Тёмный
No video :(

LOW-BUCK, AUTO PART STORE OIL VS VS HIGH $ SYNTHETIC! 0W-10 VS 20W-50. POWER FROM AN OIL CHANGE? 

Richard Holdener
Подписаться 301 тыс.
Просмотров 34 тыс.
50% 1

DOES HIGH-DOLLAR SYNTHETIC OIL MAKE POWER? DOES THE CHEAP, NON-SYNTHETIC OIL REALLY WORK JUST AS GOOD? SHOULD I BUY SYNTHETIC OIL? ON-SALE OIL VS SNAKE OIL? LIGHT-WEIGHT OIL VS THE THICK STUFF! CAN YOU GET MORE POWER FROM AN OIL CHANGE? CHECK OUT THIS VIDEO WHERE I COMPARED CHEAP, AUTO ZONE (STP) NON-SYNTHETIC OIL (USUALLY ON SALE) AGAINST A HIGH-DOLLAR (LUCAS) SYNTHETIC OIL. WHICH ONE MAKES MORE POWER? I ALSO COMPARED 0W-10 WEIGHT SYNTHETIC VS 20W-50 SYNTHETIC OIL! THERE WAS DEFINITELY A DIFFERENCE!

Опубликовано:

 

21 дек 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 281   
@GTStuning-
@GTStuning- Год назад
You're the man Rich, thanks for doing all the tests we have wondered about for ages.
@jamesgeorge4874
@jamesgeorge4874 Год назад
You do a great job of back to back parts and method testing, Richard, not enough people realize the effort involved. Best holiday wishes, my knowledgeable freind, looking forward to the next one, cheers !
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
thnx
@ldnwholesale8552
@ldnwholesale8552 Год назад
30 years ago I started using Synthetic. Mobil 1 25/50 In race engines. Previously I had been using Pennzoil 25/50 mineral race oil. This was an existing engine that was rebuilt. Dry sumped 350 Chev. Initially the engine had too much oil psi and I had to put a softer pressure relief spring in the pump. Meaning less power to turn the pump. That engine did 2200 race km [over several years] changing the oil usually twice a year,, eg 4 meetings. When stripped for a rebuild the bearings were near new, roller cam was still perfect. With the Pennzoil, which I consider to be the best mineral oil around I changed it every second meeting and the bearings came out serviceable but scuffed. Mobil1 had 20deg C less oil temp as well. THOUGH, those very thin oils will NOT holdup in high rpm, high compression engines. They are for cold weather street car engines. I did go down to 15/40 with no difference. Synthetic gear oils too are far better. And OEM in many high performance drivelines. Manual gearboxes change better, stay cooler, as do diffs also. With mineral oils sychro cones flattened more often and second gear lasted longer. I used to use vegetable oil LSD oil in my racecar with the over rated 9", it worked but god did it stink!! And burnt badly. Went to synthetic and no more stink and a longer life as well. I changed diff oil regularly with the centre for different tracks.
@thewyattfletcher
@thewyattfletcher Год назад
Great test. This seems so straight forward until you consider the full range of purposes that oil serves. For example, if your bearing clearances or rings are a bit loose, the heavier weight might be preferable even with an associated power loss. Or vice versa with overly tight bearing clearances. Another consideration might be the heat the oil may be exposed, such as in turbo applications. And as you so rightly pointed out, oil pressure itself has to be a consideration, both in terms of getting too low or too high. So yeah, maybe that 0w-10 makes more hp, but I suspect I'd prefer something heavier in my street cars for longevity sake alone.
@SoulTouchMusic93
@SoulTouchMusic93 Год назад
Can confirm. My clapped out crap tends to clunk less with good oil and also enough oil in the sump.
@michaelblacktree
@michaelblacktree Год назад
For me, oil viscosity is dictated more by oil pressure (both cold and hot) than anything else. And as mentioned above, that's usually a result of the engine's bearing clearances. For example, I had one engine with tight tolerances, and had to run 0w20 to keep the oil pressure below 100 psi. I've had other engines that needed 10w50 to prevent low oil pressure when hot.
@MrTheHillfolk
@MrTheHillfolk Год назад
Heh, crazy thought ,but what if a couple quarts were changed with some diesel fuel? I wonder if wear would go up too much to see any power increase because of major friction, or would it be worth a few ponies (there's still gonna be some heavy wear going on)
@batman607
@batman607 Год назад
In 1986 I ran a stock 400 sbc with Slick 50 in the oil in a Camaro , ran a 100 lap endurance race , took engine apart and the Teflon in the oil welded itself to all the bearings with little white spots making clearance all around. Yea, I won the $5,000.00 purse. 🤠
@DarkLinkAD
@DarkLinkAD Год назад
Thats best case scenario, worse case scenario, it stops up your oil pump. Happens sometimes, I say only use when you absolutely need it.
@hiperformance71
@hiperformance71 Год назад
This is an excellent comparison, In the workshop were I collaborate, we have had a Renault Clio RS race engine with dry sump oil system with low oil pressure at idle when the motor was very hot, we then chose a tick racing oil (Bardahl I think), the problem was solved, the oil pressure was huge up, the workhop owner have to review the pressure relief valve of the oil pump to reduce the risk of explode the oil filter (over 150 psi oil cold in little accelleration, and about 100psi with oil hot), I do not remember the difference in power but for sure, some losses were expected (the motor was still on ECU mapping and general tuning process). Chears from Italy my friend, an keep the Good work!!
@jeffbonifield8981
@jeffbonifield8981 Год назад
Bearing clearances vs, or tailored to oil viscosity? New episode topic!
@markcole6475
@markcole6475 Год назад
Thinner oils are easier for the oil pump to circulate through the engine! I’ve seen lots of guys at the drag strip running thick oils and have all sorts of engine issues from oiling problems! Not sure if they are letting the engine oil warm up before making passes or it’s just too much windage drag and causes damage? I’ve always run 10w-30 in all my race engines…staying in the 7000 rpm or under! I typically run a stock pump and bump up the relief spring pressure 10 psi or so! Never had a bearing failure but did crack a couple blocks! 0w weight oils are designed for newer tighter tolerance engines and probably won’t work well with anything older that has bearing clearance in the .003 range!
@connor3288
@connor3288 Год назад
Well the W number only matters for cold temperature starting/oil flow. You could run a 0w40 and a 10w40, at aprx. 100C/210F oil temp they will both work as a 40 grade if oil is in good condition. In the case of people running stone-cold engines on the drag strip, that has to be terrible for engine wear and life. I recall an engine test where they showed that a lower temp t-stat makes more power. But running a stone-cold engine hard is totally different, think of the piston to wall clearance when cold, and also the extra valve clearance, kinda abusive to the valvetrain to spin high rpm like that. I do know some of the drag guys making big power run filled or partially filled blocks for added strength, which would be a factor. I think many people forget about oil operating temp too, it is important in selecting an oil. All other things being equal, a drag engine should use a thinner oil than say, a endurance race engine or powerboat race engine, because the oil temp will probably never get as high, only running hard for a few seconds. I have heard the same with ring gap from a uti instructor/engine builder years ago, where an endurance/boat engine may need for gap due to sustained high temps. He also talked about how a thrown together turbo engine with insufficient ring gap may survive on the drag strip, but could blow up on the street or racetrack, because on the drag strip it may not run hard long enough to bind the ring gaps.
@queonda3086
@queonda3086 Год назад
I follow you since your channel was small like 7k subs your still definitely under rated no one does informational videos like you!
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
I appreciate that!
@chestrockwell8328
@chestrockwell8328 Год назад
Pressure is resistance to flow. An engine needs proper volume/flow of oil in the areas that need the oil for lubrication and cooling. Higher oil pressure readings are not the best way to know if the volume of flow is where it needs to be, pressure readings only tell you that the oil pump is moving liquid against a restriction. Same when discussing boost pressure. A less restrictive air pathway will produce more more power on less pressure.
@justinfargas2367
@justinfargas2367 Год назад
Thanks mate. Shout out from Australia.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
aussie, aussie, aussie
@sstevocamaro
@sstevocamaro Год назад
The test I’ve been waiting for 👍🏾
@andrewbecker3700
@andrewbecker3700 Год назад
I've been running 10w40 as it's a happy medium that offers better protection than most other multi viscosity oils for fuel injected vehicles. Anything much thicker isn't gonna be optimum in cold climates. One of my main concerns is when high milage engines get off the highway and then sit in idle traffic for long durations. I tend to shift into neutral to take the load off the engine.
@The_R-n-I_Guy
@The_R-n-I_Guy Год назад
I'd like to see some more LT1 stuff. 2nd gen small blocks don't get any attention. My 1996 Buick Roadmaster sedan needs some low buck power
@mindblownwatcher8536
@mindblownwatcher8536 Год назад
Change your rear gear ratio first. 3.42 or 3.55’s will feel like you added 100 hp.
@mewrongway
@mewrongway Год назад
1:40 Oil running sideways, Pretty slick trick Richard!!
@ChurchAutoTest
@ChurchAutoTest Год назад
Good stuff Rich. You ever done a test with overfilled oil sump? Gave one of my guys 6 quarts of oil to do a change on my LS. He didn't bother to check how much it took and just poured all 6 in. Put the car back on the dyno and lost 30-40 hp above 5000 rpm on a 900 whp setup. Figured it wasn't actually touching the crank but at high rpms there was enough additional windage to screw things up. Pulled out a half quart and the power came right back. Obviously on the street this might be different (g-forces), but its the first time I'd ever dyno'd a car with too much oil in the pan (that I knew of).
@drewmurray2583
@drewmurray2583 Год назад
I remember seeing that test done. David freiburger maybe
@howellbranham9460
@howellbranham9460 Год назад
engine masters full episode on that
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
too much oil decreases both power and oil control
@SoulTouchMusic93
@SoulTouchMusic93 Год назад
@@richardholdener1727 people at engine masters tested it. The more you have in the pan the lower the horsepower. Also as far as I know too much oil can foam it up and you lose pressure.
@will7its
@will7its Год назад
Its like an horizontal oil tornado in there.....
@Sleeperdude
@Sleeperdude Год назад
Good information thanks for sharing
@ng6424
@ng6424 Год назад
Heard a few years ago Gibbs oil helped max hp from someone I knew in the nascar industry that tested?!? IDK?? Love your testing Richard
@terrydolbow4299
@terrydolbow4299 Год назад
No I would not use lit wight oil in my street car because it cost to much to fix it and oil is a cheaper than engine parts! Thanks for the video and have a safe and happy holidays!
@drewmurray2583
@drewmurray2583 Год назад
I came across 2 60L barrels of Castrol Edge 0w20 and I was right skeptical about using it in my Audi 4.2 V8 or 5.4 2v super duty, however I immediately noticed a difference in how the engine starts. The thinner oil is easier to pump and moves through the engine faster I figure. I also ran it in my L76 swapped bmw and it would see no less than 40 psi of oil pressure when full hot after a good drive 100C
@zac2384
@zac2384 Год назад
how do you come across 2 60L barrels of oil lol
@MonzaRacer
@MonzaRacer Год назад
You run that thin of oil in a Ford 5.4 and you'll not like results with timing chain
@paulg444
@paulg444 Год назад
@@MonzaRacer ... and when the engine loses compression on a cylinder and dies prematurely you will know for sure it was due to 0w20 weight oil. These light oils serve no real purpose, they only serve to help the manufacturer lower his CAFE average and keep the engine off the road after 200k miles.
@therandomrobert1842
@therandomrobert1842 Год назад
@@paulg444 From what I’ve heard 0 20 is great for na 4 cylinders but for a turbo v8 I’m not sure with the hotter temps
@oneninerniner3427
@oneninerniner3427 Год назад
It depends on the oils film strength. Just because it's a light or lighter viscosity doesn't "necessarily" mean it's film strength is not adequate. The big time race teams use a light viscosity for qualifying, then switch to a somewhat heavier viscosity for the race. Heck the new Toyota's are calling for 0W16 and Honda & GM are calling for 0W20. I've heard it said that heavier oils create more heat at the bearings as it kinda like piles up in front of the bearings. I've been using 5w30 premium synthetics in my ford's that call for 5W20 with good results and they all have lots of miles on them and still start really nice in our extreme cold winters too. I use 10W30 premium synthetic in my pickup because it's over a quarter million miles and that works well there too. But I wouldn't use anything heavier than probably 5 or 10W30 in anything built in the last thirty ish years, unless it's really worn out. Street use, everyday drivers I'm talking here. If it's a hot rod, race engine then go by bearing clearances n stuff for adequate oil pressure I think.
@ericschumacher5189
@ericschumacher5189 Год назад
Have you see all the oil analysis stuff on Lake Speed Jr’s YT channel……it pretty interesting that he mentions in a video that it takes about 2-oil changes before the additive package from the previous oil is out of the engine, and you see the full characteristics (for wear at least) that the new oil would provide, only for oil analysis after that point.
@3800S1
@3800S1 Год назад
I run a full syn 10W50 in my Buick 3.8, stock specs for our Aus climate is 20W50 mineral. I really wanted a 10W40 in my brand but over the years their oils have widen the cold and hot ranges. On my nephews Buick-ota 4runner, the oil pressure is about 40 psi idle hot, about 60 cold. Full noise hot it's around 60psi and 80 cold. That's with 20W50 as specified by Holden.
@coboscustoms4342
@coboscustoms4342 Год назад
Excellent video, it covered many of my curiosities that I've had over the last couple decades.
@michaelwhite7568
@michaelwhite7568 Год назад
Aside from reaĺly worn engines, i try to keep a quality oil in the recommended viscosity in my daily. Now our roll back, it has around 400k on a 454 and 20w-50 is our sole hope of keeping the pil pressure up lol
@masoncampos7043
@masoncampos7043 Год назад
Had a 92 Dakota 5.2. VR1 20W50 was the only thing that wouldn't burn and kept it going strong with good oil pressure! 🤣
@michaelwhite7568
@michaelwhite7568 Год назад
@masoncampos7043 loĺ my 2.2 only sipped 10w-40 but 5w-30 made for 7 mile forced oil changes lol
@srirachasauce8430
@srirachasauce8430 Год назад
@@michaelwhite7568 my 2.5 chrysler turbo uses up 5w-40 rotella t6 within 2000 miles. I drive her hard tho
@michaelwhite7568
@michaelwhite7568 Год назад
@srirachasauce8430 turbo and nitrous miles live in a seperate time frame. 2000 is really great... unless you say Freightliner or Peterbuilt. Lol then it's time for an inframe
@nitro1271
@nitro1271 Год назад
I have an old 06 Chevy Silverado with a 4.8, I run Walmart super tech full synthetic oil engine has been up to 7200 RPMs no problem, on dyno
@unleavenedkaraiteplus3412
@unleavenedkaraiteplus3412 Год назад
That engine is loving all those oil changes
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
OIL BATH EACH TIME
@CarsandCats
@CarsandCats Год назад
I haven't ran 20w50 since the 80's. I remember it being recommended for imports which always struck me as odd that tiny motors would want a thicker oil? Now I run the CHEAPEST 15w40 diesel oil I can find. No failures of any kind even in blown gas combinations. When people ask me what oil I run I always say, "Clean!" Because a clean cheap oil is far better than a dirty expensive one.
@DarkLinkAD
@DarkLinkAD Год назад
When the Shelby Cobra GT 500 was released in America for the first time, it called for some low visc oil, meanwhile over seas, the same engine called for 20w50 IIRC.
@CarsandCats
@CarsandCats Год назад
@@DarkLinkAD It was 5W50 full synthetic. I know because I worked for Ford.
@BruceLee-xn3nn
@BruceLee-xn3nn Год назад
Changes to oil weight or conventional to synthetic makes big changes in performance and cold starting on 7.3 powerstroke diesel. Their injectors are oil actuated.
@richardmoerke9329
@richardmoerke9329 Год назад
Wow!!! That’s a lot! Big change in oil pressure. I guess the big thing is how big are your balls! I mean at the stop light 95 outside been on the road for 2 hours you have 11 to 1 piston’s good 0.500 inch plus cam ,your bearing clearance is a good 2000s. I don’t think it’s going to live with the 0 10 . At the light I would think your oil light would be going crazy! I would love to see you test this!!! That’s why I run a 10 40 . I hope you do a test like that. Load a motor up like at a light and see what happens. My new car gets 0. 16! I am craping my pants! Love to see more. Marry Xmas!
@D2O2
@D2O2 Год назад
The engine made the same power, but you had more net available at the crank due to less power consumed by the oil pump, so less parasitic loss. There is also some loss at the bearings due to film shear as a function pressure, but the bulk of the loss is pumping.
@jimgee2676
@jimgee2676 Год назад
wow i love these videos .....i have a stock 1970 318 2bbl do i really need to use high zinc oil since the cam was broken in 50 years ago ?
@johnsricke7236
@johnsricke7236 Год назад
I have a 77 vette 383 rpm heads , comp 282s , running a z28 pump annd moroso 6 quart pan , the builder told me to run the thickness oil in it . I’ve been using valvoline 20w50 racing in it for the last 17 years and have never had a issue and my valve lash rarely changes . Can’t make anyone power when your tires are smoken , someone once told me .
@jimgee2676
@jimgee2676 Год назад
the oil you took out of motor looked exactly like my morning coffee :)
@TheDynotuner
@TheDynotuner Год назад
It takes more than 1 single oil change to "wash" off the old company's additive pack off the metals they have coated. So you can't see the actual benefits instantly. Which is easily proven by doing UOA's. As the additives coat the metal & cling to them. Not just stay suspended in the oil film
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
and yet the power changed with 1 il change
@TheDynotuner
@TheDynotuner Год назад
@richardholdener1727 On the synthetic versus conventional is where you'll never see a change in a single change due to the film that clung to the various metals by the previous additive pack. But as you showed there's surely power to be gained with the thinner oil. You'll also usually see a great oil temp change which is what most use now to determine correct oil weight
@Erichhh
@Erichhh Год назад
Pressure is created by resistance to flow. So the higher pressure created by a thicker oil is because of the reduced flowrate from the higher viscosity. The bearings will always run cooler with a thinner oil. The bearings will make their own oil pressure, even with no pressurized oil supply (Briggs&Stratton single cylinder engines do this) - via hydrodynamic film pressure generation. The oil pressure just serves to increase the flowrate through the bearing, and decreases its "residence time" in the bearing.
@britdragster
@britdragster Год назад
Surely, the application is as relevant as how much power you can make, especially in a boosted application where film strength in the areas which see the most pressure, like the big end and main bearings.
@gloriamaletta8667
@gloriamaletta8667 Год назад
Higher viscosity = slightly less power most people when picking a oil are wanting the best protection against engine wear and most car engines today will not benefit from a higher viscosity oil unless it's a race engine running higher rpm for extended periods of time like road racing l use 5w-30 in all my cars and that includes a 5th Gen Camaro with a modified LS3 that does see occasional eighth or quarter mile drag racing l use Valvoline high mileage full synthetic in my 2009 5.3 PPV 2wdTahoe and 2004 Buick LeSabre 3800 and Driven LS30 in my 2011 modified LS3 Camaro SS and so far don't have a complaint the Tahoe and LeSabre get it changed every 3000 miles or slightly less every 6 months the Camaro every 500-700 miles or every 6 months and l use Wix XP oil filters on all of them
@strokerta1986
@strokerta1986 Год назад
10 psi per 1000 rpm is perfectly fine for oil pressure... You want the thinnest oil you can run while hitting that target. Oil additive packages is what dictates the oils wear properties.
@gusgiesel
@gusgiesel Год назад
The first oil drain is not ugly, you can *easily* see through it on the filter removal. Can easily be reused.
@Cultofpersonality09129
@Cultofpersonality09129 Год назад
Tighter bearing clearances and or oil pump mods will fix the idle op issue. 68-70 psi at wot is plenty.
@Prestiged_peck
@Prestiged_peck Год назад
I'm gonna go with 5w-20 on the break-in on my mustang because that's what it ships with, and then after break-in ilm change viscosity accordingly to achieve at least 6lbs of hot idle oil pressure.
@TomSmith-cv8hk
@TomSmith-cv8hk Год назад
A pressure regulator back to the sump from an oil gallery would have made that interesting, the internal reg' obviously isn't setup to deal with the heavier oil.
@tchapps88
@tchapps88 Год назад
Supprised that salad bowl hasnt already been converted into an air cleaner 😂
@robertappleyard7053
@robertappleyard7053 Год назад
We’re going to need all these tests done again, on a LG4 305 preferably. Thanks, from the third gen contingent.
@turbo_sentra6467
@turbo_sentra6467 Год назад
I'm running 15-40 so let's find out
@StephenGiovi
@StephenGiovi Год назад
I've been told that if I wore to use 5w-30 oil in my 5.7 2014 HEMI, this would solve the issues with smaller oil galleries, vs the bigger the passages, the higher the weight of the oil should be. These engines have become, as you know, high tech, and solving the issues with viscosity is an issue. Where I'm headed with all this is that the weight of the oil is slower moving and may be the big reason for lower weight and viscosity oils. I hope you catch my drift!
@Resistculturaldecline
@Resistculturaldecline 7 месяцев назад
In a positive displacement pump, the same volume of oil is moving, regardless of viscosity. Assuming the oil isn't cold and thick, causing the pump to bypass bleed oil back into the sump before ever going to the filter. There are happy mediums. Many guys judge oil by the most oil pressure, as higher viscosity causing more pressure -- all things being equal. But, higher pressure can actually mean restriction. There is a happy spot between hydrodynamic wedge being sufficient, and too much restriction. 5w30 is probably excellent for your summer oil change, and 5w30 winter. If you're an easy driver, don't hammer is much, or tow very heavily ever, a quality 5w20 is fine too. Hard to go wrong in that range, provided it's changed 5k miles or less. Guy I work with has a 2010ish dodge with the small v8. He's used 5w20 non-synthetic since new and has almost 300k miles on it. Even though those two oils are 5W, they fall in different ranges of that allowance. 5w20 does flow a little bit better in cold than 5w30.
@bryanhallman8183
@bryanhallman8183 Год назад
The only time I use a 0w oil is when the factory says to use it.
@sinistersilverado965
@sinistersilverado965 Год назад
5w-30 in my 6 liter LS. 0w-40 in my 6.1 Hemi. and 20w-50 in my Harley, and my 350 Chevy
@anthonyrowland9072
@anthonyrowland9072 Год назад
conventional oils have came a long way since the 90s when synthetic oils hit. synthetics can last longer and deal with temperature conditions better but wear is basically the same if you use a half way quality conventional
@bryanhallman8183
@bryanhallman8183 Год назад
I prefer Mobil 1 oil filters, but Wix are also surprisingly good.
@MrEntTv
@MrEntTv Год назад
M1 oil filters are too restrictive.
@bryanhallman8183
@bryanhallman8183 Год назад
@@MrEntTv Never had a problem with them.
@MrEntTv
@MrEntTv Год назад
You just haven't checked your oil pressure. I gained 15psi from M1 to AC Delco filter with no change in oil weight on an L92 V8. M1 oil is alright though.
@tolbertgraves2064
@tolbertgraves2064 Год назад
I run 0w-40 instead of 0w-20 or 5w-30... I think I have good lubrication whatever the temperature of the motor oil... You should check out the difference is... I would run 0w-50, but it's so expensive...
@eliasmelendez1271
@eliasmelendez1271 Год назад
I personally would use the 0w10 if my bearing clearance was alot tighter so the oil pressure at idle is roughly 15-20psi.
@HioSSilver1999
@HioSSilver1999 Год назад
Try a crank scraper test!
@CLEEPER1
@CLEEPER1 Год назад
I just did one on my 6.0, can't be mad at the results. Especially 534 ft lbs of tq
@HioSSilver1999
@HioSSilver1999 Год назад
@@CLEEPER1 i put one on my ls6 too. I was just wanting to see results. What did you do to your 6.0 to get that tq?
@CLEEPER1
@CLEEPER1 Год назад
@@HioSSilver1999 11.35 compression, ls3 heads with valve job and bowl blending only, tight quench of .037,rod mod ls3 intake and a mild cam. 227/237_ .621/.604 113.5+4 , crank scraper ,
@HioSSilver1999
@HioSSilver1999 Год назад
@@CLEEPER1 probably all in that rod modded ported ls3 intake 😁🤣 How's life been on the Mississippi?
@CLEEPER1
@CLEEPER1 Год назад
@@HioSSilver1999 messaged you on signal
@RK48frazergasser
@RK48frazergasser Год назад
Hey Richard so I don't forget marry Christmas. I'm finally building my 1948 frazer gasser with a supercharged chevy 454 with a two bolt mains it's going to be more a play toy not a racer
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
should be fun
@GearlessChris
@GearlessChris Год назад
It looked like the 5w/30 and 0w/10 made the same power.
@engineguyeric682
@engineguyeric682 Год назад
Conveniently left that out to keep sponsors happy lol
@carolyntracytalbott5865
@carolyntracytalbott5865 Год назад
Ok the biggest thing to look at is, do you have a high volume oil pump. I repeat volume not pressure. Ok I put some washers behind the spring in my new factory oil pump and increased pressure with a stock oil pan and it worked great so I thought. Long story short I built the motor,had the valve guides knurled,new valves, big springs and cam. Dropped valve at 50 thousand miles. Heads where rebuilt by good head shop. Took heads back to them and said knurling short term fix,new guides long term so they were able to repair heads,and I got another block and built close to same build except I put a high volume oil pump with stock oil pan,NO GOOD! oh yeah I use 5w30 synthetic on the street, drive it daily. I'm at a light waiting for green and notice the oil light flickering. Check oil level and only below full. Put 7 qt pan with tube problem solved. Ok at 50+ thousand miles the bearings and cylinder walls with the synthetic looked new. When the valve dropped, I was at a stop sign and started to go, regular drive home from work. I reused everything bearing and rings in rebuild except a piston one ring set and block seals and gaskets. Remember I had the heads completely repaired and rebuilt. Got 80,000 miles on it, oil stays clean between oil changes. 95 f 150 5.0 mid 12s at the track. 5w30 full synthetic Pennzoil.
@DarkLinkAD
@DarkLinkAD Год назад
Even some bone stock vehicles ive driven, would make a noticeable vibration/noise at idle when only .5quart off. I can only imagine that compounded.
@davidanderson6706
@davidanderson6706 Год назад
And Yadda Yadda Yadda. Good Stuff!!!!!!!!
@mrelectron6220
@mrelectron6220 Год назад
Bottom line run the recommended weight oil for your motor. There is not much to gain by running lower weight oil. Most new motors run this light weight oil due to clearances and to gain a few % on mpg. An old motor running those low weight oils may not have enough of a oil film around the crank and piston bearings to prevent premature wear. To gain 5hp and shorten longevity of a motor makes no sense.
@pvdp2
@pvdp2 8 месяцев назад
20w50 for older engines and hot climates
@freyja4954
@freyja4954 Год назад
My brain did not realize that it was the dyno bellhousing. i'm like, man, somebody hacked that up to make it fit. Is most the hp gain from reduced force on the oil pump?
@shaneshane1379
@shaneshane1379 Год назад
Lightweight only if the need arises. Few extra ponies are only good if you need them for a good reason
@Odd_Redneck
@Odd_Redneck Год назад
tighter clearances. id run a 5w40 or 0w40. 50 on a street car seems a tad much cause u have to balance flow and psi.
@chevy383jt
@chevy383jt 6 месяцев назад
I freaked myself out on my first oil change on my fresh 5.3. It only had maybe an hour or two of run time on the first oil, because I ended up with a stuck injector. I forgot that I had put a bottle of break in lube that had tiny sparkly stuff in it. When I started draining the oil, I thought it was full of metal. I stuck a strong magnet in it, and it didn't pick anything up. Whew
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 6 месяцев назад
sparkly stuff in the break in lube?
@wdbressl
@wdbressl Год назад
If you really want to understand motor oil, I suggest you check out certified lubrication specialist Lake Speed Jr. Background includes working with NASCAR teams.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
I KNOW LAKE-HE IS GOOD PEOPLE AND IS VERY SHARP. THIS TEST WAS ONLY ABOUT POWER
@cmte.brazinazzo2061
@cmte.brazinazzo2061 5 месяцев назад
After 5k miles the 0w10 may get sheared down to 0w5. Dangerous!
@bcbloc02
@bcbloc02 Год назад
So what was your idle oil pressure with the 10w? It showed the engine wasn't running when you mentioned it being low.
@stevenshepherd1905
@stevenshepherd1905 Год назад
I have seen a lot of engines run fine with only 2 quarts of oil in the pan. So just how important is it?
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
2 quarts in an ls is getting pretty low
@jsmcortina
@jsmcortina Год назад
My LM7 has a shortened oil pan for ground clearance. With stock oil level (therefore reduced volume), I braked at the end of the 1/8th, the oil surged, light came on and wrecked the bearings.
@someinternetguy955
@someinternetguy955 Год назад
Thanks for testing, pretty much confirms what the old timers always said. Looking forward to the next video. Note: Please don't include the camera shake in the video! Thanks!
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
part of the fun-sensation of speed and chaos
@hotrod6919
@hotrod6919 3 месяца назад
And people think I'm nut's for bargain shop my oil at the Dollar store's lol. Has anyone ever tried using or testing if different viscosity or types of oil on a turbo setup with a standalone oiling system ? Just curious about using actual aircraft turbine oil? Maybe help with faster or easier spool on journal bearing turbo's
@PANTYEATR1
@PANTYEATR1 Год назад
If just put in what the factory service manual says. My 5.9L Magnum dude ran says 10w30. My Honda CBR says 10w40. My 97 Dodge neon says 5w30. I'm not sure what to run in my Ford racing crate 427 that's in my mustang, cause no recommendation was made for it. I think I'll run 10w30 in it, unless i get some professional opinions otherwise.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
the oil weight would be based on your combo of bearing clearances and pump
@PANTYEATR1
@PANTYEATR1 Год назад
@@richardholdener1727 I'm not sure what the bearing clearances are since the short block was machine and assembled by Ford Racing. I have a high volume, blueprinted oil pump from Precision oil pumps.
@wsbill14224
@wsbill14224 Год назад
Thin oil doesn't make more power. It loses less, and the lost power is due to pumping losses which are greater using thick oil.
@GTStuning-
@GTStuning- Год назад
-480-481 hp and 416 lb-ft trq with 5w30 oil -470 hp 410 lb-ft trq with 20w50 -481 hp 416 lb-ft trq with 0w-10 I'm guessing 5w40 would give 475 hp and 413 lb-ft of torque.
@supersportimpalass
@supersportimpalass Год назад
I guess it’s fine to put heavier oil in if it only has 10 psi at idle but there’s no good reason to run heavier oil on a street vehicle if it has decent idle pressure, you’re just making the motor less efficient and killing any mileage gains. MAYBE if you used it for towing but otherwise I don’t see any benefits if it’s good oil you’re using.
@anthonyanderson1479
@anthonyanderson1479 Год назад
Go for the middle 10w-30
@malamri424
@malamri424 Год назад
I didn't know 0w10 exists. You'd probably get some oil consumption with that.
@MrEntTv
@MrEntTv Год назад
Try aviation oil. Additive are what matter.
@MrMrBigro
@MrMrBigro Год назад
Come and do the same test here in calgary at -30 degrees you will see why very quickly lol the 20 w 50 the engine won't turn over
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
thick as a brick
@MrMrBigro
@MrMrBigro Год назад
@@richardholdener1727 yes I have 5w30 and the car won't turn over
@MrMrBigro
@MrMrBigro Год назад
Had 73 2.6 liter capri with 20w50 and same temperature it would start barely but it start
@DarkLinkAD
@DarkLinkAD Год назад
-25F to 110+F in NY and most all the fleets use 15w-40 Rotella in barrels.
@MrMrBigro
@MrMrBigro Год назад
@@DarkLinkAD but my sho won't start with 20w50 in minuse 30 would ever turn lol
@terrypikaart4394
@terrypikaart4394 Год назад
I did see a old sbc test of same viscosity differences, 20-50 made more power, oil pressure increase did not overcome power added from the film strength.
@RaceMentally
@RaceMentally Год назад
You have oil pressure so what does it matter? If that’s your only reason that’s not really one I’d be worried about. Protection should be the first not a lower oil pressure that’s sustainable.
@nickcook7408
@nickcook7408 Год назад
Top fuel dragsters use SAE 70 and they have 10,000 HP. Maybe we should all use SAE70?
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
CHECK THEIR CLEARANCES AND FILM STRENGTH REQUIREMENTS
@paulg444
@paulg444 Год назад
My translation: Go with the light weight oil ff you want that extra 2% of horse power at 5000rpm but you will sacrifice engine longevity. ... Only a very wealthy man that buys race cars for a hobby would do that.
@einstein3509
@einstein3509 Год назад
Why would my engine builder use 1.6 rockers on the intake and 1.5 on the exhaust? I can run 1.6 on all of them if I want to. I’m just not sure why he did what he did. He’s a hard guy to get ahold of or I would ask him. He built me a 383 stroker running “according to his Dyno” 500hp 520tq Cam 234/242 Intake cam lobe 374 with 1.6 rocker = 598 lift Exhaust cam lobe 382 with 1.5 rocker = 573 lift The heads have 205 intake 160 exhaust valve. Using Brodix RaceRite 200 runner heads Using a comp roller cam and comp short travel hydraulic lifters. According to Comp the springs he used are to weak and that why my valves a floating at above 5800rmps So I’m planning on installing the right springs and a stud girdle and installing those ultra pro magnum roller rockers. Just not sure if I should change that set up from 1.6/1.5 to 1.6/1.6 the cam card recommends 1.5 on all. Oh and the heads “according to Brodix” are good for a 640 lift. Any explanation for that set up?
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
just trying to get more lift
@jacobvanhalteren7452
@jacobvanhalteren7452 Год назад
exactly why f1 cars use lower viscosity on qualifying motors and then switch back to higher viscosity for races
@surfgod509
@surfgod509 Год назад
Very interesting 👌
@dylanarnold4487
@dylanarnold4487 Год назад
Great vidja 🤙🏼
@OEMishGarage
@OEMishGarage Год назад
What was the ow-10's oil pressure at idle? The still shows 0.3 PSI at 0 RPM. The pressure curve actually looks fine for an engine running up to 6500 RPM. Of course, with the 0w-10 making the same power as the 5w-30, unless there are improvements in fuel economy and no detriments to longevity, it doesn't make sense to go to 0w-10 in an engine with factory clearances.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
that was just a photo-the idle pressure was much higher
@button-puncher
@button-puncher Год назад
I need an oil pressure gauge on my daily. Not knowing bugs me.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
ME TOO
@The_R-n-I_Guy
@The_R-n-I_Guy Год назад
I definitely need to get some gauges
@RaceMentally
@RaceMentally Год назад
Never mind found it lol. But what about oil temps with weight change
@brucefrye8799
@brucefrye8799 Год назад
Kool test
@chriswise1232
@chriswise1232 Год назад
Changing oil in the wife's salad bowl right before Christmas. Very ballsy.
@engineguyeric682
@engineguyeric682 Год назад
You conveniently left out the comparison between the 5w30 STP conventional and 0w10 Lucas synthetic oil. They made the same exact 481 hp and 416 tq…
@D2O2
@D2O2 Год назад
I see zero psi at a stop light regardless of weight, but that is due to the stupid start/stop "feature".
@watsisbuttndo829
@watsisbuttndo829 Год назад
We really need to see where in the system the pressure is being monitored. If the transducer is prior to the oil filter is it possible that the pressure increase is due to restriction across the filter. A pressure reference downstream of the filter is a better reference. its possible that the bearings are actually seeing increased oil flow with the thinner oil. Think about if you bunged off the gallery at the bearings the gauge would show great pressure. Is the filter a partial bung?
@masoncampos7043
@masoncampos7043 Год назад
Not so much in a LS. Look at the oiling system design. It only filters about 20-30% of the oil from the pump I think it is. And if I recall its on the return side
@watsisbuttndo829
@watsisbuttndo829 Год назад
@@masoncampos7043 freely acknowledge that i know sod all about details of the LS platform. All my background is ye olde skool.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
post filter
@Garret3579
@Garret3579 Год назад
you should test Motul 300V...
@kylemilligan752
@kylemilligan752 Год назад
My 9200 rpm 163whp dynojet Honda d16 wore rings out prematurely from high piston speed. Started smoking under WOT. High rpm HP #s fell off. 0-20 as baseline. Tried 10-30, then 20-50. High rpm losses with thicker oils got worse. Hone and fresh rings jumped back to earlier HP numbers.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
HOW DID YOU WEAR RINGS OUT WITH ENGINE SPEED?
@kylemilligan752
@kylemilligan752 Год назад
Mr Holdener, I'm not 100 percent sure. But with the d16 3.54 stroke and 9200 rpm, the ring seal would go away every 6 months or so. Power would fall off. Hone and fresh rings, power would be back to normal on the dynojet
@kylemilligan752
@kylemilligan752 Год назад
This was a Dyno mule to be clear. This d16 got beat nearly daily on the dynojet chasing HP, and drag raced.
@ChurchAutoTest
@ChurchAutoTest Год назад
@@kylemilligan752 D16 rod ratio is poor compared to b-series stuff, and that 90mm stroke is longer than a B18 to boot. Plus D-series engines have big issues with oil temperatures without a cooler. Ovalling out the bores is not hard at 7500 rpm, let alone 9000+, lol
@kylemilligan752
@kylemilligan752 Год назад
@@ChurchAutoTest Sorry if I sidetracked things. I first noticed it burning oil, and HP was down at high rpm. I thought maybe thicker oil would crutch it. Saw a loss. Switched to even thicker oil to verify the trend. The loss to windage was significant at high rpm. After a hone and fresh rings HP came right back to baseline. I just accepted that as a price of doing business with a long stroke, high piston speed combo with really thin rings. No big deal.
@jacobvanhalteren7452
@jacobvanhalteren7452 Год назад
Isn't most of the gain just based on oil temp? From an air-cooled motorcycle viewpoint, we run 20w-50 in the summer because oil temps are easily over 250 deg F. I was advised that if oil temps regularly stayed below 250 (like a typical water-cooled or good oil-cooled motor would be 220 - 240) then 20w-50 will always be at a disadvantage.
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
oil temp was the same
@racerx7319
@racerx7319 Год назад
WITH THE LIGHTER WEIGHT OIL AND LOWER PRESSURE DO YOU HAVE MORE VOLUME OF OIL MOVING THRU THE BEARING'S PULLING MORE HEAT OUT OF THE BEARING'S KEEPING THEM COOLER......JUST A THOUGHT 🤔🤔🤔. MAYBE CHECK ENGINE TEMPERATURE TO SEE IF THERE'S ANY DIFFERENCE.
@robertmontgomery7158
@robertmontgomery7158 Год назад
Pressure is not equal to flow
@masoncampos7043
@masoncampos7043 Год назад
No it's not, but little to no pressure = little to no flow or volume..
@DarkLinkAD
@DarkLinkAD Год назад
Yeah but with enough reynolds wrap, 15 hippies and a basic calculator, you can send a tin foil hat to the moon. If only we still had the tech..
@scotthatch4548
@scotthatch4548 Год назад
A late model tight clearance engine the heavy oil can barely get through the bearings ! What happened to the oil pressure bypass valve ? Pressure should never have gotten that high ! The test seems to be more about the HP to run the pump at a crazy pressure then the actual weight of the oil
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
the factory bypass valve doesn't open at the tested pressures (except cold), the oil viscosity is what changed things
@scotthatch4548
@scotthatch4548 Год назад
@@richardholdener1727 it's a spring and plunger set for like 60 psi ... Usually it only is needed cold because of the oil weight used but it is there all the time and should have controled the pressure ... So either it's stuck or that oil could not get through the bearings hardly at all and bypass was not big enough ... In either case the loss of HP is mostly do to the pressure load on the pump not how the oil is working in the engine or windage which is the main reason people use thin oil ... Not a good test ... If you used a 70s engine the result would have been opposite and thick oil would have won because the thin oil would have no pressure and lifters would start pumping down
@JC-gw3yo
@JC-gw3yo Год назад
Interesting test, but shouldn't the oil pump maintain a constant pressure because of the pressure regulator valve? Something wrong here. I can understand idle oil pressure varying due to low pump volume, but the pressure regulator should maintain a constant pressure in upper RPM ranges no matter the oil thickness
@richardholdener1727
@richardholdener1727 Год назад
the (over) pressure relief valve is higher than the test pressures here
Далее
The Great Oil Debate Finally Answered  lol-Really?
21:22
Accused of not doing a valve job😤
18:49
Просмотров 1,1 млн
20W50 vs. 10W40 engine oil differences
6:52
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.