Тёмный

Kowloon Walled City Documentary (English Subtitles) 

South Sider
Подписаться 1,1 тыс.
Просмотров 707 тыс.
50% 1

Credits go to cameraman Hamdani Milas. Christina Wesemann for creation and direction of the film and also to Hugo Portisch for production.
Milas was one of the people that helped filmed this 1989 documentary about the city. I spoke with him recently and he said that he is interested in a follow up video of some sort so we may expect something new on the way.
He mentioned how it was an incredibly tough shoot. They were a five person crew; himself as cinematographer, a camera assistant, focus-puller, sound recordist, a researcher, production assistant and the director, and a very nice Austrian lady who was most willing to collaborate and listen to crew suggestions.
They shot for 6 days continuously, 10-12 hours a day, at the height of the summer of 1987. He mentioned how it smelled very bad inside from the open drainage, the heat was stifling at plus 32ºC with little to no air circulation, also not knowing whether it was sewage or clean water dripping on their heads occasionally, they regularly had to wipe the camera and lens dry.
The claustrophobia- you could hardly turn around in some places with a 7kg Betacam SP camcorder on your shoulder. They had a tripod with them but hardly used it inside because there was nowhere to position it without blocking the narrow passageways.
They also frequently got lost and had to ask the locals for directions. Lunch was much-anticipated each day when they could take a break outside in the fresh air. After a day’s shoot they were absolutely dripping with sweat and the first thing they’d do after getting home was to put all their clothes straight in the wash and have a long shower. Working in those conditions was an immense challenge technically and physically but, as is often the case, none of that shows in the resulting footage.
Here we have a very interesting first hand account of what Hamdani Milas experienced in the walled city itself when he was filming this video. So by what he’s told me we can understand just how much of an incredible risk it was to film inside this city, even though it was near to when the city was demolished and the place was seen as safer it was still a high risk no go area.
I took it upon myself to re-sub the video as best as possible, the 4 part version is hard-subbed on a version of this film with very poor quality, the subs are also worded incorrectly in some places. So all I've done is re-subbed the whole thing and put it onto a better quality video clip. Since the subtitles are not hard subbed you can now use auto translate as well should be fairly accurate.
Note: about the section of this video where Jackie Pullinger is speaking, I’m sure anyone can see the subtitles are a transcript of Jackie Pullingers actual words in English and not the narrators. I’ve noticed a comment mentioning how the subs are way off in that part. While subbing this video I realised the narrator wasn’t giving an exact translation so took it upon myself to decipher what she was actually saying over his voice. Sorry I just couldn’t help it but it was out of boredom 😉

Опубликовано:

 

18 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@matthewclark7952
@matthewclark7952 6 лет назад
I'm so grateful that footage still exists of Kowloon walled city as a historical reference. It's astonishing to me that it ever happened in the 1st place and that it was kept running (sort of) for so long. Thanks.
@S_dott
@S_dott 6 лет назад
Matthew Clark much appreciated. It’s actually astonishing that this place was up and running while I was playing sega master system at home as a kid. 😅
@catrinneumuller7619
@catrinneumuller7619 2 года назад
This film was conceived, directed and made by my mother Christina Wesemann and produced by Hugo Portisch in 1988. The beginning of the film crediting her is missing in this version.
@janni160
@janni160 2 года назад
props dafür
@S_dott
@S_dott 2 года назад
I can always write her down in the description if you want, in fact I’ll do that right now.
@catrinneumuller7619
@catrinneumuller7619 2 года назад
@@S_dott Thank you, that is very kind of you.
@S_dott
@S_dott 2 года назад
@@catrinneumuller7619 you’re very welcome thank you too
@Esner87
@Esner87 2 года назад
Ehre, wem Ehre gebührt! Eine großartige Doku!!
@anthealovett3997
@anthealovett3997 3 года назад
Many remember this place fondly, and many of the previous residents have stated that they would much prefer to still be living in the Walled City than outside of it. It is truly a remarkable place, where, while everything was "illegal", the people were able to live as free as they would like. Many didn't partake in any crime activities, they were simply poor, and this place provided a community to them that was hard to find elsewhere. Of course, it is a good thing the place is gone - the living conditions are certainly not what any human deserves to live in, but at the same time, it is viewed with a memory of nostalgia for many Hong Kongers
@solortus
@solortus 3 года назад
People would rather live free and poor than mediocre and subjugated. It's the beauty of capitalism - you can work and thrive and be poor but it's of your own volition. It's what made america great and the walled city is an example of the human drive for achievement.
@puffolotti
@puffolotti 3 года назад
I can see that, yet buildings and their components, pipes, cables and walls aren't indestructible, and one can't fix them with duct-tape or old rags forever. The fact there is people who likes to live that way is undeniable, but on such premises, the city itself can't be expected to survive indefinitely, also because who lives there is by definition not very fond of ordinary/scheduled maintenance in general. If you want me to put in a less rational and more poetic way... Human souls are much stronger than concrete and steel, if the city hadn't been demolished, it would have collapsed into a pile of rubble around it's inhabitants not much later.
@gilsonrogeriolimaoliveira2807
@gilsonrogeriolimaoliveira2807 3 года назад
@@puffolotti It was a miracle it wasn't consumed by flames.
@puffolotti
@puffolotti 3 года назад
@@gilsonrogeriolimaoliveira2807 It can be explained only assuming the inhabitants have a really high I.Q. and their intelligence makes them allergic to the hypocrisy outside their urban island.
@puffolotti
@puffolotti 3 года назад
@@gilsonrogeriolimaoliveira2807 Let say in a week we work 30 hours in 168 and sleep 49 but in the remaining 87 hours we still have bills, social obligations, polytics and such... they work 84 hours and sleep 56, but experience 168 hours a week of freedom... ...It is almost tempting.
@HeadOfBusiness
@HeadOfBusiness 4 года назад
I wish they would have made this entire city a monument. I understand the evictions due to public health concerns. But the destruction of such a beautifully individual piece of history is soul crushing.
@darkevilazn
@darkevilazn 4 года назад
I actually agree with this. When I learned about this place back in the late 90's I wanted to visit it, so when my family when to Hong-Kong I tried to go there only to find out it didn't exist anymore. I was less than 7 or 8 years old. I had a habit of exploring places a kid shouldn't be at. But I do understand why they took it down. It was structurally unsafe and probably wouldn't have lasted more than 50 years without serious structural renovation (and that it would have been a stain on a popular tourist destination).
@ELPlop
@ELPlop 3 года назад
@@darkevilaznthat's brave and unique for that age. Also I wish it's kept as monument no one would be hurt if it fell or some of it due to years of pressure as you said. I'm unhappy they demolished it
@martinschemmel84
@martinschemmel84 3 года назад
but in their (the governments) eye, there is nothing to preserve. It's a compound of people that didnt follow their rules.
@ThatGuyDownInThe
@ThatGuyDownInThe 3 года назад
everything that exists will be gone eventually though, can't hang onto the past
@martinschemmel84
@martinschemmel84 3 года назад
@@ThatGuyDownInThe yea.. right. get rid of the people and rebuild their mindset. for the next 70 years and then we'll see again when it crumbles.
@fine1764
@fine1764 5 лет назад
I love these kinds of documentaries. Just comes to show there are still so many mostly unknown places in the world
@noahjacobs5039
@noahjacobs5039 5 лет назад
It was torn down.
@romancorey6796
@romancorey6796 4 года назад
It was demolished by the British government in 1994
@dallasman1947
@dallasman1947 4 года назад
Me too! Love this
@Khanaltai
@Khanaltai 4 года назад
It got demolished in 1994
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Yes these kind of documentaries are the best. They don’t make any them raw like this anymore these days. Glad you enjoyed it.
@MrGogoido
@MrGogoido 6 лет назад
I can't help but be absolutely fascinated and amazed at the ways society organizes itself in such a small place. Kowloon may be a place filled with filth, crime and poverty, but it had a strange beauty and life to it. I'm glad we have the internet now to glance at a piece of history and proof of human endeavour like this documentary.
@OwNeD05
@OwNeD05 5 лет назад
Holy shit, it's like something from a sci-fi book about a dystopian society.
@ShelbyGT500-
@ShelbyGT500- 5 лет назад
thats whats scary and enteresting reminds you so much of something you already saw or knew without knowing what it is
@edoughty
@edoughty 5 лет назад
Those pet birds in their small cages, living inside a city made of cages... what an image
@Xezlec
@Xezlec 8 лет назад
To those wondering: it's been torn down. It no longer exists. The Walled City was also featured in the move Bloodsport. And there's a whole book about the city, complete with maps and photos, but it's all in Japanese. I managed to get a copy from some online import bookstore somewhere a long time ago. I don't remember where that was though.
@S_dott
@S_dott 8 лет назад
Yes it was torn down in 1993 and a park has been put in its place. I recently purchased a book about it which is in English. It's called City of Darkness revisited, and has lots of professionally taken photographs and is definitely worth a look if you're interested.
@Bounty2223
@Bounty2223 8 лет назад
Xezlec in the Sega Dreamcast video game Shenmue 2 a big part of the game plays in this city. The game shows a very detailed and interesting perspective of the city. I can highly recommend to try it out!
@Xezlec
@Xezlec 8 лет назад
***** Thanks! I may have to do just that.
@Xezlec
@Xezlec 7 лет назад
I can't read Japanese so I don't know the title, but the ISBN is 4-00-008070-9. Does that help?
@Ragnarosable
@Ragnarosable 7 лет назад
The name is Kowloon large illustrated (1997) ISBN: 4000080709
@krashlyboo
@krashlyboo Год назад
This is a good example of how strong, resilient, creative and adaptive humans are....to me not a condemnation of people but a story about what makes us successful as a species. We can adapt and survive under all manner of situations. Kowloon City may be disturbing on many levels but it's also proof the human race is tough.
@Accuratetranslationservices
@Accuratetranslationservices 8 месяцев назад
The kindergarten actually looks pretty clean and the children look healthy, God bless them for creating an environment like that. Just such a contrast compared to what they walk outside to.
@gabrielgermann9148
@gabrielgermann9148 Год назад
i watched this over 30 times at this point, most fscinating documentary i have ever seen. i will never get tired of it...
@itsliterallycurry4038
@itsliterallycurry4038 Год назад
Second time watching it and it is very interesting 😊
@YesOkayButWhy
@YesOkayButWhy Год назад
In that case, have a thumbs-up for each viewing.
@masterwayne420
@masterwayne420 3 года назад
I ain’t gonna lie part of me thinks this is cool as shit for some reason.
@stickygaiden
@stickygaiden 3 года назад
Cause it's look like a dark sci-fi suburbs.
@MisterBones2910
@MisterBones2910 3 года назад
The morbid curiosity of wanting to see Ancapistan tried.
@MisterBones2910
@MisterBones2910 3 года назад
@@stickygaiden all punk, no cyber
@CesarClouds
@CesarClouds 3 года назад
Cool as shit because it is shit in a fascinating way.
@Felipejvcsful
@Felipejvcsful 2 года назад
it's cool as spectator, but i would kill myself if i had to live in a place like that
@alex.b364
@alex.b364 4 года назад
Danke Herr Wiefels diese Dokumentation werde ich mir jetzt ansehen
@bigmac9859
@bigmac9859 4 года назад
Me too
@jamila7718
@jamila7718 4 года назад
Ich auch 🌚
@SirSquax
@SirSquax 4 года назад
same
@annedrieck7316
@annedrieck7316 3 года назад
Are u german?
@Andytess91
@Andytess91 10 месяцев назад
I wish more of the Kowloon walled city was documented and recorded. It’s so interesting! Especially now a days people would pay them for footage and they could make a lot of extra money. I hope everyone who lives there is living happy healthy lives with everything they need. I think the city is really cool but humans need better living conditions.
@AliBaba-mb1pu
@AliBaba-mb1pu 9 месяцев назад
Yes like feeding 🍌 to 🐒 in a zoo
@Edward-cy2wn
@Edward-cy2wn 9 месяцев назад
Ofc social phenomenons like this won’t be that much documented because it shows how humans can actually live in anarchy without a gouvernement in charge
@ishakk435
@ishakk435 9 месяцев назад
everyone who used to live there*
@saltyapollyon5042
@saltyapollyon5042 8 месяцев назад
@@Edward-cy2wn anarchy? im pretty sure the chinese mafia acted as the government in this city
@ellisdee1933
@ellisdee1933 7 месяцев назад
i recommend the book "city of darkness" where the author writed about the life of kowloon citizens. the book is pretty expensive, but you can read it online for free
@daru_klas
@daru_klas 2 года назад
This is such a gem of a documentary. A super rare look into life in an extraordinary place that no longer exists. Wish there was more of it!
@gargus777
@gargus777 2 года назад
Good thing someone had an Idea to document this city
@Nothingbutdust_
@Nothingbutdust_ 7 лет назад
A very interesting film... It looks like it was a horrible and at the same time like an amazing place to live in. Very dirty, poor and unhygienic but strangely also very cozy... It would've been an interesting place to spend a few night at as a backpacker yet it wouldn't be a place where I could manage to live in for very much longer... Thank you for translating and sharing.
@guguigugu
@guguigugu 7 лет назад
no european backpacker would be let anywhere inside
@romancorey6796
@romancorey6796 4 года назад
Most of the people who lived there remember it fondly believe it or not.
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Rᴏʏᴀʟ Rᴀʙʙɪᴛ yes that sums it up perfectly. Horrible due to crime, overcrowding and poor sanitation but weirdly amazing at the same time. Thanks for the comments.
@mariaalejandraestevez3042
@mariaalejandraestevez3042 4 года назад
I found about this and I am currently obessed with how fever dreamish this feels
@teonanhilton2512
@teonanhilton2512 4 года назад
Fever dream-ish is perhaps the best way of describing it
@Imthefake
@Imthefake 2 года назад
if this was still standing today you could probably find an airbnb inside
@AliBaba-mb1pu
@AliBaba-mb1pu 2 года назад
For $7 a night who is complaining
@nanahachi9628
@nanahachi9628 Год назад
For 150 € a night because reasons.
@MTdaBlacking
@MTdaBlacking Год назад
They'd *still* find a way to overcharge you lol
@nathanbabble1976
@nathanbabble1976 Год назад
1000%
@SkylineR33mt
@SkylineR33mt Год назад
Lol
@CarolineHeater-rm7gz
@CarolineHeater-rm7gz Год назад
like imagine if a child had only ever lived there and seen life as it is inside of that claustrophobic city, and then one day, randomly, the child is taken to a big beautiful field with green grass and a blue sky
@Rami7605
@Rami7605 9 месяцев назад
The same feeling a guy has when he leaves a jailhouse 🤷
@himirubye
@himirubye 5 лет назад
It's heartening to see that the old man takes good care of the birds he keeps them as a pet when he is living in a place like that.
@Ezio999Auditore
@Ezio999Auditore 3 года назад
Aye
@valexbast
@valexbast 3 года назад
Thank you so much for this. I've been "fascinated" with the uniqueness of the Walled City for quite some time, but none of the other sources deliver such a precise, first-hand chronicle of what went on there. This is by far the best documentary on the Walled City and has immense historical value. Your work is extremely appreciated.
@S_dott
@S_dott 3 года назад
Thanks I appreciate your comments
@Lily-iu9ms
@Lily-iu9ms 3 года назад
If you want to read more about it I'd recommend the book City of Darkness by Ian Lambot and Greg Girard, it includes many photos and a lot of first-hand testimonies as well as a really detailed history of the city and how it came to be
@Wingcusa
@Wingcusa 7 лет назад
there are beauties and unique aesthetics within these destroyed and forgotten things.
@maniya6830
@maniya6830 6 лет назад
Kurtis Chau it's Channels like these that make us see the beauty hidden
@SPLICY
@SPLICY 3 года назад
19:58 "The loneliness is grievous in the labyrinth" is the most German thing you can say in English subtitles
@BigBrotherMateyka
@BigBrotherMateyka 2 года назад
Imagine making noodles on the absolute cheap, when suddenly you trip over some random Victoria-era cannon just sitting in a dingy room, which happens to be the confectionery, the clothes sweatshop, and the dentist's office all in one.
@misterexclusive8282
@misterexclusive8282 2 года назад
Tell me you're British without telling me you're British. Use the word "Confectionary."
@AwesomeJLK
@AwesomeJLK 4 года назад
Cage homes: We have bad living conditions Walled City: Hold my rice wine
@anatolianshepherd8472
@anatolianshepherd8472 3 года назад
i dont see how kwc flats are worse than cage homes.
@ErikS-
@ErikS- 4 года назад
19:57 “Many people feel lonely ...” And that in the most densily populated place in the whole earth... Imagine feeling lonely with 50,000 people around you in a small area.
@danan9061
@danan9061 3 года назад
Its easy to be lonely and especially if you work all day and have no family
@samstarba4569
@samstarba4569 3 года назад
Heh, imagine being lonely in a town of less than 1000 people... In the middle of the woods.
@strayiggytv
@strayiggytv 3 года назад
Kowloon has definitely been romanticised now that it's gone. Sure some can look back on it fondly but others just straight up died from the poor sanitation and they aren't looking back on anything. How many people were sickened by the roach shit mixed into those noodles? How many restaurants advertised that they were getting their cheap food products from a place with zero regulation? The idea of a totally free unregulated economy is catnip to wanna be libertarians until it's them or a family member made Ill by someone picking up meat off the floor next to a open sewer pipe and continueing making dumplings with it like it ain't no thing. There are very few people who think that kowloon is aesthetically cool looking that would actually be happy there. They'd be better off trying to revive the arcade that mimicked it's look than acting like living in the real deal would be great.
@martinschemmel84
@martinschemmel84 3 года назад
question remains: why did they want to stay away from the law? Which law would have "protected" them, working outside these conditions? Looking at the documentory nowadays you can more clearly see why they want to take a step back from these other "laws"
@rzt430
@rzt430 3 года назад
i don't think those are issues caused by the existence of kowloon itself. poverty will be poverty, no matter where you take it. the same people who live in poverty there, eat the food there. definitely not outsiders. in many developing countries, there is no immunity from law and regulations such as in kowloon in many slums on paper-- but in reality they are of illegal occupation so the government just keeps their hands off those places, essentially resulting in the same thing in practice. even worse sometimes, i've seen people fish out food from (unsegregated) garbage to recook them and sell them. try visiting poorer places in developing countries, kowloon looks like a paradise for people who can't escape that low standard of living. not that anyone deserves to live like that, but reality is what it is
@darkspd31
@darkspd31 3 года назад
True
@krisgomes4381
@krisgomes4381 3 года назад
True it looked extremely unsanitary and disgusting 🤢 makes me feel grateful for a lot of things.
@martinschemmel84
@martinschemmel84 3 года назад
@@krisgomes4381 to western eyes a lot of things can look disgusting. New chinese buildings after 10 years as well.
@osman7138
@osman7138 3 года назад
1:38 „unser Kamerateam war das erste....“ wenn das Galileo hört, wird man euch verklagen, dieser Satz ist von Galileo patentiert :)
@nuschelbacke3991
@nuschelbacke3991 3 года назад
Das Video ist so alt, da dürften die Macher gerade mal eingeschulten sein.
@thebestusername5852
@thebestusername5852 3 года назад
The sleeping kindergarteners were so innocent and beautiful. Breaks my heart to know those were the lucky few among thousands of others just as precious.
@janerogers2101
@janerogers2101 2 года назад
Thinking of the kids growing up there, I cried.
@boshvasara1868
@boshvasara1868 4 года назад
This place influenced ghost in a shell and many other great masterpieces
@whatever-im5hi
@whatever-im5hi 7 лет назад
Love this documentary. I watched a british documentary about Kowloon here on youtube but this one is way better. Typical germans and their obsession with mechanical explanations. Now that's what I wanna hear.
@mortimer1976
@mortimer1976 7 лет назад
Except it’s an Austrian documentary, not a German one :-)
@poopscoop5836
@poopscoop5836 7 лет назад
whatever the british one was complete shit
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Mechanical explanations 😂 love it 👍🏼
@mencot89
@mencot89 3 года назад
Lmao
@imhellag
@imhellag 5 лет назад
Buckle up guys, this is gonna be a good one.
@teddya7844
@teddya7844 7 лет назад
thank you for all the work of sharing this and re-subbing it. this is the most complete documentary on KWC I've seen.
@S_dott
@S_dott 7 лет назад
Teddy Artschwager thank you, much appreciated!
@FilmsExtras
@FilmsExtras 4 года назад
Thanks a million for sharing such precious piece of archive as well as doing the subtitles, it is amazing and probably the best documentary about KWC available on youtube so far ! Thank you so much, as well as the description of the shooting !
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Films Extras thank you. Much appreciated. I agree this is definitely the best documentary on the walled city.
@user-sg5tr6jt3y
@user-sg5tr6jt3y 3 года назад
that moment when you’re looking for a documentary and then it’s your native language LOL
@lolscrubs8977
@lolscrubs8977 3 года назад
Ich habe zuerst auch mit Englisch gerechnet und den Sprecher gar nicht verstanden xD
@steineboden4095
@steineboden4095 3 года назад
Ging mir genauso, haha! 😂
@nickryan2016
@nickryan2016 3 года назад
Uktung
@user-vh1ys5qr1o
@user-vh1ys5qr1o 2 года назад
ja haha
@viovenda8922
@viovenda8922 3 года назад
What kind of life is it to work 12 hours a day, every single day, just to go home and spend the other 12 hours lying in a tiny room with no fresh air, and going weeks or even months without seeing the sunshine? Do these people feel close to their families? Do they ever try to get out of a day of work? The horrendous living conditions are enough to give everyone there PTSD for real. No windows, no air circulation, no access to fresh air, even on top of the building, nothing. Mix that with thousands of people lacking the utilities to keep themselves clean and taken care of, and mix that also with the constant heat and constant pollution rain. Infeel so so sad for these people, no human being should have to live like this, and no elderly person should have to walk up 10 flights of stairs, all alone, just to get to her house. Dont even get me started on those poor children. They all look so.... empty. They look tired and dirty, and sad. I really wonder where they are now. I can't believe how recent in history this took place
@anatolianshepherd8472
@anatolianshepherd8472 3 года назад
well check the japanese “salarymen” phenomenon(people who work for 16 hours and sleep in their offices some of them even die due to overwork. ) or cage houses of today’s hong kong or people who live in internet cafes in japan, sweathouses in india etc etc. life is shit for at least half of the population of the world. not even gonna mention about africa or middle east. it’s strange how people take things for granted.
@martinschemmel84
@martinschemmel84 3 года назад
ask them, before making such bold statements from above. There must be an alternative that's worse. It's not that city which is the problem.
@shaunstevens4292
@shaunstevens4292 2 года назад
You just described live in the Navy . . . congratulations
@fluffycottoncandycloud5946
@fluffycottoncandycloud5946 2 года назад
wow reading this reminds me when I worked so many hours in a care home
@evanpetelle5669
@evanpetelle5669 9 месяцев назад
What a great documentary. Hard to find stuff like this on the subject!!
@gletamendi5439
@gletamendi5439 5 лет назад
Someone should really seek out those who lived there and do a proper documentary on kwc. with all the hype about docu series in the last decade I'm surprised that there hasn't been one (well one properly funded, edited, etc. on Hulu or Netflix or the like). The juxtaposition between footage then and footage now- we take for granted how everything now is captured on smartphones, cctv, dash footage, - it's interesting to watch.
@steve1978ger
@steve1978ger 5 лет назад
The Wall Street Journal, of all places, has a few good bits of documentary, like interviews with former residents.
@S_dott
@S_dott 5 лет назад
I reckon it’s worth you looking into the book by Ian Lambot and Greg Girard. City of darkness revisited it’s called. It has lots of high quality photos and interviews with locals from the city. I bought the book myself and wasn’t disappointed. I still haven’t read through them all.
@gletamendi5439
@gletamendi5439 5 лет назад
Thank you @@S_dott , I have the book too.i agree its a great read.
@elena79rus
@elena79rus 5 лет назад
Exactly. I wanna know what happened to the people who lived there after the city was demolished. And why they chose to live in that city in the first place.
@smoog
@smoog 4 года назад
The KWC was demolished in 1993 and the area turned into multi-storey apartment blocks. There's just a small park there now with a few mementos and plaques with information about the Walled city.
@rc-gg1zg
@rc-gg1zg 3 года назад
In the 90s it was pretty common to see fake products in stores with a stampe written "made in Hong Kong". I wonder how many of them were actually produced in Kowloon.
@larserikskjrdal5291
@larserikskjrdal5291 2 года назад
Probably a lot XD
@sg5184
@sg5184 Год назад
Thank you for sharing this fascinating piece of history.
@Kralchen
@Kralchen 4 года назад
Thanks so much for uploading and adding the great translation.
@hekofabeardhb3478
@hekofabeardhb3478 2 года назад
If I can go back in time to any place and any moment in history; I want to go to Kowloon in the 90's, before it was torn down. Thank you so much for this video, for uploading it, and for the subs. Truly remarkable. This video is so underrated; it deserves more recognition and appreciation. The adults, the teenagers, but mostly the little innocent children; is who I keep thinking of.
@blobuela
@blobuela 2 года назад
Same i wanna visit this place. Bc so many history in there. Believe or not. I've been visited a kind of that place in my country. So the place is name Chinese village, and how could i been there? Bc there is a doctor he was specialist but he open his clinics in the kind of that place, it's not small it's huge, i thought that building is market place but when i go to toilet there is have a public toilet i saw many people took a bath, even living in there really im a little bit scared. Most like this place but not really scared and densely populated
@hekofabeardhb3478
@hekofabeardhb3478 2 года назад
@@blobuela where do you live and how is it similar to this place?
@j.n.4806
@j.n.4806 2 года назад
Yeah so true... but I have to admit: if I can go back in time, the construction of the great pyramid is tempting too!
@firesnakex8
@firesnakex8 2 года назад
Amazing work from the team to document life within this city and I am thankful for you uploading and subbing this video as footage of the city is rare. The Kowloon walled city is a very unique setting that I doubt will ever be replicated and to observe life within this city before it was demolished is very fascinating. Some part of me finds it sad how the city was demolished as there is a strange beauty to it and the idea of the community being tight knit like this in an unlawful land is somewhat warming, but I can't deny how difficult the living conditions must have been. I do hope that the tenants of the city that were evicted moved on to better lives.
@kiirosoleil
@kiirosoleil 2 года назад
That's the thing, it's not tight-knit - it's more like everyone fights for themselves, just like mentioned in the video. Seems like a very dangerous and sad place to live in, not warm or inviting at all, but still fascinating.
@AliBaba-mb1pu
@AliBaba-mb1pu 2 года назад
Check out Rat Utopia experiment
@theeow6103
@theeow6103 3 года назад
6 acres is about the size of my property, and there are three of us living here. Three. With the pop density of Manhattan, last I checked, would be about 300 people. But fifty thousand!!!
@S_dott
@S_dott 3 года назад
The Eow well that perfectly puts it into perspective.
@blueoutrun
@blueoutrun 2 года назад
Came to see inside the city, ended up with a fascinating look into the exploitation underneath British Hong Kong.
@makocadey
@makocadey 2 года назад
The audacity of Europeans. Their interferences leads to so many misery in the world
@stevanstankoviii-2989
@stevanstankoviii-2989 Год назад
@@makocadey it was their lack of interference that led to the city even forming. Kowloon is what happens when you let capitalism do it's thing unrestricted.if the city was regulated abd it's people offered sustainable wages they would have never resorted to living in a crime filled shit dump
@nathanbabble1976
@nathanbabble1976 Год назад
The British basically couldn’t go in to this city until Beijing signed off on it in the end, Beijing also didn’t care about it during its life cycle. The Walled city existed in a no man’s land with no government except for the triad which actually did good things there.
@ElGuapo96
@ElGuapo96 11 месяцев назад
​@@stevanstankoviii-2989Ancap paradise you mean
@MichaTheLight
@MichaTheLight 4 года назад
This is a really great documentary in old 90's style of public german television. This was a great time of educational TV such stuff was sended in normal german Television. Regarding the content this documentary shows how boundless and unregulated totall capitalism is looking like. Not so long ago only 150 years ago many similar places existed all around Europe and in parts of the USA, we today have forgotten that, but with such documentaries we get remmebered of our own past. In germany this was called "Mietskasernen" and also in Manchester Museums there should be many examples of such living conditions.
@y2kman426
@y2kman426 4 года назад
@kill kykes criticize capitalism in any way, as small as it may seem and you're a communist
@Salafessien
@Salafessien 6 лет назад
Tbh I would've liked if the government dislodged them but kept the city. I know it isn't aesthetic at all but i just find this place extremely fascinating and full of history.
@maniya6830
@maniya6830 6 лет назад
Acommenter 271 don't worry brother there is a park now that is named kwc park and has the south gate and some features of the city still in place and there is also a miniature structure of what was Kowloon walled city.
@ErikS-
@ErikS- 4 года назад
Something that would fit in a post-apocalyptic Mad Max movie! Sad that they demolished this! It would be a great example of how people live and build in a unregulated way, where only space is the limit. It shows people live similar to ants or bees in the way.
@MrMarcetLP
@MrMarcetLP 4 года назад
No they dont. ants or bees live in a big community. In this city, everyone lives alone and not in a community.
@stevensims3342
@stevensims3342 11 месяцев назад
I've always been fascinated by this city. The incredible number of small nooks, myriad of activities, shops, factories and people that surely would never allow anyone to film them. What you see in this documentary is likely tamed to some degree and you cannot know what all took place within the city. Thank you for sharing this.
@MisterBones2910
@MisterBones2910 8 лет назад
"He cut his finger off while working" Sure, that doesn't sound like 'I walked into a door' at all.
@danan9061
@danan9061 3 года назад
Yep he didnt pay his protection fee. Theres no way a grown man vould cut his whole finger off while making noodles
@MisterBones2910
@MisterBones2910 3 года назад
@@danan9061 They get pretty crazy with the meat cleaver in a Chinese kitchen, but yeah.
@stevensims3342
@stevensims3342 7 месяцев назад
I only wish I could have seen THIS in Blueray 4k. The shops that would have never allow cameras to peer into their area of the city. The kind of thing to write home about.
@rosegreensummer
@rosegreensummer 3 года назад
Thanks. Next time i complain about life, i will remember this hell and be grateful. I am so lucky.
@DasGeneral12
@DasGeneral12 7 лет назад
I had the chance to live in China for a few years (2013-2015). There was a section of street shops just outside the university I taught at that resembled the Walled City, right down to the ramshackle shops and an open slit where the restaurant owners would dump leftover food and drinks. This documentary brought me right back there. Thank you for sharing!!
@angelawang3670
@angelawang3670 6 лет назад
Paul Goodfellow where did you live in china
@DasGeneral12
@DasGeneral12 4 года назад
@@angelawang3670 I was in Anhui Province, about ten kilometers outside the provincial capital, Hefei. The university was next to Zipengshan National Forest Park.
@angelawang3670
@angelawang3670 4 года назад
Paul Goodfellow thanks :D
@lowlanz
@lowlanz 3 года назад
No sunlight, ventilation, hygiene problems would have caused a lot of diseases for the residents. They were living like post-apocalyptic survivors when the apocalypse never came lol
@sweetkali
@sweetkali 4 года назад
Kowloon’s Walled City should has been restored and preserved as a historical remnant of Hong Kong’s history.
@eeeeee3831
@eeeeee3831 4 года назад
Maybe yeah
@Tesseract1887
@Tesseract1887 4 года назад
Yeah but what you have to remember that would make China look bad
@eeeeee3831
@eeeeee3831 4 года назад
Yeah same sort of thing in india too. Dharavi makes are nation look bad because it is the most densely populated place in the world currently. Many people claim it is wonderful like the walled city but the government has a relocation plan. It also has many small industries like the walled city.
@eeeeee3831
@eeeeee3831 4 года назад
@Arty Splash I never said it was exactly like the walled city. The only similarity between the two is the high population,poverty and small industries
@t-.-t.
@t-.-t. 4 года назад
@Arty Splash this city was 25-40 years ago. Daravi didn't have anything either back then. Even today ,daravi is insanely polluted with no proper sanitation or electricity.
@zyourzgrandzmaz
@zyourzgrandzmaz 4 года назад
Pisses me off so much this place is gone.
@jabbawockee131
@jabbawockee131 4 года назад
JD Voorhees haven’t checked it out yet, but off the bat it sounds like the peach trees communities from dredd
@sophialoren7855
@sophialoren7855 4 года назад
In Brazil they have favelas that look like this
@Nikita_1692
@Nikita_1692 7 месяцев назад
Glaube die beste Doku zu dem Thema die ich gefunden hab. Danke an den uploader
@preiselbeerpie4555
@preiselbeerpie4555 3 месяца назад
das sind noch die alten dokus 👌🏼
@ZM256.
@ZM256. 4 года назад
Hello South Sider I found out that another documentary on the Walled City exists. It is titled "In Search of the Dragon's Tale " and was released in 1997. It has a 48 minute run time. I discovered its existence from a forum where a user brings it up: archive.vn/yTvtF#selection-1367.8-1373.307 The post links to the web page of the documentary: web.archive.org/web/20000617190554/dragon.tripod.com/ A synopsis for the documentary is as follows: "In Search of the Dragon's Tale follows the story of a handicapped street musician, Maurice Chan, as he explains what life is like for him in Hong Kong. In the process we go on a journey back in time to the Walled City of Kowloon. Once dubbed 'the sleaziest' place in Hong Kong, it was an 'island' of Chinese sovereignty within the British colony. As a result of a secret political compromise between the Chinese and British Governments the Walled City was destroyed in 1992. This decision resulted in the displacement of the Walled City’s 40,000 residents. The documentary gives a personal look into modern day Hong Kong and shows historical links to a place the authorities preferred to forget. Featuring never-before-seen video footage and photos, as well as on-camera interviews, it underscores the tenacity of the human spirit to rise above conditions that were, as one journalist put it, 'worse than we can imagine'." Sourced from here: web.archive.org/web/19991003121236/members.tripod.com/~dragon/synop.html I tried to see if I could find this one online but I couldn't find it anywhere. What interests me the most is if any of the footage or photos in this documentary really haven't been seen anywhere else as the synopsis claims. Since this was made after the demolition they had to obtain those materials from second hand sources and apparently one of those sources is CNN according to the fast facts page: web.archive.org/web/19991002180921/members.tripod.com/~dragon/fastfact.html The interviews could also be another interesting thing to see. For now though the closest thing to the documentary is the full script the website provides that's segmented into three pages. I've read through all three pages and I will provide notable points below along with a link to their respective pages. Page 1 introduces Maurice Chan. It has an interview with a postman who delivered in the Walled City and their encounter with a prostitute. Maurice recalled how there was a theatre called Sun Wah Sing which showed 8mm movies and had live exotic dance. Another person going by the name Mooncakes who says they saw women stripping nude in their performance of one of the live shows and also saying that he has heard from others that there was even live sex shows that happened there though he says he hasn't seen those. Maurice recalls some Indian folks asking him where Sun Wah Sing was and he gave them directions. Lastly, Maurice remembers a gutter next to where he lived as a boy and it being filled when it rained so he would fold paper boats and let them float down the flooded, dirty water. web.archive.org/web/19991003064301/members.tripod.com/~dragon/script.html Page 2 discusses a saying in Hong Kong called "Unregulated for Three" with the three referring to three crimes or misdeeds which are prostitution, gambling and drug abuse and trafficking. The activities in the Walled City can also be symbolized by the slang "Chicken", meaning prostitute and referring to prostitution. A dog meat recipe is provided and according to Mooncakes says it tastes like chicken at first but after having some more it tasted like mutton. On the topic of dogs the postman brings up a story about delivering mail and having to go up a stairway that was very dark. He needed to use a flashlight and as he reached the top he saw two spots of light. It turned out to be the eyes of a dog and it started barking which made him apparently fall down from the third floor to the ground floor. According to the narrator in 1983, there were 33 confectionery manufacturers, 93 plastic factories, 97 dentist’s clinics, and 89 doctor's clinics in the Walled City. Maurice talks about fires taking place in the buildings and the children loving it after they were extinguished since it would not be rebuilt so soon which left more space for their activities. Lastly, Maurice and Mooncakes talk about their experiences with unlicensed dentists. web.archive.org/web/20040616183840/members.tripod.com/~dragon/script2.html Page 3 has an interview with a photographer named Fu Chun Wai. Fu says they first started photographing the Walled City in 1988 and started doing it more frequently around 1991. He recounts being chased out by, in his own words, "mean old men" who would demand him to rip his films out. Most of the time he wouldn't do that since he could outrun them. When the real "mean tattooed guys" came after him, he'd have no other choice but to open the camera and over-expose a bit of the film just to get rid of them. The rest doesn't really involve the Walled City as it goes on to discuss public housing and the 1997 handover. It does end off with a beautiful statement from Maurice, "My life in the Kowloon Walled City has actually helped me cultivate a positive outlook in life. I’ve learnt how to transcend suffering and grow in conditions of hardship. For this reason, I’ve learnt to seek spiritual, rather than materialistic, fulfillment in life. Therefore, I play music. This has a great impact on me. As for my future, like most other people, I hope to have a career. If not, then I’d like to have a family. I’m like any other common person. I’d like to live a normal married life." web.archive.org/web/19991003104211/members.tripod.com/~dragon/script3.html I found a page that apparently has this documentary for order but the prices for it are really high: www.vtape.org/video?vi=3848 Single Screening Rental - $175.00 Educational Purchase DVD (Bluray +$15) - $360.00 5 Year Educational Streaming License, Digital File with DVD Circulation Copy - $550.00 Anyways, I apologize if this post may be a little too long as I just wanted to share this information out to you or for anyone else who might be interested in all things about the Kowloon Walled City.
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
ZM256 that’s a very interesting find. Looking forward to reading through all this when I get home from work. Thanks
@ZM256.
@ZM256. 4 года назад
​@@S_dott Yeah I knew when I came across this information that you might be interested in it as well. Would it also be alright to ask what you think of this when you have the chance?
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
ZM256 yes of course definitely I will go through all of this and give you my thoughts on it all. Just caught up in this work (I’m in the pharmaceutical business and it’s a bit mad at the moment) but I’ll reply properly soon.
@ZM256.
@ZM256. 4 года назад
@@S_dott I completely understand. Take your time and as I've said in my previous post you can reply whenever you have the chance.
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
ZM256 ZM256 ok now I’ve had the chance to read through this. I actually did a search a few years ago and pretty sure these documentaries showed up and I didn’t pay much mind to them since there wasn’t any available footage. Now wouldn’t it be nice if they actually contained unseen footage? I’m sure it exists somewhere. A lot of those interviews are similar to what you can find in Ian Lambot and Greg Girards book as well. There’s loads of interviews I haven’t even read yet in that book. I mean the Kwc is gone of course but only since 1993. It’s possible you or anyone has walked past ex residents of the city without even knowing! Actually when I began this pharmaceutical job there was a Chinese agency worker I spoke to about the walled city. He used to live in Kowloon at the time (not the walled city but Kowloon itself) and he recalled it as the place where the buildings weren’t that tall but stuck together. When I said I’d have loved to go there he said I’d have been cut into tiny little pieces which was actually intimidating to be fair! I will have to look into these documentaries at some point but it’s nice to see your input here. I’m still on the lookout for new stuff.
@mousbouchamekh736
@mousbouchamekh736 2 года назад
All I can say, I am left speechless 😶…. Thanks for documenting this, we deserve knowing about others
@christophermorin9036
@christophermorin9036 4 года назад
Never would have expected a Salvation Army Outpost in Kowloon. Interesting.
@redenwarriors
@redenwarriors 5 лет назад
Sometimes I wonder who those children from kindergarden are now
@jekku4688
@jekku4688 2 года назад
Amazing. Very Blade Runner.
@kiirosoleil
@kiirosoleil 2 года назад
More like the other way around...
@theantone7476
@theantone7476 4 года назад
Interesting, insightful, remarkable, scary, and disturbing is all I got to say about this. Funny thing is, I only discovered this city yesterday and been looking into it for a few hours now lol
@_timetravels4528
@_timetravels4528 3 года назад
Jackie Pullinger is a fuckin legend. It hits real hard to see people going out of their ways solely to help others...
@Luizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
@Luizzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz 6 лет назад
its so beautiful... i fel in love with this place.
@ting6571
@ting6571 6 лет назад
Levis Raster me too ..
@maniya6830
@maniya6830 6 лет назад
Levis Raster Mee three guys 😊😊
@jqkob7407
@jqkob7407 4 года назад
Same
@zillertalernazihass
@zillertalernazihass 4 года назад
Damn the translation is perfect. I've never seen such a great translation in my life. Respect bro
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Thanks for them nice comments. Makes me happy to know since I annotated a lot from the original translation but you said it like my version is spot on! Have nice day bro👌🏼
@S_dott
@S_dott 3 года назад
Calx thanks that’s good to know. At least I did something right. Thanks for watching.
@krisl7068
@krisl7068 6 лет назад
Thanks for your efforts with the subs and upload. Fascinating documentary on an incredible place.
@S_dott
@S_dott 6 лет назад
Kris L thanks much appreciated
@PotHead98
@PotHead98 Год назад
I love tis documentary. I always come back to it every year so interesting.
@ririswan6352
@ririswan6352 2 года назад
It's strange. I kinda feel nostalgic watching this. I used to live in tanjoeng priok ghetto cluster apartment back in the 90s, and it was somewhat similar with what was shown here. Condition of living back then might not be great, but i somewhat miss those difficult times everyonce in a while.
@abby9448
@abby9448 2 года назад
there’s plenty of accounts that say that the people who used to live here often look fondly back on the time. situations can be hard, but in this close knit of a place (physically and emotionally) you can miss the togetherness of everyone being in the same shitty situation. atleast you’re not suffering alone
@abenalif2147
@abenalif2147 2 года назад
Youre right back then Tanjung Priok was really a backwash place, tho i dont know about now (I live in abroad) but my friend told me yes many are of the "bedeng" are still there on the rails, under the bridge and many places, also the "preman" are still there. But I think its much more manageable nowadays new rusun are being made my friend said its around Cilincing.
@rienkhoek4169
@rienkhoek4169 Год назад
I wonder what the average life expectation was in a place like that and who was able to build a life outside.
@iichantzii9797
@iichantzii9797 Год назад
I’d imagine the same in the city and outside…
@morganserrano9219
@morganserrano9219 6 лет назад
thank you for ptting it out with english subtitles ! great work ! I've watched it a long time ago, and it's been very useful to understand better the city.
@S_dott
@S_dott 6 лет назад
Silean Pavrolo thanks a lot 👍
@Catire92
@Catire92 2 года назад
The amount of cockroaches there must have been astonishing with Hong Kong’s heat and the humid conditions
@SkylineR33mt
@SkylineR33mt Год назад
That to me would be the worst part
@flemishtemplar3766
@flemishtemplar3766 Год назад
They probably ate all the cockroaches.
@scorpio19771111
@scorpio19771111 3 года назад
Generally fair documentary. I enjoyed it. Kowloon Walled City has always captured my imagination since childhood days. Feelings of depression, discomfort, mixed with that of admiration and empathy for the resilient residents of this long-gone icon...
@elie2465
@elie2465 4 года назад
Thanks for your work! I really appreciate it. What an excellent translation.
@S_dott
@S_dott 4 года назад
Elie thank you. Although I only annotated it as the original subs had strange wording. So I won’t take credit for actually translating it.
@lasal8613
@lasal8613 2 года назад
Looks cozy in a fucked up kinda way.
@MTdaBlacking
@MTdaBlacking Год назад
Oh good I thought I was weird for thinking that.
@nathanbabble1976
@nathanbabble1976 Год назад
I agree except when the woman said it’s wet inside my apartment all day every day
@mikehunt9884
@mikehunt9884 Год назад
i dunno if the poor people of HK weren't better off living inside the walled city than the current condition in HK, where people now have to literally pay to live in something the size of a dog cage.. not everybody was able to live in the housing projects, and now they're even shutting those down.. because of its density, its insanely expensive to have an apartment in hong kong, and the real estate speculation is ruthless.
@naomiskylar1743
@naomiskylar1743 10 месяцев назад
it’s still not great now but it’s DEFINITELY so much better than it was before
@joeyrozic1100
@joeyrozic1100 3 года назад
Feels like this is where the whole world is headed.
@gabrielgermann9148
@gabrielgermann9148 4 года назад
one of my all time favourite documentaries
@twisted1800
@twisted1800 4 года назад
The Corona Virus would have destroyed that place in a month, that would have been a nightmare. Props to that American lady who actually lived there to try and save all the drug addicts, that takes real dedication.
@3rdman99
@3rdman99 4 года назад
You mean that virus that kills way less than < 1% of people infected? How would that be "destroyed"?
@patatespatatoules9270
@patatespatatoules9270 4 года назад
Jackie Pullinger was British, just saying
@mattt1155
@mattt1155 4 года назад
@@3rdman99 Now to be fair they wouldn't have any medical services in the Walled City, and the lack of hygiene would hike the infection rates way up. Probably a lot more people would be killed in the Walled City by any sort of deadly infection.
@despairdoll
@despairdoll 4 года назад
i get what you're saying but these people probably developed powerful af immune systems from living here
@mattt1155
@mattt1155 3 года назад
@Kilo Byte they lived amongst roaches and rats. The documentary was clear that the standard for health in this place was very low. It's also explicitly shown that medical professionals such as dentists are allowed to operate without best practices of hygiene.
@aleynawastaken
@aleynawastaken 3 года назад
Fun fact: There is an extremely large arcade hall in Tokyo inspired by the Kowloon Walled City!
@kellenbrent
@kellenbrent 3 года назад
not anymore, sadly. www.forbes.com/sites/geoffreymorrison/2019/12/04/goodbye-to-japans-homage-to-hong-kongs-kowloon-walled-city/
@milkdromeda7.041
@milkdromeda7.041 3 года назад
@Muffy Crosswire DEVASTATING
@detonatingpunch381
@detonatingpunch381 3 года назад
@@kellenbrent that's shitty.
@kellenbrent
@kellenbrent 3 года назад
@@detonatingpunch381 I was in Tokyo in Feb '19, only about 45 minutes away by train. So bummed I missed seeing it in its last days.
@detonatingpunch381
@detonatingpunch381 3 года назад
@@kellenbrent ouch
@patrickpoh9
@patrickpoh9 4 года назад
My heart breaks for the children
@blackbox8490
@blackbox8490 3 года назад
I'd love to go there, talk to the people, experience the culture, etc. Yes, poverty sucks and their living conditions are nothing to be glorified, but these people had nothing and made it into their home. That is beautiful.
@AlternateKek
@AlternateKek 3 года назад
Nothing beautiful about it, in reality its horrifying. The majority are slaves basically under the rule by criminals and savages living in absolute squalor. You need to get off reddit and go outside.
@blackbox8490
@blackbox8490 3 года назад
@@AlternateKek Says someone who never lived there. My family grew up in the USSR, my first home was a grey apartment building I shared with my grandparents and uncle. It wasn't great or glorious, but the family and the people made it beautiful. I am also working class still to this day. You just want to look down on poor people and how they live their lives, but these people built something out of nothing. Their living conditions sucked, that isn't what is beautiful. Their close knit communities and their hearts are beautiful. I think you're the one who is chronically online "kek"
@AlternateKek
@AlternateKek 3 года назад
@@blackbox8490 The USSR was garbage and was a genocidal regime that murdered millions of Christians and politicals dissidents... but yea it was Ok because you lived in a small shitty apartment... got it. M
@blackbox8490
@blackbox8490 3 года назад
@@AlternateKek Are you by any chance American? Americans always think they can insert themselves into talks of other cultures while looking down on them, You have no idea what the USSR was like. I never said I want to go back to those times, but plenty of people do.
@rgddydshevchenko2448
@rgddydshevchenko2448 2 года назад
@@AlternateKek just give it up, he's just gonna go on about how bad America is because the Cia did a bad thing while ignoring the mass famines of communist countries
@robotadrift778
@robotadrift778 2 года назад
Thank you for adding subtitles, this city is so unique and interesting.
@DoD01006
@DoD01006 8 лет назад
Thank you. This was very interesting. Thanks for taking the time to sub it.
@momo-dm3rw
@momo-dm3rw 3 года назад
thank you very much share this documentary with us
@jsjxyz
@jsjxyz 3 года назад
The best documentary on the walled city
@jessemarques9577
@jessemarques9577 4 года назад
Absolutely fascinating
@12akshatabodhare58
@12akshatabodhare58 5 лет назад
This is an thought-provoking documentary.Thank you for uploading!
@madamadadane7989
@madamadadane7989 3 года назад
The most fascinating is that many who lived there remember it fondly
@girlsocksfinder
@girlsocksfinder 5 лет назад
Real Life Lore anyone?
@epychan1244
@epychan1244 5 лет назад
yep
@shreyasisarkar0001
@shreyasisarkar0001 5 лет назад
Yep
@oemahkucing7876
@oemahkucing7876 5 лет назад
hello
@jqkob7407
@jqkob7407 4 года назад
Yes
@Nietzsche_K_Gote
@Nietzsche_K_Gote 8 лет назад
this was gone from dailymotion thanks for uploading it.
@misterkefir
@misterkefir 3 года назад
Absolutely amazing stuff. Just mind-boggling.
@AliBaba-mb1pu
@AliBaba-mb1pu 2 года назад
Amazing documentary
@Duhya
@Duhya 7 лет назад
Imagine the disease in such a compact, damp, pest infested place. I wonder what the people who lived there thought of it, and especially those born/that grew up there.
@Horus-Lupercal
@Horus-Lupercal 7 лет назад
Bro imagine living there your whole life and never seeing the outside.
@mencot89
@mencot89 3 года назад
The docus on this says ‘they remember it fondly’ and many live there for generations
@georgesnowling926
@georgesnowling926 2 года назад
Thank you for this, also to the people that made it originally. Extremely interesting.
@SturmZebra13
@SturmZebra13 5 лет назад
Imagine how the city would be today... Hong Kong has a new airport so they could have built even higher
@Taikina
@Taikina 5 лет назад
i so would go visit if it still stood. on the other hand, it's probably for the best it got demolished. it's impossible to know if it was stable or if it was a miracle that it didn't have a major collapse/fire/flood/etc
@RoadSurferOfficial
@RoadSurferOfficial 4 года назад
@@Taikina considering there's no laws, or news network, collapses could have happened frequently
@eeeeee3831
@eeeeee3831 4 года назад
Interesting documentary
@wayner396
@wayner396 4 года назад
So fascinating
Далее
The Densest City on Earth
17:49
Просмотров 9 млн
Inside Australia’s gangland wars | Four Corners
43:46
СМЕЛОЕ РЕШЕНИЕ #shorts
00:14
Просмотров 23 тыс.
The Hackney Mole Man
16:32
Просмотров 425 тыс.
North Korea - Faces of an Alienated Country
21:55
Просмотров 2,7 млн
The Worst Hotel in Las Vegas
9:07
Просмотров 802 тыс.
Hong Kong - is it still worth visiting?
19:32
Просмотров 472 тыс.
In the Age of AI (full documentary) | FRONTLINE
1:54:17
Inside Hong Kong’s cage homes
9:54
Просмотров 24 млн