Am I the only one who likes the whole thing as it is? It's a cover... well played and singed. The singer has its own voice, it's not a "tribute band which tries its best to play as close as the original"... I see a good job there, all in all.
gents, take it easy on the vocalist, this is how the group interpret this floyd song. if you want the 'sound original' go look for the pink floyd original. this is some band who wants to play the wall, their way. lets just enjoy and relax. ;)
if the interptretation sucks or clashes entirely with the rest of the music it's a valid complaint. they "interpreted" the instrumentals identically to the original but have a singer who sings like he has a mouthfull of marbels in an entirely different style in a different key. That's called butchering not interpreting, but at least these guys could stay mostly on tempo.
As youtube usually compresses video footage the audio in this is fantastic keys perfectly just sitting in the background mix minus kids singing in the chorus musically what a fantastic cover this song is great interpretation guys I love it I mix FOH Occasionally would love to get involved doing more stuff in the studio.
If you try to “cover” a song word for word, way for way, etc thats is Copy Covering. These guys showed true TALENT because they were able to interpret this band’s sound and applied it to their own sound. Anyone saying “no where close to Pink Floyd w the vocals” duh who tf else sounds like David Gilmour. No one. This is what makes this group unique. Open up your eyes & ears people!
This is an amazing version, re imagining of the already awesome song.....The Bass, The lead, The vocals.....I personally enjoy great covers of the most amazing songs ever created. This is a beautiful cover of an amazing song. Great job to these guys !
Okay look, I'm being for real here, this is the best cover of ANY song I've heard before, I usually find covers to be pretty much "unenjoyable", but THIS time, it's actually good for once. If you guys ever see this comment, I just wanna say that you guys all play your instruments very very well, and your voice is absolutely golden man, don't give up and keep going 👍
Are serious ??? Gilmour Sound IS Stratocaster ! He uses other instruments, but his caracteristic sound is Stratocaster. And on The Wall it is a typic Strato Mapple Neck sound : ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WK5WLq4pBFg.html
I think they did a fantastic job of recreating this song. I'm in a cover band and trust me, it's not that easy to perfectly recreate someone else's music. Not only would you have to play it note for note, but you would have to learn each musician's style of playing/performing.
La voz del vocalista es una de las mejores voces que he escuchado en mucho (MUCHO) tiempo. Sublime. PD: Guardemos un minuto de silencio por el pobre guitarrista de guitarra rosa, al que la cámara no enfoca :'(
This the BEST Cover I have ever seen of this song!..I've seen "Brit Floyd".. I've seen Austrailian Pink Floyd".... These Cat;s.. Lysergic Dream.. I hope they book in Reno, Nevada as I will Pay.. Buy a ticket to see this act! Sincerely, David Lee 3:)
Great job guys. And for all you haters, the singer has the right key and range. Just needs to work on his pronunciation as English is obviously not his first language.
I was just listening until the guy started to sing and I said, what happened with his voice. Then I realized it is a cover. Man, same thing as the original one. Hats-off guys!
This is very nice. You made it your own, but stayed true to the original also. Normally these type of thing fall apart with the vocals. They sounded great. Job well done! :)
This is BRILLIANT! I love this interpretation, wow. Such a massive, iconic tune to take on, and you nailed it, with your own style, depth and development. Man, I'd love to use an excerpt from the soundtrack for a YT vid about restricting freedom. Would that be OK with you? I will link back to this video. You deserve the exposure because this is quite an achievement.
Качество Записи - Супер !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! СПАСИБО СУПЕРСПЕЦИАЛИСТУ за пультом - Чётко, как никогда прописаны Все Гитары, клавиши и гитары, вокал - Просто Супер !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The BEST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
По ходу van halen, зря ты так себя кличешь,со слухом у тебя полный ноль, надо быть полными дебилами выложить на показ такую хуйню -бездарь,да ещё и перед Deep Purple, уровень школьников. Я с большим напрягом прослушал это ГОВНО. Англичан комментарии почитать, такая же тупая и глухая публика, надеюсь Гилмор и Вотерс эту срань не видели и не слышали. Как сказал прф. Приоброженский "В печку её, в печку".
@@Morower18 Yeah, it can, but that wasn't it, this wasn't caught in post production, there are other errors as well, and since when did you become the "Post Nazi"... SMH
“- Growth has its season. There are spring and summer, but there are also fall and winter. And then spring and summer again. As long as the roots are not severed, all is well and all be well.” ― Jerzy Kosinski, Being There
Enough about it not being "Pink Floyd" enought. The whole point of a cover is that it offers a different take on what you've already heard. And in that, they did a good job. Kudos man.
I am definitely a Pink Floyd fan, and I like this cover. They are not Pink Floyd, and they don ´t try to be. It´s got everything it takes to be "another brick in the Wall", even the stunning guitar solo...
I agree with you. People thinks it must sound exactly as Pink Floyd. It is only a cover, so differences are allowed as there are not rules neither any compromise to be doppelganger.
