LOBSTER TASTE TEST! How to Cook Lobster! Which one is the best?!?!?!? 

7:04 Ahhh, look at that smell. I also spend my years looking at smell, one of the true joys in life!

7:03 "Look at that smell" This got me weak

Have been going through some major health issues and you’re positive attitude and vibracious personality truly lifts me up. Thank you and God Bless!

7:04 “Look at that smell”

"In the manner of fairness I'm not doing anything super special to the tails" -- **proceeds to cook them totally differently** lmao

7:04 oh look at that smell. What ?😅

To get true results, they should have all been cooked and seasoned in the exact same way.

Thank you for testing with and without butter, because as all of you stated; the addition of butter really can change the overall experience. I personally like spiny lobster more, but to be fair I also really like grilling lobsters as opposed to boiling or steaming. As an additional note, I also enjoy top steaming the main body by using a heated skillet some butter and just liding the lobster body inside that, as I try not to waste anything and I especially love the head butter or tamale.

7:03 - "Oh, look at that smell."

Wouldn't of it been more of accurate test if you had cooked them all the same way?

definitely cold water/east coast lobster, they are SWEET and TENDER. Warm water spiny...is good. but I pick cold water over warm if I was given a choice.

The Maine lobster was sitting there like “Hmm I wonder why my cousins aren’t moving” and then 00:43

You should have cooked them all the same way

“Look at that smell” 😂 7:02

The live lobster died so dramaticly lol

Eats three different kinds of lobster while I sit in bed and eat Wendy’s

"For the taste test, which of these would you try first?" My answer, *Yes."

Hmmm seems like everyone agrees, they should all have been cooked the same (and also properly) .. also tomalley and roe are not the same thing. Roe are the eggs, tomalley is the "liver" - green/grey stuff in the head/torso area

I can't imange how much butter you go through in a year

Slipper lobsters are absolutely delicious so I'm glad you included them. I'm a big fan of Maine lobster with butter. But they're all good!

LOBSTER .... is just a fancy way to consume butter. :)

The blonde girl kept eating all the lobster at the end😂 it’s like save some for the other guys like Jerez.

“Look at that smell” Robert Arington 2k18

you know its fire when the cook says "Look at that smellll" XD

All the dislikes are lobsters Oh btw 0:44 R.I.P

For a taste test I think a clean steam for all would have been best

The best lobster is the one on the plate in front of you!

Sara over there eating it all while you’re taste testing 😂😂😂

Would’ve been good cook them all the same way to really test which one tasted best as far as the lobster itself. They all look so delicious though!!

Maine...gotta love that claw meat.

I think they all should’ve been cooked the same way to make it fair. Huge fan, I’ve been sick for the past couple days and your videos have been the only thing I’ve done, so thank you!

Who really wants lobster after watching this video😂

We always called the Slipper Lobster, "Bulldozers" and I agree not as good as the Maine or Spiny but not to bad at all marinated and cooked on a grill. I didn't care for them steamed or boiled though. Great video Rob & Sarah!

to make it fair they all should of ben cooked the same

I’m sitting here eating deer meat watching deer meat for dinner eat lobster lol

This video was not polished and over edited. That is what made this so enjoyable and fun to watch. Loved it!!! We are having lobster tonight for our 30th wedding anniversary. Looking forward to it!

I refuse to choose...Lobster is my favourite seafood PERIOD...Lobster and Butter?...Yes, PLEASE...YUM!

As a New Englander and a eater of lobster fairly regularly I would say that the claw meat is light years better than the tail. Great job on your content and family values!

"Look at that smell" lmao best sentence of all time. Btw that looks fire af.

Mad respect for naming one of your pets Tebow. Wish he could have worked out here in Denver, but I'll never forget that magical season where he was unstoppable in the 4th quarter, and snuck us into the playoffs only to upset the Steelers.

Ahhhh look at that smell Ummm.... I can’t even talk anymore 😂🤔

“Look at that smell.”

I like how Sara keeps on eating throughout the video. It shows how delicious it is.

i bought shrimp off a shrimp boat the other day and he gave me a slipper lobster. I was so blown away HOW INCREDIBLE the slipper taste

Sometimes i hate watching your videos because... The food looks so good

hi Rob good evening glad to be here nice to part of the channel , good evening Sarah Aria and Emma Jean, always a pleasure seeing you in the kitchen great things are created in the deer meat for dinner 's kitchen. till the next video have a wonderful evening with the family Rob. enjoyed as usual 👋 bye. 🐟🐟🐠🐡🐬🍴. The tail and the claw..

I personally like the Maine lobster. Of the three I would rate them as follows: 1) Maine Lobster 2) Spiny Lobster 3) Slipper Lobster

The claws are always the best. Nothing beats New England lobster 🦞

"Easy for me, not easy for him" hahaha lol

Come on man! All lobsters are awesome! Love the vid... Keep it up bud!

Ok, being from New England I'm partial to Maine lobster. I would say that all the lobster would need to be cooked in the same fashion to be a true equal competition. LOL I have grown to love Spiney Lobster over the 32+ years of living in Florida. Here is one of my ways of cooking Spiney Lobster that you might enjoy. I cut them in half like you do and then pull the meat out of the shell towards the tail fins. Don't take the meat completely out. Brush some Extra-Virgin Olive Oil in the shell and all over the meat. Then add your Everglade Seasoning and put the meat back in the shell. Fire up the gas grill and put the lobster tails shell down, meat up for about 5-7 minutes. When the meat becomes opaque and is just about cooked, flip the meat down on the grill and put some grill marks on it and remove. I think you will enjoy it and you can add it to your recipe box. LOL We would love to get together with you guys when we come through your area. We're working on Cooking with the Count sharing America for this summer. God Bless and Great Job once again!

It's the lobsters having all that FUN IN THE SUN! THE SUNSHINE STATE ALLLLLLLL DAY

Kinda looks like Sarah keeps going back for more Maine lobster 😄

Everyone else: Looks good and smells great! deermeatfordinner: Ugh, look at that smell 7:03

that woman is greedy

my favorite is the Maine lobster

6 people missed the like button Edit- they salty because they don’t have any Everglades lol

He done steamed that man to death RIP Larry

Try preparing them all the same way so you can get the actual flavor of the lobster opposed to the way of cooking

Very interesting how people say Maine Lobster taste like King Crab which is a bit like Snow Crab. While Slipper Lobster and Florida Spiny Lobster both taste like Giant Prawn Shrimp which is like Smaller shrimp

I really do think all of them are good but you requested we respond before your video finished, so overall I would think the Florida/Spiny lobster has a slightly better flavor. My experience is that Slipper Lobster is good like a shrimp flavor, Maine lobster is next better with a milder and clean taste to it, and Florida/Spiny lobster is overall best because it just has better flavor to it. But then later I noticed you entered butter into the equation, that changes the overall flavor of everything but it's FOR THE BETTER. Each one still flows in the progressing order that I wrote earlier...now look what you started - it's time for the blue crab, snow crab, stone crab challenge :-) :-) :-)

For the test to be fair... 1. First & foremost, you must prepare them all the same way. You did not. 2. They should all be “fresh caught”. The Florida & Slipper we’re caught the previous day. The Main lobster was purchased at a Publix Super Market in Florida, which means it was caught at least 1 week ago or up to 3 weeks ago. That’s not “fresh caught” & will greatly affect the taste.

Another great video Rob. I was fishing with one of our many common friends this weekend, Scott Donovan, whom we've been fishing in tournaments and on charters with for nearly 3 years, and I know you fished with him for many more years...and we got to talking about you and he was confirming what I've always thought and what others have said...that you're a good guy, know what your'e doing, and great at making these videos. We agree. Anyways, from one local to another, we wish you continued success. I imagine you know where to find me if you ever wanted to collab. Thank you.

We have the “Florida” lobsters here in the Virgin Islands, I think they call them spiny lobsters here though

ROB just to let you know there is a channel named “Annytta Escobar” stealing your content like so rob can see

Rob you have to steam New England Lobster live. Then steam them in Beer!

Why do I find this stuff so satisfying

I loved seeing that Sarah kept coming back for more!!

Rob, I'm coming down to Florida this summer for a family event and I was wondering if we could go fishing? I have watched you since Fresh Fish for dinner and I have never had fresh fish

You can’t compare Maine lobster from a supermarket. You have to come up here and get it fresh off the docks. I won’t even buy it from the supermarkets in Maine lol 😂

To me the best way to do a taste test is to have someone that has never had lobster before. Dont tell them what kind it is and have them try all 3. I've never had lobster or crab.

To be fair the “without butter” section isn’t really accurate since the Florida lobster was cooking in butter lol

If the Florida lobsters were alive like the Maine lobster, it would probably taste even better

“Easy for me, not easy for him” I died at that😂😂😂

Hands down Florida lobster with Maine being second all day long. Florida lobster has the flavor and texture no matter how you cook it

So you cherish your wife and children, feed and provide for them well, you are commendable man

Is it just me but I can hear really heavy breathing in this video

We are moving to Florida in the next 6 months and I’m soooo doing this challenge !!!!😋😋😋

Enjoyed the video, but was sad to see all the spices, wine, and butter to cook them. The real flavor was masked, try steaming them and let their natural goodness speak for themselves.

As a member of a lobster fishing family... You don't steam lobster, you don't kill it first, you also don't use wine or shaky seasoning, you either get a pot of ocean water, or you salt that water until it is salt water. Then boil them alive. All three should have been done this way. But interesting video.

Mainer here... Got to be voting for my state animal..Maine Lobsta....next time use a dark beer, lemon,onion and garlic w/ real fresh crusty Italy Bread...🍻👍🍷😜‼️👌

Awesome, this is a much needed video.

Im from the Bahamas and spiny lobsters the best 💯

In my travels I have had all three lobsters cooked just about every way, with grilled being my favorite. When simply seasoned and grilled over charcoal Maine Lobster is by far and a away the best. Your comment in regards freshness is key. I would rather have the Florida Lobster fresh than the Maine Lobster from Publix. It may have been a “live” lobster from Publix but it didn’t appear to be very lively.

6:01 "We'll just take skin side down"

Does a lobster have sharp talons?

I just prefer cold-water lobster to those caught in warm waters.

I legit started drooling watching this 😂🤤 now I'm hungry.

Being from Maine and eating lobster all my life I cringed watching rob clean that lobster it’s so much easier than he made it look

No fair.. the Florida lobster was cooked in butter and spices.

*heavy breathing*

watching you eat lobter constantly is awesome

Yo bro I’m a massive fan keep the great vids up 🔥

7:22 😂 hard to choose man they all look good🤷🏼‍♂️

I'm pissed! Why does your Publix still have a live lobster tank? None of them in my area do!

Brother!...thank you so much for your publications!....always a pleasure to watch them!

7:05 Haha!!! “Look at that smell...”??? DEEP!!!

btw, on a Maine Lobster, the claw and tail taste soo different...

Can you do a video grilling lobster and crab?

Just the knuckles on the Maine lobster will sell anyone. You not only need to cook them all the same but understand each part of the Maine lobster has different flavors.