sharp put also powerful. Like the dancer said, Winter has a line she doesn't go over while that's not the case with jaemin and jaem's more fluid as well. And Karina is quite detail oriented but Jeno tends to skip details sometimes. Karina's also quite graceful and fluid, jeno isn't, he's way more power centered
Jaemin and Winter doesnt have similiar dances at all wdym? Jaemin has fluidy but not as sharp as Winter, Jaemin doesn't have a proper body control like Winter too, they're too distinguable. Haechan is the one who similiar to Winter in a way since both of them arent overdone their dance. On the other hand, Jeno is heavily power based while Karina tend to focus on detail more. They're too completely different, Karina's style is similiar to Taeyong more than Jeno
@@γινομαιενα I'd like to correct you there. Jaemin has amazing body control, just look at any boom fancam and you'll know and he's very sharp as well. And no haechan and winter's dance styles aren't similar at all. Haechan is an extremely fluid dancer while winter focuses more on body locks and pops and moreover like the dancer said winter has a line she doesn't go over, haechan doesn't. They're both very different. If we had to compare her to someone in NCT it'd be jisung except that he's wayyyyyy more developed as a dancer than her.
@@vanshika2135 I agree that Jaemin has amazing body control, but to be comparise with Winter I dont think he has a proper body control attribute, that's why I also said he's not as sharp as Winter (still he's detailed based dancer too which explain why he's sharp in general). I said Winter is similiar more to Haechan is because they both tend to make the moves look simple, these two are pleasing to watch since both of them excute their moves in attractive way. I don"t mean to say they have similar the dance style, I said they're similiar 'in a way' since both of them have incredible attribute with their dance (Haechan with his fluidity and Winter with her sharpness), to me it is more reasonable to compare Winter to Haechan more than Jaemin when it comes to dance. I don't think Winter can be compared to Jisung though. Jisung is on different level, he's a part of NCT's A+ dance line along with Ten, Shotaro, and Taeyong.
i agree! winter has that kind of popping dance type(?) she would be good at hiphop dance please react to Seventeen new song Darl+ing. it's in english !
My eyes are always on winter. Her clean and very precise moves makes it so satisfying to watch like honestly i love it!!! 😳🌼 Whereas Karina!!! she is some natural moves based dancer, she has great flow and is a kind of bouncy dancer almost similar to kai? if you know what i mean. I love it they both are a dangerous duo💙
I will choose Karina because in all of aespa videos on stage, I never see even once of her slacking on stage. Her dance is so detailed and yet so powerful but she is still able to maintain a great stage presence and control the dance harmony of the group. She is not dancing solo with other members, she is dancing with other members.
As someone who also dances, I'll give my take. In terms of MBTI, this can be the explained as the difference bt an Introvert vs Extrovert dancing -one's internal focused and one is external.🤣They both a good dancers. I think Karina dances like someone who is dancing alone in her room while enjoying the music, where as, Winter dances like she's in a battle competition, focused, sharp, and precise bc she has to eat up the competition. IMO, I think Winter is more of a natural dancer and Karina is more like a star student dancer. Winter naturally has sharp and chic movements but Karina has a vibe to the way she dances, as if you can feel her feel the music more. In terms of musicality, Winter hits the beats harder but Karina has the groove. Personally, I would like to see a Winter & RyuJin stage collab vs a Karina & Yeji stage collab. That would be epic. Also, I feel like they would both be good at Krumping. (A Karina/Winter vs BlackPink's Jisoo & G-IDLE Miyeon krumping competition 🤣If you follow kpop, then you'd know what I'm talking about.)
I respectfully disagree and agree, up until a couple of hrs ago I thought the same thing, watching the BM dance practice VD really let me see that winter ain't much of a introvert dancer, she seem to have pulled back at times a lot of her fluidity and power. I had to go through several videos to see this, these videos don't highlight winter very much and there seems to be at times where winter just stop going for it. Winter is a natural/star student dancer she just holds back a lot.
@@mikimishisa Main dancer doesn't mean better dancer, just because you can give the same energy every single time, doesn't mean you gone execute every move neither does it mean, you going to better than the rest of group members in each and every since choreography
I just got into aespa like 3 weeks ago; they honestly lulled me back in after a LONG long break from kpop. First thing I noticed was Karinas "outward popping" as they put it during savage stages. I love her sharpness and power in all of those angled moves aespa has in a lot of their choreographies. winter also has a very distinct, laid back style. I love her control. great video!
one thing i noticed about karina is that she always have her flavor when performing, she never looked like she's dancing a step she memorized, she always feel like a performer. never saw her just plain executing the steps tbh. even if she isn't in the center, she gives her best.
fr! She kinda seemed nervous in her MAMA stage so she wasn't relaxed i think that's when haters go their so called reason to hate on karina's dancing. My girl gives 101%
I am so incredibly happy to see this video right here comparing the moves and the dance pros of karina and winter--like i would love more for insight on these things! they're both wonderful dancers, but it's the intricacies that set them apart and as someone who isn't a professional dancer this insight is so useful for me, and esp those who like dance and want to appreciate it. But as always xD hahaha PLEASE REACT TO CHUNGHA! I WOULD REALLY LOVE TO SEE THEIR REACTION AND COMMENTS TO HER LIVE PERFORMANCES OR DANCE CHOREOS! and i know that she participates in making some of the moves as well which only makes me look forward to what the pro dancers have to say!!! or even just generally on her movement and dancing dynamics!
The thing about Karina is that she always adds something else to her moves! She gives more than 100% to her performance and that makes her dance even more attractive!
Winter is indeed controlled, textured. But that gets I don’t the feeling out of the dance? I don’t know how to say it eloquently. Karina is bold and nice but she does have balance issues 😅 nevertheless her dance looks more alive?
I like Karina's dance strength, after Hina left the trainee team, Karina took on the role of main dancer. During black mamba Karina complained about the inappropriate shoe, currently they have been solving that.
after watching this video i can really see why karina is main dancer !! her moves are so powerful but clean and she dances like a true dancer !! whenever i watch aespa stages my attention is always drawn to karina as she has so much stage presence and she is so consistent with her dancing 🤩🤩 i like how when she dances she uses every body part and really lets the music control her body 🥰 in all her fancams her dance moves are so sharp and she is so skilled i love it !!!
Karina always dances like the rent has been due for months. She’s so good at what she does and she keeps getting better at it. I also really love how she always seems like she’s light on her feet as if she’s floating.
I think winter still doesn't show her whole potential in dancing bec.she is also a vocal material winter always showcase her vocal but not yet showing her dancing more specifically her poop dance
People always say winter looks bored and has the worst stage presence in aespa and her fancams have so many views only because she's pretty. I'm not denying that she still has a long way to go as a performer, but her moves are very sharp and satisfying to watch. As the dancers in the video said, she has her own unique vibe✨
their privilege is karina has a good body that support her dance and she's doing sports too before, for winter, she remember the dance faster than other members and i think she's kind of perfectionist who copy the dance as it is
@@fernandanahuelhual7799 they react to karina and winter bcs of they are dance line in aespa, karina is main dancer and winter is lead dancer. It's not an official position from sm but a lot of people said that
Yeah pretty much my opinion as well. Winter uses more muscle tensing to get these clean pops, whereas Karina lets loose a lot more to add more power into her moves
But stage presence is very important, I feel like having the most stage presence is more stasifying to watch than having the most accurate choreography. But whatever everybody is different.
Winter is my bias but it's really dis respectful comparing the main and lead dancers... It's always the fans who says Winter's better than Ningning or better than Karina. Everyone respect your opinion but Winter is the lead in both which means Ningning and Karina are the mains and are better than Winter.
@@cr8416 No, it is not officially announced by SM. The only official position is "leader". Instead of official position, there are lines. Dance line (Karina and Winter), vocal line (Winter and Ningning), and rap line (Giselle and Karina). Moreover, they are all-rounder.
@@boyyyo it's not officially announced but it is heavily *implied* . SM groups will always have official positions even when SM did not officially announced it, and so does aespa. Main vocalist is ningning, while the lead is winter and subs are kariselle. Main dancer is karina, and winter as the lead. Main rapper is giselle and lead rapper is karina. It's always been like that since the first time
PROFESSIONALS are praising their dancing skills and then there's some kids trying miserably to look down on aespa!!! At first, I was getting effected by their comments but it's been a while now since I don't give a damn about a word aespa's haters say~
