KOTLC FANS UNPOPULAR OPINIONS! 😱 Keeper of the Lost Cities Fans Share Crazy Opinions! 

Confession/Opinion: I think that Biana is a very well written character and I think that she should be on more covers. Cuz she is one of my favs and she absolutely SLAYS!!!!

tbh I feel like Biana and Dex are just the ultimate, and Fitz should just be a counselor so that he stays single forever.

I totally agree with the Fitz one- I'm 100% Sokeefe but Fitz is still a good character- everyone makes mistakes, no one can be perfect. And I feel like Cassius doesn't deserve redemption but Keene deserves to have a parent who cares about him ❤️

WE'RE SO CLOSE!!! And I agree with a surprising number of opinions in this. Plus one that you didn't add which was: ALVAR IS WRITTEN REALLY WELL!

I think lady Gisela should actually be the one who gets a redemption arc. But ends up dying. Like sacrificing herself for keefe in someway idk. Cuz keefe deserves some closure that his mom actually loves him

My thought : dex is overrated in the fandom but underrated in the books.

my friends like Fitz more than Keefe and have a fictional crush on Fitz and I can’t with them right now 🤢🤮

17 days until Stellarlune. I can’t believe it!! ❤

1:55 totally agree im like a mad sokeefe shipper but fitz is a good character and when he does get angry it's mainly for sophies protection. Except for the matchmaking thing that was a bit weird. But every character has their flaws.

JUSTICE FOR FITZ and also Justice for Ro! How dare anyone say bad things about her 😡 Great video!!!! CANT WAIT FOR STELLARLUNE

Wow 24 days is crazy I remember when it was title release day. I'd only just finished Unlocked haha...

I JUST CHECKED THE DATE, WE’RE SOOOOO CLOSE TO STELLARLUNE OMGGGG IM SO EXCITEDDDDDDDDD 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

I still need to preorder Stellarlune. 💀

I STAND BY MY OPINION 💪💪💪 And jeez I didn’t realize Stellarlune is approaching so fast! It’s funny how I’ve been telling myself “it’s going to come, it going to come” and it’s closer now than ever!

Ok here’s the thing: I really don’t agree with a lot of these, but it’s ok. Everyone has their opinions and that’s ok! Love the vids! Also I think Sophie is not oblivious. Also IM SO EXCITED FOR STELLARUNE!!!! And I hope keefe comes back!!

YALL! I JUST REALIZED STELLARLUNE COMES OUT IN 15 DAYS!!!!!!! This is it guys we’ve waited so long and the wait is almost over!!

jensi honestly doesnt seem serious enough to do anything in the black swan, and i do agree that fitz is hated too much by the fandom. also tho i never knew you read warrior cats! noticed on the shelf lol

I disagree that Stina is a bad character simply because she doesn't change- it's called a flat character arc. I think she's interesting because she one of the only elves who challenges Sophie. I think she could be far more interesting though

I'M SOOO EXCITED I HAD TO DO A LITERAL BOOK REPORT ON A BOOK I HATED JUST TO GET MY DAD TO PREORDER IT 😭. also HIIII

I finished watching the school of good and evil movie right when this was uploaded 😂

i'm telling you i saw the thumbnail and clicked immediately.

I would love part two!!! Please do part two!!! Also: Dex is overrated. People obsess over him, but tbh I dont rlly like him as a character. He took advantage of Sophie's problem and made it more awkward and more difficult to solve it with the crush cuffs. He holds grudges for stupid things and get over jealous. The crush he had on sophie was random. I don't know why it was even ever mentioned. 🤨

I have a theory!!! I don’t know if y’all have talked about this or not. But I feel like FOSTERKEEFE will happen in stellarlune. One reason is we all know that keefe is already in love with Sophie. And I know Sophie is in love with keefe. I think that lord cassius’ theory will become a big thing in this book. The theory about the difference between heart and head emotions. Sophie loves keefe with her heart but doesn’t know it yet. And she has a crush on fitz in her head. But once she realizes she likes keefe probably convincing him to come back or something of the sort she will realize her true heart feelings and can’t deny them. Or keefe will read her emotions and ask her about it. :))))

I agreed with most of what the people said, but to say Fitz doesn't have anger issues in blatantly not true. He gets mad at everyone and everything over the slightest things. I love Fitz, but he needs to work out his emotions better.

5:41 i cannot agree more, that is clearly what she did. i don’t know how to explain it, but it’s just so evident of her needing to bring him back in.

I agree and disagree with some of these opinions .Yes, Jensi is totally underrated, cmon Joey! .Edaline and Grady are one of my fav relationships in the series, they’re just adorable .Okay okay I’ll admit it, Fitz is a hated A LITTLE too much, and he has his issues *cough cough anger issues* .CASSIUS NEEDS A REDEMPTION ARK .Honestly Sophie is the most relatable character, not Fitz .YES WE NEED MORE THAN JUST KEEFE WHERE ARE DEX BIANA MARELLA AND MARUCA .Lady Gisela is a really brilliant villain actually, I GASPED IN BOOK THREE IN THE EVEREST BATTLE OMG😭😭😭 .I NEED MORE OF RO .I actually really enjoyed more of Lord Cassius in the first three chapters that Shannon released, he is an underrated character because of how he treated his son, but he is still a great character. I’m not saying that he or Gisela have redeemed themselves, but Cassius can redeem himself .THE FORKLE TWIN THING WAS GENIUS WHAT THE HECK IT WAS AWESOME WE ALL CRIED AND SCREAMED AT SHANNON AND THREW NIGHTFALL ACROSS THE ROOM .Keefe is overstated we need to admit it. Silveny has become forgotten. SOPHIES PARENTS BRAINWASHED WAS SAD .Marella is going to CHANGE and become more important. Stina is a MISUNDERSTOOD character and has her own struggles that we probably don’t know of yet. No one is just mean to be mean, bullies always have their own conflicts .SOPHIE IS NOT ANNOYING SHES ADORABLE. THE LOVE TRIANGLE WORKS BECAUSE IT IS NOT OVERTAKING THE WHOLE PLOT. KEEEFE… yea Keefe is overstated I’ll admit it. The series isn’t really repetitive .FITZ HAS ANGER ISSUES. THATS ALL ILL SAY okay I’m done ranting

WHEN STELLARLUNE COMES OUT I CANT WAKT FOR ALL OF UR GUYSES VIDEOS ON IT! (They better be titled, "why I'm happy SOKEEFE got together)"

I have legit been talking abt kotlc every day to my friends bcs of how excited I am for stellarlune bcs it comes out soon

I ABSOLUTELY AGREE WITH THE FITZ ONEE!! I SHIP SOKEEFE BUT LIKE FITZ DOESN'T DESERVE TO BE SO HATED AND HE DESERVES MORE LOVE BY THE FANDOM!! (also,my unpopular opinion is I like fitz like a billion times better than Keefe cuz he drew me to him in the first book and I will never betray him ❤❤)

SEVENTEEN DAYS UNTIL STELLARLUNE

Please do a part 2! Also for some reason I feel like a lot of these unpopular opinions are made popular? Idk... I agree keefe is overrated. I love him but he gets too much attention. Fitz does get hated too much I don't like him a lot but he should not get so much hate. Dex is kinda overrated in the fandom but I still love him as a character. Biana is just amazing I would like to see more of her. Idk why tam is so underrated with fans I love tam he is awesome. I honestly don't really know why Wylie's part of the team like he is so much older and he doesn't really do anything? I feel like he's just there so wylinh can happen... Um ok. Marella - I honestly don't care if her character doesn't change at all because I like her the way she is with flaws and stuff and she doesn't really need to change. I love how feisty and brave she is and she's really funny. But I understand the character growth thing so I'm hoping linh can do that. Maruca really needs to get more attention! Which I'm hoping for in stellarlune as well. Literally! I love her she is so nice and pretty 😍 not saying that's the only reason I like her. Anyway ... Here's a few more. Jensi is a really funny and awesome character and I don't mind if he comes back but if he doesn't I also don't mind so much. I know in books characters in the beginning usually last to the end or come back and it's kinda weird that jensi just pops up in random places and just disappears afterward. But I'm honestly ok with that . In real life it's normal to have a nice friend to guide you around in the beginning and even though you're still friends you're not that close anymore and you don't see each other around that often so yeah I can understand. And I do want more silveny ! She doesn't have to save Sophie or anything but I just love her and greyfell so I would like to see some cute scenes with the alicorns and other animals maybe as some break between all the action. I'm hoping to see more action like actual fighting between the neverseen? Like really intense action with lots of description and using of abilities. It would be so cool to see the battle of abilities since they are elves. Anyway so excited for stellarlune! I'm sorry for the long comment.

I'M SO EXCITED FOR STELLARLUNE TO COME OUT!!!! My friends are sick of me repeating and repeating how excited I am though! Team Foster-Keefe for the win!

keefe is definitely not overrated

The one thing I have brought up many times that I still support is the fact the Stina is one of the best characters in the series

Honestly, Jensi doesn't have a lot to do with the story. He had potential before Book 3 but now I feel like a comeback would be way too weird now.

Marella is the better version of Keefe. She has pretty much everything Keefe has (including the looks), but done better. The problem with Keefe is that Shannon liked him SO MUCH, that she decided to make him the focus of the series, and it's annoyingg. I feel like if this happened with Marella, it'd be the same, but Marella still needs more page time

I don't like Fitz, but not for the reason a lot of people don't. I don't have much of a problem with who he is as a person (except for when he hurt Sophie, but I'm willing to forgive that because everybody makes mistakes). My problem is actually with his character development/growth. Whenever there is a conflict that is centered around him, almost the exact same thing happens every time (Fitz gets angry, then he apologizes). He never seems to learn from his mistakes and he really hasn't changed all that much from book 1, aside from all of the relationship drama. Fitz just seems really bland to me, and I'd much rather read about other characters instead of having to read about him.

Thank you for giving Fitz grace. He deserved it.

1:05 I agree I dont think he had a purpose, just like a side character. I think ppl are overestimating shannon and her ability to bring jensi back into the story. It will be hard, and I just dont think that he's that interesting of a character, like he has no relevance to the plot. I think people hype him up too much. Buttt if Shannon does find a way to bring him into the story once again, I won't complain, but just don't think it's possible. Especially now that the plot is developing. It would be too late.

It’s my birthday 🎃

Ok, here I go Healing center in Flashback took WAY too long, but it had some funny moments which made it good Sometimes I want to strangle Sophie for various reasons (bad decisions, & being SO DAM [percy jackson reference lol] OBLIVIOUS mostly) I kind of want a character from the main 7 to die...or come very very VERY close to dying (other than Sophie) I want a Cassius redemption arc, & it seems like it's possible because Shannon Messenger is releasing some lines from the book, and one of the lines shows Cassius saying that Keefe can handle himself, he survived living with him and his mom in candleshade his whole life, so it's very possible it could happen I want Tam to get a stuffed animal Fitz isn't that bad, he's not perfect, nobody is, he just is so used to having life really easy that he didn't really know how to handle a huge problem Elwin, Edaline, Ro (obviously), & Sandor, all ship Sokeefe Dex is underrated in the books, but overrated in the Fandom I want Sophie in the forbidden cities to accidentally run into her human parents and I want to see her reaction to them, like she remembers them, and loves them, but they have no idea who she is, so kind of a heart breaking scene I think Glimmer has a different eye color than blue, and Tam knows who she is

I think Jensi has room for a good character arc so that he could have a bit more storyline In the first books I think he's been a pretty okay character but that being said we didn't really get a lot of back story for him... We were told he had an older brother in his family who we've never seen before so maybe something could be included in the main plot with some of his family (I think we all know abt the theory) But this is just my opinion xD Also I really enjoyed this video it was interesting to see everyone's opinions so ty for making it :D

I love fitz so so much

Opinion: I think Fitz and Dex are legitimately a good ship. I have written several essays about how the themes of their characters tie into this, how pursuing a relationship would show lots of character development on both ends, and how even them pursuing a relationship would tie up several existing loose ends in the series thus far. I can post one of my essays if you’d like.

Dude Stina's redemption arc is so random and doesn't fit into the storyline at all and actually kind of stupid Also I have to agree, the Mr. Forkle secret twin thing is so unnecessary, random and kind of runis the whole affect that his death is supossed to have had.

Okay so here's my unpopular opinions list, though I comment it on alot of videos -_- Sophie is weak and a useless, pitiful "hero" Fitz is the best written character in the series Keefe is annoying Ro is terrible Dex x Fitz is the best ship Except I also ship Dex x Biana 😂 Sophie is an awful friend I don't ship sokeefe Linh and Tam are overrated, mid, and kind of 2 dimensional Dex is the kindest fictional character to exist other than maybe Qibli from Wings of Fire and deserves 10k x more love than Keefe. Dex superiority. Empath is a dumb ability. We need way more talentless main characters. I think the Vackers and the Vacker Legacy are super interesting and I mostly just want to know more about them than like every other plot thing. And finally, I've written 12 fanfictions, and none of them were about Keefe or sokeefe.

1:56 same 😂

i have doubts that a Lord Cassius redemption arc will happen but I think that if it DID it would be kinda interesting depending on how well it's done. I mean if it's done the same way as Stina's redemption arc then HARD PASS. That was by far, the most pathetic redemption arc I've ever seen and just straight up crap I mean I am writing this after reading Stellarlune and no spoilers but I kinda feel like Lord Cassius's redemption arc has potential. Also I would like to see the triplets get more devolopment because they have so much potential and at this point in time don't actually contribute anything.

Just a question, is this forum for kotlc confessions still open or no?😊

why does everyone like lady giesla and lord cassius but hate alden. Sure alden made a couple of mistakes but lady giesla and lord cassius were so mean to keefe. I know alden isn't the best either but at least he's a pretty good father.

Honestly, I kinda think Keefe doesn’t deserve Sophie lol

3:09

SIX FREAKIN DAYS

I have mixed feelings about Fitz. He's not my fav but I don't hate him. He just doesn't mean as much to me as the other characters. I also can't look at his official art for some reason. (I can look at his fanart and covers) The same goes for Alden. He's just too much of a rollercoaster. He's fine then angry then (Almost) murderer then fine. Like what? Okay, you guys probably don't understand a word of this but let's just say he's meh to me. Meh

OPINIONS: tbh linh is kinda an annoying pick me marella smt acts rude i the short story stina converts marella and linh into a sophie diss of group fitz has a lil bug in the system but he aint that bad the keefster is NOT overrated it aint his fault he be calin all the ladies sophie is NOT annoying shes the main charecters she gonna think things that nobody elses hears but to them shes not annoying & she has EVERY RIGHT to be mad at oralie biana is beauty QUEEN and SUCH a good charecter dex is SO underrated in the books but NOT the fandom jensi NEEDS a BIGGER come back SHANNON IS SUCH A GOOD WRITER DONT BE MAD CUZ 1 THING DOESNT MAKE SENSE! 😃😊

Here is one of my opinions: I really, really, REALLY despise Sophie for the choice she made to burn the Neverseen's warehouse. I feel like she only did it to prove Glimmer wrong, rather than to make a statement. While I can't deny that she's finally going on offense and doing something rather than just playing defense the whole time, it just felt really emotional rather than thought out.

Hello.

HI

I think Ro will die in the next book

FORKLE IS MID

Lady Gisela is the BEST villion

I've got a list for you (with explanations!) I think that Dex gets too much attention for loss of page time I mean he had his turn in book one and I like that he's not in the series a lot anymore, also I wouldn't even mind if he died, it would give Sophie even more trama to deal with. Fitz is hated on too much, he made a mistake and not EVERYONE hates him but Keefe's made more mistakes than him and for dumber reasons, Fitz had a reason to get mad, I mean after what happened with Alvar being evil, Fitz doesn't want to ruin the Vacker name even more (I'm still a Sokeefe shipper tho!) I don't really like Marelle she was there in book one and then she was gone I was totally okay with that. Then in nightfall, she was brought back and I was just like "really?" I mean yeah she's a pyrokinetic but Shannon could have made anyone else a pyrokinetic, there's just something a Marella that I just find really annoying I wish that the "Love triangle" had been resolved a while ago because then the fandom wouldn't have to get mad every time Sophie is oblivious and It would just make things easier for everyone. Personally, Keefe just needed to confess and then maybe some actual relationships would happen. The only one that's happened so far is Sofitz which not many people like I hate Wylie, Linh and Tam. I don't for sure know why but I think Linh just took up too much attention when she was introduced and throughout the series I mean she did ONE thing, (saving Atlantis) and everyone Loves her but for what? Tam is too much of a side character so when he's put in the story I feel like he doesn't need to be there. Wylie has done literally nothing like maybe he did some small things in Flashback but nothing else, people give him too much credit. Make a PART 2!!!

In my opinion, as someone who has gone through stuff similar to keefe ( and that’s just with his dad mind you), I think that keefe is actually UNDER RATED. Just saying

Hate me all you want but I am a 100% FITZPHIE they are litterly a perfect match even though they broke up they WILL get back together

CANT WAIT 😭😭😭😭😭

it sucks that these are all unpopular opinions… they’re all based! the kotlc fandom sucks!

I agree, Keefe is super overrated

Confession: I think fitz is better than keefe and keefe is very overrated and isn't that special fitz doesn't deserve hate

I. SHIP. SOFORKLE. come on, guys. The age gap doesn’t matter because of the indefinite life spans, so that isn’t a problem, Mr. forkle is single, and neither fitz or Keefe really deserve her.

Thanks for using mine