Life is Beautiful: Finding Beauty in the Holocaust

Подписаться 75 тыс.

Просмотров 87 тыс.

50% 1

In Life is Beautiful, Roberto Benigni found love, comedy and beauty in the tragedy of the Holocaust. The Oscar-winning classic is a masterpiece in screenwriting, acting, direction and cinematography/photography. In this review/video essay I break down how Benigni shows us that the most beautiful thing about life is you. So stay true to yourself. Because if you can learn to love others with the same confidence with which you love yourself, then you can find the beauty in just about anything.
Note that the philosophical ideas of Schopenhauer that I touch on in this video are only the very basics and do not completely represent the man, his works or his ideas. I encourage you to do your own research and create your own opinions.
NB: I highly recommend you watch the full movie Life is Beautiful before watching this review/video essay! You won't want the movie ending spoiled for you in this video.
I would love to discuss in the comments! Or feel free to reach me on my social media:
Instagram: / shinyreviewstv
TikTok: / shinyreviews
Twitter: / shinyreviews1
Check out these wonderful videos on Life is Beautiful, many elements of which I have shamelessly copied:
Mathias Hosel: 'Life is Beautiful - Setting vs the Static Protagonist (Video Essay)': • Life is Beautiful - Se...
Pietro Schito: 'Life is Beautiful - Inject Meaning into your Story with Setup and Payoff [Write Something Great]': • Life is Beautiful - In...
Music:
'Buongiorno Principessa' by Nicola Piovani (Cover by 로피 RoPi [Roma Pianist]): • Nicola Piovani - Buong...
'Machina' by Scott Buckley: • 'Machina' [Retro Ambie...
'Hiraeth' by Scott Buckley: • 'Hiraeth' [Emotional C...

Опубликовано:

26 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 211

@inesleite7524 3 года назад

“The tragedy of the Holocaust is not something to laugh at, but it’s definitely something you can laugh against” - this is incredibly true and such a powerful way of opposing to cruelty

@punishedgloyperstormtroope8098 9 месяцев назад

I laugh at

@Your_Wingman 8 месяцев назад

@@punishedgloyperstormtroope8098 I also laugh at America for losing every war since ww2

@punishedgloyperstormtroope8098 8 месяцев назад

@@Your_Wingman lollll

@Your_Wingman 8 месяцев назад

@@punishedgloyperstormtroope8098 ik right America can't win anything 😂

@punishedgloyperstormtroope8098 8 месяцев назад

@@Your_Wingman yeah America sucks it’s the least deserving country to be global superpower Thankfully soon America will fall and be separated and balkanised into small countries and a new European superpower can emerge that’s actually competent

@EmilyKresl 2 года назад

My favorite part of the whole movie is when he's translating the German "rules for the game," for his son, and doing his best to make everything he say match the officers body language. It wasn't til I got older that I realized noone in the bunk blew his cover either, he could have easily been stopped and shot, but they let him do it for the boy. ❤️

@EmilyKresl 2 года назад

Here's the clip of the scene ❤️ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9lTSqc1UnLU.html

@kudraabdulaziz3096 2 месяца назад

100th like

@EmilyKresl 2 месяца назад

@@kudraabdulaziz3096 nice!!!! 💯

@flclhack 3 года назад

you clearly have vision and talent, and the youtube algorithm has worked in your favor! there are very few youtubers who come running out the gate with the quality and consistency of the videos you've put out this past month. you should be super, super proud of yourself.

@ehchess 3 года назад

Well, this breakdown + the Marriage Story video that introduced me to you = a new fan of your stuff (and a new subscriber). I love these deep dives into great film!

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you!

@joanneweiss3864 3 года назад

Wait til you see Call Me By Your Name......

@brittanyjohnson1945 3 года назад

Same! I came from the same marriage story video and subscribed. You’re awesome!

@nikidijawen 3 года назад

ehchess just watched Shiny Reviews The Marriage Story and then this one. In-depth in a way that adds to the picture, when I was little would want to see the same movie over and over again each time would gain something new this is a more adult way of gaining more.

@ms.m3n 3 года назад

You got me to cry still now from just watching this critique of Life is beautiful. Phenomenal film analysing 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

@Myk95 2 года назад

This is one of those movies that you wanna watch again because its just lovely and light hearted but you cant because its dark and heavy at heart.

@eternaleez 3 года назад

"But it's definitely something you can laugh against" you really have a way with words wow Your channel is great I just watched all your videos at once lol good job!!

@joanneweiss3864 3 года назад

Me too, all in last couple hours I'm emotionally drained in a good way!

@zvarka011 3 года назад

Im so sorry he died..but when I think about it, it really shows his tremendous strength

@gickyvergo4597 3 года назад

From the music to everything you just said, La vitta è bella is one of the most beautiful movies out there and my personal favourite. I can never forget at the end, the irony, the drama where the child finds the “trunk reward”, such a witty part of the movie but also so so sad. I cry every time. Have not watched this in a while, thank you for posting this.

@feliciahorne8969 3 года назад

When I read your comment and you referenced the "trunk reward", I broke down and cried. Life is beautiful is my favorite film about the triumph of the human

@gickyvergo4597 3 года назад

@@feliciahorne8969 🥺🥺yeah!

@starlit-rain 2 года назад

This is a movie that both my parents love and I was blown away when I first watched it. I don't know how important it is to mention but I am German, and I have never seen a movie on concentration camps or the holocaust like this. It's beautiful, funny and sad at the same time. Thank you for this video.

@sunnylilacs 8 месяцев назад

We watched it tonight, and one thing I realized on this watch-through was how good/subtle a job it did of showing the effect of the Holocaust on the perpetrators as well as the victims. You see and hear of the female guards’ desensitization, the doctor’s descent into madness and guilt/horror, and the early indoctrination of the children. If you’ve never read the story of Corrie ten Boom, “The Hiding Place,” I highly recommend it. One of the things I love best about it (and there are very many) is her sister’s vision, conceived even while in the concentration camp as a victim, of the place of healing she would create for the German people, because she recognized that they would need to heal, too. It’s a vision that was realized. Their story is very beautiful, as well; in fact, I would say it’s even more transcendent than this one, even as great as this one is, perhaps because it’s a true story.

@cherusiderea1330 3 года назад

I will never forget our excursion to the concentration camp right at the Polish-German border. You must understand, the nature surrounding the camp is beautiful. It's green and luscious and tranquille and you would never think that something horrible happened there. We went into the cabin where the prisoners used to eat and where nowadays lies a pile of the shoes the prisoners wore. It's all that's left of them. All their ashes were just scattered in the surrounding area. And I looked at the pile and was standing right in front of a tiny kid's shoe. We need to keep the memory alive so we will always know what those people did to those they did not deem "worthy"

@caroljeeben7064 2 года назад

I think this is my favorite movie. I went into watching it 100% not knowing what it was about. I thought it was just one of those older happy fun movies about a family just loving life... and then slowly it changed and almost shows just how gradually the change happened in small stages until it was too late. I love the aspect of him trying his best to keep his child's innocence even though it was the worst of times. A child should never ever have to deal with adult issues let alone the holocaust. It really changed my parenting style. It was one of the best movies I've ever seen.

@simonesquared 3 года назад

FAVE CHANNEL AND FAVE FILM

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

omg thanks Olivia Rodrigo!!

@simonesquared 3 года назад

@@marcustranfilm i-------

@mariafoschi1076 3 года назад

I am Italian and grew up with Roberto Benigni movies and I watched this movie countless time. I can say that your review made me observe aspects that never thought about before. Very well written video. Subscribed.

@ab-vz4ps 3 года назад

They're so many things that i overlooked or didnt think much of until you pointed it out!! I really enjoyed your video!!

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you! Glad you enjoyed

@SP-ny1fk Год назад

"Every joke is a tiny Revolution" - George Orwell

@nicolassilveiraleite2280 3 года назад

Actually, from the beggining of the pandemics till here, I've been discovering how much I love cinema and its arts, so as RU-vid showed me your channel, I've been more in love with it. Tysm for the content!

@actuallyjade 3 года назад

I want to watch the video but I haven't watch the movie so I will be watching this later when I do. But I still want to comment because 1) it helps with engagement and I'd love for others to find your channel like I did 2) as someone who loves watching video essays, I'm really glad I found your channel because yours are some of the best I've ever watched!

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

That's a dedicated subscriber - thank you! And I would definitely give this one a watch, it's one of my favourite films of all time.

@letitiakiu 3 года назад

I remember watching this movie as a child and it was so profound. It's amazing that he was able to inspire so many with this beautiful movie. I love hearing your dissection of these movies. It gives me a richer appreciation for this art, and even for my own work. Subscribed! Thank you!

@barefootdeb7183 3 года назад

This is one of the best films ever made. Every time I watch it I'm moved and amazed.

@DebRedStyles 6 месяцев назад

This examination literally brought tears to my eyes.

@fdyjt 4 месяца назад

When the kid comes off the tank and you hear the adult voice saying so that was my story my father gaved his life to protect mine.I burst into tears everytime

@acadia5898 Год назад

"Guido is so charismatic that he has rubbed off onto his son" what a perfect way to describe both of them

@cheekyyum 3 года назад

I for some weird reason watched this video. I have zero interest in movies, but the author seems incredibly smart. An analyst, observer, thinker with a multilevel foundation strong enough to explain a simple theory through philosophy, books

@bambina7433 3 года назад

Waking up and finding out one of my favourite creators on youtube made a video about one of my favourite movies must be one of the best feelings ever.

@gastisini 3 года назад

I saw your Call Me By Your Name video on my recommended, one of my all time favourites and the 2nd I saw is also one of my all time favourites. Life Is Beautiful. Loved both videos Keep it up.

@gudetamaenthusiast8315 3 года назад

i really can’t believe you just started your channel out. the quality of these videos are immensely amazing even with their straightforwardness and you break down the striking scenes really damn well. hoping to see more videos from you in the future!

@RebelNinja89 3 года назад

I recently rewatched Life is Beautiful and was already in awe of how great the film is. Your video essay really enhances the meaning for me! I'm excited to see what else you have up your sleeves :D

@ismailhacihasanov4781 2 года назад

You've missed one thing. When 2 men came to Guido's bookshop, he told his son to stay there. Then he sees that the boy is watching him and he starts to march and act goofy as he walks by his son. The same happens in the last scene when Guido walks by his son, even the melody is the same in these two scenes.

@0Iive 3 года назад

*YOU SHOULD DEFINITELY REVIEW/ANALYSE ‘IM THINKING OF ENDING THINGS’* It’s pretty insane and had to watch it twice to fully understand what was happening but it sure it interesting and would love to hear your take on it :)

@AthenaIsabella Год назад

This movie changed my life!! So glad I found your channel omg

@cameronsweeney8635 3 года назад

There are already soooooo many film review/video essay type channels out there but you seem to have tapped into something great with these more narrowly focused videos. I like it, keep going!

@kwonca5736 24 дня назад

Life is Beautiful is my all time favorite movie since I was little, and you really made it justice with this videos! I pretty sad that I didn't find it sooner and I didn't get to support your channel at the time! I would've loved your videos on the topics you talked at the end😢😊 Hope you're doing fine! Best regards.

@ItsBeatrizM 3 года назад

I am absolutely speechless. Thank you for this video

@tallybee9091 3 года назад

I've nvr heard of this film before, but I'll definitely be watching it now! Great work, you have the perfect voice & editing style for video essays imo :)

@SarhaSwati 8 дней назад

Loved your insights. "You can laugh against the tragedy."

@aurela1331 3 года назад

u have literally convinced me to watch this film and i just wanna say i hope u do start to get WAY more views bc ur videos are SO high quality and i loved ur phantom thread one aswell as the ones on marriage story and cmbyn :)

@AJPrice-cg5ip 17 дней назад

I really need to see this film. Thanks so much for a wonderful presentation!

@benwg2347 3 года назад

Can't believe you've only got 4 videos..with the way you've made them so far I'd of assumed you'd been doing this for years, absolutely amazing job, can't wait for your future videos

@lizapetrova3415 2 месяца назад

your videos are amazing! Thank you so much for them! I hope you will continue to make them.

@RuariW1 3 года назад

Another amazing video! I love this film and your insight definitely made me appreciate it even more, keep up the great work :))

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you! :))

@areebanwar9229 3 года назад

When you continue to deliver what they did not expect they stop labelling predicting expecting and rather follow you every word this is why I love your videos. Because at first I thought I knew what you were talking about in the marriage story and you surprised me and you continue to surprise me and you change the way I listen

@noahkirschtein8169 3 года назад

i love your videos so much, man. please keep going it’s AMAZING

@lexushi99 Год назад

this movie changed my brain chemistry

@PedroBrazz 2 года назад

First I've got to say that ur videos became the denifyng vision of someof my favorite films (and in the case of Young Royals, series). U really got a clear vision of the themes and techniques in creating this stories and helps me alot to create some of the thins i'm working on right now. Life is beautiful is my favorite film of all time and I cry every single time someone talks about it, so thank you for make this videos, makes me fall in love wit it even more!!!

@aaronshanly346 3 года назад

Do spirited away next pleaseee!

@funkymonks8333 4 месяца назад

It's not really "finding beauty in the Holocaust", it's finding beauty in life. Roberto Benigni himself said that this movie isn't a comedy about the Holocaust, but a movie about a comedian facing an extreme situation.

@baloonbarbies8785 3 года назад

I loved this movie!! Thank you for such a beautiful breakdown

@pulkitarora5932 3 года назад

Never before have I been stoked to get on someone's Patreon.

@pinkboo2 5 месяцев назад

i think this might be my favourite youtube video of all time

@sadfairy4095 3 года назад

Absolutely brilliant analysis. Thank you

@al-py9cn 3 года назад

i was just checking out this channel a few minutes ago and got a notification that you released a new vid ! love ur insights on the media you cover !

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you!

@user-nu2vc9mp5j 8 месяцев назад

when i first saw this film, my parents were going through a divorce. my dad took me to see this film with his new gf. he used this romantic movie as a strategic choice to get close to this young impressionable college student. note that he was 40 and he was accomplished in his career. He never had a taste for romantic films. His new marriage didn't last. the 2nd time i saw this film was the day after, i decided to bring my mother to see the film. she cried after seeing this, and on our way home i could see that she wished for a man to treat her well like guido did in the film. eventually, she did find her prince now as an adult, I decided to rewatch it for the 3rd time. i find myself feeling melancholic experiencing what my mom did and looking at what happened back then.

@keithdavis8461 Год назад

This is one of the most important movies I've seen. I can't wait to show it to my children.

@SP-ny1fk Год назад

Our school took our class to see this in the cinema when it came out. We were all rowdy and running around before we went in, but when we got out there was only silence.

@willcwhite 3 года назад

Very glad to see this video. I feel like there has been a backlash against "Life is Beautiful" in recent years, which I think is unfortunate. It's a great movie.

@bgt2848 2 года назад

Of all the films I’ve seen in my life I honestly find his character To be the most heroic . Honestly I can’t watch the film and not see a true hero

@ilyriaz 3 года назад

after watching every video on your channel I realise how little I appreciated films in general and will start seeing movies outside of my normal net... I really enjoyed Green Book and wonder if I'm missing out on anything that might have flown over my head? maybe green book is worthy of doing a video essay on. love the videos and keep up the amazing work!

@Agriking 3 года назад

Another great review.

@jiolo3404 3 года назад

Beautiful! Loving your essays 🤍, this movie was heartbreaking had to watch it for history class, just wanted to ask do you major in film at university? (side note: i watched young royals because you were so passionate about it, loved it!)

@palor2911 2 года назад

Whatever movie is discussed in your videos, it is on my list of next film to watch. This is so I can watch your video on it afterwards.

@AndreaGonzalez-ei8ut 3 года назад

I can't believe i just found your channel, i watched all of your videos, thanks for giving us a new look to these wonderful films!

@madeleineshaw5772 Год назад

Brilliant analysis deepened my appreciation...thank you

@keithdavis8461 Год назад

Great analysis, BTW!

@kramv1515 3 года назад

Love your video essay very much and how you deeply explain every ideology on a particular scene. I really want to see and hear you make a vid about Parasite (directed by Bong Joon Ho) and I would watch it no matter how long it is.

@KpopowaMi 3 года назад

I can see that you put in a lot of effort in making your videos! Your channel will get big♥️

@Harsht8 Год назад

Best analysis of this movie I have seen so far ❤

@Harsht8 Год назад

thanks for recommending the 2 channels in the end

@stefannyleungyu9427 3 года назад

Hi from NY! I really love your critical thinking and analysis of this movie. It's really impressive the way you express it. My recommendation for you for your next movies are Jojo Rabbit, Colonia (Emma Watson), and any Tim Burton's work like Scissorhands I love all of his movies since they're abstract. I'd really appreciate that if you take one of these :)

@Snackyyz 11 месяцев назад

I bawled my eyes out to this movie.

@iceleafofalba 3 года назад

This is beautiful 💙🙌🏽💜

@ines868 3 года назад

your analyses are amazing, thank you youtube algorithm for helping me find this channel !!!!

@arianam.4743 3 года назад

I watched Life Is Beautiful just because I really wanted to watch this video, and it was worth it!! The movie was, well, beautiful, and this video was fascinating too. All of your videos have been great - can't wait to see what the future holds for your channel!

@lmillet 7 месяцев назад

Hello Marcus, Thank you for your insightful reviews. I really enjoyed them.

@weston407 11 месяцев назад

What a beautiful movie - great stuff, HIGHLY recommended to anyone who hasn't seen it

@livialopes5406 3 года назад

I'm absolutely in love with your content. Can't wait for more!

@treebug7738 Год назад

I would love for you to look over the perks of being a wallflower it’s such a classic and emotional piece

@herlifemusings23 2 года назад

I cry every time I watch this movie. It's so beautiful

@jooleeeee 3 года назад

Thank you so much for this brilliant analysis of Life is Beautiful.

@zijing9548 2 года назад

You have such a calming voice

@purplebubblegum4055 3 года назад

This is one of the first movies I watched. I'll always cherish it

@sanyo5122 2 года назад

What a beautiful movie and what a beautiful message!! Heart warming 💖. Thanks for analysing this movie...you did a great job ! Vivek Agnihotri ( Director of the Kashmir files) please take notes... this is how it's done!!

@valentinacardile4771 Месяц назад

Sono orgogliosa come italiana che questo film sia tanto apprezzato in America ❤

@Plu255 3 года назад

oh ! i watched this movie when i was like 10, it was before i understood english so i watched it without understanding anything, i absolutely looooved it !! i'll defiantly look it up and watch it again soon !!!!

@briangray5067 Год назад

Excellent analysis of an amazing movie. Thank you.

@marcellelamarche6221 3 года назад

Been subscribed ever since your first video and every time you amaze me with the quality of every aspect of your content. Please keep going, you make me watch (and re-watch) everything you review and only good has came out. I really hope the algorithm works on your favor and you blow up, because videos like this is what people should be watching. I’d also like to include two little recommendations! Movies “Dear Ex” and “Breadwinner” on Netflix. Maybe it’s because I’m very emotional, but both brought me to tears, and I find them very interesting. Would be nice hearing your opinion on them!

@farsickness2723 Год назад

Want more videos from you … loved it great work very clear and soothing…

@followingheartlines 3 года назад

i havent seen the film but the way you frame and discuss things is so clear and engaging - a beauty in itself. great video☆

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you very much!

@jasmineambrose319 2 года назад

So happy I have come across this!!

@loindah4646 3 года назад

1 bonkadonk for engagement

@kanishkwaghmare5692 3 года назад

I am in for anything you will create in the future!!! Casual or otherwise :)

@marcustranfilm 3 года назад

Thank you! :)

@Sania582ify 2 года назад

Beautiful! Thanks a million!!! ❣👌

@sofiaquinelli6349 3 года назад

Can’t believe this is your fourth video

@randomgirl566 3 года назад

That was so beautiful I'm crying so much

@aviconv 3 года назад

You should talk about the movie "what dreams may come" it's truly amazing. Also I'm a new subscriber but I'm already loving the videos, keep up the good work.

@staliniumprojectile 3 года назад

I'm glad I can say that I have been here before you blew up.

@stratocaster334 3 года назад

Your videos are so beautiful and well articulated. I am so glad the algorithm brought me to your channel :)

@GirlinDungarees 3 года назад

I had not yet heard of this film, I will be watching it now! thanks

@Alexandra-dq9yz Год назад

You've done such a great job! Would love to see more of your videos

@ferrellcatdragon2017 3 года назад

Just found your channel and couldn't be happier. Great content!

@paigewang1066 3 года назад

god i love they way you write things really fascinating insights i wouldn’t have thought of you should look at black swan!! recently watched it and your perspective would be so cool!