Liberty Safe VS American Security | The BEST Gun Safe Showdown! 

At least with Liberty you never have to fear about locking your safe up accidentally. They will have the Feds come over and help you unlock it 😂

Never buying a liberty safe.

The only thing a liberty safe is good for is securing Bud lights.

Going to be hard pressed to find anyone trusting "Liberty" safes.

Screw Liberty Safe Co. I will be purchasing Amsec, even if it wasn't as good.

Dont give money to companies that hate you.

Liberty must be some slow moving inventory these days. I feel bad for their employees, distributors, suppliers, etc. Maybe they should start making boat anchors or something like that.

Liberty new CEO Dillion Mulvaney 😂

Ummm, liberty safe should be called Liberal safe!! We protect your guns unless the fbi asks nicely!!

If this were a car video, it has the info value of covering cup holders and vanity mirrors. The mention of bolt thickness is a give away. No one mentions those bolts are bolted to a piece angle iron. It’s like holding a pencil by the eraser and trying to resist prying. Look up Sturdy Safe and you’ll see a company that isn’t afraid to show you their mechanisms and how robust they are.

Every safe dealer will tell you a traditional dial lock is more reliable than a digital. Problems aren’t that common, but when they do it’s always the digital locks. It comes down to steel in the construction. 3/8-1/2” in the door is great, but most doors with less will survive prying attacks. It’s the steel in the sidewalls to consider. The strongest door around is worthless if a $30 Harbor Freight grinder can eat a ring around the top of the safe so they can just reach in and pull the guns out. Between these two safes the Amsec is better as two layers of steel with that “concrete” mixture in between. A grinder has to go “deep” to cut both layers. Fire protection is hit or miss. It all depends upon the location inside the house. Firearms rarely survive unscathed in a total house loss. If that safe falls thru the floor those guns are going to get banged up. Lastly no safe holds the amount of guns they claim especially if you have a lot of bolt actions with scopes. Remember they aren’t “safes”, they are Residential Security Containers. It says so inside the door. If they were “true safes” they wouldn’t have 7-14ga sidewalls. So for smash and grab thieves, limiting access to kids, and SOME fire protection, a gun “safe” is a good idea. The biggest complaint about all safes is the buyer wishes they would have purchased a bigger model. Your collection grows and your wives will want to put stuff in there too! This video host is very knowledgeable. If you live in TX, buy from him. If you live in WA state, buy from NWSafe in Auburn, WA. Don’t ever buy a Chinesium safe from a big box store. I don’t care if it says “Winchester” on the front of it.

Never buy liberty safe

Liberty is still in business?😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Why on Earth would anybody want a liberty safe?

liberty safe betrayed us

That Amsec will beat the pants off anything it's compared to. Conc.. I mean Dry light, filled, and dual layered. Sold.

I bought amsec 20 yesterday ago. Sergeant and Greenleaf TouchPad. Love it

42 year Safe tech here I’ll put in my two cents first off. You should never ever have an electronic safe lock Secondly, I would never buy a safe with internal Hinges. There’s no way to repair or adjust. With a lower cost gun safe. A bad fire will cook the contents. third it would be wise to purchase a $29 sentry fireproof suitcase, put all of your important documents in that and put that inside your gun safe for extra fire protection fourth you should open your safe a minimum of once a week to exchange the air fifth keep all of your important guns inside of silicone gun socks and for the record, my favorite safe lock of all time it’s called big red. You shouldn’t own Safe without one.

The words Liberty Safe and Best never belonged in the same sentence even before the start of their self destruction.

A very concise comparison. Good job.

The amsec over liberty any day of the week! Drylight over drywall alone…never mind solid plate door compared to composite bs. Sorry but no substitute for solid steel (except maybe a high psi concrete) I may have missed it but if you did a weight comparison I’d venture to say the amsec is quite a bit heavier. Two safes are roughly the same size yet one is much heavier it means it’s a better built safe in terms of steel or concrete content. Amsec equals true quality security, liberty equals some security and a lot of marketing.

Love the color of the safes , was wondering if you had an opinion on the liberty patriot gun safe or the sportsman gun safes

Love the comparison of the flagships. I like the locking bars of Liberty, but hinges of AmSec.

Well the prices defere me to other methods because I don't have 7 thousand dollars in firearms + Liberty sold out one of their customers to the ATF a while back and that in itself is not recoverable in my opinion. 🎉

Great video showcasing two different safes! The Liberty ball bearing hardened plate is the bomb ! ! ! Don't think anyone can try to drill through that without tripping the relocker ! ! !

I own 3 AMSECS BF2, BF AND BFX. All are very solidly built. Go with a combo lock, safer.

Amsec makes good safes, and Liberty makes safes that are good for the feds to get into

I looked at these and went with Fort Knox and I love it!

I have a 1996 American Security rough finish, dial and turn lever from 1996 model 6/7/F/D/B/G with no external hinges, ~65" tall, 26" wide, 18" deep. The lock is getting a little wonky on the last number to open it.

Sold mine a month after the news broke. I got pennies on the dollar. There won't be another Liberty product in this house ever again.

Liberty safes are decent, and they have promised not to release any more combination codes. But they're high gauge sheet metal, and plate safes like National Security are better, imo.

36 years as a safe tech the whole security is the small piece of hard plate between the door and lock period the best lock is a mechanical lock 20-30 seconds to open when you get to know her 😂

My beef is the prices...when provo steel stared this gunsafe industry 35 years ago (aka Browning) you could buy a top of the line for 600 bucks, today your paying up to 10k. And it's the same paper weight....rip off

Was hoping for a close up of the amsec.

Great content! U will get so many more subs!

Doesn't matter if thee company gives your code out

Will American security give a bypass code when ordered?

It really boils down to, R u protecting $1 or a life savings? Safes are a investment.

Finally outgrew my older National Security Magnum. Im not anti Liberty, but im also not dropping $10k+ on another magnum....Any dealer suggestions in the KC area?

Tucker Carlson endorses Liberty safe. He explained on his podcast a couple weeks ago what’s going on and what liberty did to rectify the situation. They have lawyers challenging subpoenas and you can get your unique master code deleted from their systems. What else could you ask?

Amsec all day

Most people are not going thru the door. They are going thru the side

There’s a lot of precision missing in this presentation. Where some things are needlessly dumbed down, others aren’t factually incorrect. The viewer is likely to be misinformed. I don’t know well Mr. Laukaitis is informed or experienced but this presentation is lacking. And to that all I can suggest is verify the details with someone who isn’t trying to sell you anything.

Got my 6030 BFX for around $5500 brand new......steal.

Liberty seems to have a big gap all around the door for a pry bar to engage.

After liberty safe gave up passwords to the government I sold my liberty safe and will never buy another one again. I would trust a crackhead on the streets over a liberty.

Whats all the hate with liberty safes im confused

I have heard good things from several credible people about the high end Dakota safes... One employee told me Fort Knox rep said "Their the fort knox of imports" - Any opinions?

Did you realize that you misspelled "Burglary" in the video (at 14:41)?

UL Burglary Ratings?

Liberty political donations are 100% democrat. Good thing i lost all my guns in an unfortunate boating accident. Any future guns will not go in a liberty

Liberty 🚫🏳️‍🌈👎🏻I would never support a company that gives the government access to private citizens property. HELL NO!!!!

They are both crap. I'm a 74 year old sheet metal worker and could get in both of them fast. Skip gun safes and buy a used TL rated safe, a TL-15 or 30 would be much better choices. I bought three 6' tall TL-30 safes from the same person on craigslist for next to nothing.

does amsec give the feds the combination to access your shit?

SUGGESTION...try FT KNOX safes out of Utah

Yea.....Not buying a Liberty after what they pulled.

7k she safe lmao

Are these TL Rated? If not....a crow bar and 10 minutes you are in.

I appreciate the video, truly. But man, your verbal delivery is brutal. I know you’re not drunk, but you sound like you are. You could’ve narrated this video in 1/2 to 2/3 of time. 🤦🏻‍♂️ TALK FASTER!

How is this a showdown who buys liberty safe anymore? It's not a safe did give out the code lol😂😂😂 They didn't even have a warrant, did they?Maybe I could just call up and they'll give me the code

Liberty safes 🤣😂🤣🖕