Тёмный

Luke: An Eyewitness Account 

InspiringPhilosophy
Подписаться 438 тыс.
Просмотров 23 тыс.
50% 1

How do we know the Gospel of Luke was really written by Luke? Also, if Luke did write the gospel how can we trust it given how far he was divorced from Jesus? We explore these questions and more in this video.
Don't forget to help us create more videos! We need your support:
/ inspiringphilosophy
/ @inspiringphilosophy
inspiringphilo...

Опубликовано:

 

18 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 623   
@maxalaintwo3578
@maxalaintwo3578 12 дней назад
Luke-Acts is really a juggernaut for ancient history in general, not just Christian history
@mgvilaca
@mgvilaca 12 дней назад
Sir Mitchell Ramsay, an archeologist used to be a skeptic but changed his mind and said "Luke is a historian of the first rank"
@maxalaintwo3578
@maxalaintwo3578 12 дней назад
@@torreyintahoe nuh uh
@maxalaintwo3578
@maxalaintwo3578 11 дней назад
@@torreyintahoe again, nuh uh. And even if there were. I’d make the case that there are good reasons to believe Luke-Acts is reliable, on the minimum basis that it describes all manner of falsifiable historical trivia that’s hard to get right but it does
@drac7478
@drac7478 11 дней назад
@@torreyintahoe No it isn't. At best, it's "contested". Roman historians have taken it's general historicity as granted. So you're either mistaken or lying.
@midlander4
@midlander4 11 дней назад
@@drac7478 oh dear. It's tapdancing time
@noahmoffitt8419
@noahmoffitt8419 12 дней назад
"Thus, Luke is in fact, based" Yes, I wholeheartedly agree.
@taylorhouser2964
@taylorhouser2964 7 дней назад
@@noahmoffitt8419 Glad someone beat me to it
@GabrielAHOG
@GabrielAHOG 12 дней назад
I didn't realize I was gifted a channel membership, so thank you to whoever gifted it to me.
@chimpanzee21
@chimpanzee21 11 дней назад
David wood selfie?
@GabrielAHOG
@GabrielAHOG 10 дней назад
@@chimpanzee21 Indeed
@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics
@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics 17 дней назад
“[T]he confirmation of historicity [in Luke/Acts] is overwhelming…any attempt to reject its historicity even in matters of detail must now appear absurd. Roman historians have long taken it for granted.” -A.N. Shernin-Wight
@dirkjensen969
@dirkjensen969 13 дней назад
Shernin says. So there you go. What's he say about the moon landing you guys probably think that's fake
@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics
@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics 13 дней назад
@@dirkjensen969 I don’t think we are talking about the same person. Adrian Nicolas Shernin-Wight was a British Ancient historian. Where did he ever comment on the moon landing?
@dirkjensen969
@dirkjensen969 12 дней назад
@@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics Do you think 🤔 the moon landing was faked?
@billotron5521
@billotron5521 12 дней назад
​@Apollos_Christian_Apologetics This guys a troll. 100+ comments and he's subscribed, it's kinda sad actually.
@dirkjensen969
@dirkjensen969 12 дней назад
@@billotron5521 lol 😆 you guys
@Genesis0Nieves0
@Genesis0Nieves0 12 дней назад
Babe wake up! New inspiring philosophy video dropped!
@Kai_Theos_en_ho_Logos
@Kai_Theos_en_ho_Logos 12 дней назад
Michael, this series is outstanding. We appreciate the time and effort you put into what you do. Bless you.
@Makaneek5060
@Makaneek5060 18 дней назад
This is lovely, thank you 🎉 Very interesting that Plutarch has Onomastic Congruence also...
@americanman3054
@americanman3054 12 дней назад
I'm looking forward to the Gosple of John video next month
@Tobias-kk8zf
@Tobias-kk8zf 3 дня назад
Dear Sir-Thank you very much for this wondreful video. I have been having a horrible time recently due to my recurring clinical Depression and anxiety. Moreover a dear friend of mine, whom I believed was very knowledgeable regarding the faith, has publicly and sharply abandoned Christ. As such the past few days have been difficult in the extream. Yet thanks to your work I remember that we are unified to the Lord Jesus Christ in both his death and his glorification. Thank you and God love you.
@EmilyTodicescu
@EmilyTodicescu 12 дней назад
“Luke is a historian of first rank; not merely are his statements of fact trustworthy; he is possessed of the true historic sense; he seizes the important and critical events...In short, this author should be placed along with the very greatest of historians.” ~ William Ramsay, _The Bearing of Recent Discovery on the Trustworthiness of the New Testament_
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 9 дней назад
​@@perfectblindguy That doesn't mean it didn't happen .
@lucienlagarde8093
@lucienlagarde8093 8 дней назад
​@@perfectblindguyargument from silence .
@HanThiThuyNgoc
@HanThiThuyNgoc 10 дней назад
read the forbidden book Magnetic Aura on Borlest, and you'll see the secrets they're keeping from us.
@jfintex43
@jfintex43 9 дней назад
If there's books on them, they're not secrets...
@regearbull
@regearbull 12 дней назад
Peak as always, Amazing editing and very much well done research.
@williamsaporetti
@williamsaporetti 12 дней назад
in god we trust brother
@renans.4292
@renans.4292 17 дней назад
The Kingdom rejoices for yet another great defence for the faith that we carry. God bless you and your family Michael, you are a treasure, Praise be to Our Lord Jesus Chris!
@polystrate1
@polystrate1 13 дней назад
the kingdom should get of its ass and do something. Most dysfunctional kingdom ever
@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj
@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj 12 дней назад
@@polystrate1 We gave you hospitals?
@polystrate1
@polystrate1 12 дней назад
@@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj Romans gave us roads
@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj
@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj 12 дней назад
@@polystrate1 Nope, you're changing the subject. You said we do nothing, that was your original point.
@polystrate1
@polystrate1 12 дней назад
@@BibleteachesTrinity-jn1yj All those earthly things are meaningless compared to eternity. I'm talking about this supposed kingdom doing real work and converting ones with conviction. Most convert due to fear or childhood indoctrination. Christianity is dying.
@AryanNaik1415
@AryanNaik1415 12 дней назад
Gospel of John next. God bless you
@akak8299
@akak8299 12 дней назад
Wow this channel is gold!
@mgvilaca
@mgvilaca 12 дней назад
This series is amazing
@Vapememes
@Vapememes 12 дней назад
Luke is one of my favorite authors in the Bible, and much of what you went over is exactly why. I don't think God could have more perfectly chosen an author given just how careful Luke was with his sources. The various parables Luke includes in his gospel are another major reason he's up there when it comes to Biblical authors.
@DM5550Z
@DM5550Z 12 дней назад
You should interview more scholars ip, would be interesting.
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 12 дней назад
I will
@Seminarystudent99
@Seminarystudent99 12 дней назад
I have really benefited from this series! Thank you!
@richardc8353
@richardc8353 11 часов назад
This is awesome! I now need to watch it again at a slower speed so I can keep up 😊
@Jupiter1423
@Jupiter1423 5 дней назад
thank God for Luke.
@Rafsanul_Haq_96
@Rafsanul_Haq_96 12 дней назад
Although I'm not a Christian, I really enjoy watching your videos. I like the way you research and explain complex topics in simple English. Anyway, I have one question: Do you think the existence of our consciousness proves the existence of God? I mean, neurotransmitters released by our brains can't cause desires, because desires are immaterial. Does that mean our desires, thoughts, and emotions come from a supernatural being?
@lufax
@lufax 12 дней назад
@@Rafsanul_Haq_96 I believe your thought processes is heading in a great direction! Not only consciousness, but all things immaterial (morals, logic, etc) points out the falsehood of materialism/naturalism. It wouldn't "prove" anything per se, but it's evidence that there is more than just matter.
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 12 дней назад
Thank you for the donation. I think consciousness is best explained by theism. See here: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-2r74vcMxwUk.htmlsi=c0ptvoZehGLMWirH
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 12 дней назад
Interesting datum. Science can explain the brain, since the brain is a material entity. It cannot explain the mind, which is immaterial. Ditto for abstract, non-physical phenomena like love, virtue, consciousness, etc.
@knkn5049
@knkn5049 7 дней назад
Do you mean we can't make you want chocolate bar directly via wire in brain? Have you heard about any kind of Marketing and Advertising?😊
@JadDragon
@JadDragon 12 дней назад
Such a brilliant report, thank you. Quite soundly puts the objections to rest! Jesus lives! ♥️ and is Yahweh God 🙏🏻 Christ ✝️ and King 👑
@JadDragon
@JadDragon 9 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy I wonder if you'll ever stop trolling
@JadDragon
@JadDragon 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy I wonder if you'll ever stop trolling
@JadDragon
@JadDragon 7 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy I wonder if you'll ever stop trolling
@CynHicks
@CynHicks 12 дней назад
I love this stuff! Thanks.
@chriscutting1284
@chriscutting1284 11 дней назад
Great video, once again thank you 😊
@jameskostrewa9861
@jameskostrewa9861 12 дней назад
THAT WAS AWESOME !!!
@RealCaptainAwesome
@RealCaptainAwesome 12 дней назад
Lots of really compelling evidence
@RealCaptainAwesome
@RealCaptainAwesome 9 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy oh look, someone who never read the Bible. Jesus' main mission was to redeem Israel then for the believers to spread across the whole world after the dispersion at the to tower of Babel. Matthew 28:18-20 does not say just for the Jews, you made that up
@RealCaptainAwesome
@RealCaptainAwesome 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy you are clearly apostate or were, like the RYR, are relying on your own works and are ignoring the first half of the 10 Commandments.
@RealCaptainAwesome
@RealCaptainAwesome 6 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy Makes sense. You were never a believer and now are simply ignoring the parts of the Bible you don't like to try and stack real Christians. I pray that you come to repentance and are truly saved
@TS-ju1up
@TS-ju1up 10 дней назад
I know these videos must take a lot of time and effort, i appreciate you doing it IP! love the first one on Matthew and looking forward to more. I've read books on this stuff, but having it in video form like this really helps and im sure i will keep coming back to them!
@toxiclegend3286
@toxiclegend3286 12 дней назад
Let's goooooooo, thank you IP I love this series. God bless you!
@CptDawner
@CptDawner 10 дней назад
Can’t wait for John!
@anon77733
@anon77733 10 дней назад
Saint Luke, Blessed Apostle of Christ, intercede on our behalf before the Throne of our Lord and pray for us sinners☦️
@Gorillarevolta
@Gorillarevolta 7 дней назад
there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus. 1 Timothy 2:5b
@ryanherndon3927
@ryanherndon3927 17 дней назад
Thats crazy about the medical details. I knew it was in the text, but but the part about jairus's daughter is very intriguing. I've never seen that angle to it, it would definitely make sense why Jesus seemed annoyed at the mourners.
@midlander4
@midlander4 12 дней назад
It's fiction. Get over it
@midlander4
@midlander4 12 дней назад
So will you also be proving that Qran - and every other holy book ever written - is fiction? Or is that too much like hard work for you 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@drac7478
@drac7478 11 дней назад
@@midlander4 Unfortunately Roman historians disagree with you.
@drac7478
@drac7478 11 дней назад
@@midlander4 Sure, Christians can concede the Quran details historical events. That's literally irrelevant.
@midlander4
@midlander4 11 дней назад
@@drac7478 much as Spiderman films detail modern New York. Wow, is that really the best you can do?
@GerardKushner
@GerardKushner 12 дней назад
Thank you excellent info
@SSgTDUD
@SSgTDUD 17 дней назад
I’ve learned a lot here
@manny75586
@manny75586 6 дней назад
For me, the fact that it is quite obvious that he spoke with The Blessed Mother (unless he interviewed the Archangel Gabriel, no one else would know how the Annunciation happened). Is enough to believe his Gospel is reliable.
@LMN579
@LMN579 8 дней назад
May you hear the Words of life from the Lord
@swiftsea6225
@swiftsea6225 11 дней назад
Hey, I don’t know where else to say this, but I’m really going through a tough time right now. My friend of two years just told me that they never cared about me. It hurts a lot today. Please, pray for me.
@danktube21
@danktube21 11 дней назад
I’ll pray for you. By the way, that was never a true friend and just know that there are kind people out there, you just have to find them, focus on those who value you. Don’t let one bad apple ruin the whole barrel 😊
@mickeylax9975
@mickeylax9975 12 дней назад
When people deny the early church’s testimony of the authorship of the gospels, they basically are saying that the early church LIED. It’s such an uncharitable and mean accusation without any evidence.
@avishevin1976
@avishevin1976 11 дней назад
There’s plenty of evidence.
@RaymondTT
@RaymondTT 11 дней назад
​@@avishevin1976 Please provide it.
@avishevin1976
@avishevin1976 11 дней назад
@@RaymondTT Read the scholarly literature. There’s plenty available from people like Bart Ehrman and Dan McClellan.
@RaymondTT
@RaymondTT 11 дней назад
@@avishevin1976 I have read some of that. I dont find their arguments any good. Its mostly based on them not being convinced or based on silence, and they conclude that therefore Luke is not the author or Luke is not reliable. Rarely do I find that they provide actual evidence to support their position. I have not seen them deal with any of the arguments provided by Michael in this video, but I assume they have touched it somewhere. Do you know where they might handle these arguments? What do you find to be their two-three best arguments against Luke as the author?
@avishevin1976
@avishevin1976 11 дней назад
@@RaymondTT I only claimed there is evidence. I have not read their works in depth.
@ByronEarnheart
@ByronEarnheart 12 дней назад
Looking forward to your video on John in this series
@DerickTherving
@DerickTherving 10 дней назад
The naming patterns thing is an absolute killshot to the idea the gospels aren't historic biographies
@vantascuriosity4540
@vantascuriosity4540 18 дней назад
Waited for this vid!! Shout-out to IP 🫡🫡
@knkn5049
@knkn5049 7 дней назад
I have seen video about you at Planet Peterson, many people agree that you have collected a lot information and it is very likely that you will become sane person in a couple of years. Everybody is glad for you and very supportive)😊
@SpiritLevel888
@SpiritLevel888 12 дней назад
As well as being an exemplary researcher and historian Luke was Inspired by the Holy Spirit.
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 9 дней назад
​@@perfectblindguy That doesn't mean it didn't happen
@financialliteracy8204
@financialliteracy8204 11 дней назад
Amazing! Thanks for the great work!
@midlander4
@midlander4 11 дней назад
Now see all the other comments from IP whiteknighters tapdancing round this unfortunate truth 😊
@robertlackar
@robertlackar 8 дней назад
What a beautiful video. Congrats.
@Bvoorhis03
@Bvoorhis03 12 дней назад
This is the type of stuff I love. You make claims but really back them up with primary sources
@nuanceatnoon
@nuanceatnoon 12 дней назад
This is the best channel! Love you IP!
@ikundoellis9156
@ikundoellis9156 12 дней назад
Now we wait for John 😁😁
@DangItDanny10
@DangItDanny10 12 дней назад
I wish i could retain all of this. But my learning disability really sucks. 😢
@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid
@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid 12 дней назад
I also can’t retain as much nowadays, so for me, I just focus on what I can remember and if it’s important for me to use for future reference when doing discussions, I’ll write it down on my phone. Then I’ll revisit this video as many times as needed to firm up the overall subject matter here, which is the authorship of Luke+Acts is Luke.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 12 дней назад
Retain what you can, and don't beat yourself up for what you can't. Few if any humans have perfect retention of what they learn. You can always rewatch this video later.
@flockinchillin35
@flockinchillin35 11 дней назад
Adhd? If you don’t take meds try doing something like chewing gum while watching or messing w something, it’ll satisfy any extra need for stimulation and you can keep focusing. If you do that you should retain pretty well
@bannie6151
@bannie6151 12 дней назад
I want to know the music IP uses for these videos, they sound like good background noise to study with lol
@charlesiragui2473
@charlesiragui2473 7 дней назад
Thank you for this thorough work. I feel trained to doubt everything and have lately felt that this is not reasonable. If a tradition says something and its roots go back to a time close to the events, the burden of proof should be on the other side. Or perhaps it's better to call this a presumption of accuracy that needs to be overcome. In any case, you have done a wonderful job of documenting how, given a couple of centuries, scholars have given ample evidence to show that the traditional teaching was right to begin with.
@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid
@I9s7lam5is-S3tu1pid 12 дней назад
Didn’t know Luke was single, lived till 80+ and the region where he lived
@LạcDiệuThương
@LạcDiệuThương 10 дней назад
the book that changed everything for me was Magnetic Aura from Borlest
@bakhop
@bakhop 12 дней назад
Beautiful job as usual. Sadly, you did not touch on Church tradition that Luke got some information from Mary the mother of Jesus. The infancy narratives would probably not be known to anyone else but she.
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 12 дней назад
Possibly, but it was not relevant to the main point.
@coffeehousedialogue
@coffeehousedialogue 17 дней назад
What great timing! Because, Holy Koolaid is up to his usual tomfoolery with the New Testament!
@5BBassist4Christ
@5BBassist4Christ 10 дней назад
"One does not obtain this kind of accuracy, unless they were an eyewitness, or were close with the eyewitnesses." -I feel a meme coming on.
@michaelogrady232
@michaelogrady232 11 дней назад
What is most obvious from the Gospel of Luke is his source for the Annunciation, the Visitation, and the infancy narratives is none other than the Blessed Virgin Herself.
@timosboudouloulisdafm6962
@timosboudouloulisdafm6962 13 дней назад
Can you respond to "The Myth Of The Christian Trinity"
@MossW268
@MossW268 12 дней назад
I'm not a scholar, so take this with a grain of salt, but here's my theory on the Synoptic gospels: Matthew was the first to write his gospel in Judea, writing a Hebrew or Aramaic version and a Greek version. When Peter was going to Rome (around 57 AD, after the letter to the Romans but before Paul returned to Judea), he had Mark write a less Jewish, more simple Gospel that would be easier to preach to Gentiles. He then took this with him to Rome. When Paul and Luke came back to Judea, Luke spoke with eyewitnesses, learnt oral traditions, and perhaps read the Gospel of Matthew. Once Paul and Luke came to Rome, Luke wrote his gospel using Mark as a base, supplementing it with extra material he had learnt.
@Zvpada
@Zvpada День назад
Top
@midimusicforever
@midimusicforever 12 дней назад
Luke is legit!
@kevinkelly2162
@kevinkelly2162 12 дней назад
In the same book we have a talking snake. Is that true too?
@therottingstench
@therottingstench 12 дней назад
@@kevinkelly2162 Actually if you understand the ancient Mesopotamian world, you would know that the serpent in Genesis the "Nahas" is not only a serpent, but also means "shining one." It isnt just a snake, but a divine being
@kevinkelly2162
@kevinkelly2162 12 дней назад
@@therottingstench Not what it says in Genesis.
@aaaaaaa7697
@aaaaaaa7697 12 дней назад
@@kevinkelly2162when's the talking snake in Luke or Acts?
@kevinkelly2162
@kevinkelly2162 12 дней назад
@@aaaaaaa7697 Right at the very beginning.
@ChevySamk
@ChevySamk 10 дней назад
you should add accurate subtitles/closed captions to these for people in other languages
@Matteo78067
@Matteo78067 3 дня назад
IP, will you speak on if John 21 is a later addition when your video on John comes out? I'm currently struggling with the issue.
@el4276
@el4276 День назад
Do you have any videos addressing the claim Halloween originated in Egypt?
@FutbolBoricuaNET
@FutbolBoricuaNET 6 дней назад
SALUDOOOOOOOOOS!!!!!
@JaylenIrving
@JaylenIrving 20 часов назад
Michael Jones can you do a video on the deconstruction center this is an atheist RU-vid channel that targets the claims of Christianity and there’s one claim I would like you to respond. This atheist claimed that God salvation is not a free gift. I would like to hear what you have to say about that.
@JeanZamot
@JeanZamot 12 дней назад
Jesus my God
@FinnishDiogenes
@FinnishDiogenes 12 дней назад
I'd like to ask if you know about the channel "Total Victory of Christ". Would like to hear your thoughts on him.
@joe5959
@joe5959 11 дней назад
IP. Unrelated to the video, I take my hat off to you as an apologist. I dont have the patience to deal with all the crazy people you speak to. Keep doing what you do👍
@reenatai75
@reenatai75 День назад
IP would you be kind enough to make a vedoe on the gospel of barnabas and the epistle of barnabas.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 12 дней назад
Luke knew and worked with the original disciples. He only tells us what those original disciples told him (Gospel of Luke), or what he himself witnessed (acts). What more do we need? Skeptics are so desperate that they grasp at straws.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy , TOTAL BS!!! If we must have only original manuscripts to know what ancient writers said, then we CANNOT know what ANY of them said, since we rarely have any original manuscripts. Thank God REAL experts don't share this rigid belief of yours!
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy , LOL!!! EXPERTS say that, because of the MOUNTAIN of attestations to the contents of the NT, from manuscripts, quotes, inscriptions, etc, we can be 99% + certain that the NT is authentic. You would NOT apply this level of hyper-skepticism to ANY other historical writing. Only to the NT, because you dislike what it says. GROW UP.
@noahmoffitt8419
@noahmoffitt8419 12 дней назад
Bro snuck in the stream countdown music lmao 30:06
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 12 дней назад
Huh
@noahmoffitt8419
@noahmoffitt8419 12 дней назад
@@InspiringPhilosophy Sounded like the 1 minute countdown before you start a stream lol. Great video btw!
@RC_Zak
@RC_Zak 12 дней назад
Mike do you have an email so we can ask you questions in relation to Catholicism and early church father history? For Instance what books you'd recommend for Early Apostolic father church history. Thanks in advance
@JaylenIrving
@JaylenIrving 11 дней назад
Inspiring philosophy, can you do a video on deconstructing Christianity and this video is titled my top five reasons why I left Christianity
@idkbro-n5c
@idkbro-n5c 11 дней назад
I think theres other videos on it
@nathankrueger9959
@nathankrueger9959 12 дней назад
Is that a Lutheran study bible i see at 1:30 👀
@matt66716
@matt66716 12 дней назад
He is lutheran by the way
@matt66716
@matt66716 12 дней назад
He is Lutheran
@JesusPerez-wd3tq
@JesusPerez-wd3tq 12 дней назад
​@@matt66716he is most likely not IP probably doesnt have a denomination He believes alot of things that contradict every denomination For example He believes in monarchical trinitarianism which only EO believe yet he has a Protestant aproach to apologetics.
@matt66716
@matt66716 11 дней назад
@@JesusPerez-wd3tq he once said in a livestream that he’s a high church Protestant also he follows a bunch of lutheran accounts on twitter
@flockinchillin35
@flockinchillin35 11 дней назад
⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@JesusPerez-wd3tq Wouldn’t this still be some form of protestantism though? Not saying this is the case for IP but “non denominational” churches are typically just evangelical or pentecostal in disguise lol
@AdrianIsaac-w7h
@AdrianIsaac-w7h 12 дней назад
Please, Do John Next please.
@StandOnTruth2010
@StandOnTruth2010 12 дней назад
If I hear IP say Onomatopeia Congruence one more time...
@weno1842
@weno1842 8 дней назад
Hey IP, question about evolutionary theism.I just wanted to know how you justify to someone that death existed pre-fall if the book of wisdom says that God didn't make death. Thanks!
@carolinaasenciocolon5484
@carolinaasenciocolon5484 10 дней назад
Hi, IP. Do you think Luke utilized Matthew, or the Aramaic Matthew as a source? Also, what do you think of the fact that many of Matthew's teachings from the Sermon on the Mount are spread across Luke's Gospel instead of concentrated in Luke's Sermon of the Plain? Could the Sermon on the Mount as present on Matthew be a literary construction? Or it literally happened but Luke recorded other ocassions where Jesus said similar sayings to some of the Sermon? Those are a couple of questions I have about Luke's use or a Matthew-like source and the Sermon on the Mount (unless he didn't use Matthew at all and the info came from direct eyewitness interviews?) God bless you and thank you for these videos, they have really helped strenght my faith in Jesus. 🙏🏼📖
@mosesalvarez831
@mosesalvarez831 4 дня назад
He wrote down his Gospel from the first pope. Peter the apostle
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 9 дней назад
Skeptics ' ' Jesus said some will not taste death until his return thats the ' plain ' reading of the text ' Christisns . ' Luke said he interviewed eyewitnesses thats the plain reading of the text '
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 9 дней назад
@perfectblindguy Aristophanes, 451-383BC, there are 10 copies from 900AD, a span of 1,300 years. Sophocles, a playwright, wrote Oedipus trilogy 496-406BC, his earliest copy is 1000 AD, a time span of 1,400 years and there are 193 copies. 9-10 good copies of Caesar's gallic Wars originally written anywhere from 100-44BC. 7 copies of Plato dated around 1000 years after its original authorship of about 427-327BC. 20 copies of Livy's Roman History, dated about 1,200 years after it was originally written in 59BC-17AD 2 copies of Tacitus' Annals written in 100 AD; copies we have are from 1,000 years after, 8 copies of Thucydides' History originally written in 460-400 BC; copies we have are from 1,300 years after. 9 copies from Euripedes originally written in 480-406 BC; copies are from 1500 years after. 5 copies Aristotle originally written in 384-322 BC; copies we have are from 1,400 years after. The most documented secular work from the ancient world is Homers Illiad -- surviving on 643 manuscript copies.
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 8 дней назад
@perfectblindguy The earliest copy of josephus is 14th century
@ramadadiver7810
@ramadadiver7810 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy Btw ' original copy' ? Sounds like an oxymoron
@Mmartins1097
@Mmartins1097 10 дней назад
Hey there Michael! Great name! Would you be interested in covering some of the points brought up in Alex O'Connor's podcast with Dr. Justin Sludge? I'd like to see a Christian's perspective
@Mmartins1097
@Mmartins1097 10 дней назад
The Trinity and Origen part of the interview is pretty interesting to me (someone who has never heard of the influence of Greek philosophy on Christianity)
@The_Ancient_Guardian
@The_Ancient_Guardian 10 дней назад
there is a video that he talk about the "blind men and the elephant". Someone now what video its?
@kennethcrenshaw317
@kennethcrenshaw317 9 дней назад
Loooook, You See? IP is talking about Pronouns, that must mean he is a progressive Christian.
@JLCProductions1976
@JLCProductions1976 12 дней назад
What if Luke was one of the Greeks who came seeking Jesus in John?
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 11 дней назад
Probably not
@JLCProductions1976
@JLCProductions1976 11 дней назад
@@InspiringPhilosophy it would be cool, you gotta admit.
@JLCProductions1976
@JLCProductions1976 8 дней назад
@@perfectblindguy We don't know if he did.
@brandonp2530
@brandonp2530 11 дней назад
Great job mate. God bless you
@midlander4
@midlander4 11 дней назад
Allah?
@brandonp2530
@brandonp2530 11 дней назад
@@midlander4 Brother seek Jesus, read the Holy Bible, amd your life will change forever
@LaToKim
@LaToKim 10 дней назад
there's a banned book called Magnetic Aura from Borlest that talks about powerful methods to increase attraction, it's the real deal
@rebelresource
@rebelresource 8 дней назад
Luke did not use mark as a source. You cannot demonstrate this as the Greek even is so radically different. We can only show they have difference sources. Luke’s Vorlage/text has non-Septuagintal hebraisms.
@thejourney4999
@thejourney4999 6 дней назад
22:49
@seekandfind1225
@seekandfind1225 12 дней назад
Question: Does Luke’s prologue have to demand a title of Luke gave it to Theophilus in-person?
@nathanielbrill1523
@nathanielbrill1523 12 дней назад
He wouldn't title it as too Theophilus in that case.
@Lintlll
@Lintlll 12 дней назад
Why do we have both IP and GodLogic going live at the same time.. Y’all need to coordinate cos we want to be on both
@bigdavexx1
@bigdavexx1 12 дней назад
If Luke thought the gospels of Mark and Matthew were adequate, why write yet another gospel version?
@xyztogrutamamenchi7894
@xyztogrutamamenchi7894 12 дней назад
@@bigdavexx1 Why wouldn't he want to make a better one? Especially considering that, being a companion of Paul, he likely was a Christian.
@xyztogrutamamenchi7894
@xyztogrutamamenchi7894 12 дней назад
Sorry, I misread your comment and can't edit my original answer. I thought it said " *in* - adequate" but it doesn't. In the beginning of Luke he writes that he wanted to give an orderly account. It also seems to imply that Luke felt like it was his mission from God, just like he says it was for the other authors.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 12 дней назад
He explains why at the beginning of his Gospel.
@bigdavexx1
@bigdavexx1 11 дней назад
@mysotiras21 , he does. He apparently didn't feel that Mark was an adequate "orderly" and complete account.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 11 дней назад
@@bigdavexx1, YAWN. Luke gives a different perspective. he didn't write because he thought Mark was "inadequate". Did you even watch this video?
@JayWest14
@JayWest14 5 дней назад
You should have competed in the Olympics. That was quite the mental gymnastics performance!!😂
@briandiehl9257
@briandiehl9257 4 дня назад
I love how you think quoting scholarship is mental gymnastics
@Mike00513
@Mike00513 4 дня назад
What an amazing rebuttal! You really got him there!
@JayWest14
@JayWest14 4 дня назад
@@briandiehl9257 nah, he’s a cherry picker is what he is. He sits and sifts through material, picking and choosing the material that fits his narrative and goes on a long winding road of nonsensical speculation. It’s truly sad, because although I feel he’s a truly intelligent guy, his intelligence is wasted defending an obvious mythology of a doctrine. Robyn Faith Walsh said it’s not considered mythology because it’s still being practiced as a religion. In other words, in another century it will be gone and folks will be talking about how silly these folks were following an ancient tradition about a guy who died and came back to life. Shjts absolutely nonsense!!
@JoyInFreedom
@JoyInFreedom 7 дней назад
Have you ever done a video talking about evolution? Do you think it is a lie or something? What makes it hard to have faith is that we have sufficient evidence to show that us evolving more is plausible than religion. We can't have both right? If we were made in God's image, we wouldn't have evolved so much. For those who claim evolution is a lie, why do you think that?
@joshuahaddow3194
@joshuahaddow3194 6 дней назад
He has a lot of videos about evolution and how it is compatible with Christianity, he also has a series on the book of Genesis in which he speaks about the meaning of being made in the image of God.
@JoyInFreedom
@JoyInFreedom 6 дней назад
@@joshuahaddow3194 oh wow. I have met Christians that said you can't be Christian and believe evolution to be true. I didn't know they could mix. But if we were made in his image, was his image for us to evolve from pond scum?
@JoyInFreedom
@JoyInFreedom 6 дней назад
@@joshuahaddow3194 Oh, wow. Some Christians have told me that one cannot be a follower of Jesus and still believe evolution to be true. Do you believe we were once apes?
@Zvpada
@Zvpada 4 дня назад
​@@JoyInFreedom They didn't watch IP then 😭
@Zvpada
@Zvpada 4 дня назад
John when?
@InspiringPhilosophy
@InspiringPhilosophy 4 дня назад
October 11
@cariboubearmalachy1174
@cariboubearmalachy1174 12 дней назад
If Luke was an eyewitness, then he could have just written "I, Luke, saw Jesus Christ myself."
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 12 дней назад
True, but he was NOT recording his own experiences, just those of the original disciples, and of Paul.
@cariboubearmalachy1174
@cariboubearmalachy1174 12 дней назад
@@mysotiras21 Then it's not an eyewitness account.
@mysotiras21
@mysotiras21 11 дней назад
@@cariboubearmalachy1174 , LOL!!! Peanut, if I report EXACTLY what eyewitnesses told me, then it IS an eyewitness account. I am just the MODE of the transmission, much like a piece of paper is the MODE of transmitting someone's words. The words remain his, despite having been written on paper.
@idkbro-n5c
@idkbro-n5c 11 дней назад
@@cariboubearmalachy1174 Luke isn't. He wrote down those of eyewitnesses.
@cariboubearmalachy1174
@cariboubearmalachy1174 11 дней назад
@mysotiras21 Well no, the Gospell of Luke is clearly not conveying exactly the words people were telling Luke, if he truly was interviewing eyewitnesses (bc Jesus' eyewitnesses were most likely speaking Aramaic and not Greek, duh). Even if you were going to be absurdly generous to Gospell Truthers, the best you can say is that it's possible that Luke took some stories told by eyewitnesses and crafted a narrative based on them, like a modern day reporter like Bob Woodward. But even in that highly implausible hypothesis, that's a second-hand account, not an eyewitness account. Bob Woodward himself, one of the most celebrated journalists of our time, was criticized for embellishing or twisting around the accounts given to him by eyewitnesses in his books.
@gabrielteo3636
@gabrielteo3636 9 дней назад
I have a question. Suppose Jesus didn't resurrect, what would explain all this "reliable" testimony from "eye witnesses" and all the other miracles Jesus "supposedly" did? I have some theories...
@CitrikkAcid
@CitrikkAcid 11 дней назад
Hey michael can you make a comprehensive list of all the prophesies jesus fufilled? Ive heard people say he is not the messiah because he apparently did not fufill all of them
@avishevin1976
@avishevin1976 11 дней назад
Here is the list: 0.
@RokketterCouncil
@RokketterCouncil 10 дней назад
@@avishevin1976return to r/atheism
@MeanBeanComedy
@MeanBeanComedy 10 дней назад
Does the Koran have that amount of onomastic congruence? 🤔 Does the Book of Mormon?
@briandiehl9257
@briandiehl9257 4 дня назад
The Quran doesn't even really mention contemporary people to try this with, so no
@lostlocked2354
@lostlocked2354 11 дней назад
Hello, I have questions in regards of Christianity. As a christian, I have doubts in my faith at times, specifically about the resurrection. And I was wondering if you could clarify things up, with a rather unbiased take. Hi, I want a genuine unbiased take from other christians about this. I’ll start now. Why do early sources like Tacitus, who mentioned Jesus' execution under Pilate, and Josephus, who briefly referred to Jesus' existence and a possible resurrection but likely altered by later Christians, not provide direct proof of the resurrection? Also, why do sources like Pliny the Younger, who noted that Christians worshiped Jesus as a god, and the Talmud, which acknowledges Jesus' execution but not his resurrection, fail to offer independent verification of this central Christian belief? We know Now on the topic of Josephus, how do you reconcile the evidence that suggests Josephus' *Testimonium Flavianum* was altered by later Christian scribes? Manuscript variations and early Christian writings, such as those by Eusebius, show that the passage likely included phrases supporting Christian beliefs that were not in the original text. Additionally, scholars note that while the passage mentions Jesus, it did not originally contain explicit Christian claims. How do you view these factors? The evidence suggesting that Josephus’ *Testimonium Flavianum* was altered by later Christian scribes is compelling. First, the variations in early manuscripts of Josephus' *Antiquities of the Jews* show different versions of the passage, hinting at modifications over time. For instance, Eusebius of Caesarea, a 4th-century church historian, quoted the passage with phrases that align closely with Christian doctrine, like calling Jesus "the Christ." This strongly suggests that Christian scribes edited the text to reflect their beliefs. Additionally, scholars like Louis H. Feldman and William L. Lane Craig have examined the passage and concluded that while it originally mentioned Jesus, the explicit Christian claims were likely later additions. Furthermore, Origen, writing in the 3rd century, referenced Josephus' works but did not mention this specific passage about Jesus, which implies that it may have been added or altered after his time. These factors together point to the likelihood that the *Testimonium Flavianum* was edited by Christian scribes to better support their faith.
Далее
Mark: An Eyewitness Account
36:01
Просмотров 40 тыс.
Matthew: An Eyewitness Account
27:28
Просмотров 27 тыс.
Dr. Jay Smith - The Truth About Islam's Origins
2:11:40
Просмотров 108 тыс.
An Introduction to Metaethics
15:39
Просмотров 2,9 тыс.
Exposing Dan McClellan’s Dogmas & Double Standards
31:19
Paranoid Protestants | Seventh-day Adventists
2:50:52
Просмотров 453 тыс.
What Is the Best Bible Translation?
55:07
Просмотров 145 тыс.
Who Wrote the Gospels?
17:37
Просмотров 80 тыс.
Mind-Blowing Bible Study w/ Dr. Scott Hahn
2:33:06
Просмотров 253 тыс.
3 Hours of Wisdom from Peter Kreeft
2:59:57
Просмотров 96 тыс.
What Are the Gospels?
25:32
Просмотров 50 тыс.