LISK Affidavits Breakdown 

I’m watching this replay right now and heard that the cop boyfriend ended up finding his belt in the back of the car. Wondering if he was serviced by karen before they went to the defendants house? That might help fill in the blanks as to how/why they picked her up. Maybe the witness didn’t want to admit to picking up a prostitute for that reason. Also if her arrest was confirmed, was it THAT cop/detective that made the arrest and got her out ? So many questions. Going to watch the Ray interview replay after this. When you have the commissioner on I’d like for you to ask him if he thinks it’s possible if Shannon Gilbert could have just accidentally run up on Rex while he was dumping a body. Imo she sounded high and we know drugs can cause paranoia but at the same time…it’s all too coincidental and with the corruption out of that jurisdiction at the time, there’s no telling what went on. Could iames burk and Rex have known eachother from trapeze or elsewhere? You’d think by now at the very least disgruntled arrestees or arrestees trying to cut a deal would have spilled the beans. Lastly- that press conference was more than odd, the commissioners face said it all. I don’t think he subscribed to the conviction in which John Ray was conveying about the information. Furthermore, I don’t think he liked John Ray constantly saying he was working “with” them and interviewed a witness “with them”. Ask him if and how that transpired please. Seems like a conflict to have a victims attorney interview a witness WITH detectives. Hope it was recorded. John Ray is so vested in this that I worry he may lead witnesses without realizing it. Credit where it’s due though, he kept the case alive!

the task force should look into a swingers club called the manor. I had friends from queens (border of Long Island part) and also friends from sayville that used to go there. Actually that couple owned a bachelor party service (dancers- all online booking and calls-not escorts) but it’s a small world with the weird sex community, back then at least. Like I said in another comment, I worked at captree park (the marina- ocean parkway is literally right there) I’ve traveled that road many times at all hours and so I have a bit of a personal interest in the case. I don’t know if that “club” is still around but i think i was first invited in like 2000 maybe? Maybe even 99 because I remember people bugging out about the y2k crap. I never took anyone up on the offer. Im not into that stuff plus I was really young back then and these were married friends that were many years older than me, but to each their own ya know. My friends from queens actually moved out to Suffolk and they started going there less, or at least talking about it less so I’m guessing it may have been on or closer to the south shore/nassau, Not sure if it was some underground thing or an actual place or if it’s even still around but it might be worth looking into. Who knows, maybe the owners/employees might know something. I’m guessing that seen was much more intimate and smaller back then and everyone probably knew everyone.

... watched all videos and all are very interesting! Looking forward of the next John Ray too! Thanks

@@user-my3wb8qb1c great. Thank you. That will be tonight at 7PM EDT or you can always catch the replay

Yes, it’s getting to be quite the rabbit hole

Thanks Terry! I’m glad you found it helpful.

I dol agree. People love John Ray he is dedicated and never gives up. He is very intelligent and without him and Shannon this would not have been solved. He should be praised by lawinforcement.

Truth!❤

My pleasure. Thanks for taking the time to watch.

Thanks Cheryl!

Thanks Jay!

Thanks Sinead! Replay team is just as awesome as the live team!

The affidavits? I have copies - send me a DM on twitter with your email and I’ll forward them to you

You’re friggin’ AWESOME 🤩

That Belt found had HW on it (or MH) if RW thought he lost his belt but found it in backseat of their car how many other people who attended the Huermann House of Horrors left their belts behind⁉️

@@CrimeSpies i think we only know the half of it

I agree ‼️ I’ve been thinking about this all night. I’m watching this video a 2nd time you did such a great job on it 🤩

Thanks Theresa!

@JosephGiacalone too funny! Those who grew up in the NE don't need closed caption it's the accent 😄

Thanks Rebecca. You won’t be disappointed!

Thanks Julie!

Yes, I agree!

Yes, it looks like someone forgot that!

Awesome, thanks for taking the time to spend with me

Me too! Thank you so much for watching!

Hi Lisa, this is awesome, yes, I don’t anything was said or shown that they didn’t want to be known. If this story proves to be accurate, RW is in trouble, especially if he is still working - which I doubt. It’s not going to be hard for the investigation to ID him.

I love the replay team and cats!

That’s been a longtime rumor that rears its ugly head. At this time, the current case has no evidence of that as well as we know

It’s going to get more interesting

Agree and this may not be the first time they cooperated. I belive Burke may have been to a swingerparty at Rex home to.

@@MsAsjak well, that wouldn’t surprise me

A lot of people feel the same way. We just need to be more patient and let the investigation take its course. If she is involved anyway, they will do something.

I’ve seen a lot of strange things over my career that makes you scratch your head

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge my late brother was a Glasgow cop 👮‍♀️ for 35 years, so, I can understand you lol

She was a present like bringing your host a bottle of wine.

Thanks for the tip - do you have a street for O’Briens or a town? I’m unfamiliar with the area

It's on Johnson ave and Ocean ave in Ronkonkoma and it is the closest Bar I know that is close to the Long Island expressway. I"m from Ronkonkama I lived on Erie street in Ronkonkama. It is the only one I can think of.@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge

I also believe Asa was abused. I belive she either knew or had suspicions that Rex murdered the woman, but I believe she was terrified of him.

@@MsAsjak certainly understandable

Thank you Giorgismama! It’s nice to meet you too!

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSargeI’m enjoying your channel, tuning in from New Zealand 🇳🇿 New subscriber 👍👍

@@heatherstephens9295 wow, thank you!

Yes, I will look into that and it could be an important factor. Thanks for the push!

Thanks Lisa!

Thanks Shannon. The story about Karen Vergota is disturbing on so many levels. We’ll have to wait and see.

Thanks tback!

Things are getting interesting Rene

Thanks, yes, some questionable comments in there - I have a FB page as well if you are interested. Thanks for your support!

Yes and there is a lot more coming soon IMO

Thank you Buster for spending your time with me

Thanks Buster for spending your time with me

He’ll be back on with me on Friday. Leave that comment and I’ll post it

Had it all

James Burke is the gift that keeps on giving

Thanks Michele!

Watch this Friday, 7PM, John Ray is returning to the show.

Thank you!

There are some major parts of that story missing and I’m sure they are working on that - huge break if it’s all true

Thank you Ms. In today’s show, PC Harrison discussed Shannan’s case

​@@TrueCrimeWithTheSargeYes I listen and was nervous but so relieved he said 1000 % that he could change his opinion. I trust him he is genuin.

@@MsAsjak awesome! Yes, he is. He has a lot on his plate ATM

A lot more than that

Yes, there are. I think we’ll hear soon about Maureen Brainard-Barnes

I meant DA

Anything in particular? He is doing the case himself, which doesn’t happen too often

I think it had WH on it but I could be mistaken. There was some thinking the initials are Rex grandfather's. Not sure if that is confirmed.

@@normajeandoyle No you’re right, ☀️shine 🌻

WH is correct.

Thanks, the replay crew is awesome!

Thanks Norma. It’s a very disturbing development

Hi Norma, it could have played out that way. Both the PC and John Ray say he’s identified and been spoken too.

We don’t know yet for sure - one belt was also cut short - maybe removing the initials.

I speak the Kings County English!

Interaction and comments are what makes this social media!

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge I know but on most crime channels the trolls 🧌 or grammar police ppl always carrying on , I’m a free speaker & my mind is always non stop . In real world 🌍 nobody would dare speak me some of the ways on here , I’m always multi tasking & make some mistakes lol I’m Irish ☘️ blood 🩸 so I lose my temper & then they report me hahaha 🤣 cheers 🌻🎧🌻

​@@BellaFinn I think we are in the right place! Seems to be a respectful intelligent community so far. ❤

@@normajeandoyle 🌸🫶🌸So true I love the way they are so respectful of each other , & just allowing John Ray just explain all the fact of this sad case , its people inciting him by calling him a lair & other insults that’s why look in these interviews his getting everything out in a way that his relaxed & comfortable & his got the real story, can you imagine now certain people truly scared . That’s why people trying to make out his insane & he gets upset 🌸🌼🌸

@@BellaFinn Same and I love hearing what everyone has to say! The more eyes on this the better. I think Rex has been a busy boy and the victims deserve justice and the families some truth.

Thanks Sarah!

See anyone you know?

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge haha:)

Thanks for watching Annette!

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge trying to get up to date with all the different crimes. Totally missed some updates. 😊🙏💙❤️ Stay safe and healthy Joe 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

@@annettemoolman6504 tomorrow morning, on my morning show, Roll Call, we’re doing updates on Long Island body parts, Madeline Soto, and Sebastian Rogers cases

@@TrueCrimeWithTheSarge wonderful! Looking forward to new updates. All the ongoing cases! Wow that will be great! Thank you so much Joe 💙❤️🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

I was never sure it was an accident. The ME certified the death as ‘Undetermined.’ Then it was up to the police to make their case. So far, they haven’t