@@dangloc89 I can't really see them drying up though - that's the problem. Look at the frequency of Private Eye for instance - still lots of sales 25 years later - and a lot have been consumed unlike the Edition bottles. We're working on an analysis of the entire set at the moment 👍 Watch this space for more info 🙂
Came here from Vin's video too and added you on IG as a result as well. Very interesting what you do. I drink, collect and invest in bottles and I'm based across Manchester, London and Hong Kong. Can never get enough whisky education. Look forward to seeing more fascinating content from you. :)
2020 I bought 25 bottles of Macallan edition whisky costing £2830 if I sold all at auction taking lowest price per bottle I could get £4050 ,profit 43% a lot better than .05% interest in banks
Agree. Ed2 just reached £350 hammer price in a London auction, less than 2 week ago. “250k is too large release, ppl dun drink em; no scarcity”... Have u seen how much is the retail price of Ed2 at e resellers countertops in Beijing, Tokyo, Shanghai, San Francisco in last 12mths?
Forget about the investment. I bought and opened the bottle no.6 and it is one of the best NAS whisky that I have tried. Orange and chocolate with very typical macallan oak taste. Highly recommended to try!
This seems to be the consensus! I can't wait to get this bottle back and have a dram! Would you say it is worth £150 which is what it seems to be selling for now?
Fantastic vblog really demolishes some of the myths regardig whiskey collecting. If you have not reviewed it already I would love your analysis of Middeleton Very Rare range. Availiability of whiskey/whisky is quite limited here in Ireland and the pricies are out of this world we are the fourth highest priced country in the world for alcohol so enjoy the UK prices look forward to your vblogs great find courtesy of Vin
Hi - glad you liked it :) That's a great idea too - we will get cracking on that and see what the prices are like. I know the first editions are becoming ever harder to get hold of now.
Shame, I got one for 145$ us in late 2021 and am psyched about it. Tasted a friends large bar, this was the winner. Bought one and made it a celebration pour (celtics win the title)...
I’ve played safe by buying two bottles of each release (with the exception of edition 1) - one to drink and one to keep. If the ‘keep’ bottles don’t increase in price, I get to drink them ;-)
I'm not interested in such volatile pricing for Macallan whiskey, so, I don't particularly look for it. I do see that the pricing is higher than the competition which is why when the product is available it stays on the shelves a hell of a lot longer.
We have to encourage the other collector's to open their bottles in the near future. Maybe we will see another increase of hammer prices in a few years.
thank you for the honest review and advice! ED#1 went up triple in just one year on the auctions, so now everybody is " collecting" these new releases, but with most of it never open their "collectible" ,,, 15-20 yrs later,, there will still be 200k bottles of ed#6 in " collector" home, are we walking into anther tulip bubble?
Hi - yes - I think they are grossly overpriced, but not as much as the Folio bottles are. If you look at the reviews of Edition 6 (take a look at the recent Whisky Fun review as this was based on this exact bottle :) ) it is a good drinker :)
Hi Roy - glad you like the video! Sure - over 30 years I am sure the price will rise. I think it's one of them to buy and forget about for at least 5 years.
Give it some time for the price of edition 2 to 6 to catch up. I agree that a certain amount of bottles are locked away in collector's stash but as time passes, it will get harder and harder to find. In my area (Toronto), Edition no.6 was released in January 2021, and people are still looking for them months later. If it doesn't go up, an excuse to crack one open and drink it.
Agree. Based on this logic, then kindly explain why the higher 250k bottles release of Ed2, just fetched £350 10 days ago in a London auction? Pressed wrong bid button? Utter nonsense analysis
@@russelt8559 When Edition no.1 was released, alot of people ( not all), overlooked it so it didn't sell too well ( plus the number of bottles produced was far less than the other editions). I recall it was only available in Taiwan and US. Upon release, Edition 2 was more widely available globally but some are already consumed for sure thus incrementally increasing the value. All we need are bidders bidding up the price in auction. My cousin told me in China they're selling Edition no.6 for £226 a bottle retail..
@@Adrian802 I was one of the ppl who laughed at Macallan when Ed1 was released. I laughed until I tasted 2 bottles...Ed1 is e closest to the banned Sherry Wood (Virgin forest oak tree in Jerez, Spain)
@@russelt8559 better than me. I knew about edition 1 when edition 3 was just released. My nose isn't quite tuned for macallan so I bought it just for "fun".
Hi - I would say watch my channel for more videos along these lines. We are working on a lot of new content which should help you make a good decision.
Can't follow your reasoning at all. I've been dealing with whisky for over 10 years and think these bottles are a great investment. If you send me a set of the six for 2000 pounds, I'd make an easy 1000 pound profit on ebay in Germany ! I expect the bottles to increase from now on because that's it - no more. I think that people did drink a lot of the bottles already (90 pounds is not so much, and they were tasty). In any case, I expect the editions 2-6 to increase to between 500 and 800 pounds (edition 2 already is 400 pounds). This is just by looking at the (NAS) edition 1 already selling for 1300 pounds. Edition 6 should increase in value rapidly because several countries didn't receive any bottles at all (for example Cyprus). Maybe edition 1 has nearly reached it's peak (I personally wouldn't buy one any more) but the other editions were also well received - even though each edition had its haters and lovers. I consider my estimates as conservative. If I sell, I always prefer selling a cheap whisky expensively, rather than an expensive whisky at an even higher price. If you buy several bottles like these, then it's very easy to enjoy one or two for free after selling a bottle, so they end up actually being cheap - you just need to adjust.
Hi - thanks for your message. Sure - let's break it down then. Sets of 1-6 were sold in many U K auctions for £2,000 in January 2020. First of all, add the buyer's premium (10% - no VAT as you are in the EU). Cost of purchase is now £2,200. When you import the set into Germany you will have 19% VAT to pay - bringing your total to £2,618. Let's add a token £20 for shipping. TOTAL PURCHASE £2,638. Let's assume you sell the set for £3,000 on eBay. Your selling fee would be 10%, so you would net £2,700. However, Paypal fees are around 2.9%, so you would only really net £2612.70 into your bank. £25.30 net loss. I do not mean to be facetious, but it is important that with any investment you take into account the full costs and not just the hypothetical profit. Again, with Edition 2 there were over 20 sold at Whisky Auctioneer in January 2021, all less than £300. Some as low as £270. I do not disagree that some bottles of Edition 2 have sold for £400, but these are the exceptions to the rule. I hope that these bottles do prove to be a good investment for people - but the more you look at *all* of the numbers it just doesn't stack up to me.
@@MarkLittler I don't know why you are trying so hard to calculate yourself right any way possible. I stated selling for 2000 pounds. If I buy something for 2000 pounds that includes VAT, buyers premiums etc - just like when you buy bottles on the internet or supermarket. To be honest I don't care - I have bought 40 bottles of this series for an average cost of 100 Euros per bottle. In the end I will be laughing and you will be arguing that you were right.
