The film I took of Kylie performing When All Is Said And Done, with Benny Anderson on piano, at the Abba Tribute Concert in Hyde Park, London on Sunday, 13th September 2009.
This should have been a single. Kylie's vocals are beautiful on this version. For Benny to accompany her was amazing. He asked for her personally which is a great honour.
I think it's every fan's wish to sing with at least *one* member of ABBA 😊 ...let alone walk on stage with one of them - hand in arm 😃👍 Great version from Kylie ❤
There's no substitute for classical training. All versions stand below Abba's. But it is a very pleasant rendering of a beautiful song. And Kylie is a truly beautiful human being and singer.
you said it,man,a beautiful human being...that s what stands out from her most of the time, when she performs slow love songs....you clearly can feel something,that she s trying to make come across...and i Love her for that
omg all this kylie bashing... this is about honouring Abba and the song. She did a splendid rendition of Dancing Queen at the Sydney Olympics 2000 and always confessed to be a big fan since her teenage years. I am happy to see that Benny seems to agree that this is a song that deservers a second life and took it into the film version of Mamma Mia... Come on people be generous to her and it was probably a dream come true for her. No matter if you thought her to have a good voice, Kylie always has a decent style as person and character. She deserves better than easy bashing on the net.
ARE YOU KIDDING?! Considering the paucity of talent and musical vision, singing ability and memorable and worthwhile songcraft that Minogue displays. people are bloody nice to her and have always been. Just like Slagdonna the vile before her, she was 'lucky lucky lucky' to appear at a time when all reviewers forgave every little embarrassing (and sometimes downright vile-yes all S/A/W fans, downright vile) mistake she put out on record. Derivative as hell, without a style to call her own, get a life, people. What is WRONG with you all?! She'll never marry you, oh fan club Kylie, she likes 'em rich and younger than her now, but she loves her so-called career more. And no I don't dislike her. S-T-O-P confusing constructive criticism of an actual career for a slagging off of the person. Christ, what the far better likes of proper female singers with quality material, underrated as hell and conveniently whitewashed out for the slaggy, contrived bimbette pretenders had to put up with. All Kim Wilde, Kirsty MacColl, Toyah, Sandra, Claudia Brucken, Voice Of The Beehive and T'Pau had to put up with was pointless, wrong-footed, near-sighted, befuddling criticism-WHEN they were even considered at all-a bit rich when they've set the standard for many to follow to diminishing returns all round. Minogue IS nice persona-wise (despite the creepy mindset to still look a schoolgirl past 40), her love of botox BEFORE it got fashionable and her inability to come out with something more meaningful than fluffy. Which is fine, but we don't all want to keep hearing someone getting bloated and misconceived hot-air clouds of fake accolades just for standing in front of a mic while wiggling her bum and sounding more like a machine then the machine does. I don't think I've heard her sing properly for years. REAL singers don't need effects to take over their voice and try and make it palatable. Be generous to her? That IS generous. People have been cotton-woolling ever since she appeared with all those vile S/A/W songs, and one could argue she's deviated little from since. This puts her WAY WAY above the vile likes of Madonna, but then she IS very like that bitch in too many senses. Both are so desperate to be remembered, to stay 'current' they won't leave us alone for more than a year, rattling off any mediocre nothing as long as it's something out there. The need to overwork their underwork while clearly fighting the undignified battle against ageing and the need to ignore a partner who knows they won't give more than 20% to a relationship is stark and glaring. This insecurity and self-love is nauseating and sad, nice person or not. And Minogue has admitted that Ciccone is one of her (zero) heroes. What a shocker! So while she feels the need to pick an ABBA song from the period everyone ignored for ever, while laudable enough, still smacks of heavy scripting. She does it when everyone is reassessing ABBA correctly, and does it once these awful 'mamma mia' films are out, with the nauseatingly players doing this song. Kim Wilde too does the odd ABBA song live-many do-but doesn't feel the need to have it lauded JUST for doing it. In fact her younger sister (the subject of her 1986 hit 'Schoolgirl') is embarrassingly a backing singer for Ms Minogue-who still won't cover a Kim song (though I bet if she did the choice would be as obvious and unwanted as her stale, long past their date lazy, uninspired and obsolete disco mashings. How long can someone keep singing about loving to dance all the time. I never liked the insipid likes Gloria Estefan doing it! I don't think Kylie will die from a little correct observation that if you try to launch for the heights from a platform not even seen with the naked eye its so low, don't be surprised if the only fair declaration you're fit for is disdain, embarrassment , or at the very least askance. That she even got these for being noticed doing it in the first place is a height she might not deserve at the very least, so there you are, Ms Minogue, one height of a kind met. No surprise, as people have only being burping your praises since your first cringed us all through the loveless 'locomotion' and the 'yucky yucky yucky' 30 dreaded years ago. How time doesn't fly or change what truly never mattered. And on an entirely different topic-only linked in as much as it concerns the same person, Minogue remains an approachable presence, and tales of her tantrum throwing seem non-existent. This alone is very different to all the others she so unnervingly holds as contemporaries. Pick better company is all I can say. And even though this performance here is exactly what it is, at least she's not loing that insipid and pitiful 'Only You' ruination. And there's no hagdonna here-the worst person in the world to screw an ABBA song. You're wrong here. The internet for once allows a few people to be brave, individual and normal enough to do the unthinkable-to actually criticise someone so unused to it that all her fawning nutters have aneurysms over something as harmless as a: "that one song is not quite so 101% out of 10 as all her other amazing million others, but she'll pull it back I know, she's the greatest after madonna". Something that would he considered the highest of praise had any pre-slagdonna female singer not already critically accepted would should they ever be 'lucky lucky lucky' to get it. And that reminds me of what several journos and many college students put forward at her first appearance. What does Kylie say when promised a future in the music biz. "I should be so lucky, lucky, lucky, lucky..." and repeat 4 more times. And then for the next 30 years. So lucky indeed that criticism and dividing taste-so expected in most things in another world-aren't even allowed to exist, never mind touch. Oh that's Kylie. SOOO the most vilified person online. Oh no! See her fall. Aren't we all so EVIL whoever we all are?!
@@dreasbn Please, save it for yourself, you're the one defending a talent so slim you'd miss it if it tuned sideways. Forget about the fawned over masses of puppets, think about the REAL unsung ones that deliver the goods, and not these bints.
@@kyachdistent1301 so you know better than Benny Andersson himself with whom he should perform his very own songs... you simply must be president of a very successfull company.. oh wait i guess not.. ps i will definitely not keep it for myself. never ever.
How Beautiful you sang this song kylie 💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋💋❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️I love you so much kylie you were truly amazing princess
I am not a big fab but i must say her vocals are fab stunning in fact not many singers can sing live very impressed . little soul with a voice of an Angel. benny was in awe.
Difficult i like ABBA song not sing from ABBA..i really think no one can't sing like Frida and Agnetha their song...and personally Kylie Mingue is not the kind of singer usually i like...BUT i think this is really really good performance..if it be ever in some album,i 'll buy it...and i say it again,i'm not a Kylie fan.but, well done...lovely version,sweet and with passion and with right use of voice. 5 stars for her... :)))
Rio de Janeiro. I envy those who were there. Not just a repair in a park, but a cultural event. The two formed a beautiful and musical partner. Gratifying that many in Europe as remember the musical past decades. The legacy of ABBA will cross decades into the future. RU-vid allows you to see how different the current generation was and is the music of 60.70 and 80 years.
As much as I LOVE ABBA and Kylie Minogue, and while I think she does a good job with it, nobody can beat Frida Lyngstad. Pity we never actually got to hear Frida sing this song live. She would have smashed it! Doesn't help that this song is underrated as it is. What's with the second verse anyway? Don't recall that being in the original, and it was in the Mamma Mia version (I MUCH prefer Kylie to Pierce Brosnan's abysmal singing...). Did Benny/Bjorn just add another verse? Not that it needed one.
Some of the lyrics of the songs in the movie "Mamma Mia" they were changed to fit the story of the film. For example "My love my life", if you look at the first verse, it is already different from the original song of the group, and they did the same with many of the lyrics. Kylie did an amazing job and ik it is not the point but... NO ONE EVER can do it better than Mrs Lyngstad. I love that woman: so talented, funny, kind, sweet, charming, intelligent, generose, humble, hard worker, polite, inspirational and outrageously beautiful 🙈❤️✨💕 Benny Andersson is a genius... His band B.A.O is amazing. 😻💞
My idol Kylie has fantastic vocals i agree there is way 2 many Kylie bashers who always critise my Kylie she can definately sing @ im sure Kylie was proud 2 have sung an Abba classic Luv u Kylie
Aria retroceder el mundo como un disco ,volver al pasado pare estar cerca de la gloria con mis seres queridos amados y compartir lindos tiempos ,y la banda más hermosa de la tierra abba💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟
Kylie é uma boa cantora está versão e legal mais quando escuto esta música lembro automaticamente da incomparável Frida uma das maiores cantoras da história da música
lashertiani the extra verses were written for mamma mia musical where this song is instead intended for a man and woman who re-meet and love each other after a lor of time...
Always say that if you're going to cover a song, put your own interpretation on it and this is a nice, sweet version. Just a real pity that ABBA and Frida never got the chance to perform this live before the split. She would have knocked it out of the park without a dry eye in the house.
Great memories of this event so big thanks for posting. Kylie was great and does a good interpretation of the song as have a few others but, the definitive version will always be Frida's glorious leadvocal and the original ABBA recording of the track. A Highlight from their "The Visitors" album.
Really? Have you heard "Two for the Price of One?" Or "The Day Before You Came?" Or "Does Your Mother Know?" I think this is rather tame compares to others, personally.
She does alright. Just because it's Kylie doesn't mean it's the greatest thing ever. It's fine, that's it. Nobody, and I mean nobody, can sing this like Frida did on the original. That was a Hall of Fame performance by Frida, unmatched.
Puede sonar lindo con kylie, pero nunca va a sonar igual que con Frida, Frida por favor estas a tiempo, regalanos a tus fans un ultimo concierto para escuchar tu voz.-
The original arrangement is euphoric, upliftingly sad, driving, magic. Don't bleeding compare ABBA to a 6th rate disco amplifier whose vocals sounds more like a casio keyboard key than the synth does! And this arrangement has nothing to do with her anyway, but when HAS music ever happened BECAUSE of her?
I don't like this because as it's the 'Mamma Mia' version, some of the best lyrics of the song are replaced by worse lyrics. Kylie did a good job though.
I just don't understand all the talking, and noise in general, when she is singing. Quite of few of these public performances are afflicted by this rude behavior. What does this audience think it's like for this person they admire . . . singing to an audience that isn't really listening.
What a hideous thing to say! Kylie is wonderful! Her own style. She loves and respects Abba and has always paid homage to them. Perhaps show some respect to Kylie
I don't like it!!! I prefer Frida's voice!!! sorry guys!!! :-( Totally boring!!! Frida's voice has much more spirit and pep and excitement!!! O I'm glad I have the ORIGINAL VERSION of ABBA (Frida)!!!
It's cos she doesn't know how to sing. She shouldn't do anything ill-equipped for her playschool casio voice. But you can't tell these people that and certainly not the fans. Reality is not what can (or should?) deal with.
