Тёмный

Lula's return - A Brazil divided | DW Documentary 

DW Documentary
Подписаться 6 млн
Просмотров 75 тыс.
50% 1

Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is once again president of Brazil - and faces considerable challenges. Four years of Jair Bolsonaro's right-wing administration and an election campaign marred by political violence leave Lula at the helm of a deeply polarized society.
The preceding presidential election campaign was highly charged, reflecting the gulf between various segments of Brazilian society. This report centers on three people from São Paulo, who shared their competing visions for the future of their country before, during and after the election - right up to the new president's inauguration. A left-wing activist, an arms dealer and an evangelical Christian. For Lula's supporters, his triumph promises the restoration of a pluralistic democracy serving all Brazilians. For those who back Bolsonaro, who liberalized the economy and championed the conservative values of the fast-growing evangelical Christian community, his defeat has been devastating. But reactions on the street following Lula's narrow victory show that the "Bolsonarismo" ideology remains very much alive. On Sunday, thousands of Bolsanaro supporters stormed the Congress building and other government offices in Brasilia. President Lula has condemned the attacks, calling them "barbarism."
#documentary #dwdocumentary #brazil
[This documentary has been reuploaded due to technical issues.]
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/t...
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G

Опубликовано:

 

24 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 628   
@cristinadumitrescu1456
@cristinadumitrescu1456 Год назад
Not only Brasil entire world is polarised
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
It's important to understand exactly what that division is: bigotry. Until the internet, most bigots were in their own communities, unaware that their bigoted ideals were dying off in the greater world outside. Now the internet has brought us all face to face, and they can clearly see their bigoted idealism is unpopular at best. I imagine for many of them it seems as if their personalities are being rebuked, not just the bigotry that they were groomed with.
@drunkensailor112
@drunkensailor112 Год назад
@@aylbdrmadison1051 thanks to social media a small group of noisy idiots have managed to appear as a much bigger group than they actually are.
@Dizle81
@Dizle81 Год назад
BRICS will survive
@zekeyeager1458
@zekeyeager1458 Год назад
@@aylbdrmadison1051what is bigotry?
@zekeyeager1458
@zekeyeager1458 Год назад
@@Dizle81indeed brother
@geoffbent2691
@geoffbent2691 Год назад
Great to get perspectives from both sides of the political debates; so many obvious similarities with political culture and divisions in the US.
@thawizard4478
@thawizard4478 Год назад
33
@leonardos2925
@leonardos2925 Год назад
It is still biased to the left, cause it's DW. He basically was a leader in the left when it developed a scheme that stole billions, a international hub of corruption that sent people to jail in many countries, many of his allies were arrested, he was arrested for corruption, condemned in every instance possible, and then his allies in the Supreme Court (Indicated by him and his successor) got him out. His party caused the greatest economic crisis in the history of Brazil in 2015 and then you have leftist media glorifying his presidency, i.e. of a former inmate. Just because they don't like too much Bolsonaro and his patriotism.
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
Yes, because all that far-right nonsense, including gun culture and what else, came from there...
@marceloengecom
@marceloengecom Год назад
Yes, its very similar with United states, but have a great difference. The colors of the brazillian flag is green and yellow, not red (color of the internacional socialist).
@rmf9567
@rmf9567 Год назад
@@marceloengecom hahahhahahahah
@ItzCoopzFtw
@ItzCoopzFtw Год назад
2:30 "In my opinion he respects diverse opinions and that's what's best for Brazil today" *Promoting hatred against other groups, threatening violence and/or to shoot them is not an "Opinion" it's blatant discrimination and suppression.*
@skeetrix5577
@skeetrix5577 Год назад
k commie
@mareksicinski3726
@mareksicinski3726 Год назад
An opinion can be bad, I’m not sure why people are confused about the idea of opinion. And this guy doesn’t agree that that’s what he’s doing on some level
@unclerubo
@unclerubo Год назад
I never understood those people who get absolutely blinded and vote against their own interests when their flag is waved in front of their eyes.
@blairrobert3438
@blairrobert3438 Год назад
I agree. Like the rainbow flag for example. It's a flag used by the new age oppressive authoritarians who want to replace the old church with their own version of morality. Personally I don't like any of them and wish they'd keep their moral opinions to themselves.
@mareksicinski3726
@mareksicinski3726 Год назад
People define their own ‘interest’ It’s ideolgy
@bryanice3313
@bryanice3313 Год назад
since when lula represent the midde class interest ?
@unclerubo
@unclerubo Год назад
@@bryanice3313 the middle class does not exist. It is a construct created by the wealthy to get working people to vote in favour of the interests of the capital. Either you are working class or you live of others work. It is that simple.
@madinkan
@madinkan Год назад
The gun shop owner was voting in accordance with his interest, but so was the dance teacher who left poverty thanks to Lula's social programs.
@marilia........b
@marilia........b Год назад
"Protect family values" is more likely "protect his own family" above all.
@Guizambaldi
@Guizambaldi 8 месяцев назад
To protect HIS family values = theft.
@tharukajayasinghe7958
@tharukajayasinghe7958 Год назад
As a Sri lankan I supportered Brazil worker's party..🎉
@1533TodaVida
@1533TodaVida Год назад
🤓
@Baianoh
@Baianoh Год назад
✊🏼♥️
@tentandoumcover
@tentandoumcover Год назад
Communism is not good, Lula is a thief
@Hmonks
@Hmonks 10 месяцев назад
Everyone should be paid the same right…. Typical communist
@carlospecanha1826
@carlospecanha1826 8 месяцев назад
You should be ashamed of this.
@ArmonMitchell
@ArmonMitchell Год назад
Bolsonaro is a man of faith....? What bible are you reading?
@sotnasoigres315
@sotnasoigres315 Год назад
Same as Trump.
@MrMarcodarko
@MrMarcodarko Год назад
same as Biden
@kalui96
@kalui96 Год назад
the bible and its clergy has been sending men to force their way over foreign walls since Medieval times
@augurcybernaut4785
@augurcybernaut4785 Год назад
@@kalui96 Your comment perfectly illustrates that you don’t need the Bible in order to believe stupidity.
@MrMarcodarko
@MrMarcodarko Год назад
@@kalui96 Ok mr. Islam
@user-ms4ef8xz9t
@user-ms4ef8xz9t Год назад
From an American, well done to the people of Brazil. I admire your courage and willingness to fight for what is right.
@zekeyeager1458
@zekeyeager1458 Год назад
Bolsonaro was a informant of the CIA and controlled what economic trajectory Brazil went in order to sustain US interested. He’s an insurrectionist and hates his country being independent. US does not want Brazil to be an independent, free thinking country with economic power from BRICS because that would mean a possible rival closer than any other country since Cuba and the Cuban Missile Crisis. Ironic, isn’t it? How the US has bases all over the Pacific near China and North Korea, right near their borders, and yet when a sovereign country like Cuba wants to have deterrence capabilities (nuclear weapons) so that a much larger adversary (the US) wouldn’t consider invading it, or in this case when Brazil gets a leader who is pro-Brazil and anti-western influence, the US cries like a baby and throws a fit about it until it invades, overthrows its government, or gets its way… pathetic
@fullsend8738
@fullsend8738 Год назад
Right is wrong, left is best
@AuthenticJunior
@AuthenticJunior Год назад
"...fight for what is THE right"
@guitarlawyer75
@guitarlawyer75 Год назад
We are almost killing each other for politics. I live in Brasilia and it is horrible
@bryanice3313
@bryanice3313 Год назад
lol u dont eben know the type of people thta voted lula
@jabuticaba2000
@jabuticaba2000 Год назад
Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups. - George Carlin
@claudiabarbosareis5087
@claudiabarbosareis5087 Год назад
Said nothing
@mzx71
@mzx71 Год назад
@@claudiabarbosareis5087 No offence, but if you need an explanation, prob was meant for you. ;)
@lukassakamoto4576
@lukassakamoto4576 Год назад
@@claudiabarbosareis5087 you crazy
@claudiabarbosareis5087
@claudiabarbosareis5087 Год назад
@@lukassakamoto4576 about what? What s the subject?
@Elias-lp1kh
@Elias-lp1kh Год назад
Communism is being installed all over the world, unfortunately here in Latin America it will be established first and then for new world scales, 1984 on the way.
@sachinrv1
@sachinrv1 Год назад
There is something seriously wrong with the persons we choose to govern us. And it is every where.
@jabuticaba2000
@jabuticaba2000 Год назад
correction: we are given to choose
@sachinrv1
@sachinrv1 Год назад
@@jabuticaba2000 true..
@claytonkikugawa6657
@claytonkikugawa6657 Год назад
Fraud in elections everywhere.
@sandraschneider1622
@sandraschneider1622 Год назад
Polen is heavily divided too, but it`s tough to understand each other, when the other side forces you to do, what they want. Abortion is an excellent example of that. In Polen, women are forced to birth heavily disabled children, that would even die in hours, and if you can`t afford psychological help, you have to manage on your own. I get fed up with that, really.
@DonJohn87_YT
@DonJohn87_YT Год назад
Yeah it's really messed up with those rules
@mareksicinski3726
@mareksicinski3726 Год назад
Why do Germans say ‘Polen’ when typing in English
@mirthab.7576
@mirthab.7576 Год назад
Democracy is more than abortion .
@claytonkikugawa6657
@claytonkikugawa6657 Год назад
Here you can sand your baby to adoption, instead of killing. 🇧🇷😜
@THEREALZENFORCE
@THEREALZENFORCE Год назад
@Sandra Schneider : Thanks for the information, i did not know that women in Poland are forced to give birth to marxists.
@misjabrus9142
@misjabrus9142 Год назад
Capitol Washington vs. Capitol Brasilia. Don't miss the similarities
@toolbox0001
@toolbox0001 Год назад
both were a staged even.. the question whos pulling the strings! what will happen Canada or New Zealand..?
@flawyerlawyertv7454
@flawyerlawyertv7454 Год назад
Tudo de bom para o meu país. Que as pessoas fiquem cada vez mais tolerantes e mente abertas para que esses atos de violência e outros não aconteçam mais. 🙏
@mauricioguimaraesfilho4337
@mauricioguimaraesfilho4337 Год назад
Não se pode ter tolerância com verme comunista!
@jvfg170
@jvfg170 Год назад
Você por aqui, caro amigo!
@leonardos2925
@leonardos2925 Год назад
Que as pessoas parem de roubar o país e causar o maior esquema de corrupção da história (Petrolão).
@marceloengecom
@marceloengecom Год назад
Com a informação descentralizada e distribuida que temos hoje, nunca mais teremos a tal "tolerância", principalmente quando se colocam mentirosos e falsos no poder. Hoje em dia, a verdade sempre aparece, antes, nunca aparecia.
@flawyerlawyertv7454
@flawyerlawyertv7454 Год назад
@@jvfg170 Oiii :D
@AjitKumar-yp2on
@AjitKumar-yp2on Год назад
Religion shouldn’t get involved in politics. When they do we have extreme views.
@costafilh0
@costafilh0 Год назад
We are not divided. We are all on the same page in the fact that Brazil didn't want neither Lula nor Bolsonaro. But the PROPAGANDA to chose one or the other was to strong for people to actually see the truth!
@leonardobd6472
@leonardobd6472 Год назад
I wanted Lula
@daniellemoscury7367
@daniellemoscury7367 Год назад
@@leonardobd6472 me too!
@Ludovyko
@Ludovyko Год назад
I wanted Lula
@costafilh0
@costafilh0 Год назад
Ok. Isso é uma democracia, cada um é livre pra escolher. Agora, vcs 3 que disseram que queriam Lula: realmente acreditam que 51% da população realmente queria Lula? realmente acreditam que 49% da população realmente queria Bolsonaro? vão me dizer que a maioria das pessoas que vcs conhecem não estava escolhendo um só pra tirar ou não entrar o outro?
@lucasporto7178
@lucasporto7178 Год назад
@@costafilh0 O país vai de mal a pior com tanta gente votando nesses dois ladrões. Entretanto, eles foram os candidatos mais populares de um Brasil que gosta de polarização, violência e baixaria! Faz parte
@gregg3877
@gregg3877 Год назад
Yes, make Brasil another Venezuela . Lula only knows how to distrubute someone else's whealth not how to create one.
@pedropires6138
@pedropires6138 Год назад
ÃO ÃO ÃO BOLSONARO NA PRISÃO
@arbaz79
@arbaz79 Год назад
As always a great documentary by DW 👍.
@rejaneflorinda6162
@rejaneflorinda6162 Год назад
Nossa, que mulheres corajosas. Eu não teria tanta, pois já vi gente ser atacada aqui em Brasília. As pessoas tinham medo de colocar os adesivo no carro porque poderiam ser vítimas de vandalismo. Viva a democracia, onde cada um escolhe o sticker que quiser.
@toolbox0001
@toolbox0001 Год назад
Viva Jair da Mito!
@marechaltukhachevsky2909
@marechaltukhachevsky2909 Год назад
@@toolbox0001 Jair Já Era!
@Qubitware
@Qubitware Год назад
Ceilula
@mdu__Africa
@mdu__Africa Год назад
Quality videos as always.
@silverflame2501
@silverflame2501 Год назад
Just like philipines ....... and america People are absolutely divided🙄🙄🙄
@CerriGabriel
@CerriGabriel Год назад
i wonder how people in germany feel when they hear the logo "brasil acima de tudo"(obvius reference to "Deutschland über alles"), I just hope for this thrash to be forgotten
@ANTONIOCARLOS-jr2sv
@ANTONIOCARLOS-jr2sv Год назад
THE REAL TRASH IS LULA, THE PT AND THOSE WHO VOTE FOR PT!
@frajola_br
@frajola_br Год назад
Cadê os brasileiros? Where are the rest of brasilians? 🇧🇷🇧🇷
@patrickgomes634
@patrickgomes634 Год назад
Aqui
@Elias-lp1kh
@Elias-lp1kh Год назад
Estamos aqui , logo mais estaremos sem internet também , VIVA VENEZUELAAAAAA
@lofi4353
@lofi4353 Год назад
@@Elias-lp1kh lula foi presidente por 8 anos , peguei os 2 mandatos do Lula. Nunca virou Venezuela , muito pelo contrário, Brasil foi a 6 economia do mundo.
@israelcabral860
@israelcabral860 Год назад
@@Elias-lp1kh vai pra lá não vai fazer falta a nação
@frajola_br
@frajola_br Год назад
@@patrickgomes634 aí sim 😎😎😎
@PapaTanGh0stNI9htM4R3S0nMaInSt
Hopefully level heads will prevail through peace all the current madness and rhetoric surrounding divisive elections is getting crazy.
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
Bigotry is dying, so things will get better. This is the bigots reacting to that as would a cornered wildcat, desperate for a way out, not realizing the veterinarians are just trying to cure it's wounds.
@sandrabraga6027
@sandrabraga6027 Год назад
True Democracy comes with honesty and transparency and truth When you switch the real Democracy just to get in power the results will come. And there is no one to blame other them those people that think Democracy comes together with impunity and lies.
@construindoestufas9446
@construindoestufas9446 Год назад
Para fixar um clipe, toque nele e mantenha-o pressionado. Os clipes desafixados serão excluídos após uma hora.
@SebastiaoJoseph
@SebastiaoJoseph Год назад
Brazilian politics in a nutshell: we treat politics like we treat soccer, with unconditional love and support.
@seventh4you
@seventh4you Год назад
Lula is robbed R$ 4.000,000,000,000
@niro6492
@niro6492 Год назад
Why this leftist win?
@flaviatgoncalves
@flaviatgoncalves Год назад
Yes, people love idols and they forget that they shake hands behind the curtains.
@tiagomichel
@tiagomichel Год назад
​@@niro6492 Brazilians are historically ignorants
@joey3291
@joey3291 Год назад
but they look like exactly knowing why they vote
@Ярослав-э8ш3о
@Ярослав-э8ш3о Год назад
Lefties vs Righties and propaganda of diversity 🤣
@moviladaniel6010
@moviladaniel6010 Год назад
It's a poor documentary in my point of view. It's a bad idea to choose two extremes and render them as representatives for each president. I'm from Europe, I don't know much of the two presidents, but this documentary concluded for me with LULA=LGBT and BOLSONARO= pro-guns and that's all, which I know it's more than that.
@drunkensailor112
@drunkensailor112 Год назад
They choose two extremes because they want to show how polarized it is.
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
Generalizing has it's place as a way to explain things on a basic level. But allow me to generalize further, thus bringing us closer to understanding a little more complexity (instead of simply complaining there isn't enough).. LBGTQ = people who want equality. Guns are used to force other people to capitulate to their demands. The former is seeking freedom, the latter us seeking oppression.
@rentopr
@rentopr Год назад
If you ask a Brazilian why they voted for one or the other, the answers are those and those only. Is it more than that? Brazilians themselves don't know! So the documentary in fact accurately portrays how shallow the motives for the polarization are.
@alphahermit1911
@alphahermit1911 Год назад
@@rentopr Incorrect, many of my bolsonarist friends voted for him over fear of economic collapse under the worker's party
@rentopr
@rentopr Год назад
@@alphahermit1911 Such fear is what drives most people to vote for right-wing candidates anywhere. I meant that most Brazilians were completely unaware of the candidates' policies.
@andreanox1
@andreanox1 Год назад
Lula rejection is going strong in Brasil. In 5 month’s the only thing Lula has done is spend the taxpayer money in lavish trips.
@mohammedsaysrashid3587
@mohammedsaysrashid3587 Год назад
Good morning .Good luck ( DW) documentary channel...for its neutrality, reality showing disclosures through showing its documentary doings... such as this documentary....I think Brazilian 🇧🇷 citizens are realizing the truth on the Brazilian cities...
@grahamhiggins1
@grahamhiggins1 Год назад
Extremists/activists on the left and right are tiresome. Moderates are needed all over the world.
@rubemlb
@rubemlb Год назад
Left channel video from a typically left-wing channel. showing one side of the story
@rchiribogar
@rchiribogar Год назад
No room for compromise. The same as here and everywhere. Bad days are coming.
@jalicea1650
@jalicea1650 Год назад
How do you compromise with fascists? Conservatives around the world want a society that favors the rich and bigoted deference to certain groups of people. The Left wants democracy and equality. Can't have both. Who would you favor?
@MrGlielber
@MrGlielber Год назад
This documentary plays boring song when it comes to brazilian flag and Bolsonaro. Already know the end. Won't waste my time. Classic left tactics. Not true people
@jds614
@jds614 5 месяцев назад
Snowflake
@demetriomoura170
@demetriomoura170 Год назад
Quality videos as always. Many thanks!
@paolosantiago3163
@paolosantiago3163 Год назад
I feel so sad for Brazil 🇧🇷🇧🇷 it has so much a lot of potential I hope the biggest South American nation will become better someday.
@adilsonsf
@adilsonsf Год назад
I feel very, very happy. Deomocracy is back. Thanks to God.
@guyhosse3308
@guyhosse3308 Год назад
Once Lula's out, maybe.
@rejaneflorinda6162
@rejaneflorinda6162 Год назад
we are already better, babe. Brasil is better for getting free of that fascist. I hope he never comes back. I don't care if he doesn't pay for his crimes. I just want him gone forever
@tiagomichel
@tiagomichel Год назад
​​@@rejaneflorinda6162 Você nem sabe o que fascista meu caro, só sai repetindo o que ouve sem pensar
@madinkan
@madinkan Год назад
Being totally objective here, both Lula and Bolsonaro were president of Brazil, but Lula had better numbers.
@theeraphatsunthornwit6266
@theeraphatsunthornwit6266 Год назад
Two party with equal number of vote is not a good thing
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
Bolsonaro doesn't have an actual political party thought. He wasn't even able to hijack a big right-wing party as Trump did.
@RicardoVanHouten
@RicardoVanHouten Год назад
Thank you for this documentary !♥ i have Brazilian friends and they told me alot but you guys also given me more knowledge about Brazilian politics My opinion i don't like Jair Bolsonaro because of his attitude and how he is lacking capacity about the climate crisis and is just cutting the whole amazon.........
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Thanks for watching. We're glad you found the documentary helpful. Be sure to check out our channel for more content!
@JVieiraJr
@JVieiraJr Год назад
So you really know nothing about the old history about cutting the "whole Amazon" lol. You're just repeating the main Stream Media. Take time to read a lot in Portuguese (u can use google to translate it all) and then you will find out that during the Lula and PT gov we had the worse cuting of the Amazon forest ever. But as Lula's gov was able to silent ONGs with money, nobody know it outside the Amazon region. Just go there and ask to local people how do those "ONGs" work andcheck the whole mafia behind it. Some are just exporting plants to labs in their own countries which later they come with new "medicines" to sell in Brazil. They don't give a fuck to the ilegal cutting, jus tare there to make money as the others.
@ItIsTheLordWhoKeepsme
@ItIsTheLordWhoKeepsme Год назад
I read Lula is doing worse for the Amazon than Bolsonaro
@brunomatias1216
@brunomatias1216 Год назад
​@@DWDocumentary acho que a forma que retratou a esquerda está errado tinham que mostrar os crimes que o lula cometeu e como grande parte dos eleitores dele são ignorantes, radicais, depredam patrimônio publico, defendem bandidos, manipulam as pessoas, invadem terras, são contra religião, contra a familia, a favor do aborto ou seja tudo que a de errado no Brasil vem da esquerda.
@azterraviva6679
@azterraviva6679 Год назад
Politicians and the media dividing the people no wonder great recipe
@haydar378
@haydar378 Год назад
Trump vs Biden part two episode
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
Autocracy versus Democracy.*
@jalicea1650
@jalicea1650 Год назад
@@joshuatree2944 Trump? Bolsonaro lies a lot, but Trump takes it to new levels.
@niro6492
@niro6492 Год назад
​@@aylbdrmadison1051 Trump 2023!!
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
​@@joshuatree2944 Trump is a pathological liar and narcissist. Bolsonaro is a sociopathic.
@analucche
@analucche Год назад
The documentary seems really cool, but it is difficult to watch as there are two voices speaking at the sime time. It is unaccessible...
@lucasporto7178
@lucasporto7178 Год назад
Not only Brazil, all Latin America are in the same way! Hope for the best
@NaturallyTheCat
@NaturallyTheCat Год назад
I hated the idea that the video passed that we only vote on lula for liberal ideology, yes, a lot of woman and minorities voted on lula bcs of it, but truth be told, even with his scandals he was a better leader. Brazil surpassed the UK in economy during his rule, created the bric with russia india and china and became a gigantic spotlight internationally, even now after a month and a half of lula the mercosul-eu agreement that was all but halted bcs of bolsonaro finally is getting settled. So I didn’t voted in lula only for minorities rights like this video says, i voted on him bcs i rather live in a world where our currency was 2,50 dollars then the 6 that was during bolsonaro rule
@danielwells774
@danielwells774 Год назад
Having a strong currency shouldn't be a priority since you are still a pretty poor country and rely heavily on exports for GDP growth.
@hetoverseo3887
@hetoverseo3887 Год назад
@@danielwells774 this!
@hetoverseo3887
@hetoverseo3887 Год назад
After 7 months are you still happy with your decision? Even with the radical changes that happened recently?
@MrStv1163
@MrStv1163 4 месяца назад
As a US-based viewer, it's surreal watching this. This whole thing is so similar to the US election dynamics, it's uncanny.
@carolaynepereira.8571
@carolaynepereira.8571 Год назад
I did not vote for this man! Lula is the most honest man in the world and if you say no, you will be arrested. The minority that voted for LULA has the same character as him. LULA HONEST MAN!🤗😂😇
@joaopedrojp2225
@joaopedrojp2225 Год назад
Essa gente bolsonarista, como já vimos, tem a ficha suja
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Thanks for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers on this channel to engage with topics in English so that both DW and the community have the chance to respond. For further information, please refer to DW's netiquette policy: p.dw.com/p/MF1G Thanks for watching!
@joaopedrojp2225
@joaopedrojp2225 Год назад
@@DWDocumentary I basically said that Bolsonaro's supporters are mostly hypocrites. They allege to be moral people but their background is no moral at all
@brendalindamedinalages9204
@brendalindamedinalages9204 Год назад
Deus salve o Brasil!!!
@flawyerlawyertv7454
@flawyerlawyertv7454 Год назад
Deus salve o Brasil de pessoas intolerantes e violentas.
@aabbleo
@aabbleo Год назад
Pelo sangue de Jesus vertido na cruz do calvário LULA PRESIDENTE
@danielwells774
@danielwells774 Год назад
Pessoas de Brasil salve o Brasil!!!
@1533TodaVida
@1533TodaVida Год назад
@@aabbleo Dios está contra el Socialismo y el Comunismo, no aceptamos a los homosexualismo, amen.✝️
@Edgar2023ES
@Edgar2023ES Год назад
We Brazilians need to learn and accept reality like it's. We need to be more rational. A lot of us want to believe something or image something and we believe our wishes and imagination are the reality. Lula and Bolsonaro are thieves. Bolsonaro's family bought 100 houses using cash, but some of us lost our rationality to believe Bolsonaro is an innocent man. Some things happen with Lula's followers. While we protect and love politicians, Brazil won't reach its development.
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
So how is Lula a thief? All you said about him is _"Some things happen with Lula's followers."_ That's at best incredibly vague and an empty accusation. In particular because even you claim it was his followers, not him. Do you judge the brother of a murderer the same, simply because they are related? And would not doing that because they are friends be even worse. Or how about followers, most of witch he'd never even met? Sorry, but Lula is a far better choice than any authoritarian. Only a fool votes for authoritarians, thus literally giving away every single freedom they have. Lula is egalitarian, and that fits perfectly with democracy and freedom, whereas bolsonaro is authoritarian, that only fits with ultimate rule; dictatorship, where the dictator has total rule, so there is no freedom for anyone else.1
@ExmuslimNowAgnostic
@ExmuslimNowAgnostic Год назад
​@@aylbdrmadison1051 As someone(Indian) who is a keen observer of the world events I approve your statement.
@wuyl660
@wuyl660 Год назад
@@aylbdrmadison1051 Bolsonaro the best president Brazil ever had! sorry but only bandits support lula,lula is an ex convict he came straight from prison and took over, criminals were celebrating lula's return,it hasn't been even two months since his "victory" and he is releasing criminals tthat have been convicted and sentenced like Sergio Cabral and Suzane Von Richthofen
@Edgar2023ES
@Edgar2023ES Год назад
@@ExmuslimNowAgnostic "Mensalão" has been proven. It really existed. PT bought votes from other politicians. Accoding Lula, Everyone betrayed him, includding his ex wife. She died while the PT's corruption was being descovering. If he's a innocent man, he was the dumbest of all Brazilians politicians and didn't deserved to be president. Lula still responds to several lawsuits in court. In my opnion, Bolsonaro was the worst president of Brazil after 1988 because he want to destroy education, public health, enviornment, etc. So, had to vote for Lula, but both couldn't be Brazilian President.
@r.casagrande8689
@r.casagrande8689 Год назад
Edgar, as a Brazilian myself, I fully agree with your comment.
@MikeLiteraus
@MikeLiteraus Год назад
Check out Glenn Greenwald if you want the real story.
@herogebrial
@herogebrial Год назад
These politicians are laughing at these plebs. Playing eachother thinking that both parties are different 🤔 😕 🤣
@mareksicinski3726
@mareksicinski3726 Год назад
They aree, that’s not the problem
@jalicea1650
@jalicea1650 Год назад
The politicians are separate, you can't assume they're the same. Bolsonaro is different than Lula.
@spaghtti
@spaghtti Год назад
So, who are you cheering for?
@herogebrial
@herogebrial Год назад
@@jalicea1650 different sides of the same coin
@herogebrial
@herogebrial Год назад
@@spaghtti none of these corrupt politicians
@teacherdejanir-dejaweb8525
@teacherdejanir-dejaweb8525 Год назад
This documentary does not show the truth in Brazil. It's a shame!
@sujac664
@sujac664 Год назад
OMG, 18:08 is the absolute BEST endorsement for Lula over Bolsonaro, thank you mr trump 🫡 your recommendations are often the best indication of what NOT to do/think/buy/believe/vote for/expect...etc... likewise the people you try to discredit are often the people in whom we should trust. Horrible human! Wishing you all the best and stay strong Brazil 🥰 PS; was anyone surprised when a vote recount was called for from bolsonaro's enablers? Great documentary thanks DW
@enzobuso5933
@enzobuso5933 Год назад
Youre not brazillian lol
@sujac664
@sujac664 Год назад
@@enzobuso5933 No, I'm human and have an opinion, I don't see your point. An open connected world where you have to be a certain nationality to have a certain opinion on humanity & society...🤔 that would be a very narrow world indeed my friend. Cheers. 👊🏼 Replying to; Enzo Buso 5 hours ago Youre not brazillian lol
@hetoverseo3887
@hetoverseo3887 Год назад
@@sujac664 things are a different story inside our country. They aren't talking about why half of the population are mad with him. The news that are being divulged across the globe are majority one sided. Both are wrong. Period. There's no good guy. The only way to fix this place is to end populism and fanatism. Recently lots of bad things and radical changes happened, an entire territory is being neglected, Amazon still burns. No one talking about it internationally. Only a few national RU-vid channels are showing it. They want to regulate RU-vid channels and social media to not show what is happening.
@cathyellingsworth8300
@cathyellingsworth8300 Год назад
"People are gonna rise up and take what's theirs...." Tracy Chapman.
@martinsnow6641
@martinsnow6641 Год назад
It would be better if you didn't dub the videos. Use subtitles so people have a chance to learn new languages all over the world. You're doing not only the german people, but also everyone else a disservice by dubbing. Learn from the Scandinavian countries.
@masalagirl1
@masalagirl1 Год назад
I agree.
@Sweaper
@Sweaper Год назад
Let's continue with the media stereotype and generalize everything. DW please
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
By calling it a stereotype, you are admitting that is the standard position, and that surrounding those positions are variations expanding out every direction towards extremist ideals. This is about autocracy versus democracy, oppression versus freedom.
@Sweaper
@Sweaper Год назад
@@aylbdrmadison1051 Yeah, best way to polarize a country is to repeatedly feed them polarizing ideals and then generalizing a group of people and making others seem like the "enemy". Again, let's continue with the media stereotype and generalize everything, it will certainly be good for humanity and help them understand each other's differences
@collinsopabeng8411
@collinsopabeng8411 Год назад
Did DW uploaded this video for the second time?
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Hi @collinsopabeng8411, as mentioned in the video description, due to technical issues the documentary had to be revoiced and reuploaded. We apologize for any inconvenience caused. Thanks for watching!
@penhavasconcellos6883
@penhavasconcellos6883 Год назад
Bolsonaro,the best President ever...
@marechaltukhachevsky2909
@marechaltukhachevsky2909 Год назад
Melhor presidente sendo o único a perder a reeleição? Isso mesmo sendo o que mais cometeu crimes eleitorais... patético
@Kevin-fq3zh
@Kevin-fq3zh Год назад
car crash in slow motion
@MathLiberty
@MathLiberty Год назад
I just hope that one day we can have a government which will strive for real progress instead of money, corruption or religious ideals. People who believe we can achieve that with Bolsonaro or Lula are very naive.
@MrJeanNunes
@MrJeanNunes Год назад
Great piece of reporting, DW.
@thiagoborges8804
@thiagoborges8804 Год назад
We have not fredom anymore .
@igot40movies
@igot40movies Год назад
Yes you do, stop being so dramatic
@thiagoborges8804
@thiagoborges8804 Год назад
@@igot40movies 😘
@roflzmycopter
@roflzmycopter Год назад
Didn't the Lula guy go to jail for corruption? Lmao
@odecilnetis4709
@odecilnetis4709 Год назад
Yes, innocently. No wonder he got out of jail.
@sdafasdfasdfsda
@sdafasdfasdfsda Год назад
He was innocent, just like Joe and Hunter Biden in the USA. Only on the right can accusations of corruption be true, otherwise my feels get hurt.
@herogebrial
@herogebrial Год назад
Yes, it's actually hilarious how high and mighty he is acting
@pedroarthurbarbosa
@pedroarthurbarbosa Год назад
@@odecilnetis4709 He got out of jail because the corrupt Supreme Court bailed him out! He is not innocent, his arrest was revoked on the margins of the law!
@Luh-su2eu
@Luh-su2eu Год назад
@@odecilnetis4709 Charges dropped, he's innocent
@robisonaraujo.1760
@robisonaraujo.1760 Год назад
The thief is back at the crime scene
@m5vibe
@m5vibe Год назад
This left and right is similar to America
@albertchehade9916
@albertchehade9916 Год назад
the world is turning trumpanese.....
@IndexFossilchannel
@IndexFossilchannel Год назад
Ideological politicians are never subject to the consequences of their own ideology. This is the problem here in Brazil and in many countries around the world. 💰
@bgcvetan
@bgcvetan 7 месяцев назад
Crime spiked as the tankie returned.
@MVUK358
@MVUK358 Год назад
Interesting documentary, but clearly biased in their selection of participants. The Lula supporters chosen are easy-going dancers and feminists; the Bolsonaro supporters chosen for this are all very religious and like to own guns. I am sure that in reality there is much more variety in the people who support each politician! (Some people in rural areas can own guns & be very religious but also support Lula.)
@aylbdrmadison1051
@aylbdrmadison1051 Год назад
It's a good representation of the median, not the extreme. Of course there are grey areas, only a fool doesn't know that and DW is correct to not assume it's viewers are fools who do not understand such basics.
@paulomelettilestrade
@paulomelettilestrade Год назад
Would be nice if there were subtitles instead of voiceovers.
@zacheryhershberger7508
@zacheryhershberger7508 Год назад
Subs are better than dubs 😵
@mgithaiga1
@mgithaiga1 Год назад
I've already seen this!
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Hi @mgithaiga1, due to technical issues, the documentary had to be revoiced. We apologize for any inconvenience caused. Thanks for watching!
@mgithaiga1
@mgithaiga1 Год назад
@@DWDocumentary ok I understand
@spaghtti
@spaghtti Год назад
@@DWDocumentary if you dont mind me asking, why did it have to be revoiced/ which technical issues would require a voice over?
@bestillbaby
@bestillbaby Год назад
Together we are stronger!!!! The most High always comes through for his people🌈🗣️
@DanDanJanJanJP
@DanDanJanJanJP Год назад
Who translated the national anthem? I hope it was not a Brazilian, because it would mean the person doesn't know anthem's meaning.
@oliverwabwire2836
@oliverwabwire2836 Год назад
Extreme right and extreme left make for uncompromising fundamentalist. Any country under the grapple of this political scenario MUST find a way of spawning a centrist movement, even if it has to be legislated...a party that accommodates elements from both sides.
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
Lula is the most centrist of all left-wing Brazilian politicians. He's often heavily criticized by far-left and not-so-far-left people for not being progressive enough (both in discourse and action). Kind of like Biden is critized by many Democrats
@netoviana7636
@netoviana7636 Год назад
Eu votei no nosso querido Presidente Lula ❤ meu Brasil respira aliviado por ter democracia!!! Viva o Brasil viva Lulaaaa❤
@carlospecanha1826
@carlospecanha1826 8 месяцев назад
Você deveria ter vergonha de tar comentando isso.
@kalui96
@kalui96 Год назад
Bold of you Brazilians to think Lula is going to change anything. Decades of these ups and downs and yet your country is still the way it is. You must look beyond politics (lol BR is fubar nvm)
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
Our democratic constitution has only 35 years, too young for definitive judgments. And beyond politics there's only barbarism.
@Funkywallot
@Funkywallot Год назад
Good luck Brazil. Seems that the rage of the far left finally is a force to reckon with. How are you going to go about ? Something is seriously wrong if both partys act as if their life depends on the right outcome.
@ninalumiere145
@ninalumiere145 Год назад
In fact it did depend on the outcome. Bolsonoro meant ☠️☠️☠️, he is evil and native people's mxrderer
@joaofranca3041
@joaofranca3041 Год назад
There is no extreme left in Brazil. The lives of some do depend on it, which is why this election was so disputed and so surrounded by fear. The Bolsonaro government was directly responsible for the genocide of indigenous peoples, racism, homophobia and transphobia gained space that they had been losing in previous years, during the pandemic government negligence was directly responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands, during the election period Lula voters were executed and persecuted, lost their jobs, were threatened. It's not a fight of equals.
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
For many people, specifically marginalized people, their life's *do* depend on the electoral outcome.
@hetoverseo3887
@hetoverseo3887 Год назад
@@joaofranca3041 there is now. I'm studying to go to another country and leave this populist mess. I disagree with both candidates btw.
@Vagolyk
@Vagolyk Год назад
As usual the new regime will not bring a utiopia for all. Sometime later it will lose popularity and the opposition will be elected in hopes that will improve economy. It will not. Instead of working on a compromise the parties and their aupporters will grind endlessly against each other until some name changes or until nobody goes to vote anymore. It is almost as the global economy is formed around global interest but governments fail to globalize.
@brendansmith7842
@brendansmith7842 Год назад
So much of this discord could just be copied with the USA. Quite interesting...
@leogama3422
@leogama3422 Год назад
Guess who were two of the top Bolsonaro's consultants? Donald Trump and Steve Bannon. It wasn't copied, it was translated from the original.
@mkupoi
@mkupoi Год назад
Para cuando el fin de la humanidad? No merecemos el planeta que habitamos
@aabbleo
@aabbleo Год назад
Pelo sangue de Jesus vertido na cruz do calvário LULA PRESIDENTE
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Thanks for taking the time to comment. We kindly ask our viewers on this channel to engage with topics in English so that both DW and the community have the chance to respond. For further information, please refer to DW's netiquette policy: p.dw.com/p/MF1G Thanks for watching!
@felipe96150
@felipe96150 Год назад
Flours from the same rotten sack.
@TheSaviobarros
@TheSaviobarros Год назад
With lula in the office, Brazilians is gonna preparing to eat their own pets. Venezuela, there we go
@jenniferjohnson5683
@jenniferjohnson5683 Год назад
You are absolutely right!
@MrVitorao
@MrVitorao Год назад
i go preparing english lesson para você
@TheSaviobarros
@TheSaviobarros Год назад
@@MrVitorao vc pode fazer shaming, mas não pode mudar a realidade ;-). Viver em realidade paralela é sintoma de esquizofrenia ;-)... is, are... o resultado é o mesmo: vc faz o L e f*d3 todo Brasil.
@TheSaviobarros
@TheSaviobarros Год назад
@@MrVitorao BTW, é English, e não english. Petista, antes de corrigir os outros vá se olhar no espelho.
@MrVitorao
@MrVitorao Год назад
@@TheSaviobarros hmm pelo jeito eu need lessons de English
@marcelowever2325
@marcelowever2325 Год назад
look the diference betweem both sides, bolsonaro gave us pride to be brazilians, compare the numbers for all in brazil, bolsonaro president again and aagain
@joaobuzato8376
@joaobuzato8376 Год назад
Where is my comment....? I posted 2 days ago....
@DWDocumentary
@DWDocumentary Год назад
Hi @joaobuzato8376, as mentioned in the video description, the documentary had to be reuploaded. We apologize for the inconvenience.
@joaobuzato8376
@joaobuzato8376 Год назад
I am gay and voted for Bolsonaro. The result of this election is not fully explained. For start the polling stations were eletronic ones and could have been hacked. Bolsonaro supporters asked votes to be verified and the supreme court denied. That is thing to be questioned.... considering that Lula had been condemned by dozens of accusations and then the same supreme court canceled them all and did worse, allow him to run for presidency. A small majority of Brazilian people have been decieved with free money for poor famíly, single mons, and inclusion of LGBT community. Education in this country is really bad...get worsed since PT got power ...As Lula has twice been president and got elected his sucessor. However corruption was exposed and Lula sent to prison. But with that level of education & populist speech gave him victory... I just dont buy It...."this election was a fraudulent one.
@MarceloKfouhry
@MarceloKfouhry Год назад
I am Brazilian and i can assure to you : this video contain a lot of misleading information
@marcellomoraes680
@marcellomoraes680 Год назад
Corruption, criminal organization and drug trafficking are BACK !!!
@undertakerkl
@undertakerkl 10 месяцев назад
Crazy how much people showed😢 lula should have stayed in prison. It’s where he belongs. #lulaprisão.
@abshir2010
@abshir2010 8 месяцев назад
LULA DA SILVA what a name what a personality a man, a man whose name is marked with Brazilian unity equality prosperity and economical development. LULA DA SILVA what a name.
@carlospecanha1826
@carlospecanha1826 8 месяцев назад
you can only see this in the parallel world, this is not what we see here in Brazil, or you really have bad character, you support dictatorships in Cuba and Iran and that is why you support Lula.
@diegopereira7281
@diegopereira7281 Год назад
❤️ Democracy ❤️ ❤️ Democracy ❤️ ❤️ Democracy ❤️
@gustavoemannueldeangolasil243
Kkk don't know what wrote is Very funny.
@niro6492
@niro6492 Год назад
Democracy is bad
@gustavoemannueldeangolasil243
Choise of lula for president forget all corruption of economic history from Brazil , because the EU don't like Bolsonaro. Lula live betray of allie,my country fall with choise.
@cydinhacorinthiana
@cydinhacorinthiana Год назад
Jovem Pan is against Brazil?
@mariliagiannini4554
@mariliagiannini4554 Год назад
People voted in Lula against Bolsonaro; and voted in Bolsonaro against Lula. Both are flour from the same old bag, not good for Brazil.
@chrisballard7594
@chrisballard7594 Год назад
I hope that man wins, because the other one is a fool. Oh sorry, I meant to say it the other way round.
@spaghtti
@spaghtti Год назад
You tried to sound smart, but you just sound like a person that didnt even pass primary school. Now, if you were to be so kind to me, would you please rewrite that sentence, preferably with the names of who you meant,please?
@ConradSzymczak
@ConradSzymczak Год назад
Kommie
@JohnBosco.1308
@JohnBosco.1308 Год назад
We will not know that blacks are as many as lighter Brazilians watching this docuseries. As an Afro-Brazilian, I see this all the time, and also in Germany, the story is the same.
@briopalumpus8676
@briopalumpus8676 Год назад
Brazil and Germany the same??
@Anonymous-py1sf
@Anonymous-py1sf 9 месяцев назад
Well, do not compare. There are much more bl@ck and mixed people in Brazil than in Germany. But yes, brazilians try all the time to look "whiter" as a country. They start shaking if you remember them of africans there 🤣🤣
@tonywalton1052
@tonywalton1052 Год назад
an aging socialist
@GreenBananaz
@GreenBananaz Год назад
Hi everyone 🫶🏻
@AuthenticJunior
@AuthenticJunior Год назад
there are little things in this video that only a deep analysis reveals, the guy who owns the shooting club has a comfortable life, he has 4 stores and is planning to have 20 more. A shooting club in Brazil is not accessible to everyone, just to be able to attend such places costs around 20 minimum wages, those who frequent these places have money. The guy with his wife and daughter with the national anthem on the Imac isn't poor either, Apple in Brazil it's very, VERY expensive, the image in the church he attends also shows only white people. Things like these and several others in the video show who wants the Bolsonaro government, it is obvious that for them the previous government was better because they were getting richer and richer, however, if compared to the left we see women, especially of color, simple people of favelas and more vulnerable areas, these people sometimes became the subject of news on TV because they were collecting butcher scraps to feed the family or how they were abandoned by the government, the majority, fortunately, won and the president of the poor, as he calls himself , won.
@axeblue
@axeblue Год назад
Expect tons, of tons, of Quantitative Easing, Inflation and Wealth Disparity happen under Lula. Democracy today looks like Social Monarchy that gives to the Rich(land owners) and minorities(clerics).
@Xtragicfever
@Xtragicfever Год назад
So, single women that are post wall with cats are Lulua's constituency?
@epeeypen
@epeeypen Год назад
yep and notice the dace studio woman.. she has Che Guevara on her door but he exterminated homosexuals.... they are hypocrites
Далее
Brazil: a nation divided | FT Film
24:54
Просмотров 145 тыс.
БЕЛКА РОДИЛА КОТЯТ#cat
00:20
Просмотров 1 млн
Please Help This Poor Boy 🙏
00:40
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Kim Jong Un: The Man Who Rules North Korea
57:34
Просмотров 10 млн
Who owns water? | DW Documentary
42:32
Просмотров 1,9 млн
BlackRock: The Conspiracies You Don’t Know
15:13
Просмотров 1,3 млн
Mohammad bin Salman: Prince With Two Faces
54:00
Просмотров 6 млн
PBS News Hour full episode, Sept. 24, 2024
56:46
Просмотров 11 тыс.
How German Immigration shaped Brazil's History
53:50
Просмотров 223 тыс.